Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
Re: Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
that is interesting. let's see what happens after you've had a chance to do a few more sessions.
Re: Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
i just did another session, and while i was still thinking or posing the question sometimes, i think the relaxation im feeling is the lack of trying to do this right. I really internalized that there is no messing up this practice of not doing anything, so there's absolutely no pressure or 'making mistakes' or 'doing it wrong' so theres no doubt, or when doubt thoughts pop up, they are quickly noticed and discarded.
really enjoying this one!
really enjoying this one!
Re: Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
good to hear. are you doing some sessions without asking the question, without doing anything at all? not trying to notice anything, not judging thoughts, not discarding thoughts, not managing where attention does or does not go, just letting whatever happens happen all on it's own, so that whatever is happening it is really clear that 'you' are not doing it?
Re: Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
sorry for the lack of update yesterday, i did 30mins yesterday but was busy the rest of the day.
this last one was with 'doing' and asking the question.
let me do the next ones following the true let whatever happen happen! as of now its not always clear experientially that what is happening is not 'me' doing it.
in two days i'll be doing a one day temple stay so i'm not sure if i'll be able to respond but i'll be doing this still!
this last one was with 'doing' and asking the question.
let me do the next ones following the true let whatever happen happen! as of now its not always clear experientially that what is happening is not 'me' doing it.
in two days i'll be doing a one day temple stay so i'm not sure if i'll be able to respond but i'll be doing this still!
Re: Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
sounds good, Lucas. I hope you have a good Temple day
Re: Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
hey pablo! I had a good few days here. Temple Stay was very fun, very chill.
The main takeaway from the practice so far has just been how relaxing and kind of good/fun it has been to just sit and not have an agenda. Not really seeing any sort of "everything's happening by itself" yet but it has been very enjoyable.
Which is interesting because I was doing, before, kind of like an hour of meditation a day. and I would procrastinate on that or I wouldn't want to sit down, even though I kind of enjoyed doing it, it felt like an effort, like it was hard and taxing but this has just been very enjoyable.
Also sometimes here, even on this practice which is very enjoyable, when I do have the free time, I put other things first. Even though I would consider, at least intellectually, that this is my priority and I really feel like it is, my actions don't really reflect that sometimes.
What has kind of gone down is the guilt associated with it. even though it is still very present for not doing or failing to act how I 'should' have been acting. Even though intellectually it's like, yeah, this is all happening by itself, there's no one here to be blamed, just the body acting according to habit and conditioning.
For now I've kind of just been trying to look at it more as a mechanical problem of getting this body to do stuff and less as a willpower (funny concept right there) or identity, shame, or guilt kind of thing.
The main takeaway from the practice so far has just been how relaxing and kind of good/fun it has been to just sit and not have an agenda. Not really seeing any sort of "everything's happening by itself" yet but it has been very enjoyable.
Which is interesting because I was doing, before, kind of like an hour of meditation a day. and I would procrastinate on that or I wouldn't want to sit down, even though I kind of enjoyed doing it, it felt like an effort, like it was hard and taxing but this has just been very enjoyable.
Also sometimes here, even on this practice which is very enjoyable, when I do have the free time, I put other things first. Even though I would consider, at least intellectually, that this is my priority and I really feel like it is, my actions don't really reflect that sometimes.
What has kind of gone down is the guilt associated with it. even though it is still very present for not doing or failing to act how I 'should' have been acting. Even though intellectually it's like, yeah, this is all happening by itself, there's no one here to be blamed, just the body acting according to habit and conditioning.
For now I've kind of just been trying to look at it more as a mechanical problem of getting this body to do stuff and less as a willpower (funny concept right there) or identity, shame, or guilt kind of thing.
Re: Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
Nice to hear that this way is more enjoyable! From my perspective, a big point of this whole thing is to enjoy life more without all the unnecessary imagined burdens.
Is there a feeling that it would be wrong not to feel guilt? If so, do you have ideas about how you got that idea? And why it would be wrong?
