hello!

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: hello!

Postby poppyseed » Sat Nov 14, 2026 4:03 pm

Hi Zach,
Thank you for sharing your spontaneous discovery! There's certainly no need to apologise for reporting something you've noticed outside an exercise :)
There is a sensation that thought called "me" or "I". No doubt the sensation is there--it is a glowing bright yellow that pulses. But, it is now clearly seen as impersonal. Thought comes in later and adds, "that feeling is me" and "I am here".
What exactly has become clear? Is there anything in the sensation itself that identifies an owner, or is ownership supplied by thought?
And does the seeming location of the sensation establish that it belongs to someone?

No doubt the sensation is there--it is a glowing bright yellow that pulses.
Let's look very carefully at this.
Is the glowing bright yellow actually a bodily sensation? Can a sensation have a colour?
Is there a sensation of pulsing accompanied by a mental image of glowing yellow? Or something else?

Please separate what is actually felt from what is seen or imagined.
And when thought says "this is me", what exactly is it referring to? The pulsing sensation, the yellow image, or something else?
Let's first establish what is actually experienced before drawing conclusions about what it means.
But, sometimes it feels like they conflict with rules about being honest with what is actually experienced.
I think there's a misunderstanding here. The LU categories are simply tools for describing experience, not rules about what you must find. We use labels such as colour, sound, sensation, taste, smell and thought simply to communicate about particular aspects of WHAT IS happening. They're useful pointers, not separate things existing independently and interacting with one another. There is an important distinction between reporting what is experienced and explaining how it happens. For example, you wrote:
It is clear that thought is creating the “imagined” sensation from past experiences because thought comes first and then the imagined sensation.
What was actually observed? A thought appeared, followed by an imagined sensation. But was thought actually observed creating that sensation (one label creating another label), or is that an explanation added afterwards?
Similarly, when you wondered whether sensations could experience other sensations, notice how language turns descriptions of experience into things that supposedly have abilities of their own. Can a label experience another label?
Notice how what seems to be “Zach" and his "world", the totality of his experience of all that is happening, is a creation of language, and words are the building blocks that create the story about it.

However... Remember the desktop icons analogy? An email icon is useful for accessing your email, but it isn't an actual envelope containing letters.
Similarly, the labels we use point to and describe particular aspects of experience, but they don't turn those aspects into separate entities with their own abilities or relationships.
The important thing is to recognise the empty nature of labels — that the word is not the experience it describes.
Let's keep using the labels as practical tools (icons), without mistaking them for what they point to :)
We're not trying to establish a new theory of reality. We're learning to distinguish what is actually happening from what thought says ABOUT it.
In each case, there is the same sequence of sensations (aside from imagined sensations beginning with thought)–a texture morphing from rough/spiky to round, followed by the same taste/smell of salt and butter.
Are you sure the same sensations are present in both cases?
Think of a traveller in the desert who sees what looks like an oasis in the distance.
The appearance is there — it isn't imaginary. But does that mean there is actually water to drink?
The seeming appearance of water and the presence of water aren't the same thing.
Now apply this to your experiment.
When imagining the taste of salt, what is actually present? Is there tasting, or is there a thought or mental image ABOUT tasting?
Just as the appearance of an oasis doesn't establish the presence of water, does the appearance of a thought about a sensation establish that the sensation itself is present?
Look at the actual experience, rather than what the appearance suggests.

Is the sensation you describe actually present, or are you comparing thoughts about sensations with sensations themselves?
Please check this while doing the experiment, not by remembering or reasoning about it afterwards.

Love
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Sat Nov 14, 2026 6:33 pm


Zach,
Thank you for sharing your spontaneous discovery! There's certainly no need to apologise for reporting something you've noticed outside an exercise :)
Ok thank you.
There is a sensation that thought called "me" or "I". No doubt the sensation is there--it is a glowing bright yellow that pulses. But, it is now clearly seen as impersonal. Thought comes in later and adds, "that feeling is me" and "I am here".
What exactly has become clear?
That sensation that thought describes as glowing bright yellow, warm in feeling, in the chest and head is not "me". It is just an impersonal sensation arising that thought says is me. I identified deeply with this because this is what remained (and grew brighter and became more expansive) when, in daily deep meditation, thoughts fell away and there was just feeling of peace and joy. After mediation, thought said this was "me" and was always there if looked for. Now, it is seen that this too is impersonal and thought is supplying the idea that this is a "me", it has a location in the "chest" and "head", and it has certain sensations associated with it.

Is there anything in the sensation itself that identifies an owner, or is ownership supplied by thought?
Ownership is supplied by thought. The sensation of color and movement are imagined by thought. The sensation of warmth is real, although I dont think it's like temperature. If its a thought, it is very powerful, all encompassing. Like the warm sun on the skin or the warmth all over during a hot bath.

And does the seeming location of the sensation establish that it belongs to someone?

It does not. Chest and head are concepts. Concepts are supplied by thought. Location implies a subject/object, and space between them. But it is seen that this information is not contained within sensation itself, only thought. It is especially subtle when thought masquerade as sensation.

No doubt the sensation is there--it is a glowing bright yellow that pulses.
Let's look very carefully at this.

Is the glowing bright yellow actually a bodily sensation? Can a sensation have a colour?
Is there a sensation of pulsing accompanied by a mental image of glowing yellow? Or something else?
Please separate what is actually felt from what is seen or imagined.

Glowing bright yellow is a thought imagining a bodily sensation.

And when thought says "this is me", what exactly is it referring to? The pulsing sensation, the yellow image, or something else?

It is referring to both the imagined color and the pulsing warm sensation. I feel if this pulsing warm sensation is imagined, it is extremely convincing. But, I'm not sure it makes any difference because it's clear it is impersonal amd not a "me".


you wrote:

It is clear that thought is creating the “imagined” sensation from past experiences because thought comes first and then the imagined sensation.
What was actually observed? A thought appeared, followed by an imagined sensation.
But was thought actually observed creating that sensation (one label creating another label), or is that an explanation added afterwards?

You're right. I can't assume causation. Thought did not create anything. How could it? What could demonstrate causation except more thought?

It seems like thought comes, then emotions or sensations follow it. But, it could be the other way around or they could have no relationship, only more thought assuming relationship. It is very subtle.


Similarly, when you wondered whether sensations could experience other sensations, notice how language turns descriptions of experience into things that supposedly have abilities of their own.
Can a label experience another label?

A label is a concept, a thought. Thought says a label can't experience anything just like a thought cant because "label" is just a thought.


In each case, there is the same sequence of sensations (aside from imagined sensations beginning with thought)–a texture morphing from rough/spiky to round, followed by the same taste/smell of salt and butter.
Are you sure the same sensations are present in both cases?
Think of a traveller in the desert who sees what looks like an oasis in the distance.
The appearance is there — it isn't imaginary.
But does that mean there is actually water to drink?
The seeming appearance of water and the presence of water aren't the same thing.
Now apply this to your experiment.

When imagining the taste of salt, what is actually present? Is there tasting, or is there a thought or mental image ABOUT tasting?

There is just a thought about tasting, a memory of what it tastes like.


Just as the appearance of an oasis doesn't establish the presence of water, does the appearance of a thought about a sensation establish that the sensation itself is present?
Look at the actual experience, rather than what the appearance suggests.

No, the thought does not establish the presence of sensation. Thought cannot establish or create anything. At best, thought is thought about sensation. Like, if a driver cuts me off in traffic, I may become angry. But, actually, without the story thought creates, all that really happened was the sensations associated with driving. Thought comes in and says, "that person cut you off. How dare they break the rules." Then, thought says, "you have every right to be angry". But, does thought create the sensation of tension in the head, which is what thought says is associated with anger? Or did the tension simply arise and thought associated it with the story it created about the driver? If the tension had not arisen, could thought convincely say "the driver made me angry"? Thought might instead say, "the driver is probably just absent minded and we all are that way sometimes". In other words the sensation of tension in the head does not contain information about its cause. Thought comes in, after the fact, and tries to connect things together.

A real shift here has occurred. It is seen that thought imagines a causal link between sensations. But the sensations themselves do not contain any such information.


Is the sensation you describe actually present, or are you comparing thoughts about sensations with sensations themselves?
Please check this while doing the experiment, not by remembering or reasoning about it afterwards.

The sensation is not actually present. Very subtle thoughts arise comparing thoughts about sensations with the sensations themselves.
Nothing is excluded.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: hello!

