A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Tue Oct 16, 2012 11:04 am

Hi Neeel,

OK - so here we get the difference between "SEEING/LOOKING" and thinking. Seeing and Looking seems in these forums to have something to do with something else called "direct experience". Perhaps we are best off defining what this is actually?

My stab at it is - I experience a physical body sensation which I deduce is caused by air moving which I deduce is caused by the fan being switched on etc etc. Is direct looking just removing all of these deductions and cause/effect relationships and just describing what is happening. So - in this case . There is a fan, there is a sensation of movement, their is a physical sensation, their is a sound. IS that direct experience - LOOKING ?

If that is correct and i apply it to your question:
. Do you SEE that the "I" doesnt exist outside of a thought?
- OK so in order to look I need to simply describe experience with as little description as possible and as little cause and effect as possible. Right so this kind of brings me back to where i was..

There is a body/mind
There are thoughts and thinking
There are thoughts about I

There is no actual I - only the thoughts about I.

So YES - I see that I does not exist outside a thought. but do I SEE and have I LOOKED? I do not know..

OK - I will try with your other questions..
Are you in charge of thinking your thoughts ? Do you choose what thoughts to think? Can you predict your next thought?
I can only answer NO to your questions because I cannot prove that I am in charge, that I am the chooser etc etc - but I guess maybe I must think that I am otherwise this would not be so difficult. Again - how do I LOOK and not think?
Are you in charge of walking? Do you control the body, move each muscle at the right time in the correct order?
The body does everything on its own - although a thought about a movement can arise prior to the movement occurring.
Are you in charge of breathing? Do you make breathing happen, process the oxygen, move it around the body?
No - this all happens automatically - although a thought to decide to breather deeper or more frequently or slower can occur prior to the action of breathing.
Are you in charge of digestion?
NO
Are you in charge of hearing?
NO - but having said that - thoughts occur to focus hearing and then hearing becomes focused.
What are you in charge of?
Well there appears to be a certain amount of thoughts that dictate my actions in the world. Do those thoughts just happen and my path in the world has just happened despite my thoughts about I? I have chosen to live in another country recently. Did I in fact not choose and it is just what happened? This just seems like it could not be so..

Thanks,


Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Tue Oct 16, 2012 12:38 pm

My stab at it is - I experience a physical body sensation which I deduce is caused by air moving which I deduce is caused by the fan being switched on etc etc. Is direct looking just removing all of these deductions and cause/effect relationships and just describing what is happening.


not a bad stab. In what form are the deductions made known to you ? In what form are the cause/effect relationships made known to you?

So - in this case . There is a fan, there is a sensation of movement, their is a physical sensation, their is a sound. IS that direct experience - LOOKING ?
Is there a fan, or is there just perception of shapes and colours? In what form is the label "fan" made known?

Is there a sensation of movement, or is there just sensations? In what form is the label "movement" made known?





I can only answer NO to your questions because I cannot prove that I am in charge, that I am the chooser etc etc - but I guess maybe I must think that I am otherwise this would not be so difficult. Again - how do I LOOK and not think?

You would observe thoughts as they come up, and see if theres an "I" thats doing them.

You would look and see if you have a selection of thoughts to choose from, or if the thought is already there.Observe the process closely. What happens when you try to choose the next thought?

You would look and see if you can predict your next thought. Observe the process closely. What happens when you try to predict the next thought?

Another one, try and think a random thought. Observe closely, what happens when you try to think a random thought?


The body does everything on its own - although a thought about a movement can arise prior to the movement occurring.
Yes, good noticing. Does the thought make the body move. Can a thought DO anything?

another exercise. Raise your right arm. How did that happen? Observe the process closely, noticing thoughts and sensations.


Well there appears to be a certain amount of thoughts that dictate my actions in the world. Do those thoughts just happen and my path in the world has just happened despite my thoughts about I?


Look for yourself. Do these thoughts just happen? Are you thinking these thoughts, or is there just a thought, followed by another thought saying "I just thought that thought"?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Tue Oct 16, 2012 3:41 pm

Hi Neeel,

Thanks for your reply.
In what form are the deductions made known to you ?
as thoughts..
Is there a fan, or is there just perception of shapes and colours? In what form is the label "fan" made known?
There is simply perception of shapes and colors. "Fan" is a labeling done by thought.
Is there a sensation of movement, or is there just sensations? In what form is the label "movement" made known?


