Stream Entry

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Fri Jun 14, 2024 1:17 pm

Hello Nicholas
It’s not even a thought, I just sit here quietly without thinking. c.
"Sitting there quietly without thinking" ....
Now is that not a real difference in experience that compared to when you started all this?



But I still “see” that I’m the owner.
When you are looking up in the sky and a cloud passes, you see it .......but is it yours?




You see cars passing on the in the street does that make them yours?





A little child comes to play at his friends place and suddenly he sees a toy he likes and grabs it and declares "Mine !!!"
Does that make it his?




Or does the act of "claiming" it just appear to make it his?




The only reason he declares it is "mine" is that he thinks that it is his.




What is it that makes it true that thoughts that arise and disappear are "owned" by you?




Surely if they are owned by you, you could choose to do with them WHATEVER, WHENEVER and HOWEVER you chose?




Seems like I actually cannot choose anything but I cannot explain what’s behind this.
Wanting to explain is a real trap. This mystery of life can NEVER be explained and yet the mind insists that it will.
This is what overrides what is seen in direct experience.

You are reporting what you see in the thought stream here very clearly. Here is the full quote again and I've highlighted where the mind hijacks the direct experience.
I don’t know. If I say to myself “I’m going to think about dragons” then… why dragons? Did I choose dragons? I didn’t choose that. So… how do I choose? Whatever thing I want to think next it’s like… I’m not really in control. “Now I’m going to think about yellow and for the next 2 minutes just going to think yellow things”. Again… why yellow? Did I choose that? Seems like I actually cannot choose anything but I cannot explain what’s behind this. There’s something here though… something I cannot manage to see.
These questions are all just thoughts and the assumption is that the answer will be found in thought.
Do you see in what you've seen above how the mind imposes itself on the direct experience?



Do you really expect that thought can provide the answer when it is only ever a fragmentary reflection ABOUT the truth?




There’s something here though… something I cannot manage to see.
You are actually seeing it Nicholas. What you are NOT RECOGNIZING is the thoughts that pass by in the form of questions are being claimed by you by engaging with them. These cloud direct experience and have you conclude that you are not seeing. It's like wearing red tinted glasses and wanting to change the redness everything seems to be coloured with "out there" when all that is needed is to suddenly realize that to change the redness "out there" is to take off the glasses. The question is likely to arise "How do I do that ?" I'll come back to that in moment.

Please don’t get mad at me.
Oh Nicholas. There wasn't the slightest inclination to get mad with you here.😊😊😊 It is interesting how we can interpret things. But ...... having raised that question would it help if I did ?!?!?! 😊😊😊 Just joking !!

Just show me where I’m going wrong.
This is a judgement from the mind. Another thought that distracts from direct experience. Having said that I hear you and we'll do that by coming back to the metaphor of taking off the red glasses.

And to do that we'll come back to to your earlier report where you sat watching your thoughts. Here is what you said .....
I don’t know. If I say to myself “I’m going to think about dragons” then… why dragons? Did I choose dragons? I didn’t choose that. So… how do I choose? Whatever thing I want to think next it’s like… I’m not really in control. “Now I’m going to think about yellow and for the next 2 minutes just going to think yellow things”. Again… why yellow? Did I choose that? Seems like I actually cannot choose anything but I cannot explain what’s behind this. There’s something here though… something I cannot manage to see.
The questions highlighted in the quote above in red are thoughts that are like the red tinted glasses.

Please do this again paying keen attention to the following.

Sit watching your thoughts like this again and keep a really keen eye out for questions coming like the ones in red. DO NOT TRY TO STOP THEM but SIMPLY SEE THEM. Watch how the default is to engage with them and try to figure things out because you let the questions hook you in. Trying to answer them or feeling frustrated that you can't answer them is like looking through the red glasses. SIMPLY SEE THEM AS ANOTHER THOUGHT ARISING and passing. That is what it means to take off the red glasses,

If you do get caught by a thought - which is highly likely to happen - just say "Did it again!!!" and return to simply looking.

JUST KEEP LOOKING.

As questions arise if you simply let them be ....... what happens in your experience?



