Apologies ignore the name mark I asked a guide friend to send me an exercise as I am away from my home and do not have access to all my files on iPad. So here is the exercise again. Notice that thoughts and mental activities are arising in a kind of ‘mental space’ or 'heart space'. Don’t speculate about what this ‘space’ might be. Just notice directly that it ’ is there. Remain noticing for a while, and then reflect and write down your observations
• What are its characteristics?
• If thoughts arise, even turbulent thoughts, is this ‘space’ affected?
• Discover whether you can ‘notice’ this space while thoughts are happening. Does this mitigate or slow, or otherwise affect the thoughts themselves?
Do you find bringing attention to this ‘space’ give rise to a ‘gap’ in thinking and/or some mental calm or absorption?
This quote from Longchenpa may also help you get a sense of what’ being got at:
"The method is directing attention upon attention or awareness. When any arising is experienced, especially thoughts, moods, emotions, or feeling of personal self identity, one simply notices one’s present naked awareness. By directing the attention back to awareness, the arising dissolves back into its origin and its essential nature, awareness. In doing this, the arising releases its formative energy in its dissolution as a surge of further clarity….”
Seeking guidance from anybody
Re: Seeking guidance from anybody
Hi,
When I look at the thoughts, there are gaps between two thoughts. I can notice the space even when there are thoughts. Only this sense of space only come sporadically. For one minute or two, I can feel the stillness but it will not last. I am trying to make the stay on this space longer if possible.
When I notice the space, the thoughts did slow down. You are more aware of the thoughts and think about why you think this particular thought. Some thoughts that have no use at all, you will notice it and it will died the moment you notice it.
Thanks for the guidance,
Liang
The space is still. Last night I was in the middle of working on my computer, just for a minute or two, suddenly everything stopped. At that moment all is still. No thoughts arise for this short period. After that thoughts rise again. Normally I can only reach this space in the process of deep reflection or doing meditation.• What are its characteristics?
The thoughts does not affect this space. I heard one description before about this. The space is like the ocean. All the thoughts are just waves on the surface. The wave does not affect the ocean. No matter how turbulent is the thoughts, the space is always there, very still, quiet.• If thoughts arise, even turbulent thoughts, is this ‘space’ affected?
[/quote]• Discover whether you can ‘notice’ this space while thoughts are happening. Does this mitigate or slow, or otherwise affect the thoughts themselves?
When I look at the thoughts, there are gaps between two thoughts. I can notice the space even when there are thoughts. Only this sense of space only come sporadically. For one minute or two, I can feel the stillness but it will not last. I am trying to make the stay on this space longer if possible.
When I notice the space, the thoughts did slow down. You are more aware of the thoughts and think about why you think this particular thought. Some thoughts that have no use at all, you will notice it and it will died the moment you notice it.
Thanks for the guidance,
Liang
Re: Seeking guidance from anybody
Liang who are you without your stories? often you have answered the questions with a story you have heard.
Are you able to answer a question without clinging onto stories you have been told?
I am asking you what you find when you look? But you are thinking your way through your answers. this is a journey of looking and not thinking
Who would you be without thinking?
Are you able to answer a question without clinging onto stories you have been told?
I am asking you what you find when you look? But you are thinking your way through your answers. this is a journey of looking and not thinking
Who would you be without thinking?
Re: Seeking guidance from anybody
Liang who are you without your stories?
Often you have answered the questions with a story you have heard.
Are you able to answer a question without clinging onto stories you have been told?
I am asking you what you find when you look? But you are thinking your way through your answers. this is a journey of looking and not thinking
Who would you be without thinking?
Often you have answered the questions with a story you have heard.
Are you able to answer a question without clinging onto stories you have been told?
I am asking you what you find when you look? But you are thinking your way through your answers. this is a journey of looking and not thinking
Who would you be without thinking?
Re: Seeking guidance from anybody
Hi,
Without thoughts, all very still, there is no "I", but someone is aware of this. Sorry I am a bit confused, for the past two years I do a lot of reading and watching videos on this spiritual teachings, never do much looking inside of me.
