Hi Guys and Gala,
I am very curious about this... I have read pretty much everything on Cieran's (sp?) "Ruthless Truth" website including the demise.... I find him to be a very insightful and interesting character and was disappointed that he quit this endeavor despite understanding his reasoning....
I would say that I think I understand all of this having read a lot of philosophy both western and eastern and most importantly having participated in Landmark Education.. I had my first real experience of enlightenment and a huge alteration in my existence post Landmark ( 10 years ago)
I need to be honest and say that I want to test myself by engaging with this process. Life has a way of encouraging forgetfulness and I want to prove to myself that I have remembered.. and if not - to ensure that I can remember again...
In addition - I am also generally interested in this process.. I fear that it has inherent issues related to power and the use of power. As did landmark.. To yield the power of liberation is to yield great power. The sense of satisfaction derived from liberating another can be intoxicating and can form a sense of self even more powerful than that previously considered... The "I" that liberates, The "I" that spreads "Truth". This can prove to be very problematic...
PS: Feel free to rip the shit out of me !! ;-)
Love and Peace
Col
A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )
Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )
Hi Col, and welcome here.
A test for the already enlightened eh? Or maybe.
Well first of all, forget all about Ciaran and his methods. We are entirely independent of the ruthless truth methods, and use only direct pointing here.
I would like you to be 100% honest with me, and especially your self. And post back to me at least once a day.
Tell me. What expectations do you have of going through this process here ?
So tell me. Where is the centre of this person called Col who needs reaffirmation ?
Where is the "I" that drives this need?
What power can be problematic ? What problems can there be in liberation. Is freedom a problem to you ?
Much respect Col. Please deliberate over my questions. Dig deep and don't judge anything by using the writings of anyone else. Simply use your won experience as you feel it NOW In this moment. Do not intellectualise. Look honestly, and answer me the same way.
Robin.
A test for the already enlightened eh? Or maybe.
Well first of all, forget all about Ciaran and his methods. We are entirely independent of the ruthless truth methods, and use only direct pointing here.
I would like you to be 100% honest with me, and especially your self. And post back to me at least once a day.
Tell me. What expectations do you have of going through this process here ?
If you were Enlightened once, or even liberated once. You would not be needing reassurance Col.I need to be honest and say that I want to test myself by engaging with this process. Life has a way of encouraging forgetfulness and I want to prove to myself that I have remembered.. and if not - to ensure that I can remember again...
So tell me. Where is the centre of this person called Col who needs reaffirmation ?
Where is the "I" that drives this need?
Who holds the power over who? Who will gain the power from liberating you ? What use is this power and to whom does it serve?Hi Guys and Gala,
I am very curious about this... I have read pretty much everything on Cieran's (sp?) "Ruthless Truth" website including the demise.... I find him to be a very insightful and interesting character and was disappointed that he quit this endeavor despite understanding his reasoning....
I would say that I think I understand all of this having read a lot of philosophy both western and eastern and most importantly having participated in Landmark Education.. I had my first real experience of enlightenment and a huge alteration in my existence post Landmark ( 10 years ago)
I need to be honest and say that I want to test myself by engaging with this process. Life has a way of encouraging forgetfulness and I want to prove to myself that I have remembered.. and if not - to ensure that I can remember again...
In addition - I am also generally interested in this process.. I fear that it has inherent issues related to power and the use of power. As did landmark.. To yield the power of liberation is to yield great power. The sense of satisfaction derived from liberating another can be intoxicating and can form a sense of self even more powerful than that previously considered... The "I" that liberates, The "I" that spreads "Truth". This can prove to be very problematic...
What power can be problematic ? What problems can there be in liberation. Is freedom a problem to you ?
Much respect Col. Please deliberate over my questions. Dig deep and don't judge anything by using the writings of anyone else. Simply use your won experience as you feel it NOW In this moment. Do not intellectualise. Look honestly, and answer me the same way.
Robin.
Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )
Hi Robin,
Thanks for your response. I will respond to each of your queries in turn.
Expectations.... Well I am not sure what to expect other than I had assumed that this was an offshoot of ruthless truth so I am expected something similar - creating an opening and an awareness of "no self" and those who pass through the gate feel a profound sense of this which leaves them feeling free from previous limitations/constraints etc.
My experience is that the ego continually tries to survive and re-assert itself. I have no idea what is the centre of Col that seeks reaffirmation. I can say what thoughts and feelings drive it -curiosity, desire to be better, fun - enjoyment of the challenge, debate, intellectual process.. and others... I think of thoughts and feelings as not being me - just being thoughts and feelings which I can watch like a movie and select or deselect depending on their utility.
"I" is that which views the movie and chooses which scenes to watch.
I am what I choose.
I am the actions I take.
I am the words I speak.
I am saying that someone like yourself "a liberator" must experience some pleasure, perhaps some sense of power from liberating others . I think that the ego continually tries to re-assert itself and even in someone enlightened /liberated there is a potential danger that the ego manages to fool them into thinking the liberation exists within them when in fact slowly the ego is re-asserting itself as the "I" that liberates and feels good about liberating. I would think that the liberated would need to constantly guard against that. History shows that power can be corrupting. Having the ability to free someone is certainly a power and so by its nature it can be corrupting. Freedom is not a problem for me ( on the face of it - it certainly sounds like a nice place to be) although it certainly begs for a definition... What does it mean to be free?
Who gains - well I guess those that those that you liberate gain regardless - but potentially the liberator actually loses by the ego re-asserting itself in a new way to which he/she is unaware.. So no problems in liberating others so long as the liberator does not become corrupted with the powerful feelings provided by liberating others..
Thanks for taking the time and look forward to your response.