Postby poppyseed » Sun Nov 15, 2026 10:16 am

Hi Zach,
A real shift here has occurred. It is seen that thought imagines a causal link between sensations. But the sensations themselves do not contain any such information.
Wonderful!!! I'm very happy!
I want to reassure you that I don't doubt the shift you've described :). I'm not asking more questions because I think it wasn’t strong enough. Usually there is a "honeymoon period," and then what we call, "got it, lost it," might show up as untrue beliefs come up to be questioned. This can go on for months & years. This initial shift is irreversible, just as we can never go back to believing in Santa Claus or the Tooth Fairy. The euphoria around it is an altered state, but it passes. Then you will be back to your baseline experience, minus the me. Coming back to your former baseline state, minus the illusion that just fell away, will happen in every major belief that is seen through. I am sorry to disappoint, but you will never end up in a permanently altered state, a permanent high. It is always, “And now chop wood and carry water”.
So… The belief in a separate self is supported by many other assumptions — that there is an owner of experience, a thinker of thoughts, a controller of actions, a chooser of decisions, and so on. Even when the central illusion is recognised, some of these old assumptions may still feel convincing in everyday situations. That's why I'd like us to continue exploring them (if you are willing of course) – at least the major ones. Not to achieve another shift or maintain a particular state (which is not the point of this inquiry), but to look at the beliefs that have supported the illusion of a separate self and see whether they hold up in direct experience.
So, let’s have a look at the idea of control, choice and decisions :). Please explore the exercises below and report your findings! Remember that we’re looking for some kind of entity, a something, an ‘I’ which is doing the ‘choosing’. Remember we are not interested in “seems like” and “feels like” entities, but ones that could be described.

1. Hold a hand in front of you; palm turned down. Now turn the palm up. And down...and up and so on.
How is the movement controlled?
Does a thought control it?
Can a ‘controller’ or and entity that is choosing be located?
How is the decision made to turn the hand over?

Track any decision point when a thought MADE THE DECISION to turn the hand over.

2. Put two objects that you like in front of you (e.g. a cup of coffee and a glass of juice)
Step1. Look at drink A and at drink B. Think about their respective qualities, the things you like about them, compare and weigh the pros and cons of each. See if a preference is manifesting for one or the other.
Step2. Count to 5.
Step3. Choose one of the drinks. Pick it up and take a sip.

In step 1 when thinking about their respective qualities, did you ‘choose’ the qualities? Or did they kind of appear by themselves? If some preferences manifested, did you ‘choose’ these preferences? Or did they just pop up by themselves?
In step 2 when you counted to 5, if the preferences took the back seat while the numbers took the front seat, did you ‘choose’ this sequence of event? Did you ‘choose’ to shut down the preferences to give way to the counting? Did you directly experience an entity doing the ‘choosing’?
In step 3 where you made a choice, did anything arise that announced, ‘I am the chooser’? If so, what does it look like?


3. Please take me through a biggish decision that you made recently - not something very personal so you are able to share more details about your decision making...
How did it come to be? Consider all of the conditions that were necessary for it to happen. If any one of those conditions were different, would the outcome have been the same? How many of these conditions were outside of your influence? What was in your control (according to thought)?

Please take your time with each exercise! Repeat as many times as you need and then write the answers for all of them. Watch like a hawk. Don't go to thoughts, examine the actual experience. Do this as many times as you like, and each time inquire with the questions.

What would you like to look at next? Here are the usual places where “me” hides:
Attention/focus — what is it, what moves it, is there an observer
Time — past, future, waiting, becoming, “my life,” “my progress.”
Memory — “my childhood,” “my story,” “what happened to me”, how is it known that a ‘memory’ thought refers to something that has happened
Others — family, boss, friends, approval, conflict, being seen.
Emotions — fear, guilt, shame, pride, hurt, irritation, anger
Responsibility — caring for loved ones, work, decisions, consequences.
Awakening itself — “am I getting it?”, “will it last?”, “I need to go deeper.”
Where is Zach still hiding?

Love
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Sun Nov 15, 2026 5:45 pm

Hi rali,

I had another breakthrough this morning: thoughts are not evidence of a "me". I think I knew this intellectually before, but you really drove it home yesterday with the example of the man in the desert. I was talking with my wife this morning, asking her to probe me for what felt like remaining objections to why thought could be evidence of a "me", and she asked, "who objects?" And I said, "just another thought!" And it clicked. Thought is a perspective, not an absolute truth. It cannot be evidence of a "me".

I see you replied and I am digging into them now and will post a response today.
Nothing is excluded.

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Sun Nov 15, 2026 7:47 pm

let’s have a look at the idea of control, choice and decisions :). Please explore the exercises below and report your findings! Remember that we’re looking for some kind of entity, a something, an ‘I’ which is doing the ‘choosing’. Remember we are not interested in “seems like” and “feels like” entities, but ones that could be described.

1. Hold a hand in front of you; palm turned down. Now turn the palm up. And down...and up and so on.

How is the movement controlled?
Doing the exercise, thought says "what controller? It is spontaneous." Then, thought says "that's just a thought. I don't actually know. "
Does a thought control it?
No. It moves and then thought comments.
Can a ‘controller’ or and entity that is choosing be located?
No.
How is the decision made to turn the hand over?
Thought says, "who would decide? Movement happens without a doer or decider."
Track any decision point when a thought MADE THE DECISION to turn the hand over.

2. Put two objects that you like in front of you (e.g. a cup of coffee and a glass of juice)
Step1. Look at drink A and at drink B. Think about their respective qualities, the things you like about them, compare and weigh the pros and cons of each. See if a preference is manifesting for one or the other.

Step2. Count to 5.

Step3. Choose one of the drinks. Pick it up and take a sip.


In step 1 when thinking about their respective qualities, did you ‘choose’ the qualities? Or did they kind of appear by themselves?
Thought says, "who would choose the qualities?" And, "i think the qualities were always there. But, they were presumably selected over other qualities of the drinks. But nothing chose those qualities. It was like they were illuminated over other qualities and the illumination happened first."
If some preferences manifested, did you ‘choose’ these preferences? Or did they just pop up by themselves?
Thought says, " who would choose? Preferences arose spontaneously."
In step 2 when you counted to 5, if the preferences took the back seat while the numbers took the front seat, did you ‘choose’ this sequence of event? Did you ‘choose’ to shut down the preferences to give way to the counting? Did you directly experience an entity doing the ‘choosing’?
Thought says, "i followed your command. But, "i" is just another thought. Honestly, I dont have any idea how it happened. It just happened that way."

It is seen that the "i" who followed the command is a thought which arose as a justification for the action, not as a basis for it.
In step 3 where you made a choice, did anything arise that announced, ‘I am the chooser’? If so, what does it look like?
Thought says, "no, the concept of the chooser and free will was seen through when I had my initial awakening experience several years ago. It was seen clearly that doing happens without a doer, as thought happens without a thinker, and observing happens without an observer, and experiences happen without an experiencer."
3. Please take me through a biggish decision that you made recently - not something very personal so you are able to share more details about your decision making...
I made a recent purchase of an "orgone energy accumulation" device. It was biggish in the sense that it was costly and I had no prior experience with such a device, so i didn't know if it would actually work in the way described.
How did it come to be?
I was reading a biograhpical book about an engineer who worked on the Montauk project, a spin off of a project during ww2 to cloak aircraft from radar that resulted in a ship disappearing and reappeaering 200 miles away in an instant. The author mentioned William Reich and his concept of orgone energy accumulation devices the gov used to affect weather. Then, I remembered I had seen these devices sold on Etsy and other places. I love an experiment, especially involving unusual or esoteric technology. So, I researched who made a legitimate device, found a supplier, spoke with him, and made the order.
Consider all of the conditions that were necessary for it to happen. If any one of those conditions were different, would the outcome have been the same?
Thought says, "no. Causes come from prior causes." And, "i don't know. How could it be known? The conditions are never the same such that one condition could be varied, as a test."

Outside of thought, seeing and typing words happened, then the device was ordered. If the seeing and typing words didn't happen, the order would not have happened. How could it?
How many of these conditions were outside of your influence? What was in your control (according to thought)?
Thought says, "all conditions are outside control. Who would control?" And, "can thought influence a sensation?"

Outside of thought, seeing the words simply happened. Who would have chosen the book? Similarly, typing the words simply happened. The typing is spontaneously arising, always, even right now.
What would you like to look at next? Here are the usual places where “me” hides:
Attention/focus — what is it, what moves it, is there an observer
Time — past, future, waiting, becoming, “my life,” “my progress.”
Memory — “my childhood,” “my story,” “what happened to me”, how is it known that a ‘memory’ thought refers to something that has happened
Others — family, boss, friends, approval, conflict, being seen.
Emotions — fear, guilt, shame, pride, hurt, irritation, anger
Responsibility — caring for loved ones, work, decisions, consequences.
Awakening itself — “am I getting it?”, “will it last?”, “I need to go deeper.”

Where is Zach still hiding?
The grippiest places where an apparent "me" arises subtly are around the thoughts, "if I dont do X, I will be harmed." These thoughts produce a trap of an apparent me. Because they attach to a harm or fear, they appear more urgent and less scrutinized. The apparent "i" in them does not automatically get questioned. Instead, the focus is first on the alleged harm or fear.

The most traumatic experience after the initial awakening experience (the one several years ago) occurred when I tried to share it with others. I was invited to share during a group retreat. The invitee had told me she had experienced an "ego death" and asked me to share with the group about my experiences. Ordinarily, I would not share but this seemed like a group who could understand. I was asked about doership and long term goals and explained that there was no motivation to set goals as there was no "me" to set them, nor any "me" who could set things in motion to accomplish them, that "this" was just happening, perfectly, and there was nothing to add to it.

