Hello Alan.
Ah... uh... yeah I might have a problem. it's something that tend to happens to me, something that I tend to do but I have no idea what it is, how to describe it, if it has a name, if it's a cognitive problem...
Sometimes I have trouble following instructions/orders. It happens all the time, never managed to avoid it because I don't even know what kind of issue is it exactly.
It happens when someone asks me to go buy something or at work. I cannot remember specific examples right now, but for example... if I see a gym routine on the internet, and the routine specifically says "DON'T CHANGE ANYTHING IN THIS ROUTINE" guess what... I still change some minor things
things like that.
And I mention this to you because I already did this... and maybe I did it a couple times without realizing.
when I saw your instructions something like this happened:
"ok, what is the AE of typing. it says close your eyes... ok. oh but then it says focus on actual experience (5 senses) and says to take each sense at the same time... well... then I'm going to do it with eyes open. oh but then it says with eyes closed? ok I'm confused... eeh... ok I'm just going to do it with eyes open, I mean... if I really focus on each sense then I'm sure it won't be any different"
I don't know why it happens. do you know if it has a name? maybe a disorder or something?
anyways, sorry for this!
now to the questions...
How could that be your experience with eyes closed?
because I did with my eyes opened.
You also said .......
Taste = not going to taste it! But I feel… combination of tastes of food I had before
To reference tastes of food you had before were you not referencing memory (which is thought)?
AH! it's harder than I thought.
1. With eyes closed and hands on the keyboard what do you actually see?
Is there actually an image in mind of hands and keyboard as you LOOK?
no, I see nothing or darkness
Now, again turn attention to your hands ‘typing on a keyboard ’ and with eyes CLOSED, ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the colour.
With eyes closed do you see anything else other than the “black” of your eyelids? (or any other little flashes of light that might come with eyes closed)
only black
2. Now, turn attention to your hands ‘typing on keyboard ’ and CLOSE the eyes. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the sensation.
Does the sensation itself suggest in any way typing on keyboard, and that it knows anything about ‘typing on a keyboard’? Or that the sensation knows anything about keys? Or is it just simply AE of sensation?
ok, this is where I get confused. how do I describe what I'm experiencing? I have to use labels, I have no other choice. otherwise would be simply... just sensation.
I get confused based on how the question is asked. what do you feel? sensation of hands typing.
but if you ask me "do you just simply feel DE of sensation"? then... yes
ok... I think I get it. ok, enough with the "conceptual discussion".
again
2. Now, turn attention to your hands ‘typing on keyboard ’ and CLOSE the eyes. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the sensation.
Does the sensation itself suggest in any way typing on keyboard, and that it knows anything about ‘typing on a keyboard’? Or that the sensation knows anything about keys? Or is it just simply AE of sensation?
just sensation
Again LOOK to see whether there are images of hands or fingers or keys or keyboard popping up that you are unconsciously referencing. This can be so subtle.
Do you catch this happening at all?
yes, yes it happens. hard to ignore. even after ignoring "keyboard" some other appear like "cold, soft"
Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the sensation that has anything to do with ‘typing on a keyboard’?
without thought or preconceptions... there's nothing. just the sensation.
3. Now, with eyes CLOSED notice the smell of the ‘keyboard’. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and just focus on the smell.
Does smell itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about ‘typing on a keyboard? Or is there just simple AE of smell?
just smell
Again LOOK to see whether there are images of hands or fingers or keys or keyboard popping up or perhaps just flash up momentarily that you are unconsciously referencing. Remember this can be so subtle.
Do you catch this happening at all?
the mind is trying to label the smell. comparing it with other things. analyzing it.
Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the smell of a ‘keyboard’?
without thoughts... every smell is always new, over and over again.
4. Now, listen to the sound of ‘typing on keyboard’ with eyes CLOSED. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and just focus on the sound.
