Thank you for all of that. Thank you for spending so much time with me, vince.
Perhaps the mind suspects it is being manoeuvred towards the “correct” answer—probably “Nothing remains to be seen”—when experience still seems to say otherwise.
Yep, it was something like that.
You’ve let go of the requirement for fireworks, but a quieter set of requirements remains: . . .
But these expectations still make a future state the evidence by which no-self will be judged.
More precisely, the mind is making these expectations the evidence by which
realization of no-self will be judged.
There’s a subtle confusion here. No-self is being imagined as a new way for K to experience “herself.” Yet even an expansive, unified or psychedelic experience could be claimed by thought as “my experience of no-self.” Meanwhile, a perfectly ordinary experience of being “in here” could continue even after it is clear that no actual entity occupies that position.
OK, yeah, that’s interesting. I can see how an experience of no-self could be coopted as “my” experience and, conversely, how a sense of self can remain even when no-self is clear. And . . .
I’m struggling to see quite what to do with these insights, but let’s keep going . . .
The sense of self is not the self. It’s a collection of sensations, images, perspectives and thoughts that imply one.
I think I’m clear on that.
The thesis “I am not awake” may be doing two jobs. One is honest reporting: the expected change doesn’t seem to have occurred. The other is preserving hope that a future awakening will finally bring the relief K has sought.
Probably both of those things are going on, maybe in different proportions at different times.
You don’t need to decide which motive is “really” operating. Notice that the defence arises by itself—and that no defender chose it.
OK. Again, not quite sure what to do with these insights.
Also, “It’s all THIS” needn’t become something you must grok or feel. Even the strong impression of K being in here, looking at a world out there, is included. THIS doesn’t require an experience of unity. It includes the experience of separation and the thought that separation ought to have dissolved.
Yeah, I get all that theoretically. But . . . But . . . Isn’t what we’re doing here about changing my way of experiencing life and “self”? (Noticing emotion coming up for the first time here — frustration and tears welling up.)
So leave the self-sense completely undisturbed and examine it gently. Where does “K in here” seem to be located? Behind the eyes? In the face, throat or chest? In the visual perspective? In a mental image of the body? In the thought “I am looking”?
All of that.
- Looking out through the eyes (“self” as perceiver), from behind the face.
- In the throat and mouth (“self” as speaker and sometimes thinker).
- In the head (where hearing, seeing, smelling, and tasting are sometimes imagined to be located and where thinking is sometimes imagined to be located, including thoughts initiating action and making decisions).
- Maybe a little bit down into the throat and upper chest.
- In the whole body — in the “bag of skin,” as my first Zen teacher liked to say (quoting somebody else, I think) — in the parts over which “I” have direct control of movement and from which “I” seem to receive sensations.
- In the mental map of the body.
- Probably in many thoughts including “I” or “me.”
Take each ingredient separately. Does pressure behind the eyes say it is K?
I’ve heard “pressure behind the eyes” before but have never connected with that one. For me, it’s just the idea of a little viewer looking out through the eyes. (I noticed this “sense of self” way back while living at the monastery.) It certainly seems to think it’s K. And I’ve found that humorous from the first time I noticed it.
Does the visual perspective contain a viewer? When a sound appears, can a receiver be found—or only hearing?
The perspective from which vision is experienced and from which sound is experienced seem to locate the “perceiver” in space — specifically, in the head. But only the seeing and hearing can be found, no seer or hearer. And I say that not just from understanding or memory but from experience. I can get a sense of that right now: that only seeing and hearing are experienced, no seer of the seen, no hearer of the heard.
Does the thought “I’m in here” point to an entity, or does it merely create the impression that one must exist?
It doesn’t point to any entity that can be found. I’m not sure it even creates the impression that one must exist. I’m having trouble articulating this, but it’s more that the thought “I’m in here” (like all other thoughts) seems to originate from somewhere . . . or something like that? I’m playing with that right now, and again I’m noticing something I’ve noticed only in the past few months: that verbal thoughts sometimes feel like they originate in the throat and mouth, as if being spoken (and presumably there’s often subvocalization going on). So I suppose you could say that there’s an impression that some sort of “I” entity must exist as the originator of the thought, but that feels a little too definite or reified to describe how it seems. Maybe it’s more like how the perspective from which seeing happens is the location of eyes, not three feet to the left, but I wouldn’t say quite that it feels like a seer “entity” exists behind the eyes. Likewise, the point of origin of thoughts seems be in the throat or head, but I wouldn’t quite say that it feels like a thinker “entity” exists there. I guess “entity” seems too thing-like. Okay, moving along . . .
Don’t ask whether the self-sense has loosened. Ask whether an actual self can be found within it. If the familiar feeling remains strong, that isn’t failure.
Could it be that the self-sense doesn’t need to disappear—that only its claim to be evidence of a real owner is being questioned?
I get that the self sense doesn’t need to disappear — or I think I do. But I suppose I was thinking that I should or would have at least some flickers of a felt sense of its not being there or not being so definite, not merely the
idea that no self can be found. I don’t take the self sense to be evidence of a real owner — or at least I don’t think I do.
Right now, apart from its individual ingredients, where is K?
Nowhere to be found.
But I wrote that quickly, from knowledge, not from looking.