As I shared, some of the group strongly rejected my experience. Suddenly, there was a feeling of an "i" that needed protection and defending. Afterward, about a week later, the invitee who had claimed to have had an "ego death", had lunch with me. At this point, there had been such a looping of that experience that it appeared strongly there was an "i" who had hurt or offended and needed to apologize. So, that happened. Then, the invitee shared that she had discussed the situation with the others and had assured them no harm was intended. But, it still was believed that the understanding shared with the group was so far removed from their understanding that deep feelings of alienation and separation began to grow and grow, and have persisted since then. There became an apparent "i" which thought centers these feeling around, reinforcing the idea of an a real "i", and thought said, "if you believe this "me" is only apparent, you will harm more and be alone." Wanting to protect this apparent "me" (now treating it as real), doubt started.

Secondary to this, a similar experience happened with my father. This occurred shortly after the initial awakening experience began. I was with him while having the strong experience for the first time that there was no "i", and therefore no "doer". At the time, a strong urge to share this with him arose, but was met with deep resistance and what felt like a turning away. Feelings of deep alienation and separation arose and thought centered those feelings on an apparent "me", which reemforced the notion that there was a "me" which was "wrong" or "bad". This was such a powerful thought that it caused a serious doubt about whether "i" was real or apparent.

A third experience since the initial awakening experience occurred when I tried to find community in a zen center near me. The leader, a supposedly transmitted master, posted regularly on social media. His messaging always seemed so centered on responsibility toward others. One day, I responded pointedly, "who is responsible?" He replied, "i am responsible." I followed up:
"when bodhidharma was visited by his first disciple, he was asked to free the disciples mind of troubles. Bodhidharma asked the disciple to show him the troubled mind. But the disciple could not locate it. "There!" Exclaimed bodhidharma, "i have freed your mind." And the disciple was awakened. So, where is this "I" that is responsible for others?"

The leader simply replied with a "prayer," emoji and didn't reply further. Similar experiences happened during sangha with other members of the sangha during group break outs where we would discuss a teaching. Pointing to the absence of a "me" was met with all sort of feelings, ranging from confusion to outright anger and hostility toward an apparant "me", which again strongly re enforced the idea that a me existed and was causing harm. I left the sangha, and have not returned, feeling more confused, alienated and separated than before.

Talking with you has helped cleared that. It is seen that the doubt is just another thought, that tension in the chest is just a sensation, and that thought comes in later and adds "this tension is caused by the conflict "you" created and the "upset" "you" caused in questioning the identity of "others". But none of that is evidence that a "me" exists. Thank you so much for that clear pointing, Rali.

I think zach could still be subtly hiding in themes of "others", especially around approval, conflict, and being seen, emotions like "shame, guilt", and in responsibility, especially what happens when what is said feels like it produces harm in others or alienation in an apparent "self" .
Nothing is excluded.

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Sun Nov 15, 2026 9:07 pm

A meme for your amusement:

Image
Nothing is excluded.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: hello!

Postby poppyseed » Mon Nov 16, 2026 10:59 am

Hi Zach,
Thank you for sharing all of this so openly! I'm glad our conversation has helped you see those old doubts differently :)
I've noticed something else throughout your replies. You frequently say "thought says..." instead of simply saying "I think", "I chose" or "I decided".
There's nothing wrong with using "I", "me" or "my". They're useful conventions for communicating. Using these words doesn't create a separate self, just as avoiding them doesn't make one disappear :)
Seeing through the illusion doesn't require adopting a new way of speaking, behaving or living. Life continues, with plans, decisions, relationships, disagreements and responsibilities. The question is simply whether there's an independently existing "I" behind any of it.
Obviously there is no Zach who is right and observing what thought says and thought that is wrong – there is just THIS including the thought descriptions, which are based on previous conditioning and new ways – how thoughts relate to each other. It's all thoughts self-organising. I wonder if there's a subtle expectation here that, having seen through the illusion of Zach, life should now be lived by a different kind of Zach — one who doesn't set goals, make decisions, take responsibility or even use the word "I" :) Could this be another identity forming around the idea of "no-self"?
Remember, we're not trying to replace the old Zach with a new, improved "no-Zach". We're simply investigating whether there was ever a separate Zach running the show in the first place.
Nothing needs to be performed or maintained. Ordinary life can carry on as before.

So now back to your observations…
Thought says, "no. Causes come from prior causes." And, "i don't know. How could it be known? The conditions are never the same such that one condition could be varied, as a test."
Yes! I just wanted an example of a decision that you would normally consider that you’ve made. The point was to look entirely in thought content where cause and effect “live” and see that even there there’s no “you” making a decision. It was just one event leading to another, leading to another, with “actions” based on previous conditioning. The thought “decision is made” is layered on top of other thoughts/beliefs/descriptions of what has happened before.
Why does the wind blow? It just blows. Yes we can say it happens as a result of previous events but there’s no entity “wind” that does the blowing. There is no wind that decides to blow. It’s just language.
What is “moving of the hands” in DE? We’ve seen that it’s just a sensation, labelled “hands moving” + colour labelled “hands moving”.
So, what makes the sensations to appear? What makes seeing to appear? LOOK! Is there anything that causes anything to appear? Do cause and effect exist outside of thought content?
Thought comes to describe that things are happening and why they are happening, but in DE things are just happening. Is the description/explanation/label needed for things to happen?
I’m not saying that cause and effect are not useful – remember the analogy with the icons on your desktop. I’m saying that cause and effect are empty of inherent existence.

Something stood out in your description of the retreat:
There was no motivation to set goals as there was no "me" to set them, nor any "me" who could set things in motion to accomplish them, that "this" was just happening, perfectly, and there was nothing to add to it.
Does recognising that there is no separate self mean that goals, motivation, plans, preferences or responsibility must disappear? Does recognising the absence of a separate self mean that kindness, consideration for others, apologies or taking responsibility for actions must disappear?

Remember it’s not like the self died (e.g. an ego death) , it NEVER existed in the first place. There was no one (no Zach) that was fooled by the illusion and now he’s not. It’s very much a self-organised structure (in terms of cause and effect). Goals happened before without Zach just fine :)

Is it possible that you've been trying to live in a particular way because of what you've recognised? Is there an expectation that someone who has seen through the illusion should behave differently?
Now, something particularly interesting emerged from your experiences with the retreat group, your father and the Zen community:
If you believe this "me" is only apparent, you will harm more and be alone, that seems to be an important belief worth investigating. There are two approaches to it: one, looking for Zach, to the person that this experience is happening TO, the one that FEELS these emotions...and the other, to work with the actual sensations.
So…
When someone disagrees with you or feels hurt by something you've said, there may be uncomfortable sensations, thoughts about having done something wrong, and an urge to explain, apologise or defend yourself.
But where exactly is the separate "me" that needs defending?
And when the thought appears that without believing in a "me" you'll harm others or end up alone, what makes that thought true? Is it evidence of an actual self, or a prediction about what might happen (we can explore time)?

Of course, our actions have practical consequences, and caring for others remains important (icons on your desktop). We're not trying to deny any of that.

Now back to the second approach… Whenever a strong emotion arrives, try and deconstruct it down to bodily sensations. That is to say, see that certain sensations tend to be labelled in certain ways, e.g. the thought label “fear” may be habitually applied to a knot-like sensation in the stomach area. “Anxiety” may be the thought label for trembling hands and nausea, etc. They may vary for different people, so it helps to be aware of what it is for you. Can you give some examples of this from your experience?
So let’s work with “fear”. When ‘fear’ appears, close your eyes and do the following... Look at the label ‘fear’ itself. See the label/word ‘fear’ as a typewritten word
Does the label ‘fear’ know anything about fear, or is the word just a bunch of letters?
Is the label ‘fear’ itself fearful?
Can you find anyone/anything in the word itself that is fearful?

Then look at the sensation and ignore everything else but the sensation itself. Inquire into the sensation and ask if the sensation itself knows anything about ‘fear’. Does the sensation itself suggest in any way that it is fear or that it is fearful?
Can you find anyone or anything within or behind the sensation that is fearful?

When you have done this and if no one/no thing is found, then just sit with the sensation. Just breathe normally, notice the thoughts and images that appear and let them pass on by. Allow the sensation all the room it needs without pushing it aside or judging it. If it becomes too intense just take a couple of deep breaths into the sensation itself. If the sensation does not dissipate at all or only dissipates a little, that is okay, just notice it, without doing anything with it and just go about your day.
We are not trying to get rid of the sensation labelled ‘fear’ or the arising thoughts or images. We are only LOOKING to see what is actually appearing (ie thought, sensation, colour/image) as opposed to what thought is saying ABOUT what actually IS. Freedom comes from allowing whatever appears to appear without the need for it to be different or to leave. Perhaps the recognition doesn't require a new way of living at all. Perhaps ordinary life can simply continue, without the assumption of a separate entity running it.
What do you find?
Love
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Mon Nov 16, 2026 11:25 pm


Seeing through the illusion doesn't require adopting a new way of speaking, behaving or living. Life continues, with plans, decisions, relationships, disagreements and responsibilities. The question is simply whether there's an independently existing "I" behind any of it.
Obviously there is no Zach who is right and observing what thought says and thought that is wrong – there is just THIS including the thought descriptions, which are based on previous conditioning and new ways – how thoughts relate to each other. It's all thoughts self-organising. I wonder if there's a subtle expectation here that, having seen through the illusion of Zach, life should now be lived by a different kind of Zach — one who doesn't set goals, make decisions, take responsibility or even use the word "I" :) Could this be another identity forming around the idea of "no-self"?
That is interesting. Like in contrast to a Zach who felt he had a choice, this new Zach feels he doesn’t have a choice, so he’s stopping making them altogether. In either case, there is still a “Zach”; now he just doesn’t think he has choice: a choiceless Zach. Things are just arising to “him”. Actions are just happening to “him”. Another way thought smuggles in a “me”. But, just because thought imagines it, doesn’t make it true. The existence of a thought is not proof of its content.

