Requesting guidance

All threads where seeing happens are stored here. The complete list, sorted by guide, contains all links. The archives include threads of those that came to LU already seeing as well.
You are welcome to continue your conversation with your guide here after your name is turned blue.
User avatar
JonathanR
Posts: 5915
Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2014 10:14 pm

Re: Requesting guidance

Postby JonathanR » Thu Aug 24, 2017 9:31 pm

Hi Mic


What track? What path?
This question doesn't work for me. Perhaps I am missing something. I understand that I am working towards the realization and experience of 'no self'. That is a destination,
But in this idea there is a thing, a 'destination' as well as a 'distance' from it. Also, a traveller (or 'self'). Do you see how this language or conceptualisation creates several unchanging objects all held in fixed relation to each other?


...and although there is not 'the' track,I understand from the interaction between us that there are ways that are not helpful to attain this realization. Therefore I refer to track or path in reference to the way you are guiding me. However please correct me if I am missing something.
Don't worry I won't let you go in the wring direction.
Regarding the exercises, todays experience is very different from yesterday. I could not reproduce it. When doing brief exercises and when meditating I could not experience 'existence' instead of 'me'. Of course the question of 'who is experiencing?' was useful in diminishing the 'me' experience but I could not get across the edge. And again the question of 'who is going over the edge?' was useful also.
There were some moments of getting over just (or sort of just) over the edge but very brief and could not be sustained like last night.
I'm not surprised. Do you think there is something to be sustained? Like something that could be 'generated', for example?

Is it like that?

Is there an expectation of a sustained/sustainable experience?

love

Jon

User avatar
Treelife
Posts: 144
Joined: Sun Jun 11, 2017 6:28 am

Re: Requesting guidance

Postby Treelife » Thu Aug 24, 2017 10:44 pm

Regarding the exercises, todays experience is very different from yesterday. I could not reproduce it. When doing brief exercises and when meditating I could not experience 'existence' instead of 'me'. Of course the question of 'who is experiencing?' was useful in diminishing the 'me' experience but I could not get across the edge. And again the question of 'who is going over the edge?' was useful also.
There were some moments of getting over just (or sort of just) over the edge but very brief and could not be sustained like last night.

I'm not surprised. Do you think there is something to be sustained? Like something that could be 'generated', for example?
Is it like that?
Is there an expectation of a sustained/sustainable experience?
Yes, yes defo it is that, yes. And I know that this is not helpful and I then try to stop doing things like pushing, or constructing, or arriving, or generating, or travelling or, or, or etc... I do TRY to just stop and see, to look rather than 'achieve'. The problem I encounter by just looking is that I end up with...how to explain...eh something that feels like a zen koan (in action). Something like this: I hold a strong belief that the I/self/identity/ego is false, so I look to see if there is an I, and in order to do the looking I have to use the I/self (by way of intention). When I put this into practice it is the very act of looking that seems to anchor the whole process to the 'I' and then I find myself doing all the other things (generating, pushing, constructing, travelling etc...). Oh I have just finished meditating a few minutes ago, and I have been linking in to this on and off during the day and I AM SO FUSTRATED. And that defo doesn't help!! I would really appreciate any guidance or questions or exercises you may have on seeing through this one. I have it that I am to look at it differently, or from a particular angle.

But in this idea there is a thing, a 'destination' as well as a 'distance' from it. Also, a traveller (or 'self'). Do you see how this language or conceptualisation creates several unchanging objects all held in fixed relation to each other?
I see exactly what you mean. I have actually been working on language myself. For example in terms of how I set questions for myself - when I switch from pushing/achieving. But this one you quote above did slip by me. Please keep pointing this type of stuff out to me, it helps me internalize it.

Joh I do appreciate you input on all of this especially at this time. After my experience on the beech Wednesday of last week, and the experience in my son's bed room on Monday I know that I want this and there is no real fear - not really. I feel ready for it but even though the gate seems so close that I can breath onto it, it also seems an infinity away.

I am going to be quite active over the weekend, and where I will be staying will have very poor internet connection but I'll try my best to connect.

