Hi Jon,
That last email was most helpful, your guidance in focusing makes a big difference.
Is a secret or hidden 'me' making hearing happen, or seeing, or thoughts?
What if those things all just appear in the Now?
If there is uncertainty try looking for the 'causer' of any of these
There is absolutely no 'causer' or 'maker' of hearing, body sensations, seeing and thoughts. In moments of reflection that is certain, in moments of non reflection (plodding through the day moments) there is still no reason to identify a 'causer' or 'maker'.
Sometimes (hmmmm regular) I do identify an 'observer' of sensations/ thoughts, but some reflection into who or what and that tends to dissolve it.
Let me, for the purpose of this exercise, work with the idea of a spectrum. Posing the question 'is there an I/self in any way shape or form?'. The answer varies depending. Some times the answer is' Yes' I do identify one; other times it is 'I don't know'; other times it is 'I don't think so'; other times it is 'NO'. Over the last few days I find myself moving to the right of that spectrum. I am spending more time down that end. I am certainly spending a lot of time in the 'I don't know if I exist' or 'I really don't think so'. I have just come out of meditation and in the last 20 minutes the answer to the question was 'what is the relevance of the question?'
Looking out the window at the end of this meditation I could see the trees, and it was possible that I was the tree or maybe I am the bedside locker with the digital alarm clock. Or maybe we are all connected or maybe I am none of them, a dream character or a cartoon character on a PlayStation game. BUT There is a story of Mic. The Mic story...what to do with it. I like the version of that story where he has loving relationships with his boys and his wife, that version is preferable to the version of something bad happening to Mic or his family, yet the imagined bad version does not seem to matter either. But what does the word 'preferable' mean anyway? I don't want to wreck your head here Jon with my over analysis but in that moment of 'no I' there were thoughts arising (appearing) about the relationship between existence and the story of Mic. Correct me if I am wrong but it does seem of some importance.
I also want to reference a pleasant experience that I had during a couple of peak experiences - like when I was on the beech, when I was working in my sons bedroom last Monday, and a few other moments. The best way I can explain it is when sight sensation, physical sensation, sound sensation all merge and 'squeeze' together, leaving no room for the 'I' - merging raw unfiltered sensation with no room for 'self'. I don't know what is on the other side of the gate, but I guess that it may not be entirely like those peak experiences. Perhaps moving up and down on a spectrum, some of the time akin to what it was like when at a team meeting in work today - I was able to think and talk and the sense of I was expanding to deal with the issue on hand, and then when it was not needed it would diminish with me offering it attention (inquiring about it) [please excuse language, I know there is no one 'offering it attention' as such]. Anyway I'm outlining another spectrum as I wonder what the other side of the gate is like. This is relevant because I guess it is important to not have expectations - but the problem with no expectations is that I don't know if/how I could recognize 'no self' if I'm lucky enough to get there. Anyway I know I'm still on this side of the gate at the moment.
Another experience I want to share is that I do have a lot of mental activity almost all the time. The difference is that it is easier to divert it when such thought is unhelpful. Weather I go through the gate of not this is a welcome phenomena either way, so hopefully it will last.
Hmmm final comment, I think the word 'subtle' is useful at this time.
I appreciate every and any guidance you can offer me at this time Jon,
With love
Mic