Stream Entry

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Thu Apr 25, 2024 9:04 pm

In step 1 when thinking about their respective qualities, did you ‘choose’ the qualities? Or did they kind of appear by themselves? If some preferences manifested, did you ‘choose’ these preferences? Or did they just pop up by themselves?
I don’t think I have chosen the qualities… they were already there. I’m not sure when they were created.

yeah they pop up by themselves.
In step 2 when you counted to 5, if the preferences took the back seat while the numbers took the front seat, did you ‘choose’ this sequence of event? Did you ‘choose’ to shut down the preferences to give way to the counting?
those are functions of the mind, done automatically. no need to choose.

In step 3 where you made a choice, did you actually witness or directly experience a mental function or faculty doing the ‘choosing’? Did anything arise that announced, ‘I am the chooser’? If so, what does this function look like?
In order to choose there was monologue. that would be the chooser. Also most of the choosing was made on step 1.
Sometimes we describe this sense of choosing as a ‘feeling’: It feels like ‘I’ did the 'choosing’. But the question is, can a feeling ‘choose’? Is it in the nature of a feeling to 'choose’?
It feels like being in a stream of water, I’m not sure how I’m choosing. Something tells me I’m doing/choosing/thinking but that’s the stream. And I don’t know how to step out of it or how to actually recognize that I’m in a stream.

Is there anything in particular that is realized after having done this exercise?
With each exercise, instead of gaining clarity… I feel like I know less and less. I’m not sure of anything. Things that I assumed true but I cannot explain why are true. Maybe that’s normal?

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Fri Apr 26, 2024 1:36 pm

With each exercise, instead of gaining clarity… I feel like I know less and less. I’m not sure of anything. Things that I assumed true but I cannot explain why are true. Maybe that’s normal?
This is very encouraging Nicholas !! This is a good place to be.

When we end up truly willing to "not know" experience "shifts" Old beliefs are being challenged and seen through. We begin to realize that what we thought was true and depended on are actually opinions, assumptions, ideas and concepts ABOUT what's actually true. If we continue to deny what is or resist what is. then suffering persists. Peace comes with acceptance of what is.

As you recognize the knowing less and less that is happening, does it come with more of a willingness to let go or is there more of a tightness or anxiety felt?




Let's now take this exercise. Take a cup for instance. Grab one and hold it in your hand.

Let your gaze settle on it. Let your attention be thoroughly absorbed by the colors. Do your best to avoid labeling in any way. Just let the tones, the complexities, the subtleness of the colors be SEEN for what they are.
What happens in this experiencing?



Can what is seen be in any way accurately described so that someone listening or reading would know EXACTLY what you are experiencing?



As you are looking at the cup, notice its features. As you look at it notice what is happening in your experience.
Are there thoughts labeling what you see? A handle perhaps, the lip, the shape of it?



Is there any distinction between seeing, looking and noticing for you? What happens attention ......When seeing? When looking? When noticing?



Can you find some specific thing that we can call a "me" doing the seeing?



Watch thoughts as you consider who is seeing. Notice what happens to seeing as you consider this. Did the seeing change in any way or stop?



Now simply watch thoughts as you look at the cup.
After a while of watching thoughts, what happens to them?




As you watch the thoughts does the experience of seeing the cup change in any way?





Now look for spaces between thoughts.
Focus on seeing in the spaces. They may be milliseconds, but notice them.
What happens in your experience as you attend to the spaces?




As this seeing is happening, ask yourself "Is there a seer or a seen within or without the seeing?"




Or is there only seeing?




When you finish seeing, do you then recognize that which we call a cup is a concept? A cup that has uses and takes up space, and need washing after use? A concept that includes shape, form, color, what it is intended to be used for………...but we aren't actually seeing it anymore. We look at it but recognize a vessel to contain something.

The "details" are all still there but are now typically veiled by our thoughts ABOUT the cup.

Now do this with a flower (or any other object) and see what is experienced. Let me know what stands out for you.



Giving yourself time to really LOOK and FEEL into these questions is so important.

No need to rush. Just let me know if you need more time.

