Has the Gate been crossed?

All threads where seeing happens are stored here. The complete list, sorted by guide, contains all links. The archives include threads of those that came to LU already seeing as well.
You are welcome to continue your conversation with your guide here after your name is turned blue.
User avatar
P5yx
Posts: 49
Joined: Sun Jan 21, 2024 10:59 pm

Re: Has the Gate been crossed?

Postby P5yx » Thu Nov 05, 2026 5:18 pm

How are things looking and feeling today?
Quite normal. From time to time inquiries into the observer position arise. There is a feeling that is interpreted as being close to seeing through the separate self entirely but some beliefs still seem to be operating. Something feels off. There is still this looking for the self to confirm it's not there. So the belief of a separate self must still be operating. I don't want to fool myself here. The mind is tricky.

Also there seems to be identification with inquiry. Looking for the inquirer... which in and of itself is another inquiry ... it's like an inward glance. This urge to inquire... or the sense of inquiry is misread a me doing it. Controlling the looking.

During the day, sometimes there are these feelings of enthusiasm that come with an overflow of potential expressions. Sometimes this even feels overwhelming and the mind steps in to structure these options. After being seen it immediately stops the task, however.

User avatar
P5yx
Posts: 49
Joined: Sun Jan 21, 2024 10:59 pm

Re: Has the Gate been crossed?

Postby P5yx » Thu Nov 05, 2026 7:29 pm

The I is the interpreted continuity projected onto the mechanics of fixation.

User avatar
Elad
Posts: 3081
Joined: Tue Apr 18, 2023 6:25 am

Re: Has the Gate been crossed?

Postby Elad » Fri Nov 06, 2026 8:47 pm

Without thinking about past and future, which inherently takes you into the realm of thought rather then direct experience:

What is not clear?

Is anything missing?
With love,
Elad

Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.

- Kahlil Gibran

One gets there by being there.

- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)

User avatar
P5yx
Posts: 49
Joined: Sun Jan 21, 2024 10:59 pm

Re: Has the Gate been crossed?

Postby P5yx » Fri Nov 06, 2026 9:12 pm

Without thinking about past and future, which inherently takes you into the realm of thought rather then direct experience:

What is not clear?
There is a kind of controller identification which tries to find something stable. In direct experience it a fixating mechanism. feels like having to hold something to know it.

Vigilance. Beneath a sensation the system wants to escape. Like a strong restlessness.
Is anything missing?
Yes! Don't know what though. There is this seeking pattern.

User avatar
Elad
Posts: 3081
Joined: Tue Apr 18, 2023 6:25 am

Re: Has the Gate been crossed?

Postby Elad » Sat Nov 07, 2026 5:57 pm

What is not clear?

There is a kind of controller identification which tries to find something stable. In direct experience it a fixating mechanism. feels like having to hold something to know it.

I could be wrong here, but the feeling is that your complex words just make everything harder, still lost in intellectualization rather then looking. What is a "fixating mechanism" in direct experience? What is really not clear? You should be able to write in a language a 7 year old could understand. That will help.



Vigilance. Beneath a sensation the system wants to escape. Like a strong restlessness.


Okay so there is restlessness. And what is not clear?



Is anything missing?
Yes! Don't know what though. There is this seeking pattern.
[/quote]
[/quote]



This reminds me of the famous passage from Moliere comedy where a medical student is asked why does opium put people to sleep and he answers something like "it is because there is in it a dormitive virtue [replace: mechanism, pattern, etc] that has lulls the senses to sleep.

Point beeing. You cant get out of there from inside of there. You dont see beyond thinking from inside thinking.

Spend time really looking. Is anything missing?

Don't accept mind "explanations" (stories), they just recreate the virtual experience ad infinitum. Really stay with direct experience until clarity beyond doubt.


Again you should be able to sat everything like you were speaking to a young child.
With love,
Elad

Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.

- Kahlil Gibran

One gets there by being there.

- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)

User avatar
P5yx
Posts: 49
Joined: Sun Jan 21, 2024 10:59 pm

Re: Has the Gate been crossed?

Postby P5yx » Sun Nov 08, 2026 7:34 pm

I could be wrong here, but the feeling is that your complex words just make everything harder, still lost in intellectualization rather then looking. What is a "fixating mechanism" in direct experience? What is really not clear? You should be able to write in a language a 7 year old could understand. That will help.
This might indeed be true. But isn't seen clearly in that case. I don't know.
Okay so there is restlessness. And what is not clear?
Oh... "this shouldn't be here" is a thought which seeks for clarity. But clarity just arises.
Spend time really looking. Is anything missing?
There can't be anything missing when really looking as nothing is apart then.but there is the desire to keep the seeing permanent. Thought creates the separation and thus the search back.
Don't accept mind "explanations" (stories), they just recreate the virtual experience ad infinitum. Really stay with direct experience until clarity beyond doubt.
There are these bounces into mind which _seem_ to disturb.

