Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5866
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Postby vinceschubert » Sat Sep 24, 2016 2:19 pm

Good evening Dan,
I have great difficulty in being mindful these days for any length of time,
Tell me if this (next statement) puts a dent in your expectations.
It is neither desirable nor useful to be always mindful.
The time to be mindful is when you are operating from habit, and that habit is moving you away from health and happiness.
The organism has developed a whole swag of useful subroutines that happen automatically. Like putting your shoes on.
What is mindfulness ? It is being aware that thoughts (and their consequences) are happening. What is being aware ? Is it thoughts happening about other thoughts ?
Are you able to control your thoughts ? Can you tell which ones to occur ?
From my reading of your posts, i would say that you have a pretty good handle on this stuff. It's the depression that is the stick in the ointment. Do you have expectations that it will disappear when some magical enlightenment happens ?
i tell you one thing. If you are doing this looking for that one outcome, then there is a good chance that it won't happen.
Now here's the paradox. You (probably) won't wake up if you are focussed on the depression, and therefore this won't cure it.
But if you do wake up, then there's a really good chance that the depression will alleviate.
The suffering component will evaporate when it is recognized as happening.
It is impossible to say how being okay with everything that happens, will change the physical component of depression, but there are studies...
Entertaining thoughts? My depression keeps pretty much any of these from coming in,
Yes, it's pretty difficult to experience humor when you feel like shit. ..but here's something that might help. The organism isn't self destructive. If you're feeling crap, or sick, it is the best attempt to cope with what is encountered. As maladaptive as it may seem, the organism always strives to get to what it knows as normal.
I feel perfectly comfortable just acknowledging this limit of my thoughts.
i think that this is a particularly useful thing for you. You are wordy and cerebral.
To remind yourself that nothing can be known, and that THIS (including feeling depressed) is IT.
It is the stories that arrive to overlay THIS, that is the beginning of suffering.
By the time you notice what is happening, it is already a done deal. It is finished. It can't be changed.
So what is the least resistive position to take ? Acceptance. Surrender.
A welcoming of what is here. Of what has happened. This gives the best chance for the next happening to be uncorrupted by a desire for it to be different.
I figure now I experience life as duality, and my experience will be different when I see that the self is an illusion because it will be non-dual,
Hahaha. Do you think that duality is bad and non duality is good ?
Get this; Non-duality encompasses duality. Oneness includes everything. All that IS, includes all that isn't.
These are concepts that will frazzle your brain. Forget them. The mind doesn't have the capacity to understand infinity (or non-duality)
it will be non-dual, like my one-time experience that I tuned into hearing a sound and it became my entire field of experience.
Yes, a great experience. ..but everything is impermanent, so how could it last. ..and would you be able to navigate daily life in that state ?

love

vince
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whitey1022
Posts: 19
Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am

Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Postby whitey1022 » Sat Sep 24, 2016 11:27 pm

Wow. Pointing looks like it’s quite a commitment! :) looking forward to hearing from you as always
It is neither desirable nor useful to be always mindful.
The time to be mindful is when you are operating from habit, and that habit is moving you away from health and happiness.
The organism has developed a whole swag of useful subroutines that happen automatically. Like putting your shoes on.
What is mindfulness ? It is being aware that thoughts (and their consequences) are happening. What is being aware ?
When I say “for any length of time” I mean time that I’ve set aside for mindful meditation. I would decide for whatever reason that I wanted to do it, and then I’d sit down and do it until a useful thought arrived (funny to say, just sifting through mounds of thought until ANYTHING remotely useful surfaced. Haha, to laugh at the excess of certain aspects of “the happening” like that.). I can’t do that anymore, I’m too restless and agitated. That’s what I meant. But I have also tried to be mindful all the time as well.

This does put a dent in, or at least make a new impression on my expectations. Neither desirable nor useful…okay, I always just assumed it was both but I can see how that might not be true. It’s like the useful thoughts we were talking about versus the rubbish ones…thoughts CAN be useful, so it’s not delusional to evaluate a thought after some meditation and decide it’s worth acting on because of how it contributes to the things you value in life. This is where I’ve gotten lost often, confusing mindfulness for nihilism, a common pitfall I’m sure. But I think it was because I expected it to relieve my depression completely.

