Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
- inquirydogg
- Posts: 10
- Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:44 am
Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
LU is focused guiding for seeing there is no real, inherent 'self' - what do you understand by this?
Self is the bundle of thoughts that form an identity, which are believed by the body-mind. I (this body-mind) believes this illusion. I cannot unhook from the belief in the separate self.
During inquiry, there are moments where I can feel the spaciosness behind thoughts, but even then, there is a sense that something else needs to happen.
What are you looking for at LU?
I am looking for the truth - to unhook from this illusion that keeps pulling me in. I am tired of this feeling that I always need more. Before it focused on career/money and then I accomplished it (quit a career, build a business). And then wanted to travel and I accomplished that (lived a nomad life in different countries). And then I was lonely and needed love and then I accomplished that (have a beautiful wife and amazing son). And so it goes. The mind finds a way to replicate that lack feeling with different variables. Instead of wanting more money/travel, the new variable may be a "better place to raise your children" and the focus is now on moving to that place. It just never seems to stop. Just as soon as I accomplish, something new is somehow needed.
I am tired of that.
What do you expect from a guided conversation?
I need help to my way into inquiry that is "alive".
Yet, I find it difficult to just sit for an hour by myself. So my inquiries generally come with listening to others inquire while I do it on my own (e.g. podcasts, YT videos, etc.). Books are kind of passive for me, but real inquiry is alive.
What is your experience in terms of spiritual practices, seeking and inquiry?
Too many books I have read and known this on the level of intellect. Only over the last years, I have started applying the teaching by "looking" / inquiring rather than conceptualizing (thinking about it).
Currently, I am starting to realize that this needs more inquiry / more direct looking, rather than more knowledge.
On a scale from 1 to 10, how willing are you to question any currently held beliefs about 'self? 9
Self is the bundle of thoughts that form an identity, which are believed by the body-mind. I (this body-mind) believes this illusion. I cannot unhook from the belief in the separate self.
During inquiry, there are moments where I can feel the spaciosness behind thoughts, but even then, there is a sense that something else needs to happen.
What are you looking for at LU?
I am looking for the truth - to unhook from this illusion that keeps pulling me in. I am tired of this feeling that I always need more. Before it focused on career/money and then I accomplished it (quit a career, build a business). And then wanted to travel and I accomplished that (lived a nomad life in different countries). And then I was lonely and needed love and then I accomplished that (have a beautiful wife and amazing son). And so it goes. The mind finds a way to replicate that lack feeling with different variables. Instead of wanting more money/travel, the new variable may be a "better place to raise your children" and the focus is now on moving to that place. It just never seems to stop. Just as soon as I accomplish, something new is somehow needed.
I am tired of that.
What do you expect from a guided conversation?
I need help to my way into inquiry that is "alive".
Yet, I find it difficult to just sit for an hour by myself. So my inquiries generally come with listening to others inquire while I do it on my own (e.g. podcasts, YT videos, etc.). Books are kind of passive for me, but real inquiry is alive.
What is your experience in terms of spiritual practices, seeking and inquiry?
Too many books I have read and known this on the level of intellect. Only over the last years, I have started applying the teaching by "looking" / inquiring rather than conceptualizing (thinking about it).
Currently, I am starting to realize that this needs more inquiry / more direct looking, rather than more knowledge.
On a scale from 1 to 10, how willing are you to question any currently held beliefs about 'self? 9
Re: Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
Hi, I am guide here and would be happy to support your inquiry. Are you ready to start?
With love,
Elad
Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.
- Kahlil Gibran
One gets there by being there.
- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)
Elad
Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.
- Kahlil Gibran
One gets there by being there.
- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)
- inquirydogg
- Posts: 10
- Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:44 am
Re: Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
Hi Elad,
Thank you for being here to guide me. I am nervous, excited, and ready to start.
-Andrey
Thank you for being here to guide me. I am nervous, excited, and ready to start.
-Andrey
Re: Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
Hey Andrey, great!
Can you tell me about your excitement and your nervousness? Each one separately, everything that comes to mind/heart....
And here is some standard info for starting up:
The basics of how this works is that I’ll give you questions and exercises to help you investigate whether there is a separate self. Your task is to look directly at your alive experience in the here and now and report on your experience without resorting to memory, thinking and imagination. Try to approach these exercises with “beginner’s mind,” setting aside everything you know about spiritual teachings, science and philosophy. In other words, don't "think about" what I ask. Use all questions and exercises as a door to LOOK AT what is actually there and what is not. Also, it is helpful to remember that this is not about creating any special experience or dissolving any part of normal experience - including "selfing". Rather, the questions and exercises will help you to see what is already actually there in normal experience and what is not, what is only imagined. It's all about looking closely at ordinary experience.
