Introduction

All threads where seeing happens are stored here. The complete list, sorted by guide, contains all links. The archives include threads of those that came to LU already seeing as well.
You are welcome to continue your conversation with your guide here after your name is turned blue.
User avatar
Wisiwig
Posts: 36
Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2026 2:40 am

Re: Introduction

Postby Wisiwig » Tue Sep 15, 2026 2:27 pm

FEAR as an acronym gives: False Evidence Appearing Real - So some imagined ideas that are conclusions about the future, based on hand-me-down cautions, or past memories that create an appearance of sensations and thoughts.... all a part of the overall flow.
1. Using this metaphor, can you find anywhere where "you" autonomously intervene into life, choosing something that is not the product of all the elements; that is not a part of the overall flow?
Yes, often driven by fear of missing out or desire to appeal to others.
It is impossible for the human robot to do something that is not the product of the overall flow. Decisions align with the information available to the ‘mind’ which is influenced by mood, active memory, imagination, and sensory input. It seems that there is an interactive process between presenting thoughts and anticipated outcomes.
You wrote yes for this answer, perhaps the question was not totally clear:
So does that mean that when there is a FEAR of missing out, or desire to appeal to others that this is not a part of the overall flow?
Describe fear of missing out in simple terms based on the above.
Describe desire to appeal to others based on the above.
I wrote ‘yes’ thinking of times when I went against the flow of the moment or forced actions/decisions which interrupted the overall flow. I now see the inconsistency of this response.
Fear of missing out occurs when imaginary evidence is believed and creates fear. In the context of the original response, desire to appeal to others occurs when wanting to be liked or found to be attractive (attractive clothing, interesting self presentation) and there is a fear that simply being me is not enough. In each case, the original response did not recognize that the response to each fear was part of the now/flow.
Another blind spot. This reflected a belief that I am able exert control to upset the flow, a reflection of a ‘responsibility belief’, not true. Although I may be able to upset the current pace or direction, it is because a thought popped up that prompted me to change things up, not because I did something wrong.
I’ve been holding out that I have the ability to set intentions, but everything else is out of my control. This is the mind bender. Do I choose to set intentions, if no, there is absolutely no autonomy. My experience is that there is an ability to apply attention to a question and that it is volitional. If this capacity exists, it cannot arise out of a separate self. It may arise out of the ‘impersonal I’ described by Ramana Maharshi.
Are 'you' holding out on this, or is it not simply thinking is happening regarding this question?
Who could have or not have control of anything?
Above you stated" "I don't control choices" so is there a choice whether an intention is set or not? How often have you laid in bed and told yourself "I must get up now" and ignored that thought (intention) ?
There is a belief that awakening depends upon an intention to awaken, meditation happens because there is an intention to meditate, etc. Within the non-dual community it is common to hear gurus/teachers admonishing followers to engage in certain practices. It makes no sense that they would bother to encourage specific behaviors if those behaviors were not to some degree voluntary. Is my desire to engage with awakening outside of my control? Is everything influencing me outside of my control thus even intentions are shaped/controlled by those elements? This is the main question I am wrestling with now.
EXPLORATION OF THE OPEN FIELDS OF SENSATION

Get comfortable, calm and relaxed, take a few breaths, and then:
Tune in to the VISUAL field and ask "What's here NOW?"
Bring full attention to the visual field with a wide, open viewing, as if the whole body was involved in the viewing, not just eyes. You have this open viewing and you are gently scanning the visual field, looking for nothing, as if it were a tapestry of colors one leading to another. Let go even of finding shapes or forms. It is not about what is seen, it is the relaxed open SEEING that is being experienced. FEEL the SEEING.

After you do that for a short while, open attention up to the whole field of SOUND, as if you are opening up your whole body to the sound field, you are FEELING into the sound field, not individual sounds, as if it were one crazy moment of pure free-flow jazz. It might seem a little 'forced' in the beginning, start opening attention towards the field of body sensation, feet on floor, sitting on chair, feeling of 'forced', don't try to do anything with the body sensations, just include all as they are in this whole wide field of sensation.