The shoes…this is very interesting. There’s no reason to be mindful of your tying your shoes because you already do it as fast as you can automatically…and we can safely conclude there is no more of interest to experience in this activity. That’s one place where our agreements diverge from some Buddhist ideas that I’ve believed that teach that EVERYTHING is an illusion, so EVERYTHING you know is not just “not known by you”, but is definitively WRONG. So you can choose to let your mind wander into what’s going to happen when you get where you’re going, or be mindful of the sounds in the room, or just let the rubbish thoughts run as long as they’re doing no harm and you’re enjoying yourself. Kind of like letting a dog wander on a leash because you know you can still discipline it when you need to- there’s flexibility and play in the relationship, an authoritative relationship but not authoritarian.

So “awareness of the flow of thoughts”/mindfulness is a tool and does not NEED to be sought as a permanent insight, at the very least for our purposes here. Some people who like to sit cross-legged with their eyes closed a lot might pursue a more frequent use of it, but that doesn’t mean that their preferences are appropriate for my life. (See this is trouble for me, BECAUSE of depression I think. I still personalize it just because it’s natural to do when I’m told I have a disease that no one can see and that I confuse for a part of my personality. So I try to fix the WHOLE thing behaviorally. And that has meant for me basically charging every moment with an enlightenment type of experience, because to just shoot for any kind of normal life, I’ve tried that and it doesn’t work for me. So this might be an intuitive “duh” thing to a lot of people but this is learning for me.)

One of the traits of awareness is that in it there is a plain recognition that the idea of a “self” is yet more content of thought, and we know how to treat content of thought.

Do you have expectations that it will disappear when some magical enlightenment happens ?
i tell you one thing. If you are doing this looking for that one outcome, then there is a good chance that it won't happen.
I don’t think it will disappear exactly, I don’t expect to wake up in someone else’s mind. I have in the past, but I’m comfortable enough with how my mind works at this point that I don’t imagine much will be different in thought, belief, desired behavior, humor, etc. But I do imagine, simply, that I will no longer be or feel disabled by it. This is to say, well, the suffering. And the thing about the suffering is that it has been OVERWHELMING. I was reading an old journal entry the other day, and I saw my phrasing of my depression as meta-suffering. The suffering is too much to bear when it’s happening, and it happens too often for me to bear. Too much too-muchness. When I’ve been overwhelmed, which has never been far off, there has been no question that EVERYTHING must be immediately and forever put on hold until I find a way to make that NEVER happen again. Because that overwhelming takes every relief away from me. That’s how it’s disabled me.

I have been able to make use of mindfulness whenever I’ve had a headache to a certain extent, usually, which I’m surprised by. I focus on the sensations. People say “yea but if you’re just doing it to make it go away that’s not mindfulness.” Fine. It’s meditation, or just concentration, but it’s more magic than concentration, because insofar as I am able to pay attention and feel the sensations, there is no suffering. It’s trying to ignore it or wish it away that causes all the suffering. Otherwise, pain is just a sensation like pleasure, an event. So I imagine my experience of depression will be something like this, and that meta-suffering will eventually recede to just become one level of pain from depression, that is MANAGEABLE, without me wishing with everything for a way out, and not caring at all if I live or die.

As maladaptive as it may seem, the organism always strives to get to what it knows as normal.
Yes, I read that depression is a defense mechanism to numb the constant messages of stress and distress that the mind is creating/receiving, because otherwise I’d be in a constant state of panic. Learning things like this doesn’t make me feel any better, but fortunately I have been feeling positive in a way that hasn’t happened for this long in perhaps months. It could be a fluke or it could be a medication that I’ve just started that supposedly has worked for me in the past.

i think that this is a particularly useful thing for you. You are wordy and cerebral.
To remind yourself that nothing can be known, and that THIS (including feeling depressed) is IT.
It is the stories that arrive to overlay THIS, that is the beginning of suffering.
By the time you notice what is happening, it is already a done deal. It is finished. It can't be changed.
So what is the least resistive position to take ? Acceptance. Surrender.
A welcoming of what is here. Of what has happened. This gives the best chance for the next happening to be uncorrupted by a desire for it to be different.
This sounds good. I’ll be working with this now.

