Stream Entry

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Sun May 12, 2024 2:22 am

It is generally believed that thoughts are coming from the head somewhere around the forehead. When we try to trace back the origin of a thought, it is often believed that it's coming from the forehead, because the attention automatically goes to the sensation or feeling of the forehead.

Investigate this carefully as often as you can throughout the day.
What do you find?
thoughts have an auditive quality. also ears are in the head.
yes, there is a REALLY strong feeling with each thought, that they come from the head.
Have a very deep look here... the forehead is one of the 'residences' of the SENSE of self. Or rather say, the sensation or feeling that is labelled as forehead is believed to be one of the locations of the sense of self.

LOOK deeply at this next question before glancing further down the page.
What is the forehead in the actual experience?
a sensation in the head. something that I can see in the mirror, or touch with my hands.


In YOUR actual experience is it anything other than a feeling + a mental image (of a forehead) or some form of thought "this is my forehead"?
it's a body part that I can touch with my hands.


Is your actual experience any different from this?
a little


So, can a thought come from a feeling?
they come from nowhere
Can a thought come from a mental image?
a mental image is another thought. no.
Furthermore, it's also believed that both the 'visual sight' and 'mental images' are coming from the eyes, because when it's investigated the attention automatically goes to the sensation 'of the eyes', and at the same time the image 'of the eyes' or a thought ABOUT the eyes appears with it.

So another SENSE of self is linked to the feeling of what we label 'eyes'.

LOOK VERY CAREFULLY again.
What are the eyes in the actual experience?
something I can move. giving place to new visuals. something that I can touch.

A feeling + a mental image or some form of thought "these are my eyes", right?
I don't see that
Can seeing come from a feeling?
no



Can seeing come from an image (of the eyes)?
no


Can a 'mental image' come from a feeling?
no


Can a 'mental image' come from another mental image (of the eyes)?
no


So could it simply be that this notion that there is a "me" that is in control is simply a thought?
it's a belief. still a reality.
Please read this statement.

This belief in a "me" has comes about through a process of hypnosis - acceptance of verbal cues and mental images which we have accepted without question for as long as we can remember.

What is felt about that statement?
how crazy. amused. wow. haha its feels like I have been brainwashed, like from a cult. like believing the world is flat and you are showing me it's not but I still don't see it.

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Sun May 12, 2024 11:46 am

like believing the world is flat and you are showing me it's not
This is a really good analogy Nicholas

But here's the thing. A definition of Insanity "is doing what you've always done and expecting the results to be different"
Have you heard that before?



If you continued to see the world and talk about it in the way those who believed it was flat did, would that not make it very, very difficult to accept the truth of it being round?




If you continue to look at experience the way you've always done (through the mind) then you'll only see what you've always seen

Let me explain further. Back on April 30 you said ....
I just feel the body. That’s when I realize it’s a concept.
I hear you saying that "you realize the body is a concept."
Do you really accept the body is a concept?




In this post I sense you continue to speak as though you really do not believe the body (and all its "parts") are a concept. You speak of head, hands and ears. Yes we have to use those words as pointers and we do in exercises. BUT in doing so the exercises are pointing for you to DIRECTLY EXPERIENCE the truth that they are mere concepts. If we continue to speak of them as we've always done - as something that exists in and of itself - then we're making it a pretty difficult journey for ourselves.

What really has me question whether you truly believe that the body is a concept is when you say....
a sensation in the head. something that I can see in the mirror, or touch with my hands.
Do you actually experience your head DIRECTLY in the mirror?




Surely the truth is that in the mirror you see a bunch of colors that you LABEL head?



In fact even in relative terms to say it is your head is short of the mark. It would closer in relative terms to say it is only your face.


Before we go on we need to be really clear here about how you experience the body whenever you LOOK and experience DIRECTLY. I'd encourage you to go back and look at the body exploration exercises and ask
"What is the one thing that stops me from accepting what's actually experienced in DIRECT EXPERIENCE?"

And once you have done that then respond to this question again from YOUR DIRECT EXPERIENCE.

Is it clear to you that your body, the whole or in part, that we call "I" or "me" is nothing other than a concept, a thought, an idea, a label, a symbol in language, an image in mind that has no separate, independent existence in and of itself?




If you do recognize the body is a concept, how would you best describe your experience of that which we label body in YOUR DIRECT EXPERIENCE?





With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Mon May 13, 2024 2:31 am

But here's the thing. A definition of Insanity "is doing what you've always done and expecting the results to be different"
Have you heard that before?
yes
If you continued to see the world and talk about it in the way those who believed it was flat did, would that not make it very, very difficult to accept the truth of it being round?
yes
I just feel the body. That’s when I realize it’s a concept.
I hear you saying that "you realize the body is a concept."
Do you really accept the body is a concept?
oh no, that's not what I meant. I'm still not seeing the body as a concept. let me show you what I meant

I’ve been telling you over and over “I feel this me, I feel this me” but again… how can I feel it? I’m not feeling anything, it is not true. (I just feel the body.) That’s when I realize it’s a concept.

(the "me" is a concept, not a feeling)

I will still try to answer the questions:
a sensation in the head. something that I can see in the mirror, or touch with my hands.
Do you actually experience your head DIRECTLY in the mirror?
no

Surely the truth is that in the mirror you see a bunch of colors that you LABEL head?
yes
Before we go on we need to be really clear here about how you experience the body whenever you LOOK and experience DIRECTLY. I'd encourage you to go back and look at the body exploration exercises and ask
"What is the one thing that stops me from accepting what's actually experienced in DIRECT EXPERIENCE?"
I'm having trouble using all senses at the same time. or maybe I get confused when it's about pointing to my own body. I don't know. If I close my eyes and focus on sensations... then that's all there is. when I open my eyes, look at my hand so... well... there's more information.
And once you have done that then respond to this question again from YOUR DIRECT EXPERIENCE.