And if thoughts arise, any thought, even a thought about an "I" seeing or not seeing, they too are simply an arising and falling back in to the field of thought, (consciousness) and back into the whole field of open sensation.

Practice this for short moments (or longer moments of relaxed meditation) throughout your day.
This practice was an opportunity to experience the now. Focusing on color, sound or sensation individually is something I have been doing during each day from time to time. While focusing on sound, there was no automatic assigning of labels to each sound, simply allowing sound to be sound, being aware of what it felt like to experience sound. When seeing color, my eyes relaxed, there no tension or impression of a projection of energy to ‘see’.

User avatar
Noro
Posts: 787
Joined: Sat Feb 05, 2022 3:42 pm

Re: Introduction

Postby Noro » Wed Sep 16, 2026 6:38 am

Hi Wisiwig,

Most of the questions in blue from the last post were not answered individually nor from your direct experience.

Please answer each question directly from DE using the quote function, and NOT AS A NARRATIVE.
I wrote ‘yes’ thinking of times when I went against the flow of the moment or forced actions/decisions which interrupted the overall flow. I now see the inconsistency of this response.
Is there a separate thinker here? What is here apart from thoughts? memories are thoughts = "thinking of times....."

Is this not all part of the overall flow?

Can the overall flow be interrupted at all?

Who or what can interrupt the flow of life?


Fear of missing out occurs when imaginary evidence is believed and creates fear. In the context of the original response, desire to appeal to others occurs when wanting to be liked or found to be attractive (attractive clothing, interesting self presentation) and there is a fear that simply being me is not enough. In each case, the original response did not recognize that the response to each fear was part of the now/flow.
"Fear of missing out" is a thought, plain and simple, and there would be a narrative going on underneath together with body sensations. There might be emotional responses such as fear, anxiety, grief (i.e. for not meeting our own expectations). Really a wealth of stuff to explore. But the main thing is that there are layers of narrative (thoughts), and emotional (sensations) that will arise.

Are these not all part of the flow, even when thoughts say otherwise?
Another blind spot. This reflected a belief that I am able exert control to upset the flow, a reflection of a ‘responsibility belief’, not true. Although I may be able to upset the current pace or direction, it is because a thought popped up that prompted me to change things up, not because I did something wrong.
What is this "I" you are talking about here: " Although I may be able to upset the current pace or direction",
Can you find any separate agent that can upset anything?

Is this not more thought narrative simply being spewed out?

Is there a "you" who can do something right or wrong in the overall flow of life, except a thought that says so?


You are very good at analyzing, but analyzing is not direct experience. It is speculation, simply: thoughts. Please stick with your direct experience and stay away from analyzing. It is really important to see the difference for otherwise conventional thinking will return again and again and over-ride your findings regarding what is actually going on.

Please let me know if this is clear for you now?

There is a belief that awakening depends upon an intention to awaken, meditation happens because there is an intention to meditate, etc. Within the non-dual community it is common to hear gurus/teachers admonishing followers to engage in certain practices. It makes no sense that they would bother to encourage specific behaviors if those behaviors were not to some degree voluntary.


The above is more conceptual thinking.
Is my desire to engage with awakening outside of my control?
Can you prove that there is an independent "you' that can control anything?

Does the desire to engage with awakening belong to a separate independent "you"?

Is everything influencing me outside of my control thus even intentions are shaped/controlled by those elements? This is the main question I am wrestling with now
I can only suggest that you LOOK carefully in your direct experience.
Is there, or has there ever been any "one" separate, independent entity exercising control, or agency?

In direct experience, what is "intention"? Is it not simply an overlay of thinking responding to some prior urge already present?