Do you think that duality is bad and non duality is good ?
Well, when I had not so many years behind me I trusted my intuition/gut more uncritically and my gut was a pedal-to-the-metal tribal revivalist, i.e. hippie. Since then, more than self-indulgence, I’ve sought resolution and reconciliation with the general world population and with the concept of civilization. What I said earlier about my interest in Marshall McLuhan’s ideas about the effects of media has transformed my view completely, in principle at least, to acknowledge that civilization, just like pre- and post-civilization, has its benefits and its drawbacks, and “dualist” concepts are a product of civilization and as such also have their benefits and drawbacks. McLuhan used the words “figure” and “ground” to talk about these things.

The mind doesn't have the capacity to understand infinity (or non-duality)
I believe you’re right that the non-duality is as incomprehensible as infinity is to the mind, with the exception perhaps within the state of a mystical experience. I don’t plan on having any of those anytime soon, so I will put these concepts aside.

Would you be able to navigate daily life in that state?
This occurred to me once vaguely and fleetingly, I wasn’t very interested by it, but you make a good point with this. I can imagine it being very difficult to do so.

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5866
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Postby vinceschubert » Tue Sep 27, 2016 7:37 am

Good morning Dan,
Wow. Pointing looks like it’s quite a commitment! :)
Nah. i've never considered how long i might do it for, or under what circumstances i might stop. The rewards (my own 'deepening') are considerable, which keeps me at it.
looking forward to hearing from you as always
Well, something must be working.
I can’t do that anymore, I’m too restless and agitated.
A thought arrived saying that even if you do it for 1 or 2 minutes, it would be beneficial.
That’s what I meant.
..got it.
Kind of like letting a dog wander on a leash because you know you can still discipline it when you need to- there’s flexibility and play in the relationship, an authoritative relationship but not authoritarian.
Yes, but it's still valuable to bring the dog to a formal heel posture, frequently. Conditioning is everything with this stuff.
But I think it was because I expected it to relieve my depression completely.
Ah, this is a big one. There are a couple of things to reflect on here. One is that what might happen with the depression, is a story. It can't actually be known. Recognizing that you have entered story is THE most valuable thing that could happen. This is what changes everything.
The second is that by calling it "my depression", two things happen. It is owned. Possessed. (which, of course, is bullshit) and secondly that it is an objective thing that has independence. (also bullshit)
If you refer to the sensations that are present (or that you remember) and not to the depression, then conditioning will change.
Because that overwhelming takes every relief away from me.
Yes, "relief" is the story, and attempting to attain it is suffering. Failing it is overwhelming.
Have you tried completely surrendering, when it happens ?
Learning things like this doesn’t make me feel any better,
i wonder if it might help with surrendering ?
One of the traits of awareness is that in it there is a plain recognition that the idea of a “self” is yet more content of thought
If this is recognized experientially, then what is next is to recognize that whatever is currently being experienced (THIS) is IT.
That is, a metaphorical IT. Nothing objective, just WHAT IS. Everything else (if there is an else) is a mystery, and not worth deliberating on. (other than the useful stuff)
fortunately I have been feeling positive in a way that hasn’t happened for this long in perhaps months.
Although it is story, i would hope that the physical hormone balance in the body is changing for the better.
Celebrating each recognition with a laugh stimulates the release of oxytocin, which certainly helps this.


love

vince
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whitey1022
Posts: 19
Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am

Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Postby whitey1022 » Sun Nov 06, 2016 3:34 am

