Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
vegansatori
Posts: 393
Joined: Sun May 23, 2021 3:35 am

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby vegansatori » Wed Dec 07, 2022 3:23 am

Hi Barry!
It was like a short circuit. Just blew a fuse in the head for a second.
This is a very important fuse to be blown. The mind stopping is exactly what you need. It’s in the habit of filling every moment with concepts and comparisons. This vacancy is where the truth lives.

Really happy to hear that there wasn’t much fear. Just adrenaline!
I don’t know. I WANT to be put somewhere lol. But I want the truth more. If I’m no where than I need to recognize that
Good that you recognize this. WHY do you want to be put somewhere? Why do you feel the need to exist as Barry?
If this thinking is just thinking for the sake of thinking and I’m sending a message to someone that isn’t a someone that’s okay too I suppose. That’s a wild thought.
It is a wild thought. And it’s pretty close to the truth. lol
Can you find anything stable to hold onto?
No. That’s part of the what makes it so scary. It’s just a free fall… or more like getting shot out into space. Didn’t find ANYTHING stable. Though I will admit I wasn’t in “there” long.
That’s okay! You can see a lot in that state. It’s not necessary to maintain it forever. But notice in that moment that there is no Barry, and yet, there can still be knowing afterwards that the state happened. You were able to relay the experience. But did there have to be a real permanent self there seeing it, freaking out about it, and reporting it? Or was it simply an experience, and then thoughts relating the experience?
Anything that persists from moment to moment and decade to decade?
I don’t even know? Using DE? I’ve always had my senses though I may not in the next few decades and presumably will not in death. So what persists? I can’t find anything that continues.
Good that you can’t find anything. The idea that “you have always had your senses” is just an assumption. When you were sleeping every night, were you aware of all your senses? Can you still taste the apple you ate on October 13th, 2010? Can you still hear the same chirp of the bird that you heard this morning? The sense faculties themselves may function now, but everything they take in is completely impermanent and ungraspable.

Did you ever have a song that you hated and then eventually grew to like? Or vice versa? How about a food that you loved, and then ate so much that you got sick on it, and now even the smell of it makes you want to hurl? The song didn’t change. The smell of the food didn’t change. But the “Barry” who heard and smelled them has. So where is the consistency?

And when we do all of this, we are always looking in DE. Appealing to memory and concepts will never show you what you're looking for because it's always just more mind-stuff. If the self was going to exist, it would be HERE right NOW.

Do you know this old koan?

Gateless Gate, Case 41
Bodhidharma sat facing the wall
The Second Patriarch stood in the snow.
He cut off his arm and presented it to Bodhidharma, crying, “My mind has no peace as yet! I beg you, master, please pacify my mind!”
“Bring your mind here and I will pacify it for you,” replied Bodhidharma.
“I have searched for my mind, and I cannot take hold of it,” said the Second Patriarch.
“Now your mind is pacified,” said Bodhidharma.

Really sit with that and let it sink in! ;-)

I am happy with your progress too, but I’m not letting you off that easy! lol

When you can, let me know what else felt different about today. Do things still feel any different?
Thank you so much for this. Maybe there was a reason I had to step away for a bit. This is wild.

My pleasure! Yes, I’m telling you, everything happens in its own right time. Things must have needed time to settle. And now we’re here to see it through once and for all! :-)

Keep on it, and enjoy your time doing it!
-Todd
That relaxation of the clenched "myself" feels like having been roused from a dream to find oneself alive and aware...Each moment feels fresh, different from any other, and entirely unspeakable...And that is sufficient.- Robert Saltzman

User avatar
BarBarryN
Posts: 60
Joined: Fri Aug 13, 2021 5:33 am
Location: Portland, ME USA

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby BarBarryN » Wed Dec 07, 2022 4:17 pm

Good Morning Todd!
I don’t know. I WANT to be put somewhere lol. But I want the truth more. If I’m no where than I need to recognize that
Good that you recognize this. WHY do you want to be put somewhere? Why do you feel the need to exist as Barry?
The thought of not being is scary. Though if I'm already not a thing / just a thought than what does it matter? This is all conceptual though. In DE there is something here. Maybe not a Barry but sounds, temperature, colors. Sensations.


Can you find anything stable to hold onto?
No. That’s part of the what makes it so scary. It’s just a free fall… or more like getting shot out into space. Didn’t find ANYTHING stable. Though I will admit I wasn’t in “there” long.
That’s okay! You can see a lot in that state. It’s not necessary to maintain it forever. But notice in that moment that there is no Barry, and yet, there can still be knowing afterwards that the state happened. You were able to relay the experience.
Yes! I see that now. Brain still functioning. Memory formed. There was also seeing, feeling, hearing too. That didn't go away.


But did there have to be a real permanent self there seeing it, freaking out about it, and reporting it? Or was it simply an experience, and then thoughts relating the experience?
No. There didn't appear to be a real permanent self seeing it. Simply experiencing. The beating heart and adrenaline was then labeled "fear". I suppose I could also experience the same sensations and label it "workout" or even "day on roller coaster". This is not DE though. Right now simply the senses and thoughts. A desire to do this "right". No doer of the thought let alone a doer to do it right. Even THAT though is conceptual.


Did you ever have a song that you hated and then eventually grew to like? Or vice versa? How about a food that you loved, and then ate so much that you got sick on it, and now even the smell of it makes you want to hurl?
Yes. Preferences change. Thank God! lol.


So where is the consistency?
I can't find any consistency in DE.

Do you know this old koan?

Gateless Gate, Case 41
Bodhidharma sat facing the wall
The Second Patriarch stood in the snow.
He cut off his arm and presented it to Bodhidharma, crying, “My mind has no peace as yet! I beg you, master, please pacify my mind!”
“Bring your mind here and I will pacify it for you,” replied Bodhidharma.
“I have searched for my mind, and I cannot take hold of it,” said the Second Patriarch.
“Now your mind is pacified,” said Bodhidharma.

Really sit with that and let it sink in! ;-)
I will sit with this and will let you know what arises.


When you can, let me know what else felt different about today. Do things still feel any different?
Hmmm. Nothing that I'm aware of. There is a desire to report some amazing breakthrough to you. I look for the one that wants to report the amazing breakthrough. An image of me blissed out appears in my thought space. I then look for who that is referring to and it can't be found.

A new desire appears. Is this how I do self inquiry? An image of myself appears with eyes closed. It's just a thought.
Who is looking? another image of me with eyes closed.
Who is looking?
My mind tells me Looking Just happens. It's paroting back.
Who believes this?
SELFING


A desire to apologize for the rambling. But is it a real apology? Am I really sorry?
No.
It comes automatically when I "go off the trail".

Thanks for all your time with this Todd.

Is there real gratitude?
There is! There is REAL gratitude lol. I am ALL gratitude. It makes me tear up actually!
Amazing.

Tearfully grateful,

Barry!

User avatar
vegansatori
Posts: 393
Joined: Sun May 23, 2021 3:35 am

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby vegansatori » Thu Dec 08, 2022 3:28 am

Hi Barry!
Ah, I am very grateful to be able to have this dialogue with you! It’s a wondrous thing. Thank you for letting me work with you!
The thought of not being is scary. Though if I'm already not a thing / just a thought than what does it matter? This is all conceptual though.
I love how you can basically guide yourself. You say something, then know how to respond as if you were hearing someone else say it. The problem is that I suspect it’s still coming from an intellectual place, otherwise you wouldn’t need to have the first moment of doubt or confusion about it.
In DE there is something here. Maybe not a Barry but sounds, temperature, colors. Sensations.
I’m not denying that there are, and always will be, sounds, temperatures, colors, etc. What is it about those things you listed that even HINT at the possibility that they might sort of be a Barry? We’re never denying the existence of experience. Only the labels that try to make those different disparate experiences into one solid, stable, unified thing called Barry. Where is your evidence in DE for that?

That’s okay! You can see a lot in that state. It’s not necessary to maintain it forever. But notice in that moment that there is no Barry, and yet, there can still be knowing afterwards that the state happened. You were able to relay the experience.
Yes! I see that now. Brain still functioning. Memory formed. There was also seeing, feeling, hearing too. That didn't go away.
Well seen! How could it go away? There is no Barry now, there was no Barry then, and there will be no Barry next. The memory/brain still functioned when there was no Barry in the past. So what could possibly be different whether you’re in one state or another? The only thing missing, I suspect, were thoughts labeling, categorizing, and making a self out of various sensations.

To put it another way, you have two states, right?
1. Barry is believed in, and the brain functions.
2. Barry is not believed in, and the brain functions.

How can a belief completely change the functioning of the body-mind organism?

No. There didn't appear to be a real permanent self seeing it. Simply experiencing. The beating heart and adrenaline was then labeled "fear". I suppose I could also experience the same sensations and label it "workout" or even "day on roller coaster". This is not DE though. Right now simply the senses and thoughts. A desire to do this "right". No doer of the thought let alone a doer to do it right. Even THAT though is conceptual.
Again, well done with the self-guiding! Lol

When you recognize that there is no doer of thought, is that purely something you have learned, or have you seen it for yourself at some point and keep needing to remind yourself of it? Because those are two different things.
Yes. Preferences change. Thank God! lol.
Hahaha, so true!
I can't find any consistency in DE.
Good. Can you find any consistency in thought? ACTUAL consistency, not just thoughts about consistency?
I will sit with this and will let you know what arises.
Great. If you aren’t familiar, you don’t want to think and reason out koans. Just read them and let it strike an intuitive chord. Do you get any sense of what this one is pointing to? Is there a dawning experience that it creates/reminds you of?
Hmmm. Nothing that I'm aware of. There is a desire to report some amazing breakthrough to you. I look for the one that wants to report the amazing breakthrough. An image of me blissed out appears in my thought space. I then look for who that is referring to and it can't be found.
Again, great self-guiding! You’re doing my job for me. ;-) Please don’t feel any desire to report anything like that. That pressure will only push you further back because it reinforces the feeling that you are someone who is performing this inquiry, either succeeding or failing, and needs to report back for praise and a trophy. None of that is true.