"THERE IS NO SEPARATE SELF, NO ONE IN CONTROL, THERE NEVER HAS BEEN AND NEVER WILL BE"

Read or say out loud this sentence. Then pause and take a moment and look into your direct experience..
Can you find anything to name or identify that is truly yourself, that is constant and invariable that stands apart from all other appearances?

After doing this many times, let me know what was seen, felt, discovered.

Please share only your immediate experience when you say or read those words, take note of any thoughts that are emotionally charged, even if you think they might be irrational and any sensations that are noticed in the body. Look for any contractions in head, heart or gut. Please keep to your direct experience and stay away from discussing thoughts or ideas about a separate self.



Warm regards,
Rowena
"Awakening is seeing that all the old patterns run by themselves, and healing is releasing the old patterns so that the system can come back to its natural state, which is health." Ilona Ciunaite

User avatar
Wisiwig
Posts: 36
Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2026 2:40 am

Re: Introduction

Postby Wisiwig » Wed Sep 16, 2026 1:57 pm

Hello Rowena,
Please answer each question directly from DE using the quote function, and NOT AS A NARRATIVE.
I wrote ‘yes’ thinking of times when I went against the flow of the moment or forced actions/decisions which interrupted the overall flow. I now see the inconsistency of this response.
Is there a separate thinker here? What is here apart from thoughts? memories are thoughts = "thinking of times....."
There is no separate thinker
Is this not all part of the overall flow?
Yes, it is part of the overall flow.
Can the overall flow be interrupted at all?
No, the overall flow cannot be interrupted.
Who or what can interrupt the flow of life?
No one can interrupt the flow of life.
Fear of missing out occurs when imaginary evidence is believed and creates fear. In the context of the original response, desire to appeal to others occurs when wanting to be liked or found to be attractive (attractive clothing, interesting self presentation) and there is a fear that simply being me is not enough. In each case, the original response did not recognize that the response to each fear was part of the now/flow.
"Fear of missing out" is a thought, plain and simple, and there would be a narrative going on underneath together with body sensations. There might be emotional responses such as fear, anxiety, grief (i.e. for not meeting our own expectations). Really a wealth of stuff to explore. But the main thing is that there are layers of narrative (thoughts), and emotional (sensations) that will arise.

Are these not all part of the flow, even when thoughts say otherwise?
These are all part of the flow. I see that now.
Another blind spot. This reflected a belief that I am able exert control to upset the flow, a reflection of a ‘responsibility belief’, not true. Although I may be able to upset the current pace or direction, it is because a thought popped up that prompted me to change things up, not because I did something wrong.
What is this "I" you are talking about here: " Although I may be able to upset the current pace or direction",
Can you find any separate agent that can upset anything?
No separate agent can be found.
Is this not more thought narrative simply being spewed out?
Correct, it is a thought narrative.
Is there a "you" who can do something right or wrong in the overall flow of life, except a thought that says so?
There is only the overall flow of life.
You are very good at analyzing, but analyzing is not direct experience. It is speculation, simply: thoughts. Please stick with your direct experience and stay away from analyzing. It is really important to see the difference for otherwise conventional thinking will return again and again and over-ride your findings regarding what is actually going on.

Please let me know if this is clear for you now?
I now see it clearly.
There is a belief that awakening depends upon an intention to awaken, meditation happens because there is an intention to meditate, etc. Within the non-dual community it is common to hear gurus/teachers admonishing followers to engage in certain practices. It makes no sense that they would bother to encourage specific behaviors if those behaviors were not to some degree voluntary.