I can and have been doing mindfulness and meditation quite often in the past week and a half. Briefly I got the notion to be aware of my emotional state. This quickly became an overwhelming task again because it was too complex and uncomfortable to try to cover with my attention. I continue to be able to use walking meditation and other meditation on physical sensations like hearing and bodily sensations, meditation on my breath (the sound sometimes and the bodily feeling other times), mindfulness of others’ speech and of the verbal exchange between myself and others, focusing on the meaning in both cases and not just the sounds, and from time to time mindfulness of the general situation I’m in. Finally, I’ve been eating mindfully, deliberately noticing taste to appreciate the flavor of what’s in my mouth instead of just relentlessly shoveling more in. The general process is that I locate the center of my attention and if there is no prominent/obvious one to be found then I choose one and attend to that.
Recognizing that you have entered story is THE most valuable thing that could happen. This is what changes everything.
Referring to the sensations that are present in the heat of a meltdown seems unachievable, but a meltdown just happened and to break the cycle of dwelling on and reminding myself of how “everything” is wrong I laid down to meditate. This wasn’t during the hottest heat of it, but it was during crisis nonetheless and it wasn’t a minute after I laid down that I was calm and remembering a quote from a book on depression that became very useful in stabilizing me.
Have you tried completely surrendering, when it happens?
As for surrendering, the only strategy I can conceive to surrender more involves suicidal fantasies. I’ve pretty much laid down and completely let it take over my life for a long time. I don’t foresee that remembering that the body is just trying to normalize itself will enable a helpful surrender.
If this is recognized experientially, then what is next is to recognize that whatever is currently being experienced (THIS) is IT.
That is, a metaphorical IT. Nothing objective, just WHAT IS. Everything else (if there is an else) is a mystery, and not worth deliberating on. (other than the useful stuff)
Then perhaps it is time to try again to apply mindfulness to thought. When I’ve done this in the past, it seems to me that the only way to recognize thought/story as such is from the perspective of another identifying-as-self thought. So then I recognize THAT thought as such and so on.
Celebrating each recognition with a laugh
Yes. This is the child-like, innocent, existential laugh of man.

User avatar
whitey1022
Posts: 19
Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am

Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Postby whitey1022 » Sun Nov 06, 2016 3:39 am

I didn’t mean to quote
Recognizing that you have entered story is THE most valuable thing that could happen. This is what changes everything.
I meant to quote the following.
If you refer to the sensations that are present (or that you remember) and not to the depression, then conditioning will change.
But in reference to the “Recognizing…” quote I am happy to see this definition of THE most valuable thing. I’ll remember this.

User avatar
whitey1022
Posts: 19
Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am

Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Postby whitey1022 » Sun Nov 06, 2016 8:49 pm

Quoted from my the first of these three replies...
I continue to be able to use...from time to time mindfulness of the general situation I'm in
I was doing this today as I drove and listened to music and enjoyed the autumn scenery, and I want to point out that my awareness includes my body. I call it my self, but in this conceptual mindfulness I include my body. I realize now when I use the word "conceptual" that although this is still mindfulness (paying attention on purpose), it is not Direct Experience. While it happens I tell myself the story "I am driving in the car and listening to music and enjoying the autumn scenery". The effect of this is that I feel more present and relaxed. I bring all this up because I imagined after doing this that this must be the closest I've come to what it is to be liberated from the story of self- Being purely an observer in the drama.

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5866
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Postby vinceschubert » Mon Nov 07, 2016 1:25 pm

Good evening Dan,
this is still mindfulness (paying attention on purpose), it is not Direct Experience.
Woudn't it be direct experience of thoughts ? (as opposed to being lost in their content)
While it happens I tell myself the story "I am driving in the car and listening to music and enjoying the autumn scenery".
..and do you see yourself telling the story ? ..or something else ?
I bring all this up because I imagined after doing this that this must be the closest I've come to what it is to be liberated from the story of self- Being purely an observer in the drama.
Yes. The observer (the witness), if active without judgement about the drama (though often amused) is certainly awake enough to recognize the dream state.
I can and have been doing mindfulness and meditation
Really good stuff. You can't be lost in the dream and mindful at the same time. A great bonus of this is that you will see how conditioning happens.
it wasn’t a minute after I laid down that I was calm and remembering a quote from a book on depression that became very useful in stabilizing me.
This will get easier and easier. If you attach that feeling of calmness to particular parts of the body, recognize specific sensations associated with it, then the time will come when just remembering will bring about the state of calmness.
As for surrendering,
Hmm, surrendering, in the way i meant it, isn't a 'giving in'. It's not a victim state. By surrender, i mean a recognition that what you are experiencing has already happened.
It means nothing about what has yet to happen.
It is a willing acceptance (no resistance.) A welcoming of what is finished and therefor can't be changed.
Really, a welcoming that this is recognized.
It is a stepping out of the dream, and into the witness state.

love

vince
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whitey1022
Posts: 19
Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am

Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Postby whitey1022 » Thu Nov 10, 2016 5:10 am

I think I’ve got it.
Wouldn't it be direct experience of thoughts ? (as opposed to being lost in their content)
OK, then this is mindfulness. I am paying attention on purpose to this thought, and when I catch my mind wandering I return to this thought. And by your explanation of Direct Experience of thought, it qualifies as this as well.
..and do you see yourself telling the story ? ..or something else ?
Well I don’t think I see myself telling the story, but such a story of “I’m sitting in the car, driving, listening to music, appreciating the scenery” is judgment-free. It is pure attention on my perception. I am in the moment, prepared for anything that happens next.