The best thing you can do is R E L A X! Relax back and just let things be. What’s there when you aren’t striving to know? Striving to succeed?

Again, I will still be kind of surprised if you have an earth-shattering shift after everything you’ve done. But we never know!
A new desire appears. Is this how I do self inquiry? An image of myself appears with eyes closed. It's just a thought.
Who is looking? another image of me with eyes closed.
Who is looking?
My mind tells me Looking Just happens. It's paroting back.
Who believes this?
SELFING

A desire to apologize for the rambling. But is it a real apology? Am I really sorry?
No.
It comes automatically when I "go off the trail".
Hahaha, I love this! It’s great how aware you are of what’s going on in the mind, and how you’re getting off the rails.

Tell me this: When you are doing inquiry, and these thoughts and images are popping up, for instance, when you see the image of yourself with eyes closed, and have the thought remembering that it’s just a thought, is there a moment of space? Of silence? Of a gap where it’s clearly seen that what was being taken for a self is really just an image? It might not last, but is there a flash of insight like that before the thought “it’s just a thought” appears?

You’re doing great, and please feel no pressure to deliver the goods. Just keep your own pressure on to look because you really want to be convinced once and for all that there is no self in there!

Relax! Have fun with it! Enjoy your day!
-Todd
That relaxation of the clenched "myself" feels like having been roused from a dream to find oneself alive and aware...Each moment feels fresh, different from any other, and entirely unspeakable...And that is sufficient.- Robert Saltzman

User avatar
BarBarryN
Posts: 60
Joined: Fri Aug 13, 2021 5:33 am
Location: Portland, ME USA

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby BarBarryN » Thu Dec 08, 2022 5:59 pm

Good Morning Todd,

Busy morning. I have parents coming to town to stay with me for a few days but I wanted to send you something.

I will respond to the rest of your comments but this one I was wondering about the most:
Tell me this: When you are doing inquiry, and these thoughts and images are popping up, for instance, when you see the image of yourself with eyes closed, and have the thought remembering that it’s just a thought, is there a moment of space? Of silence? Of a gap where it’s clearly seen that what was being taken for a self is really just an image? It might not last, but is there a flash of insight like that before the thought “it’s just a thought” appears?
I want to tell you my approach with self inquiry and if you have any tips.

I'm attempting to do exactly as Angelo DiLullo instructs on self inquiry which, as my understanding, is to ask a question: Who am I? What am I? Who hears? etc. -- Something that strikes a chord inside of me and see what appears. Recently it's been "How do I know I exist?"

If an image appears try to then see where or what the image is referring to inside of my experience (I think? I'm fuzzy on this and would like any direction on this)

Or, if nothing appears just be with that nothing.
I'm noticing though when nothing appears I'm just asking the question again. I'm trying to recognize that sooner so I can just with the silence which isn't silence at all. Its just 100% DE -- Breath, Heart Beat, Sounds, Colors. I'm sure you know this 1000x better than I do but that's my approach.



Which makes me interested when you said:
Of a gap where it’s clearly seen that what was being taken for a self is really just an image? It might not last, but is there a flash of insight like that before the thought “it’s just a thought” appears?
When an image of me, a past event, really any image appears I then "look" for who believes that image (if it's a story about my past or hope for the future) or who believes that images is me. This is where I feel like I "lose the trail." My attention moves then around the headspace. Am I inside the head? It moves down to the heart. Am I the heart? Etc. Etc. I then start wondering well who the hell is feeling this attention move? An Image appears. Who sees this image? And the loop continues.

To reiterate:
when you see the image of yourself with eyes closed, and have the thought remembering that it’s just a thought, is there a moment of space?
As soon as there is an image seen I then go looking for who that thought is referring to. I'm realizing now I'm expecting to find SOMETHING. I don't know what that something is but it never occurred to me that the exercise could actually be to show me that I will find nothing.... which is what I've been finding.... only more searching. Jesus Christ really? LOL

Anyways. I'll sit with that...

I do want to say thanks for reminding me of just labeling these types of thoughts as "selfing" has helped very much. Just kind of shuts it all down for a few breaths and some other mind activity appears.

Talk soon,

Barry

User avatar
vegansatori
Posts: 393
Joined: Sun May 23, 2021 3:35 am

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby vegansatori » Thu Dec 08, 2022 9:58 pm

Hi Barry!
Oh fun! That’ll be a great workshop, since nothing can make you “Self” like your parents! :-)
I’ll be very curious to hear how that goes.
I want to tell you my approach with self inquiry and if you have any tips.
I'm attempting to do exactly as Angelo DiLullo instructs on self inquiry which, as my understanding, is to ask a question: Who am I? What am I? Who hears? etc. -- Something that strikes a chord inside of me and see what appears. Recently it's been "How do I know I exist?"

If an image appears try to then see where or what the image is referring to inside of my experience (I think? I'm fuzzy on this and would like any direction on this)

Or, if nothing appears just be with that nothing.
I'm noticing though when nothing appears I'm just asking the question again. I'm trying to recognize that sooner so I can just with the silence which isn't silence at all. Its just 100% DE -- Breath, Heart Beat, Sounds, Colors. I'm sure you know this 1000x better than I do but that's my approach.
Okay, this is SUPER helpful!
I agree with finding a sentence that works for you. Personally I’m not a fan of the “Who/what am I” questions, but that’s just me. I feel like they are too vague and are too open to interpretation. There can also be the hidden expectation in them that there really is a thing to find. Like “I am Awareness” or something like that. So that defeats the purpose.

I’m on the fence about your “How do I know I exist” question. It’s a good thing to inquire into, but I would use it differently. If you make it into a meditation, which is what it sounds like you’re doing, where you intone the question and actively explore your body/sensations, I suspect you’re going to run into exactly what it sounds like you’re running into. You are actually expecting on some level to find something.

The way I would approach that question is as an almost nonverbal intention to discover the answer to it in the situation when you feel yourself selfing. I know that was probably a confusing sentence. In practice it would look like this:

I’m washing dishes, thinking about five things I have to do later today, feeling stressed and like I don’t have enough time, and then I suddenly wake up for a second to realize that I’ve been lost in thought about all of these things. In that next moment I would stop, and using the intention to discover how I know that I exist, or what it feels like to be selfing in this moment, I would just scan the body for anything that feels like “Todd,” or that separate self. And if I realize that there is tension in my chest… okay, that’s just a physical sensation, not Todd. If I see a mental image of my body doing one of the activities I’m worried about later in the day, that was just a thought imagining a possible future situation. It is neither a “Todd”, nor does it have any reality at all. The future hasn’t happened yet. The situation as it was envisioned will almost certainly be different than imagined. And none of that is happening now. So that can be discarded. What else feels like Todd in this moment?…. And I would go through each of those to see if they are proof of the existence of Todd right now.

Does that help?
It’s a bit of a Neti Neti approach.

One thing that I cannot stress enough (because I overlooked it for some damn long) is how obvious and almost surface-level this looking is. We aren’t looking for some deep underlayer of experience that only a few loin-clothed yogis in the Himalayas can see. The self is either found immediately when you turn inwards and look, or it isn’t. And when it isn’t found so many times, eventually that’s the shift that convinces you more deeply than just by logical argument that it’s really the case.
If an image appears try to then see where or what the image is referring to inside of my experience (I think? I'm fuzzy on this and would like any direction on this)
Yeah, if I understand what you mean by this, it would definitely lead you down more conceptual dead-ends. An image is just a thought image. Is the image Barry? It might be an image that somewhat resembles the exterior of the body sitting in that chair right now. But is the image a self?

The one thing which Angelo says that I find very helpful is the suggestion to just label thoughts and let them pass without following them. And to notice that even the words “Oh, that was just a thought” is itself another thought. There is a very easy identification with thoughts as though they are ME/MINE. And this helps break that illusion apart. Even the wise ones that know that we've gotten lost in thoughts are still thoughts! LOL
When an image of me, a past event, really any image appears I then "look" for who believes that image (if it's a story about my past or hope for the future) or who believes that images is me. This is where I feel like I "lose the trail." My attention moves then around the headspace. Am I inside the head? It moves down to the heart. Am I the heart? Etc. Etc. I then start wondering well who the hell is feeling this attention move? An Image appears. Who sees this image? And the loop continues.
This is actually on the right trail, as I pointed out earlier. But you don’t need to intellectually inquire into each body part. Just look for what sensation or thought RIGHT NOW, RIGHT HERE, is masquerading as a self. What is it about your experience RIGHT NOW that tells you you are a stable self?

You could probably get an intellectually satisfying answer to the question about who is feeling the attention move by reading more about neuroscience. But neuroscience didn’t exist for the thousands of years that people have been coming to the insight of no-self. So learning how it happens won’t actually help you.

