Stream Entry

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Thu Jun 06, 2024 5:42 am

Hi Nicholas
I don’t know. I don’t even know what a dividing line is in this case. This one I don’t see it yet.
So a dividing line cannot be found?
Could that be because a dividing line does not in fact exist in direct experience?
I don’t know. Is there another way to see this? Is there a dividing line between hearing and seeing or is that a different kind?


Just LOOK again ....is there any dividing line actually found?
Hahaha! So confused here. I will stray a bit here. Do people that are at “level 0” of this path find dividing lines? How does that look?

I’m asking because I really don’t know what I’m looking for exactly.
Conceptual thinking is taking hold here Nicholas. But let's break down what you have said and LOOK at this in raw DE terms. Keep it simple.
Yes I did it fully aware. It was necessary because there are things I don’t understand, so I cannot try to see something that I don’t really understand. For example: if you tell me “now feel your feet” but I have no idea what “feel” means… I have to ask!
Dreaming is closer to hallucinations, they happen right in front of our eyes.
When you say "right in front of our eyes" are you saying that SEEING depends on our physical eyes?
Not exactly. Depends on the brain. But dreaming has more resemblance to what we see awake than imagination.
In your DIRECT experience right now can you find and describe a mental image that is not seen?
I’m not sure I understand. Could you rephrase or dissect this question please?
Is this any clearer now?
I get that we are trying to arrive to no “outside” no “inside”. I’m not there yet.

I think I need to internalize this “Wherever there is color in experience, there is SEEING”

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Thu Jun 06, 2024 10:53 am

Hi Nicholas,

I get that we are trying to arrive to no “outside” no “inside”. I’m not there yet.
I think I need to internalize this “Wherever there is color in experience, there is SEEING”
Yes, that's what comes here too Nicholas. Let this clarify itself as we get back into your recap of the exercises and questions and see what other "bricks" fall

And it pays to again remind ourselves that at the heart of the investigation is LOOKING to see that there is no such entity as an independent "me" - that this "me" is a fictitious mind construct.

So let's get back to your second pass of the questions.



With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Fri Jun 07, 2024 3:08 am

Yes, that's what comes here too Nicholas. Let this clarify itself as we get back into your recap of the exercises and questions and see what other "bricks" fall
Yeah sometimes it is better to stop pushing and try another route
(thought exercise)
Using some specific examples from your experience let me know how you go.
Ok as always… 3 layers. I’m going to observe first one

1 monologue
2 music
3 random undefined thoughts

Ok they come like knee jerk reaction (monologue). It’s like it has a life of its own.
When observing thoughts the monologue becomes about this exercise.
When reacting to thoughts that also generates more thoughts.

When finding a gap… that’s also a thought “oh here’s the gap… oh it’s not there anymore”

Mhm, it seems that it is not possible to focus on nothing. Always something calls my attention. There’s always stuff in the background.

Its hard to focus

Tinnitus, hehe

Mhm doesn’t seem that mind slows down. It goes super super fast, all the time, a whirlind chaotic stream of thoughts.
Also are you experiencing any reaction to observing thoughts in this way? Any resistance? Any hesitation? Any undue procrastination? Let me know about your reactions to doing this as that might also give us some important clues.
Fatigue. Just that.
Tell me about your experience in the gap. Is there anything in particular that you notice when in the gap?
I don’t if it’s a true gap. But I haven’t noticed anything!

Observations:

+ no difference, same issues as before in this case

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Fri Jun 07, 2024 1:01 pm

OK Nicholas
Ok as always… 3 layers. I’m going to observe first one

1 monologue
2 music
3 random undefined thoughts
For these net questions please take your time and REALLY LOOK to DIRECT EXPERIENCE and describe what you see in DE.
Do at least 2 or 3 passes of these questions.
For any or all the layers of thought you report ......
These thoughts ....what are they arising in?




What notices these thoughts are happening?




Is there a "me" that knows or notices these thoughts or is noticing just happening?



Its hard to focus
What is it that finds it hard to focus?




Is there a "me" anywhere to be found that finds it hard to focus or is "hard to focus" just happening





If the thought "its hard to focus" was not believed, what would be experienced?





What happens if attention is relaxed and not focused anywhere in particular?





With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Sat Jun 08, 2024 6:03 am

These thoughts ....what are they arising in?
mmhm they are also sound. Because they have an auditive quality. I think I’m understanding the “everything is color including imagination”.

Now that I think about it… it seems that they just arise, like the sounds outside. The difference might be preconceptions, also they “sound” different from external sounds.