Peace and love,
Mike

User avatar
JonathanR
Posts: 5915
Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2014 10:14 pm

Re: Requesting guidance

Postby JonathanR » Fri Aug 25, 2017 11:49 am

Hi Mic,
Yes, yes defo it is that, yes. And I know that this is not helpful and I then try to stop doing things like pushing, or constructing, or arriving, or generating, or travelling or, or, or etc... I do TRY to just stop and see, to look rather than 'achieve'. The problem I encounter by just looking is that I end up with...how to explain...eh something that feels like a zen koan (in action). Something like this: I hold a strong belief that the I/self/identity/ego is false, so I look to see if there is an I, and in order to do the looking I have to use the I/self (by way of intention). When I put this into practice it is the very act of looking that seems to anchor the whole process to the 'I' and then I find myself doing all the other things (generating, pushing, constructing, travelling etc...). Oh I have just finished meditating a few minutes ago, and I have been linking in to this on and off during the day and I AM SO FUSTRATED. And that defo doesn't help!! I would really appreciate any guidance or questions or exercises you may have on seeing through this one. I have it that I am to look at it differently, or from a particular angle.
OK Mic.
I do TRY to just stop and see....When I put this into practice it is the very act of looking that seems to anchor the whole process to the 'I'
Seems. :-)

What 'I'? (That is really all this is about). Beyond an idea of one?

Yes there are thoughts about a 'me, looking', there are thoughts about needing to 'push', to 'follow a path' about needing to 'not push' to 'just see'.

What if all this stuff, thoughts, 'I' 'effort', the whole shabang is simply appearing? What 'I' are we speaking about then?


love

Jon

User avatar
Treelife
Posts: 144
Joined: Sun Jun 11, 2017 6:28 am

Re: Requesting guidance

Postby Treelife » Fri Aug 25, 2017 12:07 pm

Hi Jon,
I hope you are well.
I've had a night sleep since my last entry and can see that the fustration has been fuled by tiredness over a hectic week Also combined with a fear that I will not be able to make the next step; this brings sbutle beliefes about failure as well as beign realy inclined to this non-duality/no self thing now (having gotten over my fear life on the other side of the gate.
What 'I'? (That is really all this is about). Beyond an idea of one?

Yes there are thoughts about a 'me, looking', there are thoughts about needing to 'push', to 'follow a path' about needing to 'not push' to 'just see'.

What if all this stuff, thoughts, 'I' 'effort', the whole shabang is simply appearing? What 'I' are we speaking about then?
I have the piece about looking. But the way you have put it here is helpful. "what I" versus all the thoughts and beliefs. It focused it down for me.
Just tried it now and it settled things. I'll work away with this, thank you.

sending love,
Mike

User avatar
JonathanR
Posts: 5915
Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2014 10:14 pm

Re: Requesting guidance

Postby JonathanR » Sun Aug 27, 2017 9:43 am

Hi Mike,

I could even rephrase that;
.
What if all this stuff, thoughts, 'I' 'effort',all sensations of hearing, seeing, feeling, the whole shabang, is simply appearing? What 'I' are we speaking about then?

Love

Jon

User avatar
Treelife
Posts: 144
Joined: Sun Jun 11, 2017 6:28 am

Re: Requesting guidance

Postby Treelife » Sun Aug 27, 2017 9:52 pm

What if all this stuff, thoughts, 'I' 'effort',all sensations of hearing, seeing, feeling, the whole shabang, is simply appearing? What 'I' are we speaking about then?
Sounds good with me Jonathan.

I have had a very busy weekend but did manage to give some time to the exercise. I've had some milder versions of 'no I' experiences. Experience when the idea of 'no self' made perfect sense, further than that when I looked for an 'I' there was non to be found. When the 'mind' is clear it has been easy to identify the edge between existence of what is appearing versus 'I'.
I think what is most important for me now is that I really feel clear to proceed in this process. I still had a bit of a fear about the gate that was impacting upon me and it seems to have cleared over the weekend - I feel I've given myself permission to proceed. I don't have anything coming up that will take me away from things for the next six weeks or so - although work is going to get very busy now in September...but that is my life. So I have a clear run and am excited to see where it is going to go.
I am glad to report that I am more relaxed than I was earlier in the week (Wednesday I think). Not putting pressure on my self to achieve anything, (no pass or fail), I think this is very important. If it happens it happens, and if not well I can live with that knowing it is for another time.