Is it clear to you that your body, the whole or in part, that we call "I" or "me" is nothing other than a concept, a thought, an idea, a label, a symbol in language, an image in mind that has no separate, independent existence in and of itself?
no, not clear!


If you do recognize the body is a concept, how would you best describe your experience of that which we label body in YOUR DIRECT EXPERIENCE?
but I don't.

the body is this thing that I move, that contains the 5 senses + mind.

sorry for the misunderstanding!

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Mon May 13, 2024 1:39 pm

sorry for the misunderstanding!
Hey Nicholas - no need to be sorry. Thank you for the clarification!!
So important.


OK Two things I'm seeing in particular here. You say...
(the "me" is a concept, not a feeling)
and
the body is this thing that I move, that contains the 5 senses + mind.
Thus the body seems real and NOT a concept

So to make sure I've got it let me play this back to you.

What I'm hearing you say is that
+ you see the "me" is a concept
+ for you the "body" still seems "real" and not a concept

Have i got what your saying correctly?



I don't want to make any assumptions before we move on.

But before I hit the submit button let's go to this...
I'm having trouble using all senses at the same time. or maybe I get confused when it's about pointing to my own body. I don't know. If I close my eyes and focus on sensations... then that's all there is. when I open my eyes, look at my hand so... well... there's more information.
I think I get what you are saying. Attempting to see what is going on with the senses ALL AT THE SAME TIME understandably leads to confusion. There is such an avalanche of input to apprehend. In the exercises we typically are asking you to look at each of the senses INDIVIDUALLY. Whilst this is artificial the aim is to zoom in on what is happening in perception PRIOR to the mind processing the sensory information - that is what we are calling DIRECT EXPERIENCE. And we do it by focusing on EACH SENSE as the exercise or part of the exercise calls for it.

From now on I will be more specific pointing to which sense to attend to in particular.

Does that make it clearer?



Just this for today.


With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Tue May 14, 2024 3:48 am

What I'm hearing you say is that
+ you see the "me" is a concept
+ for you the "body" still seems "real" and not a concept

Have i got what your saying correctly?
Yes. The me is a concept. The body… is another thing. More real… yes. Far from a concept from now.
Does that make it clearer?
Yes!

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Tue May 14, 2024 12:49 pm

That's good Nicholas

We'll attend to this matter of the 'body' concept.

To explore what 'body' is in direct experience we'll do a couple of things first and we will slow this exploring right down as we get into this.

First of all, we'll reiterate what actual experience is (AE) and what LOOKING is.

‘Looking’ is just plain looking at actual/direct experience (AE), which is simply colour (image), sound, smell, sensation, taste and the simple knowing of thought at face value that is appearing right now in the moment. But NOT being drawn into and believing the abstractness (concepts) found in the content of thought

You are being pointed to the raw experience of AE and noticing the labels and thoughts ABOUT the raw experience. The key to this exploration is the careful LOOKING. Why? Because it’s the act of actually LOOKING and discerning the difference between AE and the content of thought that brings clarity to experience.

The interpretation of actual experience happens SO quickly. So while inquiring, labelling and interpretation will always appear, but it is also possible to become aware of the thoughts that appear with, and overlay actual experience. Another key component of this exploration is being able to tell the difference between actual experience and the interpretation by thought of actual experience


The following exercise points to what I mean.

For this exercise you will need an apple or any other piece of fruit will do.

Image


The questions in this exercise are primarily to do with SEEING and THOUGHT. No need to invoke the other senses.


Have a look at an apple. When ‘looking at an apple’, there's colour; a thought saying ‘apple’; and maybe a thought saying, "I'm looking at an apple."
As you look what is known for sure?



Is it clear that Colour is known and thoughts are known.





As you look at an ‘apple’ what about the content of thoughts, tell me what thoughts you are having as you look?




The truth is whatever you thought ABOUT apple is NOT Actual Experience. Actual experience does not refer to thoughts ABOUT something…because that is only just more thought. Actual experience is sound, thought, colour, smell, taste, sensation.

Is there really an ‘apple’ here, or only colour and thoughts ABOUT ‘apple’?




Can ‘apple’ be found in actual experience?





While these thoughts are known, what they talk ABOUT can't be found in actual experience.

This is what is meant by ‘looking in actual experience ‘. What you know for sure, and, is always here.

The label ‘apple’ is known
Taste labelled ‘apple’ is known (when 'apple' is tasted)
Colour labelled ‘apple’ is known
Sensation labelled ‘apple’ is known (when ‘apple’ is touched)
Smell labelled ‘apple’ is known
Thought about/of an ‘apple’ is known
However, is an ‘apple’ actually known in actual experience?




With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Wed May 15, 2024 3:47 am

Looking a tomato
As you look what is known for sure?
it’s a tomato

Is it clear that Colour is known and thoughts are known.
I guess this was supposed to be a question. Then yes.