You can pay more attention to that feeling of attention. How does it move? Are you really able to move it? Are you able to keep it still on one object for as long as you want, or does it keep getting diverted? Do you really choose where it goes next most of the time? Noticing that can use it break down the illusion of personal control. And point to the fact that you can’t be the attention, or else you would have perfect control of it all the time. Right?
is an image seen I then go looking for who that thought is referring to. I'm realizing now I'm expecting to find SOMETHING. I don't know what that something is but it never occurred to me that the exercise could actually be to show me that I will find nothing.... which is what I've been finding.... only more searching. Jesus Christ really? LOL
HAHAHAHAHA!!! YES! Exactly right!!! The whole point of every one of these exercises is to pull the rug out from under you every single time you feel like you have place to stand. “I am my body.” Or really? Whoosh! Not the body! “I am my thoughts” You think so, huh? Whoosh! On and on so that every time you will feel that open space for another moment. That freefall that you described the other day. There is no place to land, and that is the key! And then when that is finally completely understood, then the searching can end.
I do want to say thanks for reminding me of just labeling these types of thoughts as "selfing" has helped very much. Just kind of shuts it all down for a few breaths and some other mind activity appears.
So glad to hear it! And like I keep stressing, that mind-shutdown is where we’re going. In that space, is there any Barry? There is still awareness. The world doesn’t disappear. But is the you that you always assumed existed still there? Just rest in that space for as long as it persists and then go back again.

So going back to that koan.
Show me your mind. After all these months of searching, have you found it yet? If not, what more can be done to pacify it?

You are doing so well! Bravo!
Have a nice time with the parents! I understand if you won't have as much time to respond over the next few days.
-Todd
That relaxation of the clenched "myself" feels like having been roused from a dream to find oneself alive and aware...Each moment feels fresh, different from any other, and entirely unspeakable...And that is sufficient.- Robert Saltzman

User avatar
BarBarryN
Posts: 60
Joined: Fri Aug 13, 2021 5:33 am
Location: Portland, ME USA

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby BarBarryN » Fri Dec 09, 2022 5:04 pm

Good morning Todd!
I’m washing dishes, thinking about five things I have to do later today, feeling stressed and like I don’t have enough time, and then I suddenly wake up for a second to realize that I’ve been lost in thought about all of these things. In that next moment I would stop, and using the intention to discover how I know that I exist, or what it feels like to be selfing in this moment, I would just scan the body for anything that feels like “Todd,” or that separate self. And if I realize that there is tension in my chest… okay, that’s just a physical sensation, not Todd. If I see a mental image of my body doing one of the activities I’m worried about later in the day, that was just a thought imagining a possible future situation. It is neither a “Todd”, nor does it have any reality at all. The future hasn’t happened yet. The situation as it was envisioned will almost certainly be different than imagined. And none of that is happening now. So that can be discarded. What else feels like Todd in this moment?…. And I would go through each of those to see if they are proof of the existence of Todd right now.
Does that help?
Yes. That helps very much. Thank you.

I particularly like what you said: "I don’t have enough time, and then I suddenly wake up for a second to realize that I’ve been lost in thought"-- Each moment when you realize you're lost in thought and just the mere recognization of it being a thought is a little wake up moment, isn't it?
I never really thought of it like that that... but that in itself is a little "shift" each time isn't it? I like that. Thank you.

What is it about your experience RIGHT NOW that tells you you are a stable self?
I immediately go to the senses. Sounds. Sight. There is also recognition of these senses / attention moving to Sounds one moment and Sight the next. Attention moving to the dictation thoughts as I write this to you now. Though the idea of attention comes after doesn't it? There is just sound one moment and just thought or maybe a combination of sounds and thoughts. The realization that attention is moving comes after the experience.

So where is the stable self?
I feel like a stable self. What does that feeling feel like? There appears to be images appearing in MY vision. There appears to be sounds appearing in MY soundspace.
How to see just sounds appearing, just images appearing without the MY? hmmmm.
There isn't a thought that is actively saying these are YOUR visions or these are YOUR sounds or even YOUR thoughts. It's a subtle "knowing".

hmmm.

I guess it's that simple. There is a feeling that feels like a stable self. That's it. Do I dive into this feeling? Do I let it ride out like other feelings and emotions?
Unlike thoughts / just simply recognizing it... I don't see an "entrance" into this one.

I feel like a stable self though I haven't found evidence to support this and I believe that the self is just a feeling of a self.
Man, what conceptual bullshit I just spewed hahaha.

hmmm.

Am I identifying the self with the senses?
I'm not taking ownership of the senses. I clearly see they just happen with out any control from me. How great would it be if I never smelled garbage and only chose to hear pleasant sounds. I can't. Though how are any of these things be experienced? Who is the one experiencing all this? Thoughts? That doesn't feel right.

something about experiencing this is where I'm tied up in I think.

Phew took me a minute haha thanks for hanging in there.


You can pay more attention to that feeling of attention. How does it move? Are you really able to move it? Are you able to keep it still on one object for as long as you want, or does it keep getting diverted? Do you really choose where it goes next most of the time?
It moves to whatever is the Loudest, Brightest, Touchiest, Smelliest thing. I'm not moving it at all and attention keeps getting diverted.


And like I keep stressing, that mind-shutdown is where we’re going. In that space, is there any Barry? There is still awareness. The world doesn’t disappear. But is the you that you always assumed existed still there? Just rest in that space for as long as it persists and then go back again.
No. There is just the space. I've only been "there" a few times... perhaps with more time in "there" the illusion of self will finally been seen through. This of course is all conceptual.


So going back to that koan.
Show me your mind. After all these months of searching, have you found it yet? If not, what more can be done to pacify it?
Who experienceses all THIS?


-Barry

User avatar
vegansatori
Posts: 393
Joined: Sun May 23, 2021 3:35 am

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby vegansatori » Sat Dec 10, 2022 12:19 am

Hi Barry!
I particularly like what you said: "I don’t have enough time, and then I suddenly wake up for a second to realize that I’ve been lost in thought"-- Each moment when you realize you're lost in thought and just the mere recognization of it being a thought is a little wake up moment, isn't it?
I never really thought of it like that that... but that in itself is a little "shift" each time isn't it? I like that. Thank you.
Yes! Great that you picked up on that. Every time you catch yourself thinking or selfing, that is a brief moment of clarity. Hopefully there will be a little gap in there that you can sit in, or feel your way into. Either way, just noticing it is retraining your subconscious to keep vigilant for these moments. And if you celebrate it as a little victory, you incentivize yourself to keep finding them because you get a little hit of happy hormones when you do. :-)
What is it about your experience RIGHT NOW that tells you you are a stable self?
I immediately go to the senses. Sounds. Sight. There is also recognition of these senses / attention moving to Sounds one moment and Sight the next. Attention moving to the dictation thoughts as I write this to you now. Though the idea of attention comes after doesn't it? There is just sound one moment and just thought or maybe a combination of sounds and thoughts. The realization that attention is moving comes after the experience.
Okay, yes, good. The sense information will always be there, but again, there is nothing in the sense appearance itself that claims to be a self, right? So it sounds like you are identifying with the attention. What you notice about the idea of attention being a later add-on to the actual raw sensory event of seeing/hearing/etc. is very good. That book that I quoted about Metacognitive Introspective Awareness actually has a very interesting description of how we only take in discrete sights, sounds, tastes, smells, one at a time, (switching from one to another extremely fast) and then a separate faculty called Binding Consciousness stitches them together afterwards, effectively creating our smooth experience like a movie made out of individual frames. It’s very interesting, and something which people can notice with a lot of meditation practice. But I really don’t think that will do much except for giving your already too-busy mind something else to chew on and use to label your experience. So I would recommend not going down that rabbit hole.
So where is the stable self?
I feel like a stable self. What does that feeling feel like? There appears to be images appearing in MY vision. There appears to be sounds appearing in MY soundspace.
How to see just sounds appearing, just images appearing without the MY? hmmmm.
There isn't a thought that is actively saying these are YOUR visions or these are YOUR sounds or even YOUR thoughts. It's a subtle "knowing".
Have you done the exercise where you list what's happening right now? Then say them out loud:
I am typing
I am hungry
I am hearing a truck etc.

And then try the same sentences but without the subject:
Typing (or Typing is happening)
Hunger (Hunger is happening)
Hearing a truck

Say those out loud and see if something feels different in the body. Try making your own lists. Even try throughout the day to notice every time a thought says "I'm so hungry," "I have to do that later," "I can't deal with this," whatever. And then feel that "I". What is it referring to? Anything? Then try rephrasing it without the subject and see what changes.

hmmm.
I guess it's that simple. There is a feeling that feels like a stable self. That's it. Do I dive into this feeling? Do I let it ride out like other feelings and emotions?
Unlike thoughts / just simply recognizing it... I don't see an "entrance" into this one.

I feel like a stable self though I haven't found evidence to support this and I believe that the self is just a feeling of a self.
Man, what conceptual bullshit I just spewed hahaha.

Am I identifying the self with the senses?
I'm not taking ownership of the senses. I clearly see they just happen with out any control from me. How great would it be if I never smelled garbage and only chose to hear pleasant sounds. I can't. Though how are any of these things be experienced? Who is the one experiencing all this? Thoughts? That doesn't feel right.

something about experiencing this is where I'm tied up in I think.

Phew took me a minute haha thanks for hanging in there.

It’s very helpful to hear your thought process laid out like this!

Remember that when we use words like “I feel like…” or “It seems that…” you are really saying “I THINK that…”

You see a "chair" across the room. What’s there? There’s a "chair," right? No. There’s awareness of colors and shapes. But then there is a conception of it being a “chair”, and worse yet, “MY chair.” “My chair that I sat on when I texted so-and-so for the first time, and…” And then “I’m not only aware of the chair, but I’m also aware of my memories about my chair, and I’m aware that I’m aware of being aware…” Does this sound familiar? The thing is, everything in that paragraph in quotes was a THOUGHT. Even simply “chair.” There is no such thing as a “chair” outside of a concept.