Please read through “Liberation Unleashed is not …” in the FAQs of LU.
http://liberationunleashed.com/about/faq/#faq-1041
When you reply to a questions, please use the quote function to highlight the question being answered. This will make our dialogue easier to follow. Please watch the video below to learn how to use the quote function.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-fAToDNh9hQ
The website goes down at times. To avoid losing your work, you may find it helpful to copy and paste questions asked into Word, answer them there, and then copy and paste them to your thread.
Let’s try to post daily, if we can. Of course, life happens, so if you need more time, just let me know. I’ll do so as well. If I don't seem to answer for more then 2 days, write to eladexplore1111@gmail.com - maybe there is some system error.
Let me know if you have any questions or anything else coming up wanting attention, in relation to this message and the FAQ!
Can you tell me about your excitement and your nervousness? Each one separately, everything that comes to mind/heart....
And here is some standard info for starting up:
The basics of how this works is that I’ll give you questions and exercises to help you investigate whether there is a separate self. Your task is to look directly at your alive experience in the here and now and report on your experience without resorting to memory, thinking and imagination. Try to approach these exercises with “beginner’s mind,” setting aside everything you know about spiritual teachings, science and philosophy. In other words, don't "think about" what I ask. Use all questions and exercises as a door to LOOK AT what is actually there and what is not. Also, it is helpful to remember that this is not about creating any special experience or dissolving any part of normal experience - including "selfing". Rather, the questions and exercises will help you to see what is already actually there in normal experience and what is not, what is only imagined. It's all about looking closely at ordinary experience.
Please read through “Liberation Unleashed is not …” in the FAQs of LU.
http://liberationunleashed.com/about/faq/#faq-1041
When you reply to a questions, please use the quote function to highlight the question being answered. This will make our dialogue easier to follow. Please watch the video below to learn how to use the quote function.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-fAToDNh9hQ
The website goes down at times. To avoid losing your work, you may find it helpful to copy and paste questions asked into Word, answer them there, and then copy and paste them to your thread.
Let’s try to post daily, if we can. Of course, life happens, so if you need more time, just let me know. I’ll do so as well. If I don't seem to answer for more then 2 days, write to eladexplore1111@gmail.com - maybe there is some system error.
Let me know if you have any questions or anything else coming up wanting attention, in relation to this message and the FAQ!
With love,
Elad
Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.
- Kahlil Gibran
One gets there by being there.
- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)
Elad
Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.
- Kahlil Gibran
One gets there by being there.
- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)
- inquirydogg
- Posts: 10
- Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:44 am
Re: Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
Thank you, Elad! Let's get started.
Nervousness: Arises from the same location, but feels more constricting. I don't feel the spaciousness that came with excitement when I focus in on nervousness. Almost like I have goosebumps in the heart.
Reflection: As I do this exercise, I think that both emotions are actually just the same sensation, or at least attributed to the same heart space location. There is a sensation in my heart space. It is not static. Rather, it is evolving moment to moment. Sometimes I pick up goosebumps in that area and that is labeled as nervousness, sometimes a pleasant tickle and that is labeled as excitement. As I stay with it, it seems like that which the body likes / has pleasant undertones is labeled as excitement, and that which constricts the body is labeled as nervousness. But the sensation itself it not stagnant and changing as I type this. It's kind of difficult to take the underlying sensation and attribute it to the correct label since they are both arising from the same location and have so many similarities between them.
Excitement: A sensation around the heart space. It has a feeling of openness and spaciousness as it spreads out from the heart space. Sometimes it pulses, almost like a pleasant tickle.Can you tell me about your excitement and your nervousness? Each one separately, everything that comes to mind/heart....
Nervousness: Arises from the same location, but feels more constricting. I don't feel the spaciousness that came with excitement when I focus in on nervousness. Almost like I have goosebumps in the heart.
Reflection: As I do this exercise, I think that both emotions are actually just the same sensation, or at least attributed to the same heart space location. There is a sensation in my heart space. It is not static. Rather, it is evolving moment to moment. Sometimes I pick up goosebumps in that area and that is labeled as nervousness, sometimes a pleasant tickle and that is labeled as excitement. As I stay with it, it seems like that which the body likes / has pleasant undertones is labeled as excitement, and that which constricts the body is labeled as nervousness. But the sensation itself it not stagnant and changing as I type this. It's kind of difficult to take the underlying sensation and attribute it to the correct label since they are both arising from the same location and have so many similarities between them.
