realizing selflessness

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:12 pm

P.S. It occurs to me that sometimes the crying baby needs to be fed or needs its diaper changed or needs a nap. But once its needs are taken care of—or while its needs are being taken care of—it can be held tenderly and lovingly.

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Fri Nov 20, 2026 3:09 am

Not sure what’s going on with me.

At the meeting, I’d thought I was feeling relatively okay or neutral, but I realized toward the end that I was bored, and in my experience, boredom is related to depression, and I recently ran across the rather obvious insight that boredom is a species of aversion.

Right after I left the meeting, I was presented with a “life administration” chore that spawned a strong reaction of resistance and unhappiness. Then I was trying to see if I could figure out what you'd been saying to me about the room labeled “want” and looking at my nonacceptance of suffering, but I wasn’t sure, and that was frustrating.

I thought of an Angelo video I'd watched earlier today, “A Simple Approach to Settling Your Nervous System” (which doesn’t seem like quite the right title for it), in which he suggested that when you’re feeling “contracted” or uncomfortable or confused, ask yourself, “What is it I really don't want to feel right now?” or “What thought do I really not want to see right now?”
Is that anywhere in the vicinity of where you were pointing me?

I feel like shit at the moment, and my own recent advice to myself would be to embrace the shitty feelings like a mother embraces her baby.
So let’s pause for a moment and try that . . .
Yeah, okay, there’s something to that . . .
It feels like my arms are the mothering part, wrapping around the rest of me, which is the crying infant. And I naturally started rocking.
Is that anywhere in the vicinity of where you were pointing me?

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5870
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby vinceschubert » Fri Nov 20, 2026 4:50 am

Is that anywhere in the vicinity of where you were pointing me?
Yes, yes, yes.
Do you 'get' that the nurturing mother is acceptance?
Because she has no sense of self/is entirely with/in the baby; there is no self-consideration happening.
i like the baby analogy because of feeling protected, the warmth, the cosiness, & safety. This baby can be totally uninhibited. Spontaneous. Authentic. (not that it thinks about any of this)
That baby is you (i know "that's obvious")
Then I was trying to see if I could figure out what you'd been saying to me about the room labeled “want” and looking at my nonacceptance of suffering, but I wasn’t sure, and that was frustrating.
You're not going to figure it out. It's not cerebral.
You're looking for a vague feeling that has a hint of resonance (with ??)
"Not sure.." is good. (= not cerebral)
"frustration" is good. It's the energy of wanting. Of course you would exchange that for the sense of satisfaction that a conclusion promises. ..but they're empty promises.
he suggested that when you’re feeling “contracted” or uncomfortable or confused, ask yourself, “What is it I really don't want to feel right now?” or “What thought do I really not want to see right now?”
Is that anywhere in the vicinity of where you were pointing me?
It's heading in the 'right direction', but it's overreach. Start with "in my current experiencing, is there (even a vague) feeling that there is 'something' underneath the obvious (what arises - surface stuff)
Once we 'lock on' to the 'something', we can issue an invitation for the actual to either reveal itself or simply take a holiday. (a holiday because given the right conditions it will return - albeit in a different form)
Yeah, great, I just have to suffer through whatever is presented. I have no choice but to live through all the pain. Terrific.
That's true, but it will be experienced differently once acceptance clears the way. (pushes the old stories into the background.)
mere intellectual understanding
This doesn't exist exclusively. If you start with that story (intellectual understanding) and look for the heretofore unseen/unrecognized sensations, you will find ...

v
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Fri Nov 20, 2026 2:37 pm

Thanks for your message.

Last night, I wanted to skip our usual twenty-minute late-night sit because I felt like I would just sit there and cry, and anyway, my husband had had an “extra” sit in the evening with his online zendo, so I didn’t feel like I’d be cheating him out of sitting time. At first, he agreed, but then he suggested that maybe, for my sake, we should at least do ten minutes. I thought he was probably right.

I sat in my usual place on the couch and hugged a pillow and cried, with the sense of embracing my shitty feelings like a mother embracing her baby. That was good. Partway through, my husband, sitting next to me on the couch, gently put a hand on my back.

Before that, he had realized I might feel oppressed by the chore he had mentioned, and he said it was okay if I didn’t do it then. I didn’t see how it would ever feel any less oppressive and didn’t want it hanging over my head, so I said I’d at least get a start on it. We ended up doing most of what needed to be done, but I was very grateful that he had recognized how it might feel to me. And his saying I didn’t need to do it then lightened up the demand-resistance.

Later on, we dug up a computer file from almost ten years ago, when we lived in a place with colder, darker, longer winters and he’d decided to keep a journal chronicling my winter depression to help us understand it better and be more alert to it in the future. He wanted to add to it this year.

