A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Tue Jan 24, 2012 4:42 am

Hi Neil,

Ok here goes again...
itches occur, but do they occur to a separate self? Is this a sticking point for you, that things appear located in this body? I read over the whole thread again and you said earlier

"So in reality there is a body mind machine experiencing and that is it. My body mind machines still has separate and different experiences to yours. It is still your body -mind machine+operating system (called Robin) writing to my body mind machine+ operating system (called Col)"

The reason it occurs in your body and not someone elses is because all the physical apparatus is in your body and not anyone elses. Im sure you realise this. But the question we are asking is, inside all the physical apparatus that is in your body, is there a separate, controlling self? Or is it all just natural biological processes, occuring to no-one?
What is the 'your' in 'your' statement? ( or indeed in this one?). It refers to something belonging to something. In language it is impossible to lose the "I' or "your" or to move away from this sense of 'belonging too'. If it is happening in my mind/body then this distinguishes my mind/body from your mind/body OR one mind/ body from another. In that sense there is differentiation. The itch occurs to 'this mind/body' which is separate to 'that mind/ body' This is what I meant in my statement to Robin that you quote. it is still a unique body/mind machine communicating with another unique body/mind machine. Their are separate thoughts and feelings in each and we call these thoughts and feelings and the remembering of previous thoughts and feelings the "I" or "character" . These thoughts and feelings occur in reality and so arguably the "I" exists in reality or more precisely thoughts and feelings about the "I" exist in reality. What it is true to say is that this "I' is not fixed or unalterable. It is all natural biological processes of course. These don't occur to no-one - they occur to a specific body/mind machine with the label 'some-one". I can say that they occur to no-one , in the sense that it is to the idea of a someone made up of thoughts and feelings about it rather than something solid and real like a table. What is the test for reality here? A concept about a new building in the mind is not real in the sense that it does not hold real physical space but it is real as a concept. Only with the concept in mind first will we have the possibility of a drawing, a computer rendition, a model and then the building itself occupying physical space. It is true to say that unlike a building a character or 'I" cannot hold real physical space on its own other than in a body and so remains a concept.
Ok, so it looks like you have seen through the illusion.

Reading this thread back though, it seems like you are still identifying with something. It seems like you feel like you are the thing that chooses what to do, the decision maker, the one who looks at all the input and decides on the best course of action, the observer. Am I correct in this?
Thoughts and feelings ARE something - they occur in reality The "I" is made up of thoughts and feelings therefore the "I" is something and appears in reality as a concept created of thoughts and feelings. It is not physically real if that is indeed the test for reality here? My thoughts and feelings give me the illusion of being the chooser which is almost indistinguishable from actually being the chooser when it comes to living a life. I cannot stop my thoughts - they occur regardless. Do I direct them - well sometimes I do. When I am writing this they come out of my head in a manner consistent with answering the questions posed by you. If they were not directed on this task then what i write here would be gobbledegook. But yes - they appear to come from no-where but they do seem to have an inextricable relationship with 'this body/mind machine' and not 'that body/mind machine'. I do identify more with the 'observer' than with the original 'character' and if there is something that this LU process has taught me is that identifying with the observer or any potential observer of the observer is as much a fallacy as identifying with the 'I' or 'character'. Although, identifying with the observer in my experience has tended to provide more utility. So if my thoughts tell me to be frightened - my observer says ah - what is happening in reality? It then says well you have a physical sensation which you label fear. It then says is there a use in feeling this right now? That process often allows me to disregard thoughts and emotions which might negatively impact on me or stop me taking an action. I don't stop having the thought or emotion but considering its utility frees me up to take action that can then dispel the thought or emotion. So I guess i am hung up on the idea of 'usefulness'. What is the use in not identifying with 'the observer', the observer of the observer' ad infinitum' ? What else can I identify with? There is nothing else to identify with and what is the use in identifying with nothing? Perhaps this is my 'I' attempting to defend it's position but it seems like an impasse to me.

Anyhow - over to you.

