Stream Entry

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Sun May 19, 2024 10:28 am

Hi Nicholas,
"well! that's direct experience. can't be described."
Ha ha great !!

well, I'm trying to untangle that.
LOOKING is all that's needed to see the tangle and the untangling takes care of itself !!

I chose argentina vs netherlands penalty but the argentinian version (because I'm from Argentina) hope that's not a problem! It's the same video, but with argentinian commentator.
No problem at all.

with sound feels more "alive"
Yes I understand what you are saying. The commentary helps keep boredom (mind condition) at bay. The mind is constantly looking for entertainment. This is what drives the seeking. It never is really satisfied so continually its looking for fulfillment. This keeps suffering going. Constantly looking for fulfillment in that which can never fulfill

it's... emotional, energizing, uplifting. not strictly necessary but it's part of the experience, specially with world cups.
That’s true. And there's nothing inherently "wrong" with that. It’s not about not enjoying these experiences. Rather it is realizing them for what they are and not depending on them for true satisfaction. There is often a paradox here which is this - in realizing that they don’t render lasting satisfaction we can immerse ourselves in it fully aware of their inherent limitations.

A bit like Santa Claus. Even though we know he is not real kids and adults can have a lot of fun with him around.

it lags some!
Yes it does. The lag is hardly discernible initially but then we start to realize that in thinking a thought that by the time we think about it, what it is referring to has already past or has not yet happened.

like... narration is not even necessary but it happens anyway. but it's not something I can just shut off, of course.
The truth is "I" can't shut it off whenever I choose to. What we come to realize as we go deeper into this discovery is there is a peace, an equanimity, a silence underlying all of this that we start to get a taste for and is so much more satisfying than the activity of the mind.

some... small insight. yes. life is a play and the narrator is like the commentator. how do I go deeper with this insight?
Let's take this another step right now.


The biggest part of everyday thinking for most of humanty is made up of stories about what is NOT happening here and now. The focus seems to stay on what is happening in imagination, in the head. This narrative appears to be the most important part of experience; it’s composed of imaginary what-if scenarios, replays of arguments, daydreaming, remembering, planning, and looking for problems and possible solutions….. on and on it goes.

When everything seems to be going well we don't seem to have a problem. In fact we can enjoy it. When the going gets rough the voice seems to amp up typically. And getting caught up in the voice creates the turmoil. What is this voice actually doing? This voice is telling stories always relevant in some (often very subtle or not so subtle) way to "ME" and made up of thoughts about thoughts about thoughts. It’s thoughts all the way through.

So let's look .......

There is a voice so surely there HAS TO BE SOMETHING that this voice emanates from.

What is it that is telling the story?


Are you in control of what is being told?


If not, what is controlling this voice in the head?


What is it talking to and what is it that is listening?



Often all that we really hear is what IT is talking about! Our "very own hypnotist" that does not exist.


Are you the one that talks or listens?



Are you the owner of the voice?



Are you the thinker of thoughts?



Is the “I” the thinker or is it a thought?



Where is the narrator?




Narrator, hello-o-o! Who’s there? Anyone?


Try This for Yourself

Just for fun, or just because you're curious, ask that voice what it is and see what it says.

Zoom right in the focus on the commentator, and wait for the comments.
Is there a voice that speaks independent of thoughts?




If the voice suddenly shuts up, notice the silence.

This silence is not the absence of an answer.

The message from the silence is simple: there is no one here.

There is nothing fixed or solid there.

Thoughts arise and pass away and happen to no one.

And watch so closely right here .....does the voice just start up again with doubts or trying to explain this away?




Simply keep asking the voice what it is and to show itself.

Do this as many times as you can throughout the day and let me know what happens.




With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Mon May 20, 2024 3:13 am

So, I tried to do this exercise paying attention to how the mind is just another door of perception.
but... I'm totally lost on this one. Maybe I need more work on this part, and then repeat the same exercise again.

sometimes I get the impression that I forget any insight (small or big) that I got. Is that expected? 1 step forward, 4 steps back?
What is it that is telling the story?
a narrator... identification with it, with self.
Are you in control of what is being told?
it looks like I am
If not, what is controlling this voice in the head?
-
What is it talking to and what is it that is listening?
they are the same entity, talking to itself
Are you the one that talks or listens?
both

Are you the owner of the voice?
I strongly feel (believe) that

Are you the thinker of thoughts?
yes

Is the “I” the thinker or is it a thought?
the thinker!

Where is the narrator?
mind says "here"
Just for fun, or just because you're curious, ask that voice what it is and see what it says.

Zoom right in the focus on the commentator, and wait for the comments.
Is there a voice that speaks independent of thoughts?
but I'm the one asking the question.
after the question there's silence. waiting for the answer
And watch so closely right here .....does the voice just start up again with doubts or trying to explain this away?
doesn't try to explain anything. nothing happens. it doesn't need to explain anything because it strongly identifies with ME


Simply keep asking the voice what it is and to show itself.

