realizing selflessness

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5870
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby vinceschubert » Sat Nov 14, 2026 5:34 am

I want to read or reread this story, but I can't seem to find it in your Substack. Can you send a direct link?
Ha, i couldn't find it either and when i confronted ChatGPT about it, it confessed to hallucinating it. That gave me the theme of a story for next week. Here it is.
This is now the proper Ravi story—the realization happens here, rather than being referred to as though it had already happened.

# Story: The Thing Ravi Had Been Studying Around

## Song: Under All the Questions
## Short Story
Ravi had brought three books.
Maeve looked at them.
“Emergency?”
“I’ve been thinking about something.”
“Obviously.”
Ravi ignored her.
“I think there’s a connection between predictive processing, Buddhist dependent arising and the way the nervous system—”
“Ravi.”
He stopped.
Tess smiled.
Maeve asked, “What happened?”
Ravi looked irritated.
“That’s what I’m explaining.”
“No. You’re explaining what you think about what happened. What happened?”
He went quiet.
The night before, Ravi had woken at two forty-three.
There had been tightness in his chest.
A sense that something was wrong.
No clear reason.
Then the familiar movement started.
He reached for his phone.
Read an article.
Then another.
Looked up something he remembered from a retreat.
Opened notes he had made six years earlier.
By four o’clock he had learned quite a lot.
The tightness was still there.
Maeve asked, “What were you trying to find?”
“Understanding.”
“What would understanding have given you?”
Ravi started answering intellectually.
Then stopped.
Something shifted in his face.
“Safety.”
Nobody spoke.
Ravi looked down.
“If I understand what’s happening, then it feels like it can’t overwhelm me.”
Tess said softly, “So maybe the studying isn’t always about curiosity.”
Ravi shook his head.
“No.”
He looked almost embarrassed.
“Sometimes I think I’ve been studying around fear.”
Maeve said nothing.
Ravi continued.
“Thirty-four years of maps.”
Meditation.
Buddhism.
Advaita.
Neuroscience.
Somatic work.
Inquiry.
Teachers.
Books.
Retreats.
Frameworks.
“What if a lot of it was me trying to make sure nothing could arrive that I didn’t understand?”
Maeve asked, “And did it work?”
Ravi laughed.
“No.”
The room stayed quiet.
Then he said:
“I think I’ve been trying to know enough that life couldn’t surprise me.”
Maeve nodded.
“And life?”
“Has been extremely uncooperative.”
That got a laugh.
Ravi smiled too.
For once, he didn’t explain the laugh.