User avatar
Elad
Posts: 3081
Joined: Tue Apr 18, 2023 6:25 am

Re: Has the Gate been crossed?

Postby Elad » Mon Nov 09, 2026 7:10 pm

Okay good clarity here.

Now, lets look again, what do you truly wish for yourself?

Speak from the heart, let it flow, let go of all limitations of what is right through spiritual knowledge, or claims from LU or nonduality folks or anything else...

And also:

What is most helpful and fulfilling in life so far in your personal experience?
With love,
Elad

Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.

- Kahlil Gibran

One gets there by being there.

- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)

User avatar
P5yx
Posts: 49
Joined: Sun Jan 21, 2024 10:59 pm

Re: Has the Gate been crossed?

Postby P5yx » Tue Nov 10, 2026 3:44 pm

Now, lets look again, what do you truly wish for yourself?
This question initially spiked fear, followed by a cascade of thoughts projecting what needs to be let go off in order for such a wish to come true. After the frightening thoughts subsided, I asked again. I think what I truly wish for myself is being free from believing in the mind's torturing stories, to be seen, as well as to experience unmanaged expression. To be free from the personal suffering.
What is most helpful and fulfilling in life so far in your personal experience?
Self-expression aka burning for something.

I'd like to bring up the sense of observing once more as it seems so central for this inquiry into the separate self. If you don't want me to deviate from your questions, please tell me.
I looked into the mechanics of looking some more. There is the seen which seems to be there independently of looking. Sometimes the seen is clear, sometimes it is blurred. Sometimes it seems peripheral, sometimes it seems partial.

The looking is mostly automatic. It's a combination of tension patterns, a center from which perspective seems to flow towards the visual field, a narrowing/focusing of attention, movements in the eyes, etc. Some of the tension patterns carry a sense of agency. Specifically, when the visual field was updated, and stillness becomes apparent, sensations intensify. This intensity seems to spike the next looking. So there is this constant monitoring due to the restlessness underneath. None of this requires a separate self. but some parts feel like a me doing them. a holding pattern which feels like "I hold". In other words, looking still feels somehow managed.

User avatar
Elad
Posts: 3081
Joined: Tue Apr 18, 2023 6:25 am

Re: Has the Gate been crossed?

Postby Elad » Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:26 pm

Now, lets look again, what do you truly wish for yourself?
This question initially spiked fear, followed by a cascade of thoughts projecting what needs to be let go off in order for such a wish to come true. After the frightening thoughts subsided, I asked again. I think what I truly wish for myself is being free from believing in the mind's torturing stories,

1) What torturing stories are being believed right now? Check that many times, see what comes up.


to be seen, as well as to experience unmanaged expression.


Conventionally speaking you will continue to feel the difference between driving a car or choosing what movie to see on the one hand, and tripping over a stone on the other. If you cannot experientially feel the difference, you cannot function as a human. This is true also when it is seen that ultimately everything is spontaneous nature.

2) What reactions come up to this?

3) Give me an example of the kind of unmanaged expression you wish for yourself.


What is most helpful and fulfilling in life so far in your personal experience?
Self-expression aka burning for something.

4) Please explain this in a way so a 7 year old can understand. Give an example from your life.


I'd like to bring up the sense of observing once more as it seems so central for this inquiry into the separate self. If you don't want me to deviate from your questions, please tell me.
Not sure, lets see how it goes. I do think it would be good for you to try and focus deeply on just what I suggest for a while. But if any deep intuition that feels like truth from within comes up, I would always encourage you to honor it. The tricky part is separating deep intuition from staying in your habitual patterns without knowing it.

There is the seen which seems to be there independently of looking.

5) What do you mean by this, explain in simple words.

The looking is mostly automatic. It's a combination of tension patterns, a center from which perspective seems to flow towards the visual field, a narrowing/focusing of attention, movements in the eyes, etc. Some of the tension patterns carry a sense of agency. Specifically, when the visual field was updated, and stillness becomes apparent, sensations intensify. This intensity seems to spike the next looking. So there is this constant monitoring due to the restlessness underneath. None of this requires a separate self. but some parts feel like a me doing them. a holding pattern which feels like "I hold". In other words, looking still feels somehow managed.