So, in those examples (dad, zen community, retreat), it was subtly imagined there was a “zach” who these experiences just happened to.

I have a question, if you don’t mind about cause and effect:

Can we explore whether imagination (thought) can actually cause sensation, like a bodily sensation. Or, does imagination (thought) invent a story about the bodily sensation and add time, such that it appears imagination causes the bodily sensation? Like, bodily sensation does not contain within itself any information about its cause, or about the time it occurred (as I think thought would have to compare it to another time to say it happened in a certain sequence). Or, can imagination only cause other imagined bodily sensations (hallucinations), and because thought creates cause/effect and time, it decides the appearance of sequence?
So now back to your observations…
Thought says, "no. Causes come from prior causes." And, "i don't know. How could it be known? The conditions are never the same such that one condition could be varied, as a test."
Yes! I just wanted an example of a decision that you would normally consider that you’ve made. The point was to look entirely in thought content where cause and effect “live” and see that even there there’s no “you” making a decision. It was just one event leading to another, leading to another, with “actions” based on previous conditioning. The thought “decision is made” is layered on top of other thoughts/beliefs/descriptions of what has happened before.
Why does the wind blow? It just blows. Yes we can say it happens as a result of previous events but there’s no entity “wind” that does the blowing. There is no wind that decides to blow. It’s just language.
What is “moving of the hands” in DE? We’ve seen that it’s just a sensation, labelled “hands moving” + colour labelled “hands moving”.
So, what makes the sensations to appear? What makes seeing to appear? LOOK! Is there anything that causes anything to appear? Do cause and effect exist outside of thought content?
Cause and effect are concepts (thought). They are not contained within experience itself apart from thought. Seeing color/shape (which thought labels “toast”) does not, within itself, contain information about its cause. Thought supplies memories of taking bread out, putting it in the toaster, and letting it toast, to conclude that that is what “caused” “toast”. But, really, nothing causes shape/color.
Thought comes to describe that things are happening and why they are happening, but in DE things are just happening. Is the description/explanation/label needed for things to happen?
No. Not at all.

Something stood out in your description of the retreat:
There was no motivation to set goals as there was no "me" to set them, nor any "me" who could set things in motion to accomplish them, that "this" was just happening, perfectly, and there was nothing to add to it.
Does recognising that there is no separate self mean that goals, motivation, plans, preferences or responsibility must disappear?
It does not follow that those things “must” cease” to happen simply because “me” is seen through as the “doer” of them. That suggests an “absence of me” can do a thing or refrain from doing a thing. Like, turning this absence into another concept through which thought says something causes something else.

I agree that may be why feelings of shame/guilt arise and trouble with the concept of “responsability” come from. To have a feeling of shame/guilt, there would need to be a “me”, even a “choiceless me”. That’s so funny. Thoughts are now saying, “but I had no choice! Why are they angry at me? That seems so unfair!” I ask thought, “where is this “I” that had no choice?” Now thought is giving images of a younger me. I ask thought, “where does that image live?” It says, “in memory”. I ask it, “does that image live outside of memory”? Thought says, “no.” I ask it, “can the image be hurt by anything then?” Feelings of tears and shaking are happening. Thought says, “the image is safe here. Nothing can hurt it.” More tears, more shaking. I ask it, “who is the one asking right now?” Thought says, “just a process”. I ask it, “is it me?” Thought says “yes.” I ask thought, “apart from thoughts, does this me exist?” Thought says, “no.”

Does recognising the absence of a separate self mean that kindness, consideration for others, apologies or taking responsibility for actions must disappear?

Remember it’s not like the self died (e.g. an ego death) , it NEVER existed in the first place. There was no one (no Zach) that was fooled by the illusion and now he’s not. It’s very much a self-organised structure (in terms of cause and effect). Goals happened before without Zach just fine :)
It does not follow that those things “must” cease or disappear. It redefines what they mean though.

Is it possible that you've been trying to live in a particular way because of what you've recognised? Is there an expectation that someone who has seen through the illusion should behave differently?
That’s very interesting. Perhaps I’ve been subtly judging this “choiceless zach”, finding him worthy of the punishment my dad subtly wants to inflict on me for saying there is no “choice” or “zach” to make a choice. But, where is the “I” that judges? If this “I” originates from my dad’s speech, and it was interpreted by thought without investigation into the location of the “I”, then it remains unexamined. So, thought, “where is this “I” that holds my dad’s feeling about choiceless zach?” Thought says, “it is here”. I ask thought, “apart from thought, does it exist somewhere?” Thought says, “maybe in my dad”. I ask thought, “where in my dad does it exist?” Thought says, “in your dad’s thoughts”. I ask thought, “apart from thoughts in your dad, and here in thoughts, does it exist?” Thought says, “no. Judgment is a concept that requires the existence of a “me” to be judged apart from the rest such that it could be a cause worthy of judgment”. I ask thought, “apart from thought, is there a “me” separate from the rest of it?” Thought says, “it cannot be located apart from thought”. I ask thought, “then can it be hurt by something?” Warmness in the chest. Thought says, “its just a thought. It cannot be hurt.” I ask, “can it be imagined to be hurt?” Thought says, “yes, it can.” I ask, “can that imagined hurt exist apart from thought?” Thought says, “No.”

Now, something particularly interesting emerged from your experiences with the retreat group, your father and the Zen community:
If you believe this "me" is only apparent, you will harm more and be alone, that seems to be an important belief worth investigating. There are two approaches to it: one, looking for Zach, to the person that this experience is happening TO, the one that FEELS these emotions...and the other, to work with the actual sensations.
So…
When someone disagrees with you or feels hurt by something you've said, there may be uncomfortable sensations, thoughts about having done something wrong, and an urge to explain, apologise or defend yourself.
But where exactly is the separate "me" that needs defending?
I am going to add “explaining” and “apologizing”. It feels like all of it is a desire to be seen or understood as a “something”--as a “choiceless zach”, or just an “object” or “container” of experiences. I ask thought, “What wants to be seen?” “Thought says, “that you are good”. Deep sigh arises. I ask thought, “what does “good” mean?” Thought says, “worthy of love and connection”. Tears and shaking are arising. I ask thought, “does someone need to deem you worthy of those things?” Thought says, “yes.” I ask thought, “is that a thought or the truth?” Thought laughs, and says, “it’s all thought over here”. Laughter out loud arises. I ask thought, “apart from thought, does this rule actually exist?” Thought says, “ it is just a rule in thought.” I ask thought, “where is this “me” that wants to be worthy of love and connection?” Thought shows me many images where these desires occurred to a younger me. I ask thought, “apart from thought, do these images exist?” Thought says, “no.”. I ask thought, “can love and connection be offered now?” Deep sigh arises. Feeling of appreciation arises. I ask thought, “is there a “me” that can obtain love or connection from others?” Thought says, “connection is a concept necessitating another and necessitating a separation between the “me” and this “another” in the first place. Love is always present, you just don’t see it.” I ask thought, “OK, but is there a “me” that could obtain these things?” Thought says, “where would you obtain these from? You are not separate.” I ask thought, “OK, but who is the one who is not separate?” Thought says, “you”. I ask thought, “Apart from thought, do I exist?” Thought says, “no.” I ask thought, “OK, so who needs defending, who needs to apologize? Who needs to take responsibility? “Thought says, “thought.” I ask thought, “apart from thought, does thought exist?” Thought says, “no.”
And when the thought appears that without believing in a "me" you'll harm others or end up alone, what makes that thought true? Is it evidence of an actual self, or a prediction about what might happen (we can explore time)?
More thought says its true or shows me images suggesting its true. Thought is not evidence of its content. It is a prediction of what might happen.
Now back to the second approach… Whenever a strong emotion arrives, try and deconstruct it down to bodily sensations. That is to say, see that certain sensations tend to be labelled in certain ways, e.g. the thought label “fear” may be habitually applied to a knot-like sensation in the stomach area. “Anxiety” may be the thought label for trembling hands and nausea, etc. They may vary for different people, so it helps to be aware of what it is for you. Can you give some examples of this from your experience?
The feeling “I” did something wrong/guilt/shame/anxiety is usually a pit in my stomach. Anger usually appears as a kind of intense pulsing in my head. Sadness/dispair/loneliness appears as a hollow sensation in my chest.

So let’s work with “fear”. When ‘fear’ appears, close your eyes and do the following... Look at the label ‘fear’ itself. See the label/word ‘fear’ as a typewritten word
Does the label ‘fear’ know anything about fear, or is the word just a bunch of letters?
Is the label ‘fear’ itself fearful?
The label in my mind doesn’t know anything about fear.