So there have been a lot of thoughts that there is a you that should be doing something other than what your body is doing, and then feelings of frustration? I'm wondering how much attention those thoughts and feelings have been getting in comparison with attention to sensory awareness of what is happening at the time.
What have you seen causing something to happen?Not really seeing any sort of "everything's happening by it self" yet but it has been very enjoyable.
.What has kind of gone down is the guilt associated with it. even though it is still very present for not doing or failing to act how I 'should' have been acting
Is there a feeling that it would be wrong not to feel guilt? If so, do you have ideas about how you got that idea? And why it would be wrong?
For now I've kind of just been trying to look at it more as a mechanical problem of getting this body to do stuff and less as a willpower (funny concept right there) or identity, shame, or guilt kind of thing.
So there have been a lot of thoughts that there is a you that should be doing something other than what your body is doing, and then feelings of frustration? I'm wondering how much attention those thoughts and feelings have been getting in comparison with attention to sensory awareness of what is happening at the time.
Re: Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
it seems that, rather than seeing something causing other things to happen, it's more like experience hasn't changed. The default has been to live with this cause-effect type of feeling overlaid. That's closer to what I meant. just noticing that everything's happening by itself hasn't happened yet I suppose.What have you seen causing something to happen?
I think it's just been that whenever I notice feelings of guilt or shame or these kinds of thoughts, I'm just like, "Well if there's no one here, then these are unnecessary." Obviously they're still present right now but it seems like if I really experientially knew that there was no one here, then guilt wouldn't pop up. Who would the guilt be attributed to, similar to shame and these other feelings that kind of need a self at least? I think that's how the mental concepts are here. So reading all that i just wrote again, it seems that perhaps I've conceptualized the undoing part of the process that naturally happens after noticing that there is no self here. There seem to be thoughts that are almost trying to convince other thoughts, or convince "me," or remind me that there is no one here (rather than just noticing thoughts as they happen and just kind of knowing that they're happening to no one, and then naturally they stop). Or this could also be another concept but at least that's what it seems.Is there a feeling that it would be wrong not to feel guilt? If so, do you have ideas about how you got that idea? And why it would be wrong?
yes, even just now reading this i felt some guilt and shame thinking that depending on how I answer, it might clue you into how identified I've been and how not "spiritual" or awake-focused I've been.So there have been a lot of thoughts that there is a you that should be doing something other than what your body is doing, and then feelings of frustration? I'm wondering how much attention those thoughts and feelings have been getting in comparison with attention to sensory awareness of what is happening at the time.
Yeah I feel like there are a lot of thoughts that are like the "productive identity." Whenever something is happening, that isn't necessarily progress towards some higher-priority goal or something. It's like judging it and saying, "Oh you should be doing something else."
At least more recently, some thoughts kind of fight back, saying, "Well no, but there's no one here doing anything. The body's moving by itself and so whatever's happening is just happening." Kind of explaining to myself, which kind of implies that attention is more on thoughts than sensory experience.
Re: Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
im setting up some sytems to make doing all this easier and and more consistent.
Now I have a couple questions for you and also some observations I had. First my observations during this practice. I'm calling this practice "just relaxing" because it just is relaxing.
I noticed a couple times boredom coming up and feelings of "Okay I've got to do this or I've got to do that." I noticed a judgment or a pattern of feeling that I've noticed when I'm forcing myself to do something.
It's interesting just noticing those thoughts because it's so easy and it's so relaxing that they kind of don't make sense. They're kind of silly. That's like, "What do you mean, this is hard or this is boring?" I'm just existing. Not a very strong observation or insight but something a little fun that I thought I'd share.
