OK - so here we get the difference between "SEEING/LOOKING" and thinking. Seeing and Looking seems in these forums to have something to do with something else called "direct experience". Perhaps we are best off defining what this is actually?
My stab at it is - I experience a physical body sensation which I deduce is caused by air moving which I deduce is caused by the fan being switched on etc etc. Is direct looking just removing all of these deductions and cause/effect relationships and just describing what is happening. So - in this case . There is a fan, there is a sensation of movement, their is a physical sensation, their is a sound. IS that direct experience - LOOKING ?
If that is correct and i apply it to your question:
- OK so in order to look I need to simply describe experience with as little description as possible and as little cause and effect as possible. Right so this kind of brings me back to where i was... Do you SEE that the "I" doesnt exist outside of a thought?
There is a body/mind
There are thoughts and thinking
There are thoughts about I
There is no actual I - only the thoughts about I.
So YES - I see that I does not exist outside a thought. but do I SEE and have I LOOKED? I do not know..
OK - I will try with your other questions..
I can only answer NO to your questions because I cannot prove that I am in charge, that I am the chooser etc etc - but I guess maybe I must think that I am otherwise this would not be so difficult. Again - how do I LOOK and not think?Are you in charge of thinking your thoughts ? Do you choose what thoughts to think? Can you predict your next thought?
The body does everything on its own - although a thought about a movement can arise prior to the movement occurring.Are you in charge of walking? Do you control the body, move each muscle at the right time in the correct order?
No - this all happens automatically - although a thought to decide to breather deeper or more frequently or slower can occur prior to the action of breathing.Are you in charge of breathing? Do you make breathing happen, process the oxygen, move it around the body?
NOAre you in charge of digestion?
NO - but having said that - thoughts occur to focus hearing and then hearing becomes focused.Are you in charge of hearing?
Well there appears to be a certain amount of thoughts that dictate my actions in the world. Do those thoughts just happen and my path in the world has just happened despite my thoughts about I? I have chosen to live in another country recently. Did I in fact not choose and it is just what happened? This just seems like it could not be so..What are you in charge of?
Thanks,
Colin