Col
Thanks for your response. I will respond to each of your queries in turn.
I will post back once a day but it may be that there is the odd day where it is difficult ( i.e hard for me to find an internet connection although I don't expect that to be a problem for the next 2 weeks or so..)I would like you to be 100% honest with me, and especially your self. And post back to me at least once a day.
Tell me. What expectations do you have of going through this process her.
Expectations.... Well I am not sure what to expect other than I had assumed that this was an offshoot of ruthless truth so I am expected something similar - creating an opening and an awareness of "no self" and those who pass through the gate feel a profound sense of this which leaves them feeling free from previous limitations/constraints etc.
If you were Enlightened once, or even liberated once. You would not be needing reassurance Col.
So tell me. Where is the centre of this person called Col who needs reaffirmation ?
Where is the "I" that drives this need?
My experience is that the ego continually tries to survive and re-assert itself. I have no idea what is the centre of Col that seeks reaffirmation. I can say what thoughts and feelings drive it -curiosity, desire to be better, fun - enjoyment of the challenge, debate, intellectual process.. and others... I think of thoughts and feelings as not being me - just being thoughts and feelings which I can watch like a movie and select or deselect depending on their utility.
"I" is that which views the movie and chooses which scenes to watch.
I am what I choose.
I am the actions I take.
I am the words I speak.
I fear that it is difficult for me not to intellectualise with these kind of questions.. These questions that you ask beg for a considered answer..Who holds the power over who? Who will gain the power from liberating you ? What use is this power and to whom does it serve?
What power can be problematic ? What problems can there be in liberation. Is freedom a problem to you ?
Much respect Col. Please deliberate over my questions. Dig deep and don't judge anything by using the writings of anyone else. Simply use your won experience as you feel it NOW In this moment. Do not intellectualise. Look honestly, and answer me the same way.
I am saying that someone like yourself "a liberator" must experience some pleasure, perhaps some sense of power from liberating others . I think that the ego continually tries to re-assert itself and even in someone enlightened /liberated there is a potential danger that the ego manages to fool them into thinking the liberation exists within them when in fact slowly the ego is re-asserting itself as the "I" that liberates and feels good about liberating. I would think that the liberated would need to constantly guard against that. History shows that power can be corrupting. Having the ability to free someone is certainly a power and so by its nature it can be corrupting. Freedom is not a problem for me ( on the face of it - it certainly sounds like a nice place to be) although it certainly begs for a definition... What does it mean to be free?
Who gains - well I guess those that those that you liberate gain regardless - but potentially the liberator actually loses by the ego re-asserting itself in a new way to which he/she is unaware.. So no problems in liberating others so long as the liberator does not become corrupted with the powerful feelings provided by liberating others..
Thanks for taking the time and look forward to your response.
Col
Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )
Hi Col. I'm glad you agree to posting once a day. Your other answers are very interesting lets look at them.
You sound like you have a good all round knowledge of what no self is all about, but for now, can you tell me. Where is this "I" that chooses, decides what actions you take, and words you speak? When pealing back the many layers that make up your character "Col" Where can you find an "I" ?
Your last answer forced an intellectual answer from you as you cannot see that no one is writing to you yet.
How could you know there could be potential powerful feelings to be had from liberating others?
A liberated person would not lose out to their ego/Character as "no one" is doing the liberating. This is what I would like you to see. No one is liberating any one. And it's the character/ego who is tricking you into thinking so.
So please. Take a deep look within your thoughts. Notice how you cannot stop them. How you don't know what your next thought will be. They all just come and go. Try to stop them. While you are looking, locate the source of where this "I" is and tell me where it can be found.
You will also notice that you cannot stop your heart beating, your hair growing, fingernails etc. All these process's happen without any input from you. Where are "you" in all of this ?
Much respect Col.
Robin.
Well your assumptions are correct, this is exactly what we do here, (Politely) using direct pointing to guide you. As for what you will feel when you pass through the gateless gate is anyone's guess. I cannot put my own experience into words, so I have not a hope of suggesting what others will, or have felt.Expectations.... Well I am not sure what to expect other than I had assumed that this was an offshoot of ruthless truth so I am expected something similar - creating an opening and an awareness of "no self" and those who pass through the gate feel a profound sense of this which leaves them feeling free from previous limitations/constraints etc.
You say that "The ego" Continually tries to survive. This is also correct. For our purpose here can we swap ego for "Character"? The founders of this site have expressed a wish for us all to use the same terminology and have agreed on Character, as being the accepted term.My experience is that the ego continually tries to survive and re-assert itself. I have no idea what is the centre of Col that seeks reaffirmation. I can say what thoughts and feelings drive it -curiosity, desire to be better, fun - enjoyment of the challenge, debate, intellectual process.. and others... I think of thoughts and feelings as not being me - just being thoughts and feelings which I can watch like a movie and select or deselect depending on their utility.
"I" is that which views the movie and chooses which scenes to watch.
I am what I choose.
I am the actions I take.
I am the words I speak.
You sound like you have a good all round knowledge of what no self is all about, but for now, can you tell me. Where is this "I" that chooses, decides what actions you take, and words you speak? When pealing back the many layers that make up your character "Col" Where can you find an "I" ?
Your last answer forced an intellectual answer from you as you cannot see that no one is writing to you yet.
From "my" direct experience There is no one to experience power, or pleasure, and if I wanted an ego/Character trip I can think of easier ways of doing it for Robin. My overwhelming urge is for me to pass this freedom on to others and stop the suffering that the ego/Character constantly faces by failing to see no separateness, or non duality. How can "No One" become corrupted ? Corruption happens in the world. Just a happening to no one and everyone.I fear that it is difficult for me not to intellectualise with these kind of questions.. These questions that you ask beg for a considered answer..