There are sensations and movement is made known by sensations and sight and then a thought about it.

OR similar to a previous post - at the base level - there are happenings and their are thoughts Even sensations is a label !
You would observe thoughts as they come up, and see if theres an "I" thats doing them.
Ok - I have observed and what happens is that thoughts arise about observing thoughts, thoughts arise about the I, thoughts arise about other random stuff. It does not appear that an "I" is doing the thinking.. There is now a thought that says that there does appear to be a relationship between these particular thoughts and a particular body/mind. That they are in some sense momentarily unique to a specific body/mind, This does not mean that there is an "I" it simply means that there are thoughts which is already established.
You would look and see if you have a selection of thoughts to choose from, or if the thought is already there.Observe the process closely. What happens when you try to choose the next thought?
I can only have a selection of thoughts to choose from if I create that selection of thoughts first and then choose and so the answer is NO - I cannot select from my thoughts they simply arise . If I try to choose my next thought - I find myself saying something aloud in my mind - Like - Now I am thinking about an Orange, now a banana. now an apple. My mind automatically picked something with relationships to each other - but the actual thought of the specific word of the fruit arrived before the image.
You would look and see if you can predict your next thought. Observe the process closely. What happens when you try to predict the next thought?
Again the only way that I can predict my next thought is within a kind of game where let's say I have a passion about something and if someone brings up one thing then I could predict that it would cause a particular thought in my mind. Or maybe that even works with opposites.. IF I say Tall- maybe I can predict that my next thought is Short to a reasonable degree of accuracy. If I just try to predict my next thought now - that is not possible. MY mind just goes blank and thinks about predicting the next thought. I guess I could predict that whatever word I read on a page or environmental stimuli that is about may relate to my next thoughts.
Another one, try and think a random thought. Observe closely, what happens when you try to think a random thought?
Again blankness and just thinking about coming up with a random thought and then a thought just arrises.
Does the thought make the body move. Can a thought DO anything?


NO there is not a required relationship between the thought and the movement although a thought tells me that there may be one. Thoughts cannot DO ( as in Actions) things themselves maybe they can influence doing ...
Raise your right arm. How did that happen? Observe the process closely, noticing thoughts and sensations.


Ok - raise arm, thought about raising arm, physical sensation of arm raising, feeling of tshirt pulling on skin,- basically no real thought - arm just moves after i read the instruction move arm
Look for yourself. Do these thoughts just happen? Are you thinking these thoughts, or is there just a thought, followed by another thought saying "I just thought that thought"?
yeah - thoughts about thoughts ad-infinitum... thoughts and happenings and no relationship except in thought.

Thanks.

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Tue Oct 16, 2012 4:35 pm

as thoughts..


There is simply perception of shapes and colors. "Fan" is a labeling done by thought.


There are sensations and movement is made known by sensations and sight and then a thought about it.
Ok, so there are sensations and perceptions, and then there are thoughts about the sensations and perceptions. Which is reality? The sensations and perceptions, or the thoughts about them?

In direct experience, is there an "I" doing anything?

OR similar to a previous post - at the base level - there are happenings and their are thoughts Even sensations is a label !
yes, stuff happens, and then thought automatically attempts to process and make sense of it.

Ok - I have observed <--snip--->
Good looking. Do you see the difference? You actually looked at how the thoughts arise, and noticed a lot of things that maybe you didnt realise, or that you believed were different. I would say, keep looking, over the next few days, every time you remember, observe thoughts, observe sensations, observe actions, in yourself, and in others. Observe what stimuli triggers the thoughts you just had. Observe what thoughts trigger which feelings. Observe how a coherent story is built up in thoughts. For example, someone steps in front of you as you are walking down the street. there is the direct experience, shapes, colours and sounds. Thoughts come up , maybe ( if you are anything like me) of "What an asshole". Feelings of anger arise. From direct experience, to story of " that guy just stepped right in front of me!" And, none of it is being done by anyone, its all just stimuli and response. Im not saying to try and get rid of any of it, or to try and stop being angry. Just notice how things really work, as opposed to how you assumed they worked.

Keep LOOKING, and deepen the seeing.

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Thu Oct 18, 2012 1:17 pm

Hi Neeel,
Which is reality? The sensations and perceptions, or the thoughts about them?
The sensations and perceptions..
In direct experience, is there an "I" doing anything?
No. In direct perception there are simply thoughts about the I doing something.
Do you see the difference?


