Yes i know - i was being funny.. it was a joke.. .. Is it all seriousness in the post self world - or is humour still allowed? (Ps.. that was also meant to be humorous... )
didnt realise it was a joke, sorry.
Although it seems to me that this concept of "Looking" is somewhat fraudulent in that what you are really doing is thinking and describing. But if someone goes beyond a first level thought description (eg.. There is rain falling... ) then this is labelled by you and LU as "Thinking"... and not "Looking".. A lot of contradictions... BUt whatever - I get that the pointing does not have to be logical or consistent or true in order for seeing to happen..
In what way am I asking you to think and describe?
we are communicating with language. Language involves concepts, ideas, thoughts, no getting away from that. the language we are using has an "I" concept, implicit in the language is the belief in the existence of an "I"
I ask you whether I am holding a blue ball
Thinking about it would be wondering whether I have a blue ball, thinking about what it would mean if I had a blue ball, pondering the meanings of blue and ball, imagining what a blue ball looks like,logically deducing the likelyhood of me having a blue ball, etc
Looking would be looking and seeing if I am holding a blue ball.( yes you need to use concepts, ideas, even thoughts, to report what you saw, but they are not part of the looking and seeing, are they?)
You could sit there for the rest of your life thinking about it, and would never know until you actually looked.
Another example, to look, rather than think -
You would observe thoughts as they come up, and see if theres an "I" thats doing them.
You would look and see if you have a selection of thoughts to choose from, or if the thought is already there.Observe the process closely. What happens when you try to choose the next thought?
You would look and see if you can predict your next thought. Observe the process closely. What happens when you try to predict the next thought?
Another one, try and think a random thought. Observe closely, what happens when you try to think a random thought?
observe, look, that doesnt sound like thinking to me.
I already answered this question I do not know how many times ! I cannot find one ... But that is not the same as saying that there is no self.
ok so how do you know you have a self then?
What evidence do you have for a self?
If you look in your room for a red dragon, and dont find one, does that mean that there is no dragon there? Do you hold on to the belief that there might be a dragon somewhere in the room, even if you have looked everywhere and not found one?
Looking back over the last few pages, I noticed something that I maybe glossed over a little bit
This NO I to truly see it and know it to be true must be rather bizarre because it means that everything is determined, there is no possibility, everything is just happening, free will does not exist and I am just like a machine that experiences and thinks and none of it is mine or controlled its just all happening... That seems very frightening to me... Maybe that is why I am resistant to seeing..
Look behind the fear, what is it that is frightening? Are these thoughts an accurate representation of reality? Are these thoughts not just projections and deductions, ie what you think it might be like?
Remember, if its true that theres no self, then its ALWAYS been true. Everything that has happened in your life already, has occurred without a self to do it ( if its true that there is no self). Take a look at cats. Is there a little cat self there controlling everything? Take a look at babies and children, how spontaneous, reactive, alive, energetic they are.
You are scared of loss of control. What are you in control of now, that you would lose if there was no self?
Each part of the condition required for raining to occur... could be called a separate part or entity - so a cloud is required, moisture in the air is required, temperature alterations are required etc etc... Some of the tings may be physical things and some pay not be, but usually are caused by physical things as far as we know..
None of these are entities, they are same as the cloud, they occur when the correct conditions arise, and none of these, cloud, moisture, temperature can be said to be doing the raining.