I am saying that someone like yourself "a liberator" must experience some pleasure, perhaps some sense of power from liberating others . I think that the ego continually tries to re-assert itself and even in someone enlightened /liberated there is a potential danger that the ego manages to fool them into thinking the liberation exists within them when in fact slowly the ego is re-asserting itself as the "I" that liberates and feels good about liberating. I would think that the liberated would need to constantly guard against that. History shows that power can be corrupting. Having the ability to free someone is certainly a power and so by its nature it can be corrupting. Freedom is not a problem for me ( on the face of it - it certainly sounds like a nice place to be) although it certainly begs for a definition... What does it mean to be free?
Who gains - well I guess those that those that you liberate gain regardless - but potentially the liberator actually loses by the ego re-asserting itself in a new way to which he/she is unaware.. So no problems in liberating others so long as the liberator does not become corrupted with the powerful feelings provided by liberating others..
How could you know there could be potential powerful feelings to be had from liberating others?
A liberated person would not lose out to their ego/Character as "no one" is doing the liberating. This is what I would like you to see. No one is liberating any one. And it's the character/ego who is tricking you into thinking so.
So please. Take a deep look within your thoughts. Notice how you cannot stop them. How you don't know what your next thought will be. They all just come and go. Try to stop them. While you are looking, locate the source of where this "I" is and tell me where it can be found.
You will also notice that you cannot stop your heart beating, your hair growing, fingernails etc. All these process's happen without any input from you. Where are "you" in all of this ?
Much respect Col.
Robin.
Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )
Hi Robin,
Thanks for your reply. My responses below..
Await your response.
Col
Thanks for your reply. My responses below..
The answer is that I cannot find an "I' as such. I find a myriad of thoughts and feelings and choose to give precedence to some thoughts over others depending on what has utility. It is this critical aspect that decides what has utility that I choose to call "I" The character is made up of thoughts, feelings , words and actions that come from nowhere that I can identify exactly but appear to come from somewhere. Character is better described by others than myself. They say Col is funny, annoying - whatever... Certainly the thoughts and feelings and sense of "I" appear to be inextricably linked with this physical entity which does exist in reality. When you say that there is no-one liberating me - I find that confusing - because there is two distinct entities communicating over cyberspace - Robin and Col. I think maybe you are saying that our bodies/minds are a conduit for consciousness but that consciousness is not contained by them -so exists independently - so our consciousness is in fact the same ? My character/ego is fooling me into believing that we are separate? That Robin is the liberator and i am the soon to be liberated (?)Where is this "I" that chooses, decides what actions you take, and words you speak? When pealing back the many layers that make up your character "Col" Where can you find an "I" ?
I can say that individual humans can be a catalyst for corruption in the world. If I am a politician and I embezzle funds meant to alleviate suffering in my country and spend it on a swimming pool and some fine wine then I am a catalyst for corruption.How can "No One" become corrupted ? Corruption happens in the world. Just a happening to no one and everyone.
How could you know there could be potential powerful feelings to be had from liberating others?
Yes I notice that i cannot stop my thoughts - even if i think I have no thought I have the thought that there is no thought. I do not know what the next thought will be - but I can say in which context a thought may arise. So if I am thinking about mathematics there is a greater likelihood that my next thought will be in that context. Of course I could also start thinking about a bird in the tree that distracts my attention. Again I cannot locate the source of the "I" other than it appears to emanate from this physical being called Col because I am the only describer of my thoughts . Who is the "I" describing? Hmmnnn...So please. Take a deep look within your thoughts. Notice how you cannot stop them. How you don't know what your next thought will be. They all just come and go. Try to stop them. While you are looking, locate the source of where this "I" is and tell me where it can be found.
Yes - these are unconscious processes - thinking seems to have a mix of both unconscious and conscious processes so they seem different to me. Some people have been able to control these processes - slow down their heart beat and speed it up. The input from me to my thoughts and feelings is the fact that I can be separate from them and view them as not being independent and so I can choose. So "I' is the chooser.You will also notice that you cannot stop your heart beating, your hair growing, fingernails etc. All these process's happen without any input from you. Where are "you" in all of this ?
Await your response.
Col
Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )
Hi Col. lets examine your answers.
The physical entity called Col operates to a great extent independent of any input from anything other than a set of default programmes from the brain, which is also physical. Things like, breathing, blinking, heartbeat, hair growth, digestion. All simply happening. These are the default programmes you are born with. On top of these defaults is the story of Col. This I liken to windows 7, or Linux, or windows millennium, lets say. This programming was done by parents, teachers, TV, books, and whatever you took to be fact. These inputs of information all contribute towards the sum total of Col.
It's also true that the brain has a self protection mechanism that is automatically triggered when there is any sign of danger. It warns you by means of fear, and anxiety. Lots of people suffer from a fault in this mechanism and suffer anxiety, and panic attacks for no apparent reason. We won't go into why that is here, but suffice to say, that depending on what you took to be truths where danger is concerned, your brain will produce a loud warning for you. Finger over a burning flame is a good example.
So now we have a body, and brain which are both physical, the control tower, (Brain) being what we take to be self. But NO INDIVIDUAL "I" And what's more, ( no self ) So when you say,
If you walk outside amongst nature, weather permitting. Just notice how trees simply are. They don't need to be anything, or do anything. They simply are. Birds are flying, it may well be raining. Its all simply happening without any intelligence, or consideration for a why? It's the same with us. If we feel happy, Happiness is happening.
Tell me Col. When you read this, do you get any physical sensations at all?
If so, can you pinpoint where they are coming from, and where they are being felt?
If there are feelings here, who is it that is feeling them?