I am not sure if I see the difference - nothing came up for me that I did not already feel aware of.. I do see that everything is stimuli and response . human beings live like that - React React React .. I would say -everything is stimuli and response until it isn't though.. In other words as soon as the stimuli /response is noted it is no longer stimuli/response or it is but it is noticed stimuli/response which subtly alters it. That causes the possibility for not just react react react..

I have a feeling we are gonna go in circles.. again..

There is no I that can be pinned down when looking either intellectually or with direct looking. These is a sense of I for sure. It is a concept and it is not real. What is it like to drop the veil, the illusion of I ? Is it as if the world is looking at itself? What is it like to look without the I concept? Looking without any ownership . IS it even possible to drop the I alltogether? Really possible?

Thanks for your help.


Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Thu Oct 18, 2012 1:47 pm

Do you see the difference?


I am not sure if I see the difference -
I meant , do you see the difference in looking rather than thinking about?


I do see that everything is stimuli and response . human beings live like that - React React React .. I would say -everything is stimuli and response until it isn't though.. In other words as soon as the stimuli /response is noted it is no longer stimuli/response or it is but it is noticed stimuli/response which subtly alters it. That causes the possibility for not just react react react..
Is the noticed stimuli/response not also another stimuli?

I have a feeling we are gonna go in circles.. again..
Probably, yes :D
There is no I that can be pinned down when looking either intellectually or with direct looking. These is a sense of I for sure. It is a concept and it is not real. What is it like to drop the veil, the illusion of I ? Is it as if the world is looking at itself? What is it like to look without the I concept? Looking without any ownership . IS it even possible to drop the I alltogether? Really possible?
Who would drop the I? I have never asked you to drop the "I", just to see that its an illusion.

There may be moments when the sense of self recedes. But people who havent seen through the illusion also experience this( eg when playing sports, or deeply involved in some activity etc), so its not like some special thing that only "enlightened" people get. Is that what is stopping you from fully grasping that you have seen this? That you are expecting bells, whistles, explosions and angelic choirs ?

So where are you with this? Is it crystal clear to you that no I exists? Are there any doubts? It seems to me that there are.

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Fri Oct 19, 2012 12:20 pm

Hi Neeeel,
I meant , do you see the difference in looking rather than thinking about?
Yeah I got that and I sort of see the difference - but it seems a little contrived to me.. In other words if I take out all language and interpretation and story and external referencing - in other words all "thinking" - what exists in the absence of thinking about it? Who knows because as humans we always think? I have an experience when I ski sometimes - it is a feeling of no thought - the speed and exhilaration of heading down the mountain. White snow everywhere - very little challenge to the senses - the mind has nothing to interpret, the cold taking your breathe away. In that i get what I call the 1000 yard stare. There is no room or hardly any room for thought - just experiencing..But the experiencing is still something experienced by something unique. It was experienced by this body/mind with an I concept and not that body/mind with I concept. Is the I still a concept - Yes... How can a concept have a different experiential reality to another concept - well you got me there... but that points to something more than a concept surely... Can I ever know the answer to that - well NO... but you and LU tell me that you can know - that when looked at in reality - with direct looking it can be seen without a shadow of a doubt that there is no I.. I can see that it is not possible for me to discern an I that does not appear more than conceptually - but I cannot see that without a shadow of a doubt that there is no I or better - I cannot see that there is no separate experiencing that relates to a specific body mind with I concept.
Is the noticed stimuli/response not also another stimuli?
Well yes it is.. but it allows a modification of the response.. Stimuli/response implies mechanical reaction , it implies that recognition of the process has no influence.. But when response is modified because of a recognition of the mechanical response then is is still a mechanical response? This does not seem so clear cut to me..
Who would drop the I? I have never asked you to drop the "I", just to see that its an illusion.
So where are you with this? Is it crystal clear to you that no I exists? Are there any doubts?
Ok I think I covered some of this above.. if i was totally clear that there was no I and above and beyond that and perhaps more importantly that there is only experiencing with no ownership what-so-ever.. then that is like WOW - There is a difference between something being TRUE and something being useful - or acting as if it was TRUE is useful.. So with the idea of NO I - acting as if it is true is pretty useful but It actually being TRUE.. OK let's get absolutely clear again here. It is absolutely true that the self (or I) as we think of it is only the self as we think about it.. In other words a concept made up of thoughts.. ( it could never be anything else to us !! but that simply means than any REAL self may be simply unknowable by us) BUT reven ecognizing the truth of that in no way points to the idea that there is only experience -
There is unique experience being experienced by something..- i.e - the body/mind/self concept is in fact a something - a unique something. It is not a nothing..