Do this as many times as you can throughout the day and let me know what happens.
well, I did this several times. same thing happens. nothing (silence)! BUT, there's strong ownership of the voice

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Mon May 20, 2024 9:57 am

So, I tried to do this exercise paying attention to how the mind is just another door of perception.
If I've understood you correctly Nicholas that is fine. Be very careful you don't go through that door as thought can entice you into the chaos of thought. I strongly suggest you SIMPLY do one question at a time by simply LOOKING without anything added or modified

sometimes I get the impression that I forget any insight (small or big) that I got. Is that expected? 1 step forward, 4 steps back?
We can forget - or rather OVERLOOK - the insights. That usually is because the mind will tell us "Oh that's no big deal or that's not important or there has to be a bigger fish"

Every insight is a treasure. I have said before and will say it again THE MOST PROFOUND INSIGHTS CAN BE SO SUBTLE AND SO EASILY OVERLOOKED


We'll work backwards here Nicholas.

And please BE VERY CAREFUL NOT TO ANSWER FROM THE MIND. LOOK DIRECTLY AT WHAT IS HAPPENING AND DESCRIBE THAT

after the question there's silence. waiting for the answer.
Did you command the 'voice' to stop the 'voice' or did the 'voice' cease when you simply put your attention on it?




When the 'voice' started up again did you choose to start it or did it just start?




Did you decide or know what the 'voice' would 'say' when it started up again?





there's strong ownership of the voice
Surely if you are the owner of the 'voice' you would have control of it - you could stop and start it at will and be in control of what it would 'say''?



mind says "here"
You say "mind says" .....Mmmm. Haven't we agreed not to believe the content of any thought?[




Please LOOK AGAIN and tell exactly where this voice arises from WITHOUT GOING TO THE MIND? Can it be found at all?




Is the “I” the thinker or is it a thought?
the thinker!
This is a very definite statement.
Please describe this "I" that you say is the thinker in precise detail





When you LOOK for this 'thinker' do you find anything else other than one thought after another?





Could this phenomena of thought after thought be what is labeled 'thinker' until it is closely investigated and we see there these 'chains' of thought simply appearing?





they are the same entity, talking to itself
You've made another very definite statement here Nicholas but it is not apparent to me how you have substantiated that this is a fact. It is an opinion or speculated conclusion. The word entity is a label. It means "independent, separate, or self-contained existence"
OK Nicholas, you say there is an entity - PLEASE TELL ME ABOUT IT. Forget saying it seems like or there must be something there or the mind says. Look for evidence.
PLEASE TELL ME ABOUT THIS ENTITY YOU SAY IS THERE?



Does it have "independent, separate, or self-contained existence"?




How is this 'voice' any different to any other thought?




Could this that we call a 'voice' - which by its very label can hypnotize us into believing there is actually someTHING speaking - be anything at all other than a thought about a thought about a thought ...on and on and on ...? PLEASE LOOK FOR A FEW TIMES AT WHAT IS ACTUALLY HAPPENING BEFORE YOU ANSWER





Are you the one that talks or listens?
both
Are you actually talking and listening or are you imagining that you are talking and listening?




With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Tue May 21, 2024 3:37 am

(so I started aswering and then went to the final questions and... well, I will include my second answer (a revision) to these questions inside these symbols **. hope it's not troublesome. I want to have both answers)
And please BE VERY CAREFUL NOT TO ANSWER FROM THE MIND. LOOK DIRECTLY AT WHAT IS HAPPENING AND DESCRIBE THAT
I think here's my issue... how do I answer without the mind?
after the question there's silence. waiting for the answer.
Did you command the 'voice' to stop the 'voice' or did the 'voice' cease when you simply put your attention on it?
the voices stops because I'm the one doing it
*I'm under the belief that I'm commanding the voice*
When the 'voice' started up again did you choose to start it or did it just start?
I did
*I believe I'm starting it*

Did you decide or know what the 'voice' would 'say' when it started up again?
I get "echos" of what I'm going to say next.
*ooooooooooh so what I did was just observe the mind and see what happens. the music always there. the wall of thoughts without definition also there. then a thought appeared saying "ok enough" which normally would be "the voice" but for the first time I... saw it as just another thought. so weird*
there's strong ownership of the voice
Surely if you are the owner of the 'voice' you would have control of it - you could stop and start it at will and be in control of what it would 'say''?
I do
*from the previous experiment... this belief lost a few bricks*
mind says "here"
You say "mind says" .....Mmmm. Haven't we agreed not to believe the content of any thought?
yes, but how do I do this without looking at the mind if that's where answers are formed?
*I'm still confused, on this one. can answers be created without thinking?*

Please LOOK AGAIN and tell exactly where this voice arises from WITHOUT GOING TO THE MIND? Can it be found at all?
I spent a good time here and I have no idea how to answer this!
*the voice seems to be just another familiar thought* (another brick fell)
Is the “I” the thinker or is it a thought?
the thinker!
This is a very definite statement.
Please describe this "I" that you say is the thinker in precise detail
The I gives direction to thoughts and directs attention to the 5 senses.
*it's a belief. belief of control, of thinker, of controller of attention, of senser*


When you LOOK for this 'thinker' do you find anything else other than one thought after another?
control
*?*


Could this phenomena of thought after thought be what is labeled 'thinker' until it is closely investigated and we see there these 'chains' of thought simply appearing?
but I can stop those chains. or decide when to continue them.
*yes, it looks like thoughts just appear*
they are the same entity, talking to itself
You've made another very definite statement here Nicholas but it is not apparent to me how you have substantiated that this is a fact. It is an opinion or speculated conclusion. The word entity is a label. It means "independent, separate, or self-contained existence"
OK Nicholas, you say there is an entity - PLEASE TELL ME ABOUT IT. Forget saying it seems like or there must be something there or the mind says. Look for evidence.
PLEASE TELL ME ABOUT THIS ENTITY YOU SAY IS THERE?
ok you got me. there's no entity apparently. only a belief and a sense of control. those give shape to an entity.
(this is the part I did the questions again)

Does it have "independent, separate, or self-contained existence"?
no, it doesn't. but it tricks me, over and over again.