Thanks for taking the time.. I feel like I am a hard nut to crack.LOL ;-)

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Tue Jan 24, 2012 11:55 am


What is the 'your' in 'your' statement? ( or indeed in this one?). It refers to something belonging to something.
Yes, it does refer to something belonging to something. But is it true that the body belongs to you? What is the you that the body belongs to?
In language it is impossible to lose the "I' or "your" or to move away from this sense of 'belonging too'.
We could just start using unnatural language , "a feeling of anger has just occurred in this body, other body over next to that tree , please stop throwing rocks at this body" or whatever. Its not very useful, and would quite quickly become confusing( and probably very annoying to most people). "I" and "your" do imply that there is something that the body belongs to, so what? Is it true that there is something that the body belongs to? Thats all we are interested in.

These thoughts and feelings occur in reality and so arguably the "I" exists in reality or more precisely thoughts and feelings about the "I" exist in reality
Thoughts and feelings exist. Is there an owner of the thoughts and feelings? Do these thoughts and feelings happen to a "someone"? ( I know you answered this in your previous post, but just making sure :D)

I can say that they occur to no-one , in the sense that it is to the idea of a someone made up of thoughts and feelings about it rather than something solid and real like a table.
Does a table exist? Yes, there is a formation of atoms that exist, but the table is an idea made up of thoughts.
To use someone elses analogy, A university is a group of buildings and people, that have the function of passing on learning. Does University actually exist? Or is it just a group of buildings and people? The concept of University only exists in thought. Its abstract.
What is the test for reality here? A concept about a new building in the mind is not real in the sense that it does not hold real physical space but it is real as a concept. Only with the concept in mind first will we have the possibility of a drawing, a computer rendition, a model and then the building itself occupying physical space. It is true to say that unlike a building a character or 'I" cannot hold real physical space on its own other than in a body and so remains a concept.
Santa claus is real as a concept. Does he exist in reality? Can anything exist as "just a concept"? Does the "I" hold real physical space on its own in the body?
Thoughts of building. Look outside, see building is real
thoughts of santa claus. Look outside, no santa claus
thoughts of self. .......?


Thoughts and feelings ARE something - they occur in reality The "I" is made up of thoughts and feelings therefore the "I" is something and appears in reality as a concept created of thoughts and feelings. It is not physically real if that is indeed the test for reality here?
Thoughts and feelings exist. Does the content of thoughts and feelings always exist? what other test for reality is there other than "is it physically real?"
Again,
I can have thoughts of santa claus, is santa claus real?
I can have thoughts of "I", is the "I" real?
My thoughts and feelings give me the illusion of being the chooser which is almost indistinguishable from actually being the chooser when it comes to living a life. I cannot stop my thoughts - they occur regardless.


Give who the illusion of being the chooser?
Do I direct them - well sometimes I do. When I am writing this they come out of my head in a manner consistent with answering the questions posed by you. If they were not directed on this task then what i write here would be gobbledegook.


Ok, who directs the thoughts?


My last 2 questions might seem to be throwaway and not meaningful, but they are actually really important. What you are telling me is that you still believe in some separate entity, that 1) has the illusion of being the chooser( or is actually the chooser, but you dont want to admit it), and 2) can direct thought.

This is where you really need to look, not think. I can tell you have been doing a lot of thinking about this, but thinking is going to get you nowhere. You are getting lost in thoughts of self.

Look at the process of making a decision. Raise your right arm. Were there thoughts about raising your arm? Are these thoughts you? or are they just thoughts? Really look at the thoughts that come up, see if they are some special kind of thought, or if they are just thoughts with an "I" tag on them. Why did thoughts of raising your arm occur at this point in time?

Investigate as much as you can throughout the day, be aware of the times you have the sense of a you making decisions, and try and notice thoughts as they happen. Also be aware of any times where decisions seem to get made automatically, notice any thoughts that were happening in these cases too.

remember, LOOK, dont think.

neil

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Tue Jan 24, 2012 2:40 pm

Hi Neil,
But is it true that the body belongs to you? What is the you that the body belongs to?
No. But there does seem to be an inextricable relationship between the 'I" construct of thoughts and feelings that is labeled Colin and a particular body.
Is there an owner of the thoughts and feelings? Do these thoughts and feelings happen to a "someone"? ( I know you answered this in your previous post, but just making sure :D)
These thoughts and feelings just happen and seem to come from nowhere. In the sense that they occur and are processed by the "character" called Colin also made up of thoughts and feelings who then has thoughts and feelings about thoughts and feelings . So all that is happening in reality are thoughts and feelings referring to thoughts and feelings in an endless referential loop. So an example is ..