Its hard for me to understand what you are saying. I honestly don't feel compelled to spend a lot of time trying (I studied math, philosophy and cognitive psychology in the past, but I find that almost everything that helps wake up goes in a much simpler direction). I am open to discover it is needed. But for now, are you up for keeping things much simpler? I don't think you have to anlyze experience with extraordinary complexity and refinement (which seems to happen here, more or less well executed, I cannot judge).
With love,
Elad

Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.

- Kahlil Gibran

One gets there by being there.

- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)

User avatar
P5yx
Posts: 49
Joined: Sun Jan 21, 2024 10:59 pm

Re: Has the Gate been crossed?

Postby P5yx » Sun Nov 15, 2026 4:16 pm

Sorry for letting you wait. I took some time to sit with your questions.
1) What torturing stories are being believed right now? Check that many times, see what comes up.
Mainly thoughts about losing my wife, not being able to fully met her needs/fulfill her, not being good enough. We had a series of honest talks yesterday which revealed that these fears were only in my thoughts. I grew up in a house where speaking my truth was strongly punished. So the past days, I faced this strong fear and was able to open up more and more. Now, I am starting to feel even mildly addicted to freely express my truth ^^. It still doesn't feel like the barrier is fully gone but I can see it's eroding after the talks with my wife.
Conventionally speaking you will continue to feel the difference between driving a car or choosing what movie to see on the one hand, and tripping over a stone on the other. If you cannot experientially feel the difference, you cannot function as a human. This is true also when it is seen that ultimately everything is spontaneous nature.

2) What reactions come up to this?
No strong reactions arose. It's not about those things. It's about the belief that experience has anything to do with ME having to manage it/being responsible for it.
3) Give me an example of the kind of unmanaged expression you wish for yourself.
Expressing freely on a moment-to-moment basis. E.g., speaking my truth without self-reference, doubts, fear of triggering someone even without having bad intentions, etc.
4) Please explain this in a way so a 7 year old can understand. Give an example from your life.
You know what, forget about that. The most personally fulfilling moments were all expressions of selfless love. Even from a personal perspective.
Not sure, lets see how it goes. I do think it would be good for you to try and focus deeply on just what I suggest for a while. But if any deep intuition that feels like truth from within comes up, I would always encourage you to honor it. The tricky part is separating deep intuition from staying in your habitual patterns without knowing it.
Yes, that's exactly the difficult part. I won't deviate from your questions until there is a really strong sense of intuition from here on anymore.
There is the seen which seems to be there independently of looking.
5) What do you mean by this, explain in simple words.
There is the visual field. It is just there.
Then there is this sense of actively looking towards something. There still seems to be the assumption of a looker. And that looker is further assumed to be ME.
When looking for the looker, all I can find are sensations, a sense of perspective, and thought images. Still, the assumption hasn't stopped operating.
It's hard for me to understand what you are saying. I honestly don't feel compelled to spend a lot of time trying (I studied math, philosophy and cognitive psychology in the past, but I find that almost everything that helps wake up goes in a much simpler direction). I am open to discover it is needed. But for now, are you up for keeping things much simpler? I don't think you have to anlyze experience with extraordinary complexity and refinement (which seems to happen here, more or less well executed, I cannot judge).
Please continue to point that out. I am definitely willing to describe experience in a different way. For me, this style of expressing feels natural so I will have to play around a little. Please bear with me :).

User avatar
Elad
Posts: 3081
Joined: Tue Apr 18, 2023 6:25 am

Re: Has the Gate been crossed?

Postby Elad » Sun Nov 15, 2026 9:21 pm

Sorry for letting you wait. I took some time to sit with your questions.
All good!

1) What torturing stories are being believed right now? Check that many times, see what comes up.
Mainly thoughts about losing my wife, not being able to fully met her needs/fulfill her, not being good enough. We had a series of honest talks yesterday which revealed that these fears were only in my thoughts. I grew up in a house where speaking my truth was strongly punished. So the past days, I faced this strong fear and was able to open up more and more. Now, I am starting to feel even mildly addicted to freely express my truth ^^. It still doesn't feel like the barrier is fully gone but I can see it's eroding after the talks with my wife.

Happy for you! This sounds very genuine and wholesome.

Conventionally speaking you will continue to feel the difference between driving a car or choosing what movie to see on the one hand, and tripping over a stone on the other. If you cannot experientially feel the difference, you cannot function as a human. This is true also when it is seen that ultimately everything is spontaneous nature.

2) What reactions come up to this?
No strong reactions arose. It's not about those things. It's about the belief that experience has anything to do with ME having to manage it/being responsible for it.


Okay. Lets focus on this seeming me who has to manage. Look in direct experience when constructive actions are taken. Is there ME needed or present making them happen? Or they just come naturally when they come?

