realizing selflessness

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5866
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby vinceschubert » Sun Aug 02, 2026 3:10 am

But I think I’ve done a lot of the deconstruction that I hope might be helpful for getting to a yes?
Agreed. It seems to be happening.
So, let's switch our focus to what might be hidden resistance to fully investing in a non-personal perspective.
Consider the ramifications of this.
If there is no self running the show, what of responsibility, choice, intention, agency, control, decision-making, effort, willpower, purpose, consent, commitment, accountability, praise and blame, guilt and regret, learning, change, morality and consequences?
What about your relationship to (apparent) other people?
Is that which was perceived as 'wrong' in the world still 'bad'?
Is anything still binary?

Consider each of these from an experiential perspective.

love

v
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 541
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Sun Aug 02, 2026 5:26 am

let's switch our focus to what might be hidden resistance to fully investing in a non-personal perspective.
Consider the ramifications of this.
If there is no self running the show, . . .
On my first read of your message, this all sounded a little scary and intimidating, so it seemed like you might be onto something with the “hidden resistance” idea. I also wondered if you needed a little vacation from doing this because it seemed like it might take me a couple weeks to reply.

But then I realized that if there’s no self running the show, there’s never been any self running the show, so nothing changes about how things work; it’s all just understood differently. E.g., it’s not like K suddenly stops “making decisions”; it’s just recognized that decision-making has always simply been a series of thoughts arising with no “decider” behind them.

And the only thing that’s scary about it is the idea of understanding some fundamental aspects of being human in a different way from almost everyone else . . . but actually I’m not sure why that’s scary. All I can think of is doubting one’s own sanity, which I don’t think I would, or maybe having to avoid talking with people about how this stuff actually works if you don’t want them to think you’re crazy or at least very weird. Well, and I suppose there’s fear of the unfamiliar— rearranging the ways you’ve thought about reality for your whole life.

I feel like there could be some other sort of fear lurking in there somewhere, but it’s bedtime, so I’ll ponder that tomorrow.

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 541
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Sun Aug 02, 2026 2:50 pm

P.S. I feel a little like I cheated in my previous reply by undermining the whole premise of the questions. Here's a response to one of them in particular:
let's switch our focus to what might be hidden resistance to fully investing in a non-personal perspective.
Consider the ramifications of this.
If there is no self running the show,
. . . . .
What about your relationship to (apparent) other people?
Realizing no-self doesn't mean that a "self" that used to be there suddenly vanishes, upending K's whole life. Realizing no-self means grokking that there never has been a "self." So life carries on just as it always has, with just shift in how it is seen and understood (and a resulting lightening of the load of suffering and lessening of the sense of separation from everyone and everything — or something like that).

The pattern known as "K" will still interact in basically the usual ways with the patterns conventionally identified as other people (but presumably, as habit patterns dissolve, in less and less "self"-centered ways).

One small concern here, as noted before, is that it would mostly be strange and unhelpful to talk to other people about what is probably the biggest shift of perspective K has ever had. It might be weird and uncomfortable to feel like I'm withholding something so important to me, but that would only apply to a small number of people. And there are several with whom I feel like I could at least broach this, including my spouse, one of my best friends (the one who's a Zennie), and the three staff members of the little ecumenical Christian retreat center that is our religious community and second family. The primary message recently of the founder of the retreat center has been, "Here. Now. This." !!!

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 541
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Mon Aug 03, 2026 1:44 pm

[Post #3 in this batch.]

P.P.S. Wrote a long musing, which I won't inflict on you, about whether there might still be some fear, or maybe mainly just unpleasant confusion, around the issue of what, in college, we framed as “free will vs. determinism,” and I couldn’t entirely access the freaked-out feeling I had back then. But this is the conclusion I was moving toward: I think there’s something freaky about the idea that consciousness is just along for the ride, that being alive is like watching a movie starring “me,” but “I” have no role in writing the script, directing the movie, or even deciding exactly how to play the role.

At the moment, I’m getting only mildly freaky feelings about that. Perhaps the prospect of reducing the suffering of being alive is so attractive that it overrides any inhibitions related to fully accepting that "I" am not the "chooser" of anything about this life, at least not in the way I've spent more than half a century thinking I am.

If there's any "hidden resistance," that's probably the main thing — and now it's not so hidden.

