Naturally, I identify with Clara in "The Picture That Wouldn't Appear."
Of course, you inspired that story.
I feel like I might be missing something obvious.
Yes.
Watch your bodily response to this one...
We are not talking about it
becoming this way.
It already is
Everything will continue to happen the way it always has. Except one thing..
You will discriminate between what is actual and what is conceptual. (and respond accordingly)
i imagine that you already know this, but let's examine it some more..
Conditioned arising means that nothing appears independently or from a single cause. Every event—thought, emotion, choice or action—arises when the necessary biological, psychological and environmental conditions come together.
When those conditions change, the event changes or ceases. This is not fatalism: intentions and actions also become conditions influencing what happens next.
Conditions All the Way Down
Cause and effect is a story. It is a conceptual model in which thought isolates one event, calls it a cause, identifies another as its effect and draws a line between them. This is often extremely useful. It allows us to learn, predict, build, repair and avoid danger. But it is also a radical simplification of an immeasurably complex unfolding.
Another useful concept is
conditions.
To satisfy the mind’s wish for an explanation, we can say that every event depends upon conditions that enable it. No single condition produces the event by itself, and no event arises independently.
For these squiggles to appear on this screen, one obvious condition is the presence of a computer. But consider the conditions required for this computer to exist: minerals extracted from the earth; metals refined; plastics manufactured; components designed and assembled; software written; electricity generated; factories built; workers trained; transport systems operating; mathematical discoveries preserved; languages developed; and countless people performing actions they could never have known would contribute to this particular moment.
Other conditions are equally necessary. This organism had to learn language, encounter schooling, develop the ability to read and type, and accumulate the particular experiences that made these words possible.
Going further back, my parents had to conceive me. For that to happen, they had to be conceived, survive, meet and live through precisely the experiences that shaped them into the people capable of raising this particular organism in this particular way.
The same applies to their parents, and to every preceding generation.
In the theoretical family tree required to produce one person, there are:
2 parents
4 grandparents
8 great-grandparents
16 second great-grandparents
32 third great-grandparents
64 fourth great-grandparents
128 fifth great-grandparents
256 sixth great-grandparents
512 seventh great-grandparents
1,024 eighth great-grandparents
2,048 ninth great-grandparents
That gives 4,094 ancestral places across eleven generations—roughly three to four centuries.
Every one of those ancestors required food, water, shelter and enough safety to survive until another generation became possible. Their food required soil, sunlight, rain, seeds, animals, microorganisms, seasons and human labour. Their shelter required trees, stone, tools, knowledge and cooperation. Their survival depended upon political events, migrations, diseases, accidents, weather patterns and innumerable meetings between people.
Follow the conditions far enough and the family tree becomes inseparable from the history of life, the planet and the universe.
At this point, the language of individual causes begins to fail. It may not be accurate to claim that a butterfly in the Amazon
caused these words to appear, or that a speck of stardust in another galaxy was a direct cause of this particular sentence. But neither exists independently of the total unfolding in which this sentence is also appearing.
If anything were different, THIS would be different. This precise moment—with this organism, this computer, these words and these conditions—would not be precisely as it is.
This does not mean that all these conditions are separate pieces assembled into something larger called THIS. The pieces themselves are conceptual divisions. The mineral, the computer, the ancestor, the butterfly and the person typing are names given to temporarily distinguish patterns within one indivisible unfolding.
The hologram is a useful metaphor. The whole is not merely assembled from independent fragments; something of the whole is expressed through every apparent fragment. Each event carries within it the history and conditions of everything that enabled it.
Nothing stands alone. Nothing authors itself. Nothing exists entirely through its own power.
Everything depends upon everything else—not necessarily as a chain of simple causes, but as an inconceivably intricate web of conditions.
We might call that interconnectedness. We might say that every apparent part belongs to the whole. We might even say,
“All is One.”
And as profound, beautiful and convincing as all of this may sound, it remains a story.
Cause is a concept.
Condition is a concept.
Ancestor is a concept.
Interconnection is a concept.
The whole is a concept.
Even
“All is One” is a thought appearing within THIS.
The story may be useful. It may loosen the belief that anything exists separately or that an isolated “I” authors what happens. But it is still a map drawn by thought.
THIS itself does not explain itself.
The explanation is simply one more event arising through conditions within the very mystery it attempts to describe.
You never had control. It was always an illusion.
Both free will and determinism are ridiculous stories—conceptual attempts to explain an unfolding that thought can never stand outside and observe.
I could go on about how society is built around the fiction of a separate chooser, but that would take us deep into storyland and offer little adaptive value for this Inquiry.
What matters here is much simpler: choosing happens, intentions arise, actions occur—and no separate entity running the show can be found.
v