realizing selflessness
Re: realizing selflessness
This evening, the oppression and dread-full-ness and demand-resistance were starting to creep up on me again. Late-night sit was spent mostly lost in thought and feeling unhappy. Wasn’t sure how it helped to think that the demand-resistance has its roots long ago.
I do seem to get some winter doldrums every year. Maybe that’s part of what’s going on.
I do seem to get some winter doldrums every year. Maybe that’s part of what’s going on.
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: realizing selflessness
There is a desire here to express something i'm finding difficulty with. That is outcomes.and while I did feel like I might be working a little too hard and getting a little too frustrated on a couple of those, it seemed like it still might be a fruitful investigation.
It's not actually about outcomes. It's about what they mean for you.
Of course the brain produces an impression of what it is that we want. Even if it can't articulate it.
It might be some scenario that we call success, or satisfaction.
We cant produce or inhibit these consciously, but we can invite a (different than our usual) attitude towards them.
If we recognise that the presence of current conditions are what stimulate them (and don't believe that they say anything about a mythical self (take them personally) then the whole thing can take on a different importance.
So, the old way is that they turn up and induce stress, pressure to perform.
The new way is that they are polite and patiently wait for evaluation before being acted on or dismissed (or something else)
https://soundcloud.com/vince-schubert-1 ... ult-arrive
Re: realizing selflessness
Echoing back what I’m hearing, in order to listen better:It's not actually about outcomes. It's about what they mean for you.
. . . . .
This isn’t about outcomes. It’s about inviting a different attitude toward thoughts about desired outcomes. These thoughts simply arise due to conditions. They say nothing about a fictional “self,” and they aren’t “personal.” These thoughts don’t need to induce pressure to act in service of the desired outcomes. The existence of the thoughts can be recognized, and they can be given consideration before being acted on or not.
The “outcomes” most on my mind these days are awakening and, perhaps even more prominently right now, lessening suffering related to demand-resistance. I can see how what you said applies to the desired outcome of awakening. I’m not sure how it applies to the desired outcome of lessening suffering related to demand-resistance, and I’m not sure whether you even intended to be addressing that sort of thing.
But, let’s see . . . Due to conditions, the brain produces the idea that it would be good if there were less resistance to doing what needs to be done and/or more acceptance of the feelings of resistance. It’s supposedly not “me” thinking these things, and I supposedly don’t need to take them personally, which all makes sense, but it isn’t really felt, isn’t really experienced—well, not right now, but this is sort of abstract. Maybe I’ll take a look in a bit when I’m actually trying to get some things done.
Enjoyed getting a sneak preview of a new song. And the idea of asking what threat lies underneath the promise especially caught my attention.
That general idea also came up at a recent meeting (maybe partially after I signed off and then you signed off but other folks carried on, and I watched the recording). Although I understand the rhetoric of “giving up hope” on this kind of path (and have heard this idea spun out at length by Zen teacher Charlotte Joko Beck and Tibetan Buddhist teacher Chögyam Trungpa), I’ve never liked it because I think it can easily be misinterpreted in a harmful way by desperate seekers, like me a lot of the time. But I think I’m now in a place where it could be suitable, especially when accompanied by the pointers that were offered at the meeting (and in your song) toward examining the fear underlying the hope (or the threat underlying the promise), seeing the mistaken nature of that fear, seeing how the hope and the fear reinforce each other, and looking at what’s underneath the fear.
(It occurs to me that your word “promise” might generally be better than the word “hope” because of the deep significance embedded in the word “hope,” especially by Christianity. It might generally be better to talk about something like “seeing through misguided promises” rather than “giving up hope,” except maybe when you really want to give someone who’s ready for it a bracing slap in the face—which is perhaps what Joko and Trungpa were doing but then those talks got published for a general audience.)
Listened to the song again, and this line jumped out: “A preference can be present without becoming a despair.”
Time to try to get a task or two done . . .
* * * * *
Managed to get a few tasks done without a lot of angst, but didn’t even attempt to tackle grading the new batch of papers my students submitted, which is a task I’m dreading.