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Fri Oct 19, 2012 2:11 pm

Yeah I got that and I sort of see the difference - but it seems a little contrived to me.. In other words if I take out all language and interpretation and story and external referencing - in other words all "thinking" - what exists in the absence of thinking about it? Who knows because as humans we always think? I have an experience when I ski sometimes - it is a feeling of no thought - the speed and exhilaration of heading down the mountain. White snow everywhere - very little challenge to the senses - the mind has nothing to interpret, the cold taking your breathe away. In that i get what I call the 1000 yard stare. There is no room or hardly any room for thought - just experiencing..But the experiencing is still something experienced by something unique. It was experienced by this body/mind with an I concept and not that body/mind with I concept. Is the I still a concept - Yes... How can a concept have a different experiential reality to another concept - well you got me there... but that points to something more than a concept surely... Can I ever know the answer to that - well NO... but you and LU tell me that you can know - that when looked at in reality - with direct looking it can be seen without a shadow of a doubt that there is no I.. I can see that it is not possible for me to discern an I that does not appear more than conceptually - but I cannot see that without a shadow of a doubt that there is no I or better - I cannot see that there is no separate experiencing that relates to a specific body mind with I concept.
thanks for the honest response. I think I see your sticking point.
How can a concept have a different experiential reality to another concept


Can a concept do anything, or have a different experiential reality? If "I" is a concept, and not real, then is there an actual "I" there doing or experiencing anything?


But the experiencing is still something experienced by something unique.
Is the body experiencing? Are these experiences happening "to" a body?

Get a cup and a spoon. Sit down and close your eyes. Now hit the cup with the spoon. Is there a body and a sound? In direct experience, is there an experiencer AND an experience? Notice how thoughts come in and try to claim that you are hearing. There may be mental images of a body sitting and hearing the sound.

In direct experience, Is there a body, or is there just a perception of shapes and colours? In what form is the label "body" made known?

Well yes it is.. but it allows a modification of the response.. Stimuli/response implies mechanical reaction , it implies that recognition of the process has no influence.. But when response is modified because of a recognition of the mechanical response then is is still a mechanical response? This does not seem so clear cut to me..
Who or what modifies the response? In what way is the modified response not also a mechanical (automatic) reaction?

if i was totally clear that there was no I and above and beyond that and perhaps more importantly that there is only experiencing with no ownership what-so-ever..
Who or what would be the owner of the experience? How can a body be the owner? Does a computer own its keyboard? Does a rock own the moss that is growing on it?

What is ownership? what makes a cup "my cup" rather than " a cup"?

We often say "my body". What is the my that owns the body? If, as you say, the "my" is just a concept, then what is left that can own anything



There is unique experience being experienced by something..- i.e - the body/mind/self concept is in fact a something - a unique something. It is not a nothing..
Is the body/mind/self concept a "something"? a something separate from everything else? Look at a patch of skin, zoom in , closer and closer, until we are just seeing molecules, then atoms. Where is the boundary between your skin and the air?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Sat Oct 20, 2012 2:04 pm

Hi Neeel,
I think I see your sticking point.
Yeah - I read back through this whole thread and it seems to me that one of the key sticking points at least is the idea that you guys seems to have which is that their is no separation of experience/experiencing. It seems to me that regardless of the recognition of 'NO I" there is still a separation of experience in that 'a unique body/ mind with thoughts' experiences differently to another 'unique body/mind with thoughts'.
Can a concept do anything, or have a different experiential reality? If "I" is a concept, and not real, then is there an actual "I" there doing or experiencing anything?
N0 and No.. But I am not debating that. A concept cannot do anything or experience anything but "some-thing" as "opposed" to no-thing is experiencing. That some-thing is the' unique body/mind with thoughts'. That is a some-thing.
Is the body experiencing? Are these experiences happening "to" a body?
No... Experiences are happening but they are recognized /noticed by a ' unique body/mind with thoughts' In

Get a cup and a spoon. Sit down and close your eyes. Now hit the cup with the spoon. Is there a body and a sound? In direct experience, is there an experiencer AND an experience? Notice how thoughts come in and try to claim that you are hearing. There may be mental images of a body sitting and hearing the sound.