## Long Story
Ravi had always loved understanding.
That part was genuine.
He loved ideas.
He loved seeing connections.
He loved the moment when something confusing suddenly made sense.
There was nothing wrong with any of that.
But lately he had begun to notice something else mixed in with curiosity.
Urgency.
### The Two O’Clock Scholar
It happened at two forty-three in the morning.
Ravi woke with a tight chest.
Nothing dramatic.
No nightmare.
No obvious problem.
Just activation.
The body felt alert.
Uneasy.
Thought appeared:
**What is this?**
Then:
**Why is this happening?**
Then:
**There must be something underneath it.**
Within minutes he was reading.
An article about autonomic regulation.
Then a paper on prediction error.
Then notes from a retreat.
Then something on attachment.
Then a lecture he had bookmarked months ago.
At four twelve he noticed he had seven browser tabs open.
The original sensation was still there.
He laughed without humour.
### The Group
The next afternoon Ravi brought it up.
“I think there may be a relationship between conceptual understanding and physiological regulation.”
Maeve looked at him.
“You woke frightened and read for ninety minutes.”
Ravi frowned.
“That’s an oversimplification.”
“Good.”
Tess laughed.
Ravi sighed.
“Yes. Fine.”
“What happened before the reading?”
“Tightness.”
“And after?”
“More thoughts.”
“What were you hoping the thoughts would do?”
Ravi started:
“From a predictive-processing perspective—”
Maeve raised one finger.
He stopped.
“Answer the question.”
Ravi looked down.
“I suppose I wanted to understand it.”
“And if you understood it?”
“I’d know what was happening.”
“And then?”
He paused.
“I could handle it.”
“And if you couldn’t understand it?”
Another pause.
Then Ravi said:
“I’d be helpless.”
The word surprised him.
### Helpless
He repeated it.
“Helpless.”
Something moved in the chest.
Not larger.
Just more obvious.
Ravi sat very still.
Jonah asked, “Does that word fit?”
“Yes.”
Ravi rubbed his hands together.
“I don’t like it.”
Maeve said, “That’s allowed.”
“I’ve spent most of my life assuming understanding was strength.”
“Sometimes it is.”
Ravi nodded.
“But maybe I also used it to avoid helplessness.”
That was harder.
### The First Memory
A memory appeared.
He was nine or ten.
His parents were arguing in the kitchen.
Not violence.
Nothing dramatic enough for a biography.
Just two adults speaking sharply in a way Ravi couldn't understand.
He remembered sitting in his room with an encyclopedia open.
Planets.
Distances.
Moons.
Numbers.
Things that could be known.
Ravi immediately started explaining.
“Obviously we shouldn't reduce thirty-four years of seeking to a childhood adaptation—”
Maeve said, “Nobody did.”
He stopped.
Tess smiled.
Ravi laughed.
“Right.”
The memory didn't prove anything.
It was simply one condition among countless conditions.
But it had a flavour.
Confusion outside.
Order inside the book.
### The Search
Ravi began looking back.
At seventeen he read philosophy.
At twenty-three he discovered meditation.
At twenty-seven Buddhism.
Then retreats.
Teachers.
Nonduality.
Advaita.
Neuroscience.
Somatic approaches.
Psychology.
Inquiry.
Every time something didn't fit, Ravi searched for the framework that would include it.
He had always described this as sincerity.
And it was.
But now another possibility appeared.
Maybe some of the drive said:
**If I can understand enough, nothing can get me.**
He said it aloud.
The room went quiet.
### Tess Asks the Obvious
Tess asked, “Has understanding ever stopped life getting you?”
Ravi smiled.
“No.”
Grief still happened.
Illness happened.
Relationships ended.
People misunderstood him.
Bodies aged.
Plans failed.
Fear appeared.
“Understanding helped with many things,” Ravi said.
“But it never made me invulnerable.”
Maeve nodded.
“That sounds expensive.”
### Not Anti-Intellectual
Ravi became defensive.
“So what are you suggesting? That I stop studying?”
“No.”
“That concepts are useless?”
“No.”
“That thought is avoidance?”
“No.”
Ravi looked suspicious.
Maeve said, “You're arguing with something nobody said.”
Everyone laughed.
Ravi caught it too.
Even now the mind was protecting the role of understanding.
Maeve continued.
“Read because you're interested.”
“Study because it helps.”
“Think because thinking happens.”
“But maybe occasionally notice when curiosity has turned into emergency.”
That landed.
### Curiosity and Urgency
Ravi began to see the difference.
Curiosity had space.
It could stop.
Urgency couldn't.
Curiosity:
**That’s interesting.**
Urgency:
**I need to understand this now.**
Curiosity could read one article.
Urgency opened seventeen tabs.
Curiosity could say:
**I don't know.**
Urgency heard:
**Danger.**
### The Conversation
A week later Jonah disagreed with Ravi about something.
Normally Ravi would explain.
Then clarify.
Then refine.
Then offer another example.
Then correct the example.
This time he noticed the body before speaking.
Tightness.
Forward movement.
Urgency.
Thought:
**He doesn't understand.**
Then:
**I need to explain this properly.**
Ravi paused.
Jonah said, “What?”
Ravi smiled.
“I noticed something.”
“What?”
“I want to make you understand me.”
Jonah shrugged.
“I might not.”
Ravi felt the old impulse.
Explain again.
Instead:
“Apparently.”
The conversation continued.
Nothing collapsed.
### The Safety of Being Right
At the next group Ravi said, “I think being understood has been part of it too.”