And as we continue please challenge anything that you feel is not clear in my responses.



With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Sat Apr 27, 2024 2:54 am

Hey, just did the first half! tomorrow will do second half and answer.

talk tomorrow

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Sat Apr 27, 2024 5:31 am

😊 😊 😊

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Sun Apr 28, 2024 2:07 am

As you recognize the knowing less and less that is happening, does it come with more of a willingness to let go or is there more of a tightness or anxiety felt?
no tightness. not sure if anxiety. I feel… lost, insecure. I feel like I’m getting little bits of truth but I feel they lack depth for me, like I don’t get the true depth of each one.
Let's now take this exercise. Take a cup for instance. Grab one and hold it in your hand.

Let your gaze settle on it. Let your attention be thoroughly absorbed by the colors. Do your best to avoid labeling in any way. Just let the tones, the complexities, the subtleness of the colors be SEEN for what they are.
What happens in this experiencing?
I notice details
Can what is seen be in any way accurately described so that someone listening or reading would know EXACTLY what you are experiencing?
no, never

As you are looking at the cup, notice its features. As you look at it notice what is happening in your experience.
Are there thoughts labeling what you see? A handle perhaps, the lip, the shape of it?
this is what happens: there’s music in my head, and without using monologue or thoughts, my mind just notices different things in the cup: cracks, marks, there’s no handle, it isn’t a perfect cup.

is this labeling? labeling without thinking?

Is there any distinction between seeing, looking and noticing for you? What happens attention ......When seeing? When looking? When noticing?
seeing = my attention takes things as a whole, not focusing on anything in particular
looking = attention focuses on object
noticing = while looking at object, mind looks for details

Can you find some specific thing that we can call a "me" doing the seeing?
there’s this feeling that I’m controlling this body, choosing where to see, where to look, monologuing, this owner that owns this body.
Watch thoughts as you consider who is seeing. Notice what happens to seeing as you consider this. Did the seeing change in any way or stop?
well… yes, seeing stops, I’m listening to thoughts now.
Now simply watch thoughts as you look at the cup.
After a while of watching thoughts, what happens to them?
music goes on forever. monologue talks about this question, asking and wondering what should happen. that’s it.


As you watch the thoughts does the experience of seeing the cup change in any way?
I’m splitting my attention


Now look for spaces between thoughts.
Focus on seeing in the spaces. They may be milliseconds, but notice them.
What happens in your experience as you attend to the spaces?
other than small silence (but I have to admit that I have to force it a bit, remember: music NEVER stops) I don’t notice anything


As this seeing is happening, ask yourself "Is there a seer or a seen within or without the seeing?"
there’s always the sense of a seer, the subject that is trying to see the truth.


Or is there only seeing?
nop

When you finish seeing, do you then recognize that which we call a cup is a concept? A cup that has uses and takes up space, and need washing after use? A concept that includes shape, form, color, what it is intended to be used for………...but we aren't actually seeing it anymore. We look at it but recognize a vessel to contain something.

The "details" are all still there but are now typically veiled by our thoughts ABOUT the cup.
From my answers it seems I didn’t see this. What do you think?
Now do this with a flower (or any other object) and see what is experienced. Let me know what stands out for you.
I’m doing this with a card (two of clubs)
the colors stand out
shapes, the number 2
it’s dirty, used
music on my mind
thoughts about this exercise

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Sun Apr 28, 2024 9:44 am

Hi Nicholas
I feel… lost, insecure. I feel like I’m getting little bits of truth but I feel they lack depth for me, like I don’t get the true depth of each one.
This feeling you describe is not unusual in this sort of investigation. We find we can no longer look with confidence at what we - up till now - had taken to be true but now are not yet sure what can be depended upon . Finding what is not true is as important as finding what is true. As we remain intent on finding what is true, falsehood falls away and little by little what is true reveals itself and deepens and we find we can depend on it.

Right now this feeling is so understandable. At the start you highlighted earlier in the thread that ......
I also wanted to tell you, I'm the type of person that analyses everything. I'm a brain type, a cerebral type, everything is meticulously planned and thought.