It’s very clear when I’m practicing mindfulness/meditation, at the moment I snap out of the trance of living in the content-drama (the dream state)- transported as if in that scenario NOW- that I was just under a spell (though this isn’t necessarily always a bad thing) and am now am back at the present moment. Witness is a good word, it’s like a Sherlock Holmes experience- Calmly scanning and stopping here or there, waiting patiently for something to jump out and become the focus of attention. It is recognizing that attention/consciousness/I am a witness to my entire perceptive input and that thoughts and emotions are just two parts of what composes that reality.

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5866
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Postby vinceschubert » Fri Nov 11, 2016 12:55 pm

Good evening Dan,
I am paying attention on purpose to this thought,
Would it be more accurate to say; "there is a thought about the first thought. There is a story about having had control of which thoughts arise.
when I catch my mind wandering I return to this thought.
How does the "catching" happen.
What part does Intention play in it ?
Does "return to this thought" happen. Is it controlled, or does the thought about returning just arise (for reasons too complex to know)
Is there a thought about returning, or does returning happen (first) ?
t is pure attention on my perception. I am in the moment,
Excellent.
Is there a commentary on what is being perceived ?
Do you think that it is possible to be 'In the moment', without being aware of being in the moment ? (that is that there is no commentary about it. Describing it. Labeling it.
Dan, have a go at these questions;
1) Is there a separate entity 'self', 'me' 'I', at all, anywhere, in any way, shape or form? Was there ever?

2) "Describe your experience of the illusion of separate self, how it arises/disappears. Is that process always the same, or does it vary, and if so, how?"

3) How does it feel to see this? What is the difference from before you started this dialogue? Please report from the past few days.

4) What was the last bit that pushed you over, made you look?

5) Do you decide, intend, choose, control events in Life? Do you make anything happen? Give examples from your experience.

6) Anything to add?

vince
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whitey1022
Posts: 19
Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am

Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Postby whitey1022 » Sun Nov 13, 2016 4:45 am