Can you find anyone/anything in the word itself that is fearful?
No. All I can find that is fearful is the images that come up when I see the word.

Then look at the sensation and ignore everything else but the sensation itself.

Inquire into the sensation and ask if the sensation itself knows anything about ‘fear’. Does the sensation itself suggest in any way that it is fear or that it is fearful?
Can you find anyone or anything within or behind the sensation that is fearful?
The sensation is in my chest, feels like a fast vibration. It is very subtle, like just barely above the surface of awareness. It is very difficult to separate out the story from the sensation itself. Actually now the sensation is in my head, a pressure between the eyes that feels like its growing bigger. Now the sensation is both in the chest and between the eyes.

The sensation does not contain any information about what it is, or a story about itself. The sensation. I’m not even sure it has labels like “painful” without thought.

When you have done this and if no one/no thing is found, then just sit with the sensation. Just breathe normally, notice the thoughts and images that appear and let them pass on by. Allow the sensation all the room it needs without pushing it aside or judging it. If it becomes too intense just take a couple of deep breaths into the sensation itself. If the sensation does not dissipate at all or only dissipates a little, that is okay, just notice it, without doing anything with it and just go about your day.
We are not trying to get rid of the sensation labelled ‘fear’ or the arising thoughts or images. We are only LOOKING to see what is actually appearing (ie thought, sensation, colour/image) as opposed to what thought is saying ABOUT what actually IS. Freedom comes from allowing whatever appears to appear without the need for it to be different or to leave. Perhaps the recognition doesn't require a new way of living at all. Perhaps ordinary life can simply continue, without the assumption of a separate entity running it.
What do you find?
The sensation is there. The stories (thought) about the sensation are there. The urge to inquire, “is the story true?” and “did the sensation cause the story? Did the story cause the sensation or amplify it?” arise and persist. Now the sensation is not felt anymore, the story fades. The urge to inquire drops.
Nothing is excluded.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: hello!

Postby poppyseed » Tue Nov 17, 2026 2:06 pm

Hi Zach,
Throughout your reply you're having quite elaborate conversations with thought, asking questions and receiving answers :)
But we're not interested in what thought concludes, even when the answers sound convincing. We're interested in what can actually be found in direct experience.
Thought says, “worthy of love and connection”. Tears and shaking are arising.
That's something to look at!
When the feeling of being hurt or needing approval arises, look directly. Can you find an actual Zach who is hurt or needs approval? Or is there sensation, mental imagery and thoughts describing someone to whom all this is happening?
Don't ask thought for the answer. LOOK!
More thought says its true or shows me images suggesting its true.
Do the images make it true? Is ANYTHING thought says true? Could it even be true?
At best, thoughts are nothing but approximation of reality. Thoughts are always out of step with reality, and they obstruct the clear seeing of how things actually are. Reality is very simple. Once you can see this, you will stop endlessly frustrating yourself by trying to figure out how things are. Just notice what is ‘underneath’ all thoughts. Thoughts add an overlaying narrative of names, labels, interpretations, explanations over the simplicity of what is. Instead of endlessly reaching for ideas, concepts and explanations, just let it all go, and see. Just see what is here now silently, without words. Explanations offer supposed “why” and “how”, “relationships” (if …then, because), and all of these are where the illusion is.

Truth or reality is not an idea or a belief. It cannot be grasped by thoughts. It does not need to be understood by the intellect. Actually, it is impossible to understand through thoughts. It is inconceivable, ungraspable. And yet, it can be directly seen.
Is meaning ubiversal?
The meaning of a word is not the word itself but is found within the structure of language. It is easy to get stuck on concepts and believe that they are telling the truth, but none of them are truth, they are only carriers, like fingers pointing. Usually we look at the finger that points to the moon and assume that the finger itself is the moon. If you get hooked on looking at the finger, you can discuss the finger, debate about it, argue about it, and even create a following, but the moon is not there. The moon is located where the finger is pointing to.
Language is basically the relationship between concepts – how they are organised. That carries meaning on top of the meaning of the actual concepts. That is why different concepts mean different things to different people and in different situations. One very good example of how words and language are just pointers to but not the actual DE, and how meaning is formed, is AI. GPT (Generative pre-trained transformers) are large language models that are based on the semantic relationships between words in sentences (natural language processing). GPT models are trained on a large amount of text. The training consists in predicting the next token (a token being usually a word, sub-word, or punctuation). Throughout this training, GPT models accumulate knowledge about the world, and can then generate “human-like” text by repeatedly predicting the next token. But does a language model have any direct experience of what it’s talking about? Does it have knowledge and understanding of reality or just spits out tokens in a predictive way. That is why I always use the analogy with the desktop icons – they give meaning to 0’s and 1’s. There are no actual eraser or pen there, nor a mailbox :)
THIS - what we see, hear, taste, and feel—is neutral. It doesn’t interpret or have meaning. Seeing doesn’t "know" what is seeing. The act of seeing just happens. But it’s when thoughts step in, with their layers of pre-chewed, second-hand knowledge, that the process of interpretation begins. This is where the distortion begins. Meaning is created through what’s been fogged up by other people’s thoughts, societal conditioning, and outdated knowledge. It’s like wearing sunglasses in the fog. You think you see reality, but what you’re perceiving is just a filtered version of it—biased and clouded by conditioned thinking. All this knowledge that claims to “know” what’s happening is just pre-packaged bullshit. THIS (what appears) is pure, but the thought’s interpretation? It’s a recycled narrative.
So don’t look at thoughts for answer. SEE instead!
Who needs defending, who needs to apologize? Who needs to take responsibility?
And thought answers that no such entity exists.
But does the absence of a separate self mean that apologies or taking responsibility are no longer necessary?
Suppose you accidentally hurt someone you care about. There may be recognition of what happened, concern for the other person, and an apology. You probably believed in Santa when you were little. There was magic and joy, and love, and giving, and caring. When you realised that Santa is not real, did Christmas change? Did the spirit of Christmas disappear or just the belief in Santa?
You say it redefines what goals, motivation and responsibility mean. In what way?
Before recognising that there is no separate Zach, "plans" were made, "decisions" happened, and "consequences" followed. Is any of that actually different now? When you realise that the mailbox icon isn't an actual mailbox, does that change how you use it to manage your correspondence? Do you stop sending and receiving emails?
There is a Buddhist saying: "Before one studies Zen, mountains are mountains and waters are waters; after a first glimpse into the truth of Zen, mountains are no longer mountains and waters are no longer waters; after enlightenment, mountains are once again mountains and waters once again waters"
Similarly, recognising that "Zach" is a useful label rather than a separate entity doesn't mean that planning, choosing, caring or taking responsibility must change or disappear.
Has anything about these activities actually changed, or only the belief about who's behind them?
Or has the understanding of who is doing all this changed, while life continues much as before?

Look at an actual example from your life. What happens? Is a separate "Zach" needed for any of that to take place?
And notice the difference between seeing that no separate controller can be found and concluding that nobody needs to take responsibility.
Is that conclusion something directly experienced, or is it another story thought tells about "no-self"?

There is a huge difference between spiritual avoidance ("no me, no problem") and seeing through the illusion of a separate self while remaining fully engaged in life.
The absence of a separate doer doesn't mean that actions have no consequences, that caring stops, or that mistakes don't need correcting. Life was already happening without a separate Zach, including kindness, apologies, learning and taking responsibility. Why should recognising this change any of that?
Is there perhaps a new belief about how life should unfold without a separate self?
Love,
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Tue Nov 17, 2026 10:43 pm

Can you find an actual Zach who is hurt or needs approval?
You’re right. In DE, I can’t find a Zach that needs approval or is hurt apart from feelings (thoughts+sensations) of needing approval or is hurt. Who could possibly need approval? Does a thought need approval?
Or is there sensation, mental imagery and thoughts describing someone to whom all this is happening?
Correct. Why believe the thought that says this is happening to a personal “me”? Where is this personal me? There are thoughts and sensations arising that suggest its existence, but when I look in thought I just find more thought and when I look in sensation, I just find more sensation. I never find a personal me.

Don't ask thought for the answer. LOOK!
More thought says its true or shows me images suggesting its true.

Do the images make it true? Is ANYTHING thought says true? Could it even be true?
The images don’t necessarily make it true. There could be a thought, “there is a watermelon on the table”, but other than thought (or mental image), there is no evidence for what thought claims. But, if seeing indicates a watermelon is indeed on the table, then the thought “there is a watermelon on the table” could be true.
So don’t look at thoughts for answer. SEE instead!
Who needs defending, who needs to apologize? Who needs to take responsibility?
And thought answers that no such entity exists.
But does the absence of a separate self mean that apologies or taking responsibility are no longer necessary? Suppose you accidentally hurt someone you care about. There may be recognition of what happened, concern for the other person, and an apology.
/
I think the phrasing of the pointing might be causing me some confusion. I agree those consequences of accidentally hurting someone might arise, but they also might not. There is no controller of consequences. Consequences happen.