So when you “feel” like you are the awareness, that “feeling” is a “thinking”. You are saying there are appearances appearing, and before you realize it’s happening, you have claimed ownership of them by identifying with the awareness that is seeing them.

Is that clear? Again, turning to the Zen tradition, there’s a line “As soon as you speak one word, you’re dead.” There is just ______.

It’s good that you see that you aren’t in control of the senses. Now you have to see that you are not the awareness, or the experiencer of them too.

Remember, awareness will still be there. But what is it about the awareness itself that says “Hi, I’m Barry!”?
You can pay more attention to that feeling of attention. How does it move? Are you really able to move it? Are you able to keep it still on one object for as long as you want, or does it keep getting diverted? Do you really choose where it goes next most of the time?
It moves to whatever is the Loudest, Brightest, Touchiest, Smelliest thing. I'm not moving it at all and attention keeps getting diverted.
Well seen.
And like I keep stressing, that mind-shutdown is where we’re going. In that space, is there any Barry? There is still awareness. The world doesn’t disappear. But is the you that you always assumed existed still there? Just rest in that space for as long as it persists and then go back again.
No. There is just the space. I've only been "there" a few times... perhaps with more time in "there" the illusion of self will finally been seen through. This of course is all conceptual.
Yeah, the idea of more time in there is conceptual, but it might also turn out to be true. lol

Angelo points people to sitting in that space as long as you can, as frequently as you can. However, I think it might be more helpful to just keep searching for whatever identifies itself to be Barry, and then dissect the shit out of it to see if that’s really true.
Who experienceses all THIS?
DOES anything/anyone experience all THIS?

Let’s investigate the senses one by one.

Try this out:
Seeing Exercise - Part I
The usual belief that 'I am this body' is generally tied in with the belief that the body as a separate item is responsible or 'DOING' the senses - 'I see', 'I hear', 'I feel' etc. We will begin with 'seeing' - Just that one sense on its own.

Close your eyes. With eyes closed, you will now experience 'blackness'. There may be other things you can find going on. If you are looking at a bright light, there may be a red glow. There may be sparkly bits or cloudy flecks appearing and disappearing… It really doesn't matter about the specifics. Just to make things simple, whatever you can see with eyes closed, I'm going to refer to it as 'black' or 'blackness' just for simplicity.

With eyes closed, can you confirm that what is experienced is 'blackness' as I mentioned?
Is there anything else in 'seeing' other than 'blackness'?
Can what is witnessing the blackness be found?
Are you seeing any thought images arise? If so, where do they appear? Are any of them mental representations of body images? (i.e. Your face, the posture of your body, etc.)
Can a pair of eyes, an 'I' / 'me', a person be found that is witnessing the blackness? Or is there just 'blackness' to be found? What do you find?
Can an INHERENT SEER be found? Would anything that is suggested as the seer, be anything other than a concept/idea/thought?


Seeing Exercise – Part II
Let's move on to opening the eyes now. Again, we are addressing only the 'seeing' sense for the moment. With eyes open, a world of objects appears... a room.... a computer screen etc. What you can specifically see isn't of interest here, and whatever it is, I am simply going to refer to it as 'what can be seen'. This might be a little trickier, but give it some consideration.

With eyes open, can you confirm that what is experienced is 'what can be seen' as I mentioned?
Is there anything else in 'seeing' other than 'what can be seen'?
Can what is witnessing 'what can be seen' be found?
Can a pair of eyes, an 'I' / 'me', a Barry, be found that is witnessing 'what can be seen'? Or is there just simply 'what can be seen' being found?
What do you find? Can an INHERENT SEER be found? Would anything that is suggested as the seer, be anything other than a concept/idea/thought?


Keep up the good work!
-Todd
That relaxation of the clenched "myself" feels like having been roused from a dream to find oneself alive and aware...Each moment feels fresh, different from any other, and entirely unspeakable...And that is sufficient.- Robert Saltzman

User avatar
BarBarryN
Posts: 60
Joined: Fri Aug 13, 2021 5:33 am
Location: Portland, ME USA

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby BarBarryN » Sat Dec 10, 2022 6:37 pm

Good afternoon Todd!

Long post coming in!


Have you done the exercise where you list what's happening right now? Then say them out loud:
I am typing
I am hungry
I am hearing a truck etc.

And then try the same sentences but without the subject:
Typing (or Typing is happening)
Hunger (Hunger is happening)
Hearing a truck

Say those out loud and see if something feels different in the body. Try making your own lists. Even try throughout the day to notice every time a thought says "I'm so hungry," "I have to do that later," "I can't deal with this," whatever. And then feel that "I". What is it referring to? Anything? Then try rephrasing it without the subject and see what changes.
I am typing
I have an itch
I close my eyes
I open my eyes
I feel frustration
I want something
I want to be better at my craft
I want to be a writer
I should be writing
I close my eyes
Typing
Sounds
Breath
Sounds
Sounds
Breath
Sounds
Awaring
Pressure
Sounds
Feeling
Thoughts
Sounds
Black

It has a very calming effect to be without the subject.



So when you “feel” like you are the awareness, that “feeling” is a “thinking”. You are saying there are appearances appearing, and before you realize it’s happening, you have claimed ownership of them by identifying with the awareness that is seeing them.

Is that clear?
Yes. That is much clearer. These are like little tidbits of remembering here. Like oh yeah! I forgot that! Like I’ve treaded over this ground and have forgotten that I’ve seen this already. Tricky thing.

I see that the ownership is so sneaky. When sounds appear its just sounds and a millisecond later there is the thought of experiencing the sound. But it comes in a way that it makes me think the idea of an experiencer was always there at the start. But it wasn’t! It was a thought very shortly after. AND to make it even trickier its coming in without ownership. It’s like no man, there is no owner of the sound, it’s just happening… but there is someone here experiencing it. FREAKING THOUGHTS!


But what is it about the awareness itself that says “Hi, I’m Barry!”?
It’s a lie! A multi-layered Ponzi scheme. There is an experience (something via one of the sense gates or a thought), then a thought saying there is something aware of the experience, and then another thought saying that I am that experiencer. All happening in a blink of an eye.


Who experienceses all THIS?
I don't know....I need to have a look. I think this is my practice now. The Neti Neti approach. My heart is racing again lol.

I’m going to meditate for 15 minutes and report back.

….

And back. Man, my mind was super active. Serving up stories I want to write. I kept using the “this isn’t me” or “selfing” and another story was served up. Didn’t reach that quiet place but that’s okay. I actually feel pretty happy right now.


Seeing Exercise - Part I
The usual belief that 'I am this body' is generally tied in with the belief that the body as a separate item is responsible or 'DOING' the senses - 'I see', 'I hear', 'I feel' etc. We will begin with 'seeing' - Just that one sense on its own.

Close your eyes. With eyes closed, you will now experience 'blackness'. There may be other things you can find going on. If you are looking at a bright light, there may be a red glow. There may be sparkly bits or cloudy flecks appearing and disappearing… It really doesn't matter about the specifics. Just to make things simple, whatever you can see with eyes closed, I'm going to refer to it as 'black' or 'blackness' just for simplicity.

With eyes closed, can you confirm that what is experienced is 'blackness' as I mentioned?
Yes. Experiencing the blackness.


Can what is witnessing the blackness be found?
No.


Are you seeing any thought images arise? If so, where do they appear? Are any of them mental representations of body images? (i.e. Your face, the posture of your body, etc.)
Yes. Thought Images arise. These images appear where the blackness is. Back to just random things — Characters from stories I want to write or an image of something that I need to do later.


Can a pair of eyes, an 'I' / 'me', a person be found that is witnessing the blackness? Or is there just 'blackness' to be found? What do you find?
No pair of eyes, nor an ‘I’ / ‘me’ can be found witnessing the blackness. Just blackness with the occasional thought image.


Can an INHERENT SEER be found? Would anything that is suggested as the seer, be anything other than a concept/idea/thought?
No inherent seer can be found. Nothing to suggest a seer other than a concept/idea/thought.


Let's move on to opening the eyes now. Again, we are addressing only the 'seeing' sense for the moment. With eyes open, a world of objects appears... a room.... a computer screen etc. What you can specifically see isn't of interest here, and whatever it is, I am simply going to refer to it as 'what can be seen'. This might be a little trickier, but give it some consideration.

With eyes open, can you confirm that what is experienced is 'what can be seen' as I mentioned?
Yes.


Is there anything else in 'seeing' other than 'what can be seen'?
Occasionally a thought is “seen.” An overlay over the “actual” seen. Much like a thought overlaying the blackness with eyes closed.


Can what is witnessing 'what can be seen' be found?
No.


Can a pair of eyes, an 'I' / 'me', a Barry, be found that is witnessing 'what can be seen'? Or is there just simply 'what can be seen' being found?
No pair of eyes to be found. Simply ‘what can be seen’.


What do you find? Can an INHERENT SEER be found? Would anything that is suggested as the seer, be anything other than a concept/idea/thought?
No, an inherent seer cannot be found nor anything that is suggesting a seer. Just a thought telling me but you feel like a seer. This is just a thought. Even the thought that this is just a thought is just a thought.

There is a thought of “okay so what?’

Looking for identification. A thought of “somethig should happen with this realizations.”

This is just a thought.

There are sounds.

Sensations.

Colors.

More sounds.

Small annoyance to a sound

A story about the sound and why I feel the annoyance. More story.

Selfing.

Sensations

Looking for some sort of shift / realization. More thoughts.

Looking for a “conclusion”. More thoughts

Colors

Sounds.