Hey Vince
4) What was the last bit that pushed you over, made you look?
I don’t think I looked. And going by the answer to question 1 I didn’t see. I’m just talking about an extension of the practice of mindfulness that I’d been doing. 1) pick anything and put your attention on it alone. 2) find something that actually captures your attention and attend to it alone. 3) bring your attention to the mix of perceptions in the present moment. 4) Follow wherever the highest stimulation leads, moment-to-moment. Once found, attend to it.
1) Is there a separate entity 'self', 'me' 'I', at all, anywhere, in any way, shape or form? Was there ever?
I just have no idea about that. I have nothing to say about the no-self language of this insight. I don’t sense a “self” when I feel I’m in the moment but I have the same old exceptions to that statement- I don’t know what a “self” looks or feels like, so I wouldn’t make any claim about knowing anything about its existence. Moreover my intuition outsources such a question to science and comes up with the old, “I don’t experience my neurons in any immediate way but that doesn’t mean they don’t exist”. If we're only talking about what exists in experience, because the whole "self" concept is exclusively experiential, then I'd have to say again that I don't feel like my search for a self was even very thorough, let alone exhaustive. I would outsource such a search to an expert of mental experience like a Buddhist to tell me how to look for it, but I guess that's what we're doing here.
2) "Describe your experience of the illusion of separate self, how it arises/disappears. Is that process always the same, or does it vary, and if so, how?"
The mindfulness I'm practicing does offer a stabilizing peace, a release of the pressure cooker that my mind can become. It’s not profound but it is real and useful. And the whole thing is generally uneventful. It’s not immediately apparent that there’s much significance, certainly not anything spiritual, to the whole acknowledgment that the thoughts and feelings of the body that I’m chained like a ghost to (see the movie Heart and Souls) are equal in truth-weight as sources of experience to sights, sounds, etc. And I can survey any part of the present input from any of these sources and not be trapped in the judgment patterns of my mind/thoughts. Though I said it’s not immediately apparent that this is a spiritual way of being, I can imagine it becoming so in the future.
Would it be more accurate to say; "there is a thought about the first thought. There is a story about having had control of which thoughts arise.
I think it would be more accurate to say that.
How does the "catching" happen.
There’s a sudden awareness of a given thought, an awareness that feels like it holds more options. I want to be clear though that just because this awareness holds more options doesn’t mean it feels spiritual or profound, because the moment after I become aware in this way, I start to judge or reject the thought and strategize about how to get away from it or stop it from coming up again.
What part does Intention play in it ?
Intention plays absolutely no part in it, as far as I can see, whether or not I decided to be mindful sometime before getting lost in thought. Intention, which is the referencing of a thought that I keep in my toolbox to direct myself back to the behavior of mindfulness, may come up immediately after the “catching”, but only after.
Does "return to this thought" happen. Is it controlled, or does the thought about returning just arise (for reasons too complex to know)
Is there a thought about returning, or does returning happen (first) ?
There is a thought about returning, ALMOST every time, I think, BEFORE there is the returning. And I guess from analysis I'd say that the thought about returning just arises.
Is there a commentary on what is being perceived ?
There is no commentary at all
Do you think that it is possible to be 'In the moment', without being aware of being in the moment ? (that is that there is no commentary about it. Describing it. Labeling it.
I don’t think that is possible, to answer the first question. I’m not sure what you mean by the parentheses part. If you're setting "being aware of being in the moment" equal to having a "commentary about it. Describing it. Labeling it." then I'm confused, I didn't think they were the same thing.
3) How does it feel to see this? What is the difference from before you started this dialogue? Please report from the past few days.
It’s really comforting at the moment, but I think that’s a real understatement to the kind of peace that such a sustained comfort level will become. It’s a reliable way to handle situations well and wisely, and it’s always available, and it seems like it taps into a very stable way of navigating the human experience.
Before I started this dialogue I was used to dealing with a lot of solutions that were theoretically brilliant and strong and capable and wise and compassionate but that couldn’t survive more than a few days’ worth of use. I’m still unsure of this and I’ve been made a fool countless times by believing in one or another “fixes” to my tumultuous life experience with depression and anxiety only to have them collapse. But this one seems to continue delivering. For me, peace- and I mean a very reasonable level of peace, enough to be sane- and stability are too good to be true, so I’ll just keep working this until it works no more. Hopefully that day never comes, and hopefully my practice will just grow my “skillful means” and well-being.
I’ve had quite a mood change, unrelated to this exchange, since we started and my mind has always been a bit hectic and hazy anyway so it’s hard to describe any changes exactly.
5) Do you decide, intend, choose, control events in Life? Do you make anything happen? Give examples from your experience.
Yea I definitely didn’t “see”. As far as I can tell you don’t decide, intend, etc. but I have no examples from my experience that I can recall, only from theory.
6) Anything else?
I’d like to say here that I’ve kept up with the mindfulness of the present situation and I’ve really opened up to that Sherlock Holmes image- When I’m stressed or just otherwise inclined to be mindful, I kind of relax to let myself locate where my attention already is. So say I’m feeling annoyed by sound of the wind through the trees. That means that one kind of my attention has already been grabbed by that sound, and mindfulness is bringing the other kind of my attention to where the first kind of attention already is, in this case to the sound. This could happen with pleasure too, and in a true detective fashion, I utilize this process even when I don’t know where my attention is and I just know I’m stressed or that I want to be mindful. It still works. I could bring my attention to somewhere as vague as “the white noise in my mind” or just “a general emotionality”, and still I feel I’m present. I just try to find where it leads and I follow. This is less stressful than trying to push or pull my attention this way or that.