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5866
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby vinceschubert » Mon Aug 03, 2026 2:11 pm

I think there’s something freaky about the idea that consciousness is just along for the ride, that being alive is like watching a movie starring “me,” but “I” have no role in writing the script, directing the movie, or even deciding exactly how to play the role.
There is an important assumption hidden inside the movie metaphor:
There is a mechanical life unfolding, and consciousness is a separate, powerless spectator watching it.
That recreates the very split being questioned. It imagines the body and brain producing the movie while a helpless “I” sits in the audience.
Can that spectator be found?
There is seeing, thinking, deliberating, intending, choosing and acting. But is there also a separate consciousness standing outside those events?
Recognising that there is no I does not mean that consciousness is “just along for the ride.”
What can be seen is more modest:
• deliberation happens;
• alternatives appear;
• preferences and intentions arise;
• consequences are anticipated;
• choices occur;
• actions affect what happens next;
• no independent author can be found outside that process.
Thoughts and intentions are not causally irrelevant merely because no separate thinker authored them. Your intention to write can lead to fingers moving. Deliberation about “Hmm” versus “Um” can change what appears on the screen. Learning today can alter a response tomorrow. These processes matter because they are part of the unfolding, not because an unconditioned “I” owns them.
The old free-will-versus-determinism framing offers two frightening alternatives:
Either a sovereign self controls life, or a helpless witness watches a predetermined machine.
But both alternatives assume a separate self—first as controller, then as passenger.
A more accurate image might be live improvisation rather than a movie. There is no musician separate from the playing, no completed score determining every note and no audience trapped inside the instrument. Each note emerges from the instrument, training, previous notes, present conditions and countless influences—and each note helps condition what follows.
Life is responsive without being personally authored.
So I would also soften this:

Choosing happens, but no chooser separate from the choosing can be found.
That is not quite the same as saying K has no role. K—the whole living pattern—is where considering, choosing, acting, learning and responding happen.
What cannot be located is an essential K standing outside the pattern and directing it.
Of course this feels freaky. For more than half a century, the organism has interpreted agency as evidence of an inner author. The prospect of losing that author can be what gets in the road of freedom.

Look carefully at what would actually be lost.
Would deliberation stop?
Would intentions stop affecting behaviour?
Would learning stop?
Would K become unable to respond?
Or would only the imagined ownership of those processes be lost?

The fear appears to be:
If there is no separate chooser, I become a powerless spectator of my own life.
So this is the next question:
Can either the powerless spectator or the predetermined movie be found—or are both appearing now as thoughts about what no-self would mean?

v
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 541
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Mon Aug 03, 2026 4:57 pm

Dear vince,

THANK YOU for seeing and addressing the hidden assumption in my previously hidden resistance, connected with a fear that was deliberately buried forty years ago.

There is an important assumption hidden inside the movie metaphor:
There is a mechanical life unfolding, and consciousness is a separate, powerless spectator watching it.
Yes, this is precisely the assumption.
That recreates the very split being questioned. It imagines the body and brain producing the movie while a helpless “I” sits in the audience.
Can that spectator be found?
Interesting . . .
There is seeing, thinking, deliberating, intending, choosing and acting. But is there also a separate consciousness standing outside those events?
No. (Or that’s my understanding, and it’s fairly compelling, though I haven’t grokked it yet.)
Recognising that there is no I does not mean that consciousness is “just along for the ride.”
. . . . .
These processes matter because they are part of the unfolding
Hmm . . . Sure, processes that are part of the pattern known as “K” were part of the chain of events. But . . . nothing else could have happened.
OK, there we go: More of the freaked-out feeling is arising.
(I’ve been starting to wonder if at least some of the folks who have talked about karma and about the Buddhist notion of “dependent origination” have had all of this in mind, without my ever noticing.)
The old free-will-versus-determinism framing offers two frightening alternatives:
Either a sovereign self controls life, or a helpless witness watches a predetermined machine.
Yes. Scary. It’s no wonder 20-year-old K willfully decided not to think about it anymore.
But both alternatives assume a separate self—first as controller, then as passenger.
This is hopeful, as a way out of the fear (a way that 20-year-old K, though already exploring Buddhism, would never have come up with).
A more accurate image might be live improvisation rather than a movie. There is no musician separate from the playing, no completed score determining every note and no audience trapped inside the instrument. Each note emerges from the instrument, training, previous notes, present conditions and countless influences—and each note helps condition what follows.
Life is responsive without being personally authored.
The improv image is promising (and clever and lovely), but it’s not quite clicking.
Choosing happens, but no chooser separate from the choosing can be found.
This part I get.
But I’m still stuck on the idea that nothing else could have happened.
The choosing was only ever going to happen in precisely the way it did.
(And my brain is wondering why exactly that is experienced as so freaky.)
So it’s not a movie following a script that wasn’t written by the actors or a musical performance following a score not written by the musicians but, rather, improv music created, in part, by processes within the musicians. But still, the music couldn’t have ended up any other way.
(And again, why is that so freaky? But it is.)
That is not quite the same as saying K has no role. K—the whole living pattern—is where considering, choosing, acting, learning and responding happen.
What cannot be located is an essential K standing outside the pattern and directing it.
Yeah, but, back to this:
The old free-will-versus-determinism framing offers two frightening alternatives:
Either a sovereign self controls life, or a helpless witness watches a predetermined machine.
So far, I feel like that has only been modified to say:
Either a sovereign self controls life, or conscious processes that we refer to as “choosing,” within patterns of thinking and experiencing that we refer to as “people,” play out in the only way they could possibly play out.
Or, more concisely: conscious beings are integral parts of a process that can only play out in one way.