As you look at an ‘apple’ what about the content of thoughts, tell me what thoughts you are having as you look?
It’s a tomato. Red. Or… something like red. With green. It’s not complete. I can see it’s liquid.
The truth is whatever you thought ABOUT apple is NOT Actual Experience. Actual experience does not refer to thoughts ABOUT something…because that is only just more thought. Actual experience is sound, thought, colour, smell, taste, sensation.
oh… I got it. Thoughts about something are not direct experience. got it. When I see a tomato my mind will start doing its thing “it’s a tomato” etc. but… those are only thoughts. Not DE. DE is just the fact that I’m having thoughts.
Is there really an ‘apple’ here, or only colour and thoughts ABOUT ‘apple’?
exactly! No tomato here. Only color and related thoughts.

Can ‘apple’ be found in actual experience?
No!
However, is an ‘apple’ actually known in actual experience?
Nop.

Let’s see… if I take an apple and taste it. And it’s sweet. “sweet” is also a label, so there’s only taste.
If the apple is rough to the touch, or smooth… those are also labels.

So basically… it’s only sensations, flavors, smells… colors and sounds. And thoughts (but not content)
BUT… if I start describing those sensations then… they are not “pure” anymore. They are now labels. It seems that "pure" can't be described at all. confusing thing I admit.

I guess… I’m starting to see it a bit more.

uh, it's like there's nothing out there... only labels and more labels. strange thought.

Thanks for your patience and dedication. Let’s keep going!

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Wed May 15, 2024 12:26 pm

Thanks for your patience and dedication. Let’s keep going!
You bet! We're not going to stop now !!😊😊😊

oh… I got it. Thoughts about something are not direct experience. got it. When I see a tomato my mind will start doing its thing “it’s a tomato” etc. but… those are only thoughts. Not DE.
Indeed !

Let’s see… if I take an apple and taste it. And it’s sweet. “sweet” is also a label, so there’s only taste.
If the apple is rough to the touch, or smooth… those are also labels.

So basically… it’s only sensations, flavors, smells… colors and sounds. And thoughts (but not content)
BUT… if I start describing those sensations then… they are not “pure” anymore. They are now labels. It seems that "pure" can't be described at all. confusing thing I admit.
Very clear Nicholas

I guess… I’m starting to see it a bit more.
Be careful you don't start to discount this that you're realizing

uh, it's like there's nothing out there... only labels and more labels. strange thought.
Yes, that's it. The mind 'plasters' them over all of experience. This is the super fast phenomena of the mind that we don't realize is happening until we actually LOOK. In conventional living it SEEMS that all these labels are the truth and its that unconscious belief in thought/labels/concepts that is at the root of all suffering. It's not that there is anything wrong with labels. Language would not exist as we know it without labels. The 'problem' is that we give them a totally unwarranted substantiality that distorts experience.


Let’s break it down further so you get to experience the 'object', in this case, a tomato via direct/actual experience.

So grab the tomato again or any other piece of fruit or even a piece of cheese or chocolate will do….go get it and then place it in front of you on the table.

Now LOOK carefully.

1. The image (seeing) of the ‘tomato ’ is the actual experience of colour and NOT the AE of an tomato. The shape referred to as ‘tomato’ is just different shades and patterns of colour. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘tomato ’ and just focus on the colour.
Does the colour itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about an ‘tomato ’? Or is it just simply AE of colour?



Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that the colour appearing is that of an ‘tomato ’?





2. Now, pick up the ‘tomato ’ and close the eyes. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘tomato’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the sensation.
Does the sensation itself suggest in any way that it is an tomato, and that it knows anything about an ‘tomato’? Or is it just simply AE of sensation?



Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the sensation has anything to do with an ‘tomato’?





3. Now, take a bite of the ‘tomato’. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘tomato’ and just focus on the taste.
Does taste itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about an tomato? Or is there just simply AE of taste?



Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the taste of an ‘tomato’?




4. Now, have a smell of the ‘tomato’. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘tomato’ and just focus on the smell.
Does smell itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about an tomato? Or is there just simple AE of smell?



Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the smell of an ‘tomato’?





5. Now, listen to the sound of the ‘biting into a tomato’. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘tomato’ and just focus on the sound.
Does the sound itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about an tomato? Or is there just simple AE of sound?



Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the sound is that of an ‘tomato’?





6. So now look at the label ‘tomato and the thought “I am looking at, and eating an tomato”.
Does the label itself or the thought itself know anything about an ‘tomato’? Or are they just simply AE of label/thought?



The label ‘tomato’ is the AE of thought and not the AE of an tomato
The image labelled ‘tomato’ is AE of colour and not the AE of an tomato
The smell labelled ‘tomato’ is AE of smell and not the AE of an tomato
The taste labelled ‘tomato’ is AE of taste and not the AE of an tomato
The sound labelled ‘squishy tomato’ is AE of sound and not the AE of an tomato
The sensation labelled as ‘hard, round tomato’ is the AE of sensation and not the AE of an tomato

Thought overlays actual experience with concepts. An example being the AE of colour is being labelled as an 'tomato'.

So is there really actual experience of an ‘tomato’, or what is actually appearing, what the actual experience is, is colour, sensation, taste, smell, sound, which thought then labels and describes as an 'tomato'?



In other words, is an tomato actually known or only thoughts about an tomato are known?





With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Thu May 16, 2024 4:56 am

Ok, tomato again
The image (seeing) of the ‘tomato ’ is the actual experience of colour and NOT the AE of an tomato. The shape referred to as ‘tomato’ is just different shades and patterns of colour. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘tomato ’ and just focus on the colour.
Does the colour itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about an ‘tomato ’? Or is it just simply AE of colour?
just color!

Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that the colour appearing is that of an ‘tomato ’?
No way of knowing. Tomato is a label. It’s just color. My mind is doing a conceptualization of shapes and colors (red, half circle) but those are also labels.
There seems to be something “different” here (a tomato), but how can I know? It’s only senses and thoughts.

