Wow. Pointing looks like it’s quite a commitment! :) looking forward to hearing from you as always
It is neither desirable nor useful to be always mindful.
The time to be mindful is when you are operating from habit, and that habit is moving you away from health and happiness.
The organism has developed a whole swag of useful subroutines that happen automatically. Like putting your shoes on.
What is mindfulness ? It is being aware that thoughts (and their consequences) are happening. What is being aware ?
When I say “for any length of time” I mean time that I’ve set aside for mindful meditation. I would decide for whatever reason that I wanted to do it, and then I’d sit down and do it until a useful thought arrived (funny to say, just sifting through mounds of thought until ANYTHING remotely useful surfaced. Haha, to laugh at the excess of certain aspects of “the happening” like that.). I can’t do that anymore, I’m too restless and agitated. That’s what I meant. But I have also tried to be mindful all the time as well.
This does put a dent in, or at least make a new impression on my expectations. Neither desirable nor useful…okay, I always just assumed it was both but I can see how that might not be true. It’s like the useful thoughts we were talking about versus the rubbish ones…thoughts CAN be useful, so it’s not delusional to evaluate a thought after some meditation and decide it’s worth acting on because of how it contributes to the things you value in life. This is where I’ve gotten lost often, confusing mindfulness for nihilism, a common pitfall I’m sure. But I think it was because I expected it to relieve my depression completely.
The shoes…this is very interesting. There’s no reason to be mindful of your tying your shoes because you already do it as fast as you can automatically…and we can safely conclude there is no more of interest to experience in this activity. That’s one place where our agreements diverge from some Buddhist ideas that I’ve believed that teach that EVERYTHING is an illusion, so EVERYTHING you know is not just “not known by you”, but is definitively WRONG. So you can choose to let your mind wander into what’s going to happen when you get where you’re going, or be mindful of the sounds in the room, or just let the rubbish thoughts run as long as they’re doing no harm and you’re enjoying yourself. Kind of like letting a dog wander on a leash because you know you can still discipline it when you need to- there’s flexibility and play in the relationship, an authoritative relationship but not authoritarian.
So “awareness of the flow of thoughts”/mindfulness is a tool and does not NEED to be sought as a permanent insight, at the very least for our purposes here. Some people who like to sit cross-legged with their eyes closed a lot might pursue a more frequent use of it, but that doesn’t mean that their preferences are appropriate for my life. (See this is trouble for me, BECAUSE of depression I think. I still personalize it just because it’s natural to do when I’m told I have a disease that no one can see and that I confuse for a part of my personality. So I try to fix the WHOLE thing behaviorally. And that has meant for me basically charging every moment with an enlightenment type of experience, because to just shoot for any kind of normal life, I’ve tried that and it doesn’t work for me. So this might be an intuitive “duh” thing to a lot of people but this is learning for me.)
One of the traits of awareness is that in it there is a plain recognition that the idea of a “self” is yet more content of thought, and we know how to treat content of thought.
Do you have expectations that it will disappear when some magical enlightenment happens ?
i tell you one thing. If you are doing this looking for that one outcome, then there is a good chance that it won't happen.
I don’t think it will disappear exactly, I don’t expect to wake up in someone else’s mind. I have in the past, but I’m comfortable enough with how my mind works at this point that I don’t imagine much will be different in thought, belief, desired behavior, humor, etc. But I do imagine, simply, that I will no longer be or feel disabled by it. This is to say, well, the suffering. And the thing about the suffering is that it has been OVERWHELMING. I was reading an old journal entry the other day, and I saw my phrasing of my depression as meta-suffering. The suffering is too much to bear when it’s happening, and it happens too often for me to bear. Too much too-muchness. When I’ve been overwhelmed, which has never been far off, there has been no question that EVERYTHING must be immediately and forever put on hold until I find a way to make that NEVER happen again. Because that overwhelming takes every relief away from me. That’s how it’s disabled me.
I have been able to make use of mindfulness whenever I’ve had a headache to a certain extent, usually, which I’m surprised by. I focus on the sensations. People say “yea but if you’re just doing it to make it go away that’s not mindfulness.” Fine. It’s meditation, or just concentration, but it’s more magic than concentration, because insofar as I am able to pay attention and feel the sensations, there is no suffering. It’s trying to ignore it or wish it away that causes all the suffering. Otherwise, pain is just a sensation like pleasure, an event. So I imagine my experience of depression will be something like this, and that meta-suffering will eventually recede to just become one level of pain from depression, that is MANAGEABLE, without me wishing with everything for a way out, and not caring at all if I live or die.
As maladaptive as it may seem, the organism always strives to get to what it knows as normal.
Yes, I read that depression is a defense mechanism to numb the constant messages of stress and distress that the mind is creating/receiving, because otherwise I’d be in a constant state of panic. Learning things like this doesn’t make me feel any better, but fortunately I have been feeling positive in a way that hasn’t happened for this long in perhaps months. It could be a fluke or it could be a medication that I’ve just started that supposedly has worked for me in the past.
i think that this is a particularly useful thing for you. You are wordy and cerebral.
To remind yourself that nothing can be known, and that THIS (including feeling depressed) is IT.
It is the stories that arrive to overlay THIS, that is the beginning of suffering.
By the time you notice what is happening, it is already a done deal. It is finished. It can't be changed.
So what is the least resistive position to take ? Acceptance. Surrender.
A welcoming of what is here. Of what has happened. This gives the best chance for the next happening to be uncorrupted by a desire for it to be different.
This sounds good. I’ll be working with this now.
Do you think that duality is bad and non duality is good ?
Well, when I had not so many years behind me I trusted my intuition/gut more uncritically and my gut was a pedal-to-the-metal tribal revivalist, i.e. hippie. Since then, more than self-indulgence, I’ve sought resolution and reconciliation with the general world population and with the concept of civilization. What I said earlier about my interest in Marshall McLuhan’s ideas about the effects of media has transformed my view completely, in principle at least, to acknowledge that civilization, just like pre- and post-civilization, has its benefits and its drawbacks, and “dualist” concepts are a product of civilization and as such also have their benefits and drawbacks. McLuhan used the words “figure” and “ground” to talk about these things.
The mind doesn't have the capacity to understand infinity (or non-duality)
I believe you’re right that the non-duality is as incomprehensible as infinity is to the mind, with the exception perhaps within the state of a mystical experience. I don’t plan on having any of those anytime soon, so I will put these concepts aside.
Would you be able to navigate daily life in that state?
This occurred to me once vaguely and fleetingly, I wasn’t very interested by it, but you make a good point with this. I can imagine it being very difficult to do so.