If you don't claim or believe ANY thought what is your experience?




With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Sun Jun 16, 2024 4:43 am

It’s not even a thought, I just sit here quietly without thinking. c.
"Sitting there quietly without thinking" ....
Now is that not a real difference in experience that compared to when you started all this?
Not sure… how?
But I still “see” that I’m the owner.
When you are looking up in the sky and a cloud passes, you see it .......but is it yours?
it’s not


You see cars passing on the in the street does that make them yours?
no


A little child comes to play at his friends place and suddenly he sees a toy he likes and grabs it and declares "Mine !!!"
Does that make it his?
nop


Or does the act of "claiming" it just appear to make it his?
ok. Claiming. Then what am I claiming here exactly? The experience? Confusing.
(claiming everything inside, actually)


The only reason he declares it is "mine" is that he thinks that it is his.
What is it that makes it true that thoughts that arise and disappear are "owned" by you?
because they are… inside this body? Everything from this body belongs to me.
(but maybe it's just noise, a lot of noise. ok but then who's watching the noise? it's tricky!)

Surely if they are owned by you, you could choose to do with them WHATEVER, WHENEVER and HOWEVER you chose?
But I can’t
These questions are all just thoughts and the assumption is that the answer will be found in thought.
Do you see in what you've seen above how the mind imposes itself on the direct experience?
yes… I see
Do you really expect that thought can provide the answer when it is only ever a fragmentary reflection ABOUT the truth?
You are right. Thoughts are concepts and concepts will never reflect reality 1 to 1.
Sit watching your thoughts like this again and keep a really keen eye out for questions coming like the ones in red. DO NOT TRY TO STOP THEM but SIMPLY SEE THEM. Watch how the default is to engage with them and try to figure things out because you let the questions hook you in. Trying to answer them or feeling frustrated that you can't answer them is like looking through the red glasses. SIMPLY SEE THEM AS ANOTHER THOUGHT ARISING and passing. That is what it means to take off the red glasses,

If you do get caught by a thought - which is highly likely to happen - just say "Did it again!!!" and return to simply looking.

JUST KEEP LOOKING.

As questions arise if you simply let them be ....... what happens in your experience?
questions stop. Every thought is just an attempt to explain what’s happening. Every thought tries to explain what another thought means… it’s an endless circle. Pointless.

As far as I’m aware of this… thoughts get veeeeery quiet.

If you don't claim or believe ANY thought what is your experience?
I’m not sure, it’s hard. They are extremely sticky, especially monologue. But I can somewhat… try to… get away a bit from them. Not too far. Uuuuuh maybe I’m not generating any of them. Maybe they just arise based on conditions… on this machine.
OK… I can see a biiiit of what’s the deal here. But it’s… easy to get trapped again. So easy.

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Sun Jun 16, 2024 12:22 pm

questions stop. Every thought is just an attempt to explain what’s happening. Every thought tries to explain what another thought means… it’s an endless circle. Pointless.
As far as I’m aware of this… thoughts get veeeeery quiet.
This is good Nicholas

But I can somewhat… try to… get away a bit from them. Not too far.
No need to try to get away from them. Doesn't matter if they seem "close" or "far" Or if they seem to brush past Just see them for what they are. Just let them be without engaging with them.

OK… I can see a biiiit of what’s the deal here. But it’s… easy to get trapped again. So easy.
Yes, it can be so easy to get trapped sometimes. Getting trapped is not the issue persay but NOTICING when you get trapped is the key. "Oh done it again!!!" And then you go back to LOOKING again. You are interrupting a lifetime habit here.

What you are doing here is at the heart of this investigation. So the task for today is to do this again. As many times as possible throughout the day do this. I'll repeat the exercise here again for easy reference.

Sit watching your thoughts again and keep a really keen eye out for questions coming like the ones in red. DO NOT TRY TO STOP THEM but SIMPLY SEE THEM. Watch how the default is to engage with them and try to figure things out because you let the questions hook you in. Trying to answer them or feeling frustrated that you can't answer them is like looking through the red glasses. SIMPLY SEE THEM AS ANOTHER THOUGHT ARISING and passing. Just letting them be without engaging with them. is what it means to take off the red glasses,

If you do get caught by a thought - which is highly likely to happen - just say "Did it again!!!" and return to simply looking.

