New to This -help needed
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
Just re read your post and realised I answered wrong question-do memories constitute a self as normally considered?No they most definitely not. It goes way beyond that and back to the little man in the head scenario which is total balls.
Its a good question to ask what is the self. My body-partly we work out the self from a body. But its a collected sense of memories plus self beliefs. Actually defining the self is quite hard to do...
Its a good question to ask what is the self. My body-partly we work out the self from a body. But its a collected sense of memories plus self beliefs. Actually defining the self is quite hard to do...
- Damon Kamda
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1291
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
- Location: Amsterdam
Re: New to This -help needed
Yes, it's a good question to ask. In fact, it is the most important question to ask because our entire lives revolve around this assumed entity.Its a good question to ask what is the self. My body-partly we work out the self from a body. But its a collected sense of memories plus self beliefs. Actually defining the self is quite hard to do...
Now I'm not aksing you to give a definition of the self, I'm asking you to point out, where, how and in what form YOU exist.
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
[/quote]Now I'm not aksing you to give a definition of the self, I'm asking you to point out, where, how and in what form YOU exist.[/quote]
What form I exist? Ok I feel I exist in my memories of experiences. In my accumulation of interpretations of these memories. In the story or narrative I tell myself. When I say " Tell myself" its like I take a book down off the shelf and continue on the story. Though I know this story has np physical reality like a book has. Its also what other people say about "me" thouh Im well aware of the fact that nobody knows us. We often get it wrong about people or "think" we know them. So in a real sense its quite difficult to pin down the self. We often define the self by career or position (ie wife husband etc) but these things are subject to change. Practically everything bar our gender is open to change.
Im probably meandering here a bit.
What form I exist? Ok I feel I exist in my memories of experiences. In my accumulation of interpretations of these memories. In the story or narrative I tell myself. When I say " Tell myself" its like I take a book down off the shelf and continue on the story. Though I know this story has np physical reality like a book has. Its also what other people say about "me" thouh Im well aware of the fact that nobody knows us. We often get it wrong about people or "think" we know them. So in a real sense its quite difficult to pin down the self. We often define the self by career or position (ie wife husband etc) but these things are subject to change. Practically everything bar our gender is open to change.
Im probably meandering here a bit.
- Damon Kamda
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1291
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
- Location: Amsterdam
Re: New to This -help needed
Well, you're demonstrating you have an intellectual grasp of the nonexistence of anything that could constitute a permanent self. Which is helpful, yet as I've mentioned before, not sufficient.Im probably meandering here a bit.
Yes.So in a real sense its quite difficult to pin down the self. We often define the self by career or position (ie wife husband etc) but these things are subject to change.
Most of the things that we generally consider to be self, are subject to change, are constructs, a stories, fictions.
Can you find an actual self that can be pinned down, right now?
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
Not really is the simple answer. Its a transient thing or constantly in flux. Its just a story added to as far as I can work out. Im typing this and am having a chat to myself but cant pin down this self. I can be aware of patterns of thoughts . I can at times,step above them and watch but thats difficult as often "these stories" drag me down and present themselves as truth.Can you find an actual self that can be pinned down, right now?
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
I meant to add to last line -absolute truth rather than just truth.
- Damon Kamda
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1291
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
- Location: Amsterdam
Re: New to This -help needed
What is the I that is typing this?Im typing this and am having a chat to myself but cant pin down this self. I can be aware of patterns of thoughts . I can at times,step above them and watch
What is the I that is having a chat to itself?
What is the I that can't pin down the self?
What is the I that can be aware of patterns of thought?
What is the I that can at times step above them and watch?
You see what I'm asking you to look at here?
There appear to be two poles to existence.
What is happening and someone to whom it is happening.
The first is easy to pin down, it's simply this.
The second- the experiencer- is it there at all- other than as an assumption that there must be?
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
Its not there in a real sense-ie there is a table in front of me but there is no self as such. I can see that but why does the ego take root ? Evolution?What is the I that is typing this?Im typing this and am having a chat to myself but cant pin down this self. I can be aware of patterns of thoughts . I can at times,step above them and watch
What is the I that is having a chat to itself?
What is the I that can't pin down the self?
What is the I that can be aware of patterns of thought?
What is the I that can at times step above them and watch?
You see what I'm asking you to look at here?
There appear to be two poles to existence.
What is happening and someone to whom it is happening.
The first is easy to pin down, it's simply this.
The second- the experiencer- is it there at all- other than as an assumption that there must be?
Can ask about the I who is aware of pattterns-is that "I" part of the ego or is that " I "possibly something else? Not a self or just another level of ego? The "I" that steps above? The language is difficult to express here.
- Damon Kamda
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1291
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
- Location: Amsterdam
Re: New to This -help needed
Is there an I who is aware at all?Can ask about the I who is aware of pattterns-is that "I" part of the ego or is that " I "possibly something else? Not a self or just another level of ego? The "I" that steps above? The language is difficult to express here.