What notices these thoughts are happening?
I don’t know. Entity. Sustained by belief.


Is there a "me" that knows or notices these thoughts or is noticing just happening?
Yeah I’m still under the reality that “me” is noticing those thoughts.
Its hard to focus
What is it that finds it hard to focus?
same “me”


Is there a "me" anywhere to be found that finds it hard to focus or is "hard to focus" just happening
yes, as a reality/belief.



If the thought "its hard to focus" was not believed, what would be experienced?
fatigue


What happens if attention is relaxed and not focused anywhere in particular?
Attention always goes somewhere, jumps from here to there.

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Sat Jun 08, 2024 1:01 pm

Hello Nicholas

mmhm they are also sound. Because they have an auditive quality. I think I’m understanding the “everything is color including imagination”.

Now that I think about it… it seems that they just arise, like the sounds outside. The difference might be preconceptions, also they “sound” different from external sounds.
In reading your reply here I see that the earlier explanation about seeing color in imagination was not as clear as it could have been and may well have created some confusion.

I'm going to clarify this as we need to clear about the fundamentals before we move on.

Anything we experience in imagination is the AE of thought. Experiencing whatever seeming "qualities" are contained in thought- images,voices, color, sounds, smell, taste - is the AE of thought. The AE of thought is an imitation of the AE of the five senses. Imagination is a story ABOUT reality, a fictional simulation of reality and not the reality of the direct experience of the senses - seeing, hearing, smelling, tasting and touching.

Keeping a crystal clear distinction between
- the AE of thought on one hand
AND
- the AE of the five senses on the other hand

is fundamental to this investigation.

So apologies if this earlier description created some confusion.
Does that help make it clearer now Nicholas or do you have any questions about this before we move on?



With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Sun Jun 09, 2024 3:18 am

Hi Alan…
Does that help make it clearer now Nicholas or do you have any questions about this before we move on?
Not sure! I went to the previous post and saw these written by you:
So whether SEEING is "within" or "without" so called, can you see it is the same SEEING sense?
But SEEING is SEEING regardless of whether color is in, or not in, imagination.
SEEING is not confined to physical eyes
Confused. So you say there’s a distinction… but then why it’s the same “seeing” sense? Or wait… are you saying it’s the same sense but applied to different areas? One of DE of five senses and one of DE of thought?

Then why Is this wrong?
mmhm they are also sound. Because they have an auditive quality. I think I’m understanding the “everything is color including imagination”.

Now that I think about it… it seems that they just arise, like the sounds outside. The difference might be preconceptions, also they “sound” different from external sounds.

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Sun Jun 09, 2024 11:10 am

Hello Nicholas
Or wait… are you saying it’s the same sense but applied to different areas? One of DE of five senses and one of DE of thought?
If I understand you here yes, that is one way of saying it.

However I sense the comments made about seeing in imagination are more of a distraction rather than a help right now so PLEASE LEAVE THEM ASIDE for now. For the purposes of what we are doing here we need to come back to the fundamentals.

Do you remember this at the start of the thread?

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Direct or Actual Experience (DE or AE for short)


So many of us humans believe we are seeing clearly when in fact we are seeing through what might be described as a fog of thought (labels, beliefs, concepts, assumptions, perspectives and many other attributes of what we call mind) This can come as a bit of a shock and also a great relief to truly see the ways in which we do this.

So what is this Direct or Actual Experiencing? For practical purposes we can identify 6 aspects of experiencing. It is PURE

Seeing
Hearing
Feeling (Sensation,
not emotion. Emotion is Sensation plus made-up thoughts & labels)
Tasting
Smelling
Thoughts Arising
(but not their content)

We are depending totally on DE to LOOK for no self.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Please note in particular the pointing to "Thoughts Arising(but not their content)"

The mind loves to get into the CONTENT of thought - especially the analytical mind and this little "detour" can help us notice how subtly this can happen.

Further commentary about seeing in imagination will likely draw us into the CONTENT of thought which at this stage is not helpful.

Rather it is being aware of the ARISING OF thought and then being aware of the automatic tendency of being seduced into the content(story) of thought. This is what needs to be recognized

So when you ask ........
Then why Is this wrong?
mmhm they are also sound. Because they have an auditive quality. I think I’m understanding the “everything is color including imagination”.

Now that I think about it… it seems that they just arise, like the sounds outside. The difference might be preconceptions, also they “sound” different from external sounds.


It's not WRONG per say but when you start to look at the qualities of thought such as "auditive quality or sounding different" recognize that you are being drawn into the CONTENT of thought. Simply recognizing that these are THOUGHTS ARISING is what is necessary here WITHOUT analyzing their content. Recognizing when we are being drawn into the content of thought is the aim of this investigation.