Does the sound itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about typing on a keyboard? Or is there just simple AE of sound?
just sound
Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that the sound is that of ‘typing on a keyboard’?
without thought there are no labels, all sounds are just sounds. they have no... owner? (I don't know why I said that)
5. So now look at the label ‘typing on keyboard" and the thought “I am typing on a keyboard”.
Does the label itself or the thought itself know anything about an ‘typing on a keyboard’? Or are they just simply AE of label/thought?
they are just thoughts
So is there really actual experience of an ‘typing on a keyboard’, or simply actual experience of what is actually appearing, what the actual experience is, is colour, sensation, smell, sound, which thought then labels and describes as an 'typing on a keyboard'?
just a bunch of thoughts appearing and sensations and the super quick conceptualization of "typing on keyboard"
In other words, is typing on a keyboard actually known or only thoughts about typing on a keyboard are known?
only thoughts about typing on keyboard.
Now repeat the exercise this time with eyes OPEN.
1. With eyes open and typing on the keyboard what do you actually see?
Is there an image or a label in mind of a keyboard as you LOOK?
aah yes.
If so, then you are referencing thought and not actual experience
Now, again turn attention to your hands ‘typing on a keyboard ’ and with eyes OPEN, ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the colour.
Does the colour itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about ‘hands’ or ‘keyboard ’? Or is it just simply AE of colour?
oh... it's like a baby. a baby doesn't understand a damn thing what's going on. just simple DE of colour.
Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that the colour appearing is that of ‘hands’ or ‘keyboard ’?
no way of knowing
2. Now, turn attention to your hands ‘typing on keyboard ’ and with eyes open, ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on keyboard’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the sensation.
Does the sensation itself suggest in any way typing on keyboard, and that it knows anything about ‘typing on a keyboard’? Or that the sensation knows anything about keys? Or is it just simply AE of sensation?
hard to see. but just sensation.
Again LOOK to see whether, as well as experiencing sensation, there is unconscious referencing of the images or thoughts of hands or fingers or keys or keyboard.
Is this referencing happening in any way at all?
mmmhm.... it's more like distractions. like "I SEE KEYBOARD AND HANDS" and no "I TOUCH KEYBOARD WITH HANDS"
Is there difference in experience of sensation only between having your eyes OPEN and your eyes CLOSED?
it's the same, the difference is the number of distractions.
Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the sensation has anything to do with ‘typing on a keyboard’?
no way of knowing.
3. Now, with eyes open notice the smell of the ‘keyboard’. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and just focus on the smell.
Does smell itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about ‘typing on a keyboard? Or is there just simple AE of smell?
just smell
Again LOOK to see whether there are labels / thoughts / images of hands or fingers or keys or keyboard popping up or perhaps just flash up momentarily that you are unconsciously referencing.
Is this happening in any way at all?
same as before. instead of "keyboard smell" it looks for similar objects... like car. ugh.
Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the smell of a ‘keyboard’?
not known
4. Now, listen to the sound of ‘typing on keyboard’ with eyes open. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and just focus on the sound.
Does the sound itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about typing on a keyboard? Or is there just simple AE of sound?
just sound
Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that the sound is that of ‘typing on a keyboard’?
no knowing
5. So now look at the label ‘typing on keyboard and the thought “I am looking at, and, typing on a keyboard”.
Does the label itself or the thought itself know anything about an ‘typing on keyboard’? Or are they just simply AE of label/thought?
they are just thoughts
So is there really actual experience of an ‘typing on a keyboard’, or what is actually appearing, what the actual experience is, is colour, sensation, smell, sound, which thought then labels and describes as an 'typing on a keyboard'?
no actual experience. there's no actual experience of anything then?
In other words, is typing on a keyboard actually known or only thoughts about typing on a keyboard are known?
only thoughts labeling
If you were asked by a 7 year old out of the blue "What is direct experience?" how would you answer from your own experience?
I don't know. I spent several minutes on this... but I have no idea. I don't know how to make it understandable to a small kid.