A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Sat Oct 27, 2012 9:37 am

Hi Neeel,
Does some thing notice?
Noticing is an action. In language it is a verb. To notice implies a notice-er – something there to do the noticing. How can noticing just happen?
What is this thing that notices? /Is there an entity that notices?
I do not know.... or perhaps the body/mind/I concept with a label.
Is it possible that noticing happens, without there being a noticer?
As above... this is not logical... To notice implies a noticer... Without a noticer there would be no noticing.. You could argue that there is no noticing at all – only thoughts about noticing.
When you hear a sound, is there a division between the sound, and the experience of the sound? Is there a sound, the experience of a sound, and an experiencer of the experience?
I do not know.. The sound occurs, hearing occur, thinking occurs, experience occurs, It is not clear if there is a division. If the sound occurs even if I am not there to hear it then that is evidence for division..


Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Sat Oct 27, 2012 1:03 pm

Noticing is an action. In language it is a verb. To notice implies a notice-er – something there to do the noticing. How can noticing just happen?
Is language an accurate representation of reality? Just because the structure of the language implies a noticer, does that mean that that noticer must exist?

We say, it is raining. Is there something doing the raining, a rainer? Is a cloud a rainer?

We say, I am thinking, and you have already seen that there is no one, and no thing, doing the thinking.

We say, I am breathing. Is there a breather?
We say , I am digesting, is there a digester?

Yes, there is some stuff ( a body, atoms, molecules etc) that is involved in the process of breathing, digesting, etc, but is the body doing it? In what way is the body doing the breathing, and the oxygen in the air not doing the breathing?

Is it possible that noticing happens, without there being a noticer?
As above... this is not logical... To notice implies a noticer... Without a noticer there would be no noticing..


It is not logical within the framework of language maybe. A verb needs a noun to "do" the verb. But we are looking at reality, not at concepts and symbols used for communication.
You could argue that there is no noticing at all – only thoughts about noticing.
Yes, you could argue that. Look at this. Even noticing is a label thoughts put upon a certain part of experience.


I do not know.. The sound occurs, hearing occur, thinking occurs, experience occurs, It is not clear if there is a division. If the sound occurs even if I am not there to hear it then that is evidence for division..
Evidence for division between what? "Sound" is also just a label that thought puts upon a certain phenomenon.

Remember, we are looking for evidence of a separate self. A doer, a thinker. In direct experience, can you find one?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Sun Oct 28, 2012 5:56 pm

Hi Neeel,
Is language an accurate representation of reality? Just because the structure of the language implies a noticer, does that mean that that noticer must exist?
No it does not.
We say, it is raining. Is there something doing the raining, a rainer? Is a cloud a rainer?
with direct looking and no thinking then raining is just happening..
We say, I am thinking, and you have already seen that there is no one, and no thing, doing the thinking.
I am not clear that there is no-one/no-thing - simply that no-one/no thing can be found with direct looking.
We say, I am breathing. Is there a breather?
We say , I am digesting, is there a digester?
parts of the body seems to be at least involved in the doing of these things - but without any thinking or knowledge then it could be said that these things are simply occurring,
Look at this. Even noticing is a label thoughts put upon a certain part of experience.
Yes.. Ok so using our mind and thinking we divide up experience into parts and label it. We then think of the label as experience itself instead of just the label. Without any labels or thinking - experience is just happening and it has no discernible meaning. I get all this..
Evidence for division between what? "Sound" is also just a label that thought puts upon a certain phenomenon.
Sure it is.. But it is still a happening in experience which is distinctive to other happenings.

Remember, we are looking for evidence of a separate self. A doer, a thinker. In direct experience, can you find one?[/quote]

I cannot find evidence for anything. I find only 'thoughts'. If everything thought or thought about is not real - because we accept that the content of thought is not real - then evidence cannot be found about anything..