Maeve nodded.
“If someone understands what I mean, I feel safer.”
Tess asked, “Why?”
“Because then reality is shared.”
He heard himself.
“That sounds strange.”
“It sounds human,” Maeve said.
Ravi thought.
If someone disagreed, it destabilised the map.
If enough people agreed, the map felt solid.
Authority had partly been social.
Books.
Teachers.
Traditions.
Experts.
Agreement.
All helping create a sense:
**I know where I am.**
### The New Problem
Ravi then did something perfectly Ravi.
He made a model.
Curiosity → uncertainty → fear → urgency → conceptualisation → temporary relief.
He showed it to the group.
Maeve stared at the page.
Ravi saw her expression.
“Oh.”
Tess burst out laughing.
“You made a map of your map addiction.”
Ravi looked at the diagram.
Then laughed too.
It was a good diagram.
That wasn't the issue.
The issue was what job he wanted it to do.
### Maeve’s Question
Maeve asked:
“What happens if you don't explain this one?”
Ravi looked startled.
“What do you mean?”
“Don't explain why you explain.”
Silence.
The chest tightened.
There was a faint sinking sensation.
Then thought:
**But I need to understand what this means.**
Ravi watched it.
For perhaps twenty seconds nobody spoke.
Then he said:
“This is very uncomfortable.”
Maeve nodded.
“What’s uncomfortable?”
“Not knowing.”
“Anything else?”
“Feeling exposed.”
“Anything else?”
Ravi waited.
“Helpless.”
There it was again.
No explanation followed.
### Nothing Underneath?
Ravi asked, “Do you think helplessness is underneath all of it?”
Maeve said, “I have no idea.”
He looked almost disappointed.
“You’re not going to tell me?”
“No.”
Tess smiled.
Ravi saw the joke.
He wanted Maeve to give him a final explanation of his need for final explanations.
### The Very Old Promise
That night Ravi noticed the promise more clearly.
It wasn't verbal.
But if translated, it sounded like:
**Understand this and you'll be safe.**
**Understand yourself and you won't suffer.**
**Understand awakening and you won't miss it.**
**Understand other people and they won't surprise you.**
**Understand the body and it won't betray you.**
**Understand death and you won't fear it.**
The promise had never been fulfilled.
Yet each new framework renewed it.
### Not Giving Up Knowledge
Ravi worried that seeing this would make him stupid.
Then laughed at himself.
He still knew what he knew.
Books had genuinely helped.
Meditation had changed him.
Neuroscience had given useful models.
Inquiry had opened things.
Nothing needed throwing away.
The only thing being questioned was the belief that enough understanding could remove vulnerability.
### Another Night
Two weeks later he woke again.
Three fourteen.
Chest tight.
The phone was beside the bed.
Thought:
**Look this up.**
He reached for it.
Stopped.
Not because reading was forbidden.
He asked:
**What am I hoping the answer will give me?**
Safety.
There it was.
He put the phone back.
The chest stayed tight.
For a while.
Thoughts continued.
No great peace descended.
He felt tired and vulnerable.
And oddly, that was simpler.
### The Morning
At breakfast Ravi realised something.
He hadn't solved the feeling.
He hadn't identified its cause.
He hadn't found the correct framework.
And the morning had still arrived.
Coffee.
Toast.
Bird outside.
A message from Jonah.
Life had proceeded without explanatory permission.
### Back at the Group
Ravi said:
“I think I’ve been studying around it.”
Maeve looked up.
“Around what?”
“Fear.”
He paused.
“Helplessness.”
Nobody congratulated him.
That helped.
Ravi continued.
“I thought I was seeking truth.”
Tess said, “Weren’t you?”
“Yes.”
He smiled.
“That’s what makes it interesting. I was.”
“And?”
“I was also trying to become someone nothing could overwhelm.”
Maeve nodded.
“Can you?”
“No.”
“Bad luck.”
Ravi laughed.
### The Wobble
For several days after that, he felt slightly lost.
If understanding wasn't going to save him, what was all the learning for?
Then he noticed the question itself.
It wanted a new purpose.
A new framework.
A new certainty.
He laughed.
Curiosity could continue without employment as bodyguard.
### The Bookshop
Ravi went into a bookshop.
He picked up a new book on consciousness.
Immediate excitement.
Then suspicion.
**Am I seeking again?**
He nearly put it down.
Then caught the new trap.
Not reading could become another strategy.
He bought it.
Read fifty pages that evening.
Enjoyed them.
Stopped when tired.
No spiritual drama.
### Paul Asks
Paul asked Ravi later:
“So how do you know whether studying is curiosity or avoidance?”
Ravi started giving criteria.
Then stopped.
“I don't always.”
Paul smiled.
“That must hurt.”
“Deeply.”
They laughed.
Ravi continued:
“Maybe the giveaway is urgency.”
“If I feel I have to know.”
“If not knowing feels unsafe.”
“If I can't stop.”
“Then?”
“Then maybe I notice that.”
“And stop studying?”
“Not necessarily.”
Paul nodded.
That was becoming familiar.
### The Realisation
At the next meeting Ravi said:
“I used to imagine that eventually I’d understand enough to rest.”
Maeve listened.
“But now I think rest might include not understanding.”
Silence.
Not mystical silence.
Nobody knew what to say.
Ravi looked around the room.
Then added:
“And I notice I want to explain that.”
Everyone laughed.
Maeve pointed at him.
“Leave it.”
Ravi opened his mouth.
Closed it.
Smiled.
And left it.

