A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
Robin.
Posts: 144
Joined: Mon Dec 05, 2011 3:03 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby Robin. » Wed Jan 11, 2012 8:56 am

Colin. You answer.
Well - I am not sure we can rid ourselves of our character/ego altogether. That would put us in the state of a baby and we would not be able to do anything. Without a character/ego you would not be able to get up in the morning and go about your day. I can see that an awareness of the falsehood of the "I'" (meaning the construct that has built up since I was born that I identify with as myself) - enables new perspectives.
Yes we can rid ourselves of character/ego altogether, but that is much further along the road and well after passing through the gateless gate. From this statement of you saying "not sure" You go on to intellectualise about something you know nothing about, or ever experienced, You can only assume the "I" construct (Which doesn't exist in any way, shape or form? Enables new perspectives.
Here as always you are jumping way far forward of the simplicity of simply seeing ! No "I". And shutting down your strong character/ego long enough to glimpse on the other side. Once you have see, there won't be any need for all these counter arguments against what we all know here to be fact. Or at least all the pointers I am giving you to help you.

You have now reached a state of frustration because you haven't popped. You are the pop corn in the pan that is hiding from the heat.
I accept that my ego/character is not me and so in that sense I accept that there is no "I" I also cannot find another I - although it sometimes can appear that the thoughts that are able to recognise an emotion as simply that is another " I' - the observer . Although I can accept that even that is just another thought. and so yes I can accept that there is no "I". But if it is possible to drop the ego/character altogether rather than just recognising it as a construct then there is nothing left accept experiencing without labels/thoughts/emotions - a bit like a baby. I can't see how that would be useful and how living as a adult in the world would even be possible.

All my experience is in my mind in the sense that there is no other way of experiencing the world. So I could easily say that none of it is there except as I experience it /or in my mind.. But I can't see the utility in considering that Bondi Beach is in my imagination and that I am not really there. If I did that then I might keep walking out to sea and drown.
Having the untainted clarity of consciousness that a baby has does not imply that living in an adult world would be impossible.
Again. You are over intellectualising a simple request to stop intellectualising to allow the no presence of "I" to get past that character ego. You say that you "accept" There is no I. You only accept the concept. You haven't seen the reality or else it would be a completely different reply.

We do have labels attached to everything as per the conditioning. For instance, You might like a toasted crumpet with lots of butter on, where as I have a toasted pikelet. We are both having the same thing only my label is different to yours. Labels are labels. we don't have to analyse this fact. This will go on. What we are trying to do here is get past your character/ego long enough for you to witness the no"I" not stay with the concept.
You are verbalising frustration, rather than spending time with the determination to really investigate what is happening internally when you go in search of this "I"

This forum is heaving with people now waiting to be guided. We have guides like myself dealing with several people at once. We are having many people passing through no problem. It is a two way thing. I'm not going to give you the experience, you have to work for it. Keep your intellect out of it. (Raps back of hands with Zen stick) This doesn't require intellect. You're going to need all the strength of intellect to deal with all the many knock on effects from generated questions that arise when you see the other side. Just for now, drop the angry, frustrated, reasoning self and go in search of this "I" As a baby would without any pre conceived idea's of what you will find.

Switching threads and asking another guide for assistance is not the answer. Read as many other threads if you like. You will see the commonality of no "I" is the only bottom line here. It's enough that this forum is free wouldn't you agree? Or did you think it's just for the benefit of Colin ?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Wed Jan 11, 2012 10:36 am

Hi Robin,
Switching threads and asking another guide for assistance is not the answer. Read as many other threads if you like. You will see the commonality of no "I" is the only bottom line here. It's enough that this forum is free wouldn't you agree? Or did you think it's just for the benefit of Colin ?

Just to deal with the above to begin. I was sent a private message on this forum from someone saying that they had read this and that they might be able to help me past the hurdle. They then kind of reneged on that and said I should stick with you. I replied saying simply that I was open to another perspective. I have read many of the threads and I do see that there is a commonality of 'No I' I am no sure what you mean exactly by asking me if I think it is for my benefit only. And the answer is - NO i don't think that.