2. Now, pick up the ‘tomato ’ and close the eyes. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘tomato’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the sensation.
Does the sensation itself suggest in any way that it is an tomato, and that it knows anything about an ‘tomato’? Or is it just simply AE of sensation?
just sensation.

Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the sensation has anything to do with an ‘tomato’?
Impossible to know! The sensation is “cold” but that’s a label. Without labels there’s only sensation here.
The object has its distinct sensation but… how do I describe it? I have to use labels. I can only say it’s different… but isn’t that a label too?
Now, take a bite of the ‘tomato’. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘tomato’ and just focus on the taste.
Does taste itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about an tomato? Or is there just simply AE of taste?
just taste
Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the taste of an ‘tomato’?
I don’t know. How does a tomato taste? Labels and concepts. There’s just a particular taste here… but then I’m labeling.


4. Now, have a smell of the ‘tomato’. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘tomato’ and just focus on the smell.
Does smell itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about an tomato? Or is there just simple AE of smell?
only smell

Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the smell of an ‘tomato’?
can’t know!

5. Now, listen to the sound of the ‘biting into a tomato’. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘tomato’ and just focus on the sound.
Does the sound itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about an tomato? Or is there just simple AE of sound?
only sound

Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the sound is that of an ‘tomato’?
can’t know


6. So now look at the label ‘tomato and the thought “I am looking at, and eating an tomato”.
Does the label itself or the thought itself know anything about an ‘tomato’? Or are they just simply AE of label/thought?
(this one is trickier!)

Those are only thoughts!
So is there really actual experience of an ‘tomato’, or what is actually appearing, what the actual experience is, is colour, sensation, taste, smell, sound, which thought then labels and describes as an 'tomato'?
only senses and thoughts. Then labels of “tomato”
In other words, is an tomato actually known or only thoughts about an tomato are known?
Only thoughts!

I have to admit it is still tricky to see things this way though. I had to read my previous post again because it seems like I forget how to look!

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Thu May 16, 2024 12:46 pm

Really good LOOKING here in this exercise.

I have to admit it is still tricky to see things this way though. I had to read my previous post again because it seems like I forget how to look!
Totally understandable Nicholas. You're challenging a lifetime of habit!


We'll LOOK and FEEL again and again and at times it may feel like repetition (that will be the mind imposing if it does feel like repetition) but it's the staying with direct experience that brings real clarity.

Let's do something you are pretty familiar with. Typing on your keyboard

What is the AE of ‘typing’….break it down into AE and let me know what you find. (Go back to the tomato exercise if you struggle with this).
Close your eyes and feel your fingers on the key board. IGNORE all thoughts and mental images and just focus on actual experience (sound, sensation, smell, taste and colour).
Taking each of the senses one at a time tell me as much as you can about your actual experience of typing on the keyboard with your eyes closed?





Then open your eyes and focus on actual experience with eyes open as you type.
Again, taking each of the senses one at a time tell me me as much as you can about your actual experience of typing on the keyboard but with your eyes open?





Now tell me about this notion of a "me" in this experience? What is it found about the "me" in actual experience?





With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Fri May 17, 2024 1:38 am

What is the AE of ‘typing’….break it down into AE and let me know what you find. (Go back to the tomato exercise if you struggle with this).
Close your eyes and feel your fingers on the key board. IGNORE all thoughts and mental images and just focus on actual experience (sound, sensation, smell, taste and colour).
Taking each of the senses one at a time tell me as much as you can about your actual experience of typing on the keyboard with your eyes closed?
Sound = sound of keys being pressed. Some of them have a distinct sound
Sensation = feeling different shapes, sensations. Space between keys.
Smell = smelling the keyboard… smells like… well… can’t be described! It has its smell
Taste = not going to taste it! But I feel… combination of tastes of food I had before
Color = lots of color. Different shades…



Then open your eyes and focus on actual experience with eyes open as you type.
Again, taking each of the senses one at a time tell me me as much as you can about your actual experience of typing on the keyboard but with your eyes open?
it’s the same as before! Same things!!



Now tell me about this notion of a "me" in this experience? What is it found about the "me" in actual experience?
Well I can’t find it using 5 doors.
Looking at thoughts…

Ok this one is tricky again. I can’t answer without looking at content of thoughts! Hum.

What I get is “me is experiencing through the 6 doors”. “me is… doing. Things. Experiencing. Sensing”

Looks like a blind spot

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Fri May 17, 2024 1:57 pm

Let's dig in here Nicholas.I want you to really be discerning about direct experience here. SPEND TIME ON EACH POINT TO REALLY FEEL INTO IT


The instruction was to IGNORE all thoughts and mental images and just focus on actual experience (sound, sensation, smell, taste and colour).

When you were asked to do the first part of the exercise dthe instruction was to do it with eyes CLOSED.
You said....
Color = lots of color. Different shades…
How could that be your experience with eyes closed?




You also said .......
Taste = not going to taste it! But I feel… combination of tastes of food I had before
To reference tastes of food you had before were you not referencing memory (which is thought)?




Typing on keyboard II

Do the exercise again using the same investigation as we did for the tomato exercise

Now LOOK carefully. This first part is done with eyes CLOSED.

1. With eyes closed and hands on the keyboard what do you actually see?
Is there actually an image in mind of hands and keyboard as you LOOK?