# Investigation: What Is Understanding Supposed to Give You?
Think of something you are currently trying hard to understand.
A relationship.
A feeling.
Awakening.
Your past.
Someone else's behaviour.
A health concern.
A decision.
A spiritual teaching.
First ask:
**Is there useful information here?**
If yes, learn it.
This Investigation is not anti-thinking.
Understanding matters.
Knowledge matters.
Expertise matters.
Now ask something different:
**What do I expect understanding to give me emotionally?**
Certainty?
Safety?
Control?
Relief?
Approval?
Protection from surprise?
Freedom from helplessness?
Notice whether:
**I want to understand**
has become:
**I must understand.**
What changes in the body when “must” appears?
Can curiosity stop?
Can urgency stop?
Notice the flavour of each.
Curiosity may say:
**Interesting.**
Urgency may say:
**Solve this now.**
What happens if no answer comes?
Fear?
Shame?
Exposure?
A sense of being stupid?
Helplessness?
Now ask:
**What is supposedly dangerous about not knowing?**
Don't rush to answer.
Notice what appears.
Perhaps a memory.
Perhaps only sensation.
Perhaps nothing.
No original cause has to be found.
Now consider your history.
When life felt confusing or unstable, did understanding provide relief?
Books?
Rules?
Religion?
Science?
Spirituality?
Other people's certainty?
Could those have been useful and protective?
No need to condemn them.
The question is whether an old solution is still being asked to do an impossible job.
Ask:
**Has understanding ever made me invulnerable?**
Has it prevented grief?
Loss?
Ageing?
Misunderstanding?
Unexpected events?
Can understanding improve response without guaranteeing safety?
Now notice the wish:
**If I understand myself completely, I will stop suffering.**
Is that a fact?
Or another desired outcome?
What if some aspects of this organism remain mysterious?
Can life continue?
Try leaving one small question unanswered.
Not as a spiritual exercise.
Simply because the answer isn't currently known.
Notice the urge to close it.
What does that urge feel like?
What story accompanies it?
Now look at disagreement.
When someone doesn't understand you, what happens?
Is there an impulse to explain again?
And again?
What would their understanding give you?
Connection?
Validation?
Safety?
Can another person misunderstand you without reality becoming unstable?
Now take awakening.
How much of seeking has been:
**If I understand awakening correctly, it will happen**?
Could explanation itself become another way of standing one step away from the event?
Ask:
**What is actually here before I explain it?**
Then notice explanation arising.
Nothing wrong with explanation.
But what job is it doing?
Finally:
**Could curiosity remain after the demand for certainty weakens?**
What would learning look like if it didn't have to save you?
Read.
Explore.
Question.
Enjoy ideas.
Change your mind.
And sometimes:
not know.
Not knowing doesn't have to be a failure of understanding.
Sometimes it is simply the most accurate description available.