In direct experience their is a sound (stuff happening) and physical sensations (stuff happening) and thoughts about the sound and the physical sensations (stuff happening) It certainly feels like there is an experiencer and an experience because otherwise who/what could be describing it in this email if it was not experienced by something.. ? I notice that thoughts claim the hearing of the sound and claim the existence of a body through mental images. Sensation of hand on spoon and sensation of vibration also claim body.
In direct experience, Is there a body, or is there just a perception of shapes and colours? In what form is the label "body" made known?
In direct experience there is stuff(some- thing) that is acknowledged by the senses - information from those senses transmits to the brain. So answering your question - from the vision sense it is simply a perception that 'something is there' - with some thought labels added it is a perception of shape , colours and form - with further thought labels added it is shape , colours and form that differs form other shape colours and forms, - with further thought labels added it is a body etc etc etc.... In terms of the body - the fact that we call it a body is simply a label to distinguish it from other stuff and that is a label provided by thinking..
Who or what modifies the response? In what way is the modified response not also a mechanical (automatic) reaction?
Thinking itself modifies the response.. So just a walk-through of this as much for my clarity as anything else..

Part One
You decide to pinch my arm (stimulus) I cry out in pain with a noise something like... " Arghhhh" (automatic response)

I think - next time you pinch my arm I will have a different response which I choose in advance to be that I will pretend to like it.

Part Two
You pinch my arm again (stimulus) I say " That felt so good - could you do it again?" ( planned response)


Now - as to the question as to whether or not this "planned response" in Part 2 is just as mechanical or automatic a response.. Well.... I seems obvious that this is a different kind of response..
Who or what would be the owner of the experience? How can a body be the owner? Does a computer own its keyboard? Does a rock own the moss that is growing on it?
Not the owner of experience but the recognizer, the noticer, that which is aware of stuff happening. I am not sure I follow these analogies ......
What is ownership? what makes a cup "my cup" rather than " a cup"?
'A body /mind that thinks' makes a cup of tea and it is different to 'another body/mind that thinks' that is not making a cup of tea.
We often say "my body". What is the my that owns the body? If, as you say, the "my" is just a concept, then what is left that can own anything
This simply refers to the fact that there appears to be a relationship between a particular body, particular thoughts and particular actions and it is simpler to refer to "my/mine" -
Is the body/mind/self concept a "something"? a something separate from everything else? Look at a patch of skin, zoom in , closer and closer, until we are just seeing molecules, then atoms. Where is the boundary between your skin and the air?
OK - so this is the nub of it.. I know from science and other knowledge that it is not separate at all but it appears separate to the thoughts and the senses - Direct experience tells me that it is separate. The body/mind /self concept is a something in the same way that 'a tree' is something.. It is something and not nothing and furthermore even if at the core of it scientifically speaking - the tree and the body/mind/self concepts are made of the same stuff that does not mean that they are the same..

I am not sure if this pointing is helping - because of the point that I am stuck at.. What do you suggest?

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Sat Oct 20, 2012 2:53 pm

I am not sure if this pointing is helping - because of the point that I am stuck at.. What do you suggest?
Its not helping because you are still lost in thought, rather than looking.

In direct experience their is a sound (stuff happening) and physical sensations (stuff happening) and thoughts about the sound and the physical sensations (stuff happening) It certainly feels like there is an experiencer and an experience because otherwise who/what could be describing it in this email if it was not experienced by something.. ? I notice that thoughts claim the hearing of the sound and claim the existence of a body through mental images. Sensation of hand on spoon and sensation of vibration also claim body.
Like here, for example. "it feels like there is an experiencer and an experience because otherwise who/what could be describing it in this email". All of that is thoughts about , and occurs after the actual experience.

It doesnt matter what it feels like. Is it true that there is an experiencer and an experience? Look at the "feels like". Give me a description of where in the body the sensation is, what it consists of .
Sensation of hand on spoon and sensation of vibration also claim body
.