Thanks for your guidance,
Liang
I am looking inside now. Without my stories I cannot find or see anything. When all thinking stop, there is nothing there. Even this "I" also cannot be found.Who are you without your stories?
Who would you be without thinking?
Without thoughts, all very still, there is no "I", but someone is aware of this. Sorry I am a bit confused, for the past two years I do a lot of reading and watching videos on this spiritual teachings, never do much looking inside of me.
Thanks for your guidance,
Liang
Re: Seeking guidance from anybody
This is great Liang. If you keep on looking inside - there will be something different from confusion you will find. Yes when we look outside for answers from videos and spiritual teachings there can be so much confusion. You have mentioned the Buddha - a couple of times.
How did the Buddha become enlightened? He sat beneath the bodhi tree and committed to meditate until he found the answers. You may not formerly meditate and that is okay - but through direct pointing a form of meditation that we are doing now - you can look deep into yourself - without reaching for stories you have heard of.
Where was the Buddha looking for answers? He looked deeply inside himself to find the answers
I am suggesting now - that you keep on looking inside and
tell me what does it feel like when you look inside yourself?
tell me what do you find when you look inside?
How did the Buddha become enlightened? He sat beneath the bodhi tree and committed to meditate until he found the answers. You may not formerly meditate and that is okay - but through direct pointing a form of meditation that we are doing now - you can look deep into yourself - without reaching for stories you have heard of.
Where was the Buddha looking for answers? He looked deeply inside himself to find the answers
I am suggesting now - that you keep on looking inside and
tell me what does it feel like when you look inside yourself?
tell me what do you find when you look inside?
Re: Seeking guidance from anybody
Hi,
I am not sure what I should look for, all I can say is I see nothing.
Thinking back now I understand when I was young 15-16 years ago, I have a chance to step forward and look at this state of awareness. There is a fear that hold me back. Now after 30 years, now I decided to take the step forward.
When I looked inside I cannot find or see or hear anything. All are still and quiet. Is this the looking that you implied?
Thanks for the guidance,
Liang
When I closed my eyes and look inside, I cannot find anything. The thoughts had stopped, so I feel quiet, and very still.tell me what do you find when you look inside?
I am not sure what I should look for, all I can say is I see nothing.
Thinking back now I understand when I was young 15-16 years ago, I have a chance to step forward and look at this state of awareness. There is a fear that hold me back. Now after 30 years, now I decided to take the step forward.
When I looked inside I cannot find or see or hear anything. All are still and quiet. Is this the looking that you implied?
Thanks for the guidance,
Liang
Re: Seeking guidance from anybody
Hi Detox,
I think I have read too much. So every time when I try to answer your questions, those things that I read keep on coming in, I knew that I have to see this for myself.
So I try to see what is watching all these.
The "I" or "Liang" that is looking cannot be found. I cannot see anything when I try to look. But there is an awareness of this watching. So the awareness is looking, not "I" or Liang that is looking.
Thanks for the guidance,
Liang
I think I have read too much. So every time when I try to answer your questions, those things that I read keep on coming in, I knew that I have to see this for myself.
So I try to see what is watching all these.
The "I" or "Liang" that is looking cannot be found. I cannot see anything when I try to look. But there is an awareness of this watching. So the awareness is looking, not "I" or Liang that is looking.
Thanks for the guidance,
Liang
Re: Seeking guidance from anybody
Hi,
I still fall into the trap of quoting someone else words. So another try to use my own words and my own experiences to describe.
When I look inside, everything stopped. There is nothing there. Something is aware. Then thoughts start to arise which try to analyze. However the awareness kick in and realize the analyzing thought is also a thought. Then everything stopped again. However this not last long before another thoughts came in again.
Thanks for the guidance,
Liang
I still fall into the trap of quoting someone else words. So another try to use my own words and my own experiences to describe.
When I look inside, everything stopped. There is nothing there. Something is aware. Then thoughts start to arise which try to analyze. However the awareness kick in and realize the analyzing thought is also a thought. Then everything stopped again. However this not last long before another thoughts came in again.