That's why I always resort to trying to understand things with my mind.
When what we depend on is no longer able to do what we expect of it then we find ourselves in "uncharted" territory.

So in that context rest assured that what you describe is very much par for the course, so to speak.

my mind just notices different things in the cup: cracks, marks, there’s no handle, it isn’t a perfect cup.
is this labeling? labeling without thinking?
Yes, it is labeling. Two things are going on here. There is PURE SEEING which is never not happening and then an "overlay" of labeling (conceptualization) happens so quickly that we don't even notice it. When you look at what you have described notice how you did not mention color at all? Yet that is actually what is seen. What you did notice - cracks, marks, there’s no handle, it isn’t a perfect cup - are all interpretations of the colors we have learned. Labeling is a way to condense our experience to communicate. Labels (in all their forms) are the building blocks of the internal monologue. It's with labels that we communicate with each other. And it's through the lens of labels / concepts / thoughts that most of as humans live life.


Now let me reiterate - we are not trying to get rid of labeling but see that it is happening and see how it impacts experience.

seeing = my attention takes things as a whole, not focusing on anything in particular
Perfect !

looking = attention focuses on object
Yes !
And in doing so what is not focused on tends to become "insignificant" to the mind.

noticing = while looking at object, mind looks for details
That's a good way to describe it. And also when we notice something in the seeing that attracts our attention, that can lead us to focus on it

there’s this feeling that I’m controlling this body, choosing where to see, where to look, monologuing, this owner that owns this body.
Let's have a closer look at "this feeling." Feel into the feeling.....
Are YOU this feeling? Or another way to put it.... is this feeling YOU?



Are you in this feeling?



Are you outside this feeling?



How would you describe what it is that is feeling this feeling?




well… yes, seeing stops, I’m listening to thoughts now.
Just look again. Listen to thoughts again. And check......
Has seeing actually stopped?




Or - going back to what we looked at earlier - is because you are FOCUSED on thought that seeing is not, at this moment, prominent?




there’s always the sense of a seer, the subject that is trying to see the truth.
OK take a look again......
As you attend to seeing.....focus on any object "out there"
Keeping your eyes open, slowly move your attention from the object to where this seer seems to be.
Is there anywhere in this movement of attention that SEEING is interrupted in any way?




Is there a boundary that attention has to navigate?




Is there any gaps that attention has to cross?




Is there a specific point where your attention arrives which could be called the seer?




Or is there only seeing?
nop
So what else is there?




From my answers it seems I didn’t see this. What do you think?
I'm not sure. Earlier you spoke of "different things in the cup: cracks, marks, there’s no handle, it isn’t a perfect cup." From what you said here you noticed characteristics of the CUP. Those labels are all concepts ABOUT the cup. Thoughts and ideas that we entertain.The point being made here is that from the 5 sense input - feeling, seeing, hearing tasting and smelling the mind forms IDEAS or CONCEPTS ABOUT what is experienced through the senses. Every label we use is a CONCEPT.
Is this clear? If not let me know and we can come at it another way.




With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Mon Apr 29, 2024 2:52 am

there’s this feeling that I’m controlling this body, choosing where to see, where to look, monologuing, this owner that owns this body.
Let's have a closer look at "this feeling." Feel into the feeling.....
Are YOU this feeling? Or another way to put it.... is this feeling YOU?
it’s not a physical feeling. when I look at the sensations this feeling is nowhere to be found, I just feel the body. then I think “it’s a sensation, an impression that I’m controlling, owning this body” but then…
maybe it is only an idea? but it is SO STRONG. and this idea/feeling… that’s me, yes.

