Seeing through the illusion doesn't require adopting a new way of speaking, behaving or living. Life continues, with plans, decisions, relationships, disagreements and responsibilities. The question is simply whether there's an independently existing "I" behind any of it.
Obviously there is no Zach who is right and observing what thought says and thought that is wrong – there is just THIS including the thought descriptions, which are based on previous conditioning and new ways – how thoughts relate to each other. It's all thoughts self-organising. I wonder if there's a subtle expectation here that, having seen through the illusion of Zach, life should now be lived by a different kind of Zach — one who doesn't set goals, make decisions, take responsibility or even use the word "I" :) Could this be another identity forming around the idea of "no-self"?
That is interesting. Like in contrast to a Zach who felt he had a choice, this new Zach feels he doesn’t have a choice, so he’s stopping making them altogether. In either case, there is still a “Zach”; now he just doesn’t think he has choice: a choiceless Zach. Things are just arising to “him”. Actions are just happening to “him”. Another way thought smuggles in a “me”. But, just because thought imagines it, doesn’t make it true. The existence of a thought is not proof of its content.
So, in those examples (dad, zen community, retreat), it was subtly imagined there was a “zach” who these experiences just happened to.
I have a question, if you don’t mind about cause and effect:
Can we explore whether imagination (thought) can actually cause sensation, like a bodily sensation. Or, does imagination (thought) invent a story about the bodily sensation and add time, such that it appears imagination causes the bodily sensation? Like, bodily sensation does not contain within itself any information about its cause, or about the time it occurred (as I think thought would have to compare it to another time to say it happened in a certain sequence). Or, can imagination only cause other imagined bodily sensations (hallucinations), and because thought creates cause/effect and time, it decides the appearance of sequence?
So now back to your observations…
Thought says, "no. Causes come from prior causes." And, "i don't know. How could it be known? The conditions are never the same such that one condition could be varied, as a test."
Yes! I just wanted an example of a decision that you would normally consider that you’ve made. The point was to look entirely in thought content where cause and effect “live” and see that even there there’s no “you” making a decision. It was just one event leading to another, leading to another, with “actions” based on previous conditioning. The thought “decision is made” is layered on top of other thoughts/beliefs/descriptions of what has happened before.
Why does the wind blow? It just blows. Yes we can say it happens as a result of previous events but there’s no entity “wind” that does the blowing. There is no wind that decides to blow. It’s just language.
What is “moving of the hands” in DE? We’ve seen that it’s just a sensation, labelled “hands moving” + colour labelled “hands moving”.
So, what makes the sensations to appear? What makes seeing to appear? LOOK! Is there anything that causes anything to appear? Do cause and effect exist outside of thought content?
Cause and effect are concepts (thought). They are not contained within experience itself apart from thought. Seeing color/shape (which thought labels “toast”) does not, within itself, contain information about its cause. Thought supplies memories of taking bread out, putting it in the toaster, and letting it toast, to conclude that that is what “caused” “toast”. But, really, nothing causes shape/color.
Thought comes to describe that things are happening and why they are happening, but in DE things are just happening. Is the description/explanation/label needed for things to happen?
No. Not at all.
Something stood out in your description of the retreat:
There was no motivation to set goals as there was no "me" to set them, nor any "me" who could set things in motion to accomplish them, that "this" was just happening, perfectly, and there was nothing to add to it.
Does recognising that there is no separate self mean that goals, motivation, plans, preferences or responsibility must disappear?
It does not follow that those things “must” cease” to happen simply because “me” is seen through as the “doer” of them. That suggests an “absence of me” can do a thing or refrain from doing a thing. Like, turning this absence into another concept through which thought says something causes something else.
