Ok here goes again...
What is the 'your' in 'your' statement? ( or indeed in this one?). It refers to something belonging to something. In language it is impossible to lose the "I' or "your" or to move away from this sense of 'belonging too'. If it is happening in my mind/body then this distinguishes my mind/body from your mind/body OR one mind/ body from another. In that sense there is differentiation. The itch occurs to 'this mind/body' which is separate to 'that mind/ body' This is what I meant in my statement to Robin that you quote. it is still a unique body/mind machine communicating with another unique body/mind machine. Their are separate thoughts and feelings in each and we call these thoughts and feelings and the remembering of previous thoughts and feelings the "I" or "character" . These thoughts and feelings occur in reality and so arguably the "I" exists in reality or more precisely thoughts and feelings about the "I" exist in reality. What it is true to say is that this "I' is not fixed or unalterable. It is all natural biological processes of course. These don't occur to no-one - they occur to a specific body/mind machine with the label 'some-one". I can say that they occur to no-one , in the sense that it is to the idea of a someone made up of thoughts and feelings about it rather than something solid and real like a table. What is the test for reality here? A concept about a new building in the mind is not real in the sense that it does not hold real physical space but it is real as a concept. Only with the concept in mind first will we have the possibility of a drawing, a computer rendition, a model and then the building itself occupying physical space. It is true to say that unlike a building a character or 'I" cannot hold real physical space on its own other than in a body and so remains a concept.itches occur, but do they occur to a separate self? Is this a sticking point for you, that things appear located in this body? I read over the whole thread again and you said earlier
"So in reality there is a body mind machine experiencing and that is it. My body mind machines still has separate and different experiences to yours. It is still your body -mind machine+operating system (called Robin) writing to my body mind machine+ operating system (called Col)"
The reason it occurs in your body and not someone elses is because all the physical apparatus is in your body and not anyone elses. Im sure you realise this. But the question we are asking is, inside all the physical apparatus that is in your body, is there a separate, controlling self? Or is it all just natural biological processes, occuring to no-one?
Thoughts and feelings ARE something - they occur in reality The "I" is made up of thoughts and feelings therefore the "I" is something and appears in reality as a concept created of thoughts and feelings. It is not physically real if that is indeed the test for reality here? My thoughts and feelings give me the illusion of being the chooser which is almost indistinguishable from actually being the chooser when it comes to living a life. I cannot stop my thoughts - they occur regardless. Do I direct them - well sometimes I do. When I am writing this they come out of my head in a manner consistent with answering the questions posed by you. If they were not directed on this task then what i write here would be gobbledegook. But yes - they appear to come from no-where but they do seem to have an inextricable relationship with 'this body/mind machine' and not 'that body/mind machine'. I do identify more with the 'observer' than with the original 'character' and if there is something that this LU process has taught me is that identifying with the observer or any potential observer of the observer is as much a fallacy as identifying with the 'I' or 'character'. Although, identifying with the observer in my experience has tended to provide more utility. So if my thoughts tell me to be frightened - my observer says ah - what is happening in reality? It then says well you have a physical sensation which you label fear. It then says is there a use in feeling this right now? That process often allows me to disregard thoughts and emotions which might negatively impact on me or stop me taking an action. I don't stop having the thought or emotion but considering its utility frees me up to take action that can then dispel the thought or emotion. So I guess i am hung up on the idea of 'usefulness'. What is the use in not identifying with 'the observer', the observer of the observer' ad infinitum' ? What else can I identify with? There is nothing else to identify with and what is the use in identifying with nothing? Perhaps this is my 'I' attempting to defend it's position but it seems like an impasse to me.Ok, so it looks like you have seen through the illusion.
Reading this thread back though, it seems like you are still identifying with something. It seems like you feel like you are the thing that chooses what to do, the decision maker, the one who looks at all the input and decides on the best course of action, the observer. Am I correct in this?
Anyhow - over to you.
Thanks for taking the time.. I feel like I am a hard nut to crack.LOL ;-)
Colin

