Seeking guidance from anybody

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
Detox
Posts: 153
Joined: Sun Mar 10, 2013 5:48 am
Contact:

Re: Seeking guidance from anybody

Postby Detox » Tue Oct 08, 2013 6:38 am

Liang a running theme occurs in your thread an attachment to the past. As if the past is really important. We can be victims of the past.....but that is a choice. Our past does not have to shape us. The present moment shapes us. I say this as you have told me several stories...and they obviously have had an impact of you. Intellectually I have no doubt that you see there is no self, but this is not enough. The past is getting in the way of you experiencing. .and I could say yes Liang sees....but this would be spiritual bypassing? Important to investigate some stories and emotions.

You wrote
When I was 19, I have a near miss in a car accident, only by miracle me and my brother survive the crash.
And I wrote
When I was 19 I was in a car accident. And me and my brother survived.

What is the difference between what I wrote and you wrote please refer to the two sentences above.

You have written about the anxiety and depression as a child and although it is different for you now it has been important for you to tell me more than once.

Who experienced the anxiety and depression?
can you tell me what the anxiety and depression looked like as these are labels and I have no idea what that means? depression and anxiety looks different in each of us.

What are you afraid of?

With kindness
Detox

User avatar
liang
Posts: 50
Joined: Thu Sep 05, 2013 8:10 am

Re: Seeking guidance from anybody

Postby liang » Tue Oct 08, 2013 3:07 pm

Hi,
Liang wrote:
When I was 19, I have a near miss in a car accident, only by miracle me and my brother survive the crash.
Detox wrote:
When I was 19 I was in a car accident. And me and my brother survived.
Compare the two sentences, yours has no emotions in it. It more like just stating a fact, a historical fact.
My version I try to inject some emotion into it, and looks like the past did affect me deeply.

For me the anxiety attack, is when I feel panic, anxious, to the extend my mind went blank. There are cases when there is an extreme anxiety attack, my body just feel motionless, I cannot even move my body. However all these are in the past, now I will not have such an extreme attack. A mild anxiety attack still occurs, not many, for the past few years.

Depression is when I feel so down, I cannot sleep, I cannot eat. There are a few months in my life I just lied on bed and not doing anything much. It is just like a sick patient lied on a hospital bed and refuse to stand up. I remember it takes a lot of effort for me to walk out of the room, and face the world again.

So you are right, these past experiences affect me deeply, and became obstacle to move forward on this seeking path. But also because of these experiences that I become interested on all these spiritual stuff and read about them.
Who experienced the anxiety and depression?
There is no "me" that experienced this anxiety and depression. Anxiety and depression is also just a phenomenon that appeared in the mind. But funny thing is like what you say, I am aware of this intellectually, but unable to really experience it.
What are you afraid of?
I am not sure of what I afraid of. The fear is still there, but its like I am afraid of my own shadow, or a phantom in my mind. Now I can feel the stillness, I can observe all these emotions that is going on inside my mind, I am getting to understand the feeling, but still in a very early stage.

Thanks for your guidance, I have been reflecting more and more for the past few days.

Thanks
Liang

User avatar
Detox
Posts: 153
Joined: Sun Mar 10, 2013 5:48 am
Contact:

Re: Seeking guidance from anybody

Postby Detox » Wed Oct 09, 2013 4:55 am

Compare the two sentences, yours has no emotions in it. It more like just stating a fact, a historical fact.
My version I try to inject some emotion into it, and looks like the past did affect me deeply.
Yes Liang - I say what happened to you without any story - just the literal facts - There is the story that Buddha tells about two darts - He tells us that the first dart is real pain. It is sensate pain. And the first dart for you = was the car accident - and you have never said - but there will be the shock that is the initial pain - and you may have been injured which is pain and of course suffering. Then the Buddha tells us there is the second dart - that dart is the proliferation of the event after it has happened the storys that we inject into it - your stories you inject into it - are
only by a miracle
why is it a miracle - what is a miracle - you survived. Why was it a
near miss
you are alive.

All these stories have an impact on how we think - we are what we think. So it is important to be aware of these narratives.
I am not sure of what I afraid of. The fear is still there, but its like I am afraid of my own shadow, or a phantom in my mind.
Our stories can be phantoms in the mind - they are like a shadow that can follow us - and you have some strong stories that follow you.