How is this 'voice' any different to any other thought?
again: belief and sense of control. SPECIALLY... sense of control.


Could this that we call a 'voice' - which by its very label can hypnotize us into believing there is actually someTHING speaking - be anything at all other than a thought about a thought about a thought ...on and on and on ...? PLEASE LOOK FOR A FEW TIMES AT WHAT IS ACTUALLY HAPPENING BEFORE YOU ANSWER
it can't be anything else, but then why do I have this strong sense of control? I try to recognize it but it makes no difference.
Are you the one that talks or listens?
both
Are you actually talking and listening or are you imagining that you are talking and listening?
I'm under the belief that I control the talking, the listening... and so.

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Tue May 21, 2024 12:21 pm

I will include my second answer (a revision) to these questions inside these symbols **. hope it's not troublesome
Not troublesome at all Nicholas. It's a good idea

I think here's my issue... how do I answer without the mind?
Of course we use the mind to communicate. There is no other way. What we're doing when you're asked to describe what you see is what is experienced WITHOUT any involvement from the mind.

Remember when you were asked to look at this picture?

Image
It took some time but eventually you saw that pure seeing was seeing only colour. Lines. shapes objects are all interpretations of the mind that is ADDED to direct experience. That's all OVERLAY that builds the illusion. It's stories ABOUT what you are actually seeing.

It's the same principle here. You're asked look for the source of the voice. When you look you draw a blank. No interpretation, no stating what you believe, no assumptions are needed (that's all of the mind.) And that's what you are asked to report - what you see without interpretation, assumption, belief, etc etc. And you've proven you actually know how to do this because you've done it because you report it in this next point.

then a thought appeared saying "ok enough" which normally would be "the voice" but for the first time I... saw it as just another thought. so weird
Time to celebrate. You saw what was happening and you reported that. Your SEEING of the thought did not come from the mind. And yes you turned to the mind to report what you saw but the SEEING itself was not in any way dependent on the mind.
Do you get what I'm meaning here?



The last two words that you report here are critical. You say....
so weird
The word weird is a judgement laden expression. This is nothing but a mind reaction to seeing something differently to what you have believed until now. The meaning of weird is "something that is unnatural, something that induces a sense of disbelief or alienation in someone" Without realizing this by using the word "weird" you are revealing that you resisting the truth of what you saw. You're alienating truth.

You've used this word a number of times when you have actually seen the truth. There will be an energy, a sensation that feels somewhat uncomfortable that induces resistance and strange to say even fear. It can be so subtle but it's there because you've seen something that challenges what you have considered unquestionable truth.

As long as you believe this is weird you are making things very difficult for your self. It is n example of the way language conditions us.
Do you see that Nicholas?




I would encourage you to see what you are labeling "weird" as "different" and then get really curious about this that seems different. This opens the door to deeper and deeper discovery

I do notice a subtle but very real difference in the tone of your reporting what you experienced the second time through on the points where you have an asterisk. On the second time through you said a "couple of bricks fell" I can feel a more authentic looking. Keep going with that authentic looking Nicholas.

Also you say a number of times the belief that is still there. Belief is simply a thought about another thought that we give unquestioned substantiality to. This is where the rubber hits the road.

Every time you realize a belief is coming into play IT HAS TO BE INVESTIGATED. IF you simply say "oh there is a belief again" and move on without challenging it you are alienating honest seeing.

And finally you speak of this issue of control. You say you still believe you are in control.

This exercise is for going to bed and for the morning when you are 'deciding' to get out of bed.

This requires VERY HONEST LOOKING.

First of all when you go to bed as you get into bed. ....
Is there an ENTITY ( Remember an entity means "independent, separate, or self-contained existence") deciding the precise moment that you will get into bed or does an urge just arise and getting into bed just happens?




Is conscious thought control required for each and every step of preparing for bed or does the getting ready for bed just happen?



When you get into bed does an ENTITY consciously choose your sleeping position or does it come about naturally because of habit or the body making itself comfortable?




In the moment of getting into bed where does the decision of sleeping position come from?




Is there an entity deciding the precise moment that you go to sleep?





During the night
If you dream did you decide when to dream and what to dream about?



If you wake in the night did you wake at a time a controller decided?





Getting up in the morning
Where does the decision for you to wake up in the morning?


Can a decision maker be found making the body leave the bed?




Where does the ‘decision’, the ‘command’ to get up come from?




What makes the body get up, is there a specific entity called ‘you’, or a decider that commands the body?




When lying there, shout 'GET UP' internally as loudly as you can. Does that affect the outcome?




How does the decision happen?




Does a decider come in and take over, weighing pros and cons, looking at possible consequences?




Or does getting up just happen, or not?




As you watch thoughts here very CAREFULLY are they controlling EXACTLY what you are doing moment to moment or are they simply commentating on what's happening?




