Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
- jeffdilbeck
- Posts: 587
- Joined: Thu Feb 02, 2012 6:47 pm
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
Zoc,
Where are you at with this?
Where are you at with this?
- ZenOfchaos
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Sun Aug 12, 2012 11:45 am
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
Sometimes it feels like I'm close, other times the opposite. It feels like a kind of underlying spiritual depression. I worry that this is all out of reach and that the egoic tendencies have gotten stronger again instead of weaker. My answers of late have been slightly apathetic although this is for the reasons I just stated rather than a lack of looking. It feels as if mind makes progress then a thousand questions come rushing in casting doubt. Many already answered questions so it feels like I'm stuck in the spin cycle of the dryer going round and round. And that these things are getting in the way of the experiential element of this liberation process.Zoc,
Where are you at with this?
As you know I occasionaly look at other threads for reminders or pointers. Came across this post by Valerie in a conversation with Ron in the Home forum:
"I believe you have a good intellectual understanding of no self. But I also think that because you get it intellectually, you may not be digging even deeper into the experience of it. So, when you look for the self and hit the 'Oh, yes, of course. It's not there, it's imaginary.", you may be stopping and resting right there. And then getting disappointed, sort of like 'Is that all there is?". The reason I think this is possible is that many people who get it intellectually get stuck right at this point. There is no big sigh of release because the experience of it isn't as strong as it could be. Sometimes folks get stuck there for a long time."
This is possibly where I'm at. It's kinda difficult to tell though because we've been in discussion for a long time and we maybe need a review or something.
Thanks Jeff for sticking with this for so long. At times it feels like "i missed the boat" with liberation: missed the opportunity. Hopefully we can clear the fog and find that gate! Thanks to you too Rohit.
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
You can't get this intellectually, you can't even be smart about this, this is blatant truth, this is as true as the sky being blue, it's not some equation you gotta solve.
There is no you anywhere, that's truth.
You don't need evidence to see that the sky is blue do you?
This is the same thing, you don't need evidence to prove the absence of self, because there already is no such thing as a self, all you have to do is see that.
There is no you anywhere, that's truth.
You don't need evidence to see that the sky is blue do you?
This is the same thing, you don't need evidence to prove the absence of self, because there already is no such thing as a self, all you have to do is see that.
- ZenOfchaos
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Sun Aug 12, 2012 11:45 am
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
I was making the point that I can understand, for the most part, how the delusion develops and what its attributes are. You know that speech from Good Will Hunting where Williams talks to Damon in the park. It's like that. If I told a blind man about the sky he could maybe understand it but never experience it. I'm the blind man without the experience. I'm not looking for a complete understanding, although that would be great and it would please mind but the point of that post was to say rather than intellect I need to get this experientially.You can't get this intellectually, you can't even be smart about this, this is blatant truth, this is as true as the sky being blue, it's not some equation you gotta solve.
There is no you anywhere, that's truth.
You don't need evidence to see that the sky is blue do you?
This is the same thing, you don't need evidence to prove the absence of self, because there already is no such thing as a self, all you have to do is see that.
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
It's about realizing the truth of what the self is. Big diff. But that self exists as a thought pattern, a concept. And it doesn't go away with enlightenment. That would be ridiculous. How would there be any functioning in the world if that were to happen? Do you suppose enlightenment means something that would result in the total cessation of self, that you'd have to go live in a cave or sit drooling on a mountaintop?
As I've said, the concept, the thought pattern, persists. And it's useful.
But the point is to see it. See what it REALLY IS.
As I've said, the concept, the thought pattern, persists. And it's useful.
But the point is to see it. See what it REALLY IS.
- ZenOfchaos
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Sun Aug 12, 2012 11:45 am
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
Perhaps in the beginning when I first started to listen to Tolle did I think enlightment meant living in a permanent state of bliss. But no I don't think it involves sitting on a mountain top nor do i think the self will disappear. I do still have expectations if I am honest but I also understand that seeing no self means being able to see through that selfing filter rather than it to be gone altogether. I think those expectations I have are still to do with finding an underlying sense of peace despite what is on the surface and getting into the 'flow' of life, seeing through separation into oneness (whatever that means).It's about realizing the truth of what the self is. Big diff. But that self exists as a thought pattern, a concept. And it doesn't go away with enlightenment. That would be ridiculous. How would there be any functioning in the world if that were to happen? Do you suppose enlightenment means something that would result in the total cessation of self, that you'd have to go live in a cave or sit drooling on a mountaintop?
As I've said, the concept, the thought pattern, persists. And it's useful.
But the point is to see it. See what it REALLY IS.
hell, maybe its already been seen. I dunno. I just want to be clear as crystal.
- jeffdilbeck
- Posts: 587
- Joined: Thu Feb 02, 2012 6:47 pm
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
What is a self, Zoc? In one word.
- ZenOfchaos
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Sun Aug 12, 2012 11:45 am
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
A constructWhat is a self, Zoc? In one word.