What would it be like to never tell another person about your car accident?
what would it be like to never tell another person about your depression?
What are you trying to protect?

with kindness - be well - and take gentle care of yourself

User avatar
liang
Posts: 50
Joined: Thu Sep 05, 2013 8:10 am

Re: Seeking guidance from anybody

Postby liang » Thu Oct 10, 2013 1:24 am

Hi,

Thanks for the guidance, it helps.
What would it be like to never tell another person about your car accident?
what would it be like to never tell another person about your depression?
What are you trying to protect?
If I never tell another person about anything that ever happens in my life, then it is just another stories, that happen and pass me by. It is just like another ripple on the ocean, after the ripple gone, nobody will remember there is a ripple there in first place. All these are just stories or experiences that will pass.

I am trying to protect this person that is called "I", without all these stories and experiences, this "I" will not exist. I am in fact try my best to hold on to this person, or mind that is called "I", or some called it "ego". I understand that I have to let go of this "ego", but it is hard to let it go. I also understand eventually every person will have to let it go when this body has passed. It is better to let it go before that happen. I am on the way there but not sure how to let it go yet.

Thanks for your guidance. Much appreciated.
Liang

User avatar
Detox
Posts: 153
Joined: Sun Mar 10, 2013 5:48 am
Contact:

Re: Seeking guidance from anybody

Postby Detox » Thu Oct 10, 2013 4:31 am

This is great Liang -
If I never tell another person about anything that ever happens in my life, then it is just another stories, that happen and pass me by. It is just like another ripple on the ocean, after the ripple gone, nobody will remember there is a ripple there in first place. All these are just stories or experiences that will pass.
Can you allow yourself to experience what you write above. Just let the past be another ripple on the ocean. Remember whenever we step into the ocean it is never the same ocean - each time we step into it - the ocean has changed. Similarly each time we step into the past - it has changed - there is no fixed past - in fact no past. What a liberating thought. All we have is the present moment.
I am trying to protect this person that is called "I", without all these stories and experiences, this "I" will not exist. I am in fact try my best to hold on to this person, or mind that is called "I", or some called it "ego". I understand that I have to let go of this "ego", but it is hard to let it go. I also understand eventually every person will have to let it go when this body has passed. It is better to let it go before that happen. I am on the way there but not sure how to let it go yet.
yes Yes - we all have to renounce - at the point of death we renounce everything - so we have a choice do we begin now - or do we wait until we die. What will bring us more happiness. If we let go of the past - this will be a huge renunciation. Begin letting go. And yes thanks for your honesty- lets move on - and keep looking for the 'I' that you are protecting, that 'I' you find hard to let go off. Look for that person you are trying to hold onto..

I want you to investigate if the thing you called 'I'' is the Doer? ( I want you to do the following exercises before you answer. Please literally get up and do the exercise through out the day -don't think about just get up and do the exercise)
"get up… walk slowly…
is there a controller that controls walking?
or
is there just walking?"

Now start consciously breathing ---
Is there a self that controls breathing?
that walks?
Use your computer and then answer
is there a self that does daily activities?

Thank you for your gratitude - with kindness
Detox

User avatar
liang
Posts: 50
Joined: Thu Sep 05, 2013 8:10 am

Re: Seeking guidance from anybody

Postby liang » Fri Oct 11, 2013 11:40 am

Hi,
is there a controller that controls walking?
or
is there just walking?"
---
Is there a self that controls breathing?
that walks?
Use your computer and then answer
is there a self that does daily activities?
Detox
The day to day activities that happen to this body, is by itself independent of the mind. I do meditation before, in meditation one can see that the breathing is not control by anything. It is an automatic process, your lungs just start pumping air in and out.

As for physical activities like walking, I never really thought much about it. Now after some observation, there is no controller also. Walking is also automatic, you just put one foot in front of another, then it just starts by itself.

As for typing on the computer keyboard, the fingers' movement is also automatic. The sentence came into one's mind, the finger just move automatically onto the correct keys.

