Hello Nicholas
Or wait… are you saying it’s the same sense but applied to different areas? One of DE of five senses and one of DE of thought?
If I understand you here yes, that is one way of saying it.
However I sense the comments made about seeing in imagination are more of a distraction rather than a help right now so PLEASE LEAVE THEM ASIDE for now. For the purposes of what we are doing here we need to come back to the fundamentals.
Do you remember this at the start of the thread?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Direct or Actual Experience (DE or AE for short)
So many of us humans believe we are seeing clearly when in fact we are seeing through what might be described as a fog of thought (labels, beliefs, concepts, assumptions, perspectives and many other attributes of what we call mind) This can come as a bit of a shock and also a great relief to truly see the ways in which we do this.
So what is this Direct or Actual Experiencing? For practical purposes we can identify 6 aspects of experiencing. It is PURE
Seeing
Hearing
Feeling (Sensation, not emotion. Emotion is Sensation plus made-up thoughts & labels)
Tasting
Smelling
Thoughts Arising (but not their content)
We are depending totally on DE to LOOK for no self.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Please note in particular the pointing to "
Thoughts Arising(
but not their content)"
The mind loves to get into the CONTENT of thought - especially the analytical mind and this little "detour" can help us notice how subtly this can happen.
Further commentary about seeing in imagination will likely draw us into the CONTENT of thought which at this stage is not helpful.
Rather it is being aware of the ARISING OF thought and then being aware of the automatic tendency of being seduced into the content(story) of thought. This is what needs to be recognized
So when you ask ........
Then why Is this wrong?
mmhm they are also sound. Because they have an auditive quality. I think I’m understanding the “everything is color including imagination”.
Now that I think about it… it seems that they just arise, like the sounds outside. The difference might be preconceptions, also they “sound” different from external sounds.
It's not WRONG per say but when you start to look at the qualities of thought such as "auditive quality or sounding different" recognize that you are being drawn into the CONTENT of thought. Simply recognizing that these are THOUGHTS ARISING is what is necessary here WITHOUT analyzing their content. Recognizing
when we are being drawn into the content of thought is the aim of this investigation.
Now the ACTUAL question of this exercise is...What are thoughts arising
IN? The question is not about the characteristics of the thoughts themselves (content) but what are they arising IN? Or what are they appearing IN?
Here is a way to approach this. Thoughts are like the words on the white page of a book. When you read a book the words are what stand out. However we are rarely conscious of the white page the words appear on. That white page is something we typically take no notice of until our attention is drawn to it. Yet without the page on which the words appear, there would be no words at all.
So similarly, thoughts appear and you notice them. Unless our attention is drawn to it rarely do we notice what thoughts arise IN. This then is the question we come to here. What do thoughts arise
IN?
I ask you to go back and LOOK again at the following questions in that context
For these questions please take your time and REALLY LOOK to DIRECT EXPERIENCE and describe what you see in DE.
Do at least 2 or 3 passes of these questions. DO NOT GO TO THOUGHT FOR AN ANSWER
For any or all the layers of thought you report ......
These thoughts ....what are they ARISING IN?
What notices these thoughts are happening?
Is there a "me" that knows or notices what these thoughts are appearing in or is there simply awareness of thoughts?
With love
Alan