I started this forum suggesting that I might be already liberated/enlightened. I have so far not heard anything that I do not already know... except from your responses it seems that maybe there is something more for me to get as you say - I have not experience the reality. If that is so then I am open to looking for it as we have been doing..
You are verbalising frustration, rather than spending time with the determination to really investigate what is happening internally when you go in search of this "I"
I have mentioned a feeling of frustration but that does not mean that I am not trying to investigate this. I am still here and posting. The point is that nothing is happening internally when I go and search for the "I" apart from what has already been posted by me in this forum. There is no I so how can I find it? When I try to find it - I don't find it.. I find things that look like it but are not.
Keep your intellect out of it. (Raps back of hands with Zen stick) This doesn't require intellect.
I don't know what I am looking for and I am not sure how to look for it without thinking about it ( i.e intellect)
Just for now, drop the angry, frustrated, reasoning self and go in search of this "I" As a baby would without any pre conceived idea's of what you will find.
Know that I am not at all angry , slightly frustrated maybe at the lack of progress in this - but only slightly... and yes reasoning.

I don't know how to search as a baby would for the 'I'. I have only the preconceived notion that I will not find the I because I already know that it is not there..

What else to say?

Col

User avatar
Robin.
Posts: 144
Joined: Mon Dec 05, 2011 3:03 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby Robin. » Wed Jan 11, 2012 11:28 am

Colin. Whoever offered to help you and then reneged should have told me first.I hope this is why they had second thoughts. It is not the way we do things here so I am surprised. I was simply saying to you that switching guides at this stage will not make any more difference than reading the various threads that are happening all over this forum to other seekers. We are stretched to the limit with guides as it is. And for that matter, the fact that you feel we are not getting anywhere is proof enough that you have a block somewhere. It needs finding. The basic task I am here to help you with is to see the false illusion of self. Not describe it, not give you a false concept and wave goodbye. So. Back to basics.

What brought you here in the first place?
What are you expecting to happen ?
When you talk about self what are you referring to?
How much of Colin is authentic to yourself, and how much of Colin is based on stories and belief ?

When you go in search of a valid "I" you say nothing happens. There has to be some internal dialogue with yourself at least. Anything that is real like the keyboard you write with, doesn't disappear when you stop believing in it
I am telling you in all honesty and truth. If you search whole heartedly for this "I" that is you, its is as futile as searching for Santa Clause. YOU have to search for yourself. Innocently, not straining and waiting for a flash of light or some unknown. Our aim here is to set you free from suffering due to false expectations, false beliefs in the concept of a you. And the false belief that there is separation between you and the rest of the universe.

I think that when you are searching for the "I" that is Colin. You start to run the programme of pre conceived idea's and stories about Colin. Colin is 6? tall. He is ?years old. He likes ? He believes this that, and the other. His favourite food is? Can you see how if you look with all these interfering, judgemental false beliefs still running, you are reaffirming the false belief in an "I" that is responsible for making you think your who in fact! You are not.

Look for what, is at the core of your being-ness. There is indeed plenty happening, and plenty that will continue to happen. Lots of occurrences popping up out of nowhere. But to who?
And lastly, because I'm really trying my best here Col. Where are these thoughts arising from, and from where are they generated ?

Come on. Lets cut through this crap and get to the heart of it. You say you accept the concept of no you, no "I"
Then you will also accept the concept, the fact of no Santa Clause. Run the facts about Santa past yourself, and what we do with him fictionally every Christmas for the enjoyment of our kids, then see for yourself the similarities between him, and you, and your no self, or "I" This is doing me so much good believe me. I am laughing like a bloody drain here. I sincerely hope you do soon.

Robin.

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Wed Jan 11, 2012 11:43 am

Hi Robin,

Thanks for your post. I am traveling tomorrow and will be changing timezones so please bear with me..

Colin

User avatar
Robin.
Posts: 144
Joined: Mon Dec 05, 2011 3:03 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby Robin. » Wed Jan 11, 2012 5:20 pm

Hi Col. No worries about time zone changes. Just lets try get back to the basic questions again. Compared to some liberations this one has barely got going in the way of question and answers. We only have 3 pages opened in comparison to some with 9 or 10. This isn't a race, its about really seeing, and not conceptualising.
Please consider the questions in my last post and try and answer them whilst really looking within non intellectually. Tell me exactly what you see and feel.