The above is more conceptual thinking.
Is my desire to engage with awakening outside of my control?
Can you prove that there is an independent "you' that can control anything?
I cannot prove that there is an independent ‘me’.
Does the desire to engage with awakening belong to a separate independent "you"?
No it does not come from a separate independent me, so it must come from the overall flow of life.
Is everything influencing me outside of my control thus even intentions are shaped/controlled by those elements? This is the main question I am wrestling with now
I can only suggest that you LOOK carefully in your direct experience.
Is there, or has there ever been any "one" separate, independent entity exercising control, or agency?
There has never been a separate entity exercising control.
In direct experience, what is "intention"?
Intention is a thought.
Is it not simply an overlay of thinking responding to some prior urge already present?
Correct, it is a thought overlay. I see it now.
"THERE IS NO SEPARATE SELF, NO ONE IN CONTROL, THERE NEVER HAS BEEN AND NEVER WILL BE"

Read or say out loud this sentence. Then pause and take a moment and look into your direct experience..
Can you find anything to name or identify that is truly yourself, that is constant and invariable that stands apart from all other appearances?
No, I cannot find anything to name or identify that is truly myself.
After doing this many times, let me know what was seen, felt, discovered.
There is a sensation of peace. The mind is free of thought. There is no urge to ‘do something’. Simply being is enough.

Thank you for helping me stick with the disciplined process, Scott

User avatar
Noro
Posts: 787
Joined: Sat Feb 05, 2022 3:42 pm

Re: Introduction

Postby Noro » Fri Sep 18, 2026 4:35 am

Hello Wisiwig/Scott!!
After doing this many times, let me know what was seen, felt, discovered.
There is a sensation of peace. The mind is free of thought. There is no urge to ‘do something’. Simply being is enough.
Yes, when it is clear, this is how it is. When mind chatter takes over then the clarity gets obscured.
Thank you for helping me stick with the disciplined process, Scott
You are welcome Scott, and I think that you are now seeing clearly how the so called "sense of I" arises.


We have a set of final checkpoint questions that I could share with you if you feel ready. When I have received your answers I will read through them and if I have no points to review will share with some other guides who might have their own questions. Would you be ready for this? Please let me know either way.

In the meantime, here are a couple more to explore:


SENSE OF SELF - PERSONAL DOERSHIP

Please contemplate these two questions.

What do you perceive to be "you" in your every day life when ALL THOUGHTS ABOUT YOU are dropped?

If I were to ask you to stand up and take a step towards your self, where would you go?


Warm regards,
Rowena
"Awakening is seeing that all the old patterns run by themselves, and healing is releasing the old patterns so that the system can come back to its natural state, which is health." Ilona Ciunaite

User avatar
Wisiwig
Posts: 36
Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2026 2:40 am

Re: Introduction

Postby Wisiwig » Sun Sep 20, 2026 7:43 pm

I am having trouble accessing a quiet space in order to address these questions. After receiving these question, I was initially struck with difficulty meditating without constant thought intrusions and weak concentration. Now today, my efforts at meditation are interfered with by sensations that I realized were enduring sensations that had helped to shape my life, many of which I recall from my youth. I recognize what is happening, it is that my process tripped into a ‘house cleaning’ period. I need to let it play out as I process the sensations. I have experienced similar episodes before, and know that once they abate, I will then be able to access a better state of meditation. I want to respond to these questions with a state of knowing rather than an intellectual knowledge. I will keep you posted as to my status.

User avatar
Wisiwig
Posts: 36
Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2026 2:40 am

Re: Introduction

Postby Wisiwig » Sun Sep 20, 2026 8:03 pm

correction to sentence above: "I was initially struck with difficulty meditating WITH constant thought intrusions". That might make more sense. I haven't figured out how to edit posts, I assume there isn't a way.

User avatar
Noro
Posts: 787
Joined: Sat Feb 05, 2022 3:42 pm

Re: Introduction

Postby Noro » Sun Sep 20, 2026 8:40 pm

Hello Scott,

Please take your time with this. However, I would like to point out that this is not about accessing some mystical state of knowing.... I am not entirely sure as to what this refer? It is certainly not some spiritual interpretation of something like "It's all one!" or "I am awareness!" These are both conclusions.