The idea that it can only play out in one way, which seems to be at the core of what freaks me out (though maybe I’m wrong about that), has not been touched.
Of course this feels freaky. For more than half a century, the organism has interpreted agency as evidence of an inner author. The prospect of losing that author can be what gets in the road of freedom.
I appreciate that acknowledgment.
Look carefully at what would actually be lost.
Would deliberation stop?
Would intentions stop affecting behaviour?
Would learning stop?
Would K become unable to respond?
No, of course not. That part is clear.
Or would only the imagined ownership of those processes be lost?

The fear appears to be:
If there is no separate chooser, I become a powerless spectator of my own life.
It feels bigger than that.
(And more existential fear is arising here.)
It’s not just about “me” and “my” life.
It feels like it’s about the whole setup of the universe, of conscious existence.
OK, maybe that’s just an expansion of the concern about “me.” But whatever.

Even if “I” am not “a powerless spectator of my own life” but am, rather, an ever-changing pattern of thoughts and sense experiences that is an integral part of the whole process of life . . . well, I don’t know . . . then this pattern is unfolding in the only way it possibly could. And that still feels like powerlessness. I’m not a spectator watching a machine doing what it was programmed to do, but I’m a cog in a machine that can only do one thing. I’m not getting how that’s better.

I really hope you can see something here that I’m missing.

Again, it’s not entirely clear to me why I find nothing else could happen so very disturbing. I guess it’s about powerlessness?

So this is the next question:
Can either the powerless spectator or the predetermined movie be found—or are both appearing now as thoughts about what no-self would mean?
OK, this is probably the only way to go with this — that is, with a “What is actually here?” inquiry (even if the thoughts are not precisely about a powerless spectator of a predetermined movie but of a conscious cog in a machine that will inevitably move in one specific way).

Will follow up on that later . . .

(I used up my entire morning work time on this, which is a problem given how much work I have to do to get my grades submitted by August 10 and given that morning is generally when I work best. Well, OK, I might again be running into the phenomenon that part of me knows how quickly and efficiently I can get things done when I need to. But there’s been a lot of self-castigation here this morning. Ugh. Posting this now so I’ll quit tinkering with it.)

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 541
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Mon Aug 03, 2026 11:16 pm

Continuing my response to your latest message.
(And happy to report that I got a reasonable amount of grading done in the afternoon.)

First, back to this:
The old free-will-versus-determinism framing offers two frightening alternatives:
Either a sovereign self controls life, or a helpless witness watches a predetermined machine.
But both alternatives assume a separate self—first as controller, then as passenger.
This implied, I think, that realizing no-self would eliminate the freakiness of there being no free will because it would dissolve the idea of being a helpless witness watching a predetermined machine. But I have imagined, instead, that with the realization of no-self and seeing clearly that “K—the whole living pattern—is where considering, choosing, acting, learning and responding happen,” what would remain would still be a universe in which nothing else could happen other than what actually does happen.

So this is the next question:
Can either the powerless spectator or the predetermined movie be found—or are both appearing now as thoughts about what no-self would mean?
As I concluded in my previous post, I think all I’m left with, as a way to deal with being freaked out by how existence is set up, is the way I’ve been learning to deal with all suffering: looking at what’s actually here (or at least that’s the first step).

When Christians talk about “turning it over to God,” my husband and I (both Catholic) are apt to think, half-jokingly and half-seriously, “So it’s come to that?” I feel a bit like that here.

Has it come to that, vince? Is that all I can do with my existential fear and disorientation regarding a universe in which only one chain of events is possible — look at what’s actually here?