Yes, I am fully committed to do this daily. Thank you for your time to do this with me.Let’s try to post daily, if we can. Of course, life happens, so if you need more time, just let me know. I’ll do so as well.
Re: Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
Hi Andrey,
Great attending in detail, and the awareness that the sensations don't come with a label of what feeling it is.
Great. Also, can you please drop reading/watching other spiritual stuff while we do this?
This is to keep the process focused. I might give you things to watch at some point as part of the process. Practicing "meditation" that supports your calmness, presence or release is fine.
Now:
Please look at what it is you take to be "the self" that you are. Look in direct experience, not in habitual thoughts. Describe to me what it is.
Excitement: A sensation around the heart space. It has a feeling of openness and spaciousness as it spreads out from the heart space. Sometimes it pulses, almost like a pleasant tickle.Can you tell me about your excitement and your nervousness? Each one separately, everything that comes to mind/heart....
Nervousness: Arises from the same location, but feels more constricting. I don't feel the spaciousness that came with excitement when I focus in on nervousness. Almost like I have goosebumps in the heart.
Reflection: As I do this exercise, I think that both emotions are actually just the same sensation, or at least attributed to the same heart space location. There is a sensation in my heart space. It is not static. Rather, it is evolving moment to moment. Sometimes I pick up goosebumps in that area and that is labeled as nervousness, sometimes a pleasant tickle and that is labeled as excitement. As I stay with it, it seems like that which the body likes / has pleasant undertones is labeled as excitement, and that which constricts the body is labeled as nervousness. But the sensation itself it not stagnant and changing as I type this. It's kind of difficult to take the underlying sensation and attribute it to the correct label since they are both arising from the same location and have so many similarities between them.
Great attending in detail, and the awareness that the sensations don't come with a label of what feeling it is.
Yes, I am fully committed to do this daily. Thank you for your time to do this with me.Let’s try to post daily, if we can. Of course, life happens, so if you need more time, just let me know. I’ll do so as well.
Great. Also, can you please drop reading/watching other spiritual stuff while we do this?
This is to keep the process focused. I might give you things to watch at some point as part of the process. Practicing "meditation" that supports your calmness, presence or release is fine.
Now:
Please look at what it is you take to be "the self" that you are. Look in direct experience, not in habitual thoughts. Describe to me what it is.
With love,
Elad
Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.
- Kahlil Gibran
One gets there by being there.
- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)
Elad
Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.
- Kahlil Gibran
One gets there by being there.
- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)
- inquirydogg
- Posts: 10
- Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:44 am
Re: Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
Code: Select all
Great. Also, can you please drop reading/watching other spiritual stuff while we do this?
It is difficult to answer this question purely from direct experience; there is a desire to go towards thoughts; I will push forward anyway and try to stay away from thoughts as much as possible.Please look at what it is you take to be "the self" that you are. Look in direct experience, not in habitual thoughts. Describe to me what it is.
Attempt #1: When I sit and look at direct experience, the first thing I see in my visual field are two hands typing these words. There is a sense of these hands being attached somehow to whatever I am. There is a sense that the controller is somehow here. There is a hypnotic feeling to it when I see these hands typing and at the same time I hear a voice in my head narrating whatever is being typed. "Who else could it be" is a thought. I have inquired before into the idea that thoughts are not created by me, but in this moment, the belief is believed here underneath even though I wish didn't. It's hypnotic. Somehow the appearance of the thought is just assumed to be me. This is getting too heady now - I will pause and try again.
Attempt #2: I will try again with fresh eyes. There is hearing of the air conditioner; there is no self in the pure sound (the sound just appears without my help). There is a noticing of the breathing; the breathing does itself; no self here either. Attention moves to smell. There is no unique smell in this moment, but there is an awareness of the lack of smell; there was a focusing of attention to be aware of that. The movement of attention to go from the breath to the lack of smell - that somehow feels like it was moved by "me." There appears to some mechanism/belief/sense that whenever I move my attention, somehow I make that happen. I do not have good evidence for this; it appears to be a habit.