Selfing continues but there is an okayness with that. There is also a realization that I don’t know how any of this works. I feel like I just swallowed a pill and I don’t know what the effects will be yet. LOL. And I’m okay with that too.


Again, thank you for your time and thorough questioning on this. I keep thinking how true this all feels— this path I’m on. It feels right to be here. Did you ever feel that way? Like I feel as if I’m in a groove or some sort of pattern… kinda of like “being in the zone”. It also feels really authentic. I pretty much stopped watching all youtube videos on this subject because all of a sudden they don’t feel at all like they pertain to me. Like the scope was so broad and I feel— there is that feeling again— that I’m narrowing in on something. I know all this is a bunch of conceptual talk but something about all this feels very different than it did a couple weeks ago. And who knows what will happen tomorrow or even a few minutes from now…. but anyways… thanks for all of it.

-Barry

User avatar
vegansatori
Posts: 393
Joined: Sun May 23, 2021 3:35 am

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby vegansatori » Sat Dec 10, 2022 9:15 pm

Hey Barry!
Sorry, it has been, and is going to be, a busy day, so I might not get to respond to all of this tonight.

But I wanted to quickly check in and say that yes, I completely know the feeling that you're going through! I relied on that as a map to know I was in the right place. Honor that. I don't know how it works, but things seem to appear at the right time to let things grow in the right way.

At one point I was obsessed with Angelo's videos, and then I hit a point where I not only wasn't interested, but they felt abrasive and wrong. Not for everyone, just for myself in that moment.

I also think we have a lot in common in that our primary way of navigating the world was always through intellect. And that involved taking in as much information as possible from every possible source. But now you're seeing that intellect is the wrong tool for this job. You don't need to acquire anything new for awakening. You have to divest yourself of all the concepts and illusions you've filled yourself with for your whole life.

This is the emptying out. Awakening is like a huge garage sale. You can get rid of anything that isn't serving you right now. And buying more stuff while you're sorting and emptying the contents of your house is just going to make the task infinite and impossible.

It's a great sign that you feel like things are really changing! It sounds like you're finally seeing these things on a non-conceptual level. Now just keep looking over and over. Reinforce that seeing as much as you can. And do it by cutting off thinking at the root, and just be the awareness, for lack of a better word. It's not quite right, but it points you there. :-)

Selfing is still going to happen for a long time. Maybe years. But you won't be caught up in for as long, and even when you go unconscious like that, you will know immediately after that it happened, and see how much unnecessary bullshit it was.

Keep up the great work, and I'll respond to everything else asap.
Enjoy the rest of your Saturday!
-Todd
That relaxation of the clenched "myself" feels like having been roused from a dream to find oneself alive and aware...Each moment feels fresh, different from any other, and entirely unspeakable...And that is sufficient.- Robert Saltzman

User avatar
vegansatori
Posts: 393
Joined: Sun May 23, 2021 3:35 am

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby vegansatori » Sun Dec 11, 2022 8:54 pm

Hi Barry!
I am typing
I have an itch
I close my eyes
I open my eyes
I feel frustration
I want something
I want to be better at my craft
I want to be a writer
I should be writing
I close my eyes
Typing
Sounds
Breath
Sounds
Sounds
Breath
Sounds
Awaring
Pressure
Sounds
Feeling
Thoughts
Sounds
Black

It has a very calming effect to be without the subject.
It does, right? Do you notice any spaciousness, openness, anything like that in the second group as compared to the first?

Yes. That is much clearer. These are like little tidbits of remembering here. Like oh yeah! I forgot that! Like I’ve treaded over this ground and have forgotten that I’ve seen this already. Tricky thing.
Hahaha, I know! We do that. Something comes in, it’s taken as a nice concept, but then we take in so much other stuff that it gets forgotten. But then eventually it gets seen more clearly and it’s like discovering it all over again.
I see that the ownership is so sneaky. When sounds appear its just sounds and a millisecond later there is the thought of experiencing the sound. But it comes in a way that it makes me think the idea of an experiencer was always there at the start. But it wasn’t! It was a thought very shortly after. AND to make it even trickier its coming in without ownership. It’s like no man, there is no owner of the sound, it’s just happening… but there is someone here experiencing it. FREAKING THOUGHTS!
Excellent!!! Very well seen! Now where do you go with that insight? Where is the self before the labeling/identifying thoughts appear?
But what is it about the awareness itself that says “Hi, I’m Barry!”?
It’s a lie! A multi-layered Ponzi scheme. There is an experience (something via one of the sense gates or a thought), then a thought saying there is something aware of the experience, and then another thought saying that I am that experiencer. All happening in a blink of an eye.
Hahahahaha! So true! Very well said!
I don't know....I need to have a look. I think this is my practice now. The Neti Neti approach. My heart is racing again lol.
Wonderful! Latch on to whichever practice gives you that rush and see where it takes you!
And back. Man, my mind was super active. Serving up stories I want to write. I kept using the “this isn’t me” or “selfing” and another story was served up. Didn’t reach that quiet place but that’s okay. I actually feel pretty happy right now.
That’s okay. You can’t/won’t always be in that quiet place. The purpose is to take advantage when that quiet place appears to see that there is no Barry there. And when thoughts keep getting served up, to do just what you did and notice that you aren’t thinking them, or witnessing them. And for that split second after they’ve been dismissed and seen through, notice that there really is nothing there. Well done!
Yes. Thought Images arise. These images appear where the blackness is. Back to just random things — Characters from stories I want to write or an image of something that I need to do later.
No pair of eyes, nor an ‘I’ / ‘me’ can be found witnessing the blackness. Just blackness with the occasional thought image.
No inherent seer can be found. Nothing to suggest a seer other than a concept/idea/thought.
These are very good! So how does it feel to see this?
Occasionally a thought is “seen.” An overlay over the “actual” seen. Much like a thought overlaying the blackness with eyes closed.

No, an inherent seer cannot be found nor anything that is suggesting a seer. Just a thought telling me but you feel like a seer. This is just a thought. Even the thought that this is just a thought is just a thought.
YES!!! Bang-on!!! And we spend 99% of our lives believing thoughts that are just thinking of thoughts! Lol
There is a thought of “okay so what?’
Looking for identification. A thought of “somethig should happen with this realizations.”
This is just a thought.
There are sounds.
Sensations.
Colors.
More sounds.
Small annoyance to a sound
A story about the sound and why I feel the annoyance. More story.
Selfing.
Sensations
Looking for some sort of shift / realization. More thoughts.
Looking for a “conclusion”. More thoughts
Colors
Sounds.
Selfing continues but there is an okayness with that. There is also a realization that I don’t know how any of this works. I feel like I just swallowed a pill and I don’t know what the effects will be yet. LOL. And I’m okay with that too.
Hahaha, I love this. Yes, we do keep expecting some major shift or realization, but like you so adeptly noticed, that expectation is just another thought that has no ground in “reality” because it’s not happening right now. It’s just a thought about what it wants to happen. What is here right now, in the seeing that yet again your search for a self has come up empty? That there really is nothing there to find? How does that feel before thinking gets involved?

Again, thank you for being so invested in this! In a very real way, I wouldn’t be writing this if you weren’t reading it. My availability is co-arising with your inquiry, and these words are only arising in a sort of dance with your words. Even that is all too dualistic. It really is just all happening together as a beautiful interwoven flow of totality. (for lack of better words) :-)

Keep up the excellent work, and let me know what else you (don’t) find!
-Todd
That relaxation of the clenched "myself" feels like having been roused from a dream to find oneself alive and aware...Each moment feels fresh, different from any other, and entirely unspeakable...And that is sufficient.- Robert Saltzman

User avatar
BarBarryN
Posts: 60
Joined: Fri Aug 13, 2021 5:33 am
Location: Portland, ME USA

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby BarBarryN » Mon Dec 12, 2022 4:15 pm

Good Morning Todd,
Hope you had a good weekend.

So, as you've noticed, I have a tendency to ramble. This is very helpful for me but may be annoying to you.
Going forward, for brevity, would you like me to edit these down before sending them off to you or continue in this manner?

No hurt feelings if you would like me to edit it down :)

I am typing
I have an itch
I close my eyes
I open my eyes
I feel frustration
I want something
I want to be better at my craft
I want to be a writer
I should be writing
I close my eyes
Typing
Sounds
Breath
Sounds
Sounds
Breath
Sounds
Awaring
Pressure
Sounds
Feeling
Thoughts
Sounds
Black

It has a very calming effect to be without the subject.
It does, right? Do you notice any spaciousness, openness, anything like that in the second group as compared to the first?
No I did not notice that. Just an easy rightness. I will continue to play and explore.


I see that the ownership is so sneaky. When sounds appear its just sounds and a millisecond later there is the thought of experiencing the sound. But it comes in a way that it makes me think the idea of an experiencer was always there at the start. But it wasn’t! It was a thought very shortly after. AND to make it even trickier its coming in without ownership. It’s like no man, there is no owner of the sound, it’s just happening… but there is someone here experiencing it. FREAKING THOUGHTS!
Excellent!!! Very well seen! Now where do you go with that insight?
Where do I go? My instinct tells me to go nowhere. To continue to recognizing this when ever this occurs.

Where is the self before the labeling/identifying thoughts appear?
Who knows? No self without label. I'm not even sure what is here without labels. A sound appears and I'm labeling it sound. A sensation appears and I'm labeling it touch. Images appear and I'm labeling it seeing. What is any of this really?
This is still conceptual though. Surprising no frustration comes though. It's like seeing the jail cell for the first time-- not to be too overly dramatic lol.

Just realization that there is something here but I'm just slathering with label after label. I don't how to not apply all these labels to things. My mind is so trained to do this.

