hello!

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: hello!

Postby poppyseed » Sat Nov 07, 2026 10:46 am

Hi Zach,
I think we're making this a little more complicated than necessary :). Yes, I agree:
Sure, but in my direct experience, seeing, hearing, sensation, tasting, smelling, and thought are dissolving concepts/distinctions for me.
However, even calling “all” ”sensations” is not correct or close to “reality”. We're not claiming that seeing, hearing, tasting, etc., are fundamentally separate things. These are simply labels (DE labels) we use to communicate what is actually experienced, rather than what thought says ABOUT it. The categories we use in LU are simply practical labels to help distinguish direct experience from the stories about it. There's no need to replace one set of beliefs with another :).
I hope you would agree that language is a structure of agreed upon concepts (their definitions), as well as the relationships amongst them. In order to understand each other, these concepts have to mean the same thing for both of us. So what we mean here as sensations is what is felt, not all experience. You don't need to dissolve concepts or go beyond language. - that's not the point of this inquiry, We're just learning how to use language precisely to distinguish direct experience from interpretation.

I liked your coffee example:
So, most of the experience is color and some sensation (touch). It's incredible how colorful it is. I rarely sensed things in terms of taste or smell. But, it was interesting to watch as it seemed like color turned to taste and texture as I drank a coffee. Yet, I'm not even sure thats true. Maybe there was color and then there was taste and texture, but I connected the two automatically because I assume that taste and texture follows color when the concept of drinking coffee occurs.
I asked you to break down daily activities EXACTLY as in the example, using the six LU categories: colour, sound, sensation, taste, smell and thought, so in a way we establish meaning for these concepts and we understand each other in “LU language” so we don’t end up misunderstanding what we are pointing to. Also learn how to LOOK of course :)
For example:
Seeing the coffee cup = colour
Feeling its warmth = sensation
Smelling the coffee = smell
Tasting the coffee = taste
Hearing the cup being placed on the table = sound
Thinking about the coffee = thought

Please give me an example from your own daily activities in this format, without additional explanations or philosophical interpretations, so I know that you speak “LU” language :). For now, please oblige me and let's get comfortable with this simple way of looking.
We'll explore the other things you've noticed in due time.

For the next exercise I want you to sit somewhere quiet and observe thoughts.
A thought appears.
In that moment is there anyone or anything which recognises the thought or is being aware of it?
Can you see anything that is separate from the thought and does the thinking?
Did you do anything to make a particular thought or thoughts appear? Could you have done anything to make a different thought appear at that exact moment instead? Can you select from a range of thoughts to have only pleasant thoughts?
Can you choose not to have painful, negative or fearful thoughts?
Can you pick and choose any kind of thought?

Is there anything that is responsible for the thoughts like a traffic cop saying which one to go and which one to stay? Can the flow of thoughts be changed?
Where do thoughts appear from? Where are they coming from and going to? Do they appear randomly or in a structured way?
Watch like a hawk.

Write down a sequence of 5 thoughts in the order that they appear. Now check:
Could you predict the order of their appearance?
Did you know which will be the second or the fourth?
Is it possible to prevent a thought from appearing? Can you stop thinking a thought in the middle? How long does that last?
Test it for the fun of exploration.
It seems that thought has some logical ordered appearance, but look carefully and just notice if there is an organised sequence. Or is it just another thought that says ‘these thoughts are in sequence’ or “they take content from previous thought”, or that "one thought follows another thought"?

Are thoughts 100% true?
What are you, when you don't think about what you are?


Love
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Sat Nov 07, 2026 5:58 pm

e're just learning how to use language precisely to distinguish direct experience from interpretation.
Ok got it! Sorry, I have a tendency to drift into philosophizing and I understand that's not going to help here. Thank you for your patience.

Im eating a pastry:

Looking at the pastry: sight
Feeling the texture of the pastry in my hand: touch
Smelling the aromas of the pastry: smell
Tasting the pastry before thought arises as to whether it is enjoyable or not: taste
Hearing the crunch of the pastry in my mouth: sound
Comparing this taste of this pastry to others I've had: thought
A thought appears.

In that moment is there anyone or anything which recognises the thought or is being aware of it?
No. In the moment the thought itself takes center stage. There is just the thought.

Can you see anything that is separate from the thought and does the thinking?
In the moment, there is just the thought itself. After the thought ended, another comes in saying "that was just a thought. It came out of nowhere." And, then another thought notices that thought that said that.

Did you do anything to make a particular thought or thoughts appear?
Many thoughts arise saying variations of "i choose my thoughts". Another thought arises and says "who is it that chooses?" Then silence for awhile. So, to answer, I did not. The thought just arose.
Could you have done anything to make a different thought appear at that exact moment instead?
Thoughts arise saying variations of "no, because i don't pre plan thoughts, although they seem to be appropriate to the moment sometimes, other times they are intrusive and unwanted, but I can't change them".
Can you select from a range of thoughts to have only pleasant thoughts?
I cant see the range in advance so I can't select out of them only pleasant ones.
Can you choose not to have painful, negative or fearful thoughts?
Thoughts arise saying, "no, I absolutely cannot. Who would choose? Where would this so called choosing happen? ".
Can you pick and choose any kind of thought?
Absolutely not. They just come and go on their own. Who would choose? Where would this choosing occur?
Is there anything that is responsible for the thoughts like a traffic cop saying which one to go and which one to stay? Can the flow of thoughts be changed?
Yes, thoughts judge and police other thoughts. Sometimes it seems the flow can be changed. It seems like there is an "i" who can become aware of the flow and shift them. But then more thoughts come and say "even that is a thought" and who thought it?"
Where do thoughts appear from? Where are they coming from and going to? Do they appear randomly or in a structured way? Watch like a hawk.
Often they drift in as if they own the place, or feel like they are "me". Like, it feels like they were created by me, yet I'm not aware of that process. But then I think, "this is also just a thought". Other thoughts it is very clear they come on the scene from nowhere, like i can almost see them form into coherence and drift away just the same. They come and go out of nowhere. Honestly, I can't tell if they are random or structured. A part of me reports they are very sequential, like they tell a story in a logical order or repeat the same loop over and over.


Write down a sequence of 5 thoughts in the order that they appear. Now check:

The leaves are brown and pretty.
My lower back hurts maybe I should change my position.
I need to hurry up my friends are getting ready to go.
What else should I write here?
Noticing myself checking myself for thoughts.
Could you predict the order of their appearance?
After the fact, yeah. Sure. It looks like a fairly typical pattern of mine. But, before the fact, no way. It was just happening.
Did you know which will be the second or the fourth?
No not at all.
Is it possible to prevent a thought from appearing? Can you stop thinking a thought in the middle? How long does that last? Test it for the fun of exploration.
I dont think so. Its like saying "dont think of the elephant." Although I try now, I can't. I first have to think of the thought that I dont want to appear.

I tried stopping a thought mid thought. I ask who is thinking? And then a long pause occurs. Maybe 15 seconds. Then more thoughts come in.

It seems that thought has some logical ordered appearance, but look carefully and just notice if there is an organised sequence. Or is it just another thought that says ‘these thoughts are in sequence’ or “they take content from previous thought”, or that "one thought follows another thought"?
Yes, upon reflection, I cant be sure its sequential, ordered or random because all answers to the questions are more thought. But, as I wrote them down as they came, and then look at them, there does appear to be a pattern or locust. Like, they all center around a "me" and what this me experiences in the moment.