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Fri Nov 20, 2026 9:08 pm

Then I was trying to see if I could figure out what you'd been saying to me about the room labeled “want” and looking at my nonacceptance of suffering, but I wasn’t sure, and that was frustrating.
You're not going to figure it out. It's not cerebral.
You're looking for a vague feeling that has a hint of resonance (with ??)
"Not sure.." is good. (= not cerebral)
"frustration" is good. It's the energy of wanting. Of course you would exchange that for the sense of satisfaction that a conclusion promises. ..but they're empty promises.
I’m confused, and it doesn’t seem like it’s in a possibly productive, koan-like way.
I don’t need to “figure out” wanting or suffering or awakening; I just want to figure out what you’re trying to say.
I’m fine with looking for something that is “not cerebral” and is “a vague feeling,” but a vague feeling about what?
And are you saying that “‘frustration’ is good” because “it’s the energy of wanting” so this is an example of wanting that I can examine?
I have plenty of experiences of wanting. Do I need to examine this particular type of wanting—wanting to understand what you’re saying—or will any sort of wanting do?
Should I focus on wanting awakening and/or wanting not to suffer?

Start with "in my current experiencing, is there (even a vague) feeling that there is 'something' underneath the obvious (what arises - surface stuff)
Once we 'lock on' to the 'something', we can issue an invitation for the actual to either reveal itself or simply take a holiday. (a holiday because given the right conditions it will return - albeit in a different form)
So, yes. Underneath, say, last night’s strongly negative reaction to a chore I had to do, there certainly seems to be “something” else going on, something more general, with a long history, possibly related to demand-resistance. But that’s all I’ve got at the moment. Is that enough for now?
So then I invite whatever is underneath there to reveal itself now or wait until the next time it gets triggered in some form?

Re: whether I can see that there’s no chooser, I said:
I suppose I can see cognitively that it’s all conditioned arising, but mere intellectual understanding doesn’t seem to be helpful.
And you said:
mere intellectual understanding
This doesn't exist exclusively. If you start with that story (intellectual understanding) and look for the heretofore unseen/unrecognized sensations, you will find ...
So, here, you’re inviting me to look at “heretofore unseen/unrecognized sensations” related to there being no chooser? or just in general?

Yeah, great, I just have to suffer through whatever is presented. I have no choice but to live through all the pain. Terrific.
That's true, but it will be experienced differently once acceptance clears the way. (pushes the old stories into the background.)
OK. That makes some sense.

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Sat Nov 21, 2026 4:07 pm

Maybe I unnecessarily confuse myself by reading your stories (which, of course, might not be precisely what you’d want to convey to me where I am now) and watching the recordings of your old Zoom meetings, watching Angelo’s videos, and browsing through other people’s LU threads. But anyway, it feels like there are too many things in my head now about what to do when I notice suffering.

I’m even getting confused just about your suggestions specifically for me:
(1) One suggestion was to examine bodily sensations in minute detail.
(2) But then you invited me to notice whether “these sensations might be part of an expression, rather than simply something to examine” and then
(3) “even if something wants to be said,” to examine “what happens in response to that impulse”—i.e., your recent theme of examining reactions to reactions.
(4) Another suggestion (which actually wasn’t so much from you as from another regular at the Zoom meetings) was to let the suffering fully play out in a sort of temper tantrum.
(5) You also invited “a gentle curiosity about what happens when even that desperate wanting is allowed to be here, without becoming another problem to solve,” and this gave rise to my remembering Thich Nhat Hanh’s image of embracing difficult emotions like a mother embracing her baby.
(6) And then there are your most recent invitations to examine the room labeled “want” and look for “a vague feeling that has a hint of resonance (with ??)” (but I have no idea what to do with that) and
(7) to look for even a vague sense of something underneath what’s obvious and invite it to reveal itself. (Maybe that’s basically the same thing as #2.)

Then, of course, there’s the strategy of trying to find practical remedies for the pain that’s getting a layer of suffering added onto it. E.g., especially if at least part of what I’m dealing with at the moment is seasonal depression, I can consider whether I should be spending more time in the morning under the light I bought for this purpose, getting more exercise, adjusting my medication, or trying to get more sleep (or less sleep; these things are confusing). But the general issue of how to approach suffering remains.

Could you perhaps help me narrow this down to one or two go-to approaches for right now? That would be really helpful, I think. (Or, of course, you might come at this from some other direction I haven’t anticipated.)

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Sun Nov 22, 2026 12:21 am

Misc. things:

(1) Today has not been so laden with suffering as the previous couple of days were. It’s hard to tell to what degree that’s because fewer first arrows came at me and to what degree it’s because I was adding fewer second and third arrows. I don't think I was consciously doing anything in particular to address suffering.

(2) Noticed my grumpiness when spouse asked me to do something while I was doing something else and when I thought he should perfectly well be able to do the thing without my help. My reaction seemed inordinate, and it seems like one of those places where there’s “something” underneath.

(3) This is related to the question you raised a while back about the difference between thoughts and sensations, and it seems important:

During our afternoon sit, I was mostly noticing seeing, hearing, and feeling—y’know, with plenty of excursions into thinking. Toward the very end of the sit, I was exploring the sense that just as “I” don’t produce sense perceptions and they just happen based on the location and position of this body and all sorts of conditions that “I” have no control over, maybe the same goes for thoughts. I mean, theoretically, I understand that this is in fact the case, but I was trying to really experience that “I” don’t produce thoughts any more than “I” produce sensations and to see that thoughts, like sensations, just happen based on all sorts of conditions that “I” have no control over.