Are you in this feeling?
I’m the feeling

Are you outside this feeling?
not inside or outside, I’m the feeling, I’m the idea

How would you describe what it is that is feeling this feeling?
I don’t know how to see this. But then “something” tells me: no one is holding this idea, this feeling of ME. and then my head hurts.
well… yes, seeing stops, I’m listening to thoughts now.
Just look again. Listen to thoughts again. And check......
Has seeing actually stopped?
you are right, seeing never stops. but when I stop paying attention to it, it seems to disappear. but only from my awareness.
Or - going back to what we looked at earlier - is because you are FOCUSED on thought that seeing is not, at this moment, prominent?
yes, true
there’s always the sense of a seer, the subject that is trying to see the truth.
OK take a look again......
As you attend to seeing.....focus on any object "out there"
Keeping your eyes open, slowly move your attention from the object to where this seer seems to be.
Is there anywhere in this movement of attention that SEEING is interrupted in any way?
ok before answering the question, I realized it’s not a feeling. it’s an idea. The most powerful idea I have seen in my life, so powerful that it clouds my senses.

now I answer:
no, seeing can’t be interrupted. I can’t focus on the seer because it’s an idea, a concept. But it’s my entire reality.

Is there a boundary that attention has to navigate?
it is futile trying to see the seer. I will never be able to do it. not because I don’t believe in its existence, but because it’s a concept that has no shape, no form.

I see no boundaries because there’s nowhere to go.


Is there any gaps that attention has to cross?
there are no gaps, It’s like trying to see a new color. I believe it exists but it is impossible to see it.


Is there a specific point where your attention arrives which could be called the seer?
nothing. I can’t feel it, I can’t see it, I can’t ear it or think about it.
right now it’s an idea, a concept that I cannot show.

I said before “I have this sensation that I’m controlling life, or this feeling that I’m this thing” but no one of my senses can’t locate it. I just feel the body. But I’m aware ME is a concept, but right now is my entire reality. It’s everywhere and nowhere.
Or is there only seeing?
nop
So what else is there?
there’s nothing. there’s only what comes from the sense doors. but this idea of ME is so strong that I cannot shake it.
From my answers it seems I didn’t see this. What do you think?
I'm not sure. Earlier you spoke of "different things in the cup: cracks, marks, there’s no handle, it isn’t a perfect cup." From what you said here you noticed characteristics of the CUP. Those labels are all concepts ABOUT the cup. Thoughts and ideas that we entertain.The point being made here is that from the 5 sense input - feeling, seeing, hearing tasting and smelling the mind forms IDEAS or CONCEPTS ABOUT what is experienced through the senses. Every label we use is a CONCEPT.
Is this clear? If not let me know and we can come at it another way.
it is clear, BUT to be sure, I want to try it again with another exercise

thank you

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Mon Apr 29, 2024 12:41 pm

Hello Nicholas

I am really feeling into what you've sent here. I'll go to this .........
ok before answering the question, I realized it’s not a feeling. it’s an idea. The most powerful idea I have seen in my life, so powerful that it clouds my senses.
This is so significant. The word that comes here is "Wow"
The power we have given this idea, this belief that there is a ME comes from deep conditioning over our life time. To realize what you have seen can often evoke deep emotion. That can come from intense reaction to feeling that we have been deluded and tricked for so long into believing something that has had such as effect on our living. At the other end of the spectrum the reaction some have is "Oh that's all it is - a thought" with very little immediate reaction. And then of course there is the myriad of reactions in between that are unique to each individual body/ mind.
How do you feel to REALIZE this for what it is - that ME is just an idea? Is there a relief, or anxiety or a settledness or some other strong emotion?




So now is the time to be very gentle with yourself dear Nicholas

But then “something” tells me: no one is holding this idea, this feeling of ME. and then my head hurts.
"No one is holding this idea" - beautiful!! This is the truth. Another realization in and of itself.

This "something" that brings wisdom to the fore is your intuition, the inner guide. Sometimes it is hard to distinguish it from "It's just another thought." However when it's intuition "speaking" there is a quality about it that carries a "weight" a "substantiality" that somehow sets it "apart" There's a knowing somehow that this is true. It's so hard to put into words. As we learn to recognize it and trust it we find we can depend on it. It is the ultimate teacher.

Someone once said..
Listening to your own deepest wisdom is the inner teacher. And learning what is and isn’t wise through trial and error is how you more precisely hone in on the authentic inner teacher.
Does that make sense?



there’s only what comes from the sense doors. but this idea of ME is so strong that I cannot shake it.
Now take this slowly.....
You say "this idea of ME is so strong" Could it be that this belief of "so strong" be an extension, per say, of the sense of a feeling that is in truth another "layer" of the original ME idea?