If so, then you are referencing thought and not actually experience

Now, again turn attention to your hands ‘typing on a keyboard ’ and with eyes CLOSED, ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the colour.
With eyes closed do you see anything else other than the “black” of your eyelids? (or any other little flashes of light that might come with eyes closed)





2. Now, turn attention to your hands ‘typing on keyboard ’ and CLOSE the eyes. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the sensation.
Does the sensation itself suggest in any way typing on keyboard, and that it knows anything about ‘typing on a keyboard’? Or that the sensation knows anything about keys? Or is it just simply AE of sensation?





Again LOOK to see whether there are images of hands or fingers or keys or keyboard popping up that you are unconsciously referencing. This can be so subtle.
Do you catch this happening at all?




Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the sensation that has anything to do with ‘typing on a keyboard’?




3. Now, with eyes CLOSED notice the smell of the ‘keyboard’. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and just focus on the smell.
Does smell itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about ‘typing on a keyboard? Or is there just simple AE of smell?




Again LOOK to see whether there are images of hands or fingers or keys or keyboard popping up or perhaps just flash up momentarily that you are unconsciously referencing. Remember this can be so subtle.
Do you catch this happening at all?





Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the smell of a ‘keyboard’?






4. Now, listen to the sound of ‘typing on keyboard’ with eyes CLOSED. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and just focus on the sound.
Does the sound itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about typing on a keyboard? Or is there just simple AE of sound?




Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that the sound is that of ‘typing on a keyboard’?





5. So now look at the label ‘typing on keyboard" and the thought “I am typing on a keyboard”.
Does the label itself or the thought itself know anything about an ‘typing on a keyboard’? Or are they just simply AE of label/thought?





Thought overlays actual experience with concepts. An example being the AE of sound is being labelled as an 'typing on a keyboard'.

So is there really actual experience of an ‘typing on a keyboard’, or simply actual experience of what is actually appearing, what the actual experience is, is colour, sensation, smell, sound, which thought then labels and describes as an 'typing on a keyboard'?




In other words, is typing on a keyboard actually known or only thoughts about typing on a keyboard are known?






Now repeat the exercise this time with eyes OPEN.

1. With eyes open and typing on the keyboard what do you actually see?
Is there an image or a label in mind of a keyboard as you LOOK?




If so, then you are referencing thought and not actual experience

Now, again turn attention to your hands ‘typing on a keyboard ’ and with eyes OPEN, ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the colour.
Does the colour itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about ‘hands’ or ‘keyboard ’? Or is it just simply AE of colour?




Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that the colour appearing is that of ‘hands’ or ‘keyboard ’?





2. Now, turn attention to your hands ‘typing on keyboard ’ and with eyes open, ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on keyboard’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the sensation.
Does the sensation itself suggest in any way typing on keyboard, and that it knows anything about ‘typing on a keyboard’? Or that the sensation knows anything about keys? Or is it just simply AE of sensation?




Again LOOK to see whether, as well as experiencing sensation, there is unconscious referencing of the images or thoughts of hands or fingers or keys or keyboard.
Is this referencing happening in any way at all?




Is there difference in experience of sensation only between having your eyes OPEN and your eyes CLOSED?





Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the sensation has anything to do with ‘typing on a keyboard’?





3. Now, with eyes open notice the smell of the ‘keyboard’. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and just focus on the smell.
Does smell itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about ‘typing on a keyboard? Or is there just simple AE of smell?




Again LOOK to see whether there are labels / thoughts / images of hands or fingers or keys or keyboard popping up or perhaps just flash up momentarily that you are unconsciously referencing.
Is this happening in any way at all?




Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the smell of a ‘keyboard’?






4. Now, listen to the sound of ‘typing on keyboard’ with eyes open. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and just focus on the sound.
Does the sound itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about typing on a keyboard? Or is there just simple AE of sound?





Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that the sound is that of ‘typing on a keyboard’?





5. So now look at the label ‘typing on keyboard and the thought “I am looking at, and, typing on a keyboard”.
Does the label itself or the thought itself know anything about an ‘typing on keyboard’? Or are they just simply AE of label/thought?





The label ‘typing on a keyboard’ is the AE of thought and not the AE of typing on a keyboard
The image labelled ‘typing on a keyboard’ is AE of colour and not the AE of typing on a keyboard
The smell labelled ‘keyboard’ is AE of smell and not the AE of a keyboard
The sound labelled ‘typing on a keyboard’ is AE of sound and not the AE of typing on a keyboard
The sensation felt when hands are on the keyboard or typing is the AE of sensation and not the AE of typing on a keyboard


So is there really actual experience of an ‘typing on a keyboard’, or what is actually appearing, what the actual experience is, is colour, sensation, smell, sound, which thought then labels and describes as an 'typing on a keyboard'?



In other words, is typing on a keyboard actually known or only thoughts about typing on a keyboard are known?





If you were asked by a 7 year old out of the blue "What is direct experience?" how would you answer from your own experience?






With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Sat May 18, 2024 4:48 am

Hello Alan.

Ah... uh... yeah I might have a problem. it's something that tend to happens to me, something that I tend to do but I have no idea what it is, how to describe it, if it has a name, if it's a cognitive problem...

Sometimes I have trouble following instructions/orders. It happens all the time, never managed to avoid it because I don't even know what kind of issue is it exactly.

It happens when someone asks me to go buy something or at work. I cannot remember specific examples right now, but for example... if I see a gym routine on the internet, and the routine specifically says "DON'T CHANGE ANYTHING IN THIS ROUTINE" guess what... I still change some minor things

things like that.