Do these sensations claim anything? Or do thoughts claim this about the sensations?
Is the body experiencing? Are these experiences happening "to" a body?
No... Experiences are happening but they are recognized /noticed by a ' unique body/mind with thoughts' In
Does this recognition happen at the time of the experiencing? Or does it happen afterwards, when thoughts come up about the experience? Ie is there direct experience of a body/mind experiencing? Or does that come in afterwards in thoughts about the experience

Do the exercise again. Look closer at what is happening. In direct experience. Can you find an experiencer AND an experience? Observe how thoughts come in claiming that there must be some entity there that is experiencing the experience.

Thinking itself modifies the response.. So just a walk-through of this as much for my clarity as anything else..

Part One
You decide to pinch my arm (stimulus) I cry out in pain with a noise something like... " Arghhhh" (automatic response)

I think - next time you pinch my arm I will have a different response which I choose in advance to be that I will pretend to like it.

Part Two
You pinch my arm again (stimulus) I say " That felt so good - could you do it again?" ( planned response)


Now - as to the question as to whether or not this "planned response" in Part 2 is just as mechanical or automatic a response.. Well.... I seems obvious that this is a different kind of response..
In what way is it a different kind of response? There is an experience, then thoughts about the experience, then a thought about what to do in the future, then another experience, then some more thoughts. Are you doing any of the thoughts?

What is ownership? what makes a cup "my cup" rather than " a cup"?
'A body /mind that thinks' makes a cup of tea and it is different to 'another body/mind that thinks' that is not making a cup of tea.
This isnt answering my question.

What makes a cup "My cup"? What gives me ownership of the cup? How do I own the cup? Is there a change to the cup that suddenly makes it my cup? Can a body/mind own a cup?
We often say "my body". What is the my that owns the body? If, as you say, the "my" is just a concept, then what is left that can own anything
This simply refers to the fact that there appears to be a relationship between a particular body, particular thoughts and particular actions and it is simpler to refer to "my/mine" -
Im going to call bullshit here. If this was true we would say "this body". Who or what is the owner of "my body"?


OK - so this is the nub of it.. I know from science and other knowledge that it is not separate at all but it appears separate to the thoughts and the senses - Direct experience tells me that it is separate.
Does direct experience tell you its separate, or does thought tell you it separate. Does direct experience "tell" you anything? When you look at an apple does the looking tell you "its an apple" , or is there perception, followed by thoughts of "red" "apple"? you need to really look closely at this.

In what way does it "appear separate to the senses"?


The body/mind /self concept is a something in the same way that 'a tree' is something.. It is something and not nothing and furthermore even if at the core of it scientifically speaking - the tree and the body/mind/self concepts are made of the same stuff that does not mean that they are the same..
I understand where you are coming from, and I can feel myself wanting to answer your questions, but I dont think that would help. You are lost in a world of concepts and ideas, and me using more concepts and ideas to try and help you see will probably just confuse you more.

Is the above paragraph any more than thoughts? Are you doing the thoughts?

Is the body/mind an "I", a self?

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Wed Oct 24, 2012 5:13 pm

Hey, whats happening, havent heard from you for a few days. Are you still looking into this?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Thu Oct 25, 2012 11:49 am

Hi Neeel,

Sorry for the delayed response.
Like here, for example. "it feels like there is an experiencer and an experience because otherwise who/what could be describing it in this email". All of that is thoughts about , and occurs after the actual experience.
Ok - that is true - I can only state that after the experience and it is thoughts about...
Is it true that there is an experiencer and an experience? Look at the "feels like". Give me a description of where in the body the sensation is, what it consists of .
The answer is -" I don't know". I can say for sure is that there is the experience, thoughts about the experience and thoughts about an experiencer of the experience.. Ok - so "feels like" is itself a thought... There is no bodily sensation of the experiencer or the "feeling" of being the experiencer. I can only conclude (although I find myself resistant to concluding) that there is no conclusive evidence for an experiencer. When I try to think of all of this I do find a kind of mental block sensation - even an actual physical pressure in the head... and thoughts like - "it can't be so", "it is not logical" and somthing wants to tell me that there is evidence everywhere for an experiencer - but in reality there is only evidence for thoughts about an experiencer.. I am not sure what if anything this all means..
Sensation of hand on spoon and sensation of vibration also claim body
Do these sensations claim anything? Or do thoughts claim this about the sensations?
Ok - thoughts about actually occurring physical sensations claim that these are related to a body that is related to them.
No... Experiences are happening but they are recognized /noticed by a ' unique body/mind with thoughts'

Does this recognition happen at the time of the experiencing? Or does it happen afterwards, when thoughts come up about the experience? Ie is there direct experience of a body/mind experiencing? Or does that come in afterwards in thoughts about the experience


I am not sure - maybe it is simultaneous with experience but perhaps a mili-second behind. Certainly thoughts about experience are always behind it.. Perhaps there is an indescribable body/mind direct experiencing and then a describable one which is no longer direct experiencing.. I feel that the "answer" is "NO" there is only ever thoughts about experience happening after and this is supposed to point at the fact that there is "NO I" and only experience..