JUST KEEP LOOKING.

And again ....
Tell me ......as questions arise if you simply let them be ....... what happens in your experience?



Again if you don't claim or believe or engage with ANY thought what is experienced?





With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Mon Jun 17, 2024 4:54 am

Tell me ......as questions arise if you simply let them be ....... what happens in your experience?
Again if you don't claim or believe or engage with ANY thought what is experienced?
Gonna answer both…

music is always there.

Thoughts start to appear thinking about this exercise.

The more I do it… the more monologue just looks like… another passing thought. Like… just arising on their own.

it’s funny cause it’s automatic to react to thoughts with more thoughts.

Mmhm.. then… after a while… monologue stops… music too… and then there’s only the third layer of… whirlwind of dismantled thoughts. Maybe some peace.

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Mon Jun 17, 2024 1:12 pm

Hello Nicholas,

The more I do it… the more monologue just looks like… another passing thought. Like… just arising on their own.
You say ...."The more I do it" .... Beautiful. And the more we keep doing it, the more we find it becomes the way we live


it’s funny cause it’s automatic to react to thoughts with more thoughts.
Ah "it's funny" .......Can you find yourself actually laughing at it?



Mmhm.. then… after a while… monologue stops… music too…
Interesting ! Until this happened did you ever believe that this that you describe could be experienced?




This is the power inherent in simply LOOKING and being able to see what is going on in thought in a way that we hadn't seen before. It 'slows" things down, it changes the way we relate to experience.

Clear seeing and feeling with deep curiosity and "radical" honesty is the key to transformation

I think we can move on to the next questions in your review. Looking forward to it Nicholas.



With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Tue Jun 18, 2024 4:12 am

Ah "it's funny" .......Can you find yourself actually laughing at it?
it’s actually an expression! Didn’t actually laugh.

Code: Select all

[quote]Mmhm.. then… after a while… monologue stops… music too… [/quote] Interesting ! Until this happened did you ever believe that this that you describe could be experienced?
Actually… yes! For some reason I got to that kind of state several times a couple months ago… then it just became impossible with my previous method!

(before doing this exercise)
When I produce thoughts it really feels like I’m doing something. Like some kind of a muscle!
Let's take this a little further...
Can you select from a range of thoughts to have only pleasant thoughts?
for a little while, yes

Can you choose not to have painful, negative, or fearful thoughts?
can use some brute force… but its hard

Can you pick and choose any kind of thought?
in this case, not sure I’m the one doing the choosing.
Is it possible to prevent a thought from appearing?
No

Compared to before:
+ little less blabber
+ some small differences, still need more work here

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Tue Jun 18, 2024 1:39 pm

Nothing in particular comes up to respond to here Nicholas.

It'll be interesting to see your review of some of the next questions Nicholas.

With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Thu Jun 20, 2024 4:50 am

hi!
This is very subtle stuff. Please be extra careful that you don’t fall into the trap of telling a story of what you believe / assume / conclude is happening. So without any analysis just tell me what you observe as you LOOK DIRECTLY at what’s happening right this moment
What was the very last thought that you were conscious of in your mind before you read this question?
music!
Did you consciously choose to think it?
no

What thought has your attention right now, in this split second? (This can happen so fast that it maybe that when you look you feel that another thought has already arisen. If this happens, just type whatever thought you notice)
still music


Did you actually choose to think about that specific thought?
nope

Now watch again as another thought arises. Did you catch the moment when you decided to have that SPECIFIC THOUGHT or did it just arise and disappear?
they just arise, there’s some kind of impression than I’m choosing them BUT… as I said before… “why X thought?”