What is being looked at in your direct experience is really quite simple,,,, you can refer back to the exercise where the "I am" thought is dropped and take it from there. It is not necessary to be in deep meditation for this exercise. In fact, it is not even desirable. Both questions are simply questioning the evidence of a separate, autonomous "you" that has agency. What is present in your direct experience. Look at the sense fields for this. I hope this clarifies.

Also, look at your tendency to get drawn back into rational thinking and/or thinking that there is some possibility of some deeper knowing that some people (teachers or gurus claim. See that tendency for what it is, a mind seeking 'knowledge". This is not about knowledge, this is about clarity and evidence seen through looking directly at what is present.

There is a BIG difference between knowing/believing that there is no independent separate self, and seeing that there is no separate self. If you can’t see for yourself directly, you cannot describe what you see in your own words. You have already seen this. Maybe the questions are misleading, consider that a good thing, the mind will come in and try and analyze....that's what minds do. Let that happen and see thought in action.

Is there an independent "you" that can control thinking?


And then look again in your direct experience:

What do 'you' perceive to be "you" in your every day life when ALL THOUGHTS ABOUT YOU are dropped? or,
Where are 'you' in your every day life when all thoughts about you are dropped?


If I were to ask 'you' to stand up and take a step towards 'you', where would you go?


And yes, once you press submit you can no longer edit.

Look forward to hearing from you.

Warm regards,
Rowena
"Awakening is seeing that all the old patterns run by themselves, and healing is releasing the old patterns so that the system can come back to its natural state, which is health." Ilona Ciunaite

User avatar
Wisiwig
Posts: 36
Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2026 2:40 am

Re: Introduction

Postby Wisiwig » Tue Sep 22, 2026 9:13 am

Rowena, Thank you for your patience, here are my responses:
What do you perceive to be "you" in your every day life when ALL THOUGHTS ABOUT YOU are dropped?
I am that which experiences. I am the wide-eyed child on the roller coaster.
If I were to ask you to stand up and take a step towards your self, where would you go?
There is no where to go. I am Here, Now.
Is there an independent "you" that can control thinking?
There is no separate self. Thoughts cannot be controlled.

Best regards, Wisiwig

User avatar
Noro
Posts: 787
Joined: Sat Feb 05, 2022 3:42 pm

Re: Introduction

Postby Noro » Tue Sep 22, 2026 1:05 pm

Hi Wisiwig,

That is great. Would you like the checking questions that will be shared with other guides?

For the 'part' that likes to "know" this is not a test and any questions are helpful to query something I might not have seen, and there is no final end to this exploration; it will end when it feels right as conditioning still continues as it did, but as you have already seen, it appears to lessen with the clear looking from DE.

Warm regards,
Rowena
"Awakening is seeing that all the old patterns run by themselves, and healing is releasing the old patterns so that the system can come back to its natural state, which is health." Ilona Ciunaite

User avatar
Wisiwig
Posts: 36
Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2026 2:40 am

Re: Introduction

Postby Wisiwig » Tue Sep 22, 2026 3:36 pm

Hello Rowena,
I'm not familiar with the process you are describing. It seems that you think I have hit some milestones. Will you tell me about what you are considering?

Best regards,
Wisiwig

User avatar
Noro
Posts: 787
Joined: Sat Feb 05, 2022 3:42 pm

Re: Introduction

Postby Noro » Tue Sep 22, 2026 8:41 pm

Hello Wisiwig,

"You" have hit no milestone. There is no "you". However, through the direct exploration that has been going on here there comes a time when the difference between what is made up through thought content regarding the seeming reality of a separate sense of self is fully known to be another appearance amongst all other appearance and holds no separate independent reality. At that time, when it comes, the inquiry can run out of steam. Direct looking has served its purpose and there is total clarity that there is no independent separate self. At this point we can forward your responses to a set of questions for other guides to take a look at and ask their own questions if necessary.