Attempt #3: I notice that I keep being pulled toward thoughts (it's hypnotic and takes a while to notice that I got on the thought train). There is a feeling of guilt (I am doing this wrong). I took a break and will try again starting now:
In the sound field, there are air conditioner sounds. No effort on my part - no self there. In the visual field, I noticed a hand grabbing a cup of coffee and drinking it. There was no intention or plan to do so beforehand. It happened by itself. In that action, there was no sense of self/no manager of actions. Now the hands type. Who is doing the typing? There is a sense of self when I watch the typing (not sure why). The thought field has thoughts as usual - there is no choice in this - I wish they would stop altogether if it was up to me. Now in the sensation field, I feel the sensation as I type. It just comes and goes - there is no action needed to feel the sensation. Now in the smell field - although there is coffee near me, I cannot smell it at this distance now. No choice there. When I sip it, I smell it at close proximity. No choice there. The smell does the smelling without any help by a self.
When I inspect the sense fields by themselves, they seem to function on their own. I don't find a self in any of the senses. But yet, this sense of someone being in here (behind my eyes) is persistent. There is a sense of a self whenever the attention moves between objects or sense fields (as if "I" am doing the moving of attention).
Now, I opened up my attention (I am not sure if I did it or it just opened up). There is a mild sensation behind my face so to speak. It feels like where I am, whatever I am. I have been coming back to this location of I often in the last days, especially during meditation. I am not sure if this perceived location of "I" is my little self, or the big Self. It feels like a spaciousness rather than an object.
Reflection on the Exercise: There is a feeling of frustration here. Like a child that is doing something wrong and just can't get it right. This self of sense is so persistent and I can't even articulate why/how. When I look at the senses themselves, I see no evidence of a self. Things appear to happen by themselves (in the same way the heart beats - I am 100% confident I don't control my heart). And yet, here I am, trying to see through this "self" by talking with you. The story that is being told here is believed.
Elad - thank you for listening to me ramble on. It feels nice to have someone listen to me about these things. Although we never met, I feel supported. Thank you.
Re: Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
Andrey,
It sounds like its clear to you that you are not finding a real self anywhere, is that true?
If yes, what happens if you just let yourself become quiet with the reality of that?
It sounds like its clear to you that you are not finding a real self anywhere, is that true?
If yes, what happens if you just let yourself become quiet with the reality of that?
With love,
Elad
Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.
- Kahlil Gibran
One gets there by being there.
- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)
Elad
Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.
- Kahlil Gibran
One gets there by being there.
- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)
- inquirydogg
- Posts: 10
- Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:44 am
Re: Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
This is true. When I look in direct experience, I cannot find a self.It sounds like its clear to you that you are not finding a real self anywhere, is that true?
It doesn't take very long for thoughts to arise about why this can't be it.If yes, what happens if you just let yourself become quiet with the reality of that?
Not finding a self in direct experience is not equivalent to clearly seeing no-self. Although when I look closely in the sense fields, I cannot find it in any field, there is still somehow a subtle sense of something living this life in day-to-day experience. And who else could be living this life other than "me" - I cannot comprehend an alternative.
Expectations: I am waiting for some kind of clear realization of no-self. An awakening event where I genuinely have an identity shift of what I take myself to be. Something that is self validating where no doubt can touch it. And there is no such experience here. So there is a belief that this type of clear knowing is missing here.
Reflection: I realize that I have not followed your instructions very well. It's very hard to "become quiet with this" because there is a belief here that it's not enough. The mind here is very active - lots of thoughts. I am using thoughts in real time to construct a self. This is basically what I told you so far - here is my expectation; it is not met; "I" need to find a way to fix it/see it because it's not seen without me doing something about it.
I think that thoughts are somehow the culprit that blinds me, but they are so hypnotic. They have a hold of me and something is being obscured somehow. And I can't quiet my mind for long enough to see what it is that is being hidden.
Re: Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
It sounds like its clear to you that you are not finding a real self anywhere, is that true?
This is true. When I look in direct experience, I cannot find a self.
!
It doesn't take very long for thoughts to arise about why this can't be it.If yes, what happens if you just let yourself become quiet with the reality of that?
Could it be those thoughts that create the sense of not being there?
And how are those thoughts connected to you? Are they you or yours, can you control them, or are they just a pattern that happens when it happens, and stops when it stops?
Dont theorize about what I say, look as deeply and sincerely as possible at the alive truth.
Funny the way you write this it sounds like no-self is a thing that you need to get, a thing... Kind a like realizing that santa or uncorns are not real whould be reified into finding " The No-Santa", "The No-Uncorn".Not finding a self in direct experience is not equivalent to clearly seeing no-self.
Although when I look closely in the sense fields, I cannot find it in any field, there is still somehow a subtle sense of something living this life in day-to-day experience. And who else could be living this life other than "me" - I cannot comprehend an alternative.
