Hi Jon,
Okey, fine. Let's explore something different.
Think about the person you were ten years ago.
When you look at your direct experience right now, what is actually present of that person?
Is the past itself here, or are there memories, images, and thoughts appearing now?
And what gives you the sense that you are the same person continuing through time?
Please take your time and explore this carefully.
Looking for the self
Re: Looking for the self
Hi Necip!
Been a busy day I’ll try to respond later today or tomorrow
With love
Jon
Been a busy day I’ll try to respond later today or tomorrow
With love
Jon
Re: Looking for the self
Hi Necip!
Sorry for the delay in responding.
Thoughts, memories, and feelings. That person 10 years ago is not here now.
There are only memories, thoughts, and images of the person ten years ago appearing right now.
I’ve already examined this assumption and seen through the belief or sense of continuity. I no longer experience the same person continuing through time.
Sorry for the delay in responding.
Think about the person you were ten years ago.
When you look at your direct experience right now, what is actually present of that person?
Thoughts, memories, and feelings. That person 10 years ago is not here now.
Is the past itself here, or are there memories, images, and thoughts appearing now?
There are only memories, thoughts, and images of the person ten years ago appearing right now.
And what gives you the sense that you are the same person continuing through time?
I’ve already examined this assumption and seen through the belief or sense of continuity. I no longer experience the same person continuing through time.
- Iconoclast
- Posts: 361
- Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2022 8:51 am
Re: Looking for the self
Two different propositions:
1. There used to be a separate self 10 years ago, but that self no longer exists.
2. There was never a separate self in the first place; there was only the illusion that one existed.
Which one reflects your direct experience?
1. There used to be a separate self 10 years ago, but that self no longer exists.
2. There was never a separate self in the first place; there was only the illusion that one existed.
Which one reflects your direct experience?
- Iconoclast
- Posts: 361
- Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2022 8:51 am
Re: Looking for the self
Jon, you wrote:
Is there any person to be called "I"?
What exactly do you mean by "the same person"?I no longer experience the same person continuing through time.
Is there any person to be called "I"?
- Iconoclast
- Posts: 361
- Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2022 8:51 am
Re: Looking for the self
and can you see the difference between
relatively stable "personality traits"
and
a separate "Person" ("I" or "me")?
relatively stable "personality traits"
and
a separate "Person" ("I" or "me")?
Re: Looking for the self
1. There used to be a separate self 10 years ago, but that self no longer exists.
2. There was never a separate self in the first place. There was only the illusion that one existed.
Which one reflects your direct experience?
There was never a separate person. There was only the thought of one. The belief in a separate self dissolved.
Jon, you wrote:
I no longer experience the same person continuing through time.
What exactly do you mean by "the same person”?
I’m sorry I did not word that correctly. What I meant to say is:
I no longer experience a separate person continuing through time.
Is there any person to be called “I"?
There is no person that “I” refers to.
and can you see the difference between
relatively stable "personality traits"
and
a separate "Person" ("I" or “me")?
Some personality traits may appear to be stable, yet no “I” or “me” can be found apart from a thought. Relatively stable personality traits do not establish that a separate self exists.
- Iconoclast
- Posts: 361
- Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2022 8:51 am
Re: Looking for the self
Very good!
Jon, when you go about your ordinary day, without deliberately looking for a self or thinking about this inquiry, what is different now compared to before?
Please describe what you actually notice, rather than what you understand about the self.
Jon, when you go about your ordinary day, without deliberately looking for a self or thinking about this inquiry, what is different now compared to before?
Please describe what you actually notice, rather than what you understand about the self.
Re: Looking for the self
Hi Necip!
Most of the changes I’ve experienced have developed gradually over many years, including the dissolution of the sense of a separate, gross, enduring self.
As a result of this inquiry, I’ve noticed a weakening of the subtler senses of self that had previously gone unnoticed. The apparent center from which experience seemed to be happening has also greatly weakened.
Over the past years I’ve noticed a greater equanimity. I am significantly less reactive, and I find it easier to sit with unpleasant emotions without resisting or trying to change them.
I am fine with uncertainty as I know I cannot be certain of anything.
There are moments when everything loses its usual ‘thingness’ and opens up into sensations that seem to have no discernible location. At times familiar objects appear as if I am seeing them for the very first time, reminding me of how I experienced things as a small child.