Me: Is the I real?
Me: Yes the I is real?
Me: No it is not?
Me: Who says?
Me: I do?
Me: But so and so told me the I was real and she is a Guru?
Me: Ok so the I must be real?
Me: But who is she to know if the I is real or not..?

blah blah blah blah blah... blah de blah blah blah..

So unless I can somehow state that referential thoughts and feelings can form something real and by that I mean physical and existing in space (which I cannot) then I can only say that the 'I" is a phantom - a swirly mist or perhaps a fog and is not real and so everything has to be happening to no-one. if everything is happening to no-one then there is no owner and so these thoughts and feelings are not happening to a someone but to no-one.

Shit.. I think I might have got this... Will Look through the day and respond later to the other queries

Col

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Tue Jan 24, 2012 3:27 pm


No. But there does seem to be an inextricable relationship between the 'I" construct of thoughts and feelings that is labeled Colin and a particular body.
Well yes, there needs to be neurons, organs, nerves etc etc for thoughts and feelings to occur. Does this collection of organs neurons and nerves constitute , or contain, a self?
These thoughts and feelings just happen and seem to come from nowhere. In the sense that they occur and are processed by the "character" called Colin also made up of thoughts and feelings who then has thoughts and feelings about thoughts and feelings . So all that is happening in reality are thoughts and feelings referring to thoughts and feelings in an endless referential loop.
If Colin is just a character thoughts and feelings, how can he process anything? how can thoughts and feelings process anything What is doing the processing?



Shit.. I think I might have got this... Will Look through the day and respond later to the other queries
Col
Yes, I think you are close. Keep looking!

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Mon Jan 30, 2012 12:42 am

hey colin, you still around?

Youre so close, dont give up now!!

neil

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Tue Jan 31, 2012 3:23 pm

Hi Neel,

I am - sorry - was unable to get internet access for a few days. I am on the move allot at the moment and changing locations regularly.

CTK1 wrote:My thoughts and feelings give me the illusion of being the chooser which is almost indistinguishable from actually being the chooser when it comes to living a life. I cannot stop my thoughts - they occur regardless.
Give who the illusion of being the chooser?
Give my character the illusion of being chooser so in effect give no-one the illusion of being chooser.

CTK1 wrote:Do I direct them - well sometimes I do. When I am writing this they come out of my head in a manner consistent with answering the questions posed by you. If they were not directed on this task then what i write here would be gobbledegook.
Ok, who directs the thoughts?
No idea. I guess no-one as it is just thoughts about thoughts in a continuous cycle
Look at the process of making a decision. Raise your right arm. Were there thoughts about raising your arm?
Yes.
Are these thoughts you or are they just thoughts? ?
They are not me they are thoughts

Really look at the thoughts that come up, see if they are some special kind of thought, or if they are just thoughts with an "I" tag on them. Why did thoughts of raising your arm occur at this point in time?
Nope just thoughts. I guess thoughts about raising my arm came up because printed words appeared on the computer which put this in mind.

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Tue Jan 31, 2012 10:44 pm

What you said there is good clear stuff.

Seems like you are almost there. It might be time for you to do a bit of a rant about what is happening with you right now, how you see experience unfolding now? And also talk a bit about what the self is, and whether there is one, in one form or another?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Fri Oct 12, 2012 5:00 pm

Hello - I know it has been a long time since I have responded here. I don't have any excuses but I would like to continue now if you are willing?

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Fri Oct 12, 2012 9:16 pm

hey, hows it going?

I am happy to continue with you if you like. Or were you looking for a different guide?

If you are happy to carry on with me as a guide, give me a run down of where you are with all of this.

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Sat Oct 13, 2012 10:59 am

Yo Neeel. All is well. Happy to stick with you. Ok run down on where I am..... That's a tough one.. Let me give it a go....

Ok - so I think intellectually I get this no self thing. Experientially - I do no think I have experienced anything and so as this is not an intellectual knowing ( as I understand it intellectually - ha ha !) then I guess I do not get it!

Overwhelmingly I have a sensation of - "Ok there is no self - So what?" Other than it being very useful to be able to not identify with thoughts and feelings if you so choose (which is very useful - but that is nothing new to me) what else is this....?

