This is useful—not because the loose, spacious feeling is “awakening,” but because the ordinary construction of “me in here experiencing a world out there” became less convincing. (the feeling is nice, but care is necessary that this doesn't become a goal.)
Understood.
One subtle caution: “That’s all that exists for me” goes beyond what can actually be known. More precisely, thoughts and perceptions are all that can be directly accessed. Whether something exists beyond them is simply unknown. No need to turn no-self into solipsism.
That’s actually what I meant: that thoughts and perceptions are all that can be directly accessed. I find it bothersome when folks in the nonduality arena make what sound like metaphysical claims about what does and doesn’t exist rather than sticking with talking about what can and can’t be known through experience. I appreciate that you’re careful about this distinction.
Also watch whether “a big cluster of experiential stuff” quietly becomes a replacement K—a container possessing all the blips. Is there an actual cluster with a boundary, or does thought gather changing perceptions and name the collection “K”? Does the apparent space contain experiencing, or is space itself another perception or interpretation?
Yep, the idea of perceptions and thoughts swirling in space is a metaphor, a helpful image, but like all metaphors, it has its limits. The image of a cluster does suggest that it has a boundary and that space is a container, both of which are misleading. I get that I don’t want to shift from the clear and definite boundary of the bag of skin to simply a more vague, permeable, and expansive boundary of the edges of the cluster. And I don’t want to simply expand the image of experience happening inside a body (or a head) to happening inside a vague and expansive region of space. To try to avoid those problems, maybe the swirl of experiential stuff would have to be imagined as infinite in extent? I guess I was picturing it as extending past anything I can perceive to anything I can imagine, so that’s essentially infinite. Or the limits of the metaphor just shouldn’t be overlooked.
Also, my image may suggest that each “person” is a separate cluster. But this is a tricky one because it’s hard not to think that. The cluster labeled K does seem to be basically separate from the clusters with other labels, though they may interact and affect each other. In all of this talk of no-self and nonduality, I’ve never known what to do with the fact that “I” don’t have direct access to “your” perceptions and thoughts and vice versa, and I guess I’ve mostly decided to not worry about that and to toss it into the mystery bag. But if you have any helpful insights or images here, I’d be glad to hear them.
And not feeling spacious now means nothing. Spaciousness was a passing experience; seeing doesn’t depend upon reproducing it.
Good reminder.
Right now, notice one sound, one bodily sensation and one thought. They may appear in different relative locations, but can an owner, centre or boundary separating “self” from “world” actually be found—or does thought add that organisation afterwards?
What I noticed was the sound of my intestines gurgling, the bodily sensations of whatever’s going on in there, and the thought, “Am I actually feeling that or just imagining that I’m feeling it based on the sound?”
No owner can be found, just sound, sensation, and thought.
Any notion of a “center” is added by thought.
I don’t think I’m finding even a thought-created “boundary” between “self” and sound; there’s just sound. Well, hold on — thought adds the location “down there” (in the intestines) to the sound and adds the location “up here” (in the head) to the supposed “perceiver” of the sound. Maybe that’s sort of a boundary, but it feels more like just a separation or distance. But in any case, it’s added by thought.
The sensation gets located in space, and specifically inside the body, by thought. And there’s the same sense of the sensation “down there” and the perceiver “up here” — added by thought.
The thought gets located in the head. That location is added by thought. I’m not sure whether there’s always a felt sense of a thinker of the thought or a perceiver of the thought that’s separate from the thought itself, but if there is, it’s obviously added by thought.
Well, now I do have the impulse to think, “Now what?” and to ask you, “OK, vince, now what?”
And what was the answer to that question?
Basically, “Whatever”?
That’s some combination of frustrating and freeing.
Just for fun, or as an experiment, I did put a little checkmark on the calendar for yesterday. (The calendar is on the living room wall and was in my line of site at the meeting.) But it felt like a fib or a mistake.