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5866
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Postby vinceschubert » Sun Nov 13, 2016 1:58 pm

Hey Dan,
I don’t think I looked. And going by the answer to question 1 I didn’t see.
Oh, ok. i got it wrong.
I don't feel like my search for a self was even very thorough, let alone exhaustive.
No matter how exhaustive you search, you know that an actual self will be as illusive as that unicorn.
If you don't find one, it could be because it isn't there, or you simply couldn't find it.
If you know the difference between actual experience and concept (about stuff), then you will recognize that everything that you know about your self is concept. It's memory and projection, ABOUT the main character in the story. You.
Are you with me so far ? Does it resonate ? (or is there some jarring, that says "no that isn't right".)
..and then you will also recognize that the whole world is so completely filtered by the conditions that have lead to you being you at this moment in time, that even the whole world is purely your version of it.
..am i going too far ?
What are your thoughts on this ?

love

vince
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whitey1022
Posts: 19
Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am

Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Postby whitey1022 » Tue Nov 15, 2016 5:06 pm

You’re not going too far at all, I’m with you 100% on this. This first part about concept seems very realistic and doable. Once I get the feel for actual experience, I’ll be able to tell that apart easily from concept, at the very least in a looking-back way, and I’ll be able to see that everything I associate with my self is concept…memory and projection ABOUT the instances of actual experience. But the un-wordable immediate quality of actual or direct experience isn’t present in the story of the self and vice versa.

This resonates.

I accept what you say here too about noticing the inherent subjectivity of our experience of what we call objective realities like “the whole world”.

:)

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5866
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Postby vinceschubert » Wed Nov 16, 2016 8:39 pm

Good morning Dan,
This first part about concept seems very realistic and doable. Once I get the feel for actual experience, I’ll be able to tell that apart easily from concept,
Ok, good.
Now here's the bad news.
You're actual direct experience is very fleeting. As a sensory input reaches the brain, it is overlaid by concept. It is interpreted to mean something.
Now here's the good news. With a simple addition of recognition that a concept has arisen, you will be having direct experience of thought (that concept)
Along with that recognition that this happened, another thought will happen, saying that the concept may or may not be accurate. (often that thought will give rise to great humor as the ridiculousness of the concept is seen)
This then becomes a condition of change. Different processes will start to emerge.
i imagine that this is already happening to you. Is this so ?
I’ll be able to tell that apart easily from concept, at the very least in a looking-back way
Yes, absolutely.
Don't underestimate the value of that telling (recognition) as it is what leads to the brain pathways that are a developing skill. If you celebrate that recognition with a laugh, you will accelerate that learning incredibly. (it doesn't matter if that "looking back" happens days later)
But the un-wordable immediate quality of actual or direct experience isn’t present
Yes, the belief in the conceptual (the interpretation of experience) tends to cloud the actual experience. Once the bit that says 'this may or may not be accurate', kicks in, the actual becomes better perceived.
I accept what you say here too about noticing the inherent subjectivity of our experience of what we call objective realities like “the whole world”.
Are you noticing this ?

love

vince
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info

User avatar
whitey1022
Posts: 19
Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 11:06 am

Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Postby whitey1022 » Fri Nov 18, 2016 4:43 pm

Hi Vince, Love to you :)
With a simple addition of recognition that a concept has arisen, you will be having direct experience of thought (that concept)
When I’ve tried to notice thoughts, I’ve naturally tried a formal recognition of concepts as such. I said earlier in this exchange that I had trouble with this because it seemed that I could only recognize a concept as such from the point of view of another concept (like one about how mindfulness is good or conceptualization is illusion or delusion), and so I gave it up because I would try to recognize as concept the motivation for the initial recognition and so on. I expected to short-circuit my thoughts and jump into a pure witness state, if even for a moment or two. This never happened and I would just repeat this recognition process until I felt mentally dizzy from it.
So maybe now, while practicing mindfulness at least, I’ll scan for sensory input, and once I can notice some concept that follows it I’ll formally recognize it as thought-guesses or story/concept, and then I’ll evaluate its accuracy (and I’m sure I will have some good laughs at how hyper-reactive the mind is in leaping to conclusions). I won’t try to keep recognizing every possible concept that might be present in my mind in any way. Then after I settle on a concept's accuracy, I’ll return to scanning for sensory input.
i imagine that this is already happening to you. Is this so ?
I’m not noticing the ridiculousness of any concepts these days. I've been playing “follow the leader”, which is to say “bringing my on-purpose attention to where my automatic attention is”. Finding where one’s attention is moment-to-moment is an intensely full-time task, so there was never any inclination to differentiate a concept from a sensory stimulus or to connect the appearance of the two. ALSO, importantly, I felt that the real value in “follow the leader” is in the ability to do it at the “SPEED OF THOUGHT”. I hope you have something to say about this because I think I put a lot of pressure on myself to be attentive at this speed, when maybe I can afford to be more relaxed and deliberate in noticing sensory input (would memory of sensory input still be considered concept even when the memory seems as crystal clear as the initial input? Because when I described a “oneness with sounds” earlier in this exchange I mentioned how impossibly difficult it was to actually hear sounds as they happened. I seemed to always have to rely on a very recent memory of them no matter how closely I tried to listen.), in recognizing the concept that follows it as such, and in lingering on the difference between those two or just on evaluation of the concept's accuracy.
Are you noticing this?
No, not lately. This is just something I’ve acknowledged in past existential thinking.