What’s actually here?
The thought “There is only one way everything can happen.”
Tears pooling. Tightness in throat. Constriction of breathing.
Feeling of wanting to fend off existential fear.
Crying.
The thought, “Sheesh, a lot of crying in this process.”
Sniffling.

Now what?

Do I put myself through a desensitization process: engage in relaxation techniques and expose myself to ever-increasing lengths or intensities of exposure to this thought?

I feel like I might be missing something obvious.

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 541
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Tue Aug 04, 2026 12:47 am

Naturally, I identify with Clara in "The Picture That Wouldn't Appear."

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5866
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby vinceschubert » Tue Aug 04, 2026 1:50 pm

Naturally, I identify with Clara in "The Picture That Wouldn't Appear."
Of course, you inspired that story.
I feel like I might be missing something obvious.
Yes.
Watch your bodily response to this one...
We are not talking about it becoming this way.
It already is
Everything will continue to happen the way it always has. Except one thing..
You will discriminate between what is actual and what is conceptual. (and respond accordingly)

i imagine that you already know this, but let's examine it some more..
Conditioned arising means that nothing appears independently or from a single cause. Every event—thought, emotion, choice or action—arises when the necessary biological, psychological and environmental conditions come together.

When those conditions change, the event changes or ceases. This is not fatalism: intentions and actions also become conditions influencing what happens next.

Conditions All the Way Down

Cause and effect is a story. It is a conceptual model in which thought isolates one event, calls it a cause, identifies another as its effect and draws a line between them. This is often extremely useful. It allows us to learn, predict, build, repair and avoid danger. But it is also a radical simplification of an immeasurably complex unfolding.

Another useful concept is conditions.

To satisfy the mind’s wish for an explanation, we can say that every event depends upon conditions that enable it. No single condition produces the event by itself, and no event arises independently.

For these squiggles to appear on this screen, one obvious condition is the presence of a computer. But consider the conditions required for this computer to exist: minerals extracted from the earth; metals refined; plastics manufactured; components designed and assembled; software written; electricity generated; factories built; workers trained; transport systems operating; mathematical discoveries preserved; languages developed; and countless people performing actions they could never have known would contribute to this particular moment.

Other conditions are equally necessary. This organism had to learn language, encounter schooling, develop the ability to read and type, and accumulate the particular experiences that made these words possible.

Going further back, my parents had to conceive me. For that to happen, they had to be conceived, survive, meet and live through precisely the experiences that shaped them into the people capable of raising this particular organism in this particular way.

The same applies to their parents, and to every preceding generation.

In the theoretical family tree required to produce one person, there are:

2 parents
4 grandparents
8 great-grandparents
16 second great-grandparents
32 third great-grandparents
64 fourth great-grandparents
128 fifth great-grandparents
256 sixth great-grandparents
512 seventh great-grandparents
1,024 eighth great-grandparents
2,048 ninth great-grandparents

That gives 4,094 ancestral places across eleven generations—roughly three to four centuries.
Every one of those ancestors required food, water, shelter and enough safety to survive until another generation became possible. Their food required soil, sunlight, rain, seeds, animals, microorganisms, seasons and human labour. Their shelter required trees, stone, tools, knowledge and cooperation. Their survival depended upon political events, migrations, diseases, accidents, weather patterns and innumerable meetings between people.

Follow the conditions far enough and the family tree becomes inseparable from the history of life, the planet and the universe.

At this point, the language of individual causes begins to fail. It may not be accurate to claim that a butterfly in the Amazon caused these words to appear, or that a speck of stardust in another galaxy was a direct cause of this particular sentence. But neither exists independently of the total unfolding in which this sentence is also appearing.

If anything were different, THIS would be different. This precise moment—with this organism, this computer, these words and these conditions—would not be precisely as it is.

This does not mean that all these conditions are separate pieces assembled into something larger called THIS. The pieces themselves are conceptual divisions. The mineral, the computer, the ancestor, the butterfly and the person typing are names given to temporarily distinguish patterns within one indivisible unfolding.

The hologram is a useful metaphor. The whole is not merely assembled from independent fragments; something of the whole is expressed through every apparent fragment. Each event carries within it the history and conditions of everything that enabled it.

Nothing stands alone. Nothing authors itself. Nothing exists entirely through its own power.

Everything depends upon everything else—not necessarily as a chain of simple causes, but as an inconceivably intricate web of conditions.