Watch the thought stream for few moments. Are you choosing each and every thought or are they just arrisinand disappearingg??
Just arising and gone
Just a few other questions to use in your investigation as you LOOK
In and of itself, what can a thought actually do?
nothing

Can a thought think?
no

Can a thought expect anything?
no

Does a thought know anything?
no


observations:
+ less blahblah
+ less mind

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Thu Jun 20, 2024 1:35 pm

Nicholas
they just arise, there’s some kind of impression than I’m choosing them BUT… as I said before… “why X thought?”
Do you realize you have the "red glasses" on again in entertaining this question of“why X thought?”?




What happened when you became aware of engaging with the "mind" questions a couple of days ago? Did not the thoughts slow right down?





At this stage vigilance of being sucked into the fiction of thought is required to save us falling back into the old habits. Otherwise you'll just keep going round and round in circles.


Let's keep going


With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Sat Jun 22, 2024 4:08 am

they just arise, there’s some kind of impression than I’m choosing them BUT… as I said before… “why X thought?”
Do you realize you have the "red glasses" on again in entertaining this question of“why X thought?”?
yeah… looking at thought content


What happened when you became aware of engaging with the "mind" questions a couple of days ago? Did not the thoughts slow right down?
I… don’t notice any difference.

Lemme try again
This is very subtle stuff. Please be extra careful that you don’t fall into the trap of telling a story of what you believe / assume / conclude is happening. So without any analysis just tell me what you observe as you LOOK DIRECTLY at what’s happening right this moment
What was the very last thought that you were conscious of in your mind before you read this question?
music!

Did you consciously choose to think it?
no

What thought has your attention right now, in this split second? (This can happen so fast that it maybe that when you look you feel that another thought has already arisen. If this happens, just type whatever thought you notice)
nothing! Mind went silent. On further investigation only third layer.


Did you actually choose to think about that specific thought?
no

Now watch again as another thought arises. Did you catch the moment when you decided to have that SPECIFIC THOUGHT or did it just arise and disappear?
I’m doing nothing, thoughts do they thing

Watch the thought stream for few moments. Are you choosing each and every thought or are they just arrisinand disappearingg??
No
Monologue feels personal, maybe because it has the same voice as this body, and also reacts real time to everything!

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Sat Jun 22, 2024 12:36 pm

Hello there Nicholas
yeah… looking at thought content
Great !! Again and again we notice when we are mesmerized by thought content.
It may be hard to accept however CLEAR SEEING is all that is needed.

What happened when you became aware of engaging with the "mind" questions a couple of days ago? Did not the thoughts slow right down?
I… don’t notice any difference.
This is what I was recalling you said on June 16....
As far as I’m aware of this… thoughts get veeeeery quiet.

Monologue feels personal, maybe because it has the same voice as this body, and also reacts real time to everything!
Is the voice in the head anything other than a stream of thoughts that is a story ABOUT experience which arises and disappears?



Does the monologue ACTUALLY have the SAME voice as this body you claim to be yours or are you imagining it is the same voice?




What exactly is that personal feeling? Please describe the sensation.




Are the feeling that it's personal and the thought that its personal totally inseparable?




Where is the evidence that it is nothing other than an ASSUMED association?




Can the feeling be totally and authentically ever be represented by thought?




Or is the thought just a label, a conceptualization, a story ABOUT what is being felt?




If you didn't associate the thought "I" or "me" with the monologue in any way, would it still feel personal or would the monologue just just be thoughts arising and disappearing?




As you notice thoughts check ......is any independent aliveness inherent in them when you ONLY LOOK at them without believing them?



Is it just thoughts in the head which are actually implying a "me"?



Can thoughts in the head trigger feelings which then become a convincing, believed fictional story producing significant visceral bodily reactions?




Please do not skip over these quickly and superficially. Do not simply depend on memory. They deserve DEEP LOOKING.



With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Sun Jun 23, 2024 6:23 am

Monologue feels personal, maybe because it has the same voice as this body, and also reacts real time to everything!
Is the voice in the head anything other than a stream of thoughts that is a story ABOUT experience which arises and disappears?
yes! Exactly what you say

Does the monologue ACTUALLY have the SAME voice as this body you claim to be yours or are you imagining it is the same voice?
mind says yes.
Without looking at content of the mind… well it’s not EXACTLY the same. It’s like a… “lite” version of my voice.