It does not mean that the exploration between us needs to come to an end, but there might be a natural tailing off of the conversation if it feel appropriate. There is no goal achieved since any goal would imply a separate 'someone" to achieve a goal.

Is this OK with you? (And there is no 'you'') It is simply a convention of language.

Please let me know,

Warm regards,
Rowena
"Awakening is seeing that all the old patterns run by themselves, and healing is releasing the old patterns so that the system can come back to its natural state, which is health." Ilona Ciunaite

User avatar
Wisiwig
Posts: 36
Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2026 2:40 am

Re: Introduction

Postby Wisiwig » Tue Sep 22, 2026 9:04 pm

Hello Rowena,
Thank you for addressing the questions. It will take some time to integrate the new knowings into the complete lived experience. It is reassuring to know that you are available for continuing consultations. I agree to seeking feedback from other guides.

Best regards,
Wisiwig

User avatar
Noro
Posts: 787
Joined: Sat Feb 05, 2022 3:42 pm

Re: Introduction

Postby Noro » Tue Sep 22, 2026 9:18 pm

Hello Wisiwig,


Here are the questions I mentioned. If there seems to be some lack of clarity to some answers I will of course get back to you with my own questions and then after that your responses will be shared with other guides who may have questions.

Please relate your answers to your direct experience and not from a conceptual understanding, unless the question seems to invite a conceptual answer.


1) Is there a separate entity 'self', 'me' 'I', at all, anywhere, in any way, shape or form?
Was there ever?


2) Explain in detail what the illusion of separate self is, when it starts and how it works from your own experience. Describe it fully as you see it now.


3) How does it feel to see this? What is the difference from before you started this dialogue? Please report from the past few days.


4) What was the last bit that pushed you over; made you look?

5) Describe decision and give an example from experience.

Describe intention and give an example from experience.

Describe free will and give an example from experience.

Describe choice and give an example from experience.

Describe control and give an example from experience.


6) What are you responsible for? Give an example from your experience.

7) What makes things happen? How does it all work?

8) Anything to add?



Warm regards,
Rowena
"Awakening is seeing that all the old patterns run by themselves, and healing is releasing the old patterns so that the system can come back to its natural state, which is health." Ilona Ciunaite

User avatar
Wisiwig
Posts: 36
Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2026 2:40 am