Back to your question-- Where is the self before the labeling/identifying thoughts appear? Probably no where.

I know this is a weak answer and I truly wish I could simply say that there is no self before the labeling (I believe there is no self) but I can barely be without any labels.


Yes. Thought Images arise. These images appear where the blackness is. Back to just random things — Characters from stories I want to write or an image of something that I need to do later.
No pair of eyes, nor an ‘I’ / ‘me’ can be found witnessing the blackness. Just blackness with the occasional thought image.
No inherent seer can be found. Nothing to suggest a seer other than a concept/idea/thought.
These are very good! So how does it feel to see this?
I have a thought that says "So what?" and I'm saying this with a smile on my face.
There is a desire to see that this is a big realization, a desire to be a "good" pupil, a desire to x, y, and z. A desire not to be "rude." All these "desires" and social norms just to say nothing feels different "seeing this".

Let me get back to DE.
So how does it feel to see this?

Can't see this in DE. Looking for eyes is all concept. Looing for a seer is also a concept. Even "Looking" is a concept.

Is that true? Is looking a concept? I guess if "seeing" thoughts is DE then, no, that is part of DE. Thoughts simply appear... is that also true?
not sure... Attention moves seemingly all on it's own to a thought. Does thought appear before the attention?
How could it? How could I see a thought and THEN attention moves to it. I wanted to call it MY attention.

Do sounds appear before the attention moves to it?
The old if a tree falls in the forest thing.

Does attention move before an image?
These things seem to happen together. I guess you could say there is only sound when there is sound. There is only thoughts when there are thoughts. LOL.


Hahaha, I love this. Yes, we do keep expecting some major shift or realization, but like you so adeptly noticed, that expectation is just another thought that has no ground in “reality” because it’s not happening right now. It’s just a thought about what it wants to happen. What is here right now, in the seeing that yet again your search for a self has come up empty?
There are still sights, sounds, sensations, etc. DE is still here.


That there really is nothing there to find? How does that feel before thinking gets involved?
I'm finding expectation and letting that go. Thoughts come and I let those go.
Breath.
Thoughts.
Sounds.
Everything is still here. Nothing disappears it's all still right here.
Nothing holding this together (that I can tell). No pushing or pulling.
A story comes. more sensations.
Not searching for a self but searching for a result of finding no self.
The result is Life is still going on. The selfing goes on. The ride continues.

I do recognize a desire, still, to have some sort of conclusion and I'm trying to let that go too.
Until then I'm content where I'm at.


In a very real way, I wouldn’t be writing this if you weren’t reading it. My availability is co-arising with your inquiry, and these words are only arising in a sort of dance with your words.
This is nice to hear-- a nice reminder. Again, if a tree falls in the woods scenario.

Thank you so much for all this. Your co-arising friend,

Barry

User avatar
vegansatori
Posts: 393
Joined: Sun May 23, 2021 3:35 am

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby vegansatori » Tue Dec 13, 2022 2:47 am

Hey Barry!
Thanks for asking, my weekend was good. Dog-sat for three cold and snowy days. :-) But we had fun. How about you?
So, as you've noticed, I have a tendency to ramble. This is very helpful for me but may be annoying to you.
Going forward, for brevity, would you like me to edit these down before sending them off to you or continue in this manner?

On the contrary, I actually find the rambling to be extremely helpful in seeing where you’re at, and how you find your way to different insights. So ramble on (Rose)! (Sorry, Grateful Dead reference…)
It does, right? Do you notice any spaciousness, openness, anything like that in the second group as compared to the first?
No I did not notice that. Just an easy rightness. I will continue to play and explore.
It’s okay, there’s no right or wrong answer here. It’s a pretty common experience, but if you don’t, you don’t. Feel free to keep exploring it though. Some people even make it into a practice to spend portions of each day, or even many days, cutting the words “I/me/my” out of the their vocabulary. Not necessarily suggesting that, but it can be helpful to play with.
Excellent!!! Very well seen! Now where do you go with that insight?
Where do I go? My instinct tells me to go nowhere. To continue to recognizing this when ever this occurs.
Yeah, I didn’t mean to literally go somewhere with it, but keep noticing it every time it becomes obvious. And use that as a wedge to separate identity from thought any time that you can.
Where is the self before the labeling/identifying thoughts appear?
Who knows? No self without label. I'm not even sure what is here without labels.
Yes! Exactly!
A sound appears and I'm labeling it sound. A sensation appears and I'm labeling it touch. Images appear and I'm labeling it seeing. What is any of this really?
This is still conceptual though. Surprising no frustration comes though. It's like seeing the jail cell for the first time-- not to be too overly dramatic lol.
It’s great that you’re not getting frustrated, but don’t get soft on the motivation. Do you want out of the jail cell?

We want to keep sticking with anything that feels for a moment like it might be a self, and then see if it’s just a thought/label. Keep to that! Investigate it deeply, what is it without the label?

What is Barry with no label?

Just realization that there is something here but I'm just slathering with label after label. I don't how to not apply all these labels to things. My mind is so trained to do this.
Totally. Can you create your thoughts? So can you create labels? Right now you just need to keep noticing that labels keep appearing, and notice things in DE without labels automatically attached to them.
Back to your question-- Where is the self before the labeling/identifying thoughts appear? Probably no where.
I know this is a weak answer and I truly wish I could simply say that there is no self before the labeling (I believe there is no self) but I can barely be without any labels.
So what does that tell you? Okay, so let’s drop the logical reasoning. Just tell me, when you notice the feeling of Barry, however and wherever it arises, and you notice those sensations without a label, can you find a self/Barry? Just keep looking until you can say definitively that the self doesn't exist without labels without needing to qualify it with a "probably"!
These are very good! So how does it feel to see this?
I have a thought that says "So what?" and I'm saying this with a smile on my face.
There is a desire to see that this is a big realization, a desire to be a "good" pupil, a desire to x, y, and z. A desire not to be "rude." All these "desires" and social norms just to say nothing feels different "seeing this".
The smile sounds like the more reliable marker in that first sentence. Doubt hasn’t fallen yet, so keep looking. You have expectations, but what are expectations? Thoughts! And who is thinking those thoughts and coming up with the expectations??? And who is believing those expectations??? Keep looking there!
So how does it feel to see this?
Can't see this in DE. Looking for eyes is all concept. Looing for a seer is also a concept. Even "Looking" is a concept.

Is that true? Is looking a concept?
When we talk about it, everything becomes a concept, but that gets us lost in the weeds again. When I tell you to Look in this context, take it at face value. Scan around your experience and see what you find. Don't worry about the label of the activity. Look inside the body, inside experience, at the thoughts and sensations as they arise (and by Look I also mean feel, hear, etc.).
I guess if "seeing" thoughts is DE then, no, that is part of DE.
Noticing that thoughts are arising is DE. The content of an individual thought is not in DE, however. Do you get that? So if you are meditating watching the breath, and suddenly you have a thought about an elephant bouncing on a pogo stick, the fact that a thought suddenly appeared is DE. However the elephant on a pogo stick is not. It’s pure thought-stuff. Is that clear?
Thoughts simply appear... is that also true? not sure...
Can you make a thought appear at will?

Attention moves seemingly all on it's own to a thought. Does thought appear before the attention?
How could it? How could I see a thought and THEN attention moves to it. I wanted to call it MY attention.
Hahahaha, notice how insidious that “My” is! On one hand, we can talk about attention and awareness, and there are practical reasons, especially in meditation, to make the distinction. But in DE you eventually notice that sights, sounds, thoughts, etc are all simply “known” (for lack of a better word) immediately upon their arising.

Your questions imply that there is a separate knowing force called attention which is outside the objects of the mind, and can perceive them. However these are also later insights that don’t necessarily fall with the illusion of self, but they might help break things up.
Do sounds appear before the attention moves to it?
The old if a tree falls in the forest thing.
We’re probably also talking about things which could be answered by neuroscience, but again, that’s not helpful for our purposes here. We only need the technology of 2500 years ago to see through the self! :-)
Does attention move before an image?
These things seem to happen together. I guess you could say there is only sound when there is sound. There is only thoughts when there are thoughts. LOL.
Yes, that is what I was pointing to just before this.
There are still sights, sounds, sensations, etc. DE is still here.
Great. And it will be.
That there really is nothing there to find? How does that feel before thinking gets involved?
I'm finding expectation and letting that go. Thoughts come and I let those go.
Breath.
Thoughts.
Sounds.
Everything is still here. Nothing disappears it's all still right here.
Nothing holding this together (that I can tell). No pushing or pulling.
A story comes. more sensations.
All of the noticing of thoughts is useful.
Not searching for a self but searching for a result of finding no self.
This is maybe not so useful. Every time you notice expectations arising, note them as thought and get back to looking at the task at hand.
The result is Life is still going on. The selfing goes on. The ride continues.
I do recognize a desire, still, to have some sort of conclusion and I'm trying to let that go too.
Until then I'm content where I'm at.
Good, but don’t get too content! You need a bit of fire to continue if you still feel like your understanding is too conceptual.
Thank you so much for all this. Your co-arising friend,
Hahahahaha! It’s always a pleasure! Have a great night, my co-arising friend!
-Todd
That relaxation of the clenched "myself" feels like having been roused from a dream to find oneself alive and aware...Each moment feels fresh, different from any other, and entirely unspeakable...And that is sufficient.- Robert Saltzman

User avatar
BarBarryN
Posts: 60
Joined: Fri Aug 13, 2021 5:33 am
Location: Portland, ME USA

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby BarBarryN » Tue Dec 13, 2022 9:01 pm

Good afternoon Todd.
Glad to hear you had a good weekend. My weekend was very nice. Family left early so most of Sunday was spent in a lazy daze on the couch.