In addition - when I read through this forum I see - perhaps wrongly - alot of "THE TRUTH" . What I mean by that is it seems that you guys think that you have somehow got "THE TRUTH". In general I am suspicious of "THE TRUTH". I am biased towards thinking about what is useful or what works as opposed to what is THE TRUTH. One of the things that comes across in this forum is the idea of "the end of seeking" and that this "end of seeking" equates to freedom. That is true if you are attached to a result but if you are not attached to a result "seeking" can continue and is fun !! Advocating that mankind ends its quest for knowledge as this forum appears to do also seems somewhat odd and possibly worrying. Another worry about the no self thing is that with no self there is also no do'ing. If there is no do'ing then why fight against injustice - everything will just happen as it is supposed to right? I find that worrying also...

But somehow - actually particularly because of MArk Thywarton's thread - i think there is something to get here that I might not get and that might have utility. By the way - I am generally curious and read all kind of things and not because I expect to actually get anything from it but just because I am curious. In other words - I am not results focused - I am process focused.

In case I did not mention it in this thread - I am a Landmark Education graduate -10-12 years ago. Mark seems to think that this can get in the way of getting this..

Thanks for working with me again :-)

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Sat Oct 13, 2012 1:44 pm

Ok - so I think intellectually I get this no self thing. Experientially - I do no think I have experienced anything and so as this is not an intellectual knowing ( as I understand it intellectually - ha ha !) then I guess I do not get it!
What do you expect experiencing no self to be like?


Overwhelmingly I have a sensation of - "Ok there is no self - So what?" Other than it being very useful to be able to not identify with thoughts and feelings if you so choose (which is very useful - but that is nothing new to me) what else is this....?


"ok, So what" was also my immediate reaction. What else is this? A deeper understanding of how things are? Greater clarity? Are you saying you are only in it for what you can get ?( not meant to be disparaging, I can relate to that too)
In addition - when I read through this forum I see - perhaps wrongly - alot of "THE TRUTH" . What I mean by that is it seems that you guys think that you have somehow got "THE TRUTH". In general I am suspicious of "THE TRUTH". I am biased towards thinking about what is useful or what works as opposed to what is THE TRUTH. One of the things that comes across in this forum is the idea of "the end of seeking" and that this "end of seeking" equates to freedom. That is true if you are attached to a result but if you are not attached to a result "seeking" can continue and is fun !! Advocating that mankind ends its quest for knowledge as this forum appears to do also seems somewhat odd and possibly worrying. Another worry about the no self thing is that with no self there is also no do'ing. If there is no do'ing then why fight against injustice - everything will just happen as it is supposed to right? I find that worrying also...
Its good to be suspicious of "the truth", this is why we dont ask you to just believe, rather that you see it for yourself. I am wary of answering your other questions, as this is not meant to be a back and forth discussion, but rather me pointing and you looking. Take a look at your questions. Are they relevant as to whether its true that there is a separate self or not? Ie, it seems to me they are questions about "how things are if no self is true" rather than questions about "is no self true", if that makes sense. We want to be investigating whether its true or not, not investigating what it would mean if no self is actually true.


But somehow - actually particularly because of MArk Thywarton's thread - i think there is something to get here that I might not get and that might have utility. By the way - I am generally curious and read all kind of things and not because I expect to actually get anything from it but just because I am curious. In other words - I am not results focused - I am process focused.

In case I did not mention it in this thread - I am a Landmark Education graduate -10-12 years ago. Mark seems to think that this can get in the way of getting this..
I have no idea about this. Perhaps you can outline what landmark education is, and why you think it will stop you from seeing this.

So, Colin, do you exist? Is there a Colin anywhere except in thoughts about Colin?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Sun Oct 14, 2012 1:18 pm