We might call that interconnectedness. We might say that every apparent part belongs to the whole. We might even say, “All is One.”

And as profound, beautiful and convincing as all of this may sound, it remains a story.

Cause is a concept.
Condition is a concept.
Ancestor is a concept.
Interconnection is a concept.
The whole is a concept.
Even “All is One” is a thought appearing within THIS.

The story may be useful. It may loosen the belief that anything exists separately or that an isolated “I” authors what happens. But it is still a map drawn by thought.

THIS itself does not explain itself.

The explanation is simply one more event arising through conditions within the very mystery it attempts to describe.

You never had control. It was always an illusion.

Both free will and determinism are ridiculous stories—conceptual attempts to explain an unfolding that thought can never stand outside and observe.
I could go on about how society is built around the fiction of a separate chooser, but that would take us deep into storyland and offer little adaptive value for this Inquiry.
What matters here is much simpler: choosing happens, intentions arise, actions occur—and no separate entity running the show can be found.

v
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 541
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Tue Aug 04, 2026 3:50 pm

Naturally, I identify with Clara in "The Picture That Wouldn't Appear."
Of course, you inspired that story.
:-) That’s fun. (Maybe you told me that before and I forgot.)

Watch your bodily response to this one...
We are not talking about it becoming this way.
It already is
Everything will continue to happen the way it always has. Except one thing..
You will discriminate between what is actual and what is conceptual. (and respond accordingly)
Response is frustration, anger, resistance, weariness, fear.
We are not talking about it becoming this way.
It already is
Well, yeah.
And that’s like saying, “It’s not that it’s becoming true that you were abused as child and your parents didn’t know how to love you. It already is true.” (It isn’t. Just an example.) Well, great, so now I have to really face up to that truth and assimilate it.
Everything will continue to happen the way it always has. Except one thing..
You will discriminate between what is actual and what is conceptual. (and respond accordingly)
“Everything will continue to happen the way it always has” =
“It’s still true that you had a horrible childhood, just as has always been the case” =
“The universe will continue to unfold in the only way it possibly could, just as it always has.”
Except one thing: Now you will see these uncomfortable and disorienting facts clearly.

Is that supposed to be comforting?

Yeah, OK, so maybe (continuing with my comparison) I’m at a point in life where’s it’s probably good to really face the truth about my horrible childhood and assimilate it, and some sort of healing can come out of that? Maybe that’s what’s supposed to be comforting? Or maybe comfort isn’t the point?

So apparently I figured it out forty years ago and then tried to ignore it because it freaked me out, but now it’s time to face the truth (and maybe I’m better equipped now to face it). Perhaps it’s more accurate to frame it not as being a powerless spectator of a reality that can only unfold in one way but as an integral part of the unfolding of a reality that can only unfold in one way. But in any case, even from a no-self perspective (as far as I can tell), it can only unfold in one way.

This is, apparently, hard for me to cope with.

Maybe there are some specifically K-related things going on here, but it seems like a lot of it could be explained by what I assume are universal human fears of powerlessness, lack of control, unchangeable fate.

You never had control. It was always an illusion.
Yes, this is what I’m gathering and what I’m apparently freaked out by.

I totally get what you’re saying about “conditions all the way down,” including my great-great-great-grandparents and all that. This is precisely how I came to the conclusion that free will makes no sense and that everything is “determined,” which is maybe not the best word for it because that sounds like there was a plan in advance, but it does indicate that, as I’ve been saying, it can all only unfold in one way.

(And maybe I’m desensitizing myself to this thought by saying it over and over again in italics.)

(And I’m realizing that the absence of a “controller” is maybe baked into the notion of “dependent origination” or “conditioned arising,” which is an interesting new thought.)

Everything depends upon everything else . . .
. . . . .
And . . . it remains a story.
. . . . .
The story may be useful. It may loosen the belief that anything exists separately or that an isolated “I” authors what happens. But it is still a map drawn by thought.
So I think you’re saying that “conditioned arising” is a story?
And did you mean to imply that, thus, my “Nothing could be otherwise” is also a story?
That sounds possibly comforting.
But hold on, when you say “story,” does that mean “thought that doesn’t correspond with reality” or just “thought that may or may not correspond with reality”?
Some thoughts do correspond with reality.
Doesn’t “Nothing could be otherwise” correspond with reality?
So perhaps there’s no comfort to be found in thinking of it as a story?