Thanks for the guidance,
Liang
Re: Seeking guidance from anybody
hi Liang - the beauty of habit is that they can be changed. It's hope in seeking, in looking to see what is there - that we will begin to become less of our habits. Sadly most people become more of there habits.
Exactly as you write
Here is a quote by Longchenpa on the importance of noticing The four "faults" of natural awareness. I quote Longchenpa because he identifies hindrances, obstacles that can get in the way of seeing. And through our dialogue I have seen how some of these hindrances have got in your way of seeing. Take a look.
So close you can't see it.
So deep you can't fathom it.
So simple you can't believe it.
So good you can't accept it.
with that said - I have a few more questions to ask you - firstly
1)do you have any doubts at all about seeing through the illusion of a separate self?
with kindness Detox
Exactly as you write
There is nothing there - not even fear - if we look deeply. No Liang, no nothing.When I look inside, everything stopped. There is nothing there.
This is inevitable - thoughts will not disappear - as you have noticed There are gaps, and new thoughts arise. But what is different - you will notice your thoughts more, and your thoughts will not have the same pull or hold over you. Everything becomes looser, in a sense - a less of you - a less of self that we can project into the world. I wonder if you have been looking for the big bang experience - and by doing that have negated your own personal experience. Comparing our experience with people who have written about it, will cause frustration and suffering. We are all different.However this not last long before another thoughts came in again
Here is a quote by Longchenpa on the importance of noticing The four "faults" of natural awareness. I quote Longchenpa because he identifies hindrances, obstacles that can get in the way of seeing. And through our dialogue I have seen how some of these hindrances have got in your way of seeing. Take a look.
So close you can't see it.
So deep you can't fathom it.
So simple you can't believe it.
So good you can't accept it.
with that said - I have a few more questions to ask you - firstly
1)do you have any doubts at all about seeing through the illusion of a separate self?
with kindness Detox
Re: Seeking guidance from anybody
Hi,
I will put down my journey so far.
When I was 15 or 16, first time when I got a glimpse of this, I have a lot of fears and it stopped me from moving forward.
Then through out the years somehow the heart has a yearning to keep on coming back. Then I go into Buddhism and get a misconception about this enlightenment. Not knowing that I already started the path towards it.
For some reasons, without aware of it, I slowly move away from Buddhism and other religions also. Somehow there is a knowing that I will always go back to this path. I remember one day there is a voice inside, telling me to look inside again. At that time I am not in the right mental state to take on this task. Somehow I told myself give me another ten years or so, once my mental state is healthy again, I will start this journey again.
Now the journey begins again. Already I have gain so much more inside, think you understand what I means.
Thanks for the guidance,
Liang
At this moment there is no doubt about seeing through the illusion of a separate self.1)do you have any doubts at all about seeing through the illusion of a separate self?
I will put down my journey so far.
When I was 15 or 16, first time when I got a glimpse of this, I have a lot of fears and it stopped me from moving forward.
Then through out the years somehow the heart has a yearning to keep on coming back. Then I go into Buddhism and get a misconception about this enlightenment. Not knowing that I already started the path towards it.
For some reasons, without aware of it, I slowly move away from Buddhism and other religions also. Somehow there is a knowing that I will always go back to this path. I remember one day there is a voice inside, telling me to look inside again. At that time I am not in the right mental state to take on this task. Somehow I told myself give me another ten years or so, once my mental state is healthy again, I will start this journey again.
Now the journey begins again. Already I have gain so much more inside, think you understand what I means.
Thanks for the guidance,
Liang
Re: Seeking guidance from anybody
Liang you write
and tell me what you consider enlightenment to be?
Thank you for staying on this journey - with kindness
Please tell me what this misconception was?the misconception about this enlightenment.
and tell me what you consider enlightenment to be?
Thank you for staying on this journey - with kindness
Re: Seeking guidance from anybody
Hi,
Second misconception is there are many levels of enlightenment, first level is Ara-hat, next level is Bodhisattva, and the final level is Buddha.