I agree that may be why feelings of shame/guilt arise and trouble with the concept of “responsability” come from. To have a feeling of shame/guilt, there would need to be a “me”, even a “choiceless me”. That’s so funny. Thoughts are now saying, “but I had no choice! Why are they angry at me? That seems so unfair!” I ask thought, “where is this “I” that had no choice?” Now thought is giving images of a younger me. I ask thought, “where does that image live?” It says, “in memory”. I ask it, “does that image live outside of memory”? Thought says, “no.” I ask it, “can the image be hurt by anything then?” Feelings of tears and shaking are happening. Thought says, “the image is safe here. Nothing can hurt it.” More tears, more shaking. I ask it, “who is the one asking right now?” Thought says, “just a process”. I ask it, “is it me?” Thought says “yes.” I ask thought, “apart from thoughts, does this me exist?” Thought says, “no.”
Does recognising the absence of a separate self mean that kindness, consideration for others, apologies or taking responsibility for actions must disappear?
Remember it’s not like the self died (e.g. an ego death) , it NEVER existed in the first place. There was no one (no Zach) that was fooled by the illusion and now he’s not. It’s very much a self-organised structure (in terms of cause and effect). Goals happened before without Zach just fine :)
It does not follow that those things “must” cease or disappear. It redefines what they mean though.
Is it possible that you've been trying to live in a particular way because of what you've recognised? Is there an expectation that someone who has seen through the illusion should behave differently?
That’s very interesting. Perhaps I’ve been subtly judging this “choiceless zach”, finding him worthy of the punishment my dad subtly wants to inflict on me for saying there is no “choice” or “zach” to make a choice. But, where is the “I” that judges? If this “I” originates from my dad’s speech, and it was interpreted by thought without investigation into the location of the “I”, then it remains unexamined. So, thought, “where is this “I” that holds my dad’s feeling about choiceless zach?” Thought says, “it is here”. I ask thought, “apart from thought, does it exist somewhere?” Thought says, “maybe in my dad”. I ask thought, “where in my dad does it exist?” Thought says, “in your dad’s thoughts”. I ask thought, “apart from thoughts in your dad, and here in thoughts, does it exist?” Thought says, “no. Judgment is a concept that requires the existence of a “me” to be judged apart from the rest such that it could be a cause worthy of judgment”. I ask thought, “apart from thought, is there a “me” separate from the rest of it?” Thought says, “it cannot be located apart from thought”. I ask thought, “then can it be hurt by something?” Warmness in the chest. Thought says, “its just a thought. It cannot be hurt.” I ask, “can it be imagined to be hurt?” Thought says, “yes, it can.” I ask, “can that imagined hurt exist apart from thought?” Thought says, “No.”
Now, something particularly interesting emerged from your experiences with the retreat group, your father and the Zen community:
If you believe this "me" is only apparent, you will harm more and be alone, that seems to be an important belief worth investigating. There are two approaches to it: one, looking for Zach, to the person that this experience is happening TO, the one that FEELS these emotions...and the other, to work with the actual sensations.
So…
When someone disagrees with you or feels hurt by something you've said, there may be uncomfortable sensations, thoughts about having done something wrong, and an urge to explain, apologise or defend yourself.
But where exactly is the separate "me" that needs defending?
I am going to add “explaining” and “apologizing”. It feels like all of it is a desire to be seen or understood as a “something”--as a “choiceless zach”, or just an “object” or “container” of experiences. I ask thought, “What wants to be seen?” “Thought says, “that you are good”. Deep sigh arises. I ask thought, “what does “good” mean?” Thought says, “worthy of love and connection”. Tears and shaking are arising. I ask thought, “does someone need to deem you worthy of those things?” Thought says, “yes.” I ask thought, “is that a thought or the truth?” Thought laughs, and says, “it’s all thought over here”. Laughter out loud arises. I ask thought, “apart from thought, does this rule actually exist?” Thought says, “ it is just a rule in thought.” I ask thought, “where is this “me” that wants to be worthy of love and connection?” Thought shows me many images where these desires occurred to a younger me. I ask thought, “apart from thought, do these images exist?” Thought says, “no.”. I ask thought, “can love and connection be offered now?” Deep sigh arises. Feeling of appreciation arises. I ask thought, “is there a “me” that can obtain love or connection from others?” Thought says, “connection is a concept necessitating another and necessitating a separation between the “me” and this “another” in the first place. Love is always present, you just don’t see it.” I ask thought, “OK, but is there a “me” that could obtain these things?” Thought says, “where would you obtain these from? You are not separate.” I ask thought, “OK, but who is the one who is not separate?” Thought says, “you”. I ask thought, “Apart from thought, do I exist?” Thought says, “no.” I ask thought, “OK, so who needs defending, who needs to apologize? Who needs to take responsibility? “Thought says, “thought.” I ask thought, “apart from thought, does thought exist?” Thought says, “no.”