Colin

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Sun Oct 28, 2012 6:14 pm

I am not clear that there is no-one/no-thing - simply that no-one/no thing can be found with direct looking.
You have a belief that there is a separate entity, a self, a you. You attribute to this self all sorts of actions, the thinker of thoughts, the maker of decisions, the doer.

What we are looking at is, is this belief true?

If I ask you if I am holding a blue ball, how would you find out? ( yes, blue, and ball, are concepts, ideas, but forget about that for now)

If I ask you if there actually exists a self that does all the things you are attributing to it, how would you find out?

We say, it is raining. Is there something doing the raining, a rainer? Is a cloud a rainer?

with direct looking and no thinking then raining is just happening..
Even thinking about it, is something doing the raining? Is the cloud a rainer? Is the cloud an active entity that is doing the raining? Or is cloud just part of the process?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Sun Nov 04, 2012 4:49 pm

Hi Neeeel,
You have a belief that there is a separate entity, a self, a you. You attribute to this self all sorts of actions, the thinker of thoughts, the maker of decisions, the doer.
I do not have this belief. I simply think it is a possibility.
If I ask you if I am holding a blue ball, how would you find out? ( yes, blue, and ball, are concepts, ideas, but forget about that for now)
Well discounting the fact that they are concepts as you have asked- I could ask you to send me a photo of you holding the ball - but this is not evidence - because you could have colored it using photoshop or something. The only real test would be to be physically in front of you and see with my own eyes that you are holding a blue ball.
If I ask you if there actually exists a self that does all the things you are attributing to it, how would you find out?
Well self is more intangible than blue and ball in that I cannot use my senses to discern it.. LU and you tell me that I should LOOK as if somehow I could turn my eyes inward and view the inner workings.. As this is not possible and may not yield much of a result other than viewing some bloody looking internal organs... and so the answer to your question is that it does not appear possible to find out...
Even thinking about it, is something doing the raining? Is the cloud a rainer? Is the cloud an active entity that is doing the raining? Or is cloud just part of the process?
Well raining is happening but we also have explanations.... There are active processes which include active entities which appear to be involved in raining happening.

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Sun Nov 04, 2012 5:17 pm

Well discounting the fact that they are concepts as you have asked- I could ask you to send me a photo of you holding the ball - but this is not evidence - because you could have colored it using photoshop or something. The only real test would be to be physically in front of you and see with my own eyes that you are holding a blue ball.
yes, you dont think about what it means to have a blue ball, you just look and see.


Well self is more intangible than blue and ball in that I cannot use my senses to discern it.. LU and you tell me that I should LOOK as if somehow I could turn my eyes inward and view the inner workings.. As this is not possible and may not yield much of a result other than viewing some bloody looking internal organs... and so the answer to your question is that it does not appear possible to find out...
the self being intangible is already evidence for no self ( yes, I know you cant say that it doesnt exist just because you cant sense it). When I say look, yes it means look with the eyes, not by thinking about it. But I havent asked you to look inside your body or internal organs. I have been asking you to look at what actions and "powers" you ascribe to the self. Ie doing, thinking, decision making, hearing, seeing, tasting etc. I have been asking you to look and see if there is a self behind all these things. In the same way that to detect a colorless odorless gas, you would look at the properties of that gas( eg burns on contact with naked flame) and then check to see if the gas has those properties.

So, when you look at all the actions and powers you ascribe to the self, can you find a self that is doing them?
Even thinking about it, is something doing the raining? Is the cloud a rainer? Is the cloud an active entity that is doing the raining? Or is cloud just part of the process?
Well raining is happening but we also have explanations.... There are active processes which include active entities which appear to be involved in raining happening.
you kind of missed/avoided my questions. Is the cloud a rainer? Is it an active entity doing the raining? What do you mean by active entity? In my mind that means a person or thing which is actively doing the activity. Is the cloud actively doing the raining, or does raining happen when the conditions arise( Eg certain percentage of moisture in the air, certain temperature and so on). In what way is the cloud an active entity? Can you define what you mean by active entity?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Mon Nov 05, 2012 5:27 pm