For me now enlightenment is very simple. I just want to see through that this "self" is not real. Once I can dropped this "self", then there will be peace. All the suffering and pain felt by the self will be seen as just an illusion, or just another thought, so there will always be calm inside.
Thanks for your guidance,
Liang
The main misconception about enlightenment as a Buddhist is you cannot get enlightenment in this life time. The enlightenment is always in the future.Please tell me what this misconception was?
and tell me what you consider enlightenment to be?
Second misconception is there are many levels of enlightenment, first level is Ara-hat, next level is Bodhisattva, and the final level is Buddha.
For me now enlightenment is very simple. I just want to see through that this "self" is not real. Once I can dropped this "self", then there will be peace. All the suffering and pain felt by the self will be seen as just an illusion, or just another thought, so there will always be calm inside.
Thanks for your guidance,
Liang
Re: Seeking guidance from anybody
Great Liang yes they are misconception. But to remember seeing through the illusion of self is not enlightenment but is moving in that direction. Doubt, rights and rituals, craving, hatred are just a few of the things we need to be paying attention to once seeing through this illusion. But things do begin to change,
Here are some questions that we us usually give toward the end as a kind of 'summing up' -- they often reveal a few aspects that might need looking at further, which we can continue to do, if you like. Remember to answer from DE -- not from thought:
1) Is there a separate entity 'self', 'me' 'I', at all, anywhere, in any way, shape or form? Was there ever?
2) 2) Explain in detail what the illusion of separate self is, when it starts and how it works from your own experience. Describe it fully as you see it now.
3) 3) How does it feel to see this? What is the difference from before you started this dialogue? Please report from the past few days.
4) 4) What was the last bit that pushed you over, made you look?
Here are some questions that we us usually give toward the end as a kind of 'summing up' -- they often reveal a few aspects that might need looking at further, which we can continue to do, if you like. Remember to answer from DE -- not from thought:
1) Is there a separate entity 'self', 'me' 'I', at all, anywhere, in any way, shape or form? Was there ever?
2) 2) Explain in detail what the illusion of separate self is, when it starts and how it works from your own experience. Describe it fully as you see it now.
3) 3) How does it feel to see this? What is the difference from before you started this dialogue? Please report from the past few days.
4) 4) What was the last bit that pushed you over, made you look?
Re: Seeking guidance from anybody
Hi,
It is like say for this moment there is a sudden urge to drink coffee, then a thought appear that this self has a craving for coffee. The moment the thought appear, the separate self appear.
My work is quite stressful. I find that when I felt stress, I can just stopped and watch this stress and it will go away. You realized you can only concentrate on the job at the moment.
Thanks for he guidance,
Liang
There is no separate entity called "self". This I can see. When I look inside, there is nothing there.1) Is there a separate entity 'self', 'me' 'I', at all, anywhere, in any way, shape or form? Was there ever?
I can see that this self is an image created by the mind. It felt like there is a consciousness looking at this self. The body works like automatic pilot where eating or going to toilet is an automatic function. The separate self only appears as thoughts, the thoughts create this image called self.2) Explain in detail what the illusion of separate self is, when it starts and how it works from your own experience. Describe it fully as you see it now.
It is like say for this moment there is a sudden urge to drink coffee, then a thought appear that this self has a craving for coffee. The moment the thought appear, the separate self appear.
Definitely there are peace and quiet. Once all these humming of thoughts slowed down, you will find it more peaceful and calm inside. A lot of negative emotions like anger and worry I find I can better manage and control them.3) How does it feel to see this? What is the difference from before you started this dialogue? Please report from the past few days.
My work is quite stressful. I find that when I felt stress, I can just stopped and watch this stress and it will go away. You realized you can only concentrate on the job at the moment.
I will say the pain. All the pains or sufferings for the past 20 years or so made me want to go over. Strange it may sound, I remember the day that the shift happens is when I find my life not worth living anymore. Then I start to think who will miss me when I am dead. Then I looked inside and saw that it is this self that wants to die. That is the point I started looking.4) What was the last bit that pushed you over, made you look?
Thanks for he guidance,
Liang
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 53 guests