You probably believed in Santa when you were little. There was magic and joy, and love, and giving, and caring. When you realised that Santa is not real, did Christmas change? Did the spirit of Christmas disappear or just the belief in Santa?
I think the phrasing of the pointing is causing me confusion. If I’m honest, the concept of Christmas really did change when I realized Santa was not real. The “spirit”of it changed, too. I saw that my parents were using a manipulation tactic to attempt to coerce my behavior. It was seen that actually, regardless of my behavior, they gave presents. I think maybe this specific pointing is too conceptual to be useful.
You say it redefines what goals, motivation and responsibility mean. In what way?
Before recognising that there is no separate Zach, "plans" were made, "decisions" happened, and "consequences" followed. Is any of that actually different now?
Absolutely not. How could it be any different. There was never a zach to begin with.
When you realise that the mailbox icon isn't an actual mailbox, does that change how you use it to manage your correspondence? Do you stop sending and receiving emails?
If I thought it was an actual mailbox first, and later realized it was just an icon I click with a mouse, it would certainly change how I use it. I would stop trying to open the mailbox on my screen with my hands and instead use the mouse to click on the icon. But, actually, this raises an interesting question about cause and effect. If thought supplies the information that this is not a physical mailbox in which I can use my hands to directly open, is the change in behavior a caused by thought, or are the sensations and thoughts wholly unrelated, and thought stitches them together?




There is a Buddhist saying: "Before one studies Zen, mountains are mountains and waters are waters; after a first glimpse into the truth of Zen, mountains are no longer mountains and waters are no longer waters; after enlightenment, mountains are once again mountains and waters once again waters"
Similarly, recognising that "Zach" is a useful label rather than a separate entity doesn't mean that planning, choosing, caring or taking responsibility must change or disappear.
Has anything about these activities actually changed, or only the belief about who's behind them?
I think the phrasing of this pointing is making it difficult to understand. To me, these “activities” exist in thought only, where thought mixes them up with other thoughts about beliefs about who is behind the “activities”. Let’s say an accident occurs. Yes, there is seeing, hearing, feeling. But, where in this is the “activity” of “taking responsibility” apart from the thought, “I/they need to take responsibility”?

So, yes, the “activities” change because “activities” in this sense are thoughts that are mixed up with more thoughts about who is behind them. In other words, when there is no thought of “me”, there is no thought of a “me/them” who could take responsibility. Likewise, when there is a thought of “taking responsibility”, there is, implicit in that thought, another thought, which is a thought about the one whom the first thought is referring to–the implicit one who takes the responsibility. But, when looked for, the referent is not there apart from thought. So, it feels like, sure, we can use the concepts in a conventional way, but it seems to add a confusing layer to what is already here. The hand clicks the mouse which signals the mailbox icon to open, or it doesn’t. Nothing needs to “take responsibility” for it happening or not, just like nothing needs to be “blamed” if it happens or not.

Or has the understanding of who is doing all this changed, while life continues much as before?
I don’t know how this was for you at the beginning, but for me the difference is stark in my day to day life. Imagine 5,433 “urgent messages” come flooding into your head each morning before you are awake enough to make any sense of them, most of which require deep untangling until to see they were built upon pure speculation. Imagine the big bright red “danger” symbol flashes every time you even hint you have a different viewpoint to someone else. Imagine walking in your city of over 10 million to get coffee involves a constant snap judgment about whether the people you encounter, some of whom pass inches away, will hurt you or not. Now imagine realizing that the person who you thought all of this was happening to doesn’t exist–thought just imagined it. That what is actually here is fresh and spontaneous and neutral. It isn’t inherently dangerous and it doesn’t come with a sneaking feeling that the other shoe is about to drop–only thought says that. That is huge to me.
Look at an actual example from your life. What happens? Is a separate "Zach" needed for any of that to take place?
No, life just happens. Right now, there is seeing of a “computer”, touching/feeling of a keybed, thoughts arising about what else is happening. None of that disappears if the concept of “zach” or a “doer/controller” is taken out.
And notice the difference between seeing that no separate controller can be found and concluding that nobody needs to take responsibility.
Is that conclusion something directly experienced, or is it another story thought tells about "no-self"?
A conclusion about anything is always a thought, but a thought is directly experienced (if by DE we mean sensations+thoughts). Just like “toast” is a conclusion thought makes about shape/color/texture/taste/smell.

There is a huge difference between spiritual avoidance ("no me, no problem") and seeing through the illusion of a separate self while remaining fully engaged in life.
The absence of a separate doer doesn't mean that actions have no consequences, that caring stops, or that mistakes don't need correcting. Life was already happening without a separate Zach, including kindness, apologies, learning and taking responsibility. Why should recognising this change any of that?
If these concepts (kindness, apologies, learning, and taking responsibility) were founded on a sense of “me” that recognition dismantles, then dismantling of those concepts is bound to follow that. Perhaps new formations of those concepts will emerge without a “me” grounded in them, perhaps not. Where does “spiritual avoidance” exist but in a thought which supposes one is avoiding what one should do for reasons thought to be “spiritual”? Couldn’t it too be a part of life unfolding?
Is there perhaps a new belief about how life should unfold without a separate self?


There is perhaps subtle beliefs that after no self is seen, the feeling of shame should lose its power; that taking things personally should dissolve; that the need to control circumstances (esp around managing others disapproval, rejection to avoid feeling like I’m in danger) should dissolve; that failing to see no self in moments of overwhelm indicates a failure to see no-self or that the recognition is temporary and will fade over time; and that no resistance should be felt to what is. Wow, ok. High expectations!


Thank you for all your help.
Nothing is excluded.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: hello!

Postby poppyseed » Wed Nov 18, 2026 10:14 am

Hi Zach,
Thank you for your thoughtful reply! And yes, the Santa analogy clearly didn't work for you :)
I hear you about how significant the changes in your everyday experience have been. I'm not suggesting that nothing changes when the illusion is seen through. That’s what we call the "honeymoon period". But the euphoria is a state and nothing is permanent and then what we call "got it, lost it" shows up as untrue beliefs come up to be questioned (as in your high expectations at the end). I am sorry to keep saying this, but you will never end up in a permanently altered state, a permanent high. It is always, “And now chop wood and carry water”. I can feel your resistance to this. Resistance is a good tool for uncovering unchecked beliefs.

Now back to your answers:
But, if seeing indicates a watermelon is indeed on the table, then the thought “there is a watermelon on the table” could be true.
Remember our apple exercise? :)
When you look at a watermelon on a table, what does seeing actually provide? Does seeing itself say "watermelon" or "table", or are those labels supplied by thought?
Of course, the description "there's a watermelon on the table" is perfectly useful in everyday life. But can seeing confirm the labels themselves, or only the colours and shapes being described?
But, actually, this raises an interesting question about cause and effect. If thought supplies the information that this is not a physical mailbox in which I can use my hands to directly open, is the change in behavior a caused by thought, or are the sensations and thoughts wholly unrelated, and thought stitches them together?
Does thought cause behaviour or merely describes a sequence? And do we need to settle that question to see whether there's a separate controller?
Can “behaviour” be found in DE? Can even "thought" be found as a separate thing in DE?

We have to make a distinction when we are talking about a story change and DE…Yes the story changes – there could be less judgment, more openness. more appreciation - and even less story, more looking; less structure, more flow. You will notice that some habitual thoughts no longer arise. The story changes in a way that allows more space for simply flowing. But even on the level of the story:
When an ordinary action happens, what can you actually observe? Is there a separate Zach directing it, or is that something added by thought?
If I thought it was an actual mailbox first, and later realized it was just an icon I click with a mouse, it would certainly change how I use it. I would stop trying to open the mailbox on my screen with my hands and instead use the mouse to click on the icon.
You're taking the mailbox analogy a little further than I intended :)
Were you actually trying to open the mailbox on your screen with your hands before discovering it was an icon? :)
The point is simply that recognising an icon as an icon doesn't make it useless and it doesn't mean you have to stop using it.
Similarly, life was already happening without a separate Zach. Goals, decisions, relationships and responsibility were all part of it. Why should recognising the illusion require a new way of living?

You describe how much better life feels now, and I'm not questioning that your experience has changed.
But what exactly is "better"? Can "better" be found in the sensations themselves, or is it a comparison supplied by thought? Sensation is just a sensation without the label “good” or “bad” as you've seen already.
Are you looking for freedom from unwanted feelings? If so, it’s not how it works. The freedom is to experience all, good, bad, and the ugly, without judgement that it’s wrong. The key is to realize that shoulds and should nots are the very things that make for a distorted view.
To “improve” suggest that there is something wrong with it, like it can be different than what it IS. But can it be in a different way than it is now, perfect? It is “perfect” not because it is nice and amazing, it is perfect because it can’t be any other way. THIS (What IS) is beyond qualities and flaws to be added or removed, accepted or rejected. Perfection is a flawless state where everything is exactly right the way it is. Faults and flaws in THIS can be found only in thought which, defines THIS as “positive or negative”, to be desired or avoided. Surrendering is what is left when resistance to what is ends.
Furthermore, to “improve” suggests there is a doer who makes things happen - having an inquiry, looking at things, working with the unwanted feelings, etc. That makes a nice “enlightenment story”. That is what thought loves – finding meaning where there is none, planning “activities” that might happen or not :).