HI Neeel,
When I say look, yes it means look with the eyes, not by thinking about it. But I havent asked you to look inside your body or internal organs.
Yes i know - i was being funny.. it was a joke.. .. Is it all seriousness in the post self world - or is humour still allowed? (Ps.. that was also meant to be humorous... )

Although it seems to me that this concept of "Looking" is somewhat fraudulent in that what you are really doing is thinking and describing. But if someone goes beyond a first level thought description (eg.. There is rain falling... ) then this is labelled by you and LU as "Thinking"... and not "Looking".. A lot of contradictions... BUt whatever - I get that the pointing does not have to be logical or consistent or true in order for seeing to happen..
So, when you look at all the actions and powers you ascribe to the self, can you find a self that is doing them?
I already answered this question I do not know how many times ! I cannot find one ... But that is not the same as saying that there is no self.
Is the cloud a rainer? Is it an active entity doing the raining?
NO - raining occurs when the correct conditions arise..
Can you define what you mean by active entity?
Each part of the condition required for raining to occur... could be called a separate part or entity - so a cloud is required, moisture in the air is required, temperature alterations are required etc etc... Some of the tings may be physical things and some pay not be, but usually are caused by physical things as far as we know..

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Tue Nov 06, 2012 1:02 am

Yes i know - i was being funny.. it was a joke.. .. Is it all seriousness in the post self world - or is humour still allowed? (Ps.. that was also meant to be humorous... )
didnt realise it was a joke, sorry.
Although it seems to me that this concept of "Looking" is somewhat fraudulent in that what you are really doing is thinking and describing. But if someone goes beyond a first level thought description (eg.. There is rain falling... ) then this is labelled by you and LU as "Thinking"... and not "Looking".. A lot of contradictions... BUt whatever - I get that the pointing does not have to be logical or consistent or true in order for seeing to happen..


In what way am I asking you to think and describe?

we are communicating with language. Language involves concepts, ideas, thoughts, no getting away from that. the language we are using has an "I" concept, implicit in the language is the belief in the existence of an "I"

I ask you whether I am holding a blue ball

Thinking about it would be wondering whether I have a blue ball, thinking about what it would mean if I had a blue ball, pondering the meanings of blue and ball, imagining what a blue ball looks like,logically deducing the likelyhood of me having a blue ball, etc

Looking would be looking and seeing if I am holding a blue ball.( yes you need to use concepts, ideas, even thoughts, to report what you saw, but they are not part of the looking and seeing, are they?)

You could sit there for the rest of your life thinking about it, and would never know until you actually looked.

Another example, to look, rather than think -

You would observe thoughts as they come up, and see if theres an "I" thats doing them.

You would look and see if you have a selection of thoughts to choose from, or if the thought is already there.Observe the process closely. What happens when you try to choose the next thought?

You would look and see if you can predict your next thought. Observe the process closely. What happens when you try to predict the next thought?

Another one, try and think a random thought. Observe closely, what happens when you try to think a random thought?

observe, look, that doesnt sound like thinking to me.

I already answered this question I do not know how many times ! I cannot find one ... But that is not the same as saying that there is no self.
ok so how do you know you have a self then?
What evidence do you have for a self?
If you look in your room for a red dragon, and dont find one, does that mean that there is no dragon there? Do you hold on to the belief that there might be a dragon somewhere in the room, even if you have looked everywhere and not found one?

Looking back over the last few pages, I noticed something that I maybe glossed over a little bit
This NO I to truly see it and know it to be true must be rather bizarre because it means that everything is determined, there is no possibility, everything is just happening, free will does not exist and I am just like a machine that experiences and thinks and none of it is mine or controlled its just all happening... That seems very frightening to me... Maybe that is why I am resistant to seeing..
Look behind the fear, what is it that is frightening? Are these thoughts an accurate representation of reality? Are these thoughts not just projections and deductions, ie what you think it might be like?
Remember, if its true that theres no self, then its ALWAYS been true. Everything that has happened in your life already, has occurred without a self to do it ( if its true that there is no self). Take a look at cats. Is there a little cat self there controlling everything? Take a look at babies and children, how spontaneous, reactive, alive, energetic they are.