Where is something that we can label "controller" in any of this?




If you've found it. please describe it in detail




With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Wed May 22, 2024 6:09 pm

Time to celebrate. You saw what was happening and you reported that. Your SEEING of the thought did not come from the mind. And yes you turned to the mind to report what you saw but the SEEING itself was not in any way dependent on the mind.
Do you get what I'm meaning here?
yes, it's tricky though
As long as you believe this is weird you are making things very difficult for your self. It is n example of the way language conditions us.
Do you see that Nicholas?
ok, I see
First of all when you go to bed as you get into bed. ....
Is there an ENTITY ( Remember an entity means "independent, separate, or self-contained existence") deciding the precise moment that you will get into bed or does an urge just arise and getting into bed just happens?
no entity necesary. it's more like a set of conditions. time + things that need to be done at night + some delays


Is conscious thought control required for each and every step of preparing for bed or does the getting ready for bed just happen?
it just happens
When you get into bed does an ENTITY consciously choose your sleeping position or does it come about naturally because of habit or the body making itself comfortable?
it comes based on certain past conditions. the initial position has been the same for the last months. after that... it's looking for a comfortable position.


In the moment of getting into bed where does the decision of sleeping position come from?
habit


Is there an entity deciding the precise moment that you go to sleep?
no, it's based on conditions/triggers

During the night
If you dream did you decide when to dream and what to dream about?
ah that's impossible!

If you wake in the night did you wake at a time a controller decided?
no, of course not.
Getting up in the morning
Where does the decision for you to wake up in the morning?
it's based on time mostly, triggers,conditions...
Can a decision maker be found making the body leave the bed?
I don't know. it seems so. but I have no evidence.


Where does the ‘decision’, the ‘command’ to get up come from?
when... the body or mind are ready


What makes the body get up, is there a specific entity called ‘you’, or a decider that commands the body?
even if I wanted to command the body to wake up, I can't do that. it has a ..."mind " of its own

When lying there, shout 'GET UP' internally as loudly as you can. Does that affect the outcome?
ah yes, haha, makes no difference.


How does the decision happen?
when the body seems ready. or mind wants to get up.


Does a decider come in and take over, weighing pros and cons, looking at possible consequences?
mmmhm the mind does a bit of weighing but I don't know if a decider is necessary for that


Or does getting up just happen, or not?
apparently it just happens


As you watch thoughts here very CAREFULLY are they controlling EXACTLY what you are doing moment to moment or are they simply commentating on what's happening?
wait a second... that makes no sense. a thought can't control the body. so... maybe they are just commentating!

Where is something that we can label "controller" in any of this?
If there's a controller or not, does it make any difference? the body just ends doing whatever it wants. I try to steer the direction but if the body/mind doesn't want to wake up... it won't. until its ready. some things apparently I control, some not. but then where's the controller? or maybe I'm not controlling anything.


If you've found it. please describe it in detail
Maybe actions just happen. if they are what I want then I claim control. if they are things I don't want... then I claim lack of control. maybe it's just the mind saying "I did that" "that I did not".

so it seems to be action -> comment of the mind.

it seems

eventually I will be able to fully see it

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Thu May 23, 2024 11:31 am

You know Nicholas what you say here really captures what is being pointed to
no entity necesary. it's more like a set of conditions. time + things that need to be done at night + some delays
Life unfolds according to prevailing conditions. It seems as though the sense of making a choice in any given moment determines what will happen however as you are seeing there is no entity that is making a specific decision right in this moment. The convergence of infinite conditions manifest as the happening of this moment.

Now you say ......
no entity is necesary
Not only is it not necessary but RIGHT NOW AS YOU LOOK does it even exist?



if they are what I want then I claim control. if they are things I don't want... then I claim lack of control
This is what the "me" does alright. It claims. It claims in such a way that we identify with what it claims. And the way it happens is the "me" thought is interwoven in the stream of thought so pervasively and so insidiously that it becomes the default way of navigating life.

If there's a controller or not, does it make any difference?
In one sense I get what you mean when you say "does it make any difference?"
However it does make a life changing difference because in truth if someone is hypnotized by the belief that there is a controller then the attempt to control will be pursued leading to on-going suffering.
This feeling that there is a controller comes about through one thing. And that is the "me" is continually saying "NO NO NO" to what already is. This pushing back, this resistance that happens so fast and so unconsciously gives the FALSE SENSE of feeling we can have control. How can anything that already IS be prevented from happening?
Does this resonate in any way as you feel into experience?




Do you see the futility of this pushing against what already is?





eventually I will be able to fully see it
This typically happens through realization after (often subtle) realization. As you said in a previous post "another brick has fallen !!" Each realization no matter how insignificant it appears to the mind is the falling of another brick. Some report this can "sneak" up on them. That is why I continually encourage you not to discount ANY realization. Each "Ah ha" helps in this dismantling process. We never know which brick will precipitate a collapse of a lot of bricks in one go.

And please bear in mind that when it becomes obvious that the "me" is a non-existent entity this sense of "me" typically will still be doing its thing on subtler and sutler levels. This is seen in that reactions will likely still happen however once we have seen that the "me" is a mental construct then when reactions do happen we are now conscious of what is happening and catch it before it happens or as it is happening and as a result they then no longer have the hold on us that they once had. Seeing truth is a never ending adventure !!