Ok - so LOOKING and not THINKING>>>>>
Do the exercise again. Look closer at what is happening. In direct experience. Can you find an experiencer AND an experience? Observe how thoughts come in claiming that there must be some entity there that is experiencing the experience.
Ok I did again - their is the occurrence of sounds, sensations, thoughts (stuff happening) . There is a body mind. There is the thought that says that their must be some entity experiencing the experience.
In what way is it a different kind of response? There is an experience, then thoughts about the experience, then a thought about what to do in the future, then another experience, then some more thoughts. Are you doing any of the thoughts?
I can see what you are getting it.. It is always only thoughts about thoughts ad infinitum and then their is the thought that it seems as if one set of thoughts has an impact on the next set of thoughts that occur int he future and then there is the thought that this is true or not true etc etc etc.. The thoughts are doing themselves but they they seems to be self reflective and so one set of thoughts appear to be able to influence another set of thoughts..and there is a thought that this can be directly experienced.. This is where it is paradoxical - because of course thoughts cannot do anything by themselves.. I am left confused by this
What makes a cup "My cup"? What gives me ownership of the cup? How do I own the cup? Is there a change to the cup that suddenly makes it my cup? Can a body/mind own a cup?


Ownership is a concept. Nothing about the cup needs to change or makes it my cup. I simply need to declare that it is my cup and have others accept it
Im going to call bullshit here. If this was true we would say "this body". Who or what is the owner of "my body"?
I don't know....

Does direct experience tell you its separate, or does thought tell you it separate. Does direct experience "tell" you anything? When you look at an apple does the looking tell you "its an apple" , or is there perception, followed by thoughts of "red" "apple"? you need to really look closely at this.

In what way does it "appear separate to the senses"?
OK - thought tells me it is seperate. Direct experience without labels tells me nothing. Thinking tells me "its an apple... Direct experience is just that - experience without labels...

It "appears seperate to the senses" because when I walk into a wall I do not go straight through it even though neither me or the wall are solid . Even though the wall and me are made of the same stuff we do not mingle. I do not become partly wall and the wall does not become partly me.. Something is separate.. Ok this is all thoughts about experience.. But direct experience notices something as I bump head first into the wall trying to walk through it right??

[quote"CTK1"]The body/mind /self concept is a something in the same way that 'a tree' is something.. It is something and not nothing and furthermore even if at the core of it scientifically speaking - the tree and the body/mind/self concepts are made of the same stuff that does not mean that they are the same.. [/quote]
Is the above paragraph any more than thoughts? Are you doing the thoughts? Is the body/mind an "I", a self?
Correct it is thoughts - the thoughts are just happening. The body/mind is a something ( like a tree) and it exists.. It is not " I " in that there is nothing to own it. There are thoughts of I'ness and therefore thoughts of ownership.

Thanks,

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Thu Oct 25, 2012 1:18 pm

I can only conclude (although I find myself resistant to concluding) that there is no conclusive evidence for an experiencer. When I try to think of all of this I do find a kind of mental block sensation - even an actual physical pressure in the head... and thoughts like - "it can't be so", "it is not logical" and somthing wants to tell me that there is evidence everywhere for an experiencer - but in reality there is only evidence for thoughts about an experiencer.. I am not sure what if anything this all means..
Yes I know all these feelings. It does seem illogical. Observe the thoughts trying to make sense of it. Observe them whirring round and round,




I am not sure - maybe it is simultaneous with experience but perhaps a mili-second behind. Certainly thoughts about experience are always behind it.. Perhaps there is an indescribable body/mind direct experiencing and then a describable one which is no longer direct experiencing.. I feel that the "answer" is "NO" there is only ever thoughts about experience happening after and this is supposed to point at the fact that there is "NO I" and only experience..
Is the body/mind the experiencer? Is it doing the experiencing?

