No. apology can happen. A thought “I am Zach and I need to apologize” can also happen or not. But, the apology can happen (or not) regardless. Even the thought can be there, but it doesn’t imply an “owner”, just like the appearance of color does not imply there is an owner of the color.
Hi Zach,
Lovely! This is much more direct looking :)
When resistance appears, it just appears, no separate entity is causing the resistance. But, it is a good reminder to investigate whether a new thought-identity is forming around the resistance that claims to actually exist.
Yes, resistance can be a useful pointer to an unquestioned belief. And as you've noticed, neither the resistance nor the thought claiming ownership of it establishes a separate Zach.
Just remember, there's no need to make investigating every thought or resistance into another task that must be accomplished.
There's one thing I’d still want you to look at: responsibility.
You've seen that no separate Zach can be found making decisions or controlling actions. But earlier you questioned who needs to apologise or take responsibility if there's nobody doing anything.
Let's use an ordinary example. Suppose you say something hurtful to your wife. She tells you she's upset.
What happens next?
Perhaps there's concern, an apology, or an attempt to make things right.
Does any of that require a separate Zach making it happen?
Consequences arise (or not) regardless of whether those consequences are thought to be owned by a “someone” or not.
And does recognising that there's no separate controller mean that the hurt, the consequences or the possibility of making amends disappear?
“Responsability” is a concept created by thought. Apart from the thought about “responsibility” it does not exist in direct experience. For example, shape does not contain any information about “responsability”. Thought adds an owner of shape and may say “the owner is responsible for the shape”. But, thought is not evidence of what it describes. It is not evidence of an owner, or evidence that the owner has ownership (and therefore responsibility) of the shape.
LOOK at how this works in your own experience, rather than reasoning about what responsibility must mean without a self in nondual environment. It does sound logical - no self, no problem - but logic is not what we are interested here :)
“No self, no problem” is an attitude or belief. Apart from thought, it does not arise in direct experience. The thought or belief “no self, no problem” supplies a subtle identity of “no self”, and then concludes because there is the identity of “no self” and “no self has no ability to have ownership or control, it cannot be responsible. Rather than thought supplying an identity of a “me” that has ownership or control over other things, thought of “no self” as an identity supplies the conclusion that the identity cannot have ownership or control over things, and perhaps further supplies a very subtle conclusion “therefore, it is unfair to hold ‘no self’ responsible because it has no ability to own or control.” It is a kind of belief in a self which simply doesn’t have choice. It is still a thought that says there is a “me” separate from the “rest”. But, this thought does not supply any evidence of the truth of its content.
I’m sorry if that’s not “looking”, and just more reasoning, but it can be difficult with words to talk about the looking when it is looking at thoughts themselves.
My wife prides herself on having preferences/judgments and loves to tell me about them, sometimes inviting me to have preferences/judgments, too. If you’d asked this question a week ago, I might have said I feel flummoxed when her invitations land because there was a subtle and unexamined sensation of an “I” who didn’t want to lose the recognition of “no self”, but also didn’t want to risk losing connection by declining to have preferences/judgments with my wife.
We've explored quite a lot now, and you've become much more direct in your looking :)
I'm curious about how things are unfolding in everyday life, when you're not deliberately investigating.
When you're busy working, talking with your wife, making plans or dealing with something unpleasant, how does the sense of "me" show up, if at all?
But, now I see that is just another thought consisting of a subtle formation of an “I” who could lose something (either the thought “I’ve recognized something I could lose” or the thought “I will be hurt if I don’t state preferences/judgments”. Those thoughts can be there, after all, who could resist them, and who could own them?
In work, subtle thoughts about an “I” who could be in trouble if certain actions are not performed by an “I” arise and are initially believed. Then, more thought comes up later to investigate that belief about ownership and the thoughts are seen to not have an owner.
I think “ownership” is actually something that, for the past few days, needed exploring, but now is clear.
In the moment, yes. Subtle beliefs that imply a zach crop up. Sometimes they are investigated, sometimes not because they are so quickly dismissed.
And when it does, is there still a belief that there's an actual Zach behind the experience, or is it recognised as thoughts and sensations without a separate owner?
Well, all my judgments, preferences, and habits still happen, but there is no me behind them. Reactions still happen like frustration and guilt. Sometimes investigation into whether there is a “me” happens when something feels particularly grippy.There's no need to go looking for a particular experience. Just tell me what you've noticed naturally.
What has changed and what hasn’t in normal everyday living?
I can see now there was identification with a self who believed he’d been treated unfairly.What is the biggest difference from before starting this conversation?
No. Sometimes investigation into whether a thought subtly implies a self is investigated, and is seen through. There isn’t seeking for enlightenment or awakening. I can’t find a self who could do that.Is seeking still going on?
I just want to thank you so much for all the guidance. It really means a lot that you helped me so much.Is there any confusion at all or anything you would like to address?
If you had asked me 2 days ago, I probably would have said ownership is something worth exploring. But, I’ve investigated ownership deeply on my own now and I can’t find an owner of any sensation or thought. Just thoughts that claim there is an owner.
Yes! It is a thought that arises. It is without a cause, an owner, or a location. Once it was understood that thought is not evidence of what it describes, the mechanism maintaining the illusion was seen and the thought was no longer convincing.Can you say with a big fat YES, it is clear what the illusion of a separate self is?