Now the question that came up here: I think this is just thoughts trying to conceptualize something or judge something, whether it's good or bad, god this sounds so silly as I'm thinking this out, but how do I know if this planning stuff and accountability stuff that I'm setting up (and all these things to make life easier and make doing the things that I have an intention to do more consistent) is self-delusion trying/seeking versus just things naturally occurring? haha just typing this it seems of course it's naturally occurring but i think id still like to hear your thoughts on this, as the way you put things often just clears things up completely for me.
Now I have a couple questions for you and also some observations I had. First my observations during this practice. I'm calling this practice "just relaxing" because it just is relaxing.
I noticed a couple times boredom coming up and feelings of "Okay I've got to do this or I've got to do that." I noticed a judgment or a pattern of feeling that I've noticed when I'm forcing myself to do something.
It's interesting just noticing those thoughts because it's so easy and it's so relaxing that they kind of don't make sense. They're kind of silly. That's like, "What do you mean, this is hard or this is boring?" I'm just existing. Not a very strong observation or insight but something a little fun that I thought I'd share.
Now the question that came up here: I think this is just thoughts trying to conceptualize something or judge something, whether it's good or bad, god this sounds so silly as I'm thinking this out, but how do I know if this planning stuff and accountability stuff that I'm setting up (and all these things to make life easier and make doing the things that I have an intention to do more consistent) is self-delusion trying/seeking versus just things naturally occurring? haha just typing this it seems of course it's naturally occurring but i think id still like to hear your thoughts on this, as the way you put things often just clears things up completely for me.
Re: Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
Thanks for the insights!
That belief is what we need to address. I think it may be one of the biggest barriers to awakening.
And far too many ‘teachers’ just don’t talk about the times when doubts and remorse or whatever “shouldn’t” happen when one is awake, maybe from fear it will tarnish their reputation or credibility. Maybe there are a few to whom those never occur, maybe Ramana Maharshi or others...or maybe those who don’t have to buy or cook their own food. Or maybe it happens after years and years of being awake. Or maybe some just didn't get conditioned that way before awakening. Or maybe for some it just happened with awakening. I expect there are probably lots of people who are awake who just don't talk about it, too, so who knows.
So much of what you report seems to be just trying to figure it all out with words, and I fear asking you to note whether some thoughts/actions seem to be from a self or just happened may have contributed to that. Kind of backfired.
How can thoughts try to do something? Do thoughts have agency? Maybe they have a self, or there’s another type of self that is causing those thoughts?
Here’s a quote from somebody I really like
Be careful. The moment you start talking you create a verbal universe, a universe of words, ideas, concepts and abstractions, interwoven and interdependent, most wonderfully generating, supporting and explaining each other and yet all without essence or substance, mere creations of the mind. Words create words, reality is silent.
—Sri Nisargadatta Maharaj, from I AM THAT
With great compassion,
Pablo
one more thing--you probably already know, but it's worth reminding, that relaxing your muscles and relaxing your senses open to feelings don't mean getting mentally lazy. those are just some ways of reducing cognitive load so your neocortex can more effectively process the present moment. reducing attention to thoughts helps a lot, too.
your reaction to feelings of a self, or guilt, or any other types of experience shouldn't happen reveal that what hasn’t changed is a deep belief that things should be different than they are at any given time, including when those thoughts and feelings occur.it's more like experience hasn't changed
That belief is what we need to address. I think it may be one of the biggest barriers to awakening.
And far too many ‘teachers’ just don’t talk about the times when doubts and remorse or whatever “shouldn’t” happen when one is awake, maybe from fear it will tarnish their reputation or credibility. Maybe there are a few to whom those never occur, maybe Ramana Maharshi or others...or maybe those who don’t have to buy or cook their own food. Or maybe it happens after years and years of being awake. Or maybe some just didn't get conditioned that way before awakening. Or maybe for some it just happened with awakening. I expect there are probably lots of people who are awake who just don't talk about it, too, so who knows.
So much of what you report seems to be just trying to figure it all out with words, and I fear asking you to note whether some thoughts/actions seem to be from a self or just happened may have contributed to that. Kind of backfired.