We'll come back to this voice in the head once more before we move on.

So let’s investigate this illusory inner voice a little further.

(What if you do what you did with the first part of this exercise where you did a second pass and used an asterisk to denote the second time through?)

Now LOOK REALLY, REALLY CLOSELY. When we say that we hear this “voice in the head”
Is this voice anything else other than a stream of arising and disappearing thoughts?



What tells you that thoughts have a voice?



Can thoughts actually speak?



Does this voice actually have a sound?



Have you ever actually heard your thoughts?



Is that voice your voice? If not what does it belong to?



Where precisely is that voice coming from?



What relationship does this “I /ME” that we have for so long claimed to exist, have with this voice?



Have you ever been able to retain / record those "voice thoughts" as they spontaneously arise and then play them back in that exact order again to hear them?



Just like mental images, are those voice thoughts actual words or just thoughts about words?




Sometimes you hear a song on the radio on your way to work or while you are cooking or doing something, and that song can stay with you all day. The song seems to play over and over again. All the intricate details are there. All the lyrics, all the notes in the guitar solo are as clear as when it was playing out of the car speakers.

Or as you have described already Nicholas this music for you, is a constant phenomenon that continues without ceasing
But is there really music playing, someone singing, someone playing an instrument?



Or are there just thoughts about ‘sounds’ and ‘sounds’ that appear as thoughts?



Are these ‘sounds’ AE of sound or AE of thought?





With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Fri May 24, 2024 3:53 am

no entity is necesary
Not only is it not necessary but RIGHT NOW AS YOU LOOK does it even exist?
I don't know how or where to look right now. it exists in my mind. it is still real.
Does this resonate in any way as you feel into experience?
feels more like a "I don't understand whatever is happening here" haha. like "how come there is not a ME? I'm right here my friend!!!"... but hey those are only thoughts. but they do have a ... scent... a... heaviness?

Do you see the futility of this pushing against what already is?
I don't even know how I am pushing. of course it is futile... but... who's resisting? if there's nobody who the hell (pardon my language, it's directed to me hehe) is resisting? thoughts? more thoughts? they cannot resist, how does even a thought resist...?
Some report this can "sneak" up on them. That is why I continually encourage you not to discount ANY realization
mmhm maybe I should go back reread everything and take note of each realization. what do you think? maybe I'll do it
(What if you do what you did with the first part of this exercise where you did a second pass and used an asterisk to denote the second time through?)
ok, I will have it in mind for this exercise. HOWEVER, that will only be possible if I actually get some realization while doing the questions, I don't know if that will happen!
Now LOOK REALLY, REALLY CLOSELY. When we say that we hear this “voice in the head”
Is this voice anything else other than a stream of arising and disappearing thoughts?
it's a stream of thoughts but they do have a special quality

What tells you that thoughts have a voice?
more thoughts! ha
(thoughts don't have a voice, some are thoughts with the SOUND on my MIND of my voice)

Can thoughts actually speak?
I'm having trouble answering this one, so I'm going to go at it even knowing that is wrong but don't know why. thoughts can do everything. speak, sing, show images, music...

oh but you said voice thoughts. well, speaking is a function of the body. thoughts cannot speak.

Does this voice actually have a sound?
only on my mind, not out there

Have you ever actually heard your thoughts?
only on my mind, not out there.

Is that voice your voice? If not what does it belong to?
my voice

Where precisely is that voice coming from?
mind

What relationship does this “I /ME” that we have for so long claimed to exist, have with this voice?
well, is the voice that this body produces. but I'm not the body. ah confusing.
Have you ever been able to retain / record those "voice thoughts" as they spontaneously arise and then play them back in that exact order again to hear them?
not really

Just like mental images, are those voice thoughts actual words or just thoughts about words?
ok, took me some time. just thoughts about words.
Or as you have described already Nicholas this music for you, is a constant phenomenon that continues without ceasing
But is there really music playing, someone singing, someone playing an instrument?
it's... only a long long long thought.

Or are there just thoughts about ‘sounds’ and ‘sounds’ that appear as thoughts?
it appears as one big continuous thought. so it would be... music that appears as thought.

Are these ‘sounds’ AE of sound or AE of thought?
DE of thought!

(no realization, so no second revision)

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Fri May 24, 2024 1:01 pm

Hi Nicholas,

I don't know how or where to look right now
It is the mind's job to objectify reality. The mind says "There HAS to be someTHING here"
Could it be that when you LOOK and can't find what you think is there that the mind, rather than admitting there is no object to find, resorts to saying "I don't know how or where to look right now?"



it exists in my mind. it is still real.
What do you mean by real?




Is that any more than a thought?




Is a mirage real?




We can see a mirage but do we say it is REAL?




We see a mirage and do we believe what it seems to be (water) to be true?




Are shadows real?




When a shadow appears as someTHING in our minds (say a wild animal that terrifies us) what is "real" here? The shadow or the wild animal that our mind has interpreted?





So at this point we will give ourselves this concession that thoughts are "real" but their contents are not. While we believe they faithfully reflect - or more often than not we believe THEY ARE - reality they never can. Why? Because thoughts are concepts, they are abstractions of reality. The contents only take on a "realness" sense when they are believed. Any thought believed is imagination and in no way can define reality.