Re: Introduction

Postby Wisiwig » Thu Sep 24, 2026 2:24 pm

1) Is there a separate entity 'self', 'me' 'I', at all, anywhere, in any way, shape or form?
Was there ever?
Answer: There is no separate self, me or I. There never has been. Self inquiry has revealed that there is no separate self. If the following responses contain references to an ‘I’, this is an artifact of language.
2) Explain in detail what the illusion of separate self is, when it starts and how it works from your own experience. Describe it fully as you see it now.
It starts when a child is trained to see itself as separate from others and the perceived world. Language, which is subject/object oriented, orients the child to view itself as a noun. The child forms an imaginary self composed of beliefs and memories (thought) which becomes rooted as the view of self and other.
3) How does it feel to see this? What is the difference from before you started this dialogue? Please report from the past few days.
It feels destabilizing and liberating. This insight has shown that this mortal life has been interpreted through a grossly distorted lens, resulting in chronic suffering. This realization is liberating but is currently accompanied by a grieving process (which is fading over time).
4) What was the last bit that pushed you over; made you look?
The recognition that no matter how hard I worked, focused, and disciplined myself, I could not control my life path.
5) Describe decision and give an example from experience.
Decision is a belief that one exercises control through thought. This an illusion. In reality, decisions are controlled by forces that influence the thought context, the mental mindset, the currently accessible set of memories, and thoughts that present in the mind. Most decision outcomes are predisposed by the conditions and influences. It is true that a process involving thought (deliberation) may occur before a decision is taken, but often the thoughts bear little to no influence on the decision taken. Example, being vaguely aware of competing urges (complete these questions or scan for the latest news on news sites), thoughts occur about which would be best to do, then an urge to use the toilet occurs and that is the decision taken with neither contemplated tasks engaged.
Describe intention and give an example from experience.
An intention seems to arise from an urge (sensation like an energetic compression), which is then supported by thought. Example, a sensation presents that ‘something needs to be done’. Then a thought arises ‘buy eggs at store’. Then an action plan is formed in thought.
Describe free will and give an example from experience.
Free will assumes an autonomous actor controlling choices. In the absence of a separate self, free will is not necessary or possible. Examples from experience would be misinterpretations of what was happening.
Describe choice and give an example from experience.
Choice arises, sometimes after thoughts are considered, thus giving the illusion that the choice involved weighing alternatives and picking the most desirable expected outcome. Choice is not an act of free will. Choices simply arise. Example: To choose strawberry or chocolate flavored ice cream when at the ice cream shop? The visual image of the ice cream color/shape is recognized, memories of the taste/smell of strawberry and chocolate ice cream flash into the now experience, then a choice arises in the mind.
Describe control and give an example from experience.
Control is exerting influence toward a desired end. The belief in one’s ability to control is a misinterpretation of an event by imputing an actor with the power to make decisions, generate a final choice, and exert influence. Example, there no control other than to exert control of attention.
6) What are you responsible for? Give an example from your experience.
Responsibility is being accountable for consequences of decisions/choices made when one possesses volitional control over those decisions/choices. Responsibility requires that there be a separate self that is capable of controlling decisions/choices. There is no separate self or control, thus no responsibility.
7) What makes things happen? How does it all work?
The current understanding is that things simply happen. The ‘I am’ can observe and somehow a response arises. There is a choice to identify with what is happening or not identify with it. This may be related to attention (see below).
8) Anything to add?
Attention holds a role that is involved with intention and control. The current impression is that there can be control of attention, or at least the focus of attention. This is needed for tasks like meditating and focusing on Direct Experience. For example, there could be intention to focus attention, then effort to focus attention in the absence of a separate self.

User avatar
Noro
Posts: 787
Joined: Sat Feb 05, 2022 3:42 pm

Re: Introduction

Postby Noro » Thu Sep 24, 2026 3:06 pm

Hello Wisiwig,

Just a few points to clear up here before I pass on to other guides to take a look.
Describe control and give an example from experience.
Control is exerting influence toward a desired end. The belief in one’s ability to control is a misinterpretation of an event by imputing an actor with the power to make decisions, generate a final choice, and exert influence. Example, there no control other than to exert control of attention.
This response is confusing. In the first sentence you are saying that the. "idea of control is a misinterpretation....... "
Then, in the second sentence you are saying that there are occasions where some ability for control is available. i.e. "to exert control of attention."

Who or what can exert control of attention? Can such an actor be found when you look closely?
8) Anything to add?
Attention holds a role that is involved with intention and control. The current impression is that there can be control of attention, or at least the focus of attention. This is needed for tasks like meditating and focusing on Direct Experience. For example, there could be intention to focus attention, then effort to focus attention in the absence of a separate self.
This last paragraph seems to negate your responses to the questions above regarding intention and control.

"The current impression....."
In your direct experience, to what does this refer? What constitutes "a current impression." ? Is it anything more than an idea or a thought, i.e. thinking happening ?

Is there anything separate anywhere that can be found to actually control or focus (or not focus) attention. Please say more about this.

"This is needed......." Please say more about this, needed for whom?

".....then effort to focus attention in the absence if a separate self."
Please look in your direct experience to the word "effort."

To what does something called "effort" refer?
How does it show up?
What does "effort" FEEL like?
Is there even such a thing as "effort" that can be used as a tool ?


Warm regards,
Rowena
"Awakening is seeing that all the old patterns run by themselves, and healing is releasing the old patterns so that the system can come back to its natural state, which is health." Ilona Ciunaite


Return to “ARCHIVES”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 44 guests