Ponder on this no self, or no "I" fact. And then tell me where it takes you.
Much respect,
Robin.
You say you cannot find an "I" as such. I don't expect you to find an "I" as there is no I to be found. neuroscience agrees, and endorses this fact. When monitoring the brain with electrodes fitted to the person for brain activity, brain mapping, as they call it. No "I" can be found. When people are describing Col, they are describing the character/ego, not the "I" Even though they will believe they are talking about an "I".The answer is that I cannot find an "I' as such. I find a myriad of thoughts and feelings and choose to give precedence to some thoughts over others depending on what has utility. It is this critical aspect that decides what has utility that I choose to call "I" The character is made up of thoughts, feelings , words and actions that come from nowhere that I can identify exactly but appear to come from somewhere. Character is better described by others than myself. They say Col is funny, annoying - whatever... Certainly the thoughts and feelings and sense of "I" appear to be inextricably linked with this physical entity which does exist in reality. When you say that there is no-one liberating me - I find that confusing - because there is two distinct entities communicating over cyberspace - Robin and Col. I think maybe you are saying that our bodies/minds are a conduit for consciousness but that consciousness is not contained by them -so exists independently - so our consciousness is in fact the same ? My character/ego is fooling me into believing that we are separate? That Robin is the liberator and i am the soon to be liberated (?)
The physical entity called Col operates to a great extent independent of any input from anything other than a set of default programmes from the brain, which is also physical. Things like, breathing, blinking, heartbeat, hair growth, digestion. All simply happening. These are the default programmes you are born with. On top of these defaults is the story of Col. This I liken to windows 7, or Linux, or windows millennium, lets say. This programming was done by parents, teachers, TV, books, and whatever you took to be fact. These inputs of information all contribute towards the sum total of Col.
It's also true that the brain has a self protection mechanism that is automatically triggered when there is any sign of danger. It warns you by means of fear, and anxiety. Lots of people suffer from a fault in this mechanism and suffer anxiety, and panic attacks for no apparent reason. We won't go into why that is here, but suffice to say, that depending on what you took to be truths where danger is concerned, your brain will produce a loud warning for you. Finger over a burning flame is a good example.
So now we have a body, and brain which are both physical, the control tower, (Brain) being what we take to be self. But NO INDIVIDUAL "I" And what's more, ( no self ) So when you say,
This is exactly what is happening.so our consciousness is in fact the same ? My character/ego is fooling me into believing that we are separate? That Robin is the liberator and i am the soon to be liberated (?)
If you walk outside amongst nature, weather permitting. Just notice how trees simply are. They don't need to be anything, or do anything. They simply are. Birds are flying, it may well be raining. Its all simply happening without any intelligence, or consideration for a why? It's the same with us. If we feel happy, Happiness is happening.
Tell me Col. When you read this, do you get any physical sensations at all?
If so, can you pinpoint where they are coming from, and where they are being felt?
If there are feelings here, who is it that is feeling them?
Ponder on this no self, or no "I" fact. And then tell me where it takes you.
Much respect,
Robin.
Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )
Hi Robin,
Thanks for your reply.
Yes - the "character" Colin is a story I tell myself and a story told by others. And much of this story comes from the past - be it decisions I made, parental inputs, education etc.. But at the moment it does not ring true that our consciousness is the same and my character/ego just lies that we are different and separate. I am open to explore this idea.
Await your reply..
Colin
Thanks for your reply.
Yes - the "character" Colin is a story I tell myself and a story told by others. And much of this story comes from the past - be it decisions I made, parental inputs, education etc.. But at the moment it does not ring true that our consciousness is the same and my character/ego just lies that we are different and separate. I am open to explore this idea.
I can notice how things just "are" at least from my point of view. There is a table before me - it requires nothing from me . It does not need to serve a function or be or do anything. It is only a table because I interpret it as such and I give it its being and function. But it does not require this being or function because it is regardless. It is made of wood. The wood came from a tree. Neither the wood nor the tree have to be or do anything. Humans are the only ones that consider a 'Why?' as far as I know. I also get that if we feel happy - happiness is just happening. I feel happy = happiness is happening. but we have the ability to shift our emotional states or to make particular states more likely. Does that not imply some control over the happening of happiness or the happening of sadness? If you and I and everyone else have the same consciousness how is that we can hold different emotional states at the same time?If you walk outside amongst nature, weather permitting. Just notice how trees simply are. They don't need to be anything, or do anything. They simply are. Birds are flying, it may well be raining. Its all simply happening without any intelligence, or consideration for a why? It's the same with us. If we feel happy, Happiness is happening.
I don't think I get any specific physical sensations from reading this if that is what you mean? I have specific physical sensations that are occurring regardless-. So my ear is a bit itchy. I pinpoint that sensation to my ear - but I know that my brain creates the sensation - presumably there is an irritation on the skin and the nerve endings tell the brain and then then brain says feel itchy to draw attention to the ear. But the itchiness is also just a happening like happiness. It just is - the happening of itchiness. I give the itchiness a story. The human being made up of default programs and with the operating system "Col" is what is feeling the itch. And that is what "I' am. But there is something else - there is something that can change some of the programs and even the operating system..Tell me Col. When you read this, do you get any physical sensations at all?
If so, can you pinpoint where they are coming from, and where they are being felt?
If there are feelings here, who is it that is feeling them?
I think I might be missing something or something is not translating for me, because as far as I can see we have established that there is a "self". Albeit a self which is a fantasy or story but a self none the less.Ponder on this no self, or no "I" fact. And then tell me where it takes you.
Await your reply..
Colin
Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )
Hi Col. Lets look at your answers and see what we can agree on.