Talk soon,
Lots of thanks and lots of love Jon
Mic

User avatar
JonathanR
Posts: 5915
Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2014 10:14 pm

Re: Requesting guidance

Postby JonathanR » Mon Aug 28, 2017 7:24 pm

Hi Mic,

Its great that you feel less fear now. That's important.
. What if all this stuff, thoughts, 'I' 'effort',all sensations of hearing, seeing, feeling, the whole shabang, is simply appearing? What 'I' are we speaking about then?


Sounds good with me Jonathan
Well, look at this right now.

Is a secret or hidden 'me' making hearing happen, or seeing, or thoughts?

What if those things all just appear in the Now?

If there is uncertainty try looking for the 'causer' of any of these

Love

Jon

User avatar
Treelife
Posts: 144
Joined: Sun Jun 11, 2017 6:28 am

Re: Requesting guidance

Postby Treelife » Tue Aug 29, 2017 9:59 pm

Hi Jon,
That last email was most helpful, your guidance in focusing makes a big difference.
Is a secret or hidden 'me' making hearing happen, or seeing, or thoughts?
What if those things all just appear in the Now?
If there is uncertainty try looking for the 'causer' of any of these
There is absolutely no 'causer' or 'maker' of hearing, body sensations, seeing and thoughts. In moments of reflection that is certain, in moments of non reflection (plodding through the day moments) there is still no reason to identify a 'causer' or 'maker'.
Sometimes (hmmmm regular) I do identify an 'observer' of sensations/ thoughts, but some reflection into who or what and that tends to dissolve it.
Let me, for the purpose of this exercise, work with the idea of a spectrum. Posing the question 'is there an I/self in any way shape or form?'. The answer varies depending. Some times the answer is' Yes' I do identify one; other times it is 'I don't know'; other times it is 'I don't think so'; other times it is 'NO'. Over the last few days I find myself moving to the right of that spectrum. I am spending more time down that end. I am certainly spending a lot of time in the 'I don't know if I exist' or 'I really don't think so'. I have just come out of meditation and in the last 20 minutes the answer to the question was 'what is the relevance of the question?'
Looking out the window at the end of this meditation I could see the trees, and it was possible that I was the tree or maybe I am the bedside locker with the digital alarm clock. Or maybe we are all connected or maybe I am none of them, a dream character or a cartoon character on a PlayStation game. BUT There is a story of Mic. The Mic story...what to do with it. I like the version of that story where he has loving relationships with his boys and his wife, that version is preferable to the version of something bad happening to Mic or his family, yet the imagined bad version does not seem to matter either. But what does the word 'preferable' mean anyway? I don't want to wreck your head here Jon with my over analysis but in that moment of 'no I' there were thoughts arising (appearing) about the relationship between existence and the story of Mic. Correct me if I am wrong but it does seem of some importance.

I also want to reference a pleasant experience that I had during a couple of peak experiences - like when I was on the beech, when I was working in my sons bedroom last Monday, and a few other moments. The best way I can explain it is when sight sensation, physical sensation, sound sensation all merge and 'squeeze' together, leaving no room for the 'I' - merging raw unfiltered sensation with no room for 'self'. I don't know what is on the other side of the gate, but I guess that it may not be entirely like those peak experiences. Perhaps moving up and down on a spectrum, some of the time akin to what it was like when at a team meeting in work today - I was able to think and talk and the sense of I was expanding to deal with the issue on hand, and then when it was not needed it would diminish with me offering it attention (inquiring about it) [please excuse language, I know there is no one 'offering it attention' as such]. Anyway I'm outlining another spectrum as I wonder what the other side of the gate is like. This is relevant because I guess it is important to not have expectations - but the problem with no expectations is that I don't know if/how I could recognize 'no self' if I'm lucky enough to get there. Anyway I know I'm still on this side of the gate at the moment.

Another experience I want to share is that I do have a lot of mental activity almost all the time. The difference is that it is easier to divert it when such thought is unhelpful. Weather I go through the gate of not this is a welcome phenomena either way, so hopefully it will last.

Hmmm final comment, I think the word 'subtle' is useful at this time.