Consider this. Let's say that I watch multiple documentaries on Argentina, I could immerse myself in all sorts of facts and information about Argentina
but would I know the reality of having experienced Argentina?




feels more like a "I don't understand whatever is happening here" haha. like "how come there is not a ME? I'm right here my friend!!!"... but hey those are only thoughts. but they do have a ... scent... a... heaviness?
We get so lost in our minds that it does seem real. Coming back to Argentina, I could get to know more (conceptually) about Argentina that many Argentinians but still not know the reality of Argentina

In fact in spite of not having not been to Argentina I could actually beat you in a quiz about Argentina to the point where someone would not even realize I had not been there. My descriptions could seem so real, so vivid to an Argentinian that it would not even cross their mind that I had not been there.
Can you see how this mind capacity can create such a false sense of reality?



if there's nobody who the hell (pardon my language, it's directed to me hehe) is resisting? thoughts? more thoughts? they cannot resist, how does even a thought resist...?
Thoughts do not resist. It's our BELIEF in thought that creates what we call resistance.
Do shadows scare?




Or is it what we BELIEVE ABOUT a shadow that creates the fear?





Thoughts in and of themselves are benign, are powerless UNTIL we give them juice by believing them

mmhm maybe I should go back reread everything and take note of each realization. what do you think? maybe I'll do it
This has come to me in the last couple of days as well. Interesting that it has come to you as well. It is often a very useful useful step and I suggest you go with it.

I suggest you take your time and report on any insights that come and any clarification you need about DIRECT EXPERIENCE.

There will be a huge temptation for the mind to say "Oh I've done this before and I know the ANSWERS etc etc"
DO THE BEST YOU CAN TO APPROACH EACH EXERCISE and ALL THAT HAS BEEN COVERED AS THOUGH YOU HAD NEVER SEEN IT BEFORE.

Be REALLY CURIOUS to allow something FRESH to show itself.

WATCH FOR HOW THOUGHTS take you out of DE

Take your time. PLEASE DON'T RUSH IT. Best to really let yourself sink into this over a few days.

Please report each day and
+ note any differences compared to the first time through
+ note any insights that arise
+ note any emotions that arise

Are you OK with that approach?




With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Sat May 25, 2024 4:20 am

I don't know how or where to look right now
It is the mind's job to objectify reality. The mind says "There HAS to be someTHING here"
Could it be that when you LOOK and can't find what you think is there that the mind, rather than admitting there is no object to find, resorts to saying "I don't know how or where to look right now?"
maybe... there is a habit. a "let's act like there's an entity here". a belief.
it exists in my mind. it is still real.
What do you mean by real?
AH! I know I shouldn't have said that! I looked at that sentence and thought... "you know this doesn't make any sense, you know this is a contradiction" but still left it!

that's a good question. what is real? I guess we consider real what comes from the 5 senses + thoughts but not content. am I right? asking sincerely, maybe I got it wrong.
Is that any more than a thought?
it can't be real, it is still content of thoughts. beliefs.

Is a mirage real?
no!


We can see a mirage but do we say it is REAL?
nop


We see a mirage and do we believe what it seems to be (water) to be true?
we do, for a moment


Are shadows real?
I don't know


When a shadow appears as someTHING in our minds (say a wild animal that terrifies us) what is "real" here? The shadow or the wild animal that our mind has interpreted?
the wild animal
Consider this. Let's say that I watch multiple documentaries on Argentina, I could immerse myself in all sorts of facts and information about Argentina
but would I know the reality of having experienced Argentina?
no
In fact in spite of not having not been to Argentina I could actually beat you in a quiz about Argentina to the point where someone would not even realize I had not been there. My descriptions could seem so real, so vivid to an Argentinian that it would not even cross their mind that I had not been there.
Can you see how this mind capacity can create such a false sense of reality?
yes
Thoughts do not resist. It's our BELIEF in thought that creates what we call resistance.
Do shadows scare?
well... yes. they can scare you

I have a question here... what is a belief? thoughts about thoughts?

Or is it what we BELIEVE ABOUT a shadow that creates the fear?
ah! you are right. yes. a shadow is just a thing out there.
Are you OK with that approach?
my plan was to just take note of past insights. BUT I also thought about redoing all the exercises again (like you recommend)

so... first thing I'm going to do tomorrow is to take note of all insights and paste them here... THEN I will do a redo and see what comes up and report each day!

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Sat May 25, 2024 12:10 pm

Hi Nicholas,

maybe... there is a habit. a "let's act like there's an entity here". a belief.
Two things you say here are true.
Yes, it is a habit - a conditioned behaviour
and
there is an act(or) here - a fictional character

it exists in my mind. it is still real.
What do you mean by real?
AH! I know I shouldn't have said that!
Good to have the uncensored first reaction Nicholas 😊

that's a good question. what is real? I guess we consider real what comes from the 5 senses + thoughts but not content. am I right? asking sincerely, maybe I got it wrong.
We will stray into concepts here a little but your question deserves a response.
In a sense the word "real" depends on context.
Ultimately that which is real is beyond or prior to thought. That which you truly are. That which never comes and never goes.
Do you know what this is pointing too?