User avatar
Robin.
Posts: 144
Joined: Mon Dec 05, 2011 3:03 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby Robin. » Sat Jan 14, 2012 2:46 pm

Colin, I know you were changing time zones, but please don't leave the planet. Are you in my friend?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Sat Jan 14, 2012 6:54 pm

Hi Robin,

I am in. I have been trying to take the time to really think through these questions and the No I without intellectualising and frankly I find it difficult. A change to a new time zone and a fair amount of moving around now over the next weeks may make it more difficult but I am determined to put aside some time to dedicate. As we have been going around in circles a little I wanted to find a moment to try to look at this differently. Since changing time zone I have not had a moment free and have given sufficient thought to reply with something different.

Hope you can bear with me.. Apologies for the silence.

Colin

User avatar
Robin.
Posts: 144
Joined: Mon Dec 05, 2011 3:03 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby Robin. » Sun Jan 15, 2012 11:58 am

Hi Robin,

I am in. I have been trying to take the time to really think through these questions and the No I without intellectualising and frankly I find it difficult. A change to a new time zone and a fair amount of moving around now over the next weeks may make it more difficult but I am determined to put aside some time to dedicate. As we have been going around in circles a little I wanted to find a moment to try to look at this differently. Since changing time zone I have not had a moment free and have given sufficient thought to reply with something different.

Hope you can bear with me.. Apologies for the silence.

Colin
No need for apologies Colin. Time zone changes must be difficult. But regardless of those, and anything else that may, or may not seem to be happening. The fact that there is No "I" anywhere to be found stays the same.
It doesn't require any intellectualising to find it. Simply look, and SEE. Where is it ? Science can't find it. I can't find it. It only exists in the same way that Batman does. What does exist is consciousness. Everything is appearing in consciousness. The trees, the birds, cattle in fields. swans on water. None of these life forms question an "I" as being separate from anything else. They all just are. Because they have not had their brains imprinted upon, they don't worry about what they are,or question their place in the world. Its only when you bring the character/ego into play that it tries to reason with its own survival mechanism, protecting itself at all costs.

If there is an "I" where is it? Rather than go around in circles as you put it. Give me a counter argument as to why the "I" does exist, and what purpose does it serve ? Read some of the liberations here Col. Read some other conversations and see if you can find something that perhaps takes your protective character/ego down a different view point. The end result is always the same. But there are many ways to describe an apple. I do admit.

Regards. Robin.

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Wed Jan 18, 2012 2:47 pm

Hi Robin,

I think I have been clear that I can see that the I as you describe it is indeed a fiction. I have searched for the I and I cannot find it. I have considered that only consciousness exists. But then I ask the question - well who or what is is that is having a particular experience in consciousness? If it is not me that is experiencing an itchy foot then who or what is it that experiences the itch - consciousness itself? A body/mind experiences an itch - not my body/mind? - just a body/mind? But a body that it seems very much that consciousness interacts with in a fairly unique way. No other body /mind is conscious of the exact same experience at the same time as my body/mind. (well some maybe do but that is not relevant) Ok - so these are only thoughts and feelings occurring in consciousness that describe experience. So yes - I am a story telling , describing machine and all that can be done on top of experience/consciousness is to describe it or tell stories about it. Experience itself is happening regardless. And yes that describing and story telling is also a part of experience. So the whole thing is circular. There is no I , there is only "character" which amongst other things describes and tells stories about consciousness which are filtered and colored by the other stories the "character" has told itself about consciousness. All of which are part of consciousness experiencing itself. So - I am a wave and in that sense I am unique from the other waves despite still being indistinguishable from the sea.

BUT..... Nothing happens for me knowing all of this. SO What? It makes me feel nothing !

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Thu Jan 19, 2012 8:59 pm

Robin is away for a while, so I will jump in if thats ok.
I think I have been clear that I can see that the I as you describe it is indeed a fiction. I have searched for the I and I cannot find it. I have considered that only consciousness exists. But then I ask the question - well who or what is is that is having a particular experience in consciousness? If it is not me that is experiencing an itchy foot then who or what is it that experiences the itch - consciousness itself? A body/mind experiences an itch - not my body/mind? - just a body/mind? But a body that it seems very much that consciousness interacts with in a fairly unique way.
"Who or what is it that is having a particular experience in consciousness" is begging the question, and assuming that there is a who or what that is experiencing. A better question would be "[b]Is there [/b] a who or what that is having a particular experience, or is there just experience?", And then looking for the answer. Not thinking about the answer, you will only come up with more questions/thoughts. But looking to see if there is a "Who" behind the experience.