Try it now. Are you your body? No. You can lose your arms and legs and still be here. Are you your thoughts? are you your conscious everything ? No. That would mean that when you sleep you die. Where does Col go in the sleep state ? There is no "I" to be found. All there is after all the chemicals and elements that constitute your body are removed is the programme loaded onto your brain called Col. You might say, I am my spirit, or my soul. That implies that there is more than one of you. Look for this "I" that is not the bodymind programme and tell me what you find.
Regards, Robin.
Consciousness/awareness is a commonality between sentient beings. All things are appearing in consciousness to all sentient seeing beings. There is NO, separateness at all. Non duality is another myth that comes with the false sense of an "I". A good analogy is the sea and the wave. The wave is a wave upon the sea, but it is made from currents within the sea. There is no separation between the wave and the sea. Its all a "one" expanse of water, unquestionably.Yes - the "character" Colin is a story I tell myself and a story told by others. And much of this story comes from the past - be it decisions I made, parental inputs, education etc.. But at the moment it does not ring true that our consciousness is the same and my character/ego just lies that we are different and separate. I am open to explore this idea.
We do have a certain amount of autonomy to change our state of thoughts, and feelings. But our feelings arise as a direct result of how we have been conditioned. You will have seen how different people react in different ways. The optimist, the pessimist. Why? Complete extremes of each other. Without the overwritten story of Col upon your Character/ego, you would not be feeling any emotions, either good or bad. It's also true to say that your emotional responses to extreme situations happen in a split second without you realising it. How many times have you thought afterwards. "Oh I wish I hadn't said that"? It is the character called Col that is responsible for this. A character which does not have any authentic relationship to the original consciousness the body had at birth. It is over written data.I can notice how things just "are" at least from my point of view. There is a table before me - it requires nothing from me . It does not need to serve a function or be or do anything. It is only a table because I interpret it as such and I give it its being and function. But it does not require this being or function because it is regardless. It is made of wood. The wood came from a tree. Neither the wood nor the tree have to be or do anything. Humans are the only ones that consider a 'Why?' as far as I know. I also get that if we feel happy - happiness is just happening. I feel happy = happiness is happening. but we have the ability to shift our emotional states or to make particular states more likely. Does that not imply some control over the happening of happiness or the happening of sadness? If you and I and everyone else have the same consciousness how is that we can hold different emotional states at the same time?
When I asked about Physical sensations, I perhaps should have included emotional sensations. like happiness, sadness, fear, anger. No feelings other than an itch is fine. And stories is exactly what we give to everything. The operating system of Col, and its overwritten programmes will change only when the character/ego Col has been convinced of a new paradigm that is true. Beliefs are nothing. Beliefs are held on fear mainly. When you can see for yourself clearly, then the change in the whole system will begin.I don't think I get any specific physical sensations from reading this if that is what you mean? I have specific physical sensations that are occurring regardless-. So my ear is a bit itchy. I pinpoint that sensation to my ear - but I know that my brain creates the sensation - presumably there is an irritation on the skin and the nerve endings tell the brain and then then brain says feel itchy to draw attention to the ear. But the itchiness is also just a happening like happiness. It just is - the happening of itchiness. I give the itchiness a story. The human being made up of default programs and with the operating system "Col" is what is feeling the itch. And that is what "I' am. But there is something else - there is something that can change some of the programs and even the operating system..
No Col. There is no self at all. There is this false self, or character/ego called Col. This is a programme as we've discussed. When you go in search of an "I" , You cannot find one, no more than science can either.I think I might be missing something or something is not translating for me, because as far as I can see we have established that there is a "self". Albeit a self which is a fantasy or story but a self none the less.
Try it now. Are you your body? No. You can lose your arms and legs and still be here. Are you your thoughts? are you your conscious everything ? No. That would mean that when you sleep you die. Where does Col go in the sleep state ? There is no "I" to be found. All there is after all the chemicals and elements that constitute your body are removed is the programme loaded onto your brain called Col. You might say, I am my spirit, or my soul. That implies that there is more than one of you. Look for this "I" that is not the bodymind programme and tell me what you find.
Regards, Robin.
Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )
Hi Robin,
Thanks for your reply. I agree with almost everything you write ..
There is no " I " - only an operating system that we choose to call "I" That begs the question - "So what exists if I erase the operating system called "Col" ? Only the hardware remains which can't do anything without a new operating system. But as a baby - you are immediately able to process information - although you can't make much sense of it. So there is consciousness of what is out in the world around you. But a consciousness without labels. There is no language to describe and no experience to look back at. So all there is, is experiencing . But something is doing the experiencing.. The baby human with No character is experiencing and it's experiencing is still presumably unique to it. So in reality there is a body mind machine experiencing and that is it. My body mind machines still has separate and different experiences to yours. It is still your body -mind machine+operating system (called Robin) writing to my body mind machine+ operating system (called Col).
It is also generally useful to the body mind machine to have an operating system in order to try to make sense of the incoming stimuli. Although often the program gets some bad code which causes it to run less effectively.
Not sure If I am getting anywhere here. I feel that we agree and yet I feel that I am missing something.. I can sit outside of my thoughts and feelings and just observe them apart from in those extreme situations you mention where my character just reacts. But even with those - immediately after I can recognize it for what it is .. I can observe that the observer is just another thought and on and on into infinity !
Look forward to your response.
Colin
Thanks for your reply. I agree with almost everything you write ..
There is no " I " - only an operating system that we choose to call "I" That begs the question - "So what exists if I erase the operating system called "Col" ? Only the hardware remains which can't do anything without a new operating system. But as a baby - you are immediately able to process information - although you can't make much sense of it. So there is consciousness of what is out in the world around you. But a consciousness without labels. There is no language to describe and no experience to look back at. So all there is, is experiencing . But something is doing the experiencing.. The baby human with No character is experiencing and it's experiencing is still presumably unique to it. So in reality there is a body mind machine experiencing and that is it. My body mind machines still has separate and different experiences to yours. It is still your body -mind machine+operating system (called Robin) writing to my body mind machine+ operating system (called Col).