Over the years I’ve noticed that people, including myself, appear to be playing out roles as if we are acting, and sometimes the acting is really bad.
Over the years I have developed a preference for being alone, in silence, without distractions.
Sometimes fear arises when the openness becomes particularly deep.
When I am around other people, the openess tends to diminish without my noticing. When I consciously remember, the openness can return.
With Love
Jon
Jon, when you go about your ordinary day, without deliberately looking for a self or thinking about this inquiry, what is different now compared to before?
Please describe what you actually notice, rather than what you understand about the self.
Most of the changes I’ve experienced have developed gradually over many years, including the dissolution of the sense of a separate, gross, enduring self.
As a result of this inquiry, I’ve noticed a weakening of the subtler senses of self that had previously gone unnoticed. The apparent center from which experience seemed to be happening has also greatly weakened.
Over the past years I’ve noticed a greater equanimity. I am significantly less reactive, and I find it easier to sit with unpleasant emotions without resisting or trying to change them.
I am fine with uncertainty as I know I cannot be certain of anything.
There are moments when everything loses its usual ‘thingness’ and opens up into sensations that seem to have no discernible location. At times familiar objects appear as if I am seeing them for the very first time, reminding me of how I experienced things as a small child.
Over the years I’ve noticed that people, including myself, appear to be playing out roles as if we are acting, and sometimes the acting is really bad.
Over the years I have developed a preference for being alone, in silence, without distractions.
Sometimes fear arises when the openness becomes particularly deep.
When I am around other people, the openess tends to diminish without my noticing. When I consciously remember, the openness can return.
With Love
Jon
- Iconoclast
- Posts: 361
- Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2022 8:51 am
Re: Looking for the self
Hi Jon,
Thank you for your detailed response.
You mentioned that openness tends to diminish around other people and can return when you consciously remember it.
When that openness diminishes, does a separate self actually reappear, or is there simply a change in experience?
And is openness itself necessary for seeing that there is no separate self?
Much love,
Necip
Thank you for your detailed response.
You mentioned that openness tends to diminish around other people and can return when you consciously remember it.
When that openness diminishes, does a separate self actually reappear, or is there simply a change in experience?
And is openness itself necessary for seeing that there is no separate self?
Much love,
Necip
Re: Looking for the self
You mentioned that openness tends to diminish around other people and can return when you consciously remember it.
When that openness diminishes, does a separate self actually reappear, or is there simply a change in experience?
I haven’t experienced a separate self when openness diminishes. There is a sense of a self that can sometimes arise. I have seen that this sense arises through thoughts, emotions, bodily sensations, and social interactions, but this does not establish that an actual separate self has appeared or exists.
And is openness itself necessary for seeing that there is no separate self?
Openness is not necessary for seeing that there is no separate self.
- Iconoclast
- Posts: 361
- Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2022 8:51 am
Re: Looking for the self
Hi Jon,
Before moving to the final questions, I'd like to explore one last distinction: continuity without a separate, enduring self.
Consider a river.
A river flows, bends, changes direction, and follows a relatively stable course. It has a recognizable shape, a history, and a name. We can identify it as the same river today and tomorrow.
Yet what exactly makes it the same river?
The water is constantly changing. Its shape, depth, speed, and course may change as well. There is no separate, unchanging river-entity behind the flowing water, directing or owning the flow.
The river is not something that flows. The river is the flowing itself.
Now consider the human organism.
The body has biological continuity. Memories, habits, personality traits, emotional patterns, and behavioral tendencies may persist for decades. There is a recognizable "individual" with a relatively stable history.
But does this continuity establish the existence of a separate, enduring self?
Or could the organism, like the river, simply be an ongoing, interconnected process without a separate entity behind it?
Notice the distinction:
— Continuity does not necessarily imply an unchanging essence.
— A recognizable pattern does not require a separate owner.
— Memory does not establish a separate rememberer.
— Behavior does not establish a separate controller.
— The arising of a sense of self does not establish an actual self.
The organism continues, just as the river continues. But is there an additional entity that has this continuity?
I'd like you to look directly at these three questions:
1. When you experience the continuity of your body, memories, personality, and everyday life, can you find an enduring self that exists separately from these processes?