Does the wind need a winder to blow? Does the rain need a rainer to rain? Does life need a "lifer" to happen?
Or is this just an assumption based on language habits? (noun-verb, a verb needs a noun)/subject.
Expectations: I am waiting for some kind of clear realization of no-self. An awakening event where I genuinely have an identity shift of what I take myself to be. Something that is self validating where no doubt can touch it. And there is no such experience here. So there is a belief that this type of clear knowing is missing here.
So you are imagining a future self that knows it has a realization at the same time it knows that it doesnt exist and cant have a realization?
There is a paradox here as you can see.
What do you think will lead you to truth, thinking about experience in comparison with a belief - or attending directly to what is clearly true in alive experience NOW?
Reflection: I realize that I have not followed your instructions very well. It's very hard to "become quiet with this" because there is a belief here that it's not enough.
Can you see how this just happens by itself, like not chosen by you, not in your control?
ha ha ha - sounds like you see the contradiction in this. The story about a self maintaining a story about a self. And no one truly chosing or controling or owning any of it.The mind here is very active - lots of thoughts. I am using thoughts in real time to construct a self. This is basically what I told you so far - here is my expectation; it is not met; "I" need to find a way to fix it/see it because it's not seen without me doing something about it.
I think that thoughts are somehow the culprit that blinds me, but they are so hypnotic. They have a hold of me and something is being obscured somehow. And I can't quiet my mind for long enough to see what it is that is being hidden.
The thoughts are not blinding you, there is no you, except in thoughts, there is only the belief in a story about a blinded you, with a you that is holding/controlling/choosing the belief! Look - can you see it is so?
With love,
Elad
Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.
- Kahlil Gibran
One gets there by being there.
- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)
Elad
Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.
- Kahlil Gibran
One gets there by being there.
- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)
- inquirydogg
- Posts: 10
- Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:44 am
Re: Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
Hi Elad,
I read this back like 5 times already and sat with it. This post is stirring something up. I will respond now, and continue to sit with it as a form of inquiry for the rest of the day. I feel truth here.
Yes, your are right - thoughts are believed that it’s not it. But it is not understood how to lose that belief in a practical sense.
There is no control over the thoughts that come - they come when they come and stop when they stop. Sometimes it's easy to let thoughts pass without holding on to them. It's when attention grabs them and focuses it's attention there, the problems seem to start.
If I don’t orient to thoughts, what should be oriented to? It still feels like I have control over what attention is focused on. Maybe the answer is no thoughts at all and just be.
I think what will lead to truth is attending to alive experience.
Another Reflection: the following is something I have been thinking about, which is probably just ultimately useless, but I will put it here as a journal entry of sorts and if you have anything to point out, please do:
Is there a merging that happens with this? It feels like I have a “Beloved” within whatever I am that I have forgotten, but she/it is deep in my heart (and I had glimpses of such mergings before with it, in short moments without thoughts as well as longer sessions with psychedelics), and I’m yearning for it, but the more I seek this beloved/ completeness, the further I get away from it. Each step I take is a step away from it somehow. When I forget the search for a moment, it gets closer (I feel it as direct experience opens up), but the closer it gets, the mind gets excited with it and it seems to leave just as fast as the next thought arrives to disturb it. Like the water is still for a moment and I realize I’m one with the ocean so to speak, but the thoughts about it create ripples and that realization is lost somehow. The ocean became the wave again. I don’t like the overused ocean/wave analogy but here I am using it. There is such strong conditioning to keep the search. Who is the one searching? I genuinely don’t know. But there is a search before my eyes.
As I read this back, it sounds a little cuckoo. I don’t speak like this in my daily life I promise. But there is just a sense of these thoughts that need to be released. Are they a waste of effort when it comes to this?
I read this back like 5 times already and sat with it. This post is stirring something up. I will respond now, and continue to sit with it as a form of inquiry for the rest of the day. I feel truth here.
Thank you - this inquiry/line of questioning was alive for me.Could it be those thoughts that create the sense of not being there?
And how are those thoughts connected to you? Are they you or yours, can you control them, or are they just a pattern that happens when it happens, and stops when it stops?
Dont theorize about what I say, look as deeply and sincerely as possible at the alive truth.
Yes, your are right - thoughts are believed that it’s not it. But it is not understood how to lose that belief in a practical sense.
There is no control over the thoughts that come - they come when they come and stop when they stop. Sometimes it's easy to let thoughts pass without holding on to them. It's when attention grabs them and focuses it's attention there, the problems seem to start.