I appreciate every and any guidance you can offer me at this time Jon,
With love
Mic

User avatar
JonathanR
Posts: 5915
Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2014 10:14 pm

Re: Requesting guidance

Postby JonathanR » Wed Aug 30, 2017 5:57 pm

Hi Mic

Sometimes (hmmmm regular) I do identify an 'observer' of sensations/ thoughts, but some reflection into who or what and that tends to dissolve it.
The only thing is to keep looking. Take a good look to see if an observer is 'there' or if 'observer' is its self a thought?
The Mic story...what to do with it...in that moment of 'no I' there were thoughts arising (appearing) about the relationship between existence and the story of Mic. Correct me if I am wrong but it does seem of some importance. .
What is the relationship between existence and the story of Mic?
Another experience I want to share is that I do have a lot of mental activity almost all the time. The difference is that it is easier to divert it when such thought is unhelpful.
Good. As I suggested before, it can be helpful to look at the way thoughts appear and notice the gap after one thought has ended but another one is yet to appear. The space between words.


love

Jon

User avatar
Treelife
Posts: 144
Joined: Sun Jun 11, 2017 6:28 am

Re: Requesting guidance

Postby Treelife » Wed Aug 30, 2017 6:35 pm

Thanks Jon,
What is the relationship between existence and the story of Mic?
Existence being the experience of sensations (the five senses), while the story of Mic seems to make sense out of it, seems to format that information. For example I look down and see my legs, or I see my eye lashes through my eyes and the story arising is that Mic exists in a body. With the sensations in my body (especially my solar plexus and chest) there is an implicit assumption that there is a body and a person Mic. Not only does this relate to a body, it relates to history of Mic and to responsibilities and family etc... It relates to Mic being different from Jon or the person I see walking on the foot path etc...
Looking out the window at the end of this meditation I could see the trees, and it was possible that I was the tree or maybe I am the bedside locker with the digital alarm clock. Or maybe we are all connected or maybe I am none of them, a dream character or a cartoon character on a PlayStation game. BUT There is a story of Mic.
This story of Mic runs my life and has played an obvious role in how things happen, because the story of Mic is not about me being a tree or a bedside locker or anything like that. When the thoughts of Mic arise/appear I can try just observing and asking in this is real or if it is just appearing, but it is a challenge to not get pulled into them; also it is not helpful to just dismiss them as that is not realistic.
My thoughts are quite busy - sometimes more than other times - and these relate to believable stories. When engaged in a believable story it is the opposite to 'no self'. The story defines existence, rather than existence doing its thing.
Anyway I'll go back to the 'space between thoughts' exercise and that should do something.

The only thing is to keep looking. Take a good look to see if an observer is 'there' or if 'observer' is its self a thought?
That sounds good Jon, it is good to know where to keep the focus.

Talk soon Jon,
Mic

User avatar
JonathanR
Posts: 5915
Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2014 10:14 pm

Re: Requesting guidance

Postby JonathanR » Wed Aug 30, 2017 10:25 pm

Existence being the experience of sensations (the five senses), while the story of Mic seems to make sense out of it, seems to format that information. For example I look down and see my legs, or I see my eye lashes through my eyes and the story arising is that Mic exists in a body. With the sensations in my body (especially my solar plexus and chest) there is an implicit assumption that there is a body and a person Mic. Not only does this relate to a body, it relates to history of Mic and to responsibilities and family etc... It relates to Mic being different from Jon or the person I see walking on the foot path etc...
Well, the sensations part sounds fine.

In directly seeing sunlight, would you say that whatever is doing the seeing cannot be found, in contrast with the way that the sensation of light IS found to be really happening? That the seer or experiencer appears only as an assumption that such an entity must exist?

If there is no sunlight then substitute some other real sensation. I'm currently looking at the whiteness of a window-frame.

Don't think about this. Really don't think about it! Look.
My thoughts are quite busy - sometimes more than other times - and these relate to believable stories. When engaged in a believable story it is the opposite to 'no self'. The story defines existence, rather than existence doing its thing.
It may seem so, if you believe that no self is a state of mind, or an experience of some sort that can be eclipsed or ousted somehow.

love

Jon

User avatar
Treelife
Posts: 144
Joined: Sun Jun 11, 2017 6:28 am

Re: Requesting guidance

Postby Treelife » Fri Sep 01, 2017 5:24 pm

Hi Jon,

I think I got it. There is no self, there is noone making seeing happen, there is no one receiving seeing: no maker no see'er. There is only sensation and thoughts.