How can thoughts try to do something? Do thoughts have agency? Maybe they have a self, or there’s another type of self that is causing those thoughts?
Here’s a quote from somebody I really like
Be careful. The moment you start talking you create a verbal universe, a universe of words, ideas, concepts and abstractions, interwoven and interdependent, most wonderfully generating, supporting and explaining each other and yet all without essence or substance, mere creations of the mind. Words create words, reality is silent.
—Sri Nisargadatta Maharaj, from I AM THAT
With great compassion,
Pablo
one more thing--you probably already know, but it's worth reminding, that relaxing your muscles and relaxing your senses open to feelings don't mean getting mentally lazy. those are just some ways of reducing cognitive load so your neocortex can more effectively process the present moment. reducing attention to thoughts helps a lot, too.
Re: Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
yup, this is so clearly true here. I was actually just reading https://vinceschubert.substack.com/p/th ... inbox=true and the parallels there were great :)your reaction to feelings of a self, or guilt, or any other types of experience shouldn't happen reveal that what hasn’t changed is a deep belief that things should be different than they are at any given time, including when those thoughts and feelings occur.
hmm i dont think so. I think the practice was really good and so far the most fun i've had with practicing. everything else always felt like something i 'have' to do, whereas this one felt like something i 'get' to do.So much of what you report seems to be just trying to figure it all out with words, and I fear asking you to note whether some thoughts/actions seem to be from a self or just happened may have contributed to that. Kind of backfired.
let me sit with this today and see what comes up.How can thoughts try to do something? Do thoughts have agency? Maybe they have a self, or there’s another type of self that is causing those thoughts?
really liked the Nisardgadatta quote :)
I think one of the strong beliefs held here (kinda of tied to the earlier that things should be different than they are) is that my actions/doing would change after waking up.one more thing--you probably already know, but it's worth reminding, that relaxing your muscles and relaxing your senses open to feelings don't mean getting mentally lazy. those are just some ways of reducing cognitive load so your neocortex can more effectively process the present moment. reducing attention to thoughts helps a lot, too.
I've always been a big planner and future thinker and setting systems and mental deliberating, and I think now judging these things happening as evidence that I'm not awake, because if I was, then why would I strive to make the 'self' better or improve the self's life?
but I think this is just another belief that I can just look at until it goes away. this begs the question for me, how do I change beliefs? right now my understanding of the process is that all beliefs are false, and you let go of them when by looking or analyzing reality vs what the belief says, you see that the belief makes no sense and is thus just not true.
I'm curious if you have a better explanation or any remarks to the belief-changing process!
Thank you pablo, truly.
Re: Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
Excellent!
The beliefs you report need a bit more consideration before I reply, but first this:
The beliefs you report need a bit more consideration before I reply, but first this:
What is the self you would be benefitting? Do those things make your life run more smoothly? Do they help you in your education or career, or are they just unproductive ruminations and fantasies?I've always been a big planner and future thinker and setting systems and mental deliberating, and I think now judging these things happening as evidence that I'm not awake, because if I was, then why would I strive to make the 'self' better or improve the self's life?
Re: Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
What is the self you would be benefitting? Do those things make your life run more smoothly? Do they help you in your education or career, or are they just unproductive ruminations and fantasies?
Ooh I like that reframe quite a bit. Yeah the self is just another thought. These things make my life easier, and run more smoothly. Just one caveat, a lot of the things that I do seem to be from a place of bettering the self/adorning it.
For example, while I somewhat enjoy going to the gym, the main motivation is to look better/become this idea of who I want to be. There are obviously so many benefits to working out and it is clearly very productive, just the actions seem to be coming from a place of self-improvement.