I started writing this around 11am in the morning and wrapped up around 3:00pm.
I already feel like a completely different person... different emotions, different wants. Everything is just so fluid.
Anyways...

On the contrary, I actually find the rambling to be extremely helpful in seeing where you’re at, and how you find your way to different insights. So ramble on (Rose)! (Sorry, Grateful Dead reference…)
Sweet. Ramble will continue.

It’s great that you’re not getting frustrated, but don’t get soft on the motivation. Do you want out of the jail cell?
Oof. To be 100% honest... I don't know. I don't know what's beyond this cell. I want to continue forward but I also don't want to waste your time.
This question is bringing up strange emotions. Not fear... at least not directly on the surface.
There is a bit of a let down feeling. It's like driving to the skydiving school, taking the course, packing up my parachute, getting in the airplane, flying up, and when the door opens... on second thought....

What's stopping me? The unknown?
Is my jail cell comfy?
Am I looking for a reason to be freed? I don't know... selfing.

Thinking back on just a week ago I feel like there have been several little shifts. More honesty with myself. More recognition. And I want to keep that up.
I want to say, "yes I want out!" But out of what? If I'm in a cell what is it made up of? Labels and mind activity? Do I want less of that or none of that? Yes, I suppose I do... Is that even possible? Is that what it would be or would it be something different?

Is it really greener on the other side?
Selfing....


This question has some teeth to it lol.

Can I tell you, in this moment, that I don't know if I want out? I'd like to explore a bit?
I feel like I'm letting you down by just saying that.


I'd like to explore this further.
Who feels this to be true?... in DE....
No one can be found...
There is a feeling in the chest. A weight.

Okay what about the jail cell?... in DE....
LOL there is no jailcell. HAHAHAHAHAHA
OMG i was legit sadden and the next moment I'm laughing.
I'm making this freaking cell up. Labels aren't real. Wow. Wow. Hillarious. Okay. moving on.
Even if there was who is there to trap?

Who is the one that's trapped?... in DE...
Just a recognition of a feeling like something behind the eyes. Recognition of a thought of an experiencer.
That's not DE though... recognition is also conceptual... moving on... back to your question.
Do you want out of the jail cell?
There is no jail cell. Just breath, sounds, images.


We want to keep sticking with anything that feels for a moment like it might be a self, and then see if it’s just a thought/label. Keep to that! Investigate it deeply, what is it without the label?
Can't be written down. Writing it down would be labeling it. What's here is DE which is another label.... maybe one of the most stripped down labels but still a label.
What is Barry with no label?
Barry IS the label. No Label = No Barry.
DE is still here. Things arise and go through a "BARRY" filter.
Is that true?

SOunds.
Touch.
Sounds.
breath.
A memory. A memory that pertains to ME.
Memories from THIS viewpoint. What else?

it feels like MY memory.
Is that true?
It's just a recording, a playback of some past event. A very bad recording one at that. Barely anything to it. Not even "crisp". Kind of murky actually.
Who's taking ownership?
A feeling in the chest.
Who's taking ownership?
No one can be found.
The feeling that it is meant for someone comes after... very very quickly after.
I open my eyes and I see a screen. I don't take ownership of that image. It just appears.
Why then do I take ownership of a memory or a thought? It just appears.
They're personal.... but who cares?
selfing.
sounds.
sounds.
colors.
breath.

what is a memory without a label?
A thought.... what is a thought without a label?
colors and sounds all in the head.

okay moving on...


Can you create your thoughts? So can you create labels?
Whoa.... shit. haha duh! No I can't create a label. That's part of the (very minimal) frustration.
Once an idea or concept is in the head I can't shake it out. It's in there until it's forgotten or if some sort of brain damage occurs.
Maybe. Who knows. This is all conceptual. Back to the breath. colors and sounds.


Just tell me, when you notice the feeling of Barry, however and wherever it arises, and you notice those sensations without a label, can you find a self/Barry?
No I cannot find a self.
Doubt comes. Thoughts come. "You don't really know how to look."
Using DE. There is no language in DE. Just sounds.
Every word is translated into concept. Self is just a word that takes on a different meaning to everyone. No one's "Self" is alike because no one's translation would be alike.
All concept. But in DE there are no labels. With no labels no self/Barry.


And who is thinking those thoughts and coming up with the expectations??? And who is believing those expectations???
Expectations rise all up on their own. Not even that. A thought rises all on their own and labeling it Expectation. Labeling happening all on its own.
The mind doing mind things while the heart doing heart things while the nose does nose things etc etc etc.
So where am I? Again. Thoughts doing thought things. No I. A thought trying to out think a thought LOL.

A thought trying to escape. A thought trying to become enlighted. Poor thing.
Silence.
Sounds. Images. Thoughts starting back up.


Noticing that thoughts are arising is DE. The content of an individual thought is not in DE, however. Do you get that? So if you are meditating watching the breath, and suddenly you have a thought about an elephant bouncing on a pogo stick, the fact that a thought suddenly appeared is DE. However the elephant on a pogo stick is not. It’s pure thought-stuff. Is that clear?
Yes. Thank you!


Thoughts simply appear... is that also true? not sure...
Can you make a thought appear at will?
No I cannot. I guess how they appear doesn't matter. I have no control one way or the other.

Phew. This one... drained me a bit to be honest. I feel lighter though.. in the head. Maybe some things were shaken out... loosened.

Talk with you tomorrow,

-Barry

User avatar
vegansatori
Posts: 393
Joined: Sun May 23, 2021 3:35 am

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby vegansatori » Wed Dec 14, 2022 3:09 am

Hi Barry!
Oh nice! That sounds like a spectacular way to spend a Sunday!
I started writing this around 11am in the morning and wrapped up around 3:00pm.
I already feel like a completely different person... different emotions, different wants. Everything is just so fluid.
Anyways...
First off, I applaud your dedication and time-expenditure on this. And seriously, isn’t it amazing how constantly fluid our experience of everything is when we actually pay attention to it???
It’s great that you’re not getting frustrated, but don’t get soft on the motivation. Do you want out of the jail cell?
Oof. To be 100% honest... I don't know. I don't know what's beyond this cell. I want to continue forward but I also don't want to waste your time.
This question is bringing up strange emotions. Not fear... at least not directly on the surface.
There is a bit of a let down feeling. It's like driving to the skydiving school, taking the course, packing up my parachute, getting in the airplane, flying up, and when the door opens... on second thought....
That hesitation is normal, and could be investigated. Or it could just be noted and ignored while you continue straight past it and see everything for yourself. How do you want to handle it? Is it still there?
Thinking back on just a week ago I feel like there have been several little shifts. More honesty with myself. More recognition. And I want to keep that up.
It certainly sounds that way from my side!
I want to say, "yes I want out!" But out of what? If I'm in a cell what is it made up of? Labels and mind activity? Do I want less of that or none of that? Yes, I suppose I do... Is that even possible? Is that what it would be or would it be something different?
Is it really greener on the other side?
Selfing....
This question has some teeth to it lol.
Can I tell you, in this moment, that I don't know if I want out? I'd like to explore a bit?
I feel like I'm letting you down by just saying that.
You’re never letting me down. You can’t. I just want you to be 100% honest with your feelings and motivation. If you hide inner conflicts or fears, it prolongs things because you are going to need to deal with them, or else they will keep holding you back.
Okay what about the jail cell?... in DE....
LOL there is no jailcell. HAHAHAHAHAHA
OMG i was legit sadden and the next moment I'm laughing.
I'm making this freaking cell up. Labels aren't real. Wow. Wow. Hillarious. Okay. moving on.
Even if there was who is there to trap?
Love this!!! But let that insight REALLY sink in! THERE IS NO JAIL CELL! LABELS ARE NOT REAL! Expand that out. What else is a label that is not real? Can you feel that the idea of a self is the same thing as a jail cell? Like really FEEL that to be the case?
Who is the one that's trapped?... in DE...
Just a recognition of a feeling like something behind the eyes. Recognition of a thought of an experiencer.
That's not DE though... recognition is also conceptual... moving on... back to your question.
Well seen!
Do you want out of the jail cell?
There is no jail cell. Just breath, sounds, images.
Beautiful!
Investigate it deeply, what is it without the label?
Can't be written down. Writing it down would be labeling it. What's here is DE which is another label.... maybe one of the most stripped down labels but still a label.
Fantastic!
What is Barry with no label?
Barry IS the label. No Label = No Barry.
DE is still here. Things arise and go through a "BARRY" filter.
Is that true?
I’d say the Barry filter metaphor works, more or less. It might make the filter itself seem a little too real, though. It’s more like lines of longitude and latitude, or borders between countries on a map. On paper you can see them very clearly, and they appear to be real things. But when you walk in the world, you have never seen a line of longitude or latitude, or even a real country border the way they appear on the map. It’s just one continuous ball that’s being partitioned up by different labels for different needs. Does that make sense?

