Yes it is only a very subtle thought that is being missed many many times. Only a thought about me doing the action or decision making. It can't be found there for real.So, you seem to be saying, on the one hand, that it"s really clear that there's no "I" to be seen and that I-thoughts sneak in after the event, but on the other hand, you can't be totally sure that no "I" is involved because it feels as if "you" are involved, at least when you are trying to point out that there is no you. Is that right?
Can you say which it is? What do you mean by it ... feels as there is me doing that? Is this feeling present in direct experience and, if so, what is it? is it a physical feeling or an afterthought, albeit perhaps a very subtle one, or what?
I did as you said and noticed that it can't be known when the fingers will tap. Thoughts of tapping like "tap now" may arise or not, but it doesn't imply that tapping necessarily happens when the thought arises. It actually happened few times that there was thought "tap now" and nothing happened. No me there doing that it seems.Tap with two or three fingers on the leg. Tap, tap, tap. Then, hold the fingers positioned ready to tap. Just waiting in the air for a command to tap.
Looking at the fingers in the air, is it known when they will tap? Can the thought “tap now” quite happily show up and yet the fingers remain in the air?
See if you can notice the moment when the command is issued and from whence it comes SUCH THAT the fingers simply have to obey. Notice if other commands to tap can be issued which have no affect on the fingers, leaving them remaining in the air.
Hmmmm... there is no command to make the tapping happen. Most of the time it just feel this way, same goes to everything. What ever the situation is there will probably always be thoughts related to it and the happening which cause it seem as if there is "me" in the body doing the thing. Thoughts will make the process look controlled by "me" as they either tell that there was or wasn't done anything by "me". Whether "i" did the action or didn't do. It all just happens by itself. I'ts clear, there is no me in the action even tho it surely feels so all the time. There is nothing commanding anything.In direct experience, is there a command that can be issued to make the fingers tap?
What causes the finger to tap? Anything? See what can be discovered in experience rather than thought?
Yes, this has been more or less clear for me for a while, that there is no me. It has been known intellectually for a quite while but you pointed it out very clearly, i think it is definitely sure for "me" now. This still hasn't taken a hold of the experience here or i can't say that the "me" that in real life doesn't exist wouldn't still be a major part of the everyday experience.You've made very rapid progress here with me over the last few days, possibly partly because you did quite a bit of this work a few months ago. As we've covered most areas already, once I'm satisfied that you can see no self involved in any way as decider/chooser, I'm going to send you some comprehensive sweep-up questions so that we can both see where you're at, whether any aspects need further looking at etc. But before I do, how do you think you're doing, and are there any aspects/areas where you've got doubts about there being no self-entity and that you'd like to look at in more detail?
There is lot of anxiety showing up everyday which i am right now alleviating with meditation. When sitting in meditation for lets say.. one to two hours there comes severe feeling to do something, to go somewhere except just sit. I know that to be the mind trying to get somewhere, better place in the future and for a while it hurts but then when not paid attention to, just vanishes more and more. There is still story of me unfolding from moment to moment so i can't say that i have seen though the illusion clearly at all. Don't know where to go from here. I have a video i would like you to watch which points out pretty much where i think i'm at (where the lady's at) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ohVRK3nlsgQ
- Roni