Haha, man just replying/typing clears up a lot. The above I just wrote, was the exact sort of question that was sloshing through my head but it doesn't even make much sense at all. The 'reason' for doing things is just another thought coming up with a story/narrative. The actions are either occurring or they are not, and the story is also just either there or not. It is just what is going on right now.
something I have to write about/inquire about is why I avoid inquiring. I thought these questions were so poignant and sharp but then I find anything else to do except actually contemplate and look to answer them.How can thoughts try to do something? Do thoughts have agency? Maybe they have a self, or there’s another type of self that is causing those thoughts?
Re: Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
😊 😊😊😊 😊😊😊 😊😊😊 😊😊😊 😊😊😊 😊😊 Perfect!! Yes Yes Yes. That brings a huge smile here.The 'reason' for doing things is just another thought coming up with a story/narrative. The actions are either occurring or they are not, and the story is also just either there or not. It is just what is going on right now.
How are those kinds of stories like the beliefs about beliefs you reported two posts ago?
Don’t try to answer immediately, just let the question percolate a bit.
Perhaps it is the process of writing that leads you to actually observe the process of avoidance, just looking at the feeling of or thoughts about something without judging it?something I have to write about/inquire about is why I avoid inquiring. I thought these questions were so poignant and sharp but then I find anything else to do except actually contemplate and look to answer them.
Maybe you will look at the urge to avoid, and look at the thoughts about that, with non-judgemental curiosity 😊
So happy here to watch how you are waking up!
/p
Re: Step 5, doubt, and wanting to be done with this
Hey Pablo,
I read this in the morning and while I didn't really spend much time yet contemplating the questions you posed. I just wanted to share a very interesting experience I had last night.
I was talking with AI and even I talked to my dad beforehand too, debating whether I should spend money on this course about productivity and really the neuroscience behind just doing stuff. I thought it really clicked with my understanding nowadays of less identity, less willpower, and just the body doing what the body does, computing decisions, and everything happening automatically. Kinda like covering the science of the body, and setting up systems for life goals that I was talking to you about the other day too.I spent a long time talking with AI kind of debating with it.
And then there came a moment that I found so funny. I was sitting there at like 1:30 am, talking and debating. At some point I just noticed that the doubt and the questions that were running through my head, like "Oh I got to figure this out," were just thoughts. They were just thoughts. I don't know how else to say it. It was just so, so obvious to me that they were just thoughts.
I just started laughing for maybe 2, 3 minutes. I was just laughing at how silly it all was. Even just recounting this right now, I'm laughing a little again. It was so silly and it was so clearly just thoughts. There's nothing wrong or correct about them or the decision or anything. It clearly seemed to just be thoughts appearing.
I'm still believing thoughts or rather, attention stays on thoughts quite a bit throughout the day, but there are some moments when it's all pretty silly :)
I read this in the morning and while I didn't really spend much time yet contemplating the questions you posed. I just wanted to share a very interesting experience I had last night.
I was talking with AI and even I talked to my dad beforehand too, debating whether I should spend money on this course about productivity and really the neuroscience behind just doing stuff. I thought it really clicked with my understanding nowadays of less identity, less willpower, and just the body doing what the body does, computing decisions, and everything happening automatically. Kinda like covering the science of the body, and setting up systems for life goals that I was talking to you about the other day too.I spent a long time talking with AI kind of debating with it.
And then there came a moment that I found so funny. I was sitting there at like 1:30 am, talking and debating. At some point I just noticed that the doubt and the questions that were running through my head, like "Oh I got to figure this out," were just thoughts. They were just thoughts. I don't know how else to say it. It was just so, so obvious to me that they were just thoughts.
I just started laughing for maybe 2, 3 minutes. I was just laughing at how silly it all was. Even just recounting this right now, I'm laughing a little again. It was so silly and it was so clearly just thoughts. There's nothing wrong or correct about them or the decision or anything. It clearly seemed to just be thoughts appearing.
I'm still believing thoughts or rather, attention stays on thoughts quite a bit throughout the day, but there are some moments when it's all pretty silly :)
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot], Bing [Bot] and 14 guests