If I don’t orient to thoughts, what should be oriented to? It still feels like I have control over what attention is focused on. Maybe the answer is no thoughts at all and just be.
Ok - that got a chuckle out of me. Good point. I find it funny now. Thank you for that clarification and joke :)Funny the way you write this it sounds like no-self is a thing that you need to get, a thing... Kind a like realizing that santa or uncorns are not real whould be reified into finding " The No-Santa", "The No-Uncorn".
I agree - it's an assumption from a language construct - noun/verb.Or is this just an assumption based on language habits? (noun-verb, a verb needs a noun)/subject.
Ok - a lot more laughter on this one. When you point it out, it seems absurd.So you are imagining a future self that knows it has a realization at the same time it knows that it doesnt exist and cant have a realization?
There is a paradox here as you can see.
What do you think will lead you to truth, thinking about experience in comparison with a belief - or attending directly to what is clearly true in alive experience NOW?
I think what will lead to truth is attending to alive experience.
I am starting to see.Can you see how this just happens by itself, like not chosen by you, not in your control?
There is a story being told here of a person named Andrey looking for completeness via awakening. With inquiry and with the help of a guide Elad, old beliefs are loosening up. He’s starting to realize that maybe he’s not in control after all. And whatever sees the story is what “I” actually am. But then what am I? I am starting to get more clarity on what I am not. I am not a controller of this happening. But then what am I? The voice in my head doesn’t know. How do I find out what it is that I am? Or does the question itself hold me back from knowing the answer?The story about a self maintaining a story about a self. And no one truly chosing or controling or owning any of it.
Another Reflection: the following is something I have been thinking about, which is probably just ultimately useless, but I will put it here as a journal entry of sorts and if you have anything to point out, please do:
Is there a merging that happens with this? It feels like I have a “Beloved” within whatever I am that I have forgotten, but she/it is deep in my heart (and I had glimpses of such mergings before with it, in short moments without thoughts as well as longer sessions with psychedelics), and I’m yearning for it, but the more I seek this beloved/ completeness, the further I get away from it. Each step I take is a step away from it somehow. When I forget the search for a moment, it gets closer (I feel it as direct experience opens up), but the closer it gets, the mind gets excited with it and it seems to leave just as fast as the next thought arrives to disturb it. Like the water is still for a moment and I realize I’m one with the ocean so to speak, but the thoughts about it create ripples and that realization is lost somehow. The ocean became the wave again. I don’t like the overused ocean/wave analogy but here I am using it. There is such strong conditioning to keep the search. Who is the one searching? I genuinely don’t know. But there is a search before my eyes.
As I read this back, it sounds a little cuckoo. I don’t speak like this in my daily life I promise. But there is just a sense of these thoughts that need to be released. Are they a waste of effort when it comes to this?
I am going to sit with this for the next day. Something seems to be opening up when I am not stuck in the stories (like the long message above).The thoughts are not blinding you, there is no you, except in thoughts, there is only the belief in a story about a blinded you, with a you that is holding/controlling/choosing the belief! Look - can you see it is so?
Re: Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
Hi Andrey!
You don't need to "lose the belief'. It is enough to see it for what it is, mere belief, and also see there is no one having it (look, you find no one, only thoughts that say otherwise).
You do not control attention. There is no you to control attention. Sit still facing a wall for 20 minutes, eyes open, relaxed. Notice every time the focus of attention shifts. Notice how it happens. See directly it just happens when it happens. No controller of it, that is just a fantasy.
Just see there is actually no you orienting. Orienting happens. It goes here, it goes there. Now on a task, now on a fantasy, now thinking this, now that.
Beautiful. What produces the laughter? See it just happens when it happens. Recognition and laughter happens when it happens, confusion and discomfort happens when it happens. No you to control either.
What awakening is, is beyond words. So instead just see that you are not. Stay in the silence and simplicity of that.
I would recommend to leave this aside, while allowing any devotional and loving feelings that naturally emerge to be enjoyed directly.
It is not about you not being stuck in stories, it is about that you are not. Do you see that believing the story "I get unstuck from thoughts" is now the way ego-belief maintains itself?
Thank you - this inquiry/line of questioning was alive for me.Could it be those thoughts that create the sense of not being there?
And how are those thoughts connected to you? Are they you or yours, can you control them, or are they just a pattern that happens when it happens, and stops when it stops?
Dont theorize about what I say, look as deeply and sincerely as possible at the alive truth.