You are scared of loss of control. What are you in control of now, that you would lose if there was no self?



Each part of the condition required for raining to occur... could be called a separate part or entity - so a cloud is required, moisture in the air is required, temperature alterations are required etc etc... Some of the tings may be physical things and some pay not be, but usually are caused by physical things as far as we know..
None of these are entities, they are same as the cloud, they occur when the correct conditions arise, and none of these, cloud, moisture, temperature can be said to be doing the raining.

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Fri Nov 09, 2012 7:52 pm

Hi Neeeel,

There is no I in any shape or form.. There never was.. I is simply a strong illusion created by the idea that I am in here and everything else is out there..

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Fri Nov 09, 2012 7:55 pm

Hi Neeeel,

There is no I in any shape or form.. There never was.. I is simply a strong illusion created by the idea that I am in here and everything else is out there..

Colin
Ok, this is a bit of a change. What brought this realisation on? Do you feel you have SEEN it now?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Tue Nov 13, 2012 9:23 pm

hi Neeeel,

Everything just shows up in awareness or better in a kind of space of awareness including the me/I concept and all other thoughts and perceptions of stuff. I am the thing or nonthing - in which awareness occurs. I don't know what it is or even if it is anything.. This is certainly what looking at life as actually experienced without any filters looks like.. I do not know if it is true.. But it will always look as if it is.

All that happened is I dropped my filters and looked..

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Tue Nov 13, 2012 10:10 pm

hi Neeeel,

Everything just shows up in awareness or better in a kind of space of awareness including the me/I concept and all other thoughts and perceptions of stuff. I am the thing or nonthing - in which awareness occurs. I don't know what it is or even if it is anything.. This is certainly what looking at life as actually experienced without any filters looks like.. I do not know if it is true.. But it will always look as if it is.

All that happened is I dropped my filters and looked..

Colin
ok, but "everything just shows up in awareness" is just a concept, an idea, a thought. Yes, I know we need to use concepts to communicate, but this is very intellectual, it sounds like something you might have read somewhere. Is there such a thing as awareness in direct experience? If so , who or what is aware of awareness? Its just too much of an abstract level away from reality for me to be confident you have seen it.

Are YOU the thing or no thing in which awareness occurs? It sounds like you are still clinging to an identity, a self here. Does awareness occur IN anything? Do things( sounds, sights, sensations, thoughts) occur IN awareness? That implies a separation between awareness over here, being aware, and the stuff over there, that is being awared.

When you hear a sound, is there a sound, AND awareness of a sound?

Has anything changed for you since seeing this? If so, can you give me as much as you can on what has changed?

Do you feel that you have seen it clearly. Do you think that you are through the gate?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Wed Nov 14, 2012 10:22 am