It is also generally useful to the body mind machine to have an operating system in order to try to make sense of the incoming stimuli. Although often the program gets some bad code which causes it to run less effectively.
Not sure If I am getting anywhere here. I feel that we agree and yet I feel that I am missing something.. I can sit outside of my thoughts and feelings and just observe them apart from in those extreme situations you mention where my character just reacts. But even with those - immediately after I can recognize it for what it is .. I can observe that the observer is just another thought and on and on into infinity !
Look forward to your response.
Colin
Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )
Hi Colin. Well, we don't intend to erase the operating system for a start. That would require brain death, or similar.
Babies do not start processing any real information until they reach 18 months- 2 years. They quickly learn that by screaming, they will get attention to needs.
My point is so simple you 're overlooking it. You are not your brain, or your character/ego. You are not your body either. YOU are nowhere to be found. Absolute scientific fact. Your brain does label everything it sees, and sets about processing everything according to its belief system. When liberation occurs, and the shift in conciousness takes place, like the clear seeing of no "I", and the fact that you really are another part of everything you see. Just like the analogy of the wave and the sea I made.
various things happen all the time to Colin. But at present you identify with them as Colin the character/ego. Not Colin the everything, and the nothing both at the same time. Things happening to Colin are simple as that. Happening. Things are happening everywhere. Everything is popping up in conciousness, without any input from you.
Now you can chose to identify with certain things like happiness. Or you can allow happiness to just simply be happening. This of course applies to pain also. But the fact remains the same, that it is all happening to no one. Why? Because no one, no "I" exists. If no "I" exists why identify with anything. Who is there to claim ownership ?
Dig a little deeper Colin. Its staring you in the face now.
Much respect. Robin.
Babies do not start processing any real information until they reach 18 months- 2 years. They quickly learn that by screaming, they will get attention to needs.
My point is so simple you 're overlooking it. You are not your brain, or your character/ego. You are not your body either. YOU are nowhere to be found. Absolute scientific fact. Your brain does label everything it sees, and sets about processing everything according to its belief system. When liberation occurs, and the shift in conciousness takes place, like the clear seeing of no "I", and the fact that you really are another part of everything you see. Just like the analogy of the wave and the sea I made.
various things happen all the time to Colin. But at present you identify with them as Colin the character/ego. Not Colin the everything, and the nothing both at the same time. Things happening to Colin are simple as that. Happening. Things are happening everywhere. Everything is popping up in conciousness, without any input from you.
Now you can chose to identify with certain things like happiness. Or you can allow happiness to just simply be happening. This of course applies to pain also. But the fact remains the same, that it is all happening to no one. Why? Because no one, no "I" exists. If no "I" exists why identify with anything. Who is there to claim ownership ?
Dig a little deeper Colin. Its staring you in the face now.
Much respect. Robin.
Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )
Hi Robin,
So having written all this and thinking some more I anticipate what you might respond - something like - "Who is the I that is looking for things to have utility or value?" and presumably that must also be my ego/character that is looking for that. And so - given that that is a construct then it is true to say that no-one is looking for things to have value/utility and no-one is writing to me and no-one is writing to you . But even if agreeing that in a linguistic way - I find that the word no-one effectively means character/ego despite it being a construct. So I am no further on and it seems like a linguistic trick of sorts.. At the same time - I feel a kind of struggle in my brain which looks at this no I thing and tries to impede my thinking about it..
I feel that we are going in circles and I am starting to feel frustrated. I ask myself - does it have utility to be frustrated - and I answer No - so I stop feeling frustrated and carry on...
I need to consider these questions more..
Col
Perhaps I was unclear. I know that there is no intention to erase the operating system. I was positing a hypothetical in order to go through a stream of consciousness with you.Hi Colin. Well, we don't intend to erase the operating system for a start. That would require brain death, or similar.
Babies do not start processing any real information until they reach 18 months- 2 years. They quickly learn that by screaming, they will get attention to needs.
I fully agree that I am not my brain, body, character, ego. So not sure what exactly I am overlooking? i also agree that I am a part of everything I see. I like the wave /sea analogy - but just to be very clear - what is the analogous to the wave and the sea>My point is so simple you 're overlooking it. You are not your brain, or your character/ego. You are not your body either. YOU are nowhere to be found. Absolute scientific fact. Your brain does label everything it sees, and sets about processing everything according to its belief system. When liberation occurs, and the shift in conciousness takes place, like the clear seeing of no "I", and the fact that you really are another part of everything you see. Just like the analogy of the wave and the sea I made.
If I travel to Australia I might have Kangaroos pop up in my consciousness and that has an input from me in the sense that it is less likely that Kangaroos will pop up in my consciousness anywhere else in the world. ( ok - apart from in a Zoo - but you get the point..) I am not sure what you mean by Colin - the everything and nothing at the same time? I get that things are happening but depending on where I choose to locate myself those happenings will vary and as in the Kangaroo example I can create a greater possibility of certain happenings. . So it does not seem as simple as that to me. I identify things that happen with Colin the character/ego because it generally serves me to do that not because I think that Colin the character/ego is real. I know it is a story . What else should I identify it with ? There is nothing else to identify things that happen with.various things happen all the time to Colin. But at present you identify with them as Colin the character/ego. Not Colin the everything, and the nothing both at the same time. Things happening to Colin are simple as that. Happening. Things are happening everywhere. Everything is popping up in conciousness, without any input from you.