Both free will and determinism are ridiculous stories—conceptual attempts to explain an unfolding that thought can never stand outside and observe.
OK, maybe there’s something helpful here.
Maybe there’s not actually a way to tell whether “Nothing could be otherwise” is a true story?
Hmm . . . Nah, that doesn’t actually seem very helpful, even though it seems like maybe it should be.

choosing happens, intentions arise, actions occur—and no separate entity running the show can be found.
If there is such a controller, it certainly seems like it’s not accessible to direct experience.

And I’m left with . . . ?
Brain offered: “THIS.”
But that was rejected as being too . . . something.
Maybe part of me wants to hang on to being freaked out or (this sound more likely) wants more acknowledgment of how very freaky it is to realize that there’s no control?
Maybe that’s it.

Holy crap, vince, the universe is not the way we’re led to believe it is!
Or, well, it doesn’t even make a lot of sense to talk about “how the universe is,” but even human experience is not the way we’re led to believe it is, if you actually look.
This is really disorienting and scary.
And I’m still not sure how to get away from the idea that consciousness is just along for the ride.

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5866
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby vinceschubert » Tue Aug 04, 2026 9:54 pm

Response is frustration, anger, resistance, weariness, fear.
This tells us that we are 'on' to something.
so now I have to really face up to that truth and assimilate it.
it was assimilated in the best way that you had available as a child. That is it was buried.
“Everything will continue to happen the way it always has” =
“It’s still true that you had a horrible childhood, just as has always been the case” =
“The universe will continue to unfold in the only way it possibly could, just as it always has.”
Except one thing: Now you will see these uncomfortable and disorienting facts clearly.

Is that supposed to be comforting?
That would be avoiding it again.
and some sort of healing can come out of that?
You're not sick. Nothing to heal. You're just bringing a story about the past into the present when it gets activated.
If we mean by "heal" that we find a more adaptable way to relate to this..
Or maybe comfort isn’t the point?
Good seeing..
it can only unfold in one way.
No. This is critical; It could have only unfolded in the way it did.
For it to have unfolded differently, at least one of the conditions involved would have had to be different. Remember, what's past is done. It's not possible to change it.
Are you having a horrible childhood now?
Is this enquiry triggering the buried story? (well great! It's an opportunity to reframe it in a more adaptable way)
it can only unfold in one way.
Is this investigation one of the conditions shaping the unfolding?
Is your present intention (to awaken) a condition?
Is that i am awake at 5am responding to your post a condition?
it seems like a lot of it could be explained by what I assume are universal human fears of powerlessness, lack of control, unchangeable fate.
Yes, that's a good story. By that i mean that it's probably accurate. (or not)
This is, apparently, hard for me to cope with.
Yes. Some opportunities elicit discomfort.
Yes, this is what I’m gathering and what I’m apparently freaked out by.
Yes. Have you examined the details of the sensations called "freaked out"?
but it does indicate that, as I’ve been saying, it can all only unfold in one way.
No. It is accurate to say (tell the story) that it could have unfolded the way it did. Future unfolding depends on conditions that are not yet in place.
Maybe there’s not actually a way to tell whether “Nothing could be otherwise” is a true story?
True, but nothing could have been different...
Oh, we can tell stories about how different conditions might have produced different outcomes, but apart from learning that might produce different conditions in the future or entertainment, it's probably unproductive.
when you say “story,” does that mean “thought that doesn’t correspond with reality” or just “thought that may or may not correspond with reality”?
The second.
When i say "story" i mean that it's a narrative about...
(this sound more likely) wants more acknowledgment of how very freaky it is to realize that there’s no control?
i have no trouble accepting and acknowledging what you describe is happening to K. Experience is so different here. When focus goes to this, there is magnificent appreciation of the freedom from the conventional views of responsibility (that doesn't mean irresponsible) or any of the morality stories. (That doesn't lead to immorality)
Maybe part of me wants to hang on to being freaked out
That was the most adaptable way that young K could manage it.
the idea that consciousness is just along for the ride.
i have a better story about that. i believe that consciousness (whatever that is) is the producer of everything (and every not thing)

It's now 7am and i am going back to sleep.

much love

v
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 541
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Wed Aug 05, 2026 12:11 am

I'm very aware these days of what time it is in Sydney, and 5 p.m. here, which is 7 a.m. there, is not a time of day when I expect to hear from you! Hope you got more sleep!

it can only unfold in one way.
No. This is critical; It could have only unfolded in the way it did.
For it to have unfolded differently, at least one of the conditions involved would have had to be different. Remember, what's past is done. It's not possible to change it.
I probably wouldn't have followed up on this except that you called it "critical."
I don't understand the distinction you made there.
Are you saying that while the past is unchangeable, the future . . . is what?
Whatever happens next is a result of all the conditions preceding it, so it can't be anything other than one specific way, right?
But is it actually fruitful to get into this?