And I mention this to you because I already did this... and maybe I did it a couple times without realizing.
when I saw your instructions something like this happened:

"ok, what is the AE of typing. it says close your eyes... ok. oh but then it says focus on actual experience (5 senses) and says to take each sense at the same time... well... then I'm going to do it with eyes open. oh but then it says with eyes closed? ok I'm confused... eeh... ok I'm just going to do it with eyes open, I mean... if I really focus on each sense then I'm sure it won't be any different"

I don't know why it happens. do you know if it has a name? maybe a disorder or something?

anyways, sorry for this!

now to the questions...
How could that be your experience with eyes closed?
because I did with my eyes opened.
You also said .......
Taste = not going to taste it! But I feel… combination of tastes of food I had before
To reference tastes of food you had before were you not referencing memory (which is thought)?
AH! it's harder than I thought.
1. With eyes closed and hands on the keyboard what do you actually see?
Is there actually an image in mind of hands and keyboard as you LOOK?
no, I see nothing or darkness
Now, again turn attention to your hands ‘typing on a keyboard ’ and with eyes CLOSED, ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the colour.
With eyes closed do you see anything else other than the “black” of your eyelids? (or any other little flashes of light that might come with eyes closed)
only black
2. Now, turn attention to your hands ‘typing on keyboard ’ and CLOSE the eyes. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the sensation.
Does the sensation itself suggest in any way typing on keyboard, and that it knows anything about ‘typing on a keyboard’? Or that the sensation knows anything about keys? Or is it just simply AE of sensation?
ok, this is where I get confused. how do I describe what I'm experiencing? I have to use labels, I have no other choice. otherwise would be simply... just sensation.

I get confused based on how the question is asked. what do you feel? sensation of hands typing.

but if you ask me "do you just simply feel DE of sensation"? then... yes

ok... I think I get it. ok, enough with the "conceptual discussion".
again
2. Now, turn attention to your hands ‘typing on keyboard ’ and CLOSE the eyes. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the sensation.
Does the sensation itself suggest in any way typing on keyboard, and that it knows anything about ‘typing on a keyboard’? Or that the sensation knows anything about keys? Or is it just simply AE of sensation?
just sensation
Again LOOK to see whether there are images of hands or fingers or keys or keyboard popping up that you are unconsciously referencing. This can be so subtle.
Do you catch this happening at all?
yes, yes it happens. hard to ignore. even after ignoring "keyboard" some other appear like "cold, soft"
Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the sensation that has anything to do with ‘typing on a keyboard’?
without thought or preconceptions... there's nothing. just the sensation.
3. Now, with eyes CLOSED notice the smell of the ‘keyboard’. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and just focus on the smell.
Does smell itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about ‘typing on a keyboard? Or is there just simple AE of smell?
just smell


Again LOOK to see whether there are images of hands or fingers or keys or keyboard popping up or perhaps just flash up momentarily that you are unconsciously referencing. Remember this can be so subtle.
Do you catch this happening at all?
the mind is trying to label the smell. comparing it with other things. analyzing it.



Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the smell of a ‘keyboard’?
without thoughts... every smell is always new, over and over again.
4. Now, listen to the sound of ‘typing on keyboard’ with eyes CLOSED. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and just focus on the sound.
Does the sound itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about typing on a keyboard? Or is there just simple AE of sound?
just sound


Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that the sound is that of ‘typing on a keyboard’?
without thought there are no labels, all sounds are just sounds. they have no... owner? (I don't know why I said that)


5. So now look at the label ‘typing on keyboard" and the thought “I am typing on a keyboard”.
Does the label itself or the thought itself know anything about an ‘typing on a keyboard’? Or are they just simply AE of label/thought?
they are just thoughts
So is there really actual experience of an ‘typing on a keyboard’, or simply actual experience of what is actually appearing, what the actual experience is, is colour, sensation, smell, sound, which thought then labels and describes as an 'typing on a keyboard'?
just a bunch of thoughts appearing and sensations and the super quick conceptualization of "typing on keyboard"

In other words, is typing on a keyboard actually known or only thoughts about typing on a keyboard are known?
only thoughts about typing on keyboard.
Now repeat the exercise this time with eyes OPEN.

1. With eyes open and typing on the keyboard what do you actually see?
Is there an image or a label in mind of a keyboard as you LOOK?
aah yes.


If so, then you are referencing thought and not actual experience

Now, again turn attention to your hands ‘typing on a keyboard ’ and with eyes OPEN, ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the colour.
Does the colour itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about ‘hands’ or ‘keyboard ’? Or is it just simply AE of colour?
oh... it's like a baby. a baby doesn't understand a damn thing what's going on. just simple DE of colour.


Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that the colour appearing is that of ‘hands’ or ‘keyboard ’?
no way of knowing


2. Now, turn attention to your hands ‘typing on keyboard ’ and with eyes open, ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on keyboard’ and of ‘hands’ and just focus on the sensation.
Does the sensation itself suggest in any way typing on keyboard, and that it knows anything about ‘typing on a keyboard’? Or that the sensation knows anything about keys? Or is it just simply AE of sensation?
hard to see. but just sensation.


Again LOOK to see whether, as well as experiencing sensation, there is unconscious referencing of the images or thoughts of hands or fingers or keys or keyboard.
Is this referencing happening in any way at all?
mmmhm.... it's more like distractions. like "I SEE KEYBOARD AND HANDS" and no "I TOUCH KEYBOARD WITH HANDS"


Is there difference in experience of sensation only between having your eyes OPEN and your eyes CLOSED?
it's the same, the difference is the number of distractions.



Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the sensation has anything to do with ‘typing on a keyboard’?
no way of knowing.