Are thoughts 100% true?
I'm not sure what you mean by true. Thoughts are a perspective and all are valid. But none are more true than others.

What are you, when you don't think about what you are?
Spaciousness. Empty. At peace.
Nothing is excluded.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: hello!

Postby poppyseed » Sun Nov 08, 2026 11:08 am

Hi Zach
Sorry, I have a tendency to drift into philosophizing and I understand that's not going to help here. Thank you for your patience.
That’s why I am here ;). And it’s my pleasure talking to you

Thank you for looking so carefully! Your pastry example is much closer to what we're looking for :).
How does it feel to see what actually is?

You noticed that thoughts appear and disappear, but sometimes they feel like "me" or "mine". We'll come back to that. First, let's explore sensations and the body.

Exercises:
1. Take something cold from the fridge – like a can of cooldrink. When you touch the can, what does more accurately describe your experience:
a. Your fingers feeling cold because of touching a cold can; or
b. Coldness - sensation labelled “cold”?

With eyes closed, where does the cold appear? Observe the order in which the details appear
2. Sit comfortably on a chair. Close your eyes and relax. Pay attention only to the feeling of your body. Just notice the pure sensations, without relying on thoughts or mental images. Keep your eyes closed and look:
Can it be known how tall the body is?
Does the body have a weight or volume?
In the actual experience does the body have a shape or a form?
Is there a boundary between the body and the chair? At the point where your body contacts the chair, are there two things there, a body and chair, or one, sensation?
Is it "my" body, or is it just a body?
Is there an inside or an outside? If there is an inside - the inside of what exactly? If there is an outside - the outside of what exactly?
What does the word/label ‘body’ ACTUALLY refer to? What is the ACTUAL experience of the body?
Can the 'body' do things?


Look very carefully, especially with the last question. You can look several times during the day while doing other things (like washing hands, showering, walking, lying down, etc) before replying.

Now, you mentioned:
What are you, when you don't think about what you are?
Spaciousness. Empty. At peace.
While looking at the sensations labelled "body", notice this spaciousness too.
What exactly is experienced when you say "spaciousness"? Is it a sensation, a mental image, or a thought describing the experience?
Does spaciousness itself say anything about what “you” are? Or is "I am spaciousness" another thought describing what is experienced?

Take your time and report what you actually find.
Love
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Sun Nov 08, 2026 7:55 pm


you for looking so carefully! Your pastry example is much closer to what we're looking for :).

How does it feel to see what actually is?
It feels very unusual. Like, everything becomes 2D. Like watching a video game where it appears 3D but with a subtle shift of perspective, it is seen that the video game is just a 2D representation of 3D.

I've realized that color and shape go together. Everywhere that is color is also shape. Even gradients of color. And, I understand that color is not inherent to the physical world but is added by our brains, which makes me think maybe shape is also not inherent to the physical world but just added by the brain.

Exercises:
1. Take something cold from the fridge – like a can of cooldrink.
When you touch the can, what does more accurately describe your experience:
a. Your fingers feeling cold because of touching a cold can; or
b. Coldness - sensation labelled “cold”?
With my eyes closed, its more accurate to say there is just coldness localized in a particular space near my hands. When I move my hands, the place where the coldness is experienced moves, too.
With eyes closed, where does the cold appear? Observe the order in which the details appear
In relationship with my hands. When the hands move, the coldness moves.
2. Sit comfortably on a chair. Close your eyes and relax. Pay attention only to the feeling of your body. Just notice the pure sensations, without relying on thoughts or mental images. Keep your eyes closed and look:

Can it be known how tall the body is?
I can sense/distinguish the ends of my body (the head and feet in concept) by feeling where the breeze brushes my skin or where the warm of the sun is most intense and get a rough idea from that.
Does the body have a weight or volume?
Yes, I can feel a pull or gravity on different parts of my body. Like, sitting in the chair, i feel more pull in my lower back and upper legs than I do in my lower legs and feet and neck.
In the actual experience does the body have a shape or a form?
With eyes closed, the body has no apparent form. I feel different sensations like heat and pressure or pulling or air brushing against at what my mind percieves is the edges of the body. But, without the story of having a body, or the story of having end points, I can't put these together into a distguishable form.
Is there a boundary between the body and the chair? At the point where your body contacts the chair, are there two things there, a body and chair, or one, sensation?
With eyes closed, I can push my arms against the chair, and it feels like two things: a body and a chair. But, without the story of the body, or control over it, the only thing happening there is just the sensation of pressure and feeling of texture of the chair.
Is it "my" body, or is it just a body?
A part of me answers that there is no body and no one to have a body, that those are just concepts. While another part feels strongly this is "my" body, that there is an "i" charged with taking care of the body, and is uncomfortable when it feels a loss of control of the body or when the body suffers, like when the body falls down and gets hurt or has a illness.

Is there an inside or an outside? If there is an inside - the inside of what exactly? If there is an outside - the outside of what exactly?
There feels like layers of an onion with parts that feel within other parts. But it doesn't feel like there is a distinguishable end point in either direction. Outwardly, it feels like the body extends as far as sense experience. Inwardly, it feels infinite, like there is no bound or limit, or ground.

What does the word/label ‘body’ ACTUALLY refer to? What is the ACTUAL experience of the body?
Can the 'body' do things?

Look very carefully, especially with the last question. You can look several times during the day while doing other things (like washing hands, showering, walking, lying down, etc) before replying.
The word body is just a concept we use, but really it is not distinguishable from the things the body experiences. The actual experience of the body, without the story of a body, is just a locust of sense experiences in space. Like, if my foot itches, there is actually just itching in an area of space that I label as my foot.

In my experience, the body does things--like it can move the arm to wash itself in the shower. I've had lots of experience just watching it do its things, like eating food, making tea, brushing teeth. Sometimes, if I'm really conscious of it, I can very clearly see its just happening, there isn't a controller of it telling it what to do-- like breathing. But, most of the time, I dont have this level of awareness.

Now, you mentioned:
What are you, when you don't think about what you are? Spaciousness. Empty. At peace.
While looking at the sensations labelled "body", notice this spaciousness too.

What exactly is experienced when you say "spaciousness"? Is it a sensation, a mental image, or a thought describing the experience?
That's very interesting. Yes, it's a sensation. A falling away. Like a sudden weighlessness and lack of center of gravity pulling something in a direction combined with an edgelessness, a feeling of boundlessness. Just this, not another here watching it.
Does spaciousness itself say anything about what “you” are? Or is "I am spaciousness" another thought describing what is experienced?
Take your time and report what you actually find.
In the direct experience of it, it is difficult to report in a way that makes sense. But afterward, I can give a report by contrast. During spaciousness, its like I'm pressed up against the glass of reality, experiencing it directly, without a feeling there is someone here witnessing it. It just is. No thoughts arise. No self concept. It feels whole and complete and joyous and perfect. Time is not here and everything is very clear and vivid and fresh. Everything is fresh and spontaneous.

When I had my initial awakening experience several years ago, this was the dominant state for about a few months. Now, it's something I can access fairly easily, but mostly I feel like a witness of what it is, or I strongly identify as the body/mind and its stories.

I would say spaciousness itself is what I am and it takes the perspectives within it, such as witness or identification with body/mind. I think it can also be turned into a concept by the mind and can get strongly identified as the illusory concept of spaciousness that the mind creates.
Nothing is excluded.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: hello!

Postby poppyseed » Mon Nov 09, 2026 10:26 am

Hi Zach

Good looking! However:
And, I understand that color is not inherent to the physical world but is added by our brains, which makes me think maybe shape is also not inherent to the physical world but just added by the brain.
Zach, remember our agreement to leave science, philosophy, spiritual teachings, and other explanations aside for this inquiry :). We're not trying to explain how experience is produced or what the physical world is made of - that would be simply the next assumption about "reality".
When looking at colour, is a brain producing it actually experienced? Do you see an actual brain doing stuff? Or is there simply colour, along with thoughts ABOUT how it arises?
Let's stick to what can be directly observed, rather than what we know or believe about it.

There's something interesting running through your answers.
There is actually just itching in an area of space that I label as my foot.
When the hands move, the coldness moves.
Let's look at this "space" a little more closely.
Close your eyes and notice a sensation — pressure, itching, warmth, whatever is present.
Is there a sensation AND a space in which it appears?
Can this space itself be experienced? Does it have any qualities or boundaries? Do you SEE a clear line/a border/an edge where sensation ends and space begin? Or is "space" another assumption/thought describing the experience (i.e. sensation)?

Now, let's return to what you called "spaciousness".
I would say spaciousness itself is what I am
You described spaciousness as a sensation of weightlessness, boundlessness and peace.
First of all…Are “you” a sensation?
And second…When those sensations are present, does that establish the existence of something called "spaciousness" which contains or experiences everything else?
When you say sensations appear "in space", what exactly is this space in direct experience?
Can you find space independently of sensations, colours, sounds and thoughts? Or is "space" a label describing the mere fact that experience appears?
What is the actual evidence for a container in which experience happens?

Look carefully rather than reasoning about it. What is actually found?

It seems that you are trying to replace one entity (self) with another ("spaciousness"'/ "emptiness"). Experiencing happens through the physical senses + thought. If there is experience, one or more of those are present. If I close my eyes and feel expansive and like there's nothing, that happens through sensations. Have you ever esperienced no experience?
Emptiness in the buddhist sense simply means that something is empty of self-nature. And no-thingness means that things are dependent. Just like a school is a thing that doesn't exist. It is empty of school-essence.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CYqaWmc ... 4&index=41
If there is 'awareness' of nothingness/emptiness/spaciousness, that is often a subtle mental image of nothing with very subtle sensations. True nothingness means absolutely nothing. So if there are no sensations and there is nothingness, that's often a subtle thought that is trying to create something.
This sensation could also be called aliveness, presence or I AM, but even that is a label, is it not? Is there anything here that is not the senses?
Those would be physical, but there are also sensations when you close your eyes that don't have a location (unless they are mapped onto an image of the body). The way I look at sensations is that they include anything that is felt, such as touching a cup or a feeling of spaciousness. The feeling of spaciousness is a plethora of sensations (e.g. weightlessness, boundlessness and peace) happening in quick succession, making it seem and feel spacious. But it's good to remember that we can only experience see, hear, feel, taste, smell and thought. Anything not in the first five is thought.
This isn't abnormal though. Many have a feeling of I AM, presence, being, consciousness, spaciousness, but even that has to be let go of at some point. Without the labels "a sudden weighlessness", "lack of center of gravity" , "an edgelessness", "a feeling of boundlessness", do you notice that these are also sensations?

Now to extend this further:
The word body is just a concept we use, but really it is not distinguishable from the things the body experiences. The actual experience of the body, without the story of a body, is just a locust of sense experiences in space. Like, if my foot itches, there is actually just itching in an area of space that I label as my foot.
You recognised that "body" and "foot" are labels, but what about "an area of space"?
Close your eyes and notice an itch or another sensation.
Is there actually a sensation inside an area of space, or simply sensation present?
What tells you where the sensation is located?

Have a closer look at this.
When itching appears, notice whether there is also a mental image (aka also thought) or a mental map of the "body" that tells you where the itching is located.
Is the location actually contained in the sensation, or does the mental map provide that information? Is the location a reality or a description (thought content)?
Now put the mental image aside for a moment. What remains? Is there itching in an area of space, or simply itching?
Can you find the space separately from the sensation?

Look carefully — are there two things, sensation AND space containing it, or is the space part of the description supplied by thought?
The actual experience of the body is thought. Thought points to sensations and colours and labels it a ‘body’, but can a body be found as actual experience or only thoughts about a body? And if body is just a label pointing to experience (e.g. sensations, colours, smells, tastes), can a label experience things?
And one last thing, Zach :)
Awakening is not about achieving or maintaining a particular state of spaciousness, peace, silence or bliss. These experiences may come and go, just like any other experience.
What we're investigating is something much simpler: whether a separate self actually exists or ever existed in the first place (with or without a state).
If it never existed, could it suddenly appear when thoughts become noisy, uncomfortable sensations arise, or the sense of spaciousness disappears?
The recognition of an illusion doesn't depend on how experience happens to appear at any particular moment.
Love
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Tue Nov 10, 2026 12:08 am

When looking at colour, is a brain producing it actually experienced?

Do you see an actual brain doing stuff? Or is there simply colour, along with thoughts ABOUT how it arises?
Let's stick to what can be directly observed, rather than what we know or believe about it.
I can’t be sure that brain is producing color, as I can’t directly observe a brain, much less a brain doing anything. Color is appearing. That’s all I can truthfully say about it from direct experience.

There's something interesting running through your answers.
There is actually just itching in an area of space that I label as my foot.
When the hands move, the coldness moves.
Let's look at this "space" a little more closely.
Close your eyes and notice a sensation — pressure, itching, warmth, whatever is present.
Is there a sensation AND a space in which it appears?
Can this space itself be experienced? Does it have any qualities or boundaries? Do you SEE a clear line/a border/an edge where sensation ends and space begin? Or is "space" another assumption/thought describing the experience (i.e. sensation)?
OK, wow. I really struggled here. I tried many experiments. You’re right, there isn’t a sensation and a space in which it appears. It is like a mental image or feeling added to the sensation itself to help define or contrast the sensation.

Now, let's return to what you called "spaciousness".
I would say spaciousness itself is what I am
You described spaciousness as a sensation of weightlessness, boundlessness and peace.
First of all…Are “you” a sensation?
Honestly, I feel I am a sensation. I come and go. Like in deep, dreamless sleep, there is no sensation and no “me” which could report anything. It feels like I am nothing except the arising and falling of sensations. That feels strange to say. I can’t say I directly experience a break in sensation during deep, dreamless sleep. At best, in the morning, I feel that time has lapsed which I can’t account for based upon things like position of the sun in the sky.
And second…When those sensations are present, does that establish the existence of something called "spaciousness" which contains or experiences everything else?
No. Spaciousness is just a concept to describe the sensations of stillness and lack of feeling of center.
When you say sensations appear "in space", what exactly is this space in direct experience?
Can you find space independently of sensations, colours, sounds and thoughts? Or is "space" a label describing the mere fact that experience appears?
Again, I really struggled here.

In sight there does not appear to be any space. Everything is filled out in sight, even “outer space” is just color which abuts another color (maybe a star or planet). And, in touch, there does not appear to be space. Everything is touching.

But, in sound, there is definitely space. Like, listening to water trickle down my water fountain, I can move so far away from it that the sound disappears entirely. And, when I gradually get closer, it gradually gets louder. Similar with smell and taste. As I get closer to my kitchen, I can smell the sardines I am frying. But, if I move to the bedroom, the smell is not there. However, on a more subtle level, the sound of trickling water fades, and more ambient sounds emerge. Or, as the sardines smell fades, the more subtle smells of faint incense in my bedroom emerge.

I can’t find space independent of sensations, colors, sounds, and thoughts. Space is like a mental image or thought or assumption the mind makes.

What is the actual evidence for a container in which experience happens?
I can’t find any that aren’t just thoughts.

Look carefully rather than reasoning about it. What is actually found?
From direct experience, I just find sensations (like thoughts, seeing, feeling, tasting, smelling). But, they seem to be happening to “me”. Like, I’m over here and I see the plant over there. There seems to be a center of experience.
It seems that you are trying to replace one entity (self) with another ("spaciousness"'/ "emptiness"). Experiencing happens through the physical senses + thought. If there is experience, one or more of those are present. If I close my eyes and feel expansive and like there's nothing, that happens through sensations. Have you ever esperienced no experience?
I cannot say I have. At best, I can guess there is no experience in dreamless sleep.


This sensation could also be called aliveness, presence or I AM, but even that is a label, is it not? Is there anything here that is not the senses?


Yes, these are concepts. In direct experience, there is just the sensations.
Without the labels "a sudden weighlessness", "lack of center of gravity" , "an edgelessness", "a feeling of boundlessness", do you notice that these are also sensations?
Yes, all of those are sensations. But, those words are just the only way to represent it in language. Either way, you’re right there is no point in clinging to it.
Now to extend this further:
The word body is just a concept we use, but really it is not distinguishable from the things the body experiences. The actual experience of the body, without the story of a body, is just a locust of sense experiences in space. Like, if my foot itches, there is actually just itching in an area of space that I label as my foot.
You recognised that "body" and "foot" are labels, but what about "an area of space"?
Close your eyes and notice an itch or another sensation.
Is there actually a sensation inside an area of space, or simply sensation present?
What tells you where the sensation is located?
Have a closer look at this.
When itching appears, notice whether there is also a mental image (aka also thought) or a mental map of the "body" that tells you where the itching is located.
Is the location actually contained in the sensation, or does the mental map provide that information? Is the location a reality or a description (thought content)?
The location info is not contained within the sensation. It’s very fast, but that location info comes in separate from the sensation of “itching”.


Now put the mental image aside for a moment. What remains? Is there itching in an area of space, or simply itching?
It is very subtle, but simply itching.

Can you find the space separately from the sensation?
Look carefully — are there two things, sensation AND space containing it, or is the space part of the description supplied by thought?
Just sensation. But, my mind is so habituated to add space to the sensation–to imagine sound as “over there”.
The actual experience of the body is thought. Thought points to sensations and colours and labels it a ‘body’, but can a body be found as actual experience or only thoughts about a body?
And if body is just a label pointing to experience (e.g. sensations, colours, smells, tastes), can a label experience things?


Yeah you’re right. There is just sensations (including thought) and the thought imagines the body.
Awakening is not about achieving or maintaining a particular state of spaciousness, peace, silence or bliss. These experiences may come and go, just like any other experience.
What we're investigating is something much simpler: whether a separate self actually exists or ever existed in the first place (with or without a state).
If it never existed, could it suddenly appear when thoughts become noisy, uncomfortable sensations arise, or the sense of spaciousness disappears?
The recognition of an illusion doesn't depend on how experience happens to appear at any particular moment.
Right. Thoughts just become noisy, uncomfortable sensation just arises, sensations of spaciousness just disappears.
Nothing is excluded.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: hello!

Postby poppyseed » Tue Nov 10, 2026 10:09 am

Hi Zach
Wonderful looking!!!
Let's explore something you mentioned:
But, they seem to be happening to “me”. Like, I’m over here and I see the plant over there. There seems to be a center of experience.
Look at that plant again (or something else).
Imagine drawing an invisible line from the plant towards wherever seeing seems to happen. Follow it all the way to its “receiving” end.
Where exactly does the line end? What is there? (Please provide a proper description; nothing seems like or feels like - direct experience only)
Can you find an actual observer receiving the image of the plant?
And is there a boundary or barrier that the image of the plant crosses, where the plant stops being "outside" and becomes an experience "inside"?
Can you find this dividing line in direct experience, or is the distinction between "here" and "there", "inside" and "outside", supplied by thought?
What exactly is found at the supposed control centre of experien
ce? Do you see a mini-me sitting in a miniature arm-chair :)?

Now let’s go to hearing…
But, in sound, there is definitely space. Like, listening to water trickle down my water fountain, I can move so far away from it that the sound disappears entirely. And, when I gradually get closer, it gradually gets louder.
Let's investigate hearing too. Close your eyes and listen to the fountain. There is sound, perhaps becoming louder or quieter as you move. But does the sound itself contain distance? We'll investigate cause and effect later...
Can you actually hear the space between the fountain and a listener? Or is there simply sound, with thought interpreting its loudness as distance?
Now follow the sound towards its supposed receiving end, just as with the image of the plant.
Where does hearing happen? Can you find a boundary where sound crosses from "outside" to "inside"?
Is there a separate hearer receiving the sound, or simply hearing?

You can explore the same thing with the smell of sardines. Does the smell itself contain a distance or location, or is that information supplied by thought? :)

Love
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Wed Nov 11, 2026 2:42 am

Look at that plant again (or something else).
Imagine drawing an invisible line from the plant towards wherever seeing seems to happen. Follow it all the way to its “receiving” end.
Where exactly does the line end? What is there? (Please provide a proper description; nothing seems like or feels like - direct experience only)
There is the thought that the line ends in the middle of my head.
Can you find an actual observer receiving the image of the plant?
No. There is just the sight of the plant and the thought that there is an observer of the plant. But, I cannot locate that observer with any of my senses except thought. I can’t see, hear, taste, smell or touch the observer. I can only think of the observer and location where the observer is.

And is there a boundary or barrier that the image of the plant crosses, where the plant stops being "outside" and becomes an experience "inside"?
In my direct experience, I’m not sure there is an “inside/outside” distinction. When I look closely, all I can really say is the plant is seen. It is not seen “inside” my head and it is not seen “outside” relative to some “inside”. But, when I add thought, it says that the plant is “outside” of the head where the perceiving of the plant is taking place.

Can you find this dividing line in direct experience, or is the distinction between "here" and "there", "inside" and "outside", supplied by thought?
I have to admit, given the above direct experience of seeing the plant, that the distinction is supplied or added later by thought. There does seem to be an “inside” though. Like, when mental images appear, they appear “inside”-- as in other people can’t see them.
What exactly is found at the supposed control centre of experience? Do you see a mini-me sitting in a miniature arm-chair :)?
I cannot find anything at all. It’s like a hall of mirrors.

Let's investigate hearing too. Close your eyes and listen to the fountain. There is sound, perhaps becoming louder or quieter as you move. But does the sound itself contain distance? We'll investigate cause and effect later…
Right. The sound does not contain distance in itself. It gets louder/softer relative to the proximity to the fountain, over time.

Can you actually hear the space between the fountain and a listener? Or is there simply sound, with thought interpreting its loudness as distance?
No. I can’t hear the space. You’re right it is just thought that interprets the loudness as proximity.
Now follow the sound towards its supposed receiving end, just as with the image of the plant.
Where does hearing happen? Can you find a boundary where sound crosses from "outside" to "inside"?
Is there a separate hearer receiving the sound, or simply hearing?
You’re right. Hearing doesn’t have a location. It is just happening. Thought/sense of time adds location/direction, and proximity.

You can explore the same thing with the smell of sardines. Does the smell itself contain a distance or location, or is that information supplied by thought? :)
You are right. Thought adds that information. It is not contained in smell itself.
Nothing is excluded.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: hello!

Postby poppyseed » Wed Nov 11, 2026 9:09 am

Hi Zach
Let's explore something you mentioned:
There does seem to be an “inside” though. Like, when mental images appear, they appear “inside”-- as in other people can’t see them.
Here's a little experiment :)
Close your eyes and imagine holding a watermelon in your hands. Imagine it as vividly as possible — its weight, shape, colour and the texture of its skin. Take a moment to really experience this imaginary watermelon. Now open your eyes.
What happened to the watermelon?
Was there ever an actual watermelon there, or was there a mental image and thoughts about one?

The mental image appeared — that much is undeniable. But was the watermelon described by the image actually present?
Now, let's return to your observation about "inside".
When a mental image appears, what exactly makes it inside?
Can you find an actual container or boundary around it? Does the image itself tell you where it is located?
Or is "inside my head" another thought describing the appearance of a mental image?


You also mentioned this:
There is the thought that the line ends in the middle of my head.
Let's investigate this further with a mirror exercise. Stand in front of a large mirror.
1. First, close the eyes and feel the sensations labelled ‘body’.
2. Then open the eyes and look into the mirror while still paying attention to the sensations. Is there any connection between the felt sensations and the image in the mirror? Or just thoughts (and/or mental images) suggest that there is?
3. While still paying attention to the sensations move one hand and observe the movement from the mirror. Is there any connection between the felt sensations (labelled ‘hand’) and image of movement in the mirror?
4. Now do the same movement with the hand, but this time look at the hand directly, not from the mirror. Is there any connection between the felt sensations (labelled ‘hand’) and the image ‘of movement’? Or only thoughts suggest it?
5. Now, pay attention only to the image in the mirror. Does the image by itself suggest in any way that is ‘you’ or ‘your body’? Does the image itself suggest in any way that it is a ‘body’ at all? Or are there only colours and shapes?
6. Where the mirror ends, some parts of the body (probably legs) cannot be seen. Just by the image in the mirror, is there any ‘knowledge’ that there must be legs, or only thoughts and mental images suggest so?
7. Now turn away from the mirror and look forward (don’t look directly to any body parts). Is there a ‘body’ anywhere when all thoughts and images are ignored, or are there only sensations?
8. Start to walk slowly.
Is there a ‘body walking’, or are there only sensations?
Is there actual experience of ‘walking’ at all?
Or just THOUGHTS ABOUT ‘walking’?
Can such a thing as ‘body’ be found OR just THOUGHTS ABOUT a ‘body’?
Can such a thing as ‘walking’ be found?

9. Are the sensations localized in space, like ‘going through the room’; OR is there only an image that is labelled ‘room’ and appearing sensations without any location?

Now return to your earlier observation that the receiving end of seeing seems to be in the middle of your head.
Press a finger down onto the top of the ‘head’. Notice what is actually present.
Is it a head, or is it just a sensation (labelled ‘pressure’) and thoughts ABOUT a head?
Do the same with a finger on each side of the head.
Is a head actually found, or are there just sensations again?
And is there anything between the pressure points, or are there just thoughts about something being in between them?

Without thought, how big is your head?
Without thought, does it have an inside or an outside?
Without thought, does it have a location?

Take your time with this and report what you actually find.
Love
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Wed Nov 11, 2026 4:46 pm

Hi Zach
Let's explore something you mentioned:
There does seem to be an “inside” though. Like, when mental images appear, they appear “inside”-- as in other people can’t see them.

Here's a little experiment :)
Close your eyes and imagine holding a watermelon in your hands. Imagine it as vividly as possible — its weight, shape, colour and the texture of its skin. Take a moment to really experience this imaginary watermelon. Now open your eyes.
What happened to the watermelon?
When i open my eyes, the sensations are still there, even the subtle sense of the sight of it in my hand are still there.
Was there ever an actual watermelon there, or was there a mental image and thoughts about one?
I’m not sure what we mean by “actual” watermelon anymore. If “actual” watermelon is just a specific pattern of sensations, and I was able to imagine that same pattern of sensations….
The mental image appeared — that much is undeniable. But was the watermelon described by the image actually present?
To my senses, it is present now as I type. The texture, the color and shape, the coldness. It’s all here now, even with my eyes open as I type this.
Now, let's return to your observation about "inside".
When a mental image appears, what exactly makes it inside?
It’s that others cant sense it, only I can.

Can you find an actual container or boundary around it? Does the image itself tell you where it is located?
/

I can imagine a container or boundary, but that is just a thought. The image/pattern of sensations itself does not tell me where it is located relative to something else. I can imagine a body and place the pattern of sensations called watermelon in a location relative to the body, but that is just thought.

Or is "inside my head" another thought describing the appearance of a mental image?
Yes, inside the head is imagined–a thought.
You also mentioned this:

There is the thought that the line ends in the middle of my head.

Let's investigate this further with a mirror exercise. Stand in front of a large mirror.
1. First, close the eyes and feel the sensations labelled ‘body’.
2. Then open the eyes and look into the mirror while still paying attention to the sensations. Is there any connection between the felt sensations and the image in the mirror? Or just thoughts
(and/or mental images) suggest that there is?
So, the sensations are feelings of warmth, with varying degrees of intensity. There is no connection between the color/shape in the mirror and those sensations of warmth, other than the thought that there is.
3. While still paying attention to the sensations move one hand and observe the movement from the mirror. Is there any connection between the felt sensations (labelled ‘hand’) and image of movement in the mirror?
Yes. The sensation feels noticeably different when the image of the hand is moving versus when it is at rest.
4. Now do the same movement with the hand, but this time look at the hand directly, not from the mirror. Is there any connection between the felt sensations (labelled ‘hand’) and the image ‘of movement’? Or only thoughts suggest it?
Yes. Same result–they are correlated even more so than just the image in the mirror.
5. Now, pay attention only to the image in the mirror. Does the image by itself suggest in any way that is ‘you’ or ‘your body’? Does the image itself suggest in any way that it is a ‘body’ at all? Or are there only colours and shapes?
The image is just color/shape. Thought says it is a body and that body is a “me”.
6. Where the mirror ends, some parts of the body (probably legs) cannot be seen. Just by the image in the mirror, is there any ‘knowledge’ that there must be legs, or only thoughts and mental images suggest so?
Only thoughts infer it.
7. Now turn away from the mirror and look forward (don’t look directly to any body parts). Is there a ‘body’ anywhere when all thoughts and images are ignored, or are there only sensations?
Only sensations that seems to come and go.
8. Start to walk slowly.
Is there a ‘body walking’, or are there only sensations?
There are only sensations of pressure, tightness, feelings of weight and pull.
Is there actual experience of ‘walking’ at all?
No. Walking is a concept–a thought.
Or just THOUGHTS ABOUT ‘walking’?
[q/uote]
Correct. Body is a concept–only thoughts that say body is a specific pattern of sensations. No. Only concepts of walking. A thought which says walking is a specific pattern of sensations. In direct experience, there are just the immediate sensations, but thought adds the concepts “room”, and “space”, and “locations”. Thought says specific patterns of sensation are a “room” and locate a “body” relation to the “room” using “space”.
Just a sensation of pressure followed by thoughts saying “this is a head”. Just sensations and a subtle thought “this is a head”. I can’t see between the pressure points. But, thought says “there is always something between two points”.
Without thought, I don’t have a relative sense of the size of it, or a comparison. No. It is just the sensation of “warmth”. Without thought, I can’t determine its relative dimensions. I can’t tell where it ends. No.
Nothing is excluded.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: hello!

Postby poppyseed » Thu Nov 12, 2026 9:46 am

Hi Zach
You're noticing how thought supplies labels, locations and connections between experiences. Let's clarify one important distinction before moving on.
I’m not sure what we mean by “actual” watermelon anymore. If “actual” watermelon is just a specific pattern of sensations, and I was able to imagine that same pattern of sensations….
Let's explore the difference between imagination (e.g. mental sensations) and direct experience (e.g. sensations) a little further. I hope you like chocolate! :)
1. Imaginary chocolate
Close your eyes and imagine eating a piece of chocolate. Imagine its taste, the texture, the aroma, and the sensation of it melting in your mouth. Make the experience as vivid as possible.
2. Real chocolate
Now take an actual piece of chocolate and eat it. Notice the taste, texture, smell and sensations as they happen. Take your time and enjoy it!
3. Description of chocolate
Finally, describe the experience of eating the chocolate in as much detail as possible. Write down what it was like.
Now compare these three:
• Imagining eating chocolate
• Actually eating chocolate
• Describing the experience of eating chocolate
What differences do you notice?
Are the imagined taste and texture the same as the actual taste and texture?
Does the description reproduce the experience, or is it a thought ABOUT the experience?
All three are experienced in some way, but are they the same?

And when you say the imagined watermelon is still present, is there an actual watermelon available to the senses, or are there thoughts and mental images ABOUT one (aka memories)?
Remember, we're not investigating whether imagination happens — of course it does! We're distinguishing the experience of thought from what thought describes.
Please report what you actually notice rather than reasoning about it.

And one more thing, Zach :)
When a mental image appears, what exactly makes it inside?
It’s that others cant sense it, only I can.
When you encounter another person, what is actually experienced? (think cup of coffee exercise)
In DE there is only seeing/hearing/etc. and thinking provides the labels. It’s like a picture that everything is drawn in pencil on paper – the illusion of separation is created by different colours used – otherwise it’s all paper.

Image

Different colours in seeing create the illusion of things (e.g. others) but all that is there is seeing. Also, is there space where these others exist?
It is only language that makes the experienced appear separated. When you see the bird in the sky, there is a movement of shapes and colors, labels come up— “bird,” “sky,” “in.” Can you experience a bird without sky, outside of sky (while looking up)? What is the difference between “here” and “there” without thought content?
When you touch 'another', are there two sensations one of 'you' and one of 'other' or just one/just feeling? Are others outside of feeling? Where is the border that marks where feeling ends and "other" begin?


Can the “I”/”inside” of “others” be directly experienced, or is it assumed? Can you directly experience "others"?

How we approach “others” from DE is the same way we see there is no “apple” – that apple is a label. Why would objects be different from ‘others’? Why were objects easier? What about animals? If we have to repeat the same example but with a “person”:
Taste labelled ‘person’ is known
Color (visual information) labelled ‘person’ is known
Sensation labelled ‘person’ is known (when a person is touched)
Smell labelled ‘person’ is known
Thought about/of a ‘person’ is known
However, is a ‘person' actually known? (Or is it just a label?) Is there really an ‘person’ here, or only color and a thought ABOUT ‘person’? Can ‘a person’ be found in actual experience?

So there are colours, sounds, perhaps sensations, smells, and thoughts labelling these as "another person", right? Can those colours or sounds experience anything?
And how do you know that this "other person" has their own separate "inside" where experiences happen? Can you directly experience that, or is it something thought assumes?
Now back to “only I (can experience “inside”)”… turn the investigation around.
What is the evidence that there is an "inside" here, with a separate "you" experiencing mental images?
When a mental image appears, is there an actual "I" experiencing it, or is there simply the appearance of a mental image?
What exactly makes the image "yours"? Is there anything in the image itself that establishes an owner?

Look for this "I" that can sense the image. What exactly can you find?
Can you find two separate experiencers, one here and another over there, or are there experiences and thoughts describing them that way?

Love
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Thu Nov 12, 2026 10:26 pm


Let's explore the difference between imagination (e.g. mental sensations) and direct experience (e.g. sensations) a little further. I hope you like chocolate! :)
1. Imaginary chocolate
Close your eyes and imagine eating a piece of chocolate. Imagine its taste, the texture, the aroma, and the sensation of it melting in your mouth. Make the experience as vivid as possible.
2. Real chocolate
Now take an actual piece of chocolate and eat it. Notice the taste, texture, smell and sensations as they happen. Take your time and enjoy it!
3. Description of chocolate
Finally, describe the experience of eating the chocolate in as much detail as possible. Write down what it was like.
Now compare these three:
• Imagining eating chocolate
• Actually eating chocolate
• Describing the experience of eating chocolate
What differences do you notice?
I can’t actually imagine eating chocolate because there is so much taste/texture already happening in my mouth presently that I can’t seem to override that does not match the pattern of sensations of eating chocolate. It’s like trying to imagine a pop song playing while another different pop song is also playing.

But, I can presently imagine a watermelon in my hand because there is ordinarily only a subtle amount of pressure on my hand and only a subtle warmth to it. When I imagine the watermelon in my hand, the contrast from the prior state is intense. I can feel the sensation of pressure intensify and the warmth change to coolness. I can also feel the texture/shape.

I think the main difference between imagined sensations and “real” sensations is intensity. A real watermelon in my hand (versus an imagined one) feels more intense…more pressure, more coolness, more detailed shape/texture. Like a train whistle sound feels more intense 20 feet away versus 1 mile away.
Are the imagined taste and texture the same as the actual taste and texture?
No. The sensations are more subtle when imagined. They are more intense and vivid when “real”.
Does the description reproduce the experience, or is it a thought ABOUT the experience?
Just a thought about the experience.
All three are experienced in some way, but are they the same?
No. The imagined watermelon and the actual watermelon vary only in intensity of sensation (pressure, texture, temperature). Like a train whistle sound 20 feet away versus a mile away. The description of it is just thought.
And when you say the imagined watermelon is still present, is there an actual watermelon available to the senses, or are there thoughts and mental images ABOUT one (aka memories)?
The sensations themselves do not contain information about their source. Thought comes in and says I imagined the watermelon and that created the sensations of one in my hand.
When you encounter another person, what is actually experienced? (think cup of coffee exercise)
Just raw sensations and thought–seeing, touching, smelling, thoughts of “this is another person”.
Different colours in seeing create the illusion of things (e.g. others) but all that is there is seeing. Also, is there space where these others exist?
No, all the colors fit together without a gap.
When you see the bird in the sky, there is a movement of shapes and colors, labels come up— “bird,” “sky,” “in.” Can you experience a bird without sky, outside of sky (while looking up)?
No, bird and sky are one thing. Like bee and flower.
What is the difference between “here” and “there” without thought content?
Colors and a sensation of depth.
When you touch 'another', are there two sensations one of 'you' and one of 'other' or just one/just feeling?
There is just the sensation of touch. Thought adds, “I am touching another”.
Are others outside of feeling? Where is the border that marks where feeling ends and "other" begin?
No. From the perspective of the sensation of feeling/touch, there is just feeling/touch, and then thought adds, “this feels like the specific pattern of sensations of another”.
Can the “I”/”inside” of “others” be directly experienced, or is it assumed? Can you directly experience "others"?
No. Only thought comes in and says “because I am here they must be here , too”
How we approach “others” from DE is the same way we see there is no “apple” – that apple is a label. Why would objects be different from ‘others’? Why were objects easier?
Thought says objects are easier because a part of me does not identify as an “object” like an “apple”, but rather like a “person” who senses other “persons”. It’s like patterns of sensations resonate with other similar and familiar patterns of sensations. We resonate with each other more than we do say, dissimilar patterns of sensations, such as those called “apple”.
What about animals?
Yes, same idea. Thoughts say when the pattern of sensation is an animal, and that pattern is known in memory as something like “dog”, thought adds a familiarity and a resonance that does not arise with the pattern of sensations called “apple”. More thoughts come in and say “it sounds like just old conditioning.”
If we have to repeat the same example but with a “person”:
Taste labelled ‘person’ is known
Color (visual information) labelled ‘person’ is known
Sensation labelled ‘person’ is known (when a person is touched)
Smell labelled ‘person’ is known
Thought about/of a ‘person’ is known
However, is a ‘person' actually known? (Or is it just a label?)
It is just a label/word/concept used to describe a specific pattern of sensations.
Is there really an ‘person’ here, or only color and a thought ABOUT ‘person’?
Only sensations arising together and a thought “these sensations must be a person”
Can ‘a person’ be found in actual experience?
Just in thought, as a concept/word.
So there are colours, sounds, perhaps sensations, smells, and thoughts labelling these as "another person", right? Can those colours or sounds experience anything?
I’m not sure. How could it be known either way in direct experience? Can sensation experience other sensation? Like, can sound experience smell? How could I investigate that?
And how do you know that this "other person" has their own separate "inside" where experiences happen?
Just thought, and hearing, when they tell me they have their own separate “inside”, and thought translates that hearing into words and understanding. Also, although I’m around my wife all the time, the thought never arises, “ I am caitlin”.
Can you directly experience that, or is it something thought assumes?
By definition of “inside”, I can’t directly experience it.

It’s something thought assumes about “others”. All that can be directly experienced is that a thought arises which does not appear to have any effect on anything else. By contrast, when a loudspeaker is played close to the ear of a crowd of people, they all react. The sound of the loudspeaker is not “inside”. I guess you could say the sound of the loudspeaker is limited or “inside” a certain radius, or its sensation has only a certain intensity. After all, at some distance, no one reacts to the loudspeaker, it does not even register for them. So, perhaps “thought” is like that. It is a sensation that is limited or “inside” only a certain radius.
Now back to “only I (can experience “inside”)”… turn the investigation around.
What is the evidence that there is an "inside" here, with a separate "you" experiencing mental images?
The evidence that there is an “inside” is that when thought appears other persons do not seem to register it. Like when I ask my wife to guess which color I’m thinking, she cannot. The thought “red” is arising, yet it is not perceived by her. Like a dog whistle. The frequency of the pitch is so high, that even though I blow the whistle, only the dog can hear it.

There is no separate “me” experiencing the thought. The thought is just appearing.
When a mental image appears, is there an actual "I" experiencing it, or is there simply the appearance of a mental image?
Just the appearance and then a thought which says “I am experiencing the image”
What exactly makes the image "yours"? Is there anything in the image itself that establishes an owner?
Others can’t automatically perceive the image. There is nothing in the image itself that establishes an owner. There is a thought that the image is only perceived by a “me”.
Look for this "I" that can sense the image. What exactly can you find?
I can’t find anything. It is a hall of mirrors, a seemingly infinite regression of mental positions.
Can you find two separate experiencers, one here and another over there, or are there experiences and thoughts describing them that way?
I can’t find any experiencers. Just thoughts arising which claim to be the experiencer.
Nothing is excluded.

User avatar
poppyseed
Posts: 3008
Joined: Sun May 20, 2018 5:28 pm
Location: South Africa
Contact:

Re: hello!

Postby poppyseed » Fri Nov 13, 2026 10:00 am

Hi Zach,
I notice that you didn't actually complete the chocolate exercise. Instead, you went back to the watermelon example and explained how you think imagination and sensation differ.
Remember, we're not interested in explanations, theories or memories of previous experiences (the colour of your socks analogy in my intro). If these were working you wouldn't be here. The whole point is to DO the experiment and observe what happens RIGHT NOW. Imagining doing an exercise or reasoning about its possible outcome is not the same as actually doing it :)
Please get a real piece of chocolate (or any other food you enjoy – like the “pop song” that is playing right now ;) ) and repeat all three steps:
1. Imagine eating it. Notice what is actually present during imagining.
2. Now physically eat it. Notice the actual taste, smell and sensations.
3. Describe the experience in words.

Compare the three experiences while they are fresh, not from memory.
Is the difference between imagining and actually tasting merely one of intensity? What else is there, what else is missing? What exactly is present in each case? I want a proper report for each case – not a summary (thought content ABOUT)
And remember, a thought/memory about a sensation is not necessarily the sensation itself. That's what we're investigating.
Take your time and report what you actually observe, rather than what you think should be happening.

Now this:
I’m not sure. How could it be known either way in direct experience? Can sensation experience other sensation? Like, can sound experience smell? How could I investigate that?
I think we're getting a little tangled up in language again :)
Remember, even words like "sensation", "sound", "seeing", "hearing" and "thought" are just labels we use to describe WHAT IS happening.
They're not separate entities or things with abilities of their own. We're simply using these categories to distinguish direct experience from the stories and explanations about it.
We don’t experience our senses individually. Rather, these are different aspects of experience. Thought tells us that our senses are separate streams of information. We see with our eyes, hear with our ears, feel with our skin, smell with our nose, taste with our tongue. In DE, though, it is seen as a one smooth/inseparable experience. Senses affect each other. Although speech is perceived through the ears, what we see can change what we hear. In this video, a man produces the same syllable over and over again. If you watch his mouth, you’ll hear the syllable “fah,” but if you look away, you’ll hear “bah.” Although your ears hear “bah,” your eyes see “fah”. This phenomenon is known as the McGurk effect. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2k8fHR9jKVM )
Another example of sensory interaction is how both taste and smell are vital for savouring food (flavour). If smell is lost or impaired, for instance, the taste of food will also be impaired, even if taste receptors on the tongue are working fine.
Here is a fun video that demonstrates a relationship between sight and touch:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DphlhmtGRqI
Even though it might look as there are clearly defined senses, DE shows a different story. Check for yourself:
Close your eyes and allow a thought or a series of thoughts to appear. Continue to pay attention to thoughts as they appear for a few more seconds. With your eyes still closed, listen to whatever sound is present for several moments. Now, go back and forth between thoughts and the sound.
Does the sound appear in a different “place” to thoughts – in “space”? Can you find an actual line / wall / boundary that divides the thoughts and the sound? Or is the line a mental construct?
The DE labels (and others) are useful for communication, but we shouldn’t confuse language for direct experience. I suppose the analogy with the icons on your computer desktop comes handy. They are used as a visual representation of what is actually a binary code – zeros and ones - so you can make use of them. But is the icon of email really a box with mail in it?
Without the labels there is just THIS/what IS. In Buddhism the term “suchness” or “thusness” (whatever is happening) is used, referring to the nature of reality free from conceptual elaborations and the subject–object distinction. I like the word “THIS” as it is more like a pointing word – pointing to whatever is directly experienced like an arrow with no extra meaning – rather than labelling the experience.

So when you ask:
Can sensation experience other sensation? Like, can sound experience smell?
Notice what happens here. You're taking labels used to describe experience and turning them into things that might do the experiencing. It’s just like saying that the grass is growing and assuming that there is something called grass that does the growing. It’s one indivisible whole, which can only be divided by words; words that are believed to be real things, objects.
When there's a prominent "hearing", we call what is experienced "sound". When there's a prominent "feeling", we call it "sensation". These are descriptions, not explanations of how experience happens. It's like looking at a lava lamp. The wax may seem to change shape, and the shapes it seems to take may seem to be present one moment, and absent the next. But all that is known is the wax. Nothing actually changed and nothing was ever born or lost, although it may have seemed to. All that is known is THIS - nothing can be added to it, nor taken away.

The question isn't whether a sound can experience a smell - that's just language.
The improtant question is whether an actual separate experiencer can be found anywhere in what is happening.
And remember, even "experiencer" is just a word. Does that word point to an actual entity in direct experience?
Let's keep the investigation simple and grounded in what is actually happening, rather than trying to solve it through language.
Love
Rali
Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in. ~Alan Alda
The mind that aims to understand reality can consider itself satisfied only by reducing it to terms of thought. ~ Albert Camus

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Fri Nov 13, 2026 9:02 pm

Hello, Rali.

a breakthrough occurred just now and wanted to share with you. Apologize if this is out of turn.

There is a sensation that thought called "me" or "I". No doubt the sensation is there--it is a glowing bright yellow that pulses. But, it is now clearly seen as impersonal. Thought comes in later and adds, "that feeling is me" and "I am here". But, that thought is not true.

The thought also says the sensation has location. It says it is "radiating in the chest and in the head". It is still not clearly seen that this sense of location (position in space in relation to something else) is just a concept that thought has.
Nothing is excluded.

User avatar
nobody435
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2026 3:19 am

Re: hello!

Postby nobody435 » Fri Nov 13, 2026 10:26 pm


Please get a real piece of chocolate (or any other food you enjoy – like the “pop song” that is playing right now ;) ) and repeat all three steps:
1. Imagine eating it. Notice what is actually present during imagining.
What is here during imagining in order of appearance:

Thought of bacon flavored salt on the tongue
Thought of feeling of a dotted texture
Thought of feeling of texture changing from spiky/prickly to round
Thought of taste of salt-like flavor

2. Now physically eat it. Notice the actual taste, smell and sensations.
What is here during physical eating in order of appearance:

Feeling of roughness and contrasting smoothness
Feeling of texture changing from spiky to round
Tasting of sweetness and saltyness
Smell of butter-like smell


3. Describe the experience in words.
It started off as rough an spiky and moved to more round as the taste and smell of salt and butter began to increase and then disappear again.

Compare the three experiences while they are fresh, not from memory.
Is the difference between imagining and actually tasting merely one of intensity?

It is clear that thought is creating the “imagined” sensation from past experiences because thought comes first and then the imagined sensation. The imagined sensations that follow thought are less intense/vivid, but essentially track the sequence of sensations of eating real bacon flavored salt.
What else is there, what else is missing?
I’m not sure what to say to this question–I don’t understand it.
What exactly is present in each case?
In each case, there is the same sequence of sensations (aside from imagined sensations beginning with thought)–a texture morphing from rough/spiky to round, followed by the same taste/smell of salt and butter.

In “imagined” sensation, the source of the sensation appears as “thought” and in the “real” sensation, the source appears to be something other than thought– it just appears.


Now this:
I’m not sure. How could it be known either way in direct experience? Can sensation experience other sensation? Like, can sound experience smell? How could I investigate that?
I think we're getting a little tangled up in language again :)
Remember, even words like "sensation", "sound", "seeing", "hearing" and "thought" are just labels we use to describe WHAT IS happening.

Thought tells us that our senses are separate streams of information. We see with our eyes, hear with our ears, feel with our skin, smell with our nose, taste with our tongue. In DE, though, it is seen as a one smooth/inseparable experience.
Yes, this is what I was telling you about at the beginning when it felt like you wanted me to “oblige” you by pretending there were actually distinct sensations as touch, taste, smell, etc, and I was saying that some of those distinctions were not feeling clear anymore. I see the value in making those distinctions however for this process. I want to follow the rules you lay down to help you understand where I am in this process. But, sometimes it feels like they conflict with rules about being honest with what is actually experienced. I agree language is not developed enough to handle this smoothly all the time and ask for your patience and understanding.

Even though it might look as there are clearly defined senses, DE shows a different story. Check for yourself:
Close your eyes and allow a thought or a series of thoughts to appear. Continue to pay attention to thoughts as they appear for a few more seconds. With your eyes still closed, listen to whatever sound is present for several moments. Now, go back and forth between thoughts and the sound.
Does the sound appear in a different “place” to thoughts – in “space”?
The sound and thought arise in the same “place”. Going back and forth, the sound appears to become quieter or less “in focus”, as the thought appears to take up more of the “room”, and visa versa.
Can you find an actual line / wall / boundary that divides the thoughts and the sound? Or is the line a mental construct?
It is clearly a mental construct.
The DE labels (and others) are useful for communication, but we shouldn’t confuse language for direct experience. I suppose the analogy with the icons on your computer desktop comes handy. They are used as a visual representation of what is actually a binary code – zeros and ones - so you can make use of them. But is the icon of email really a box with mail in it?
No, just a label/concept.

The question isn't whether a sound can experience a smell - that's just language.
The improtant question is whether an actual separate experiencer can be found anywhere in what is happening.
And remember, even "experiencer" is just a word. Does that word point to an actual entity in direct experience?
Correct. There is just the “experience”, which may include a thought “there is a separate experiencer.”
Nothing is excluded.


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Noro, Robshin and 20 guests