Song: Under All the Questions
Story: The Thing Ravi Had Been Studying Around
Verse 1

I gathered every answer
I could carry through the years,
built shelves from explanations,
built theories round my fears.
I thought if I knew deeply
what every movement meant,
nothing could surprise me,
nothing could get in.
Chorus
Under all the questions,
under all I tried to know,
there was something quieter
I wouldn't let me show.
Not a lack of wisdom,
not a failure to explain,
just the fear of being helpless
when no answer ever came.
Verse 2
I learned the names of patterns,
the workings of the mind,
the maps of every pathway
I was hoping I could find.
Each one gave a shelter,
each one helped me see,
but none could make a promise
that life would spare me.
Chorus
Under all the questions,
under all I tried to know,
there was something quieter
I wouldn't let me show.
Not a lack of wisdom,
not a failure to explain,
just the fear of being helpless
when no answer ever came.
Verse 3
Curiosity has breathing room.
Urgency says now.
One can leave the book half-read.
One must discover how.
One can say, “That's interesting.”
One says, “Make me safe.”
And sometimes both are present
in the very same place.
Bridge
Keep the books.
Keep the questions.
Keep the wonder too.
Nothing wrong with learning
what learning lets us do.
But no amount of knowing
can guarantee the ground.
Life can still arrive
before the explanation's found.
Verse 4
Maybe I was searching
for a place beyond surprise,
where nothing unexplained
could ever enter through my eyes.
But morning came without me
solving what the midnight meant.
Life had never waited
for my understanding's consent.
Final Chorus
Under all the questions,
there was nothing wrong to mend,
only fear that knowing
had been hired to defend.
Now the questions still can visit.
I can follow where they go.
But they don't have to save me
from the things I do not know.
Outro
A question comes.
An answer comes.
Another question follows.
Sometimes curiosity opens.
Sometimes fear is borrowing its clothes.
Nothing needs condemning.
Nothing needs completed.
And sometimes
the most honest thing
under all the questions
is simply:
I don't know.
https://soundcloud.com/vince-schubert-1 ... -questions

v
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Sat Nov 14, 2026 4:46 pm

Now I’m curious about all sorts of things about how you’ve been using AI and how it fooled you, but those questions don’t seem to belong here, so:
Thanks for the story! (Which was just written? But which should’ve appeared earlier?)

* * * * *

Was just about to try to wrap up and reflect on something from the meeting, having watched my parts of the recording last night, but then had a communication snafu with spouse on the phone.
And it’s early-ish in the morning, when I feel like my day is just getting under way, which is a time when I’d prefer not to talk to anyone because having conversations of any sort often results in crying or suppressing the urge to cry.
Pausing now that the conversation is over to examine the bodily sensations in detail.
On the macro level: tightness in throat; tears arising, with an attempt to suppress them because I’m at the coffee shop.
Aw, geez, gonna go sit in my car . . .

Sobbing—noisily, since no one can hear me.
Examining sobbing: spasms in throat that seem to include full glottal stops.
And now that I took a moment to write that last sentence, the sobbing has stopped.
So let’s take a look at the remaining bodily sensations . . .
Tightness in face that’s hard to notice or pinpoint until I let the face relax and see what just loosened up.
Tightness along brow line and in cheeks that feels like it’s all pulling in toward the eyes.
Lips tightened. Jaw pulled up unnaturally.
Very aware of the area of the neck around the larynx, kind of like lump in throat or tightness in throat but not exactly or just a very minor version of that.
Reread what I’d written so far (and tweaked it a little), and the sobbing starts again.
Nose getting drippy and stuffed up.

It seems like rereading the bit about how talking in the morning elicits tears is what especially elicited more tears.
So it seems like there could be a “Why do I have to deal with something so odd and annoying?” element to that, but I don’t know, and I think you don’t think I need to know.

Not crying at the moment.
Looking at bodily sensations one more time . . .
Looking for but not finding constriction in chest, belly, abdomen. Or not much anyway.
Can feel the tears drying under my eyes.

Gotta go get some work done.
Looking in rearview mirror: Yep, all around the eyes is red and puffy.
Will order my decaf latte on the app and grab it from the pickup counter, rather than getting in line and interacting face-to-face with a barista.

And again, why am I doing this—that is, examining these bodily sensations in detail?

Thinking about interaction with spouse again, and throat starts to tighten again.
OK, enough.

* * * * *

Curious what you meant about my mind being “mechanical.”
You were suggesting that that’s helpful for this sort of inquiry, but it doesn’t exactly sound like a good thing.

OK. Right. Work . . .

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5870
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby vinceschubert » Sun Nov 15, 2026 12:49 am

I think that's a very worthwhile possibility to explore, particularly given your history of finding it difficult to express your needs or wants when you anticipate someone else's reaction.

Notice the sequence. A communication difficulty with your husband, tears, tightness around the throat and larynx, and attempts to suppress the crying. Then you begin carefully examining the physical sensations.
Is this examining an avoidance? (don't answer - just consider the possibility without a conclusion)
What if your examining the expression of something without noticing what wants to be expressed?
The throat sensations might simply be part of the physiology of crying. But they could also accompany an inhibited impulse to speak, protest, say NO, ask for something, or express hurt.
Was there anything you wanted to say during that conversation with your husband but didn't? Perhaps a protest, a need, a feeling, or even just “I don't want to talk right now.”
i'm not suggesting there must be something buried there. But given what you've told me about sometimes finding it easier to suppress your own needs than face someone else's reaction, I wonder whether this resonates.
..And there's no need to find an answer. Just the possibility that these sensations might be part of an expression, rather than simply something to examine.