The truth is that clear seeing of the idea of a ME is all that is needed. The thought, the idea will try to rise up and present itself as the truth again and you SEEING that happening is all that is needed for the falling away.

This is why we LOOK and LOOK again and again to. To recognize when we are believing a thought rather than experiencing directly. And this goes on for ever at subtler and subtler levels. And greater equanimity with the more we see


I am wondering if it might be helpful for you to join a Zoom group that happens 3 times a week. They are run by Vince Schubert here in Australia at different times to suit folks from all around the world. They give opportunity to really dig in to what is being experienced with others. One of the benefits is to be reassured we are not alone !!

The format is very informal and focuses on what is important to the people who happen to be there. I am not sure about the language situation Nicholas whether spoken English is something you are comfortable with.

Why don't we do this, here is the link to Vince's Youtube channel where you can look at some past meetups and see whether they resonate with you.
https://www.youtube.com/@vinceschubert/videos

Here is Vince's email - vinceschubert@gmail.com - if you would like to have him add you to the distribution list. He will then send you timing and schedule.

No pressure here at all to join. Just if it resonates and is practical for you. I just want you to know that this is available should it have appeal.


it is clear, BUT to be sure, I want to try it again with another exercise

I do want you give yourself the chance to really FEEL into this that you have realized. And I also do hear you when you say you want to make sure it is clear by LOOKING with the help of another exercises.

So this what comes right now

Now we'll take a closer look at is there a feeler and Sensation.

Hand on Desk

Please close your eyes for this exercise, just notice any ‘mental’ images or thoughts that appear and put them aside.

Place a hand on a desk or table (flat surface) - Close your eyes.

Now 'go to' the Sensation which we would normally refer to as 'hand on desk' and answer from what you can FIND.

1) How many things do you find? Are there two things (hand and desk) or is there one thing – AE of sensation.



2) Do you notice 'one thing feeling another thing'? Or is there just 'a sensation'?



3) Do you find an 'I', a body, a hand 'feeling' . . . or is there just 'a sensation'?



Look very carefully. Where does ‘feeling’ end and sensation begin? Can a dividing line between ‘feeling’ and sensation be found? Or is there just sensation?



Can a ‘feeler’ ever be found in 'what is being felt' – in AE of sensation?



If that is all, and no INHERENT FEELER is found . . . would anything that is suggested as the feeler be other than a concept/idea/thought?





Now Nicholas please be gentle and soft towards all that is happening. So many have traveled this path and can totally relate what you are experiencing. Lean into gentleness and compassion is what we are always reminded to do.

I know there might be a lot in this post so please take it all at a pace that is right for you.


With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Tue Apr 30, 2024 2:33 am

How do you feel to REALIZE this for what it is - that ME is just an idea? Is there a relief, or anxiety or a settledness or some other strong emotion?
no strong emotions. it’s just another little step, I feel there’s around 900 more till I fully realize “there’s no me”

I’ve been telling you over and over “I feel this me, I feel this me” but again… how can I feel it? I’m not feeling anything, it is not true. I just feel the body. That’s when I realize it’s a concept.

that’s why I say “powerful idea”. because… I’m still trapped in the “meness”!
(regarding intuition) Does that make sense?
yep. sometimes I get this “knowledge” or this “answer” that feels different. it’s weird because it is not rational at all so I don’t pay too much attention to it!
Now take this slowly.....
You say "this idea of ME is so strong" Could it be that this belief of "so strong" be an extension, per say, of the sense of a feeling that is in truth another "layer" of the original ME idea?
well… it’s the same thing. the only key difference is that I get to admit that I can’t feel it.
No pressure here at all to join. Just if it resonates and is practical for you. I just want you to know that this is available should it have appeal.
will look into it!!! thanks
Hand on Desk

Please close your eyes for this exercise, just notice any ‘mental’ images or thoughts that appear and put them aside.

Place a hand on a desk or table (flat surface) - Close your eyes.

Now 'go to' the Sensation which we would normally refer to as 'hand on desk' and answer from what you can FIND.

