Let's explore the difference between imagination (e.g. mental sensations) and direct experience (e.g. sensations) a little further. I hope you like chocolate! :)
1. Imaginary chocolate
Close your eyes and imagine eating a piece of chocolate. Imagine its taste, the texture, the aroma, and the sensation of it melting in your mouth. Make the experience as vivid as possible.
2. Real chocolate
Now take an actual piece of chocolate and eat it. Notice the taste, texture, smell and sensations as they happen. Take your time and enjoy it!
3. Description of chocolate
Finally, describe the experience of eating the chocolate in as much detail as possible. Write down what it was like.
Now compare these three:
• Imagining eating chocolate
• Actually eating chocolate
• Describing the experience of eating chocolate
What differences do you notice?
I can’t actually imagine eating chocolate because there is so much taste/texture already happening in my mouth presently that I can’t seem to override that does not match the pattern of sensations of eating chocolate. It’s like trying to imagine a pop song playing while another different pop song is also playing.
But, I can presently imagine a watermelon in my hand because there is ordinarily only a subtle amount of pressure on my hand and only a subtle warmth to it. When I imagine the watermelon in my hand, the contrast from the prior state is intense. I can feel the sensation of pressure intensify and the warmth change to coolness. I can also feel the texture/shape.
I think the main difference between imagined sensations and “real” sensations is intensity. A real watermelon in my hand (versus an imagined one) feels more intense…more pressure, more coolness, more detailed shape/texture. Like a train whistle sound feels more intense 20 feet away versus 1 mile away.
Are the imagined taste and texture the same as the actual taste and texture?
No. The sensations are more subtle when imagined. They are more intense and vivid when “real”.
Does the description reproduce the experience, or is it a thought ABOUT the experience?
Just a thought about the experience.
All three are experienced in some way, but are they the same?
No. The imagined watermelon and the actual watermelon vary only in intensity of sensation (pressure, texture, temperature). Like a train whistle sound 20 feet away versus a mile away. The description of it is just thought.
And when you say the imagined watermelon is still present, is there an actual watermelon available to the senses, or are there thoughts and mental images ABOUT one (aka memories)?
The sensations themselves do not contain information about their source. Thought comes in and says I imagined the watermelon and that created the sensations of one in my hand.
When you encounter another person, what is actually experienced? (think cup of coffee exercise)
Just raw sensations and thought–seeing, touching, smelling, thoughts of “this is another person”.
Different colours in seeing create the illusion of things (e.g. others) but all that is there is seeing. Also, is there space where these others exist?
No, all the colors fit together without a gap.
When you see the bird in the sky, there is a movement of shapes and colors, labels come up— “bird,” “sky,” “in.” Can you experience a bird without sky, outside of sky (while looking up)?
No, bird and sky are one thing. Like bee and flower.
What is the difference between “here” and “there” without thought content?
Colors and a sensation of depth.
When you touch 'another', are there two sensations one of 'you' and one of 'other' or just one/just feeling?
There is just the sensation of touch. Thought adds, “I am touching another”.
Are others outside of feeling? Where is the border that marks where feeling ends and "other" begin?
No. From the perspective of the sensation of feeling/touch, there is just feeling/touch, and then thought adds, “this feels like the specific pattern of sensations of another”.
Can the “I”/”inside” of “others” be directly experienced, or is it assumed? Can you directly experience "others"?
No. Only thought comes in and says “because I am here they must be here , too”
How we approach “others” from DE is the same way we see there is no “apple” – that apple is a label. Why would objects be different from ‘others’? Why were objects easier?
Thought says objects are easier because a part of me does not identify as an “object” like an “apple”, but rather like a “person” who senses other “persons”. It’s like patterns of sensations resonate with other similar and familiar patterns of sensations. We resonate with each other more than we do say, dissimilar patterns of sensations, such as those called “apple”.
What about animals?
Yes, same idea. Thoughts say when the pattern of sensation is an animal, and that pattern is known in memory as something like “dog”, thought adds a familiarity and a resonance that does not arise with the pattern of sensations called “apple”. More thoughts come in and say “it sounds like just old conditioning.”
If we have to repeat the same example but with a “person”:
Taste labelled ‘person’ is known
Color (visual information) labelled ‘person’ is known
Sensation labelled ‘person’ is known (when a person is touched)
Smell labelled ‘person’ is known
Thought about/of a ‘person’ is known
However, is a ‘person' actually known? (Or is it just a label?)
It is just a label/word/concept used to describe a specific pattern of sensations.
Is there really an ‘person’ here, or only color and a thought ABOUT ‘person’?
Only sensations arising together and a thought “these sensations must be a person”
Can ‘a person’ be found in actual experience?
Just in thought, as a concept/word.
So there are colours, sounds, perhaps sensations, smells, and thoughts labelling these as "another person", right? Can those colours or sounds experience anything?
I’m not sure. How could it be known either way in direct experience? Can sensation experience other sensation? Like, can sound experience smell? How could I investigate that?
And how do you know that this "other person" has their own separate "inside" where experiences happen?
Just thought, and hearing, when they tell me they have their own separate “inside”, and thought translates that hearing into words and understanding. Also, although I’m around my wife all the time, the thought never arises, “ I am caitlin”.
Can you directly experience that, or is it something thought assumes?
By definition of “inside”, I can’t directly experience it.
It’s something thought assumes about “others”. All that can be directly experienced is that a thought arises which does not appear to have any effect on anything else. By contrast, when a loudspeaker is played close to the ear of a crowd of people, they all react. The sound of the loudspeaker is not “inside”. I guess you could say the sound of the loudspeaker is limited or “inside” a certain radius, or its sensation has only a certain intensity. After all, at some distance, no one reacts to the loudspeaker, it does not even register for them. So, perhaps “thought” is like that. It is a sensation that is limited or “inside” only a certain radius.
Now back to “only I (can experience “inside”)”… turn the investigation around.
What is the evidence that there is an "inside" here, with a separate "you" experiencing mental images?
The evidence that there is an “inside” is that when thought appears other persons do not seem to register it. Like when I ask my wife to guess which color I’m thinking, she cannot. The thought “red” is arising, yet it is not perceived by her. Like a dog whistle. The frequency of the pitch is so high, that even though I blow the whistle, only the dog can hear it.
There is no separate “me” experiencing the thought. The thought is just appearing.
When a mental image appears, is there an actual "I" experiencing it, or is there simply the appearance of a mental image?
Just the appearance and then a thought which says “I am experiencing the image”
What exactly makes the image "yours"? Is there anything in the image itself that establishes an owner?
Others can’t automatically perceive the image. There is nothing in the image itself that establishes an owner. There is a thought that the image is only perceived by a “me”.
Look for this "I" that can sense the image. What exactly can you find?
I can’t find anything. It is a hall of mirrors, a seemingly infinite regression of mental positions.
Can you find two separate experiencers, one here and another over there, or are there experiences and thoughts describing them that way?
I can’t find any experiencers. Just thoughts arising which claim to be the experiencer.
Nothing is excluded.