I am not sure it is possible to live in the world at all without identifying with the ego/character at least at some level. Surely the value is in recognizing it as a construct and being able to reconstruct it so that it serves more effectively. To me happiness in a choice and only a choice. It does not exist independently from me and other human beings. Feelings/Emotions often come from thinking that something should be a certain way or should not be a certain way and then feeling the apparently appropriate emotion. If everything is just happening then my value judgements on what is happening are irrelevant unless they serve a purpose. So for example - If I judge that something should be a certain way and it is not - which comes from my ego/character Colin - and the emotion that comes up is Anger - I can choose if Anger serves me or not in that moment. If` it does not - then I can discard it. Sometimes the reality is that in extreme situations I display Anger and then discard it. It would be great to get to the stage of not even displaying it even in extreme situations until after I had reviewed its value/utility.Now you can chose to identify with certain things like happiness. Or you can allow happiness to just simply be happening. This of course applies to pain also. But the fact remains the same, that it is all happening to no one. Why? Because no one, no "I" exists. If no "I" exists why identify with anything. Who is there to claim ownership ?
So having written all this and thinking some more I anticipate what you might respond - something like - "Who is the I that is looking for things to have utility or value?" and presumably that must also be my ego/character that is looking for that. And so - given that that is a construct then it is true to say that no-one is looking for things to have value/utility and no-one is writing to me and no-one is writing to you . But even if agreeing that in a linguistic way - I find that the word no-one effectively means character/ego despite it being a construct. So I am no further on and it seems like a linguistic trick of sorts.. At the same time - I feel a kind of struggle in my brain which looks at this no I thing and tries to impede my thinking about it..
I feel that we are going in circles and I am starting to feel frustrated. I ask myself - does it have utility to be frustrated - and I answer No - so I stop feeling frustrated and carry on...
I need to consider these questions more..
Thanks for bearing with me.If no "I" exists why identify with anything. Who is there to claim ownership ?
Col
Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )
Hi Colin. I won't quote all your replies but I'll try to answer everything you're struggling with and see where that takes us.
When you are liberated life continues pretty much the same. Its your new awareness which is so amazing. Nothing will have the selfishness about it any more. What's happening now is this. You are compressed into probably your head, or if not, your heart area. Compressed, and contracted. I want you to look for this illusory "I" see how conspicuous it is by its absence. Then expand, to the valid you. Your feeling all angry and frustrated will only cause more contraction. Relax, go over what we have discussed, and feel it.
I don't know if I've already used this one, if so forgive me. Imagine! You are stood in front of a large mirror in your house, or somewhere familiar to you. You see yourself. Someone comes along and pours a liquid over you that makes you completely invisible. Watch as you disappear from head to toe. But that's not all. You try to speak only to find you lost your voice as well. You can see the wall behind you through the mirror, but no Colin. Are you any the less other than bodily, and audibly? See the no "I" and this is it. The rest is an illusion. Don't just accept the concept.No it to be true and feel what happens. Any fear is good. It means you are almost there. Once through the imaginary gateless gate all fear disappears.
Robin.
Consciousness is what everything is appearing in.I was positing a hypothetical in order to go through a stream of consciousness with you.
OK. The sea in my analogy is everything you can experience and view. Right out into the universe and the many thousands of stars and galaxies. Everything within your field of vision, everything that appears in consciousness. The sea has waves. You are a wave.I am another wave. There is no difference between the sea and the wave. There is no duality.I fully agree that I am not my brain, body, character, ego. So not sure what exactly I am overlooking? i also agree that I am a part of everything I see. I like the wave /sea analogy - but just to be very clear - what is the analogous to the wave and the sea>
You can observe everything happening to Colin, everything will continue to happen to Colin. But with the knowledge that it is all an illusion, you don't have to accept it as valid. When you have crossed the gate, you will see what I am trying to explain. There is not a vocabulary to describe exactly what is, but it is enough to know experientially that you are not the body, the mind, the anything. There is no "I" You need to feel it, not know it as a concept. It is a fact! Once this is grasped experientially you will pop! Likely as not laugh your brains out at the simplicity of it, and who knows whatever other experiences you will have. As time goes on you begin to strip away more, and more layers of the lies away and see other aspects of life in all their glory.. I identify things that happen with Colin the character/ego because it generally serves me to do that not because I think that Colin the character/ego is real. I know it is a story . What else should I identify it with ? There is nothing else to identify things that happen with.
Remember you have a lifetime of conditioning to break down. Especially the character/ego which is causing your frustration. This is very natural. It will go to any lengths to stop you from destroying its hold.I feel that we are going in circles and I am starting to feel frustrated. I ask myself - does it have utility to be frustrated - and I answer No - so I stop feeling frustrated and carry on...
I need to consider these questions more..
If no "I" exists why identify with anything. Who is there to claim ownership ?
When you are liberated life continues pretty much the same. Its your new awareness which is so amazing. Nothing will have the selfishness about it any more. What's happening now is this. You are compressed into probably your head, or if not, your heart area. Compressed, and contracted. I want you to look for this illusory "I" see how conspicuous it is by its absence. Then expand, to the valid you. Your feeling all angry and frustrated will only cause more contraction. Relax, go over what we have discussed, and feel it.
I don't know if I've already used this one, if so forgive me. Imagine! You are stood in front of a large mirror in your house, or somewhere familiar to you. You see yourself. Someone comes along and pours a liquid over you that makes you completely invisible. Watch as you disappear from head to toe. But that's not all. You try to speak only to find you lost your voice as well. You can see the wall behind you through the mirror, but no Colin. Are you any the less other than bodily, and audibly? See the no "I" and this is it. The rest is an illusion. Don't just accept the concept.No it to be true and feel what happens. Any fear is good. It means you are almost there. Once through the imaginary gateless gate all fear disappears.