1) How many things do you find? Are there two things (hand and desk) or is there one thing – AE of sensation.
only one thing: sensation

2) Do you notice 'one thing feeling another thing'? Or is there just 'a sensation'?
just “a sensation”. (and it feels kind of nice)

3) Do you find an 'I', a body, a hand 'feeling' . . . or is there just 'a sensation'?
there’s just “a sensation”
Look very carefully. Where does ‘feeling’ end and sensation begin? Can a dividing line between ‘feeling’ and sensation be found? Or is there just sensation?
that’s right, I only see sensation.

(when you tell me “feeling” my mind now says “… what’s feeling? there’s only sensation” I guess this might be a good sign?)

Can a ‘feeler’ ever be found in 'what is being felt' – in AE of sensation?
there’s no feeler.

I focus on “hand on desk” and there’s only sensation. can I deviate a bit here? Now I feel everything.

and there’s only sensations. hey this is so strange. I’m just answering based on what “something” (intuition?) tells me, without thinking about it. there’s no feeler. But do I really believe that? what’s happening here?

I feel a bit of strong emotions right now, don’t know how to describe them, confusion mix with excitement mix anxiety? Like I realized something but I’m still not sure what and if I really do believe it and maybe tomorrow will be gone.
If that is all, and no INHERENT FEELER is found . . . would anything that is suggested as the feeler be other than a concept/idea/thought?
yeah totally. it is a concept, an idea… a thought like you say. or a belief! I like that better because it’s bigger and demostrates how enticing is it. so strange.

thank you Alan… this is fun haha. and scary too.

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Tue Apr 30, 2024 12:52 pm

Hello Nicholas
thank you Alan… this is fun haha. and scary too.
Ha ha!! Fun that's scary! That's great! It's a little like children playing hide and seek in the dark. They know they're safe but sometimes shadows make it seem as though there's something they need to be afraid of!

It brings to mind recently I was walking at night and in the distance saw what I thought was a cyclist. A few moments later I looked and it certainly seemed like the cyclist but somehow I wondered. I looked a little more intently and suddenly I realized that it was shadows falling on the road that made it appear there was a cyclist when there was none at all.

no strong emotions. it’s just another little step, I feel there’s around 900 more till I fully realize “there’s no me”
Someone once used this analogy. We can get soaked when getting caught in a downpour of rain. We can also get soaked and not realize it's happening through standing in the mist.

There is one of those 900 that will take care of the rest. It's like a House of Cards.

And who's to know if it hasn't already happened and there's a bit of a delayed “collapse”? Strange to say that is how it is sometimes.
And check in with this...
What will have to happen for you to FULLY realize there is no ME?



Whatever you say here that has to happen, is that not just a belief imposing again?




I just feel the body. That’s when I realize it’s a concept.
Great!

yep. sometimes I get this “knowledge” or this “answer” that feels different. it’s weird because it is not rational at all so I don’t pay too much attention to it!
That's it. It often doesn't appear rational. We ignore this at our peril. You don't have to launch yourself into it with abandon so to speak but DON'T IGNORE it. Test it or check it out gently. Get to know it.

well… it’s the same thing. the only key difference is that I get to admit that I can’t feel it.
Admitting to the truth is at the heart of this. Simple acknowledgement of the simplest of truths is actually very powerful.


Great seeing and feeling in the hand sensation experience. I'll touch on just a couple of points.

(when you tell me “feeling” my mind now says “… what’s feeling? there’s only sensation” I guess this might be a good sign?)
Definitely a good sign. The mind might actually be willing to admit what is seen rather than argue !!

I feel a bit of strong emotions right now, don’t know how to describe them, confusion mix with excitement mix anxiety? Like I realized something but I’m still not sure what and if I really do believe it and maybe tomorrow will be gone.
Beautiful Nicholas. For now, just roll with these emotions so to speak. And if you're inclined just FEEL into them and do your best to leave any story that comes to one side. Do what you did sensing into the sensation of the hand. JUST LET THEM BE FULLY FELT
And let me know what happens




Now let's just expand this experiencing of bodily sensation a little


With your eyes closed (mind interprets any body image as a “location”) do this for
Note: DO NOT TRY THIS WITH YOUR EYES CLOSED WHEN DRIVING THE CAR OR OTHER MOTION ACTIVITY !!!!