What is the ego? Does it take root? Look in your experience and tell me how the illusion of self came into being.why does the ego take root ? Evolution?
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
Im pretty tired this evening but why does it seem that my questions generally just get a question? Sophistry!? This just at times seems to go round and round.
- Damon Kamda
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1291
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
- Location: Amsterdam
Re: New to This -help needed
The ONLY reason I'm here having this apparent conversation with you is to tempt you to get out of this cycle and actually directly look at what is right in front of you.why does it seem that my questions generally just get a question? Sophistry!? This just at times seems to go round and round.
By asking questions, I'm inviting you to challenge the assumptions you're making in every single word you write.
It's your call, friend. This will go round and round and round and round until you actually muster up the courage to look at what is real right now, what has always been real.
Do you honestly believe that me telling you how things are is going to help you at all?
Seriously- stop waiting for me to spoonfeed you the truth and ACTUALLY FIND OUT WHAT'S GOING ON RIGHT NOW, IN REAL LIFE, dammnit.
This is not another theory, another nice, fluffy story about enlightenment.
It's a simple invitation to look at reality.
You'll have to do the math yourself-
I cannot see this for you.
All I can do is point you in the right direction.
So take another look at the questions I keep firing at you and find out what they are pointing to.
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
Will think about it but I really dont see the difficulty with some clarification/elaboration here and there. I do appreciate your time but to be fair answering a question with a question seems to me to be buck passing a bit but what do "I" know. Can we leave it a few days??
- Damon Kamda
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1291
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
- Location: Amsterdam
Re: New to This -help needed
Will think about it
You see, that IS the problem. Thinking, while a wonderful thing really, will be of no use whatsoever for the present purpose. Is that coming across at all?
Clarification, sure.but I really dont see the difficulty with some clarification/elaboration here and there
Yet most of the questions you ask are EXACTLY the questions YOU need to LOOK at, in real life, right now!!!!
I'm not familiar with the expression "buck passing", but the dictionary defines it as "the shifting of responsibility to another"- and that's EXACTLY what it is- instead of giving you the answers, I'm tempting you to find out for yourself- because this forum and the present conversation is about one thing, and one thing alone- getting you to actually look at reality, instead of playing with thoughts.I do appreciate your time but to be fair answering a question with a question seems to me to be buck passing a bit but what do "I" know.
Have you gotten even one inch closer to understanding even the basic format of this forum?
Not discussion, speculation, theorizing, endless blah-blah-blah, but direct, focused looking at experience. Period.
Yes. This can take as long as is needed. Take your time. I'll keep passing the buck though...Can we leave it a few days??
- demellolives
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Tue Dec 20, 2011 9:18 pm
Re: New to This -help needed
I have reflected on this matter for the last few days and here is what I think.
I am thinking at the same time that looking at things from the little man in my head perspective makes no sense at all . Meaning when I talk to people I realise there is no me or the me I think is real is simply a random collection of thoughts-not a reality. I think I just have to practice nudging myself towards the truth. Default is back to the ego. Im still curious as to why this ego takes root -even though you question that observation. It does take root. We come into the world seeing everything as being connected not separate but somehow we develop a me mentality. How that happens I believe is important , And simply putting a question mark on what I say -wont change my view of that!
Perhaps there is part of me that does not fully accept this thing-that its a clever ego led way to make you get along with people. After all-we all bury our ego from time to time for peace sake.
So I need to work on the experience because thats the only way to fully realise things. or reject it.
I am thinking at the same time that looking at things from the little man in my head perspective makes no sense at all . Meaning when I talk to people I realise there is no me or the me I think is real is simply a random collection of thoughts-not a reality. I think I just have to practice nudging myself towards the truth. Default is back to the ego. Im still curious as to why this ego takes root -even though you question that observation. It does take root. We come into the world seeing everything as being connected not separate but somehow we develop a me mentality. How that happens I believe is important , And simply putting a question mark on what I say -wont change my view of that!
Perhaps there is part of me that does not fully accept this thing-that its a clever ego led way to make you get along with people. After all-we all bury our ego from time to time for peace sake.
So I need to work on the experience because thats the only way to fully realise things. or reject it.
- Damon Kamda
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1291
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
- Location: Amsterdam
Re: New to This -help needed
Uh-oh...here is what I think
Ok, so let's crack this.Default is back to the ego. Im still curious as to why this ego takes root -even though you question that observation. It does take root. We come into the world seeing everything as being connected not separate but somehow we develop a me mentality. How that happens I believe is important , And simply putting a question mark on what I say -wont change my view of that!
Firstly- what EXACTLY do you mean with the word "ego"? What state-of-affairs is being referenced by this word?
Before we can discover how something has come into being, mustn't we find out what it is we're talking about?
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot], Elad and 13 guests