Then as you say ....."we consider real what comes from the 5 senses + thoughts but not content."
Yes. That's right. This is that which appears in that which never comes and never goes. At the level of what we might call experience.

Then in the relative world that we live in "objects" appear real. That is we believe they are real until we are prepared to investigate all this as you are Nicholas.
It's a little like layers of an onion. One level appears real until we see it's not. Then the the next layer and so on.

So to find what is true we "peel back the layers" so to speak. One of the most direct ways to do this is through the sorts of inquiries we do here. This is a very rudimentary description which I trust doesn't confuse.

So right now for the purposes of our investigation what you point to as being the uninterpreted 6 sense fields are real.


Now moving on ...
When a shadow appears as someTHING in our minds (say a wild animal that terrifies us) what is "real" here? The shadow or the wild animal that our mind has interpreted?
the wild animal
Take another look at this in the context of what we have just said about what is "real" Is the wild animal that is an interpretation of the mind actually real? No. What we call the shadow is real (color) but the interpretation of it being a wild animal is not real.
Do you see that?



I have a question here... what is a belief? thoughts about thoughts?
You've got it Nicholas. Thoughts about thoughts .....on and on. That is the "fabric" of the illusion.

so... first thing I'm going to do tomorrow is to take note of all insights and paste them here... THEN I will do a redo and see what comes up and report each day!
As you come to each step just do your best to come from a "place" of "I (the mind) don't know" Be as faithful to direct experience as you can.

Looking forward to it Nicholas !



With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Sun May 26, 2024 3:48 am

Ultimately that which is real is beyond or prior to thought. That which you truly are. That which never comes and never goes.
Do you know what this is pointing too?
(meant pointing to?)

eemm... I'm not really sure. how can I be something if I don't exist?
Take another look at this in the context of what we have just said about what is "real" Is the wild animal that is an interpretation of the mind actually real? No. What we call the shadow is real (color) but the interpretation of it being a wild animal is not real.
Do you see that?
I think so, a shadow is a shadow. color.

now this is the insight I collected so far. this is insight that has "evolved" or stayed with me

+ First thing I realized is the first few times it took me longer to answer the questions.
+ at the beginning a lot of confusion, but that was a good sign
+ there are no objects out there, it's just one big image (it's actually just seeing color)
+ color = seeing, no color = no seeing (applies to every sense, but now I know that senses are always working. seeing is always happening, same with hearing, feeling and so)
+ paying attention to intuition
+ thoughts come from and go to nowhere
+ week ago (still trying to question some of your questions haha, but that stopped happening!)
+ weeks ago (still using the mind to answer some questions! haha I look at some of my answer and smile. just 40 days ago still rambled haha.)
+ using "I" when labeling feels more personal, but also heaviness!
+ using "I,me"... it's totally automatic
+ admitting to a belief of a controller in the head
+ the "I" is not a feeling but an idea (a belief)
+ when feeling there's only sensations
+ memory are just thoughts
+ thoughts are DE, but not content! for example, seeing and labeling an apple.
+ it's only what comes from 6 doors. then the mind labels.
+ there's no entity, only belief in entity and belief in control (that means... thoughts about thoughts!)
+ the narrator is just thoughts arising but a common, familiar one.
+ the "me" likes to claim control or lack of it depending on how things go

next... let's see if we are on the same page. the plan is to go through previous questions all over again and answer them? is that right?

by the way... today I had 2 small insights...
I took a thc microdose and went on a walk.
my mind always goes to LU and the work we are doing here... so it started generating thoughts about that.

the significant one was that... I found that THERE IS RESISTANCE! and it's FEAR!

for a moment I had this "opportunity" to SEE that I don't control any thought and they just arise. it was brief... and I did not want to see it! It made me afraid, I said to myself "nono, I'm not ready yet"

HAHAHAHA wondering what that could be?! take note of it and we will have to dissect it sometime.

but then later when eating I had this "impression" this "thought" that I'm actually not controlling anything, not even my thoughts or voice. I mean, I actually saw it for a brief moment (seems that I forgot about the fear thing and didn't realize hahaha).

and I have to tell you... if I focus.. seems that I'm able to see again, and to "feel it" in my mind.

(I was about to tell "so weird" but then I remembered. so let's say... I guess this is "liberating"? but oooh I feel some fear too...! maybe to the unknown)

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Sun May 26, 2024 12:11 pm

(meant pointing to?)
Yes you're right Nicholas

eemm... I'm not really sure. how can I be something if I don't exist?
It's hard to describe the indescribable however we do out best.
Continue to LOOK and FEEL into that which is prior to and beyond thought, that in which thought rises and disappears.


Loved the your insights.
Is there any that are 'standouts' for you?




by the way... today I had 2 small insights...
Not sure they were just 'small' !!

the significant one was that... I found that THERE IS RESISTANCE! and it's FEAR!
Interesting !! I sit up a little straighter when someone experiences this.!

This is not unusual at all as the digging starts to expose the "me" for what it is. It is good news.

When we really look we find that fear is an emotion with two main components.
Sensation + a story.

The key is to recognize the story (thoughts about thoughts) and do your best to just leave the story to one side. The important thing here is to feel into the sensation with a GENUINE CURIOSITY.

