Hi Rali,
This was fun! Actually! It was a big challenge for the elle who loves explaining things. This round of questions really pushed me. Thank you so much.
Can you find a boundary in seeing that establishes an inside containing Elle and an outside containing everything else?
I don’t find a boundary. It’s seeing. Things–feet, the cat, hands, water bottle–are seen; they’re part of seeing itself.
Or are "inside", "outside", "body" and "room" labels describing what's seen?
They are all labels.
Where exactly is the dividing line between the one supposedly looking and what's being looked at?
I can’t find a dividing line between the looking and what’s seen.
When seeing happens, can an actual Elle be found somewhere inside the body doing the seeing?
I can’t find “inside the body.” I can’t find an elle that does anything. There’s no elle.
Explanation: I imagine elle is like a tiny pilot light somewhere in my chest, a spark, or code, not visible to the naked eye, and when i die, it will go out. The code stops running. Then I won’t be “in here” anymore. I won’t be anymore. Typing it, I feel silly, but I think that’s how I conceptualize it.
Have these exact colours and this exact appearance been experienced before?
No, everything is new each moment, everything is changing.
Where is the previously seen body now? Can you find it anywhere outside memory thoughts and images appearing now?
It’s not the same body. The previously seen body doesn’t exist at all except as memory which is just a thought, not the same as a past.
What establishes that this is the same body belonging to the same Elle?
It’s not the same body and there is no elle.
And when the thought "I've seen myself in this mirror before" appears, does that thought contain an actual Elle who has been present throughout all those moments?
The thought definitely appears, “There I am again.” But thought is just thought, not really an I, not an entity.
Does the sense/feeling of self have a location or boundaries? Does it contain an Elle?
The SENSATION of self is in my chest. It’s just a sensation, it feels like an anchor. There is no self in the sensation that I can find when I look. Why do I THINK it’s really the essence of me?
Does the sense of self have a shape or a size?
I can’t feel a shape or size, just a weighty sensation.
Does the sense of self say or communicate anything?
It does not.
Does the sense of self have any characteristics or attributes?
The sensation is like a pulling or a heaviness.
What is the sense of self ‘made of’?
It’s just a sensation. I don’t know what sensations are made of?
What distinguishes it, filters it out from "not me"?
I don’t know. The sensation feels like it’s inside the body, but when I close my eyes and look, I can’t find an “inside the body.” I can still feel the pulling sensation, but it’s not locateable. And it doesn’t seem separate from anything else.
If and when that sense of "me" arises, what creates and/or notices it?
I don’t know what creates it, but I think a thought “me” precedes it then it arises. My body notices? Then there is a thought about it.
What experiences the sense of me? Are there two – me and sense of me?
I do not have any ideas here. I can’t find an experiencer, or anything except the sensation, and it just is.
When there is a sense of "me", and thus "not me" as well, look for what "in here" looks out at what is "out there" (i.e., "not me")? Can you find something inside the body doing the looking, or is there simply seeing?
The sensation of me can’t look. It’s just a sensation “in here.” But when I look, I can’t find “in here” nor “out there,” to be honest. Just seeing.
And having experienced a "me" your whole life: was it because you identified with an aspect of experience (e.g. sensation or colour), or identified as an aspect of experience? Is/was there a difference between identifying with and identifying as something?
I am unsure what exactly you mean by identifying with v as, but if I’m understanding, I identified as the sensation, like, the sensation contains Me. When I type that, it sounds ludicrous, not the reality that is. But the sensation and thoughts are very convincing even still.
Now focus on the sensations that feels like a me one by one. Keep the focus on the sensation itself and ask:
Does this sensation know anything?
Does it know whatever is seen?
Does this sensation perceives the sounds in the room?
Does this sensation aware of thoughts?
All NO. It's a sensation only.
love,
elle