3. Now, with eyes open notice the smell of the ‘keyboard’. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and just focus on the smell.
Does smell itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about ‘typing on a keyboard? Or is there just simple AE of smell?
just smell


Again LOOK to see whether there are labels / thoughts / images of hands or fingers or keys or keyboard popping up or perhaps just flash up momentarily that you are unconsciously referencing.
Is this happening in any way at all?
same as before. instead of "keyboard smell" it looks for similar objects... like car. ugh.

Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that it is the smell of a ‘keyboard’?
not known



4. Now, listen to the sound of ‘typing on keyboard’ with eyes open. Ignore ALL thoughts and ‘mental’ images that appear of and about the ‘typing on a keyboard’ and just focus on the sound.
Does the sound itself suggest in any way that it knows anything about typing on a keyboard? Or is there just simple AE of sound?
just sound



Without thought, without any preconceived ideas, how is it known that the sound is that of ‘typing on a keyboard’?
no knowing


5. So now look at the label ‘typing on keyboard and the thought “I am looking at, and, typing on a keyboard”.
Does the label itself or the thought itself know anything about an ‘typing on keyboard’? Or are they just simply AE of label/thought?
they are just thoughts
So is there really actual experience of an ‘typing on a keyboard’, or what is actually appearing, what the actual experience is, is colour, sensation, smell, sound, which thought then labels and describes as an 'typing on a keyboard'?
no actual experience. there's no actual experience of anything then?

In other words, is typing on a keyboard actually known or only thoughts about typing on a keyboard are known?
only thoughts labeling



If you were asked by a 7 year old out of the blue "What is direct experience?" how would you answer from your own experience?
I don't know. I spent several minutes on this... but I have no idea. I don't know how to make it understandable to a small kid.

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Sat May 18, 2024 2:35 pm

Hi Nicholas
I don't know why it happens. do you know if it has a name? maybe a disorder or something?
anyways, sorry for this!
So good you are making me aware of this. Thank you.

I don't have a name for it. And you know what? We all have it in various forms - its just that it is more obvious for some than others.

The important thing is that you are noticing it. If you can catch it happening have a look at the thoughts that are OVERRIDING the instructions. Chances are they are such a deeply ingrained habit that they happen without you noticing.

You may well have been aware of this happening for a long time. It will be interesting as your LOOKING is being 'refined' whether these thoughts will become more apparent.

As we continue here do your best to slow things down a little. Give yourself just a bit more time to absorb the instructions. Perhaps read them a couple of times to make sure the key aspects are understood.

Also there can be a very strong belief of "I KNOW" here. It can permeate our thinking. Watch for this, or the feeling of this.
If that resonates then ask "What is it that thinks it knows?" and LOOK 'for this that thinks it knows'


AH! it's harder than I thought.
Ah Right here is an example of the "I KNOW" belief ! Before you realized "it's harder than I thought" there was likely an unrecognized belief running. Even something like ..."This is a piece of cake !" or "This seems so simplistic" or some form of this sort of belief. It might not appear in these sort of words but there will likely be thoughts/assumptions/belief along this line which will be your unique versions of "I KNOW" This is illusory thinking that has perhaps served you well in other situations. But now its being seen for what it is.
If you can right now LOOK for 'this I that thinks it knows.'
Can you find it?




Or is it just a thought that is believed to the extent that it believes it is running the show?





OK I won't comment on every response but will highlight these ...
yes, yes it happens. hard to ignore. even after ignoring "keyboard" some other appear like "cold, soft"
Very good looking. There is thought after thought

the mind is trying to label the smell. comparing it with other things. analyzing it.
Good pickup ! The mind is constantly labeling, comparing, analyzing all the time. No wonder we feel exhausted at times?!!!

without thoughts... every smell is always new, over and over again.
A new world is beckoning. Always fresh, always new.

they have no... owner? (I don't know why I said that)
The voice of intuition? Never to be ignored !

super quick conceptualization of "typing on keyboard"
So, so fast !

mmmhm.... it's more like distractions. like "I SEE KEYBOARD AND HANDS" and no "I TOUCH KEYBOARD WITH HANDS"
Ha yes. It one of the "I" thoughts primary impacts - distract, distract, distract

So is there really actual experience of an ‘typing on a keyboard’, or what is actually appearing, what the actual experience is, is colour, sensation, smell, sound, which thought then labels and describes as an 'typing on a keyboard'?
no actual experience. there's no actual experience of anything then?
There is no actual experience of 'typing on a keyboard' in and of itself. Typing on a keyboard is a concept. Any label is a concept. Concepts cannot be experienced by the senses directly. They are only thoughts about thoughts. Actual experience of what the concept points to can be experienced directly but not THROUGH or BY the thought. So coming back to your point with a slight( but critical adjustment of adding one word) it is true to say that "there's no actual experience of anything CONCEPTUAL then"

but I have no idea. I don't know how to make it understandable to a small kid.
Rather than explain one could simply get them to experience it directly with simple exercises and pointing.


You can see from these last exercises that there is thought after thought after thought appearing with direct experience. Without close investigation the default is to believe the thoughts and stories ABOUT the experience rather than directly experience what is happening.
Is that true for you now Nicholas?



Earlier in our exploration you have pointed to the narrator that always seems to be present for you saying what it says.

From these exercises it may be becoming clearer that while it seems that thought is controlling experience the truth is that it is more like a commentator commenting on what has already happened. We are going to take a closer look at this now.

As you reported in this last exercise
just a bunch of thoughts appearing and sensations and the super quick conceptualization of "typing on keyboard"
That is what is happening mostly with thought super quick conceptualizing, commenting, assuming and the like.