No answer from conviction or memory! No it seems to be like this or that. Really look til it is clear. Look many times if needed,


3) Give me an example of the kind of unmanaged expression you wish for yourself.
Expressing freely on a moment-to-moment basis. E.g., speaking my truth without self-reference, doubts, fear of triggering someone even without having bad intentions, etc.


Does it take a self to experience fear or carefulness around others? How about babies, dogs and cats? Can they be afraid and be conditioned to be anxious through abuse?

4) Please explain this in a way so a 7 year old can understand. Give an example from your life.
You know what, forget about that. The most personally fulfilling moments were all expressions of selfless love. Even from a personal perspective.

Lovely. Write me a memory of a moment of selfless love.


Not sure, lets see how it goes. I do think it would be good for you to try and focus deeply on just what I suggest for a while. But if any deep intuition that feels like truth from within comes up, I would always encourage you to honor it. The tricky part is separating deep intuition from staying in your habitual patterns without knowing it.
Yes, that's exactly the difficult part. I won't deviate from your questions until there is a really strong sense of intuition from here on anymore.


Cool.

There is the seen which seems to be there independently of looking.
5) What do you mean by this, explain in simple words.
There is the visual field. It is just there.
Then there is this sense of actively looking towards something. There still seems to be the assumption of a looker. And that looker is further assumed to be ME.
When looking for the looker, all I can find are sensations, a sense of perspective, and thought images. Still, the assumption hasn't stopped operating.


Okay so it is clear that it is just a sense of self without a self? Like there is the capacity to see what here vs there and my body vs your body means, but none of it is believed to actually be a self?



It's hard for me to understand what you are saying. I honestly don't feel compelled to spend a lot of time trying (I studied math, philosophy and cognitive psychology in the past, but I find that almost everything that helps wake up goes in a much simpler direction). I am open to discover it is needed. But for now, are you up for keeping things much simpler? I don't think you have to anlyze experience with extraordinary complexity and refinement (which seems to happen here, more or less well executed, I cannot judge).
Please continue to point that out. I am definitely willing to describe experience in a different way. For me, this style of expressing feels natural so I will have to play around a little. Please bear with me :).


Yes you call habitual thinking/talking natural... We aim to go beyond that to the natural that comes from silence and the simplicity of seeing.
With love,
Elad

Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.

- Kahlil Gibran

One gets there by being there.

- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)

User avatar
P5yx
Posts: 49
Joined: Sun Jan 21, 2024 10:59 pm

Re: Has the Gate been crossed?

Postby P5yx » Mon Nov 16, 2026 5:06 pm

Happy for you! This sounds very genuine and wholesome.
Thank you :). It indeed felt very healing.
Okay. Lets focus on this seeming me who has to manage. Look in direct experience when constructive actions are taken. Is there ME needed or present making them happen? Or they just come naturally when they come?

No answer from conviction or memory! No it seems to be like this or that. Really look til it is clear. Look many times if needed,
Actions arise on their own. Some are accompanied by thoughts describing the deeds, some are accompanied by the sense of self.
Other actions are foregone by intentions, pretending to initiate those deeds. However, I cannot find a cause/effect relationship between thought/intention and action in direct experience. It rather looks like thoughts forgoing a corresponding action are just intentions to act, that arise after the organism has already decided to execute it. So the sense of self implies a separate self while none is found.
Does it take a self to experience fear or carefulness around others? How about babies, dogs and cats? Can they be afraid and be conditioned to be anxious through abuse?
No, it does not take a self to experience such emotions. The body feels it when certain conditions are met.
Lovely. Write me a memory of a moment of selfless love.
Maybe not a moment but the entire relationship with my wife with whom I walk this path together, feels like one big expression of selfless love. E.g., supporting each other to get free from our own conditioning. For me this often lead to strong fears of not knowing how this will play out for us, as breaking free from a set of beliefs is always a step into the unknown.
Okay so it is clear that it is just a sense of self without a self? Like there is the capacity to see what here vs there and my body vs your body means, but none of it is believed to actually be a self?
Yes. there is just this sense of self and thoughts describing that sense of self. I wouldn't even know what a separate self would consist of. In direct experience there are only the five senses. All else is a concept. However, there is still this belief that I am that sense of self. Don't know what it is though.
Yes you call habitual thinking/talking natural... We aim to go beyond that to the natural that comes from silence and the simplicity of seeing.
I felt excited after reading these statements. :)

User avatar
Elad
Posts: 3081
Joined: Tue Apr 18, 2023 6:25 am

Re: Has the Gate been crossed?