What do you expect experiencing no self to be like?
I honestly have no idea other than that I expect to know it when it is experienced. That is the sense I pick up from this forum is that you will know it when it is experienced.
ok, So what" was also my immediate reaction. What else is this? A deeper understanding of how things are? Greater clarity? Are you saying you are only in it for what you can get ?( not meant to be disparaging, I can relate to that too)
The answer to that has to be Yes I guess - in that I can't see any other reason that I would be in it. What other reason might there be?
Its good to be suspicious of "the truth", this is why we dont ask you to just believe, rather that you see it for yourself. I am wary of answering your other questions, as this is not meant to be a back and forth discussion, but rather me pointing and you looking. Take a look at your questions. Are they relevant as to whether its true that there is a separate self or not? Ie, it seems to me they are questions about "how things are if no self is true" rather than questions about "is no self true", if that makes sense. We want to be investigating whether its true or not, not investigating what it would mean if no self is actually true.
Fair enough. I am digressing here for sure.
I have no idea about this. Perhaps you can outline what landmark education is, and why you think it will stop you from seeing this.
I am not sure what about it might stop me from seeing it - that was something MArk wrote. It is a course that changed my life and amongst any other things made me realise that I had a lot more choice than I realised. IT is a very powerful course. But overall prob not relevant to this discussion. I only mentioned it because of what Mark wrote..
So, Colin, do you exist? Is there a Colin anywhere except in thoughts about Colin?
Does the personality "Colin" exist as something real. ? Real defined as "not conceptual" . The answer to that is NO - Colin is made up of thoughts about thoughts about thoughts ad infinitum.. Is there a body/mind identified with a label - Colin - Yes.. and.......... So What?

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Mon Oct 15, 2012 4:13 pm

I honestly have no idea other than that I expect to know it when it is experienced. That is the sense I pick up from this forum is that you will know it when it is experienced.
Its not exactly an experience, its more of a seeing. For example, seeing that you arent doing your thoughts, that they are automatic and spontaneous. This seeing may or may not lead to various experiences, but thats not the important thing.


Does the personality "Colin" exist as something real. ? Real defined as "not conceptual" . The answer to that is NO - Colin is made up of thoughts about thoughts about thoughts ad infinitum.. Is there a body/mind identified with a label - Colin - Yes.. and.......... So What?
Is the body/mind a person? A self?

From what you wrote here , it seems you have seen it. But if you had seen it, you wouldnt be asking me questions about what it means, it would all be obvious to you.

So, maybe you understand it, have even had vague glimpses of it, but have not seen it clearly.


Are you in charge of thinking your thoughts ? Do you choose what thoughts to think? Can you predict your next thought?

Are you in charge of walking? Do you control the body, move each muscle at the right time in the correct order?

Are you in charge of breathing? Do you make breathing happen, process the oxygen, move it around the body?

Are you in charge of digestion?

Are you in charge of hearing?

What are you in charge of?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Tue Oct 16, 2012 12:04 am

Hi Neeeel

The only thing that can be said is:

Inside of the thing that is labelled "I" or "Me" their is an occurrence that is labelled thought. That thought says that the only available truth to these questions is that :

Things exist ,Thoughts exist and Stuff happens

extrapolating back to "I" .........

an individual body/mind exists which thinks and stuff happens....

The thinking that occurs appears to be happening to the individual body and so thinking becomes self referential particularly as a result of physical sensations that occur - like pain or pleasure... Arising from this is a sense of ownership or I'ness.

I can see that it is not possible to prove that the I exists other than as a conceptual idea or a thought - and therefore I guess it can be concluded that there is NO I... or perhaps more accurately - it is not possible for a real" I" to be discerned.. and therefore to assume that a real "I' can or might be discerned would be a significant leap of faith..

MY thinking (I) is all about thinking about the utility of things.. I function in that way -

My I is screaming why can I not see this other than intellectually - in other words my I won't let me see this It screams- "what is the use of their being no I !!" "What is the value" !

I say to myself - what does it mean for me to really see this? To sit quietly in the space of the knowledge that their is NO I and all that that entails. Frankly I guess it is a little scary because it feels that I would need to give up everything - I guess my entire philosophy of " I will try it on and if it works I will keep wearing it" A philosophy that has been very useful to me and which has made my life pretty great most of the time. It is a philosophy that allows me to say and mean it - that I can seek and keep seeking because I don't need an answer ! I am not looking for an answer - I just like the idea that there could be one and if there is not it is exciting to learn and think about such things... Life could be utterly meaningless and then again it might not be.. and so what !
To really sit in this idea of NO I - I have to give up all of that - because all of that assumes some distinctiveness , some individuality some relativism.. some possibility.. This NO I to truly see it and know it to be true must be rather bizarre because it means that everything is determined, there is no possibility, everything is just happening, free will does not exist and I am just like a machine that experiences and thinks and none of it is mine or controlled its just all happening... That seems very frightening to me... Maybe that is why I am resistant to seeing..