I still remember watching a youtube video, where a Japanese Zen monk taught about meditation. He told students to start by breath out all the air from the lung. When one breath out all the air from the lung, the lung will automatically breath in. As one sit down there meditate, he will see that the breathing is by itself.

The Chinese in this part of the world got one saying, "When you hungry you eat, when you tired you sleep". All these daily activities are automatic and there is no "self" that control all these activities.

Thanks for the guidance,
Liang

User avatar
Detox
Posts: 153
Joined: Sun Mar 10, 2013 5:48 am
Contact:

Re: Seeking guidance from anybody

Postby Detox » Sat Oct 12, 2013 8:31 am

Thank you Liang - for this gift of the Chinese quote -
"When you hungry you eat, when you tired you sleep
It's a great source of reflection - how do we know when we are hungry? how do we know when we are tired?

Let's now explore this automatic pilot syndrome - and choosing.

Liang can you describe from your direct experience how the self makes a choice?
Is there a difference between a choice and what is running on automatic ?

Take two objects/possibilities, of which you might ordinarily choose either e.g. coffee or tea, blue pen or black pen, salt and pepper, then sit and see if you can find the choice-point where you could go either way.
Describe how choosing happens.

Have a great day - with kindness
Detox

User avatar
liang
Posts: 50
Joined: Thu Sep 05, 2013 8:10 am

Re: Seeking guidance from anybody

Postby liang » Sun Oct 13, 2013 7:06 am

HI,

Thanks for the pointers.
Take two objects/possibilities, of which you might ordinarily choose either e.g. coffee or tea, blue pen or black pen, salt and pepper, then sit and see if you can find the choice-point where you could go either way.
Describe how choosing happens.
Over here in Singapore, anytime when I order the drink in a coffee shop here, most of the time it was either a coffee or a tea. I think back, anytime when the waiter asked me, my mind cannot decide. When the lady is waiting to take the order, I just quickly decide on one of them, coffee or tea because I felt embarrassed for making the lady waiting.

The choice at that moment is more like what the body wants. When the body is a bit lethargic the mind will automatically asked for coffee. Here the Chinese believe "tea" can dissolve the oil that you take in into your stomach, so you will ask for tea when the food you just ate is too oily.

At that moment of making a choice of either coffee or tea, it is strange, it is not really a thought. You just made a decision, like snapping fingers. There is not much thinking. It is not really automatic, come to think of it, there is definitely some thinking, but you are not aware of the thinking.

So going to the point of when you made the decision, strange, I cannot find it. Most of the time you are only aware when the decision already made. Also strange is, the decision also made sense for you. I ever read somewhere that this is called "intelligence". Throughout the years all experiences built up and ingest into the mind and become intelligence. The intelligence will come in without you aware of it.

Strange as it may sound, I cannot find the point where the decision is made.

Thanks for the guidance,
Liang

User avatar
Detox
Posts: 153
Joined: Sun Mar 10, 2013 5:48 am
Contact:

Re: Seeking guidance from anybody

Postby Detox » Sun Oct 13, 2013 8:06 am

Hi Liang - thank you
Strange as it may sound, I cannot find the point where the decision is made.
Not strange at all - It is like there is no beginning or end.

So lets keep on looking.


are YOU the thinker of thoughts?
can YOU think and choose a thought?

with kindness

Detox

User avatar
liang
Posts: 50
Joined: Thu Sep 05, 2013 8:10 am

Re: Seeking guidance from anybody

Postby liang » Mon Oct 14, 2013 1:00 pm

Hi,
are YOU the thinker of thoughts?
can YOU think and choose a thought?
I do this seeking before. There is no thinker that can be seen. But there must be a "thinker" that think all these thoughts.

I cannot really "think" or choose a thought. Sometime a thought appear, I "came" to be aware of the thought, then the process of thinking seems to start. When I close my eyes, and try to see, no thought will come. When you seeking in earnest of the thoughts, you cannot find it.

I heard it before from listening to a youtube video, when this "I" cannot be found then where can one find the thoughts? I will reflect more deeply tonight and give you more inputs tomorrow.