So is there an actual Zach/any other entity for whom the experience has improved?
If fear or anxiety returns tomorrow, does that mean something has become worse, or that Zach has lost something?
Look at what is actually happening, before thought evaluates it. This leads us to this:
that failing to see no self in moments of overwhelm indicates a failure to see no-self or that the recognition is temporary and will fade over time; and that no resistance should be felt to what is. Wow, ok. High expectations!
Wow, high expectations indeed! :)
Let's look at this. When shame, fear or resistance arises, is there suddenly a separate Zach experiencing it? Does the appearance of these feelings mean that the illusion has become reality again?
Or are there simply sensations and thoughts appearing, including the thought that they shouldn't be happening?
And is there an actual Zach who needs to maintain the recognition, or who could lose it?

Look rather than asking thought for an explanation.
Do you need to know anything in order to be (for THIS to appear)? Do you need to do anything in order for THIS to appear? Do you need to hold on to THIS, because it can slip away? Or it can be taken away? Do you need to survive in order for THIS to appear?

Love
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Wed Nov 18, 2026 7:46 pm

Hi Zach,
Thank you for your thoughtful reply! And yes, the Santa analogy clearly didn't work for you :)
I hear you about how significant the changes in your everyday experience have been. I'm not suggesting that nothing changes when the illusion is seen through. That’s what we call the "honeymoon period". But the euphoria is a state and nothing is permanent and then what we call "got it, lost it" shows up as untrue beliefs come up to be questioned (as in your high expectations at the end). I am sorry to keep saying this, but you will never end up in a permanently altered state, a permanent high. It is always, “And now chop wood and carry water”. I can feel your resistance to this. Resistance is a good tool for uncovering unchecked beliefs.
Please don’t be sorry about repeating these things. Disillusionment is wonderful. Thank you so much for guiding me through this.

Now back to your answers:
But, if seeing indicates a watermelon is indeed on the table, then the thought “there is a watermelon on the table” could be true.
Remember our apple exercise? :)
When you look at a watermelon on a table, what does seeing actually provide? Does seeing itself say "watermelon" or "table", or are those labels supplied by thought?
Right, “watermelon” is a concept, a thought. Seeing provides color/shape, and thought concludes “watermelon”. So, let’s refine it further. Let’s say seeing color/shape is arising and thought says, “color/shape is arising”. Isn’t that thought true then? Or, actually, are we just getting into more labels? Like, “color/shape” and “seeing” are themselves concepts provided by thought for “what is”-- just representations, not “it”?....

Ah, OK, I see clearly now.


Of course, the description "there's a watermelon on the table" is perfectly useful in everyday life. But can seeing confirm the labels themselves, or only the colours and shapes being described?
No, the labels are in thought only. Only the color/shapes.

But, actually, this raises an interesting question about cause and effect. If thought supplies the information that this is not a physical mailbox in which I can use my hands to directly open, is the change in behavior a caused by thought, or are the sensations and thoughts wholly unrelated, and thought stitches them together?

Does thought cause behaviour or merely describes a sequence?

That’s very subtle. You’re right, apart from thought, how could you know? Let’s say my hand accidentally bumps into a jar, knocking it over. In DE, color/shape is arising. One color/shape did not cause another color/shape, it is all one color/shape. There is no “space” separating it into two, giving the imagined two color/shapes a sequence of interaction.

And do we need to settle that question to see whether there's a separate controller?

No. there is no info about a separate me within color/shape.

Can “behaviour” be found in DE?
Yes, that’s very subtle. Behavior is a concept–a thought. Does shape/color have in itself any information about behavior? Does color/shape describe how color/shape behave? It feels similar to the concept of cause/effect, which can’t be found in color/shape. color/shape doesn’t describe how color/shape came to be.

Can even "thought" be found as a separate thing in DE?
I think you mean the label “thought”, for what “thought” is describing? Do you mean, in truth, there just “is”, before thought comes in and tries to represent “it” as apparently separate things like thought, taste, touch, sight, smell?


We have to make a distinction when we are talking about a story change and DE…Yes the story changes – there could be less judgment, more openness. more appreciation - and even less story, more looking; less structure, more flow. You will notice that some habitual thoughts no longer arise. The story changes in a way that allows more space for simply flowing. But even on the level of the story:
When an ordinary action happens, what can you actually observe? Is there a separate Zach directing it, or is that something added by thought?

Right, on the level of DE, after the shift, thought still arises (its content may change), smell, taste, touch, sight, all still arises. Is that what you mean? Zach has always been added by thought. That never changes.


If I thought it was an actual mailbox first, and later realized it was just an icon I click with a mouse, it would certainly change how I use it. I would stop trying to open the mailbox on my screen with my hands and instead use the mouse to click on the icon.
You're taking the mailbox analogy a little further than I intended :)
Were you actually trying to open the mailbox on your screen with your hands before discovering it was an icon? :)
The point is simply that recognising an icon as an icon doesn't make it useless and it doesn't mean you have to stop using it.
Similarly, life was already happening without a separate Zach. Goals, decisions, relationships and responsibility were all part of it. Why should recognising the illusion require a new way of living?


/

That’s a very subtle point. Thank you. Any change to the way of living suggests a doer who could enact it, and a “me” that could benefit from the change. The use of “should” suggests a dissatisfaction with the way living is unfolding, and therefore a “me” who could be dissatisfied. It also suggests a comparison is being made between what “is” and an imagined “what could be”. That comparison can arise. The dissatisfaction can arise. The shame associated with feeling of not “taking responsibility” can arise, etc. All that can even suggest a “me” apart from it, in thought. Thought can say, “there is a me apart from it”. But, apart from thought, where is this so-called me? It’s all a very elaborate way for thought to smuggle in a “me” who could change any of it.
You describe how much better life feels now, and I'm not questioning that your experience has changed.
But what exactly is "better"?

That is very subtle. Thank you. “Better” is a concept, a thought about an imagined reality that is compared to what thought thinks “is”. It’s so funny. It’s like thought imagines reality as this really terrible situation, and then also represents this other imagined reality, and says, “I prefer the later. Let’s do things to get to the later reality”. But, neither reality is true, just a representation in thought. And, all while its doing that, its smuggling in a “me” who could possibly do something to get from the first imagined reality to the second, when both do not actually exist but in thought.

Can "better" be found in the sensations themselves, or is it a comparison supplied by thought? Sensation is just a sensation without the label “good” or “bad” as you've seen already.

Right. It’s just a label for what thought does when it imagines two realities and compares them.


(I don’t know where else to put this, but it came up here in this part of the response) I feel like there is a subtle resistance to imagination or thought itself. Like, there is a “me” who doesn’t want to experience thought because it might take the clarity that there isn’t a me away. How funny. It’s more thought guarding an imagined “me” against more thought taking away another thought of a me. But, where is the me apart from these thoughts? The thoughts fight or protect against other thoughts. They can fight and protect all day–it doesn’t touch any of “this”. Does any of “this” need a “me” to happen? Thoughts of me aren’t proof that a me exists.
Are you looking for freedom from unwanted feelings?
Yes, that is good insight. There is a subtle thought that says, “this has to be different because it is bothersome”, and smuggled in the thought may be a “me” who is bothered, and doer who could make it different. Those thoughts can be there, but they don’t mean there is a me here who could be bothered or effect change. Bothered is a thought–a comparison of an imagined reality to another imagined reality. Uncomfortable is kind of thought and bodily sensation. A thought that compares bodily sensation and labels one good and one bad, and prefers one over the other. Preferences can happen (can express), decisions can arise about whether to take action, and action (or not) can happen, all without a zach. It's funny there is even a resistance to resisting. Who could effect it? If resistance to resisting happens, does there need to be a controller who could stop resisting resistance? It just happens. Thought imagines a cause as a “me” and says, “stop hitting yourself!”. Resistance is the resister–both are thought fighting with another thought labeled “reality” which is just another thought about a reality that thought imagines.
If so, it’s not how it works. The freedom is to experience all, good, bad, and the ugly, without judgement that it’s wrong. The key is to realize that shoulds and should nots are the very things that make for a distorted view.
Interesting. But, even the judgment that its wrong is a part of life unfolding. The thought that resists it implies a “me” that says what “is”, and says, “I want it to be different”. Even the should and should not, and the “distorted views that result” are part of it. Resisting them is part of it. Resisting resisting them is part of it. Like, thought is a part of experience. Like, is freedom really contingent upon seeing reality without a judgment that the reality is wrong? If that were the case, then when reality is seen as wrong, freedom would not be there. Freedom would have a condition. Is freedom only freedom in which you must do or see something in order to obtain freedom–such as “seeing reality without judging it as wrong”? Who gets to say what is “wrong”? Could that be another subtle way thought sneaks in a “me”? I think maybe the statement is too broad. Freedom includes the freedom to judge it all as wrong. Otherwise, it is just freedom with a subtle “me” that says what freedom is and what it is not. It is freedom with a condition created by a “me”.
To “improve” suggest that there is something wrong with it, like it can be different than what it IS. But can it be in a different way than it is now, perfect?
I think improvement is part of what is. Otherwise, there is resistance to the concept of improvement, just like having resistance to “taking responsibility”...it happens or it doesnt. It cannot be different than what “is.