Anyway - sorry for the rant....

Okeydokely..


Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Tue Oct 16, 2012 12:54 am

The only thing that can be said is:

Inside of the thing that is labelled "I" or "Me" their is an occurrence that is labelled thought. That thought says that the only available truth to these questions is that :

Things exist ,Thoughts exist and Stuff happens

extrapolating back to "I" .........

an individual body/mind exists which thinks and stuff happens....

The thinking that occurs appears to be happening to the individual body and so thinking becomes self referential particularly as a result of physical sensations that occur - like pain or pleasure... Arising from this is a sense of ownership or I'ness.
Ok, all this is thinking about no self, and in no way is it actually LOOKING to see if its true.


I can see that it is not possible to prove that the I exists other than as a conceptual idea or a thought - and therefore I guess it can be concluded that there is NO I... or perhaps more accurately - it is not possible for a real" I" to be discerned.. and therefore to assume that a real "I' can or might be discerned would be a significant leap of faith..
Stop with the logic and deduction. Do you SEE that the "I" doesnt exist outside of a thought? If you dont see it, then where does the "I" exist? Where do you see the "I" existing? Honest answers, not what you think I want to here, or looking through the lens of no I, but what you actually believe the "I" is and does.


MY thinking (I) is all about thinking about the utility of things.. I function in that way -

My I is screaming why can I not see this other than intellectually - in other words my I won't let me see this It screams- "what is the use of their being no I !!" "What is the value" !
You cant see it because you are not looking. You are thinking about the subject, coming to conclusions, deducing and using logic.

Heres a list of questions I asked in my last post which you didnt seem to answer ( maybe you did, but I cant see the answers anywhere)


Are you in charge of thinking your thoughts ? Do you choose what thoughts to think? Can you predict your next thought?

Are you in charge of walking? Do you control the body, move each muscle at the right time in the correct order?

Are you in charge of breathing? Do you make breathing happen, process the oxygen, move it around the body?

Are you in charge of digestion?

Are you in charge of hearing?

What are you in charge of?

I want you to LOOK at reality for the answer to each question. So , for question 1, you would observe thoughts as they come up, and see if theres an "I" thats doing them. Look and see if you have a selection of thoughts to choose from, or if the thought is already there. Look and see if you can predict your next thought

For question 2, walking, you would observe while you are walking and see if you are doing any of it. Are you controlling the muscles? If so , how? Is it that theres a self moving the legs, or do the legs seem to just move?

And so on, for each question. Remember LOOKING, not thinking about

I say to myself - what does it mean for me to really see this? To sit quietly in the space of the knowledge that their is NO I and all that that entails. Frankly I guess it is a little scary because it feels that I would need to give up everything - I guess my entire philosophy of " I will try it on and if it works I will keep wearing it" A philosophy that has been very useful to me and which has made my life pretty great most of the time. It is a philosophy that allows me to say and mean it - that I can seek and keep seeking because I don't need an answer ! I am not looking for an answer - I just like the idea that there could be one and if there is not it is exciting to learn and think about such things... Life could be utterly meaningless and then again it might not be.. and so what !
To really sit in this idea of NO I - I have to give up all of that - because all of that assumes some distinctiveness , some individuality some relativism.. some possibility.. This NO I to truly see it and know it to be true must be rather bizarre because it means that everything is determined, there is no possibility, everything is just happening, free will does not exist and I am just like a machine that experiences and thinks and none of it is mine or controlled its just all happening... That seems very frightening to me... Maybe that is why I am resistant to seeing..
Again, this is all just thoughts about, predictions about what it will be like, when you can have no idea. Can you know that what you wrote above is true? That that is what it will be like? When you were 5, was it this way for you? Is it this way for a dog ?
Its a way to stop doing stuff, because you "already know". Fear comes up and says "Oh no, you cant do that, because it will be a certain way, and you dont like it like that "
Take a look at the fear. Allow it to be there. Look for the entity that is doing it. Is there one, or is it just there? Look for the connections between the thoughts and the fear. Are the thoughts the stimuli for the fear?

Anyway - sorry for the rant....
dont worry, rants are good, they show me where you are with all this.


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 21 guests