Thanks for the guidance,
Liang

User avatar
liang
Posts: 50
Joined: Thu Sep 05, 2013 8:10 am

Re: Seeking guidance from anybody

Postby liang » Wed Oct 16, 2013 2:44 am

Hi,
are YOU the thinker of thoughts?
can YOU think and choose a thought?
I cannot find this thinker of thoughts. I cannot think or choose a thought.

The thoughts will come by itself. I can see and observe the thoughts. But I cannot control it, or think of it. There is definitely a thinker, because there is a definitely a source where these thoughts come from, but I cannot see the source.

Thanks for the guidance,
Liang

User avatar
Detox
Posts: 153
Joined: Sun Mar 10, 2013 5:48 am
Contact:

Re: Seeking guidance from anybody

Postby Detox » Thu Oct 17, 2013 7:46 am

Hi Liang thank you for taking the time for you to reflect.
I am curious you can not find a thinker and you know that you can not choose or think a thought. Why do you cling on to the view that there is definitely a thinker. It is a contradiction. What would it mean if there was no thinker? What would it mean if there was no source? Open up to the possibility for a moment that there is no thinker? What does that feel like?

What is Asia? Where does Asia come from? whAt is Laing? Where does Liang come from?

User avatar
liang
Posts: 50
Joined: Thu Sep 05, 2013 8:10 am

Re: Seeking guidance from anybody

Postby liang » Thu Oct 17, 2013 9:37 pm

Hi,
Why do you cling on to the view that there is definitely a thinker. It is a contradiction. What would it mean if there was no thinker? What would it mean if there was no source? Open up to the possibility for a moment that there is no thinker? What does that feel like?

What is Asia? Where does Asia come from? whAt is Laing? Where does Liang come from?
Thank you for your pointers. You are right in pointing why I cling on that there is a thinker. There is this incidence many years ago where I suffer a mental breakdown. I was having a lot of problems and the pressure of life prove too much for me to handle. I remember I was thinking so hard that I am mentally exhausted and have a breakdown.

At that time I am financially very tight so I never seek any medical advice or consulting any psychologist.

So after suffer through this mental exhaustion, the thought that there is no thinker is a bit hard for me to grasp. If I can see this years ago, I will not have the mental breakdown then.

Now I am reflecting. If there is no thinker, and all these thoughts just spring out spontaneous, then what is all these means? Who is the person that suffer depression and mental breakdown?

For the past two years after I seriously start this reflection process, I notice I am thinking less. Also my consciousness increase, I have more awareness for the current moment. So much so that I don't think any episode of mental problem will come again. That is history, like what you say the past is just my story,

The name "Asia" or the name "Liang" is just a label. Is Liang the thinker, definitely not. For me now I can only see that for the moment, this "thinker" is looking at "Liang". If you know what I means. Now like what you say if there is no thinker, then there is no Liang also.

I will look at my cling on this "thinker", try to reflect on this attachment.

Again, thanks for the pointers, this is helpful.

With gratitude,
Liang

User avatar
Detox
Posts: 153
Joined: Sun Mar 10, 2013 5:48 am
Contact:

Re: Seeking guidance from anybody

Postby Detox » Fri Oct 18, 2013 5:33 am

Continue to reflect on the clinging and I will write again tomorrow. As my job is not to persuade you to see there is no thinker it is for me to help you look, point you in the right direction so you can have a good look,and see what you see.

User avatar
Detox
Posts: 153
Joined: Sun Mar 10, 2013 5:48 am
Contact:

Re: Seeking guidance from anybody

Postby Detox » Fri Oct 18, 2013 7:09 am

hi Liang I would like you to try the following. Mark McLelland Notice that thoughts and mental activities are arising in a kind of ‘mental space’ or 'heart space'. Don’t speculate about what this ‘space’ might be. Just notice directly that it ’ is there. Remain noticing for a while, and then reflect and write down your observations

• What are its characteristics?
• If thoughts arise, even turbulent thoughts, is this ‘space’ affected?
• Discover whether you can ‘notice’ this space while thoughts are happening. Does this mitigate or slow, or otherwise affect the thoughts themselves?

Do you find bringing attention to this ‘space’ give rise to a ‘gap’ in thinking and/or some mental calm or absorption?


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 56 guests