Is it possible for things to happen without an entity to do them?

So yes - I am a story telling , describing machine and all that can be done on top of experience/consciousness is to describe it or tell stories about it. Experience itself is happening regardless. And yes that describing and story telling is also a part of experience. So the whole thing is circular. There is no I , there is only "character" which amongst other things describes and tells stories about consciousness which are filtered and colored by the other stories the "character" has told itself about consciousness. All of which are part of consciousness experiencing itself. So - I am a wave and in that sense I am unique from the other waves despite still being indistinguishable from the sea.
No, you are not a wave, because there is no you, in any way shape or form. There may be a wave, but its not you. This is an important distinction, I am not just nit picking here.

Are you your body? Or is there just a body, doing its thing?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Fri Jan 20, 2012 9:32 am

Hi - sure that is fine. Thanks for stepping in
A better question would be "Is there a who or what that is having a particular experience, or is there just experience?",
Well the answer to that question is - I don't know. It is possible that there is a who or what and it is possible that there is not a who or what. It is also possible that there is just experience.
And then looking for the answer. Not thinking about the answer, you will only come up with more questions/thoughts. But looking to see if there is a "Who" behind the experience.
I can't see a who behind experience because that is unknowable. So as far as I can see - there is no who behind experience - simply experience itself. But there could be...
Is it possible for things to happen without an entity to do them?
Yes they can happen without an entity. Things are happening all the time - the only thing that I can do is describe those things.. They are still happening without my description.
No, you are not a wave, because there is no you, in any way shape or form. There may be a wave, but its not you. This is an important distinction, I am not just nit picking here.
Ok - I picked up that analogy from Robin who I believe suggested that I am a wave but indistinguishable from the sea. I am not sure I am getting this distinction. I understand that there is no me in the sense that all the thoughts and feelings that occur that appear to relate to this body are just thoughts and feelings and therefore ultimately relate to nothing.
Are you your body? Or is there just a body, doing its thing?
I am not my body or my mind. My body and mind are doing there thing.

Thanks

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Fri Jan 20, 2012 1:07 pm

I can't see a who behind experience because that is unknowable. So as far as I can see - there is no who behind experience - simply experience itself. But there could be...
There could be a dragon living in my bathroom. There could be a striped invisible teapot hiding on the dark side of the moon. There are infinite "could be's" . Do you allow these to affect your life? If there is no evidence of a Who behind experience, then the most honest path is to not believe in one until proven otherwise.

You say "As far as I can see, there is no who behind experience". Keep checking, keep looking. Look at experiences throughout the day, and see if you can see a who behind it all, experiencing the experience. Is there an entity sitting there watching a movie screen of what is being seen by your eyes? Is there a little guy in there looking at a whole load of dials, reading off readings of energy and deducing that the body is feeling pain? Or is the very act of seeing ( light registering on back of eye, getting converted to electricity, electricity passing though brain pathways) the whole experience, the whole thing, all there is?


I understand that there is no me in the sense that all the thoughts and feelings that occur that appear to relate to this body are just thoughts and feelings and therefore ultimately relate to nothing.
Can you expand on this a little please? What do you mean by "thoughts and feelings that occur that appear to relate to the body" ? What do you mean by "they ultimately relate to nothing"?