You say "this is supposed to point at the fact that there is no I" , does it point to this fact?


I can see what you are getting it.. It is always only thoughts about thoughts ad infinitum and then their is the thought that it seems as if one set of thoughts has an impact on the next set of thoughts that occur int he future and then there is the thought that this is true or not true etc etc etc.. The thoughts are doing themselves but they they seems to be self reflective and so one set of thoughts appear to be able to influence another set of thoughts..and there is a thought that this can be directly experienced.. This is where it is paradoxical - because of course thoughts cannot do anything by themselves.. I am left confused by this
Yes, thoughts about thoughts, ad infinitum. Including thoughts about a self, and thoughts about batman, and thoughts about all sorts of concepts. But no one actually doing any of them.
Are you confused? Or are there thoughts ( and feelings) of confusion? It may seem like I am being nit-picky, but its an important distinction.


It "appears seperate to the senses" because when I walk into a wall I do not go straight through it even though neither me or the wall are solid . Even though the wall and me are made of the same stuff we do not mingle. I do not become partly wall and the wall does not become partly me.. Something is separate.. Ok this is all thoughts about experience.. But direct experience notices something as I bump head first into the wall trying to walk through it right??
Hehe, you are still trying to sneak in an experiencer. "Direct experience notices". Does direct experience notice?

I think you are getting stuck on the "All One" and "separate" thing too much.

Lets take a step back.

What we are doing here is looking at the belief in a separate self. The self that is in charge of the body, that decides what action to take, The self that thinks the thoughts, that chooses what thoughts to think. The self that experiences. So by separate , we mean that its "outside the system" so to speak. Its outside the system, but is receiving data from the system, and then inputting data back into the system. Does such a thing exist?


Correct it is thoughts - the thoughts are just happening. The body/mind is a something ( like a tree) and it exists.. It is not " I " in that there is nothing to own it. There are thoughts of I'ness and therefore thoughts of ownership.
ok so theres lots of thoughts coming up, and noone doing any of them. Does the content of a thought always refer to something real?

For example, theres a thought of santa claus, does the thought point to anything real?
Theres a thought of body, does the thought point to anything real?
Theres a thought of "USA", does the thought point to anything real?
Theres a thought of "ugly" ,does the thought point to anything real?
Theres a thought of "University" ,does the thought point to anything real?
Theres a thought of "I" ,does the thought point to anything real?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Fri Oct 26, 2012 3:35 pm

Hi Neeel,
Is the body/mind the experiencer? Is it doing the experiencing?

You say "this is supposed to point at the fact that there is no I" , does it point to this fact?
I don't know and I don't know

Are you confused? Or are there thoughts ( and feelings) of confusion? It may seem like I am being nit-picky, but its an important distinction.
There are thoughts (and feelings) only.

Hehe, you are still trying to sneak in an experiencer. "Direct experience notices". Does direct experience notice?
You are right.. Direct experience does not notice but something notices..
What we are doing here is looking at the belief in a separate self. The self that is in charge of the body, that decides what action to take, The self that thinks the thoughts, that chooses what thoughts to think. The self that experiences. So by separate , we mean that its "outside the system" so to speak. Its outside the system, but is receiving data from the system, and then inputting data back into the system. Does such a thing exist?
This "self" is made up of thoughts and does not have an independent reality or at least it's reality is not knowable to direct experience.
Does the content of a thought always refer to something real?
Of course not..
For example, theres a thought of santa claus, does the thought point to anything real?
NO
Theres a thought of body, does the thought point to anything real?
It might do, it might not do.. This is a physical object the other things are not. There is more evidence from senses for a body than there is for Santa Clause..
Theres a thought of "USA", does the thought point to anything real?
No
Theres a thought of "ugly" ,does the thought point to anything real?
No
Theres a thought of "University" ,does the thought point to anything real?
NO
Theres a thought of "I" ,does the thought point to anything real?
NO

Thanks,
Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Fri Oct 26, 2012 4:03 pm

You are right.. Direct experience does not notice but something notices..
Does some thing notice? What is this thing that notices? Is there an entity that notices?

Is it possible that noticing happens, without there being a noticer?

When you hear a sound, is there a division between the sound, and the experience of the sound? Is there a sound, the experience of a sound, and an experiencer of the experience?

Look and see


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot], Robshin, shri and 17 guests