Hi Neeeel,

No you are right I am being disingenuous. I have not seen it clearly- I am not through the gate. I don't know how to see it - I don't even know how to try. Whenever I try to do these exercises in looking etc - a fog /blankness descends on me...
Is there such a thing as awareness in direct experience?
Does awareness exist in reality - I don't know. Does awareness exist in direct experience - well no - awareness exists as a word and as a thought with a relatedness to the stuff that is happening, and the fact that the stuff that is happening includes the thought of "I" brings a thought of 'separateness ' ( I mean that there is a difference between in here and out there) and a thought that there is a relationship between the the thought of "I" and the stuff that is happening - when i fact, as counter intuitive as it seems, - there is no actual relationship in direct experience.. and there is no actual separation between in-here and out-there.... I feel like giving myself a back-door and saying there is no discernible separation to leave the room that there could be a separation but it cannot be seen in direct experience.
If so , who or what is aware of awareness?
I don't know... Nothing.. It just is
Are YOU the thing or no thing in which awareness occurs?
Awareness seems to occur in no-thing , in the absence of thing-ness. In direct experience it cannot be seen that there is a separation between in-here and out-there and so it is not related to the body/mind. - it is the space in which "thoughts about...." appear.. Awareness is like an absence - I can't really describe it very well..
It sounds like you are still clinging to an identity, a self here.
Probably.... I don't really know how to not cling to it.. I can only assume that this is a daily training of reminding myself and then maybe over time self identity clings less.
Does awareness occur IN anything? Do things( sounds, sights, sensations, thoughts) occur IN awareness? That implies a separation between awareness over here, being aware, and the stuff over there, that is being awared.
In reality I don't know.. In direct experience there is no separation. These things appear in the same space in which thoughts, thoughts of I, thoughts of awareness
When you hear a sound, is there a sound, AND awareness of a sound?


What comes to me is - the sound and the awareness are one - they are not separated..... but my mind boggles with this !!!!!!!

What to say - HELP !!!

PS _ just to say I have been traveling a fair bit again recently and I will be doing so again for the next few weeks and so as has been the case recently I may not always be able to respond every day...

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Wed Nov 14, 2012 3:07 pm

No you are right I am being disingenuous. I have not seen it clearly- I am not through the gate. I don't know how to see it - I don't even know how to try. Whenever I try to do these exercises in looking etc - a fog /blankness descends on me...
dont despair, you are making progress. I think that you are looking, and are seeing, it just maybe hasnt sunk in yet.

You say you dont know how to try, but you are already doing it. You are taking your assumptions and beliefs( eg the belief of separation, a me in here, and everything else out there) and looking at reality to see if it supports your assumptions and beliefs.

So, you have already seen that thoughts are automatic and spontaneous
You have seen that thoughts are "objects" in direct experience, same as sounds, sights, sensations etc.
You have seen how thoughts come up about stuff that is happening, that relate it to an "I"
You have seen how thoughts of "I" brings a thought of separateness
and so on



Does awareness exist in reality - I don't know. Does awareness exist in direct experience - well no - awareness exists as a word and as a thought with a relatedness to the stuff that is happening, and the fact that the stuff that is happening includes the thought of "I" brings a thought of 'separateness ' ( I mean that there is a difference between in here and out there) and a thought that there is a relationship between the the thought of "I" and the stuff that is happening - when i fact, as counter intuitive as it seems, - there is no actual relationship in direct experience.. and there is no actual separation between in-here and out-there.... I feel like giving myself a back-door and saying there is no discernible separation to leave the room that there could be a separation but it cannot be seen in direct experience.
This is fairly clear stuff. Can you talk a bit more about there being "no actual separation between in-here and out-there"?

Probably.... I don't really know how to not cling to it.. I can only assume that this is a daily training of reminding myself and then maybe over time self identity clings less.
Pretty much, although you dont want to remind yourself not to cling to it, or remind yourself that its not true, that is just telling yourself something until you believe it. Rather, remind yourself each day to LOOK. Its the looking, the seeing through the beliefs that helps things stick.

So keep looking at thoughts, how spontaneous and automatic they are.
Observe the thoughts,observe the "I" thoughts, look for the "I" that they refer to .
Keep looking at feelings, how they are just there, rather than there being a "you" that is doing them ( there is anger, rather than, I am angry, for example)
Look at stuff that happens throughout the day. Eg when you are talking to someone, notice how easy and automatic it is. Are you controlling all the muscles of the face to produce speech?
Look at when you are walking, how easy and automatic it is. Are you controlling all the muscles of the legs and body to produce walking?


I notice you didnt answer my question "Has anything changed for you since seeing this?". I am assuming you feel that nothing at all has changed?


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot], Semrush [Bot] and 21 guests