Robin.
Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )
Hi Robin,
I have spent a good deal of time today thinking about all of this and I find myself going in circles..
I understand all what you say and agree with it but I do not feel it or grasp it experientially as I expect is needed for the popping to occur.
Really - all fear disappears? Wow - I want some of that...
Col
I have spent a good deal of time today thinking about all of this and I find myself going in circles..
I understand all what you say and agree with it but I do not feel it or grasp it experientially as I expect is needed for the popping to occur.
I see the "no I" . I don't really feel fear- I maybe feel resistance... I am not sure.. but I am not popping...Are you any the less other than bodily, and audibly?
No - I am no less
See the no "I" and this is it. The rest is an illusion. Don't just accept the concept.No it to be true and feel what happens. Any fear is good. It means you are almost there. Once through the imaginary gateless gate all fear disappears.
Really - all fear disappears? Wow - I want some of that...
Col
Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )
HI Colin. Yes you're stuck it seems. Its either you accept the concept, but you character/ego is blocking you from experiencing it as truth. Its a bit like Santa Clause. You believed in his existence at one time. I'm sure you don't now. How can you hang onto something that clearly doesn't exist Superman is a fictional character. He only lives in Gotham city in a fictional story. You KNOW! Its not real. Truly know it. What is stopping you knowing there is no "I" ?
Fear does disappear. Fear is a feeling. Feelings are happening to no one. How can no one fear anything?
Are you really convinced that you accept the absence of an "I" ?
Have you searched for one ?
Are you sunbathing right now on Bondai beach, If you stop and imagine it, or is it all in your mind?
Something is holding you back. It has to be your imagination that continues to convince you of an authentic "I"
Or fear is stopping the illusive bubble that is blinding you from bursting. Challenge the concept. It's either just that, a concept. Or else there is no you, neither in body, mind, spirit, nowhere. And all there really is to be found is one Consciousness, in which everything, including you is appearing
It was all an illusion Colin. Look! Then LOOK again. It's staring you in the face. This is not a belief system, nor a religion of any kind. We're talking scientific fact, and the first hand experience of goodness knows how many people here everyday alone. I'm not giving you second hand bullshit here. These are all pointers for you to disprove, or see. I'm confident you'll see when you get past whatever the block is.
Robin.
Fear does disappear. Fear is a feeling. Feelings are happening to no one. How can no one fear anything?
Are you really convinced that you accept the absence of an "I" ?
Have you searched for one ?
Are you sunbathing right now on Bondai beach, If you stop and imagine it, or is it all in your mind?
Something is holding you back. It has to be your imagination that continues to convince you of an authentic "I"
Or fear is stopping the illusive bubble that is blinding you from bursting. Challenge the concept. It's either just that, a concept. Or else there is no you, neither in body, mind, spirit, nowhere. And all there really is to be found is one Consciousness, in which everything, including you is appearing
It was all an illusion Colin. Look! Then LOOK again. It's staring you in the face. This is not a belief system, nor a religion of any kind. We're talking scientific fact, and the first hand experience of goodness knows how many people here everyday alone. I'm not giving you second hand bullshit here. These are all pointers for you to disprove, or see. I'm confident you'll see when you get past whatever the block is.
Robin.
Re: A test for the already enlightened... (maybe ;-) )
Hi Robin,
All my experience is in my mind in the sense that there is no other way of experiencing the world. So I could easily say that none of it is there except as I experience it /or in my mind.. But I can't see the utility in considering that Bondi Beach is in my imagination and that I am not really there. If I did that then I might keep walking out to sea and drown.
Thanks,
Col
Well - I am not sure we can rid ourselves of our character/ego altogether. That would put us in the state of a baby and we would not be able to do anything. Without a character/ego you would not be able to get up in the morning and go about your day. I can see that an awareness of the falsehood of the "I'" (meaning the construct that has built up since I was born that I identify with as myself) - enables new perspectives.How can you hang onto something that clearly doesn't exist Superman is a fictional character. He only lives in Gotham city in a fictional story. You KNOW! Its not real. Truly know it. What is stopping you knowing there is no "I" ?
I accept that my ego/character is not me and so in that sense I accept that there is no "I" I also cannot find another I - although it sometimes can appear that the thoughts that are able to recognise an emotion as simply that is another " I' - the observer . Although I can accept that even that is just another thought. and so yes I can accept that there is no "I". But if it is possible to drop the ego/character altogether rather than just recognising it as a construct then there is nothing left accept experiencing without labels/thoughts/emotions - a bit like a baby. I can't see how that would be useful and how living as a adult in the world would even be possible.My experience of feelings/emotions is that they come whether I like it or not. But I am able to see them as feelings - they come and go and I don't control that. With that recognition they do not have power over me and give me the option to let them go.Fear does disappear. Fear is a feeling. Feelings are happening to no one. How can no one fear anything?
Are you really convinced that you accept the absence of an "I" ?
Have you searched for one ?
Are you sunbathing right now on Bondai beach, If you stop and imagine it, or is it all in your mind?
All my experience is in my mind in the sense that there is no other way of experiencing the world. So I could easily say that none of it is there except as I experience it /or in my mind.. But I can't see the utility in considering that Bondi Beach is in my imagination and that I am not really there. If I did that then I might keep walking out to sea and drown.
Sure - it could be true that all there is is one consciousness in which everything including me is appearing. But that idea takes all free choice away and seems to assume that nothing is real. I can't verify that.And all there really is to be found is one Consciousness, in which everything, including you is appearing
Thanks,
Col
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 15 guests