Another of my favorite metaphors that I'm sure you've heard is the university. What is the university? Is it the dean? The students? One particular building? The name? Any of those things can change, and yet we still consider it to be the same university. The same holds true for the self.
A memory. A memory that pertains to ME.
Memories from THIS viewpoint. What else?

it feels like MY memory.
Is that true?
It's just a recording, a playback of some past event. A very bad recording one at that. Barely anything to it. Not even "crisp". Kind of murky actually.
Who's taking ownership?
A feeling in the chest.
Who's taking ownership?
No one can be found.
The feeling that it is meant for someone comes after... very very quickly after.
I open my eyes and I see a screen. I don't take ownership of that image. It just appears.
Why then do I take ownership of a memory or a thought? It just appears.
They're personal.... but who cares?

what is a memory without a label?
A thought.... what is a thought without a label?
colors and sounds all in the head.
This is all wonderful! How much is conceptual reasoning, and how much really hits you in that way that makes you laugh, or feel like “Oh yeah, of course!!!”?
Can you create your thoughts? So can you create labels?
Whoa.... shit. haha duh! No I can't create a label. That's part of the (very minimal) frustration.
Once an idea or concept is in the head I can't shake it out. It's in there until it's forgotten or if some sort of brain damage occurs.
Maybe. Who knows. This is all conceptual. Back to the breath. colors and sounds.
Excellent work! Yes, there is no one creating thoughts, and no one consciously adopting or utilizing labels. They are impersonal. Very useful for daily functioning, but not something in your control. Again, don't overlook the importance of these insights!
Just tell me, when you notice the feeling of Barry, however and wherever it arises, and you notice those sensations without a label, can you find a self/Barry?
No I cannot find a self.
Doubt comes. Thoughts come. "You don't really know how to look."
Let’s pretend that those doubts are correct for a moment. Do they have any suggestions on how you should be looking? Or what you would see if you looked correctly? Are they implying that there IS a self, but that you’re just not looking in the right place?
Using DE. There is no language in DE. Just sounds.
Every word is translated into concept. Self is just a word that takes on a different meaning to everyone. No one's "Self" is alike because no one's translation would be alike.
All concept. But in DE there are no labels. With no labels no self/Barry.
Very very true! Technically every word doesn’t need to be translated into a concept because every word IS a concept. They are nothing but useful labels for various aspects of experience. Without a label, a word is just noise like a violin note.

Like if you don’t know Arabic, just seeing it written on a page looks like very pretty squiggles, but you get absolutely nothing from it because you can’t even translate the squiggles into meaningless sound, no less actual intelligible words. All of the understanding comes in later.

And again, I love hearing you say over and over that with no labels, there is no self/Barry! Does that feel like an experiential understanding, or is it purely intellectual?
And who is thinking those thoughts and coming up with the expectations??? And who is believing those expectations???
Expectations rise all up on their own. Not even that. A thought rises all on their own and labeling it Expectation. Labeling happening all on its own.
The mind doing mind things while the heart doing heart things while the nose does nose things etc etc etc.
So where am I? Again. Thoughts doing thought things. No I. A thought trying to out think a thought LOL.
Haha, nice.
Thoughts simply appear... is that also true? not sure...
Can you make a thought appear at will?
No I cannot. I guess how they appear doesn't matter. I have no control one way or the other.
Totally true! How does it feel to have no control?
Phew. This one... drained me a bit to be honest. I feel lighter though.. in the head. Maybe some things were shaken out... loosened.
Fantastic to hear this!
I have a video that I was toying with sharing that goes into detail about the functioning of the mind, and kind of clears up a lot of the questions you’ve brought up in the past couple of messages. But I feel like it’s going to put you back in the heady-space again, so I’ll save it for later.

No dessert until after you’ve eaten your veggies! LOL

Do you feel like you’ve seen through the self then, or are there still doubts arising? What more are you expecting to happen at this stage?

Keep up the great inquiry, and let me know what changes.
This has been fun!
-Todd
That relaxation of the clenched "myself" feels like having been roused from a dream to find oneself alive and aware...Each moment feels fresh, different from any other, and entirely unspeakable...And that is sufficient.- Robert Saltzman

User avatar
BarBarryN
Posts: 60
Joined: Fri Aug 13, 2021 5:33 am
Location: Portland, ME USA

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby BarBarryN » Wed Dec 14, 2022 7:20 pm

Good Afternoon Todd!

First off, I applaud your dedication and time-expenditure on this.
Thank you for YOUR time and dedication to this. I quite literally wouldn't be writing any of this if it weren't for you.


That hesitation is normal, and could be investigated. Or it could just be noted and ignored while you continue straight past it and see everything for yourself. How do you want to handle it? Is it still there?
Continue. Straight past it and see for myself.


You’re never letting me down. You can’t. I just want you to be 100% honest with your feelings and motivation. If you hide inner conflicts or fears, it prolongs things because you are going to need to deal with them, or else they will keep holding you back.
Thank you for this. 100% honesty.


Love this!!! But let that insight REALLY sink in! THERE IS NO JAIL CELL! LABELS ARE NOT REAL! Expand that out. What else is a label that is not real? Can you feel that the idea of a self is the same thing as a jail cell? Like really FEEL that to be the case?
I meditated on this. It was not what I at all expected.
Quite easily I was able to reach that stillness. The body melted and all that remained was tension from the eyes up. I may have been rolling my eyes up. I felt it very much behind the eyes and the region described as the third eye. When I meditate I generally focus in this third eye region as it seems to quickly dispel most thoughts.
This place felt quite solid, like a rock and I tried to melt that away as well but could not.

I recognize this is just an experience and not seeing that there is no jail cell though thought it may be pertinent to this conversation or not. Completely disregard if so.
But... back to the jailcell the only thing keeping me solid was that place in the head. Other than that no jail cell, no self in that place.

This is all wonderful! How much is conceptual reasoning, and how much really hits you in that way that makes you laugh, or feel like “Oh yeah, of course!!!”?
About 50/50. I do recognize there is a lot of conceptual in what I'm saying (well 100% when it's actually communicated but you know what I mean)--- but something about that feels really, really right. Like this is just how it has to work for me. I'm conceptually pointing it out to myself and then going there. You're pointing, I'm pointing, and then I dive in.


Let’s pretend that those doubts are correct for a moment. Do they have any suggestions on how you should be looking? Or what you would see if you looked correctly? Are they implying that there IS a self, but that you’re just not looking in the right place?
I believe just another layer and not a big deal. I'm sure I'll have doubt even after "seeing" no self.
Let me even drop that.
There is no self. I can't find anything I'd consider a self other than just "feeling like someone operating separately in a world of other things."
The doubt is just noise.

The feeling like I am someone even though I can't find a someone... yet still feel like someone is.... is... what I'm trying to see through.
But I have to imagine that it's like any other feeling and it just needs to be felt. If I feel sad I should feel sad. I won't always feel sad and I wont always feel like a self... if reasoning serves me correctly.

But I think there are other things I could do. Sorry lots of conceptual in there.

I know that people who have "seen" through this have this common "problem" and it doesn't mean they haven't seen through it.

Let me go back to trusty D.E.
Where do I feel the most like a self? In the head.
Where in the head?
Behind the eyes.

Anywhere else? In the chest?
No.

In my feet?
LOL no.

I know it all goes back to thought. There is sight and then very very quickly there is a feeling of something looking out through the eyes. It's so subtle.
I don't know how to see it any differently other than continue with the questioning, continue looking and meditating.


And again, I love hearing you say over and over that with no labels, there is no self/Barry! Does that feel like an experiential understanding, or is it purely intellectual?
A mix. That experiential understanding is so limited. The gap between the no self/Barry/nothing and labels is so small. An eyeblink. Trusting that in time this gap will widened and I'll be able to take it in more deeply.


Thoughts simply appear... is that also true? not sure...
Can you make a thought appear at will?
No I cannot. I guess how they appear doesn't matter. I have no control one way or the other.
Totally true! How does it feel to have no control?
So far no feelings arise. Control or rather lack their of was one of the main triggers to that fear I spoke of before.
I know I said this before but there is also some untrust with thoughts too (sometimes). Right now I recognize it's a thought that is telling me I have no control.
In DE I don't see control.... LOL what would control even look like in DE?
Hahaha even control is conceptual. No control because no controller and no on to be controlled.

A thought comes about the watcher. Oh geeze now we have a new name for it LOL.
These thoughts are like children. Just coming up to say something.
These thoughts seem to believe in SOMETHING.

Do thoughts believe?
Oh man, I'm not even going there. Its like asking is the sky really blue?
Who the hell knows what thoughts are let alone if they believe LOL.

Okay... no... I can answer this I think.... Thoughts can't believe.
Using DE there is just the recognition of a belief which is just a thought thing. Like a feeling.
Can I feel a belief in DE?

I can feel the effects of when a belief is tested-- fear, anger, anxiety. But those aren't DE either. Those are more labels.
It would look like racing heart, tight chest....

DE right now. Sounds. Tight abdomen. Temperature.

back to your question---
How does it feel to have no control?
Looking for some big realization but none comes. Huh. Oh well. LOL


Do you feel like you’ve seen through the self then, or are there still doubts arising?
Still doubts though I honestly don't know what it would feel like to see through this. I've had small shifts / realizations and what to keep looking and asking.

Doubts arise but there is not stopping a doubt / thought.
I don't believe them as much these last few days.

I still feel very much like "Barry".
Hmmm... what does "Barry" feel like?
He's constantly changing. He's not even a He. Just another label.

Barry has a bunch of likes and dislikes.
What does it FEEL like to be "Barry?"

body sensations.

Breath color and smells. Sounds. Searching. Thoughts.
Lots of mind activity.


What more are you expecting to happen at this stage?
I don't know. All I know is I want to continue.


I have to say, I'm loving these questions and looking. It feels like I had some back room closed off for years and I'm finally going in there to clean it out.
I have no idea what I'm going to find / throw out. I have no idea if it's going to lead to enlightenment or no self or whatever but for the first time I don't even care. It just feels good to get in there and look around.

Thanks for everything

Barry


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot], bluzulu, Jeffelan and 20 guests