2. Does the organism need a separate owner or controller in order to function, learn, remember, make decisions, and maintain its continuity?
3. Just as there is no separate river behind the flowing, is there a separate "Jon" behind the ongoing living, thinking, feeling, and acting? Or is "Jon" simply the name given to this continuous, changing process?
Please look at your actual experience.
Much love
Necip
Before moving to the final questions, I'd like to explore one last distinction: continuity without a separate, enduring self.
Consider a river.
A river flows, bends, changes direction, and follows a relatively stable course. It has a recognizable shape, a history, and a name. We can identify it as the same river today and tomorrow.
Yet what exactly makes it the same river?
The water is constantly changing. Its shape, depth, speed, and course may change as well. There is no separate, unchanging river-entity behind the flowing water, directing or owning the flow.
The river is not something that flows. The river is the flowing itself.
Now consider the human organism.
The body has biological continuity. Memories, habits, personality traits, emotional patterns, and behavioral tendencies may persist for decades. There is a recognizable "individual" with a relatively stable history.
But does this continuity establish the existence of a separate, enduring self?
Or could the organism, like the river, simply be an ongoing, interconnected process without a separate entity behind it?
Notice the distinction:
— Continuity does not necessarily imply an unchanging essence.
— A recognizable pattern does not require a separate owner.
— Memory does not establish a separate rememberer.
— Behavior does not establish a separate controller.
— The arising of a sense of self does not establish an actual self.
The organism continues, just as the river continues. But is there an additional entity that has this continuity?
I'd like you to look directly at these three questions:
1. When you experience the continuity of your body, memories, personality, and everyday life, can you find an enduring self that exists separately from these processes?
2. Does the organism need a separate owner or controller in order to function, learn, remember, make decisions, and maintain its continuity?
3. Just as there is no separate river behind the flowing, is there a separate "Jon" behind the ongoing living, thinking, feeling, and acting? Or is "Jon" simply the name given to this continuous, changing process?
Please look at your actual experience.
Much love
Necip
Re: Looking for the self
Hi Necip!
I’ll post my reply soon
With Love
Jon
I’ll post my reply soon
With Love
Jon
Re: Looking for the self
When you experience the continuity of your body, memories, personality, and everyday life, can you find an enduring self that exists separately from these processes?
There is no separate, enduring self to be found that exists independently of these processes.
Does the organism need a separate owner or controller in order to function, learn, remember, make decisions, and maintain its continuity?
I cannot find a separate owner or controller. These things are just happening.
Just as there is no separate river behind the flowing, is there a separate "Jon" behind the ongoing living, thinking, feeling, and acting? Or is "Jon" simply the name given to this continuous, changing process?
“Jon” is the name of the thinking, feeling, history, preferences, story, and the impermanent biological organism. There is no separate entity behind these processes.
- Iconoclast
- Posts: 361
- Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2022 8:51 am
Re: Looking for the self
OK, Jon, very good!
Now let's move on to the final questions. Please answer each question in detail, drawing on your direct experience.
1) Is there a separate entity called "self", "me", or "I" at all, anywhere, in any way, shape, or form? Was there ever?
2) Explain in detail what the illusion of a separate self is, when it starts, and how it works in your own experience. Describe it fully as you see it now.
3) How does it feel to see this? What is different compared to before you started this dialogue? Please describe your experience over the past few days.
4) What was the last bit that pushed you over the edge and made you really look?
5) Describe decision, intention, free will, choice, and control. Please address each of these five separately.
What makes things happen? How does it work?
What are you responsible for? Give examples from your direct experience.
6) Anything to add?
Now let's move on to the final questions. Please answer each question in detail, drawing on your direct experience.
1) Is there a separate entity called "self", "me", or "I" at all, anywhere, in any way, shape, or form? Was there ever?
2) Explain in detail what the illusion of a separate self is, when it starts, and how it works in your own experience. Describe it fully as you see it now.
3) How does it feel to see this? What is different compared to before you started this dialogue? Please describe your experience over the past few days.
4) What was the last bit that pushed you over the edge and made you really look?
5) Describe decision, intention, free will, choice, and control. Please address each of these five separately.
What makes things happen? How does it work?
What are you responsible for? Give examples from your direct experience.
6) Anything to add?
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot] and 10 guests