Now the ACTUAL question of this exercise is...What are thoughts arising IN? The question is not about the characteristics of the thoughts themselves (content) but what are they arising IN? Or what are they appearing IN?

Here is a way to approach this. Thoughts are like the words on the white page of a book. When you read a book the words are what stand out. However we are rarely conscious of the white page the words appear on. That white page is something we typically take no notice of until our attention is drawn to it. Yet without the page on which the words appear, there would be no words at all.

So similarly, thoughts appear and you notice them. Unless our attention is drawn to it rarely do we notice what thoughts arise IN. This then is the question we come to here. What do thoughts arise IN?

I ask you to go back and LOOK again at the following questions in that context

For these questions please take your time and REALLY LOOK to DIRECT EXPERIENCE and describe what you see in DE.
Do at least 2 or 3 passes of these questions. DO NOT GO TO THOUGHT FOR AN ANSWER
For any or all the layers of thought you report ......
These thoughts ....what are they ARISING IN?




What notices these thoughts are happening?




Is there a "me" that knows or notices what these thoughts are appearing in or is there simply awareness of thoughts?





With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Mon Jun 10, 2024 4:39 am

These thoughts ....what are they ARISING IN?
consciousness?
Space?

I don’t know.


What notices these thoughts are happening?
I don’t know.
“more thoughts” came by.

Is there a "me" that knows or notices what these thoughts are appearing in or is there simply awareness of thoughts?
Awareness, but I identify with that awareness (me). Without awareness there’s no noticing.

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Mon Jun 10, 2024 1:43 pm

Nicholas
consciousness?
Space?
Can you see how the mind kicks in with labels?




I don’t know.
Cognitively this is the truth. The mind can never know the truth of this.
However when we don't put a label on something and then be willing to stay with it, a deeper exploration tends to open up and become possible which leads to an experiential richness.

You have just said "I don't know" and we acknowledge the truth of that.
So this next question is not to challenge your responses but to invoke a deeper LOOKING and CURIOSITY here.
If you didn't know anything about these labels and someone insisted you attempt to offer some description how would you attempt to describe what thoughts arise in?




What notices these thoughts are happening?
I don’t know.
“more thoughts” came by.
Clear seeing here.

Awareness, but I identify with that awareness (me).
You clearly say you identify with that awareness so you realize identification is happening. Tell me what you find as you LOOK for this identification happening
How does this identification happen?





With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Tue Jun 11, 2024 4:02 am

consciousness?
Space?
Can you see how the mind kicks in with labels?
Yeah I’m aware! But then if I can’t go to the mind… then I can’t answer.
If you didn't know anything about these labels and someone insisted you attempt to offer some description how would you attempt to describe what thoughts arise in?
Can’t be described. So they are not arising anywhere? I don’t get this.
You clearly say you identify with that awareness so you realize identification is happening. Tell me what you find as you LOOK for this identification happening
How does this identification happen?
If there’s no awareness then nobody can receive what comes from the 6 doors.

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Tue Jun 11, 2024 1:50 pm

Hello Nicholas
Can you see how the mind kicks in with labels?
Yeah I’m aware! But then if I can’t go to the mind… then I can’t answer.
There is a subtlety here which is important.
Labels in and of themselves are not an issue. And you're right that we have to use them to communicate.
The issue is that unwittingly we can be going to the mind for an answer and not realize it. It is easy for people to use words like consciousness and leave that understanding at a cognitive level. I'm not saying that is what you are doing - in fact when you say later "I don't know" it can be seen that you are endeavoring to see past the labels. Its this LOOKING past the labels that reveals the truth of what we truly are.

You clearly say you identify with that awareness so you realize identification is happening. Tell me what you find as you LOOK for this identification happening
How does this identification happen?
If there’s no awareness then nobody can receive what comes from the 6 doors.
This question is about IDENTIFICATION. The way in which we identify is simply believing a thought about a thought. Specifically it is a thought about a fictional "ME" (and my and mine) being believed in relation to another thought that creates the illusion that a "me" actually exists.

Take a long look at this next statement and really feel into the truth of it.

There is no self at All in reality, no me as a general manager of life, no owner of life, no watcher, no I that is in control of anything that happens. None at all as in zero. All there is if life happening by itself.
Tell me......what reactions and thoughts come up?




What does word me point to?




What is "I"?





Ok. Let's go back to your reviewing the questions again Nicholas. I think the last ones you reviewed were in your June 4 post.