Here is one way of looking at this that we call "narrator" or another label could be "commentator"

Sports Exercise

Please note that you will have to check the link when using this exercise, to make sure it is still viable, as sometimes they are removed from Youtube.

The following links are short clips of football games. You may not be familiar with these particular sports so If you prefer another sport…please feel free to find one to do this exercise with.

The important thing here is to do your best in watching how thoughts behave.

Choose one of the following clips

Argentina v Netherlands
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ooZLYNQOqk4

Australia vs Brazil
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yy5pL-myDzw

AFL
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WPn3x7c9WFA


PLEASE TAKE EACH STEP SLOWLY AS YOU TURN THE SOUND ON AND OFF AS INSTRUCTED


1. Watch one minute with the sound turned OFF, watching ‘people’ chasing a leather thing on a field, up and down, up and down. Let it sink in, the whole experience.

2. Once the first minute is completed, now watch another whole minute with the commentary turned ON.

Notice the differences. Are there any differences between 1 and 2 which are immediately obvious?




Notice how the commentator (thought) offers lots of know-how, even advice. It seems to feel as though they know exactly what is being experienced out on the field. It even feels that they could influence, somehow, what is going on, as though one outcome is much preferred to the opposite outcome. The commentary may seem to heighten any supporter feelings which are there, and call for an identification with one team or other, and with the importance of the game itself. Also notice how the commentator peppers the commentary with personal interpretations.

3. Now turn the volume OFF AGAIN and just watch the action with NO audible commentary, the shapes moving around on the screen etc. Again notice all the differences in what is appearing as experience.

4. Now turn the volume ON again and ignore what you think you know thought is talking about, and just notice it as sound.

Is the commentary on the football game a necessity for the play to happen?




Does what the commentator says affect the game in any way?




Does the commentator accurately describe EVERYTHING that is actually happening?




Is the commentary totally in synch with what is actually happening as it happens or is it actually lagging? (its ABOUT something in the PAST, something not happening right NOW )




What effect does the commentary have – is it helpful in any way, is it relaxing, is it difficult to keep up with, is it a distraction from what is actually happening?




And in the same way, is the inner narration of thought a necessity for the play of life to happen?




Is there anything insight about the internal narrator after doing doing this exercise?





With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Sun May 19, 2024 3:45 am

If you can right now LOOK for 'this I that thinks it knows.'
Can you find it?
Actually I didn't think "this is a piece of cake" or "simplistic". I thought "ok, maybe I got this part" but with a lot of hesitation like walking on shambles.

regarding the question... this "I" appears to be on thoughts. on content. still not a strong realization though, I'm not even sure what I'm looking at yet. just a new step.
Or is it just a thought that is believed to the extent that it believes it is running the show?
something like that
Rather than explain (to a kid) one could simply get them to experience it directly with simple exercises and pointing.
yes, I thought about exercises but don't manage to complete it. like I got several ideas for exercises but... they are just ideas.

example: "here kid, take this lemon candy and savor it. now describe to me its taste but without using words, or signs, or anything"

kid: "but that's impossible"

"well! that's direct experience. can't be described."

(see? it makes no sense, I got a couple of those)
Is that true for you now Nicholas?
well, I'm trying to untangle that.
PLEASE TAKE EACH STEP SLOWLY AS YOU TURN THE SOUND ON AND OFF AS INSTRUCTED
I chose argentina vs netherlands penalty but the argentinian version (because I'm from Argentina) hope that's not a problem! It's the same video, but with argentinian commentator.
1. Watch one minute with the sound turned OFF, watching ‘people’ chasing a leather thing on a field, up and down, up and down. Let it sink in, the whole experience.

2. Once the first minute is completed, now watch another whole minute with the commentary turned ON.

Notice the differences. Are there any differences between 1 and 2 which are immediately obvious?
with sound feels more "alive"

Notice how the commentator (thought) offers lots of know-how, even advice. It seems to feel as though they know exactly what is being experienced out on the field. It even feels that they could influence, somehow, what is going on, as though one outcome is much preferred to the opposite outcome. The commentary may seem to heighten any supporter feelings which are there, and call for an identification with one team or other, and with the importance of the game itself. Also notice how the commentator peppers the commentary with personal interpretations.

3. Now turn the volume OFF AGAIN and just watch the action with NO audible commentary, the shapes moving around on the screen etc. Again notice all the differences in what is appearing as experience.

4. Now turn the volume ON again and ignore what you think you know thought is talking about, and just notice it as sound.

Is the commentary on the football game a necessity for the play to happen?
nop


Does what the commentator says affect the game in any way?
it doesn't


Does the commentator accurately describe EVERYTHING that is actually happening?
it can't


Is the commentary totally in synch with what is actually happening as it happens or is it actually lagging? (its ABOUT something in the PAST, something not happening right NOW )
it lags some!


What effect does the commentary have – is it helpful in any way, is it relaxing, is it difficult to keep up with, is it a distraction from what is actually happening?
it's... emotional, energizing, uplifting. not strictly necessary but it's part of the experience, specially with world cups.


And in the same way, is the inner narration of thought a necessity for the play of life to happen?
not necessary. comes with the "game". life happens anyway regardless of narration.

Is there anything insight about the internal narrator after doing doing this exercise?
some... small insight. yes. life is a play and the narrator is like the commentator. how do I go deeper with this insight?

like... narration is not even necessary but it happens anyway. but it's not something I can just shut off, of course.


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: poppyseed and 14 guests