During my afternoon sit, I returned to this:
I was thinking about how some thoughts feel more like they’re just productions of the brain and others feel more like “I” am the thinker of them.Next time a thought arises and feels especially *mine*, see if you can catch what gives it that quality. Is there actually someone producing or receiving it, or is there thinking accompanied by that familiar sense of being behind the eyes?
The song stuck in my head seemed like a production of the brain.
Thoughts that were either memories about K’s past or plans for K’s future seemed more personal, though I’m not sure they actually felt more like “I” was thinking them.
It was interesting that the very frequent thoughts of putting experience into words—like for an LU post or to file for myself—seemed more toward the impersonal end, like there’s a transcription and summary program constantly running in the background that doesn’t have a lot to do with “me.”
I wondered if thoughts that spawn bodily sensations might feel more like they’re “mine” than other thoughts, but they probably also fall into the category of thoughts about K’s past or future.
So anyway, at least in this particular investigation, it seemed like it was mainly the content of the thoughts—that they were connected with the plot of K’s biography—that made them feel especially like “mine.”
I explored that for about the first half of the 25-minute sit.
Then the second half of the sit was mostly “unbound consciousness” practice, by which I mean spending some time with awareness less caught up in thoughts than usual.
I was especially aware of hearing, particularly the high-pitched whine of electricity, which was one of the main sounds happening.
Somewhat to my surprise, thoughts weren’t particularly frequent or sticky (very different from last night’s sit).
Re: realizing selflessness
Thank you for the story about medication ("The Tablet Paul Thought Was in the Way").
I’m mostly okay with the fact that I take medication for focus, mood, and energy level (one medication, taken off-label, for all of those things), but I do regularly have thoughts come up like the ones in the story:
that it would somehow be better to experience the mind in its “natural” state;
that maybe there’s something I need to deal with that’s being covered up;
that medication will make awakening seem less authentic;
that “purity” is somehow better;
that the medicated me is not “really” me;
that awakening should mean I won’t need medication anymore;
that taking medication means there’s something wrong with me;
that I shouldn’t be dependent on medication;
that assistance invalidates discovery.
One of two of those ideas might be worthy of thoughtful consideration, but I appreciate your making it clear that most of them can simply be dismissed. (I think my most legitimate concern is about possible side effects from long-term use.) I also appreciate your acknowledgment that having a steadier or more focused mind might sometimes be useful for inquiry.
It helps that there’s the Zen story about how Bodhidharma (the semi-historical, semi-mythical founder of Zen) got so frustrated about falling asleep while he was meditating in his cave that he ripped off his eyelids and threw them to the ground, where they took root and sprouted into the first tea plant. Also, the Zen monastery where I lived always had coffee available from a huge, restaurant-style coffee maker.
I’m mostly okay with the fact that I take medication for focus, mood, and energy level (one medication, taken off-label, for all of those things), but I do regularly have thoughts come up like the ones in the story:
that it would somehow be better to experience the mind in its “natural” state;
that maybe there’s something I need to deal with that’s being covered up;
that medication will make awakening seem less authentic;
that “purity” is somehow better;
that the medicated me is not “really” me;
that awakening should mean I won’t need medication anymore;
that taking medication means there’s something wrong with me;
that I shouldn’t be dependent on medication;
that assistance invalidates discovery.
One of two of those ideas might be worthy of thoughtful consideration, but I appreciate your making it clear that most of them can simply be dismissed. (I think my most legitimate concern is about possible side effects from long-term use.) I also appreciate your acknowledgment that having a steadier or more focused mind might sometimes be useful for inquiry.
It helps that there’s the Zen story about how Bodhidharma (the semi-historical, semi-mythical founder of Zen) got so frustrated about falling asleep while he was meditating in his cave that he ripped off his eyelids and threw them to the ground, where they took root and sprouted into the first tea plant. Also, the Zen monastery where I lived always had coffee available from a huge, restaurant-style coffee maker.
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: realizing selflessness
i came across this today. It was attributed to Jung but was a discovery of one of his patients.