And there's another interesting possibility: even if something wants to be said, what happens in response to that impulse? Is there fear, hesitation, anticipated conflict, or a familiar sense that expressing it would create more trouble?

That would bring us right back to the inquiry into reactions to reactions, but in a much more immediate, emotionally relevant way.

The crucial thing is not to assume that the throat is holding an unspoken truth. It's to give you room to discover whether there's an impulse you haven't noticed, without turning that discovery into another job.

much love

vince
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Sun Nov 15, 2026 2:25 pm

Was there anything you wanted to say during that conversation with your husband but didn't? Perhaps a protest, a need, a feeling, or even just “I don't want to talk right now.”
And there's no need to find an answer. Just the possibility that these sensations might be part of an expression, rather than simply something to examine.
The most striking thing I noticed after reading your post is that I did not feel eager to work on a response, as I usually do. I’m inclined to attribute that in part to a slightly diminished urgency about seeking and in part to the seemingly psychological/therapeutic nature of the questions. I feel some resistance to examining whether that investigation of bodily sensations was an avoidance of something wanting to be expressed—a resistance that would probably be of interest to my (nonexistent) therapist—even though I realize that you mainly wanted me to note that possibility. (It has been noted.)
even if something wants to be said, what happens in response to that impulse? Is there fear, hesitation, anticipated conflict, or a familiar sense that expressing it would create more trouble?

That would bring us right back to the inquiry into reactions to reactions, but in a much more immediate, emotionally relevant way.
That part feels a little more in line with LU inquiry, but there is still resistance and/or a sense of weariness. OK, typing “weariness” brought up a lot of tearful emotion. (I’d already been feeling tightness in the throat throughout working on this message.) Maybe it’s just temper tantrum time again.

I did note and appreciate this:
without turning that discovery into another job.

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Mon Nov 16, 2026 12:11 am

Was having a depressed, unhappy, weepy day. After a post-lunch nap, was trying to entertain or occupy myself and just ended up feeling worse. Then quit trying and stayed curled up in bed, listening to sounds and dozing off, and that has been much better. Back to it . . .

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Mon Nov 16, 2026 8:35 pm

For the “gradual changes” file:

- A familiar thought arose two days ago, wondering if I’d ever be able to forgive the universe for my decades of suffering. It occurred to me that that thought hasn’t been arising so often or with so much force lately. It passed fairly quickly.

- Ended the day yesterday with an unpleasant thing that caused me less suffering than it would have a year ago. A big part of what made it easier was that spouse dealt with it better than he would have a year ago or even six months ago, but I think the way things are changing for me also helped.

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Mon Nov 16, 2026 9:51 pm

From “The Unpleasantness Paul Couldn’t Find”:
“I realised something strange. ‘Unpleasant’ seems to be another interpretation.”
I’m feeling pretty good about having made that observation a couple days before Paul did.

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Tue Nov 17, 2026 3:30 am

P.S. I appreciated the nuanced analysis in “The Unpleasantness Paul Couldn’t Find.”

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:50 pm

Had a temper tantrum in my car in the coffee shop parking lot. I used the dictation program that I went to great pains to choose and download for my husband a week or two ago and talked into it to verbalize my complaints against the universe, which right now mostly start with “I don't want to.” There were lots of specifics, including many things I have to do on a daily basis, but the main repeated complaint was, “I don't wanna suffer anymore.” (The dictation program did spell it “wanna” and didn’t include an exclamation point.) I don't wanna suffer anymore! I don't wanna suffer anymore! I don't wanna suffer anymore! And now I'm sobbing again (still in the car).

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5870
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby vinceschubert » Wed Nov 18, 2026 8:00 am

Had a temper tantrum in my car in the coffee shop parking lot. I used the dictation program that I went to great pains to choose and download for my husband a week or two ago and talked into it to verbalize my complaints against the universe, which right now mostly start with “I don't want to.” There were lots of specifics, including many things I have to do on a daily basis, but the main repeated complaint was, “I don't wanna suffer anymore.” (The dictation program did spell it “wanna” and didn’t include an exclamation point.) I don't wanna suffer anymore! I don't wanna suffer anymore! I don't wanna suffer anymore! And now I'm sobbing again (still in the car).
Hi Kim,

Something interesting here.