- jeffdilbeck
- Posts: 587
- Joined: Thu Feb 02, 2012 6:47 pm
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
Real or imaginary?
- ZenOfchaos
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Sun Aug 12, 2012 11:45 am
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
The mechanism is real but the self is a construct that is kept alive by thought and conditioningReal or imaginary?
- jeffdilbeck
- Posts: 587
- Joined: Thu Feb 02, 2012 6:47 pm
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
When do you think the fruits of this mechanism started?
- ZenOfchaos
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Sun Aug 12, 2012 11:45 am
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
Children start to develop a sense of self awareness around 4 years old when they become aware that the figure in the mirror is themselves.When do you think the fruits of this mechanism started?
- jeffdilbeck
- Posts: 587
- Joined: Thu Feb 02, 2012 6:47 pm
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
Do *you* make choices, Zoc?
- ZenOfchaos
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Sun Aug 12, 2012 11:45 am
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
If I am honest this is one area where there is still doubt.Do *you* make choices, Zoc?
There are obvious instances where there is no control such as subconscious movements like scratching your nose or walking somewhere. Basically anything that happens where you realise "Oh, yeah I did not consciously decide to do any of those things"
There are less obvious instances when the things you decide to do are based on making a conscious decision like picking what you want for dinner. anything that requires some kind of deliberation. Here we can say that the humming and hawing over making a decision "just comes up" which is true but it doesn't feel that way because you have to be looking at the space where the thoughts pop up to realise that they are just coming up from the void.
The difficult ones are the more emotional and complex decisions. Like "Do I leave my partner?" for example. It's certainly not an easy decision and one that feels like there needs to be control...a chooser. a voice in the head says "if there is no chooser then the decision should be straight forward and easy. It should be done for you." I guess that's how the illusion gathers layers.
Finally there is the issue of free will. And some part of this mind doesn't want to give that up. It wants to make it work because through suffering the mind wants to know that it can do something to recover, rather than slide back to suffering. maybe that it can make a decision (like choosing to follow a spiritual teacher or mental health technique) rather than be at the hands of a deterministic universe. I guess i'm holding on to this because it was one thing that really helped me during the worst times. It was reading through 'Conversations with God' that Walsch says that we couldn't have the good without the bad (although there isn't technically any good or bad), and that god gave us free will in order to be able to do things differently after seeing the truth. So that potential bad things can become ways of making a better life or transcending the pain.
It doesn't rest well on a psycho-philosophical level that this universe in deterministic because no matter which way you look at it it doesn't make total sense. Yes I can see how one thing leads to another in a cause and effect relationship no matter how complex but there is that other side of me that thinks "if there is an infinte I, or god, or creator, or aliens, spirit, universe, or simple evolution, or whatever made this place then that's pretty dull and rather pointless. If we are all players and the world is the stage then why bother creating something that leaves no element to the player? when I watch movies I know everyting is scripted. Is that what the universe is doing? Just experiencing a scripted movie?" Isn't there a way of allowing free will and a universe that has no separate selves?
Hope you didn't want a simple answer Jeff!!
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
Examine your decision to come here. Can you separate it from the preceding events in your life? How did they lead up to it? Trace the time line back as far as you can.
Remember a time when "you" intended to do something, but didn't. Remember a time when "you" intended to not do something, but did.
You will never discover who "you" are. What we are doing dissolves the concept of "I" in its entirety because "there is no I that you are," so You will never discover who "you" are, you will discover only that "There is no you and never was".
what are you afraid will happen, if no-you turns out to be the truth? Are you afraid to think that you have no control?
Here's where you are mistaken. Life is uncaused. Its beyond the limited scope of the 'cause n effect' thing.
Everything in the physical world is linked in terms of cause and effect by the human brain. It does this to make sense of things. Pretty useful. But counter productive to recognizing the notion of no 'you'.
Because you're used to thinking "X" causes "Y", you fail to see that everything in your experience is generated without having a central cause, i.e., a 'self'.
Stop using cause and effect as a tool to 'resolve' this 'no you' thing. Look at the reality of things.
Makes sense now?
Remember a time when "you" intended to do something, but didn't. Remember a time when "you" intended to not do something, but did.
You will never discover who "you" are. What we are doing dissolves the concept of "I" in its entirety because "there is no I that you are," so You will never discover who "you" are, you will discover only that "There is no you and never was".
what are you afraid will happen, if no-you turns out to be the truth? Are you afraid to think that you have no control?
Here's where you are mistaken. Life is uncaused. Its beyond the limited scope of the 'cause n effect' thing.
Everything in the physical world is linked in terms of cause and effect by the human brain. It does this to make sense of things. Pretty useful. But counter productive to recognizing the notion of no 'you'.
Because you're used to thinking "X" causes "Y", you fail to see that everything in your experience is generated without having a central cause, i.e., a 'self'.
Stop using cause and effect as a tool to 'resolve' this 'no you' thing. Look at the reality of things.
Makes sense now?
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot], GoodnightAZ and 5 guests