And when the thought appears that without believing in a "me" you'll harm others or end up alone, what makes that thought true? Is it evidence of an actual self, or a prediction about what might happen (we can explore time)?
More thought says its true or shows me images suggesting its true. Thought is not evidence of its content. It is a prediction of what might happen.
Now back to the second approach… Whenever a strong emotion arrives, try and deconstruct it down to bodily sensations. That is to say, see that certain sensations tend to be labelled in certain ways, e.g. the thought label “fear” may be habitually applied to a knot-like sensation in the stomach area. “Anxiety” may be the thought label for trembling hands and nausea, etc. They may vary for different people, so it helps to be aware of what it is for you. Can you give some examples of this from your experience?
The feeling “I” did something wrong/guilt/shame/anxiety is usually a pit in my stomach. Anger usually appears as a kind of intense pulsing in my head. Sadness/dispair/loneliness appears as a hollow sensation in my chest.
So let’s work with “fear”. When ‘fear’ appears, close your eyes and do the following... Look at the label ‘fear’ itself. See the label/word ‘fear’ as a typewritten word
Does the label ‘fear’ know anything about fear, or is the word just a bunch of letters?
Is the label ‘fear’ itself fearful?
The label in my mind doesn’t know anything about fear.
Can you find anyone/anything in the word itself that is fearful?
No. All I can find that is fearful is the images that come up when I see the word.
Then look at the sensation and ignore everything else but the sensation itself.
Inquire into the sensation and ask if the sensation itself knows anything about ‘fear’. Does the sensation itself suggest in any way that it is fear or that it is fearful?
Can you find anyone or anything within or behind the sensation that is fearful?
The sensation is in my chest, feels like a fast vibration. It is very subtle, like just barely above the surface of awareness. It is very difficult to separate out the story from the sensation itself. Actually now the sensation is in my head, a pressure between the eyes that feels like its growing bigger. Now the sensation is both in the chest and between the eyes.
The sensation does not contain any information about what it is, or a story about itself. The sensation. I’m not even sure it has labels like “painful” without thought.
When you have done this and if no one/no thing is found, then just sit with the sensation. Just breathe normally, notice the thoughts and images that appear and let them pass on by. Allow the sensation all the room it needs without pushing it aside or judging it. If it becomes too intense just take a couple of deep breaths into the sensation itself. If the sensation does not dissipate at all or only dissipates a little, that is okay, just notice it, without doing anything with it and just go about your day.
We are not trying to get rid of the sensation labelled ‘fear’ or the arising thoughts or images. We are only LOOKING to see what is actually appearing (ie thought, sensation, colour/image) as opposed to what thought is saying ABOUT what actually IS. Freedom comes from allowing whatever appears to appear without the need for it to be different or to leave. Perhaps the recognition doesn't require a new way of living at all. Perhaps ordinary life can simply continue, without the assumption of a separate entity running it.
What do you find?
The sensation is there. The stories (thought) about the sensation are there. The urge to inquire, “is the story true?” and “did the sensation cause the story? Did the story cause the sensation or amplify it?” arise and persist. Now the sensation is not felt anymore, the story fades. The urge to inquire drops.
Nothing is excluded.