Earlier you described the tightness in your throat, the glottal stops, and the sobbing. I wondered whether there might be something wanting to be expressed.

And now words have come pouring out!

“I don't want to!” And, over and over, “I don't wanna suffer anymore!”

I wonder if there's something significant in allowing that protest to be expressed rather than examining the sensations associated with it.
Not because expressing it will necessarily make the suffering go away, but because there's something very immediate and heartfelt happening here.

And there's nothing wrong with that enormous “NO!”

Now I'm curious about something else. When that protest arises, is there also a reaction to *having* that protest? Perhaps frustration that it's still happening, a wish to get beyond it, or a demand that all this suffering must finally stop?
Or perhaps there's simply sobbing and protesting, without anything further being added.
No need to answer while you're in the thick of it. And certainly no need to manufacture more emotion or turn this into another exercise.

I'm not asking you to stop wanting relief from suffering.
I'm inviting a gentle curiosity about what happens when even that desperate wanting is allowed to be here, without becoming another problem to solve.

Love

v
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Wed Nov 18, 2026 10:44 am

Woke up in the middle of the night, looked at my phone, and saw the new post from you. Haven't been able to go back to sleep. Some of what's going through my head:

I wish the sobbing I described had felt purgative, but I feel like there's an endlessly renewable supply of those tears. It reminds me of when I lived at the Zen monastery more than 35 years ago and did a lot of crying in the zendo (meditation hall) after discovering that crying provided some temporary symptomatic relief; however, it didn't feel like I was addressing the underlying dis-ease.
I also find myself wondering if this has anything to do with awakening or whether I'm just getting some free online therapy.
Yes, the sobbing is heartfelt, and I don't feel like there's anything wrong with the big NO.
This reminds me of the year I taught preschool, in a class of two-year-olds, who are rightly known for their proclivity to say no.
When that protest arises, is there also a reaction to *having* that protest?
There's an immediate sense of relief in expressing the feelings, though not as much relief as I would wish.
Certainly there's a desire for the feelings to stop.
There's frustration at the sense that no "progress" is being made in addressing the feelings of resistance to doing the tasks of my everyday life.

(I'm surprised it took this long, but here comes more crying.)

Last night, going to bed, I was noticing that I was feeling weepy, angry, oppressed, and generally miserable, which feels like where I spent almost all of my time for about eight years, until about a year ago.

I wondered again about seasonal depression, which I do seem prone to, especially from about November through mid-January.

I don't wanna suffer anymore!!!

Gonna try to go back to sleep now . . .

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5870
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby vinceschubert » Wed Nov 18, 2026 12:35 pm

Hi K, I hear you. And I think there's something important in what you're saying.

You've known this suffering for a very long time. You've cried before, sometimes with temporary relief, but without feeling that the underlying difficulty had changed. So I can understand why another bout of sobbing doesn't feel like much of a discovery.
And you're quite right to question whether we're doing awakening inquiry or therapy. The distinction in terms of a descriptive name could get blurred. It would depend on how you define each one. No name/label will come close to what actually happens.
We're not trying to uncover and resolve all the psychological difficulties in your history. Nor am I suggesting that expressing the feelings will necessarily make them disappear.

What we're exploring is something rather more immediate.
There's the suffering, and there's that enormous, heartfelt "I don't want to suffer anymore!"

Then there's frustration that the suffering continues, disappointment that nothing seems to be changing, and perhaps the familiar hope that awakening will finally put an end to it.
Can you see how all of that is happening, without anybody choosing any of it?

Even the desperate wish for relief is something that arises. It doesn't need to be eliminated, justified, or turned into another problem.
And there's no requirement to be okay with suffering. That would be another demand!

Your observation about feeling as miserable as you did during those earlier years deserves attention, too. If seasonal depression is contributing, that's worth taking seriously in its own right. There's nothing contrary to awakening in seeking practical or professional help with that.

Most importantly, please don't measure what's happening by whether the tears stop or whether you feel you've made progress.