During our evening sit about an hour later (as part of evening prayer with our community), I continued that exploration and noted that I probably don’t need to take thoughts any more “personally” than I take sense perceptions. Both sense perceptions and thoughts might provide information that should be acted on, but thoughts probably don’t have any greater status than sense perceptions in that regard. And I was playing with how experiencing the thoughts that arise is no more “personal” than seeing the vase of flowers on the altar.

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5870
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby vinceschubert » Sun Nov 22, 2026 7:25 am

Hi K, I've been reflecting on where our conversation went into abstract land, and I think I can make my pointing simpler.

When I asked you about wanting, I wasn't asking what you want, why you want it, or whether wanting something to disappear is different from wanting something to appear.

I was inviting you to discover what wanting actually feels like.

Take that familiar “I don't wanna suffer anymore!”

When it arises naturally, leave aside for a moment what the suffering is about.

What is the physical experience of that wanting?

Is there tightening, reaching, pushing away, restlessness, an ache? Something else entirely?

Don't take those suggestions as things you should find. I'm interested in what you actually notice.

And here's the subtle part.

How do you feel about the wanting itself?

Is it welcome? Unwelcome? Exhausting? Is there an impulse to make even the wanting stop?

That's the relationship I'm interested in.

Not the story about wanting, but the immediate experience of it and what happens in response to it.

There's no need to manufacture the feeling, intensify it, or try to change your relationship to it.

Just a little curiosity when it happens to be there.

Love,
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Sun Nov 22, 2026 1:52 pm

Thank you for the clarification about examining what wanting actually feels like and the response to the wanting.

I just woke up and am not feeling any strong wanting at the moment, but I've filed this for when it comes up. (I find myself hoping that being alert for the next bout of wanting might tend to calm the wanting, just as being alert for the next thought to arise tends to calm the thoughts.)

See ya later in my today and very early in your tomorrow.

With love & gratitude,
K

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Sun Nov 22, 2026 4:31 pm

I was inviting you to discover what wanting actually feels like.
It was probably less than an hour after my previous post that some noteworthy wanting came up.

Got a note from my boss for my editing job saying that he did, after all, want me to do some work that he’d told me I didn’t have to do, and it needs to be done by tomorrow. This is while I have lots of work to do for my class, including some grading I’ve been procrastinating on for too long, and I had been glad to have the editing out of the way so that I could focus on my class.

So there is annoyance, and there is wanting not to have to do this editing work, as well as wanting not to have to do the school work that had seemed a little more manageable when it was going to be the only thing I had to think about.

(I seem to experience a lot of negative wanting, by which I mean wanting for things not to have appeared—in particular, wanting not to have demands placed on me.)
When it arises naturally, leave aside for a moment what the suffering is about.

What is the physical experience of that wanting?
First thing I notice is, as usual, tightness in the throat and constriction of breathing. There’s also a bit of an impulse to cry but not so much as there often is in such situations. I had to make a point of looking in order to notice the tightness in the face, especially all around the eyes—up into the forehead and down into the cheeks. Maybe there’s also a sense of deflation and weariness. All of this put together feels like anger and resistance.
And here's the subtle part.

How do you feel about the wanting itself?

Is it welcome? Unwelcome? Exhausting? Is there an impulse to make even the wanting stop?

That's the relationship I'm interested in.

Not the story about wanting, but the immediate experience of it and what happens in response to it.

There's no need to manufacture the feeling, intensify it, or try to change your relationship to it.

Just a little curiosity when it happens to be there.
As for how I feel about the wanting itself, hmm . . .
I’m not sure I can separate that out very well.
But this whole structure of demand-resistance and anger at the way things are feels tiresome and like I’m being beaten down. OK, here come the tears in earnest.

And I suppose this is a new, meta-round of negative wanting. I want this to stop!
Back to the bodily sensations: Everything associated with crying: tears, the convulsions of sobbing, tightness in face.
And then the response to that wanting (though I’m not entirely sure I can tidily separate these things): More weariness, frustration, anger.
Some sense of wanting to pound my fists or shake my hands or something.
OK, letting myself do a bit of that.
Also notice some shaking my head back and forth, like: No, no, no, no!
And stronger sobbing.

Looking back at my list of seven approaches to suffering, I seem to have employed a lot of them here. But notably absent is embracing the suffering like a mother embracing her baby, so let’s take a moment for that . . .

More sobbing. Hugging a pillow. A little bit of rocking back and forth. Some sense of “It’s okay, my love. I’ll hold you. You can cry. I’m right here,” and being surrounded with warm, secure, tender love.

Each time I’ve had a good hard cry recently, I’ve thought of how the nausea due to food poisoning or a norovirus builds up to the point where you vomit and feel some relief, and then the nausea slowly builds again until you need to vomit again. I worry that I’m not actually purging the poison here and will just keep getting some relief for half a day or a day or two and then the suffering will slowly build up again, over and over and over, with no end in sight.

(P.S. Just checked email, and boss changed his mind again. He doesn’t need me to do that work.)


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 18 guests