Yes, your are right - thoughts are believed that it’s not it. But it is not understood how to lose that belief in a practical sense.
You don't need to "lose the belief'. It is enough to see it for what it is, mere belief, and also see there is no one having it (look, you find no one, only thoughts that say otherwise).
There is no control over the thoughts that come - they come when they come and stop when they stop. Sometimes it's easy to let thoughts pass without holding on to them. It's when attention grabs them and focuses it's attention there, the problems seem to start.
You do not control attention. There is no you to control attention. Sit still facing a wall for 20 minutes, eyes open, relaxed. Notice every time the focus of attention shifts. Notice how it happens. See directly it just happens when it happens. No controller of it, that is just a fantasy.
If I don’t orient to thoughts, what should be oriented to? It still feels like I have control over what attention is focused on. Maybe the answer is no thoughts at all and just be.
Just see there is actually no you orienting. Orienting happens. It goes here, it goes there. Now on a task, now on a fantasy, now thinking this, now that.
Ok - a lot more laughter on this one. When you point it out, it seems absurd.So you are imagining a future self that knows it has a realization at the same time it knows that it doesnt exist and cant have a realization?
There is a paradox here as you can see.
What do you think will lead you to truth, thinking about experience in comparison with a belief - or attending directly to what is clearly true in alive experience NOW?
Beautiful. What produces the laughter? See it just happens when it happens. Recognition and laughter happens when it happens, confusion and discomfort happens when it happens. No you to control either.
There is a story being told here of a person named Andrey looking for completeness via awakening. With inquiry and with the help of a guide Elad, old beliefs are loosening up. He’s starting to realize that maybe he’s not in control after all. And whatever sees the story is what “I” actually am. But then what am I? I am starting to get more clarity on what I am not. I am not a controller of this happening. But then what am I? The voice in my head doesn’t know. How do I find out what it is that I am? Or does the question itself hold me back from knowing the answer?The story about a self maintaining a story about a self. And no one truly chosing or controling or owning any of it.
What awakening is, is beyond words. So instead just see that you are not. Stay in the silence and simplicity of that.
Another Reflection: the following is something I have been thinking about, which is probably just ultimately useless, but I will put it here as a journal entry of sorts and if you have anything to point out, please do:
Is there a merging that happens with this? It feels like I have a “Beloved” within whatever I am that I have forgotten, but she/it is deep in my heart (and I had glimpses of such mergings before with it, in short moments without thoughts as well as longer sessions with psychedelics), and I’m yearning for it, but the more I seek this beloved/ completeness, the further I get away from it. Each step I take is a step away from it somehow. When I forget the search for a moment, it gets closer (I feel it as direct experience opens up), but the closer it gets, the mind gets excited with it and it seems to leave just as fast as the next thought arrives to disturb it. Like the water is still for a moment and I realize I’m one with the ocean so to speak, but the thoughts about it create ripples and that realization is lost somehow. The ocean became the wave again. I don’t like the overused ocean/wave analogy but here I am using it. There is such strong conditioning to keep the search. Who is the one searching? I genuinely don’t know. But there is a search before my eyes.
As I read this back, it sounds a little cuckoo. I don’t speak like this in my daily life I promise. But there is just a sense of these thoughts that need to be released. Are they a waste of effort when it comes to this?
I would recommend to leave this aside, while allowing any devotional and loving feelings that naturally emerge to be enjoyed directly.
I am going to sit with this for the next day. Something seems to be opening up when I am not stuck in the stories (like the long message above).The thoughts are not blinding you, there is no you, except in thoughts, there is only the belief in a story about a blinded you, with a you that is holding/controlling/choosing the belief! Look - can you see it is so?
It is not about you not being stuck in stories, it is about that you are not. Do you see that believing the story "I get unstuck from thoughts" is now the way ego-belief maintains itself?
With love,
Elad
Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.
- Kahlil Gibran
One gets there by being there.
- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)
Elad
Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.
- Kahlil Gibran
One gets there by being there.
- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)
- inquirydogg
- Posts: 10
- Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:44 am
Re: Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
Okay - I am starting to see more clearly after doing the exercise. So the shifting of attention is similar to the appearance of thoughts - it moves by itself. I'm a little surprised that this belief was wrong but I am starting to see.You do not control attention. There is no you to control attention. Sit still facing a wall for 20 minutes, eyes open, relaxed. Notice every time the focus of attention shifts. Notice how it happens. See directly it just happens when it happens. No controller of it, that is just a fantasy.