The invitation isn't to make suffering disappear. It's to discover what is actually happening, including the wanting for it to be otherwise.
And right now, there's nothing more you need to investigate. Get some sleep if you can.

Love


vince

Thanks for your feedback.
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Wed Nov 18, 2026 4:18 pm

By the way, when I said that I’d read your post in the middle of the night and couldn’t go back to sleep, I didn’t mean to imply that I was staying awake because of your post. I apologize if it sounded like that! I was pleased to see your message and found it comforting simply to be heard, but then my brain continued on with its unhappiness.

When I went back to bed, I surfaced briefly a couple of times from the unhappy thought storm to notice perceptions and then got submerged again, but I did get back to sleep in not too long.

As I just reread your middle-of-my-night message, I noticed that I hadn’t been in a place to hear this bit right then:
I'm inviting a gentle curiosity about what happens when even that desperate wanting is allowed to be here, without becoming another problem to solve.
I’m saving that and your second message to consider further and respond to later. Gotta do some editing now. (Hmm. I feel surprisingly not too resistant to that, merely annoyed and burdened.)

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Thu Nov 19, 2026 1:49 pm

I'm inviting a gentle curiosity about what happens when even that desperate wanting is allowed to be here, without becoming another problem to solve.
Yes. This is good.

I’m reminded of a Thich Nhat Hanh video I use in my Zen class in which he encourages us to embrace our anger tenderly, like a mother embracing her baby. Every time I watch that video, I think what a helpful image that is and that I wish I would remember it when it’s relevant, but I never do.

I’m going to write it out again here. When anger or other painful, difficult emotions come up, can I embrace them tenderly, like a mother embracing her baby? When “I don’t want to suffer anymore!!!” comes up, can I embrace it tenderly, cradling it in my arms with love and care and gentleness, stroking its head and cooing soothingly to it, while it wails and fusses?

Now returning to your latest message . . .

User avatar
whoknows
Posts: 554
Joined: Fri Mar 13, 2026 7:41 am

Re: realizing selflessness

Postby whoknows » Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:01 pm

Good morning, dear vince!
There's the suffering, and there's that enormous, heartfelt "I don't want to suffer anymore!"

Then there's frustration that the suffering continues, disappointment that nothing seems to be changing, and perhaps the familiar hope that awakening will finally put an end to it.
Can you see how all of that is happening, without anybody choosing any of it?
I suppose I can see cognitively that it’s all conditioned arising, but mere intellectual understanding doesn’t seem to be helpful.
When I first read this yesterday, what came up was something like: Yeah, great, I just have to suffer through whatever is presented. I have no choice but to live through all the pain. Terrific. (Here come the tears.)
At the moment, I don’t see how grokking that there’s no chooser could be helpful.
(The threatened tears quickly subsided.)
Even the desperate wish for relief is something that arises. It doesn't need to be eliminated, justified, or turned into another problem.
Yes. Right.
Reminding myself again that all of it can be embraced, like a mother lovingly holding her baby, rocking it for as long as it takes for the baby to cry it out and settle down and maybe fall asleep in her arms.
And there's no requirement to be okay with suffering. That would be another demand!
Yes, indeed.
I sometimes remember the meta-layers.
Pain can be seen as okay.
But sometimes there’s the suffering of not being okay with pain, and that suffering can also be seen as okay.
And when it doesn’t feel okay to not be okay with pain, even that next level of suffering can be seen as okay.
And so forth.
When it’s recognized that you’re not okay with not being okay with the original pain, it’s so hard to keep track of the layers that it’s almost funny, and there’s already a bit more distance and perspective on it all.
Most importantly, please don't measure what's happening by whether the tears stop or whether you feel you've made progress.
Um . . .
That sounds like good advice, but would you care to elaborate?
I was about to ask, “How do you measure progress?” but the answer might be, “Don’t try” or “There’s no such thing.” But maybe not. And that would be annoying.
Are we back to noting the gradual overall changes?
And/or do you have a secret little file in your head of things you’ve noticed but not commented on, based on the reasonable concern that K could get attached unhelpfully to things that seem like “progress”?
The invitation isn't to make suffering disappear. It's to discover what is actually happening, including the wanting for it to be otherwise.
Noted.

Re: “When Maeve Was Wrong,” I don’t seem to have any trouble thinking Maeve might be wrong. ;-) But she does often seem to be right, so I give careful consideration to what she says.


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot] and 20 guests