-Dan

User avatar
vinceschubert
Posts: 5866
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 11:02 am
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Will you help me recognize the (intellectual?) nature of the “self”?

Postby vinceschubert » Sat Nov 19, 2016 12:20 pm

Good evening Dan,
Hi Vince, Love to you :)
Mmmm, nice. Thank you.
When I’ve tried to notice thoughts, I’ve naturally tried a formal recognition of concepts as such.
Ok, we are really close here. Forget the recognition of concept. Just accept that every thoughts content is concept.
Instead of considering the content of a thought, just notice the fact that a thought has happened. This is direct experience of the thought. The moment you consider what it is about, you are lost in concept.
The only time that it is appropriate to actually contemplate the content of thoughts, is if it comes with a tag that says it is a useful thing to do. Once this is integrated, then you might also add that sometimes it is entertaining to notice content. (but save that for later)
I would try to recognize as concept the motivation for the initial recognition and so on.
Yes, this is a mind trick to keep you away from the discomfort of uncertainty.
Our minds are conditioned to seek familiarity in satisfactory explanations and descriptions.
Just accept that 95% of what happens arises out of mystery. (and passes back into mystery)
Then after I settle on a concept's accuracy,
Yes, good. ..but only bother with this if it is tagged as useful. (or entertaining)
Finding where one’s attention is moment-to-moment is an intensely full-time task
Yes, absolutely. So allowing the mental chatter to become background 'white noise', brings great freedom of attention and energy.
ALSO, importantly, I felt that the real value in “follow the leader” is in the ability to do it at the “SPEED OF THOUGHT”.
Hmm, i'm not sure about "value", but i have noticed that some of this stuff seems to happen instantly. It is like a whole book can be seen in one flash. ..but then to consider what is seen, it is like using memory to inspect the details. ..or it happens in 'real' time. (the inspection, that is)
i think that the "value" in this is the trust in what you might label intuition, that is developed with practice.
when maybe I can afford to be more relaxed and deliberate in noticing sensory input
For sure.
If you've ever noticed a pro golfer, they seem really relaxed when they swing the club. To put effort into the swing actually limits the outcome. It is counter-intuitive to exert discipline.
would memory of sensory input still be considered concept even when the memory seems as crystal clear as the initial input?
Is it ABOUT it ? Yes it is concept, but a good use of concept.
when I described a “oneness with sounds” earlier in this exchange I mentioned how impossibly difficult it was to actually hear sounds as they happened. I seemed to always have to rely on a very recent memory of them no matter how closely I tried to listen.
Ha. Excellent. You have stumbled onto something really valuable here.
Direct experience is impossible to describe or communicate without concept.
It is immediately swamped by overlaying (the concept of) meaning.
The outcome of this is that our whole life is lived in concept. Appearance is conceptual. Nothing is real or actual that we can describe.
Everything that is noticed is a memory. The actual is already finished by the time mind is aware of it.
It is the recognition of this that brings great freedom.
The 5% that is useful takes up very little time or energy. This frees great resources that result in focus on what is actual. (direct experience without the need to describe or judge)

love

vince
liberation starts with recognising some illusions

http://www.1ness.info


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 55 guests