thanks
neil

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Mon Jan 23, 2012 4:33 am

Hi Neil,
There could be a dragon living in my bathroom. There could be a striped invisible teapot hiding on the dark side of the moon. There are infinite "could be's" . Do you allow these to affect your life? If there is no evidence of a Who behind experience, then the most honest path is to not believe in one until proven otherwise.
No - I don't allow these to affect my life. "Could be's" tend not to be useful. However allowing for "could be's " does allow the human being to maintain curiosity and sometimes find new answers. If we eliminate the "could be's" altogether then we might stop being curious and stop questioning which I am not sure is desirable.
You say "As far as I can see, there is no who behind experience". Keep checking, keep looking. Look at experiences throughout the day, and see if you can see a who behind it all, experiencing the experience. Is there an entity sitting there watching a movie screen of what is being seen by your eyes? Is there a little guy in there looking at a whole load of dials, reading off readings of energy and deducing that the body is feeling pain? Or is the very act of seeing ( light registering on back of eye, getting converted to electricity, electricity passing though brain pathways) the whole experience, the whole thing, all there is?
That is right. I cannot see a who behind experience. I see my character, the observer of my character and then potentially infinite observers of the observers all of which are not real in that they are simply thoughts and feelings about thoughts and feelings. Is there a "purpose to this", " a little guy" etc - again not answerable other than to say - ( sorry ;-)) there could be. But of course in all probability and judging only from what I have evidence for - then yes all that is happening is l
light registering on back of eye, getting converted to electricity, electricity passing though brain pathways
etc etc.. This is the best current hypothesis. Like any good scientist - I can and should accept this as true but I must remain flexible and open to alternative testable hypothesis.
CTK1 wrote: I understand that there is no me in the sense that all the thoughts and feelings that occur that appear to relate to this body are just thoughts and feelings and therefore ultimately relate to nothing.
Can you expand on this a little please? What do you mean by "thoughts and feelings that occur that appear to relate to the body" ?
I mean that if I feel an itch on my foot. A thought or feeling about a physical sensation occurs that appears to relate to this body ( that I name my body) and not to another body.
What do you mean by "they ultimately relate to nothing"?
There is no "I" however there are thoughts and feelings. Thoughts and feelings occur in reality. Physical sensations occur in reality. It appears that there is a relationship between the two. But a thought or feeling about a physical sensation is simply a thought/feeling about a physical sensation. The false "I' or "character" is the only thing that ties the two together. In that sense they ultimately relate to nothing because there is nothing for them too relate too. Not sure if I am explaining myself well on this one.

Thanks,

Colin

User avatar
neeeel
Posts: 834
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 5:30 pm

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby neeeel » Mon Jan 23, 2012 2:54 pm


No - I don't allow these to affect my life. "Could be's" tend not to be useful. However allowing for "could be's " does allow the human being to maintain curiosity and sometimes find new answers. If we eliminate the "could be's" altogether then we might stop being curious and stop questioning which I am not sure is desirable.
Ok, having doubts is not a problem. Wondering if its really true is not a problem. But, when the doubts and wondering comes up, you can always check its true by looking at reality. I question it all the time, wonder if I have made a mistake, but every time I check I see that it is true.

I can and should accept this as true but I must remain flexible and open to alternative testable hypothesis.
again, remaining flexible and open is good, I am not asking you to do otherwise. All I am asking is that you look and see through a false belief, the belief in a separate self that controls and runs things. I am not asking you to take anything on faith, but to check it out for yourself.

I mean that if I feel an itch on my foot. A thought or feeling about a physical sensation occurs that appears to relate to this body ( that I name my body) and not to another body.
itches occur, but do they occur to a separate self? Is this a sticking point for you, that things appear located in this body? I read over the whole thread again and you said earlier

"So in reality there is a body mind machine experiencing and that is it. My body mind machines still has separate and different experiences to yours. It is still your body -mind machine+operating system (called Robin) writing to my body mind machine+ operating system (called Col)"

The reason it occurs in your body and not someone elses is because all the physical apparatus is in your body and not anyone elses. Im sure you realise this. But the question we are asking is, inside all the physical apparatus that is in your body, is there a separate, controlling self? Or is it all just natural biological processes, occuring to no-one?


There is no "I" however there are thoughts and feelings. Thoughts and feelings occur in reality. Physical sensations occur in reality. It appears that there is a relationship between the two. But a thought or feeling about a physical sensation is simply a thought/feeling about a physical sensation. The false "I' or "character" is the only thing that ties the two together. In that sense they ultimately relate to nothing because there is nothing for them too relate too. Not sure if I am explaining myself well on this one.
Ok, so it looks like you have seen through the illusion.

Reading this thread back though, it seems like you are still identifying with something. It seems like you feel like you are the thing that chooses what to do, the decision maker, the one who looks at all the input and decides on the best course of action, the observer. Am I correct in this?

User avatar
CTK1
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 4:59 am

Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )

Postby CTK1 » Mon Jan 23, 2012 5:54 pm

Hi Neil,

I wrote a long reply here and then the wifi went down and this board forced me to log in again and all the words were lost !! arghh. Need to rewrite again tomorrow. Sorry for delay.

Colin


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot], Majestic-12 [Bot], vinceschubert and 14 guests