No need to push it. If the fear ramps up again just pull back a little - even take a break and come back to it when you feel a little more settled - but do your best to still be CURIOUS. This is the absolute key. WARM CURIOSITY. With CLEAR SEEING AND FEELING the fear will start to 'resolve' itself

Then you say .....
but then later when eating I had this "impression" this "thought" that I'm actually not controlling anything, not even my thoughts or voice. I mean, I actually saw it for a brief moment (seems that I forgot about the fear thing and didn't realize hahaha).
Sounds like clearly seeing for a moment - that's really good Nicholas

I guess this is "liberating"? but oooh I feel some fear too...! maybe to the unknown
Feeling into the unknown (that which is beyond thought) can evoke fear. Totally understandable. It can come and go and simply going with the flow of it is the best way.

It really sounds like a very good move to go through the exercises again with this sense of the unknown starting to become more apparent.

Nothing out of the ordinary in what you report in all this Nicholas. I have given you the summary of the core approach of how to navigate it which typically can take care of it however there are other means that we can introduce to help if you feel it is necessary. If you do find that fear is becoming a distraction or becoming to much of a challenge PLEASE LET ME KNOW.

So just to reiterate this is not out of the ordinary at all, it is not a sign of 'failure' in any sense rather it shows that your inquiring is hitting the mark.

next... let's see if we are on the same page. the plan is to go through previous questions all over again and answer them? is that right?
Yes that's right. Go through the previous questions and answer them. Let me copy and paste what we covered in a post about this two or three days ago. See how this works for you Nicholas and we can adjust as we go,

"I suggest you take your time and report on any insights that come and any clarification you need about DIRECT EXPERIENCE.

There will be a huge temptation for the mind to say "Oh I've done this before and I know the ANSWERS etc etc"
DO THE BEST YOU CAN TO APPROACH EACH EXERCISE and ALL THAT HAS BEEN COVERED AS THOUGH YOU HAD NEVER SEEN IT BEFORE.

Be REALLY CURIOUS to allow something FRESH to show itself.

WATCH FOR HOW THOUGHTS take you out of DE

Take your time. PLEASE DON'T RUSH IT. Best to really let yourself sink into this over a few days.

Please report each day and
+ note any differences compared to the first time through
+ note any insights that arise
+ note any emotions that arise"


Looking forward to seeing what is discovered Nicholas



With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Mon May 27, 2024 3:18 am

Is there any that are 'standouts' for you?
+ the "I" is not a feeling but an idea (a belief)
+ when feeling there's only sensations
+ thoughts are DE, but not content! for example, seeing and labeling an apple.
+ it's only what comes from 6 doors. then the mind labels.

let's go to the questions! I will let you know if I find fear again!
Can you tell me what you mean when you use the word "predetermined?"
you know what? I actually don't know what exactly "predetermined" means. I should look it up but I won't (don't want to add unnecessary thought)
as a result of embarking on this investigation here at LU do you have any particular expectations about...
How this investigation might / could / should unfold?
doesn't matter, it will unfold however it has to. expectations are just thoughts.

How life will change?
who knows. maybe nothing changes, maybe something changes, maybe everything changes.

How your experience might compare to others?
I can say that so far... seems that I'm on the slower side. from what I seen... takes 1-2 months to "get it". seems that it might take me... 6 months? more? but then, is that bad or good? because all of these are expectations/beliefs. these are thoughts... and more thoughts.

Something you are expecting / want to happen that will convince you that you are "awake"?
It's not that I'm expecting something to happen. I don't know what to expect, the only thing that will happen is that when the moment comes... it will be clear.
And one more thing for today. Let the following statement really sink in.

There is no separate self, never has been and never will be. That there is, is all just a made up story, a figment of the imagination.

What reactions - from none to subtle to strong - come up when you read that statement in red?
of course it's a story! a belief, maybe a set of beliefs??. I admit that I don't see it FULLY but I see its outline.

---

compared to before, I notice:
+ I recognize expectations/beliefs/thoughts
+ some answers are more or less the same, but I'm more succint
+ less blahblah (less thinking)
+ the last one is the most obvious. there's a stark difference there.

also, there will be cases where I won't be able to answer some questions because they were based on previous responses that now I'm not doing! (like, I say "it's an illusion" then you tell me to describe that illusion... but this time I didn't write that so...!)

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Mon May 27, 2024 2:03 pm

Hello Nicholas

Thank you for the standouts !

let's go to the questions! I will let you know if I find fear again!
Good !! Do let me know.

seems that I'm on the slower side. from what I seen... takes 1-2 months to "get it". seems that it might take me... 6 months? more? but then, is that bad or good? because all of these are expectations/beliefs. these are thoughts... and more thoughts.
As you say "all of these are expectations/beliefs. these are thoughts... and more thoughts."The unfolding takes care of it all and there is no slower or faster. The comparing mind finds that a hard pill to swallow. The truth is as you say next.
doesn't matter, it will unfold however it has to. expectations are just thoughts.


compared to before, I notice:
+ I recognize expectations/beliefs/thoughts
+ some answers are more or less the same, but I'm more succint
+ less blahblah (less thinking)
+ the last one is the most obvious. there's a stark difference there.
This noticing - especially of expectations/beliefs/thoughts - will stand you in good stead Nicholas


also, there will be cases where I won't be able to answer some questions because they were based on previous responses that now I'm not doing!
Very true !😊


Looking forward to the next post !!


With love



Alan


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests