Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
vegansatori
Posts: 393
Joined: Sun May 23, 2021 3:35 am

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby vegansatori » Thu Dec 15, 2022 5:21 am

G’Day Barry!
Thank you for YOUR time and dedication to this. I quite literally wouldn't be writing any of this if it weren't for you.
Likewise!
I meditated on this. It was not what I at all expected.
Can you tell me exactly what you’re doing when you meditate? Especially on things like this?
Quite easily I was able to reach that stillness. The body melted and all that remained was tension from the eyes up. I may have been rolling my eyes up. I felt it very much behind the eyes and the region described as the third eye. When I meditate I generally focus in this third eye region as it seems to quickly dispel most thoughts. This place felt quite solid, like a rock and I tried to melt that away as well but could not.
But... back to the jailcell the only thing keeping me solid was that place in the head. Other than that no jail cell, no self in that place.
I have no issue with you continuing to meditate, but I might suggest not doing the third-eye focus right now because as you found, it’s reinforcing that sense of eye-strain. HOWEVER, it’s a good chance to notice that there is just tension in the head. Is that tension any sort of indication of being a self? Can it be dismissed just as tension? In order to see through the self you don’t need to completely evaporate all senses of the body. Just check out what’s there and discover if any of it is proof of an enduring self.
This is all wonderful! How much is conceptual reasoning, and how much really hits you in that way that makes you laugh, or feel like “Oh yeah, of course!!!”?
About 50/50. I do recognize there is a lot of conceptual in what I'm saying (well 100% when it's actually communicated but you know what I mean)--- but something about that feels really, really right. Like this is just how it has to work for me. I'm conceptually pointing it out to myself and then going there. You're pointing, I'm pointing, and then I dive in.
This sounds fine. It’s a process, and it’s different for everyone. As long as the scale is tipping towards to the felt and not the conceptual, we’re on the right track!
Let’s pretend that those doubts are correct for a moment. Do they have any suggestions on how you should be looking? Or what you would see if you looked correctly? Are they implying that there IS a self, but that you’re just not looking in the right place?
I believe just another layer and not a big deal. I'm sure I'll have doubt even after "seeing" no self.
Yeah, that’s a tricky one. Technically speaking, if there’s any doubt, it’s taken as a sign that you haven’t fully dropped the self illusion. But I think we are awash in so much hyperbole and mixed messages about what to expect that it’s natural to wonder if you’ve seen what’s being pointed to or not. The same thing happened to me.

How about during your daily life, not on a meditation cushion. What is your basic functioning like? Do you feel like you’re an experiencer and doer in the same way you used to? Has anything changed in that regard?
There is no self. I can't find anything I'd consider a self other than just "feeling like someone operating separately in a world of other things."
And what you’re describing is really more of a Fetter 6 subject/object duality issue more so than the basic illusion of self.
The doubt is just noise.
Great! But does it ever get believed?

The feeling like I am someone even though I can't find a someone... yet still feel like someone is.... is... what I'm trying to see through.
But I have to imagine that it's like any other feeling and it just needs to be felt. If I feel sad I should feel sad. I won't always feel sad and I wont always feel like a self... if reasoning serves me correctly.
It depends on what exactly that feeling is, and how strong it is. Some feeling of being an “I” will actually linger until Fetter 8 is seen through, using that model. But apparently it is something that can eventually go away altogether. (Not there yet myself!)

I would say, to be safe, keep looking deeply into whatever that feeling is when you feel it. Where is it? What senses is it found in? Just bore your attention into it to really find out of it’s a real thing or just another mirage. You never know how deeply you might see by doing that!
Where do I feel the most like a self? In the head.
Where in the head?
Behind the eyes.
I know it all goes back to thought. There is sight and then very very quickly there is a feeling of something looking out through the eyes. It's so subtle.
I don't know how to see it any differently other than continue with the questioning, continue looking and meditating.
Yup, those are your best tools for this. The philosophizing and conceptualizing will never do it.

Keep looking at exactly what it is behind the eyes.
It might help to amp it up by "intentionally" looking around the room and feel as centered behind your eyes as you can. Really enhance the feeling of being a looker in control of your eyes. And then once that feeling is strong, investigate into it to find out what that feeling is really made of. Is it physical sensations, internal images, thoughts, a combination of all of them? Don't just look quickly once and assume that's good enough. Stick with it repeatedly, really exploring the current experience of what it feels like to be a self located behind the eyes.

Again, if the spot behind the eyes is the most persuasive place of feeling like a self, keep coming back to the sensation every time throughout the day that it's noticed. And then really search it for anything that could be considered a permanent, unchanging self that can actually move the eyes and control experiences.
And again, I love hearing you say over and over that with no labels, there is no self/Barry! Does that feel like an experiential understanding, or is it purely intellectual?
A mix. That experiential understanding is so limited. The gap between the no self/Barry/nothing and labels is so small. An eyeblink. Trusting that in time this gap will widened and I'll be able to take it in more deeply.
That’s okay, at least you notice it’s there! It’s true, it will expand. But just noticing that the labels are simply labels is the most important thing here. You can still see a mirage, but you don’t believe it once you know it’s not real.
Thoughts simply appear... is that also true? not sure...
Can you make a thought appear at will?
No I cannot. I guess how they appear doesn't matter. I have no control one way or the other.
Totally true! How does it feel to have no control?
So far no feelings arise. Control or rather lack their of was one of the main triggers to that fear I spoke of before.
I know I said this before but there is also some untrust with thoughts too (sometimes). Right now I recognize it's a thought that is telling me I have no control.
In DE I don't see control.... LOL what would control even look like in DE?
Hahaha even control is conceptual. No control because no controller and no on to be controlled.
Totally, but how much of that is conceptual vs. “aha!”?

A thought comes about the watcher. Oh geeze now we have a new name for it LOL.
These thoughts are like children. Just coming up to say something.
These thoughts seem to believe in SOMETHING.
Do thoughts believe?
Oh man, I'm not even going there. Its like asking is the sky really blue?
Who the hell knows what thoughts are let alone if they believe LOL.
Okay... no... I can answer this I think.... Thoughts can't believe.
Using DE there is just the recognition of a belief which is just a thought thing. Like a feeling.
Can I feel a belief in DE?
I can feel the effects of when a belief is tested-- fear, anger, anxiety. But those aren't DE either. Those are more labels.
It would look like racing heart, tight chest....
Okay, so I’m so tempted to send you that video to help clear up some of the functions of this stuff, but again, you’re already so prone to overthinking, and I don’t know if it would satisfy that craving or just add fuel to the fire.

I love that you keep coming back to DE and derailing the thoughts after a while.

You’re right that a belief is just a thought. And what’s important is to investigate: WHO is holding that belief? Is there any inherent validity to any belief, or are they all just thoughts which are virtually indistinguishable from any other random thought?

Try this: Close the eyes. Allow any belief that you hold to come to mind. That the earth is round, that the sun is hot, that the feeling behind the eyes is proof of a self, whatever. And then, (this is the part that’s hard to describe), for me I would describe it as turning attention inwards, towards or around the thought itself, wherever that appears. And see if it’s attached to anything. Is it a tangible thing? Does it persist indefinitely or is it just a memory by the time you can turn towards it? Is there anybody attached to it in any way? Is there a thinker of it? Is there anything about it that determines its validity? Investigate everything about the experience of feeling/noticing/believing a belief.
How does it feel to have no control?
Looking for some big realization but none comes. Huh. Oh well. LOL
Notice that the expectation is just another thought. Relax that shit! ;-) By the time the recognition of disappointment or searching appears, you’re already lost in thought. What does it feel like to have the feeling of no control, even if it brings no further insight?
Do you feel like you’ve seen through the self then, or are there still doubts arising?
Still doubts though I honestly don't know what it would feel like to see through this. I've had small shifts / realizations and what to keep looking and asking.
Then we’ll just keep going! :- )
Doubts arise but there is not stopping a doubt / thought.
I don't believe them as much these last few days.
That’s a great change!
I still feel very much like "Barry".
Hmmm... what does "Barry" feel like?
He's constantly changing. He's not even a He. Just another label.
Barry has a bunch of likes and dislikes.
What does it FEEL like to be "Barry?"
body sensations.
Breath color and smells. Sounds. Searching. Thoughts.
Lots of mind activity.
That’s good. Keep looking into what it feels like to be Barry. You’re spot on with the things you said. So in those descriptions I can’t find a Barry. Can you? So what if those sensations always exist? Who says they are Barry? SERIOUSLY? Thoughts happen. Are thoughts Barry? They won’t stop when the self is seen through. Sounds and sights and breath and everything else in your experience will persist. What won’t be there is the thing that was NEVER there. What was there that is no longer there? A belief. When we drop a belief it might change everything, or it might not.

For instance, some people are brought up devoutly Christian, and then for one reason or another, lose faith and become devout atheists. For some of them there can be a huge shift when something that seemed so unquestionably real (the existence of God and the truth of the Bible) no longer feels right at all. It shakes them to the core because they've lost a huge part of their identity and the belief structure that they relied upon for security and a way of triangulating their position in the world. Suddenly they can no longer fabricate those beliefs, and they feel detached from the versions of themselves who were ever able to believe it.

That’s basically what we’re doing here, but instead of God, the self is the old belief. And once it’s obvious that it’s not there and never was, we just can’t go back to believing the old fallacy anymore. And the freedom from that delusion can be liberating for some people. Shockingly so for some, less so for others.

Personally, I was never able to believe in God even as a child, so when I eventually heard people say that God doesn’t exist, it wasn’t shocking for me. I had always assimilated part of that in my belief system. (Now I'm just agnostic to everything, btw, and I'm not pushing any belief system. Just using this as the clearest metaphor I can think of.)

In that same way, you have already assimilated the idea that there is no self so heavily, and seen so many glimpses of it, that I doubt you will have an earth-shattering realization about it. It’s already been cognitively assimilated. You just need to fully prove to yourself that you have exhausted every possible nook and cranny where the self could possibly be hiding. Then the doubt will dissolve and you'll be done.

Does that help clarify at all?

What more are you expecting to happen at this stage?
I don't know. All I know is I want to continue.
Then we will! :- )
I have to say, I'm loving these questions and looking. It feels like I had some back room closed off for years and I'm finally going in there to clean it out.
Fantastic! I’m glad we’re finally getting you to look in some new areas. That seems very positive! It feels like things are coming to a head.
I have no idea what I'm going to find / throw out. I have no idea if it's going to lead to enlightenment or no self or whatever but for the first time I don't even care. It just feels good to get in there and look around.
Well, it can’t lead to no-self because there’s always only been no-self! Lol Like nothing can lead to no-elephant in your house. You never had an elephant in there to begin with, so what would it even mean to reach a state of no-elephant in a house where one never existed? Feel into that!

Thank you, and you’re more than welcome!
Be well!
-Todd
That relaxation of the clenched "myself" feels like having been roused from a dream to find oneself alive and aware...Each moment feels fresh, different from any other, and entirely unspeakable...And that is sufficient.- Robert Saltzman

User avatar
BarBarryN
Posts: 60
Joined: Fri Aug 13, 2021 5:33 am
Location: Portland, ME USA

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby BarBarryN » Sat Dec 17, 2022 8:48 pm

Good afternoon Todd!

Very busy these last few days. I haven't been able to get a response to everything but I wanted to send you something.

I will reply with the other questions as soon as I can.


Love this!!! But let that insight REALLY sink in! THERE IS NO JAIL CELL! LABELS ARE NOT REAL! Expand that out. What else is a label that is not real? Can you feel that the idea of a self is the same thing as a jail cell? Like really FEEL that to be the case?
I meditated on this. It was not what I at all expected.
Can you tell me exactly what you’re doing when you meditate? Especially on things like this?
I meditate for ten minutes using guided meditations on the Waking Up App. And then I do 15 minutes of breathing meditation / self inquiry. During self inquiry I asked “What if there is no jail cell.” I was trying to to FEEL into this question. Any recommendations on how to FEEL an idea?


Is that tension any sort of indication of being a self? Can it be dismissed just as tension?
Just tension. Dismissed.


How about during your daily life, not on a meditation cushion. What is your basic functioning like? Do you feel like you’re an experiencer and doer in the same way you used to? Has anything changed in that regard?
This is changing day to day. Sometimes I do feel like an experiencer and other times it’s just functioning. Right now, for instance, the I thoughts aren’t here. Just the words. Just now though, typing that the selfing comes. An image of your face appears (thanks to zoom) and I see you wondering what you’ll think of this. The I is wondering this. So strange that the I which I’m trying to see through is the I that “wants this”. Most of the time I don’t notice I thoughts… though I could see that being tricky… it feels like me I may not associate that as an I thought.
The catching of my “selfing” has helped and then there is just the DE. These moments are brief but having several more than usual.


The doubt is just noise.
Sometimes for sure. I have started question “Who believes this?” Silence.


I would say, to be safe, keep looking deeply into whatever that feeling is when you feel it. Where is it? What senses is it found in?
I’m noticing feelings more these last few days. I see a lot of fear painting my experience. More than other primal feelings. I see this has been the case for a while now… years and years and years… Just the recognition of this feels like a milestone. Nothing has changed in regards to the fear, but seeing it there is a bit freeing. I will look then for the one that is afraid.
(an hour or so later)
I did this and became very anxious. Facing fears is tough and something I need to work on I see. All kinds of fears! Hard to even look for a self when fearing. Stories come up. Stories about me. Oof I’m so quick to back down out of that fear. There feels like some openness in there though. Some fears I can clearly see aren’t real or are trivial. Some fears like death seem very real in that moment.
Very conceptual right now. In DE there are sounds and taste. Colors. Thought stuff.

Knowing fear is a common occurrence when going through this sort of process I think I need learn how to become comfortable with fear. Or at least see if for what it really is... just a thought with general physical properties... it's these physical things that I am afraid of though I see.

Afraid of a racing heart = heart attack. That though is me putting a label on a racing heart. Upset stomach = disease. I'm afraid that the fear will trigger these things? With the heart for sure.
How likely is it that fear will actually do bodily harm? Probably pretty unlikely right?
That's it. I'm afraid the fear will do actual bodily harm. Can I see that that is also just a thought? A belief?

Who believes that the fear will do bodily harm?
I don't believe any other emotion can kill me so why fear?
Just looking at it that starts to feel silly.

It's definitely the beating heart when it gets ramped up that really starts to scare me.
These thoughts come telling me hey you don't want to have a heart attack do you?
Who believes I could have a heart attack from the fear?
Silence.


I'm going to take a break and get to the other questions shortly.

Hope all is well and you're staying warm and not buried under too much snow.

-Barry

User avatar
vegansatori
Posts: 393
Joined: Sun May 23, 2021 3:35 am

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby vegansatori » Mon Dec 19, 2022 5:24 am

Hi Barry!
It was great seeing you in the meeting today! Loved hearing your new perspectives, and thought you were right on point with your guiding. Well done!
I will reply with the other questions as soon as I can.
No rush. It’s actually going to be a very busy week here too, so it’s all good. Take your time.
Can you tell me exactly what you’re doing when you meditate? Especially on things like this?
I meditate for ten minutes using guided meditations on the Waking Up App. And then I do 15 minutes of breathing meditation / self inquiry. During self inquiry I asked “What if there is no jail cell.” I was trying to to FEEL into this question. Any recommendations on how to FEEL an idea?
Oh cool. I love the Waking Up App. I think it’s super helpful to focus and calm the mind like that before doing self-inquiry. Though of course, any inquiry is good inquiry! As far as FEELING into the question, it’s tricky to describe. What I would say is, drop the question into the mind, like think/say it once, and then drop awareness into the body. Notice any sensations that arise or change in the body. Let the mind be quiet. You’re not looking for a conceptual answer or picture. You’re just ringing the bell of inquiry and listening to the ring, (to add in yet another metaphor! LOL). We’re using it like a koan where you want it to trigger a moment of mind-silence to be witnessed again and again.

You can also try this one the same way and see if it works for you. A couple weeks ago Jeffrey was inspired by my metaphor of chopping off thumbs to come up with a great pointer for one of his clients regarding suffering. We’re not really discussing that here, so I’m stealing and slightly modifying part of his pointer to make it into a koan.

So try asking yourself “How does it feel to not have an elephant’s trunk?” And feel into your experience right now of what it feels like to be absent something you never had. See if that drops you into a different experience in some way. Of course it’s a metaphor.

But when you try that a few times and get a feel for it, you could try “How does it feel not having a self right now?” And see what happens.
Is that tension any sort of indication of being a self? Can it be dismissed just as tension?
Just tension. Dismissed.
Great!
This is changing day to day. Sometimes I do feel like an experiencer and other times it’s just functioning. Right now, for instance, the I thoughts aren’t here. Just the words. Just now though, typing that the selfing comes. An image of your face appears (thanks to zoom) and I see you wondering what you’ll think of this. The I is wondering this. So strange that the I which I’m trying to see through is the I that “wants this”. Most of the time I don’t notice I thoughts… though I could see that being tricky… it feels like me I may not associate that as an I thought.
The catching of my “selfing” has helped and then there is just the DE. These moments are brief but having several more than usual.
Okay, this all sounds fantastic. Keep going with this trajectory. Keep noticing the selfing, and keep noticing when those thoughts appear. That said, thoughts wondering what others will think, or craving approval aren’t likely to drop with just seeing through the self. That can take a long long time.
The I is wondering this.
How do you know this is the “I” wondering it, and not just some other random disassociated thought?

Definitely try to catch all the “I thoughts”. “I’m tired. I’m hungry. I’m going to get a drink. I just wrote a long email.” Whatever. Note how often they happen and then immediately look back at who they are referring to. IS there a you who is hungry??? Or are there just physical sensations of rumbling appearing from somewhere that we interpret as our stomach?
The doubt is just noise.
Sometimes for sure. I have started question “Who believes this?” Silence.
Excellent!!!
I would say, to be safe, keep looking deeply into whatever that feeling is when you feel it. Where is it? What senses is it found in?
I’m noticing feelings more these last few days. I see a lot of fear painting my experience. More than other primal feelings. I see this has been the case for a while now… years and years and years… Just the recognition of this feels like a milestone. Nothing has changed in regards to the fear, but seeing it there is a bit freeing. I will look then for the one that is afraid.
(an hour or so later)
I did this and became very anxious. Facing fears is tough and something I need to work on I see. All kinds of fears! Hard to even look for a self when fearing. Stories come up. Stories about me. Oof I’m so quick to back down out of that fear. There feels like some openness in there though. Some fears I can clearly see aren’t real or are trivial. Some fears like death seem very real in that moment.

Knowing fear is a common occurrence when going through this sort of process I think I need learn how to become comfortable with fear. Or at least see if for what it really is... just a thought with general physical properties... it's these physical things that I am afraid of though I see.

First off, great the fear is now recognized! Experiencing it is totally normal and understandable. Have you ever tried Ilona’s video for interacting with fear to see what it wants to teach you? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jKX1llYtlKE&t=157s

If that doesn’t resonate with you, you could dig deeply into the DE of the actual sensations of fear. Or just allow it to be, and watch it arise and change and leave all on its own. Whatever you do, you don’t want to fight it. Either love it, or engage with it in a dialogue, or just equanimously watch it and let it do its thing.
Afraid of a racing heart = heart attack. That though is me putting a label on a racing heart. Upset stomach = disease. I'm afraid that the fear will trigger these things? With the heart for sure.
How likely is it that fear will actually do bodily harm? Probably pretty unlikely right?
That's it. I'm afraid the fear will do actual bodily harm. Can I see that that is also just a thought? A belief?
Who believes that the fear will do bodily harm?
I don't believe any other emotion can kill me so why fear?
Just looking at it that starts to feel silly.
It's definitely the beating heart when it gets ramped up that really starts to scare me.
These thoughts come telling me hey you don't want to have a heart attack do you?
Who believes I could have a heart attack from the fear?
Silence.
Yup, this is totally how panic attacks start! No, I don’t believe this kind of fear can kill you. Basically there is a part of the brain that determines whether what we are feeling in the moment is appropriate to the situation or not. If you were running five miles and had a racing heart and difficulty breathing, it wouldn’t cause a panic response because it would be expected because of the context. But if it happens while sitting in meditation or lying in bed, that part of the brain assumes something must be really wrong and sends out the panic signals that maybe you’re dying. Of course you know you’re not actually having a heart attack. It was caused by a mild fear response to either a thought or some sort of insight shift. Insight experiences can often cause a racing heart, feeling of dizziness or vertigo, feeling like you’re falling, and any number of other strange sensations. So if it comes up during what feels like a moment of insight, just stay with the insight and let the fear response take care of itself. Giving the fear attention at that moment will just feed it and ruin the momentum of the insight.

If it’s more of a pervasive fear in your life like what you were describing, or even if it's just every time you get close to this stuff, then absolutely try out one of the methods I already described. And let me know how it goes!

Again, it was great seeing you, and I hope you enjoyed the rest of your night!
-Todd
That relaxation of the clenched "myself" feels like having been roused from a dream to find oneself alive and aware...Each moment feels fresh, different from any other, and entirely unspeakable...And that is sufficient.- Robert Saltzman

User avatar
BarBarryN
Posts: 60
Joined: Fri Aug 13, 2021 5:33 am
Location: Portland, ME USA

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby BarBarryN » Tue Dec 20, 2022 11:30 pm

Hi Todd!
Great seeing you on Sunday. Loved our conversation and how fluid it all just moves.
The I is wondering this.
How do you know this is the “I” wondering it, and not just some other random disassociated thought?
I know it's the I because it's wondering how you will perceive my answer. There is a concern imbedded into this. Though I suppose that's just continuing the story.
It can be noted and simply dropped. "Selfing".

IS there a you who is hungry??? Or are there just physical sensations of rumbling appearing from somewhere that we interpret as our stomach?
There is an emotion that comes with hunger beyond just physical sensations. The desire to be satiated as quickly as possible. Thoughts of "I don't have time to make food" etc.
Hunger is definitely something I could see looking into. Pretty much blank out and go for the quickest thing to eat. There is even guilt in there. Yeah... a lot of selfing going on when I'm hungry.

Right now in D.E. there is a feeling in my stomach. Just a sensation though.
Recognition that the mind is trying to make more of it. Just this.



Previous Questions....
Keep looking at exactly what it is behind the eyes.
It might help to amp it up by "intentionally" looking around the room and feel as centered behind your eyes as you can. Really enhance the feeling of being a looker in control of your eyes. And then once that feeling is strong, investigate into it to find out what that feeling is really made of. Is it physical sensations, internal images, thoughts, a combination of all of them? Don't just look quickly once and assume that's good enough. Stick with it repeatedly, really exploring the current experience of what it feels like to be a self located behind the eyes.
Test 1: Physical sensations. Tensions behind / around the eyes. An image of some fuzzy thing sitting back there. Thought stuff.
How futile is all this? The way I look for something in the head is never in D.E. it's all through thought. Am I missing this? Is that the point?
Even the recognition of a thought is a thought. I can't put my senses (smell, taste, hearing, touch, and sight) behind my eyes. It's all thought stuff.


Thoughts simply appear... is that also true? not sure...
Can you make a thought appear at will?
No I cannot. I guess how they appear doesn't matter. I have no control one way or the other.
Totally true! How does it feel to have no control?
Mostly conceptual. Control being conceptual was a "aha!" though. So wehether I have control or don't have control that in itself is an illusion.
Also... conceptual = illusion, doesn't it? There is some gravity to the word illusion... lots of labels but the sense of I being an illusion = the sense of I being a concept. Same thing. The word "conceptual" kind of lost some sharpness to me... but illusion... that resonates.

You’re right that a belief is just a thought. And what’s important is to investigate: WHO is holding that belief? Is there any inherent validity to any belief, or are they all just thoughts which are virtually indistinguishable from any other random thought?
A belief is just a thought propped up by other thoughts. Damn... that's it.
To look at the belief in a self.... dove tails right into the next question.

Try this: Close the eyes. Allow any belief that you hold to come to mind. That the earth is round, that the sun is hot, that the feeling behind the eyes is proof of a self, whatever. And then, (this is the part that’s hard to describe), for me I would describe it as turning attention inwards, towards or around the thought itself, wherever that appears. And see if it’s attached to anything. Is it a tangible thing? Does it persist indefinitely or is it just a memory by the time you can turn towards it? Is there anybody attached to it in any way? Is there a thinker of it? Is there anything about it that determines its validity? Investigate everything about the experience of feeling/noticing/believing a belief.
Okay. So tried with the "Earth is round." An image of a round earth floating in spaces appears roughly where my vision would be-- feels like it's IN FRONT of my face. It is not attached to anything. It's an overlay. It's not tangible. Does not persist indefinitely. A completely different thought image forms where the round earth was. No one is attached to it.

My mind tells me there is a thinker of it. How else did it appear there? But it appeared there without direction. I didn't tell it where to appear. I didn't tell it how to make the earth look. A lot of things with the image that just happened. Something made the thoughts appear... but it wasn't me. Something makes the heart beat and the hair to grow but it isn't me.

I believe this. I believe there isn't a thinker. And I'm using other thoughts to prop up this belief.
I don't want to trade one set of beliefs for a new set.

How does it feel to have no control?
Looking for some big realization but none comes. Huh. Oh well. LOL
Notice that the expectation is just another thought. Relax that shit! ;-) By the time the recognition of disappointment or searching appears, you’re already lost in thought. What does it feel like to have the feeling of no control, even if it brings no further insight?
No feeling as of now.

That’s good. Keep looking into what it feels like to be Barry. You’re spot on with the things you said. So in those descriptions I can’t find a Barry. Can you? So what if those sensations always exist? Who says they are Barry? SERIOUSLY? Thoughts happen. Are thoughts Barry?
No. Thoughts aren't Barry. Lot's of bodily sensations. Sounds and breath. Colors.


In that same way, you have already assimilated the idea that there is no self so heavily, and seen so many glimpses of it, that I doubt you will have an earth-shattering realization about it. It’s already been cognitively assimilated. You just need to fully prove to yourself that you have exhausted every possible nook and cranny where the self could possibly be hiding. Then the doubt will dissolve and you'll be done.
Does that help clarify at all?
Yes it does. Thank you.
Looking for doubt now... There isn't doubt that I am a self but doubt that I've seen fully through it. Still expecting some greater shift. Now time to let the expectation go. There is a desire to keep prodding though. Prodding into things like feelings. Into things I have so long ignored in my experience. Things I've tried to push away.


I have no idea what I'm going to find / throw out. I have no idea if it's going to lead to enlightenment or no self or whatever but for the first time I don't even care. It just feels good to get in there and look around.
Well, it can’t lead to no-self because there’s always only been no-self! Lol Like nothing can lead to no-elephant in your house. You never had an elephant in there to begin with, so what would it even mean to reach a state of no-elephant in a house where one never existed? Feel into that!
Clenched jaw. Release. Clenched stomach. Release. heart and breath. sounds. thoughts of "wow look at this emptiness"
more thoughts
breath. sounds.

Thank you for this, Todd. Your recommendation on "how to feel" is fantastic. It's literally feeling the body sensations rather than feeling an emotion in the head. So simple yet I completely overlooked this. i will be using this during my inquiry as well.

Barry

User avatar
vegansatori
Posts: 393
Joined: Sun May 23, 2021 3:35 am

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby vegansatori » Wed Dec 21, 2022 2:49 am

Hey Barry!
How do you know this is the “I” wondering it, and not just some other random disassociated thought?
I know it's the I because it's wondering how you will perceive my answer. There is a concern imbedded into this. Though I suppose that's just continuing the story.
It can be noted and simply dropped. "Selfing".
Good, you got there eventually. lol

Just having a thought that expresses concern isn’t proof that there’s an I behind it. It’s just a thought expressing concern. If you have a thought expressing any other emotional content, it’s still just that. Wondering how someone will perceive us is just another thought referencing the self that is believed by another thought. But none of that actually proves its existence. Does that make sense? Like if you set a flute on a table outside, and the wind happens to blow across it and produce it note, it doesn’t mean it’s proof that there is someone intentionally playing the flute.
There is an emotion that comes with hunger beyond just physical sensations.
And what is emotion? Physical sensations plus thoughts. Does that need to include a self?
The desire to be satiated as quickly as possible. Thoughts of "I don't have time to make food" etc.
Still all thoughts!
Hunger is definitely something I could see looking into. Pretty much blank out and go for the quickest thing to eat. There is even guilt in there. Yeah... a lot of selfing going on when I'm hungry.
That’s definitely a great thing to investigate. And while eating, take note of where the food is being tasted. Where does the sense of taste really arise? Where do the sensations of food in the mouth really appear? Where do scents appear in experience? Is there a taster, smeller, feeler separate from any of the sensations? Try to find a boundary between the experience and the experiencer.

Also notice any thoughts appearing around the food. Notice if you are intentionally shoveling food into the mouth, or does it happen automatically? There are tons of things to be explored while eating!
Right now in D.E. there is a feeling in my stomach. Just a sensation though.
Recognition that the mind is trying to make more of it. Just this.
Excellent! You always get there eventually, it just takes a while. :-)
Stick with it repeatedly, really exploring the current experience of what it feels like to be a self located hind the eyes.
Test 1: Physical sensations. Tensions behind / around the eyes. An image of some fuzzy thing sitting back there. Thought stuff.
How futile is all this? The way I look for something in the head is never in D.E. it's all through thought. Am I missing this? Is that the point?
Even the recognition of a thought is a thought. I can't put my senses (smell, taste, hearing, touch, and sight) behind my eyes. It's all thought stuff.
Okay, good job. There are few ways to look at this.
1. If you are scanning your internal sensations, those sensations are in DE. Those feelings of tension, tingling, etc. in or behind the eyes are all DE.
2. Regarding images that arise in the mind – remember what we’ve talked about before. The content isn’t DE, but noticing the thought is. So it’s helpful to notice the fact that there is a thought appearing, or an internal image of a body, or some hazy idea which is all somehow connected to the feeling of “I”. It doesn’t matter quite as much what the content of the thought is, so much as you need to realize over and over that what you feel to be a self is just unexamined thoughts and sensations, all appearing in DE. No more than that. Is that clear?
3. If you can’t put your senses behind your eyes, what is it that is giving you the impression that you are located behind your eyes? How else can you experience ANYTHING except through your senses? (This is super important.)
How does it feel to have no control?
Mostly conceptual. Control being conceptual was a "aha!" though. So wehether I have control or don't have control that in itself is an illusion.
That’s true. But how often in your life does it still feel like you have control? It’s okay if it happens sometimes, but are there ever times when it is clear that there is no “you” steering this ship called Barry?
Also... conceptual = illusion, doesn't it? There is some gravity to the word illusion... lots of labels but the sense of I being an illusion = the sense of I being a concept. Same thing. The word "conceptual" kind of lost some sharpness to me... but illusion... that resonates.
Don’t get too lost in the labels. For our purposes, an illusion is something which appears to be real, but ultimately isn’t. Something which appears one way, but actually is another. So the self feels real, but just like any optical illusion, we can discover why it’s not really the case, even while it still fools us every time we see it.

A concept is purely a mental model of something that may or may not relate to "reality" an any meaningful way. A concept is pure thought-stuff, though many have practical value in day-to-day life.
A belief is just a thought propped up by other thoughts. Damn... that's it.
Exactly! It’s a hall of mirrors of thought. That’s all!
Investigate everything about the experience of feeling/noticing/believing a belief.
Okay. So tried with the "Earth is round." An image of a round earth floating in spaces appears roughly where my vision would be-- feels like it's IN FRONT of my face. It is not attached to anything. It's an overlay. It's not tangible. Does not persist indefinitely. A completely different thought image forms where the round earth was. No one is attached to it.
So this is a good explanation of the experience of the visual thought. Well done! But now you need to go another layer under/behind. It’s not just the image of a round earth that we’re investigating. It’s the FEELING OF KNOWING itself, completely divorced from the object of supposed knowledge, that we’re investigating.

Try this again with a non-visual belief. Like that 4+4=8. You might see the numbers in your head, but really investigate the conviction that this is a true statement. WHO knows this? On what grounds (without counting your fingers or some other objects) do you know this to be true? It’s not enough to just say “Because I KNOW it’s true.” No you don’t! You THINK it’s true. It’s something you’ve taken in over your lifetime, but are you sure right now, without counting anything specific if it’s true? How do you know you haven’t completely gotten it wrong? Can you trust the feeling of conviction? Notice if any feelings of tension or combativeness arise at having your certainty challenged. Discover all of that. Where in the body do those feelings arise? Do they seem to reinforce a sense of selfhood?

Next try something even more personal. How about the date or city of your birth. Do you feel like you know these for sure? Where is that certainty of knowing felt? Who feels it? Is there any way to actually know those things for 100% certain? Not by relying on documents or the testimony of others. They could all be forged or lying. In your own DE, how do you know when and where you were born? Feel into your experience in the body for exactly what’s happening, and what you’re ordinarily relying on to know that you are correct about anything.

(For this exercise it doesn’t actually matter whether it’s ultimately true or not. We’re just investigating what it feels like to KNOW and be a KNOWER of anything. And also what happens when our sense of conviction is challenged.)
My mind tells me there is a thinker of it. How else did it appear there? But it appeared there without direction. I didn't tell it where to appear. I didn't tell it how to make the earth look. A lot of things with the image that just happened. Something made the thoughts appear... but it wasn't me. Something makes the heart beat and the hair to grow but it isn't me.

I believe this. I believe there isn't a thinker. And I'm using other thoughts to prop up this belief.
I don't want to trade one set of beliefs for a new set.
This is great. And our purpose here is definitely not to trade in beliefs for different ones. It’s about seeing so clearly that there isn’t any self hiding there so frequently that you don’t need to believe it. It’s just obvious. Again, I assume there’s no elephant in your living room right now. But all it will take is one quick glance around your room to convince yourself of that fact, right? And after that, you can have perfect conviction, at least until you leave the room, that the room is currently elephant-free. You’re not relying on belief. You’re relying on all the best evidence of your senses at that moment.
Thoughts happen. Are thoughts Barry?
No. Thoughts aren't Barry. Lot's of bodily sensations. Sounds and breath. Colors.
Good. So where else could Barry be hiding? If you’re still not convinced at a guttural level, keep investigating thoughts and sensations until it’s clear.
Looking for doubt now... There isn't doubt that I am a self but doubt that I've seen fully through it. Still expecting some greater shift. Now time to let the expectation go. There is a desire to keep prodding though. Prodding into things like feelings. Into things I have so long ignored in my experience. Things I've tried to push away.
That’s all very good. And after the self illusion is fully gone, there will be a lot of shadow/emotional work that might need to be done. So those investigations will continue for a while. The fact that you’re feeling more of them and inclined to dig deeper now actually makes me wonder if more of the self-illusion as fallen away, giving you more access to these things.

As for expectations, yes, just notice them as thoughts and drop them asap. If it helps, let’s turn it around for a bit. Take a big epiphany off the table altogether. One just isn’t going to happen. Congratulations, you’re free from having to anticipate and expect it! Now continue on with inquiring until you feel like you’re done. That simplifies things, doesn’t it? ;-)
Well, it can’t lead to no-self because there’s always only been no-self! Lol Like nothing can lead to no-elephant in your house. You never had an elephant in there to begin with, so what would it even mean to reach a state of no-elephant in a house where one never existed? Feel into that!
Clenched jaw. Release. Clenched stomach. Release. heart and breath. sounds. thoughts of "wow look at this emptiness"
more thoughts
breath. sounds.
Mmmmm, wonderful! That relaxation and feeling of Emptiness is KEY! Don’t undervalue those. Keep coming back there by whatever means possible. Rest in it, and gently observe all aspects of experience to see if there is anyone appearing to be an experiencer in that moment. Keep it up!
Thank you for this, Todd. Your recommendation on "how to feel" is fantastic. It's literally feeling the body sensations rather than feeling an emotion in the head. So simple yet I completely overlooked this. i will be using this during my inquiry as well.

Great! I’m so glad that was helpful! We all relate to our experiences differently, we all have different levels of introspective awareness, and interpretations of our experiences, so in communicating these subtle and abstract points it can take a while to hit on the right language that resonates.

Take your time with all of these exercises, and let me know how you make out!
Have a great night!
-Todd
That relaxation of the clenched "myself" feels like having been roused from a dream to find oneself alive and aware...Each moment feels fresh, different from any other, and entirely unspeakable...And that is sufficient.- Robert Saltzman

User avatar
BarBarryN
Posts: 60
Joined: Fri Aug 13, 2021 5:33 am
Location: Portland, ME USA

Re: Reading “Liberation Unleashed” - had some questions

Postby BarBarryN » Thu Dec 29, 2022 2:32 pm

Hey Todd,
Sorry for the delay in responses -- crazy time of year as I'm sure you're also experiencing.

I had half of the responses written up to before I traveled to family for the holidays.
Going back now but probably still won't be able to get to them until a few more days.

Hope you're holidays are well.

Talk soon,

Barry


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Jeffelan and 29 guests