Can I ask what is the problem if I were to say they are equal? I’m sure there’s something here I need to look, something I’m not realizing.


What exactly is that personal feeling? Please describe the sensation.
AH… you got me. No feeling. Just belief.


Are the feeling that it's personal and the thought that its personal totally inseparable?
it’s a thought actually

Where is the evidence that it is nothing other than an ASSUMED association?
exactly! Assumed.

Can the feeling be totally and authentically ever be represented by thought?
(not a feeling)


Or is the thought just a label, a conceptualization, a story ABOUT what is being felt?
a story


If you didn't associate the thought "I" or "me" with the monologue in any way, would it still feel personal or would the monologue just just be thoughts arising and disappearing?
I don’t know what I would think or believe. Because it’s the voice from this body and I’m living from this point of view

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Sun Jun 23, 2024 12:59 pm

Does the monologue ACTUALLY have the SAME voice as this body you claim to be yours or are you imagining it is the same voice?
Can I ask what is the problem if I were to say they are equal? I’m sure there’s something here I need to look, something I’m not realizing.
Good question Nicholas. Let's look for the answer together.
Unless you speak audibly can you directly experience the hearing of the sound (AE of sound) of your voice?




What evidence is there that the "voice" of the monologue is the same (equal in all respects) voice that you speak with audibly?



Do you actually hear sound from the "voice" in the head or is it imagined (AE of thought)?




When you record your voice and play it back do you actually hear your voice or a recording of your voice?





The recording is typically such a good reproduction that you would likely say "Of course that's my voice." However the truth is that it really is an imitation or reproduction of your voice. A mimic if you will. For one, it has happened in the past. It is not present moment direct experience of your voice. It is present moment hearing of your RECORDED voice.

It is subtle but it is an example of believing a substitute to be real. Just like the voice in the head is another form of substitute. A proxy (and a very fragmented, abstract one a that) of what is real that seems to speak but only because we believe it. Taking notice of the voice in the head is being mesmerized by the illusion.

So while the real voice we actually speak with and the "voice" in the head seem to be equal they are far from being equal.

If you didn't associate the thought "I" or "me" with the monologue in any way, would it still feel personal or would the monologue just just be thoughts arising and disappearing?
I don’t know what I would think or believe. Because it’s the voice from this body and I’m living from this point of view
You say
"I don’t know what I would think or believe."
You are not being asked what you think or believe. You are being asked to describe your experience when you don't associate the thought "I" or "me" with the monologue in any way.
So LOOKING ONLY TO DIRECT EXPERIENCE here is the question again (with a couple of tweaks to make it more direct)
If you don't believe or associate the thought "I" or "me" with the monologue in any way, is it personal or is the monologue just thoughts arising and disappearing?





With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Mon Jun 24, 2024 5:56 am

Unless you speak audibly can you directly experience the hearing of the sound (AE of sound) of your voice?
no


What evidence is there that the "voice" of the monologue is the same (equal in all respects) voice that you speak with audibly?
no evidence (they are not equal at all, the monologue is… like a LITE version, a low quality one, more clean even)
Do you actually hear sound from the "voice" in the head or is it imagined (AE of thought)?
imagined


When you record your voice and play it back do you actually hear your voice or a recording of your voice?
recording
You are not being asked what you think or believe. You are being asked to describe your experience when you don't associate the thought "I" or "me" with the monologue in any way.
So LOOKING ONLY TO DIRECT EXPERIENCE here is the question again (with a couple of tweaks to make it more direct)
If you don't believe or associate the thought "I" or "me" with the monologue in any way, is it personal or is the monologue just thoughts arising and disappearing?
Well… is it always thoughts arising and disappearing

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Mon Jun 24, 2024 12:06 pm

Clear seeing here Nicholas.

Having said that would right to suggest doubt about what is seen as you look is still lurking?





And let's see what is experienced in the review of the next questions.

Be very careful to attend to the question as asked rather than your YOUR IDEA ABOUT what the question is. Be alert for "I know what this is" as you LOOK. Assumptions can "color" your looking very subtly.



With love


Alan


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 64 guests