Postby Elad » Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:18 pm

Okay. Lets focus on this seeming me who has to manage. Look in direct experience when constructive actions are taken. Is there ME needed or present making them happen? Or they just come naturally when they come?

No answer from conviction or memory! No it seems to be like this or that. Really look til it is clear. Look many times if needed,
Actions arise on their own. Some are accompanied by thoughts describing the deeds, some are accompanied by the sense of self.
Other actions are foregone by intentions, pretending to initiate those deeds. However, I cannot find a cause/effect relationship between thought/intention and action in direct experience. It rather looks like thoughts forgoing a corresponding action are just intentions to act, that arise after the organism has already decided to execute it. So the sense of self implies a separate self while none is found.


Right. Continue to notice how thoughts and actions - including of the kinds we call intentions and effort arise without self. Like if you ask what is the strongest intention right now, or what is most deeply efforted towards now - can you see that whatever answer feels genuine just manifestst by itself.



Does it take a self to experience fear or carefulness around others? How about babies, dogs and cats? Can they be afraid and be conditioned to be anxious through abuse?
No, it does not take a self to experience such emotions. The body feels it when certain conditions are met.

Right


Lovely. Write me a memory of a moment of selfless love.
Maybe not a moment but the entire relationship with my wife with whom I walk this path together, feels like one big expression of selfless love. E.g., supporting each other to get free from our own conditioning. For me this often lead to strong fears of not knowing how this will play out for us, as breaking free from a set of beliefs is always a step into the unknown.


Wonderful!

Okay so it is clear that it is just a sense of self without a self? Like there is the capacity to see what here vs there and my body vs your body means, but none of it is believed to actually be a self?
Yes. there is just this sense of self and thoughts describing that sense of self. I wouldn't even know what a separate self would consist of. In direct experience there are only the five senses. All else is a concept. However, there is still this belief that I am that sense of self. Don't know what it is though.

You believe you are the sense of self - really?


What is this you that believes that? See it is all just a bunch of thoughts and sensations.


Yes you call habitual thinking/talking natural... We aim to go beyond that to the natural that comes from silence and the simplicity of seeing.
I felt excited after reading these statements. :)

Good. Get into that silence and see the truth as it already is!



Heads-up I have guests from abroad here this week, and might be slower to answer.
With love,
Elad

Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.

- Kahlil Gibran

One gets there by being there.

- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)

User avatar
P5yx
Posts: 49
Joined: Sun Jan 21, 2024 10:59 pm

Re: Has the Gate been crossed?

Postby P5yx » Mon Nov 16, 2026 9:47 pm

No answer from conviction or memory! No it seems to be like this or that. Really look til it is clear. Look many times if needed,
What I over-read in your previous message was to not answer from conviction. Reading it again, now it pulled my attention. So I looked into what conviction is in direct experience. There is a sense of conviction which seems to be interpreted as truth. There is even a subtle sense of pride interwoven in it.
Right. Continue to notice how thoughts and actions - including of the kinds we call intentions and effort arise without self. Like if you ask what is the strongest intention right now, or what is most deeply efforted towards now - can you see that whatever answer feels genuine just manifestst by itself.
There is one set of actions that still carries a sense of agency. It's about controlling attention. While attention selecting parts of experience feels mostly automatic, focusing/widening/holding of attention feels effortful. This effort feels like my doing. E.g., blurring/sharpening the visual field.
You believe you are the sense of self - really?
This question spikes confusion. Like if I don't know where and what to look for...
What is this you that believes that? See it is all just a bunch of thoughts and sensations.
Yes, I see that. Then the sense of self relocates to the stillness.
Good. Get into that silence and see the truth as it already is!
After a while in that silence, intensity of sensations builds up and a sense of seeking arises interrupting the silence.
Heads-up I have guests from abroad here this week, and might be slower to answer.
All good. You accompanying this inquiry and sharing your time is greatly appreciated. Thank you so much :).
Last edited by P5yx on Wed Nov 18, 2026 1:49 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Elad
Posts: 3081
Joined: Tue Apr 18, 2023 6:25 am

Re: Has the Gate been crossed?

Postby Elad » Wed Nov 18, 2026 11:02 am

Hi, short answer because visit...
This question spikes confusion. Like if I don't know where and what to look for...

Good! Confusion is a proper response to being lost in story of self. See this.


Again, all of this is not about having really precise and fine language and accumulating nuanced observations. Just see no self. Just let truth and words come from silence.
With love,
Elad

Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.

- Kahlil Gibran

One gets there by being there.

- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)


Return to “ARCHIVES”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Semrush [Bot] and 11 guests