But then, you keep saying not to bother looking again in the fridge for a watermelon when you know there isn’t one there.
That always confuses me, though. Maybe it’s my early Zen imprinting again, but does mere knowledge actually do much? Isn’t it worthwhile to keep looking (at least now and then, when it doesn't feel too rote) and going, “Nope, I truly don't see a watermelon”?
Try each sentence slowly—not to decide which is true, but to notice its effect:
“I am not awake.” What relaxes? What hope becomes available?
It feels accurate and honest. And there is hope for relief from suffering. (Emotion welling up again.)
“I am awake.” What contracts? What seems endangered or lost?
It feels false. It engenders argument to fend off hopelessness. Mind says, “It has to get better than this! I have evidence that it can!”
And actually, my considered opinion is that it does get better than this, and I do have evidence of that possibility, even from you.
But here I am in this annoying, confusing, uncomfortable limbo, which is full of paradox (which even all my Zen training and academic study of Zen didn’t eliminate my distaste for), where it seems that if I could really give up hope for relief from suffering (I’m just talking about second-arrow suffering), then there would be relief from suffering. Aagghhh!
Then notice: both are thoughts.
OK, this seems key.
(I’ve already finished my response to the rest of your message and am now returning to this paragraph.)
“I am not awake” and “I am awake” are obviously both thoughts.
Thoughts are evanescent phenomena that arise in consciousness, and they may or may not point to something true. (This is a little homily to myself.) These particular thoughts might point to something true-ish or false-ish in a conventional sense, but neither stands up to scrutiny as even making any sense from the absolute/no-self perspective. What is this “I” that’s being referred to? (It can't be found.) And what would it even mean for it to be “awake” or “not awake”? (Only from the conventional perspective is there a halfway sensible answer.)
Before either thought appears, is experiencing itself awake or not awake—
Before either thought appears (and also while each thought appears, and after it’s gone), experiencing is happening. There is consciousness, awareness, perception — i.e., awakeness. It’s not so much that experiencing itself is “awake” but that experiencing itself is
awakeness. It was a fairly recent insight for me that “awakeness” is “stupidly simple” — that it’s basically a synonym for “consciousness” or “awareness.” (That’s right, isn’t it?) It doesn’t even make sense to talk about thinking in the absence of experiencing or awareness. And as long as there is awareness, the experiencing of thoughts and sense perceptions just happens; it can’t be turned off. So: Before the thought “I am awake” or “I am not awake” appears, experiencing is happening, which means awakeness is there.
—and is there any K there requiring a verdict?
Well, there is the pattern of thoughts and perceptions that’s labeled “K” for convenience (like how certain patterns of water and air molecules get called “hurricanes” and are given names for convenience). And as part of that pattern, thoughts may arise wanting to know whether “K” is “awake” or not. (Mostly, thoughts arise claiming that “K is not yet awake.”) But there’s no underlying, essential K that could be “awake” or “not awake” or could want a verdict on that issue.
Curious what you think of this:
Perhaps the only difference between what we might really want to call “awakeness” and simply being awake or aware or conscious in the ordinary sense of the those words is that “awakeness” is ordinary awareness minus the overlay of relating everything to a fictional “self”?
the obvious version was rejected as a requirement: no fireworks, psychedelic effects, permanent bliss or dramatic mystical event needed.
But the mind may then preserve the same expectation in more respectable clothing:
Yes, I prefer to be more refined about it. :-) (But psychedelic effects are fun.)
So the specialness moves from how the event looks to what it is expected to accomplish.
I think, for me, it has always been primarily about “what it is expected to accomplish.” A flashy experience might be entertaining, but that’s just a momentary thing. What good is that in the face of ongoing suffering and existential angst?
There is still an imagined before-and-after: before, K feels located inside and suffers heavily; afterwards, the self-sense is loosened, life feels spacious, and suffering spirals less often. Because that contrast hasn’t appeared strongly enough, thought concludes: “No-self hasn’t really been seen.”
Yep. That does seem to be what’s happening.
Is there anything to be done about that?
None of those changes is unreasonable, and some may indeed happen. The subtle issue is using their absence as evidence that an actual self must still be present. That confuses the possible consequences of seeing with what is being examined.
As far as I can tell, I don’t have any notion that an actual self must still be present.
The issue for me, as I imagine it, is that realization of the accepted fact that no “self” can be found hasn’t happened. Maybe you can help me dissect that, if that would be helpful?
Try completing this honestly: “If no-self had truly been seen, then ______ would be different.” Whatever fills the blank—less suffering, more spaciousness, weaker self-sense—is that evidence about whether a self exists now, or a prediction about what seeing this should eventually produce?
None of what I hope will change is evidence about whether a self exists now (or, more precisely, whether a self can be found now). I am not under the impression that I currently have a “self,” which I need to get rid of. I am under the impression that the fact that no “self” can be found — a fact I fully accept — needs to be grokked in a way that hasn’t happened yet in order for life to be experienced differently.
So, yes, what I would put in that blank are predictions about what grokking no-self might eventually produce. And . . . what of that? (I guess that was a more polite way of saying, “So what”? :-) )
Spent almost four hours on this. The mind appreciates feeling like it has been occupied in the service of awakening. (Shhh . . . Don’t tell it that it can’t DO anything but wait.)