Were the response and uncertainty selected before they appeared?
I know the “right” answer is no, but I’m reflecting on the experience . . .
The uncertainty was not selected before it appeared. The question was considered, to try to figure out what exactly it meant; fuzzy hypotheses were floated; memory was searched; it was concluded that I wasn’t entirely sure what the question meant and that, in any case, I probably hadn’t had any experience one might describe that way and which I would call a “realization,” but that wasn’t entirely clear. At some point in that thought process, “Um . . . ” was typed, indicating that the question had required pondering. I think “Hmm” was typed first but replaced with “Um,” to indicate not just pondering but also uncertainty. And at the end of the thought process, the rest of the response, “I don’t know?” was typed. There might have been consideration given to whether to include the question mark or not; if there was, then it was apparently concluded that it helped to accurately express the answer to the question.
I began writing the above by considering the
uncertainty, because it was more obvious that it was not “selected,” just experienced. The
response felt more like it was “selected,” given the deliberation that preceded it, but I guess it was just the end of that chain of thoughts. But it still feels more like it was “selected,” which is interesting.
Hypothesis: Actions preceded by chains of relevant thoughts, especially if they’re long chains, feel more like “I” am the thinker and chooser and actor. A “decision” is simply the end of a chain of thoughts/feelings, with no need for a “decider” (a word I have trouble using because it always invokes George W. Bush).
(Just went back through my LU posts to find another conclusion like this that I came to: that an “intention” is when a thought arises about doing something and then a thought of approval arises about that thought.)
Is there a recipient standing apart from them, having them? Or does the label “my response”arrive as another thought?
Again, I already know the “right” answer, but, let’s see . . .
Is there someone apart from the response who “has” the response, or someone apart from the uncertainty who “has” the uncertainty? Well, it doesn’t take much reflection to see that the answer is no. Thoughts arise, feelings arise, a sentence gets formulated, typing happens. Experiencing happens; no need for an experiencer. No need for a “me” in there. No “me” is found in reviewing experience.
The formulating of a response feels the most like there’s a “me” doing it. Typing doesn’t feel at all like it needs a “me.” Neither does reading a question. Feeling uncertainty about what the question means feels slightly more “me”-ish. And pondering how to respond feels very “me”-ish. So, apparently, what I am most apt to identify as being done by “me” or belonging to “me” is conscious thinking and the actions that follow relevant chains of conscious thinking.
THIS is utterly particular, but ownerless.
Yep, I get that. I mean, I think I still don’t fully grok it, but I understand it.
And I appreciate your acknowledging the “personal”-seeming aspects of experience in order to set them aside as not what we’re talking about here.
But is there a separate K receiving those events—or are tears, activation, delight and the thought “this is happening to me” all parts of one process?
And again, I know the answer, but . . .
Hmm . . . It occurs to me that maybe unhappiness feels more “personal” to me than happiness does? Certainly, unhappiness seems more apt to give rise to chains of thoughts and feelings — along the lines of “Woe is me” and about how to fix it and how to prevent such things in the future, and that all sounds like selfing.
More pondering and observing to do here . . .
i was pointing to this when i wrote that frogs croak and people think.
Yep, I got that. :-)
What about when grading began without a controller first defeating resistance?
Just happened. No controller.
But I’m trying to determine whether it actually
felt like it just happened . . .
Maybe.
Choose one event occurring now—a sound, sensation or thought—and ask:
Is this happening to K, or is “happening to K” another interpretation appearing within it?
No rush to answer. Let “Um . . . I don’t think so?” be honest until something clearer reveals itself.
I hear the gentle whoosh of the air-conditioner blowing.
I realize that this is the stuff we’re setting aside, but I think I need to work this through:
- It’s “happening to K” in the sense that I know that the sound is registering in K’s eardrums and the neural pathways in K’s brain related to hearing. (But how that has any relation to conscious experience — and what conscious experience
is — is another matter entirely and a total mystery that may always remain a total mystery.)
- Even if there were someone else in the room, their experience of the sound would be at least slightly different from K’s, and their experience would not be directly accessible to K. So in that sense, this experience is “happening to K,” not to someone else.
(Hmm . . . There’s a sense in which it’s only happening when it’s being attended to. But maybe there’s another sense in which it’s happening whether it’s being attending to or not? Not sure. Maybe not relevant for this inquiry.)
Alright, but what is in direct experience? What’s actually here related to hearing the sound?
- Hearing the sound.
- Some sense of a “me” “here” who’s hearing a sound coming from over “there.”
The “there” part is clearly an overlay of thought. I can even let the mind settle and kind of experience the sound, and all sound, as “here.” Or maybe as without location? . . . No, it feels more like “here”-ish.
But what about the “me” part? Even when the sound seems kind of “here” (and it takes a bit of effort to not have it seem like it’s “there”), there’s still some sense of an “experiencer” of the sound, who’s also “here,” with “here” being “in K’s head,” maybe midway between the ears.
But look at that more closely . . .
- There’s a vague visual image (i.e., a thought) of “between the ears” — inside the skull, in the brain.
- There are also sensations of the face and mouth and scalp, kind of surrounding that space inside the head.
- And thoughts seem to appear in the head and in front of the face.
- There’s also background knowledge (thoughts) that the ears, on the sides of the head, are the hearing apparatus.
- And maybe the feel of the ears (the skin and the vestibular system) gets included here.
So maybe that all gets kind of smushed together into a lump of “me”-ness imagined in the head — a supposed “experiencer” of the experience of hearing a sound. But it’s clearly all thoughts and sensations. There’s no coherent, discrete direct experience that can pointed to that is a separate “experiencer.”
Well, but actually, there’s also that general background sense of awareness or consciousness. Maybe I spent too much time with Rupert Spira videos and it’s muddling what we’re doing here. But I do feel like I can somehow touch into the open, spacious awareness in which experience arises and of which experience is made. I can
say, “But that doesn’t feel exactly like a personal, individual self,” but I’m not sure I really believe that. So I’m not sure what to do with that.
Returning to the question: “Is this happening to K, or is ‘happening to K’ another interpretation appearing within it?”
Um . . . I don’t know.
It’s hard to set aside that the sound is experienced by the organism called K and not by another organism. And when examining whether there’s a “self,” it’s hard to know what to do with the basic sense of presence or being conscious.
(You’re presumably sleeping and won’t read this for many hours yet, and in that time, I’ll probably want to reread it and rethink some of it. But I really need to do some grading, so I’m going to go ahead and post this so that’s it’s a done deal and I won’t keep being tempted to tinker with it.)