When I am in the process of investigating / looking, there is that understanding. But throughout most of the day as I am living life, it is forgotten, until the next time investigation happens.Just see there is actually no you orienting. Orienting happens. It goes here, it goes there. Now on a task, now on a fantasy, now thinking this, now that.
It was 100% spontaneous. There was no internal analysis to decide whether there was something funny. The words were read, and laughter arrived. With some things like laughter, the lack of control is so clear. But with some other things like the investigation of attention, it takes me quite some time.What produces the laughter?
I have been staying in the silence more often in the last few days. I hope this practice continues. (I am starting to have second thoughts of using "I" in the beginning of sentences; I will put it aside and continue).What awakening is, is beyond words. So instead just see that you are not. Stay in the silence and simplicity of that.
Awakening" is the shiny object that my minds wants these days. It's nice when that is forgotten in the silence, even if just for a moment.
Thank you for the feedback, I will do so.I would recommend to leave this aside, while allowing any devotional and loving feelings that naturally emerge to be enjoyed directly.
I see it when you point it out so directly.It is not about you not being stuck in stories, it is about that you are not. Do you see that believing the story "I get unstuck from thoughts" is now the way ego-belief maintains itself?
The clarity seems to come and go. Maybe that's not true, but it appears that attention moves from seeing to something else when thoughts are followed. Currently, there is a desire here that I want to spend more time in silence in the next days to keep inquiring into this (that I am not). There is also an expectation somewhere that something should happen if I sit for long enough. Then there is a thought that it's not good to have that expectation. Then there is understanding that it is okay - that the mind moves this way way now and that's okay. And then as I read back this paragraph, I just see a bundle of thoughts that create a self.
I will continue to sit tomorrow. It is my understanding that I just need to keep sitting quietly and noticing. Let me know if you have any other suggestions for my quiet time / inquiry time.
Re: Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
I am having a visit from abroad the next few days, so might answer shorter, and not surely answer all days. From Tuesday should be back to normal.
For now, in essence:
Do you notice that looking for an instruction of what you should do over time creates a story of a self?
Who should do anything? No one to do. Seeing happens. Remembering happens. Forgetting happens. See this.
It is fine you write with the "I" and also fine not to. Either way, when it is seen that there is no self, it is seen. The languaging and believing either way (in no self or in self) is secondary. Without insight no-self languaging doesn't help. With insight langauge can function freely according to context and goal, it can be playful and attuned to circumstances.
For now, in essence:
Do you notice that looking for an instruction of what you should do over time creates a story of a self?
Who should do anything? No one to do. Seeing happens. Remembering happens. Forgetting happens. See this.
It is fine you write with the "I" and also fine not to. Either way, when it is seen that there is no self, it is seen. The languaging and believing either way (in no self or in self) is secondary. Without insight no-self languaging doesn't help. With insight langauge can function freely according to context and goal, it can be playful and attuned to circumstances.
With love,
Elad
Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.
- Kahlil Gibran
One gets there by being there.
- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)
Elad
Keep me away from the wisdom which does not cry, the philosophy which does not laugh and the greatness which does not bow before children.
- Kahlil Gibran
One gets there by being there.
- Master Woof (Gilbert, Ta Hui)
- inquirydogg
- Posts: 10
- Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2026 4:44 am
Re: Dogs are awesome, god made dogs, god made awesome
Hi Elad,
I hope you enjoy your time with your guests. I understand that our contact will be limited until next week. Here are some reflections in the meantime:
Over the last days, I have been noticing more places in my life where things just happen without a self operating. Body moving without choice, etc. It's a little bit frustrating because I feel like I am getting the non-control bit but I am left with restless energy to do something about it. I am so conditioned to plan and do, and this is out of my element.
I hope you enjoy your time with your guests. I understand that our contact will be limited until next week. Here are some reflections in the meantime:
Yes, I do see that this reinforces the idea of a self operating in time, but I don't know another way to go about it. The mind gets active here and tries to come up with new ways to live without the self (stay more in the now, ignore thoughts as they come), which further reinforces the illusion that I choose to do any of that.Do you notice that looking for an instruction of what you should do over time creates a story of a self?
Who should do anything? No one to do. Seeing happens. Remembering happens. Forgetting happens. See this.
Over the last days, I have been noticing more places in my life where things just happen without a self operating. Body moving without choice, etc. It's a little bit frustrating because I feel like I am getting the non-control bit but I am left with restless energy to do something about it. I am so conditioned to plan and do, and this is out of my element.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot], Semrush [Bot], vinceschubert and 13 guests