With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Thu Jun 13, 2024 3:40 am

There is no self at All in reality, no me as a general manager of life, no owner of life, no watcher, no I that is in control of anything that happens. None at all as in zero. All there is if life happening by itself.
Tell me......what reactions and thoughts come up?
ok but I’m still under the strong belief of a watcher, manager, owner… and so.


What does word me point to?
nowhere, it’s just a word


What is "I"?
Just a label. Thoughts over thoughts.
Nature of Thought

Here is a another way we come at observing thought. Sit quietly for a few minutes ( if you find it is too uncomfortable let it be and come back to again) and notice the arising thoughts. Just let them appear as they appear. Try your best to COMPLETELY ignore what they are saying and just notice how they appear, without you doing anything at all.Please do not try to figure this out. Simply note down the first "thing" that you are aware of as you LOOK. And yes you do have to resort to using labels to communicate this.Simply note down the first "thing" that you are aware of as you LOOK.

Where are thoughts coming from and going to?
nowhere
Did you do anything to make a particular thought or thoughts appear?
sometimes it seems so

Could you have done anything to make a different thought appear at that exact moment instead?
maybe

Can you predict your next thought?
It’s impossible just “trying” to predict.

Observations:
+ no differences, maybe a bit rambling but still no revelations here

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Thu Jun 13, 2024 1:40 pm

Nicholas
ok but I’m still under the strong belief of a watcher, manager, owner… and so.
Can you see that a belief is a thought about another thought that is accepted as true?




If the thought that there is a watcher, manager, owner was not there does experiencing stop or change in any way?





What does word me point to?
nowhere, it’s just a word
What is "I"?
Just a label. Thoughts over thoughts
.
So you see that me and I are just words, labels, thoughts.
Yet on the other hand you say that somehow the me and I thought are believed.
There is a real contradiction here.
What is it that makes them seem so real in your experience?





Do the words I and me have any independent life in and of themselves?




Are the words I and me simply symbols for a concept?





sometimes it seems so
It seems so
But is it so?




maybe
Sounds like a guess.
Tell me what you need to do to make a different thought of your choosing appear at an exact moment?




Can you predict your next thought?
It’s impossible just “trying” to predict.
I'm not sure of your answer here.
So again ......can you predict your next thought? Yes or no?




but still no revelations here
Sounds like an expectation.
Is there something more than the truth that's seen in direct experience that you're waiting for?






With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Fri Jun 14, 2024 6:54 am

ok but I’m still under the strong belief of a watcher, manager, owner… and so.
Can you see that a belief is a thought about another thought that is accepted as true?
yes


If the thought that there is a watcher, manager, owner was not there does experiencing stop or change in any way?
It’s not even a thought, I just sit here quietly without thinking. But I still “see” that I’m the owner.
How can I see? Because I’m not thinking anything at the moment. Just moving my eyes.
So you see that me and I are just words, labels, thoughts.
Yet on the other hand you say that somehow the me and I thought are believed.
There is a real contradiction here.
What is it that makes them seem so real in your experience?
Because it’s my reality. I cannot imagine how it would be without this “knowing” or belief.
Do the words I and me have any independent life in and of themselves?
they are just words


Are the words I and me simply symbols for a concept?
They are, but it’s a concept that I can’t even describe
sometimes it seems so
It seems so
But is it so?
I don’t know. If I say to myself “I’m going to think about dragons” then… why dragons? Did I choose dragons? I didn’t choose that. So… how do I choose? Whatever thing I want to think next it’s like… I’m not really in control. “Now I’m going to think about yellow and for the next 2 minutes just going to think yellow things”. Again… why yellow? Did I choose that? Seems like I actually cannot choose anything but I cannot explain what’s behind this. There’s something here though… something I cannot manage to see.
There are just influences…
maybe
Sounds like a guess.
Tell me what you need to do to make a different thought of your choosing appear at an exact moment?
Nothing, it seems I’m not choosing anything.
Can you predict your next thought?
It’s impossible just “trying” to predict.
I'm not sure of your answer here.
So again ......can you predict your next thought? Yes or no?
Please don’t get mad at me. Just show me where I’m going wrong. Sometimes I hit blind spots and I’m like a crazy man just overflowing the cup with water and spilling everywhere while shouting “oh this cup isn’t full yet it needs more water!”

I can predict not my immediate next thought, but a thought at a certain moment or time, based on context.
but still no revelations here
Sounds like an expectation.
Is there something more than the truth that's seen in direct experience that you're waiting for?
Nop.


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 68 guests