Ah. From later in your post:
Future unfolding depends on conditions that are not yet in place.
Yes, but those exact conditions will come to be in place as the only possible result of the exact conditions that preceded them, with “conditions all the way down.” Right?
I don’t see how any of this changes the idea that it can only unfold in one particular way. You start with the conditions of the Big Bang and end up with K existing and typing this exact sentence in this exact place at this exact time, which, along with everything else happening right now, sets up the conditions for what comes next.

Are you having a horrible childhood now?
Is this enquiry triggering the buried story? (well great! It's an opportunity to reframe it in a more adaptable way)
Let's skip the comparison with a horrible childhood that wasn't mine and go with the actual issue: existential fear that free will makes no sense and, thus, that there is only one way for reality to play out. This inquiry brought up the memory of wrestling with this issue forty years ago and has been giving rise to feelings of fear, confusion, and disorientation that are the same as or very similar to the feelings back then, although there's a sense now of having more resources to deal with this in a way other than burying it.

it can only unfold in one way.
Is this investigation one of the conditions shaping the unfolding?
Is your present intention (to awaken) a condition?
Is that i am awake at 5am responding to your post a condition?
Yes, yes, and yes.
(And sorry you were awake at 5 a.m.! And thanks for getting up so early for the "Monday morning" meetings, which for me are at the very civilized time of 4 p.m. on Sunday.)
But I’m not sure I see what your point is.
Some of the conditions shaping the unfolding are “internal” to these (conventionally defined) “people” labeled “K” and “vince.” And still, there’s only one way in which this could all unfold, right?
Yes, “I” will, e.g., “make decisions” about what to say to you, but that just means that a series of thoughts arises, followed by certain words being typed, and each thought and action in the series was the only possible result of all the prior conditions, right?
Am I missing something?
And again, is it fruitful to get into this — other than (the thought appears once again) as a way of desensitizing K to the freaky idea of not being a “controller”?

This is, apparently, hard for me to cope with.
Yes. Some opportunities elicit discomfort.
Yes. I have already been recognizing this as an uncomfortable opportunity, perhaps an important one (and have spent probably at least three hours today on my LU posts).

Yes, this is what I’m gathering and what I’m apparently freaked out by.
Yes. Have you examined the details of the sensations called "freaked out"?
Once a few posts back, maybe not in a whole lot of detail:
What’s actually here?
The thought “There is only one way everything can happen.”
Tears pooling. Tightness in throat. Constriction of breathing.
Feeling of wanting to fend off existential fear.
Crying.
The thought, “Sheesh, a lot of crying in this process.”
Sniffling.

the idea that consciousness is just along for the ride.
i have a better story about that. i believe that consciousness (whatever that is) is the producer of everything (and every not thing)
OK, that’s an interesting and fairly compelling story.

Now what?

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 541
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Wed Aug 05, 2026 12:49 am

P.S. I almost deleted the "Now what?" at the end of the previous message because I know it's kind of the "wrong" question. But I decided to leave it because it was what came to mind.

"Now what?" seems like a line in one of your stories. If could be followed by this:
Nothing followed the question.
Not an answer. Not a revelation. Not even a particularly peaceful silence.
There was simply the room.
Rain.
Breathing.
A page of coloured marks.
Tension in the chest.
The thought this can’t be it.
The wish that it were otherwise.
All of it arriving without permission.
Clara’s shoulders lowered slightly.
She noticed this and immediately thought, Good. Something is happening.
Then she saw that thought too.
Not as an enemy. Not as proof that she had failed. Just another movement in the same room.
“This is it,” she said quietly.
Elias didn’t confirm it.
“This is it,” she repeated. “Even the feeling that this can’t possibly be it.”
Nobody answered.
Phthftpt to THIS!
(And shut up, little Zen master in my head.)