By keeping quiet, repressing nothing, remaining attentive, and by accepting reality—taking things as they are, and not as I wanted them to be—by doing all this, unusual knowledge has come to me, and unusual powers as well, such as I could never have imagined before.
I always thought that when we accepted things they overpowered us in some way or other. This turns out not to be true at all, and it is only by accepting them that one can assume an attitude towards them. (my bolding)
— A former patient of C. G. Jung, quoted in his commentary on The Secret of the Golden Flower, in Alchemical Studies.
By keeping quiet, repressing nothing, remaining attentive, and by accepting reality—taking things as they are, and not as I wanted them to be—by doing all this, unusual knowledge has come to me, and unusual powers as well, such as I could never have imagined before.
I always thought that when we accepted things they overpowered us in some way or other. This turns out not to be true at all, and it is only by accepting them that one can assume an attitude towards them. (my bolding)
— A former patient of C. G. Jung, quoted in his commentary on The Secret of the Golden Flower, in Alchemical Studies.
Re: realizing selflessness
I feel like I get the overall gist of the quote. It is obviously encouragement to attend to things as they are and accept things as they are.By keeping quiet, repressing nothing, remaining attentive, and by accepting reality—taking things as they are, and not as I wanted them to be—by doing all this, unusual knowledge has come to me, and unusual powers as well, such as I could never have imagined before.
I always thought that when we accepted things they overpowered us in some way or other. This turns out not to be true at all, and it is only by accepting them that one can assume an attitude towards them. (my bolding)
But the one specific bit I’m not sure I understand is the part you put in bold. By accepting things as they are, one can “assume an attitude” toward them? What do you take “assuming an attitude” to mean?
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: realizing selflessness
i take it to mean our relationship to THIS.What do you take “assuming an attitude” to mean?
To quote you paraphrasing me.. using thoughts about outcomes as an example
This isn’t about outcomes. It’s a bout inviting a different attitude toward thoughts about desired outcomes.
Ok, let's talk about a possible attitude.I’m not sure how it applies to the desired outcome of lessening suffering
Conditions have arisen that on the surface seem to be causing suffering.
Suffering is somewhere between unpleasant and horrible. You imagine that in the future when awakened this won't happen.
You have a strong desire for this imagined future to be present now.
What is here now is already here. To imagine that it could be different is madness as it's already present.
We move our focus from the inagined future back to what is here now.
We accept that what we have is unavoidable as it is happening now.
We have dropped the idea that it could have been different (an essential component of suffering)
The situation is still unpleasant but we are now back to first arrow stuff.
Assuming the suffering arose on learning of a demand that is imagined to be difficult, a mechanical intention to wait until starting the job before deciding that it is difficult might happen.
Then trip to cafe is enjoyed. Coffee is enjoyed. ..and surprise, job turns out to be less onerous than expected.
v
Re: realizing selflessness
Thank you for the elaboration on “assuming an attitude” toward things as they are and specifically how that applies to my desired outcome of lessening suffering related to demand-resistance.
I’m sitting here at the coffee shop where I often do my work, responding to your post and, thereby, procrastinating on responding to my students’ discussion board posts and grading a batch of essays, all of which I’m feeling resistant to.
(This same lesson apparently needs to be learned over and over, which is, of course, unsurprising. I appreciate your willingness to repeatedly point out the same things.)
When I simply look at the current thoughts and sensations, it’s harder to see what the problem is.
(That makes me think of Philippe. I’m starting to internalize his repeated questions like “What is the problem here?” and “Can that be okay?”)
Maybe that should’ve just been: “Then trip to cafe is enjoyed. Coffee is enjoyed. And work commences, one tiny step at a time.”
I would so much rather watch the recording of the Wednesday meeting right now (and I did already take a peek), but let’s try to do some work . . .
Oh, wait, one more thing I wanted to say (providing a little more procrastination):
I’ve been experiencing how something you say a lot does seem to be true, which is (what I guess is a basic therapeutic principle) that simply becoming more consciously aware of various psychological stuff can bring some relief from suffering. You don’t necessarily need to DO anything about it.
I’m sitting here at the coffee shop where I often do my work, responding to your post and, thereby, procrastinating on responding to my students’ discussion board posts and grading a batch of essays, all of which I’m feeling resistant to.
Yes to all of that (alas).Conditions have arisen that on the surface seem to be causing suffering.
Suffering is somewhere between unpleasant and horrible. You imagine that in the future when awakened this won't happen.
You have a strong desire for this imagined future to be present now.
I paused over the idea of “accepting” what’s happening now. But if resignation can be considered a form of acceptance, then I guess I do “accept” that the current situation and feelings are unavoidable.What is here now is already here. To imagine that it could be different is madness as it's already present.
We move our focus from the inagined future back to what is here now.
We accept that what we have is unavoidable as it is happening now.
We have dropped the idea that it could have been different (an essential component of suffering)
Yes. I can feel this, to some degree.The situation is still unpleasant but we are now back to first arrow stuff.
(This same lesson apparently needs to be learned over and over, which is, of course, unsurprising. I appreciate your willingness to repeatedly point out the same things.)
When I simply look at the current thoughts and sensations, it’s harder to see what the problem is.
(That makes me think of Philippe. I’m starting to internalize his repeated questions like “What is the problem here?” and “Can that be okay?”)
This is a helpful tip. Thanks.Assuming the suffering arose on learning of a demand that is imagined to be difficult, a mechanical intention to wait until starting the job before deciding that it is difficult might happen.
Well, it’s sometimes less onerous than expected. Maybe it often is. But sometimes it isn’t.Then trip to cafe is enjoyed. Coffee is enjoyed. ..and surprise, job turns out to be less onerous than expected.
Maybe that should’ve just been: “Then trip to cafe is enjoyed. Coffee is enjoyed. And work commences, one tiny step at a time.”
I would so much rather watch the recording of the Wednesday meeting right now (and I did already take a peek), but let’s try to do some work . . .
Oh, wait, one more thing I wanted to say (providing a little more procrastination):
I’ve been experiencing how something you say a lot does seem to be true, which is (what I guess is a basic therapeutic principle) that simply becoming more consciously aware of various psychological stuff can bring some relief from suffering. You don’t necessarily need to DO anything about it.
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: realizing selflessness
Excellent! Then for fun i'll repeat what i find often stated: "The seeing is incredibly powerful. No effort required."I’ve been experiencing how something you say a lot does seem to be true, which is (what I guess is a basic therapeutic principle) that simply becoming more consciously aware of various psychological stuff can bring some relief from suffering. You don’t necessarily need to DO anything about it.
It seems like you are resistant to the job, but you are in fact responding to the idea about the job.and, thereby, procrastinating on responding to my students’ discussion board posts and grading a batch of essays, all of which I’m feeling resistant to.
Isn't it crazy that there is this resistance when you know that the procrastination is at best only delaying what is going to happen anyway?
Yes it is a form of acceptance. It just has a bunch of (unnecessary) stories attached to it. The victim mentality.if resignation can be considered a form of acceptance,
The good news is that is a lead into a better form of acceptance. A willing, inviting, humorous version.
It almost isn't a repetition as each time it is an opportunity to see it freshly. Originally. ..and anyway i get that if it needs saying again (if it arises) then it wasn't grokked previously.I appreciate your willingness to repeatedly point out the same things.
Yes. That pesky nervous system can take repeats to realign. When something is ingrained to this degree it becomes an inconscious reality.This same lesson apparently needs to be learned over and over
Yes, i see this as a tool. A technique that is useful to formalise. LOOK AT THE DETAIL of what is actually here.When I simply look at the current thoughts and sensations, it’s harder to see what the problem is.
Yes, of course. That's why we wait until it's happening to evaluate. ..but quickly learn that to do that is a diversion and a waste of focus. ..although in the beginning it will happen but easily get dismissed.t’s sometimes less onerous than expected. Maybe it often is. But sometimes it isn’t.
v
Re: realizing selflessness
It’s weird that this is news to me. It seems like it’s been taken for granted in our culture (by which I guess I mean especially Anglophone and European culture), ever Freudian psychology was popularized, that a key way of alleviating suffering is talk therapy that unearths things previously hidden from consciousness. But perhaps because of my early and intensive exposure to Buddhist practice, I had apparently dismissed the wisdom of my own culture. (And now Buddhism lite in the form of “mindfulness” is starting to permeate our culture too.)Excellent! Then for fun i'll repeat what i find often stated: "The seeing is incredibly powerful. No effort required."
Glad to hear that resignation counts at least as an inferior form of acceptance. And that’s an interesting point that it has a bunch of unnecessary stories attached about feeling victimized.Yes it is a form of acceptance. It just has a bunch of (unnecessary) stories attached to it. The victim mentality.if resignation can be considered a form of acceptance,
The good news is that is a lead into a better form of acceptance. A willing, inviting, humorous version.
Yep. I’ve been learning, through repeatedly doing it, how helpful this can be.A technique that is useful to formalise. LOOK AT THE DETAIL of what is actually here.
Got a little bit of work done this morning, without much suffering.
Re: realizing selflessness
Yesterday, I pasted this at the top of the file where I compose my LU posts, as a reminder to myself:
When I reread what you’d written, I noted again, with a smile, the phrasing “might happen,” presumably carefully chosen (consciously or not) to help keep poor K from TRYing to do this.
Settling in at the library, where I plan to to do some work related to my class, it occurred to me that while I was still at home, I dealt with a small demand from the universe (something that needed to be done for spouse that he wouldn’t be able to do himself) with a little annoyance and resignation but no great angst.
Now have a follow-up task to do. Same low-grade reaction.
Reaction to those reactions: Whew. Plus some thoughts wondering whether just talking about all of this and starting to notice the mind’s machinations is loosening it up.
* * * * *
Naturally, I’ve been identifying with Paul in your recent stories, like with this from “The Procedure Paul Couldn’t Find”:
I might’ve even been tempted to do it if it didn’t seem like too much trouble.
But, no, actually, maybe I wouldn’t be tempted, probably because of an appropriate aversion (sometimes) to doing anything that’s obviously based on an assumption that awakening needs to be achieved.
But I’m sure my brain has filed away some of those inquiry questions, having been reminded of a bunch of them all at once. And I might skim the story again. And deploying those questions at appropriate times might happen. :-)
I remembered it this morning, even before looking at that file. As I started to think of my work for the day, I mentally froze (probably holding my breath momentarily) and cut off that thought. “No need to think about my work at all just yet.”Assuming the suffering arose on learning of a demand that is imagined to be difficult, a mechanical intention to wait until starting the job before deciding that it is difficult might happen.
When I reread what you’d written, I noted again, with a smile, the phrasing “might happen,” presumably carefully chosen (consciously or not) to help keep poor K from TRYing to do this.
Settling in at the library, where I plan to to do some work related to my class, it occurred to me that while I was still at home, I dealt with a small demand from the universe (something that needed to be done for spouse that he wouldn’t be able to do himself) with a little annoyance and resignation but no great angst.
Now have a follow-up task to do. Same low-grade reaction.
Reaction to those reactions: Whew. Plus some thoughts wondering whether just talking about all of this and starting to notice the mind’s machinations is loosening it up.
* * * * *
Naturally, I’ve been identifying with Paul in your recent stories, like with this from “The Procedure Paul Couldn’t Find”:
I noticed a small, fleeting impulse to make a list of the inquiry questions in the story.Tess asked Paul, “What happens if there’s no procedure?”
He answered quickly.
“I might never wake up.”
I might’ve even been tempted to do it if it didn’t seem like too much trouble.
But, no, actually, maybe I wouldn’t be tempted, probably because of an appropriate aversion (sometimes) to doing anything that’s obviously based on an assumption that awakening needs to be achieved.
But I’m sure my brain has filed away some of those inquiry questions, having been reminded of a bunch of them all at once. And I might skim the story again. And deploying those questions at appropriate times might happen. :-)
Re: realizing selflessness
Misc. things:
(1) Again this morning, when thoughts of work arose and began to spawn unpleasant feelings, I simply decided I didn’t need to think about work until I was going to start doing work. I’ve been a little surprised that this has been effective. I think of thoughts as generally being more recalcitrant than that.
(2) From the meeting, I filed the idea of examining bodily sensations related to suffering in microscopic detail, way beyond what words can capture. But why am I doing that? I’ll do it anyway, without a good theory about why it’s helpful, but do you have even a vague theory, which I might have missed or forgotten?
(3) I identified uncomfortably with Paul in “The One Who Hadn’t Got It Yet”—that is, until his “wobble.”
(4) There have been a couple of references now to a shift Ravi had, but apparently I missed it. When did that happen? (I’ve been reading a lot of the stories but not all of them.)
Posting this now, and starting work. (Unpleasant wave of feeling in torso when I wrote that.)
(1) Again this morning, when thoughts of work arose and began to spawn unpleasant feelings, I simply decided I didn’t need to think about work until I was going to start doing work. I’ve been a little surprised that this has been effective. I think of thoughts as generally being more recalcitrant than that.
(2) From the meeting, I filed the idea of examining bodily sensations related to suffering in microscopic detail, way beyond what words can capture. But why am I doing that? I’ll do it anyway, without a good theory about why it’s helpful, but do you have even a vague theory, which I might have missed or forgotten?
(3) I identified uncomfortably with Paul in “The One Who Hadn’t Got It Yet”—that is, until his “wobble.”
(4) There have been a couple of references now to a shift Ravi had, but apparently I missed it. When did that happen? (I’ve been reading a lot of the stories but not all of them.)
Posting this now, and starting work. (Unpleasant wave of feeling in torso when I wrote that.)
Re: realizing selflessness
Immediately after submitting the previous post, I realized that “unpleasant” was an interpretation added on to the actual sensations I’d just mentioned. (And I was rather proud of that observation.)
- vinceschubert
- Posts: 5866
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
- Location: Australia
- Contact:
Re: realizing selflessness
Yes — it was easy to miss because it wasn’t written as a big “awakening event.”There have been a couple of references now to a shift Ravi had, but apparently I missed it. When did that happen?
In the current series, the clearest point was “The Thing Ravi Had Been Studying Around.” That was the story where Ravi finally noticed what had been underneath much of his 34 years of studying, explaining and searching: fear and helplessness.
His machinery was roughly:
uncertainty → understand it → name it → find a framework → feel safer
He recognised something like:
“If I understand enough, nothing can get me.”
And then more deeply:
“I’ve been studying around it.”
The important shift wasn’t that Ravi stopped thinking or became a different personality. He still reads, explains, corrects people and can disappear into concepts. What changed was that he began to recognise the urgency underneath the explaining. Sometimes he can now feel that old movement toward understanding as protection and simply not follow it.
Near the end he tried to classify what had happened — naturally — and landed on something close to:
“Something was seen. Apparently I don’t need to know what category it belongs in.”
Then, predictably, he started categorising it again and Maeve just said:
“Ravi.”
That’s the “shift” I’ve been referring to in the recent Paul stories.
There was also an earlier Ravi opening in the development of the series, where while doing an ordinary physical task he saw intention, correction and action happening without finding an independent author. But “The Thing Ravi Had Been Studying Around” is the one I regard as Ravi’s significant current-series shift, because it changed his relationship with the seeking mechanism itself.
So you haven’t missed a dramatic Ravi wakes up chapter. i deliberately made it something that sneaked up on him, much like the later Tess theme: a change becomes evident in how reactions happen rather than through a spectacular event. (hint hint)
v
Re: realizing selflessness
I want to read or reread this story, but I can't seem to find it in your Substack. Can you send a direct link?In the current series, the clearest point was “The Thing Ravi Had Been Studying Around.”
I wondered if this might have been the case.So you haven’t missed a dramatic Ravi wakes up chapter. i deliberately made it something that sneaked up on him, much like the later Tess theme: a change becomes evident in how reactions happen rather than through a spectacular event.
Yeah, yeah, I get the hint. :-)(hint hint)
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Anastacia42, Robshin and 49 guests