So is there an actual Zach/any other entity for whom the experience has improved?
No. There is an appearance of zach and an appearance that things have improved, but these cannot be found apart from the thought of them.

If fear or anxiety returns tomorrow, does that mean something has become worse, or that Zach has lost something?
The appearance of Zach can realize or lose realization. But, apart from thought there is no appearance of zach or anything which can be lost which he once had.

Look at what is actually happening, before thought evaluates it. This leads us to this:
that failing to see no self in moments of overwhelm indicates a failure to see no-self or that the recognition is temporary and will fade over time; and that no resistance should be felt to what is. Wow, ok. High expectations!
Wow, high expectations indeed! :)
Let's look at this. When shame, fear or resistance arises, is there suddenly a separate Zach experiencing it? Does the appearance of these feelings mean that the illusion has become reality again?
Or are there simply sensations and thoughts appearing, including the thought that they shouldn't be happening?
That is very subtle. There is simply sensations and thoughts appearing, including a thought “this shouldnt be happening.”

And is there an actual Zach who needs to maintain the recognition, or who could lose it?
Very subtle. No. Just an appearance of a zach in thought. The thought does not become evidence of the truth of its content simply because it appears intense or feels overwhelming.

Look rather than asking thought for an explanation.
Do you need to know anything in order to be (for THIS to appear)?
No, sound appears before it is known as some kind of sound.
Do you need to do anything in order for THIS to appear?
No, thoughts arise without first thinking them.
Do you need to hold on to THIS, because it can slip away?
There is nothing that needs to hold together experience of what is. Even thoughts, “I’ve lost it” is “this”.
Or it can be taken away?
There is no “no-experience.” Experiences can arise and disappear.

Do you need to survive in order for THIS to appear?
This just is and always is. There isn’t an experiencer that needs to exist over an amount of time for “this” to appear; it is just appearing.
Nothing is excluded.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: hello!

Postby poppyseed » Thu Nov 19, 2026 10:56 am

Hi Zach,
Haha, quite a journey through thought! :)
I notice how nearly every question leads to another explanation, another question, and another conclusion about how reality works. Can this actually be known? Or it will be just another assumption? Whatever you conclude about reality will be wrong and not the actual thing - just an approximation / a nice little story
And do we actually need to resolve any of these questions to see whether there's a separate Zach?

There is a subtle resistance to imagination or thought itself. Like, there is a “me” who doesn’t want to experience thought because it might take the clarity that there isn’t a me away.
That's worth looking at!
Next time that resistance appears, rather than analysing it, simply notice what's happening. What sensations are present? What thoughts or images appear?
And can you find an actual Zach who needs to protect the clarity, or who could lose it?

There's no need to stop thinking, resist resistance, or arrive at another conclusion. Even the thought "I've lost it" is just another thought appearing. However, resistace is a powerful spotting tool pointing to unchecked beliefs in the process of THIS self-organising :)
Interesting. But, even the judgment that its wrong is a part of life unfolding. The thought that resists it implies a “me” that says what “is”, and says, “I want it to be different”. Even the should and should not, and the “distorted views that result” are part of it. Resisting them is part of it. Resisting resisting them is part of it. Like, thought is a part of experience. Like, is freedom really contingent upon seeing reality without a judgment that the reality is wrong? If that were the case, then when reality is seen as wrong, freedom would not be there. Freedom would have a condition. Is freedom only freedom in which you must do or see something in order to obtain freedom–such as “seeing reality without judging it as wrong”? Who gets to say what is “wrong”? Could that be another subtle way thought sneaks in a “me”? I think maybe the statement is too broad. Freedom includes the freedom to judge it all as wrong. Otherwise, it is just freedom with a subtle “me” that says what freedom is and what it is not. It is freedom with a condition created by a “me”.
Yes, you're right! Even judgment, resistance and thoughts about how things should be are part of what is happening. Nothing needs to disappear :)
But remember, words like "freedom", "resistance" or "distorted reality" are pointers, not actual things. They're like arrows pointing towards something to look at. There's no need to analyse the arrows or turn them into a philosophy about what freedom must include or exclude.
When I say "freedom from judgment", I'm not describing a state in which judgment can never appear. I'm pointing towards seeing that judgment doesn't have to be believed or fought against.
So when judgment or resistance appears, what is actually experienced? Is there an actual Zach doing the judging or resisting?
That's what we're looking for, not a definition of freedom.
Love,
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:47 pm

Haha, quite a journey through thought! :)
I notice how nearly every question leads to another explanation, another question, and another conclusion about how reality works. Can this actually be known? Or it will be just another assumption? Whatever you conclude about reality will be wrong and not the actual thing - just an approximation / a nice little story
And do we actually need to resolve any of these questions to see whether there's a separate Zach?
You’re right. We don’t. Resolution will either happen or it won’t, but it is not necessary in order to see that “zach” (thought) is not apart from “this”, “zach” is a part of “this”.

There is a subtle resistance to imagination or thought itself. Like, there is a “me” who doesn’t want to experience thought because it might take the clarity that there isn’t a me away.
That's worth looking at!
Next time that resistance appears, rather than analysing it, simply notice what's happening. What sensations are present? What thoughts or images appear?
And can you find an actual Zach who needs to protect the clarity, or who could lose it?
Yes, so this morning I went back to basics and stopped trying to conceptualize and rationalize.

I asked, what is this sensation of “me” that feels resistance to thought and imagination, and attention focused on pressure and tension “behind the eyes”. That was a good clue that thought was interpreting a location and owner of the tension and pressure. So, I investigated that. “Does pressure or tension contain within itself spatial information?” I asked? I looked deeply and could not find any spatial information within tension or pressure itself. So, thought was adding “behind the eyes”. Then, I considered ownership. Thought was subtly suggesting the tension or pressure belonged to someone–to a me. So, I investigated that. “Does the tension or pressure contain within itself information about who it belongs to?” I looked deeply and that became an absurd question. Pressure and tension don’t say anything about who they belong to. So, thought was supplying information that these sensations belonged to a “me”. Then, I considered whether thought itself could provide evidence of a “me”. “Is thinking ‘I am’ proof that a “me” exists? If I think “there is a watermelon on the table”, is that proof that a watermelon is actually on the table? Then I just sat there for a bit. I couldn’t find a “me”.
There's no need to stop thinking, resist resistance, or arrive at another conclusion. Even the thought "I've lost it" is just another thought appearing. However, resistace is a powerful spotting tool pointing to unchecked beliefs in the process of THIS self-organising :)
I see that now. Thank you for the good pointer. The feeling of resistance to something can trigger a subtle “me” that is resisting what “is”, and that provides an opportunity to investigate this apparent “me” to see if it actually exists or not.
But remember, words like "freedom", "resistance" or "distorted reality" are pointers, not actual things. They're like arrows pointing towards something to look at. There's no need to analyse the arrows or turn them into a philosophy about what freedom must include or exclude.
When I say "freedom from judgment", I'm not describing a state in which judgment can never appear. I'm pointing towards seeing that judgment doesn't have to be believed or fought against.
So when judgment or resistance appears, what is actually experienced? Is there an actual Zach doing the judging or resisting?
When resistance appears, it just appears, no separate entity is causing the resistance. But, it is a good reminder to investigate whether a new thought-identity is forming around the resistance that claims to actually exist.
Nothing is excluded.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: hello!

Postby poppyseed » Fri Nov 20, 2026 9:39 am

Hi Zach,
Lovely! This is much more direct looking :)
When resistance appears, it just appears, no separate entity is causing the resistance. But, it is a good reminder to investigate whether a new thought-identity is forming around the resistance that claims to actually exist.
Yes, resistance can be a useful pointer to an unquestioned belief. And as you've noticed, neither the resistance nor the thought claiming ownership of it establishes a separate Zach.
Just remember, there's no need to make investigating every thought or resistance into another task that must be accomplished.

There's one thing I’d still want you to look at: responsibility.
You've seen that no separate Zach can be found making decisions or controlling actions. But earlier you questioned who needs to apologise or take responsibility if there's nobody doing anything.
Let's use an ordinary example. Suppose you say something hurtful to your wife. She tells you she's upset.
What happens next? Perhaps there's concern, an apology, or an attempt to make things right.
Does any of that require a separate Zach making it happen?
And does recognising that there's no separate controller mean that the hurt, the consequences or the possibility of making amends disappear?

LOOK at how this works in your own experience, rather than reasoning about what responsibility must mean without a self in nondual environment. It does sound logical - no self, no problem - but logic is not what we are interested here :)

We've explored quite a lot now, and you've become much more direct in your looking :)
I'm curious about how things are unfolding in everyday life, when you're not deliberately investigating. When you're busy working, talking with your wife, making plans or dealing with something unpleasant, how does the sense of "me" show up, if at all?
And when it does, is there still a belief that there's an actual Zach behind the experience, or is it recognised as thoughts and sensations without a separate owner?

There's no need to go looking for a particular experience. Just tell me what you've noticed naturally.

What has changed and what hasn’t in normal everyday living?
What is the biggest difference from before starting this conversation?
Is seeking still going on?
Is there any confusion at all or anything you would like to address?
Can you say with a big fat YES, it is clear what the illusion of a separate self is?


Love,
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 23 guests