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5866
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby vinceschubert » Wed Aug 05, 2026 2:17 pm

Hope you got more sleep!
i did thanks.
I don’t see how any of this changes the idea that it can only unfold in one particular way.
You're right. It can only unfold in one particular way, but that way is not predetermined.
The conditions that shape it are undetermined until the happening (the way)
existential fear that free will makes no sense
Fear is irrational. It can't make sense.
How much more irrational is it when you realise that the way things will unfold is the way they have always unfolded.
Is your fear about finding out?
When you walked across the room to where you are now, how much did free will feature in the route that you took?
How much free will was used to determine where you placed your feet as you walked?
Sure, you could recite a story about taking a different path or walking differently, but it happened the way that it did. Shaped by all of the conditions/circumstances that were present as it happened.
If one of the conditions changed you would have done it differently - and called it a choice, thus maintaining the illusion of control.
desensitizing K to the freaky idea of not being a “controller”?
Describe the freakiness.
Am I missing something?
Hmm, i think that i am missing something. Can you define the issue?

much love

vince
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 541
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Wed Aug 05, 2026 4:33 pm

If you’re reading this at 5 a.m., you should probably stop! :-)

It can only unfold in one particular way, but that way is not predetermined.
The conditions that shape it are undetermined until the happening (the way)
I agree that “predetermined” and maybe even “determinism” seem to suggest being planned in advance, which isn’t what we’re talking about.

existential fear that free will makes no sense
Fear is irrational. It can't make sense.
How much more irrational is it when you realise that the way things will unfold is the way they have always unfolded.
I dunno. This isn’t really about rationality.

At the last Zoom meeting, I felt like one of the regulars was, once again, trying to lead me step-by-step through a sort of syllogism about thoughts so that, boom, I would necessarily realize . . . I don’t recall what exactly. No-self maybe? It felt coercive and unsuitably rational, and also the spirit of it seemed to imply that I could be and needed to be fixed, which is, I think, precisely the opposite of where I need to be pointed. Of course, I realize that I show up at the meetings, as I showed up at LU, basically pleading for help waking up — saying that I want my perspective on life fixed — so I understand and am grateful when people want to jump in and try to help. But I don’t think trying to argue me into it is the way to go. (OK, yeah, I had that all locked and loaded in my mind, and it just got triggered.)

At the same time, I do recognize that I’ve had inhibitions along the way that have been dismantled essentially intellectually, in a jñana kind of way, by which I mean using rational discourse about experience. I’m thinking especially of how helpful Hubert Benoit’s The Supreme Doctrine was for enabling me to reengage with spiritual practice several years ago. It’s a super-duper intellectual book about experience, one that I would recommend to almost no one.

But anyway, in this case, I’m not sure it’s the best approach to try to convince me of the irrationality of my fear that free will makes no sense. But I do appreciate that attempt to help.

And let me say here that part of what I deeply appreciate about your guidance, vince, is the way I get a sense both that you very much want to help me “fix” what I perceive to be the fundamental problem in my life and, at the same time, that you’re always trying to point me toward grokking that it’s all always already THIS. It seems to me that handling this tension skillfully is one of the central challenges of guidance and teaching in this realm, and you do it beautifully. (Getting choked up with appreciation and gratitude. I prefer that to the other kind of tears I keep experiencing in this process.)

I also appreciate that you aren’t put off by, and don’t discourage, my sometimes intellectual-seeming style of discourse about all this. (But do feel free to stop me if I go off the rails with that!)

Is your fear about finding out?
When you walked across the room to where you are now, how much did free will feature in the route that you took?
. . . . .
. . . it happened the way that it did. Shaped by all of the conditions/circumstances that were present as it happened.
I am well aware that much of what I do every day happens without any conscious deliberation (I noticed when I was sixteen that I could drive a car without conscious deliberation — yikes!), and I’m fine with that, and it in no way challenges my lifelong view of “self” (or, y’know, my view after age two or whatever). But don’t you see that it’s quite a different matter to accept that even when there are conscious thought processes involved, there’s still never a controller? That’s a HUGE challenge to my lifelong view of “self” and how the universe works.
desensitizing K to the freaky idea of not being a “controller”?
Describe the freakiness.
Am I missing something?
Hmm, i think that i am missing something. Can you define the issue?
It’s not just that much of what happens, or even most of what happens, even within K’s mind, is not in K’s control. Fine. Of course. No big deal.
It’s that “I” have NO control whatsoever — NONE.
There are NO “selves” who control ANYTHING.
This challenges my assumed reality of nearly sixty years.
This is WEIRD. It’s a BIG DEAL.
It's a MAJOR revision of my understanding of “myself” and all of reality.
(Desensitization is working. The feelings of freakiness while writing that were manageable.)

A song I like lot, the Doobie Brothers' "Listen to the Music," is playing at the coffee shop where I'm writing this. I've been noticing increasing appreciation of music recently. And I keep noticing that I'm laughing more.


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 65 guests