It is so obvious that I almost feel embarrassed for taking so long to realise. I now know what you mean by my over thinking things – sorry about that, it was frustrating for both of us. In allowing my mind to do the looking I was looking either too far, or too near, or looking for something that is bigger than what we are talking about. Unfortunately in recent couple of weeks my thoughts created expectations of what 'no self' is.

There is no separate internal centre that receives sense data, no separate observer (that's an important one), no separate decision making entity, no separate rule maker or moral authority inside me. And on this realisation there are no trumpets or bliss like peek experiences. There is sense experience and then there are thoughts. This is very clear to me now.

At the start of this inquiry you mentioned something about seeing a silence beneath everything - and you told me don't worry if I cannot see it. I now notice some level of silence beneath everything. Not complete silence, but when I look there is more silence that I can ever remember experiencing before.
Anyway the silence thing is a distraction issue; what I want to communicate with you is that I think I see it. Of course I understand that my claim needs to be now validated.

Thanks for your patience Jon in helping me realise this,
With love and appreciation
Mic

User avatar
JonathanR
Posts: 5915
Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2014 10:14 pm

Re: Requesting guidance

Postby JonathanR » Fri Sep 01, 2017 9:22 pm

Oooh! Interesting!

That was sudden, but it can be.
There is no self, there is noone making seeing happen, there is no one receiving seeing: no maker no see'er. There is only sensation and thoughts.
Good statement.
There is no separate internal centre that receives sense data, no separate observer (that's an important one), no separate decision making entity, no separate rule maker or moral authority inside me. And on this realisation there are no trumpets or bliss like peek experiences. There is sense experience and then there are thoughts. This is very clear to me now.
Although there is no fanfare or peak experience this kind of insight is deceptively subtle. Let's see how it goes for you over the next few days? No need to have any expectations of how it should feel. But do write to me letting me know how it's going and let's not regard this conversation as 'over' just yet?
At the start of this inquiry you mentioned something about seeing a silence beneath everything - and you told me don't worry if I cannot see it. I now notice some level of silence beneath everything. Not complete silence, but when I look there is more silence that I can ever remember experiencing before.
That's interesting. Apologies for creating some kind of expectation. There is absolutely no reason why silence or anything else should be experienced. One might experience an avalanche of thoughts instead. Various things can happen or not. Nevertheless, it's good to notice this silence.

Rather than throw quizz-like questions at you to validate something I'd just like you to write to me tomorrow or the following day, saying how it's going?

love

Jon

User avatar
Treelife
Posts: 144
Joined: Sun Jun 11, 2017 6:28 am

Re: Requesting guidance

Postby Treelife » Fri Sep 01, 2017 10:04 pm

Hi Jon
let's not regard this conversation as 'over' just yet?
I do understand that, and it is OK with me what ever way the dice falls on this.
Although it doesn't feel quit so sudden to me. Feels like the pieces have been there for a few days (a week or more maybe?) and could see them put together after your response yesterday - I managed to take my analysis out of what I was looking at.
There is absolutely no reason why silence or anything else should be experienced.
I get this too, it is just an aside issue not really worthy of attention, it is curious though as I never knew silence before.

I'll sit on this for a few days.

With love
Mic

User avatar
JonathanR
Posts: 5915
Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2014 10:14 pm

Re: Requesting guidance

Postby JonathanR » Sat Sep 02, 2017 5:29 pm

Hi Mic,

Just something to try at this stage. I probably asked you to do someting similar before but this exercise could be helpful right now.

Go for a wolk in nature. By the sea or the countryside if possible. If not then a park with trees and grass and so on.

Once you're there, notice everything that is going on around you. Sun, sky, breeze, clouds, trees, noises, animals, grass, people, insects. Everything alive and happening. Notice too any sensations and thoughts that are going on at the same time as everything else.

Now look to see if there can be found an edge.
Is there some sort of boundary or border in experience behind which 'you exist' and beyond which 'everything else' is happening.

Describe what's seen.


love

Jon


Return to “ARCHIVES”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 46 guests