• feet touching the floor
• brushing your teeth
• fingers on keyboard
• sensation of water in the shower
• or any other daily activity where it is safe to do so
Are there any definable boundaries between the object being felt and the body feeling to be found at all as the many sensations are felt?




Is there an inherent FEELER in any experience of sensation.?





Then feel into sensations doing the same activities with eyes OPEN
Comparing to the experiencing of sensations with the eyes closed
Do you notice any difference in direct experience with the eyes open?




Do you notice a difference with the minds automatic habit of labeling with the eyes open?





As you reflect on the exercise and as your feel deeply into this that we call sensation are you able to describe sensation or recreate it in any way accurately to yourself or anyone else?





This can seem like a very simple exercise however if you are willing to give it the time and attention it deserves it can truly help if any doubts arise.

Let me know if any doubts do arise and if they do are they anything other than another thought?



With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Wed May 01, 2024 2:31 am

There is one of those 900 that will take care of the rest. It's like a House of Cards.
I agree
What will have to happen for you to FULLY realize there is no ME?
the thing is… I don’t know what has to happen for me to fully realize this. I mean… the belief has to drop fully, that’s it.
Whatever you say here that has to happen, is that not just a belief imposing again?
I don’t know
And let me know what happens
I did the exercise again. nothing happens in this case! no strong emotions for today.

Are there any definable boundaries between the object being felt and the body feeling to be found at all as the many sensations are felt?
no, there’s only sensations. in different parts of the body, but they are just sensations. no boundaries.


Is there an inherent FEELER in any experience of sensation.?
no feeler


Then feel into sensations doing the same activities with eyes OPEN
Comparing to the experiencing of sensations with the eyes closed
Do you notice any difference in direct experience with the eyes open?
ah, yes! it’s a bit harder to see the sensation alone, that’s it. I just have to really focus on ONLY feeling.

Do you notice a difference with the minds automatic habit of labeling with the eyes open?
yes



As you reflect on the exercise and as your feel deeply into this that we call sensation are you able to describe sensation or recreate it in any way accurately to yourself or anyone else?
no

This can seem like a very simple exercise however if you are willing to give it the time and attention it deserves it can truly help if any doubts arise.

Let me know if any doubts do arise and if they do are they anything other than another thought?
why is it harder to SEE this with eyes open?

thanks alan

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Wed May 01, 2024 12:32 pm

Hi Nicholas

no, there’s only sensations. in different parts of the body, but they are just sensations. no boundaries.
This the reality....no boundaries. Boundaries are concepts, ideas in mind. This is how the mind creates the world of form in the seamless flow of life. Applies labels which imply boundaries. That in itself is a mystery that that can not only be happening but it's so convincing that we end up being hypnotized by those boundaries in this world of form.

At the end of the post you say ...
why is it harder to SEE this with eyes open?
OK Let's work through this together.
Close your eyes.
Are forms and shapes very apparent?



Now open your eyes and look around you.
Do you see how as objects, shapes and forms are noticed so much more "readily"with eyes open?




Can you see and feel your experience being IMMEDIATELY interpreted by labels that automatically arise in your mind?




It's like when you wake up in the morning and sometimes be aware of that "zone" between being asleep and fully awake. It's very peaceful. SEEING is happening but the "labeling machine" has not yet kicked into action. But once fired up the "labeling machine" overrides the peace.

Labeling happens so fast it seems like it is the LEADER. If you really LOOK (and this can take some patience to catch it because it does happen so fast) you will see that SEEING has already happened before the labeling happens.

Try this. Wherever you are facing right now close your eyes and then turn away from the direction you were looking towards.
WATCH LIKE A HAWK as you open your eyes.
Did you notice this.... There was seeing of an object THEN the label arose?




The label is ALWAYS a thought that happens AFTER SEEING. Label after label after label. Opinions, judgements, assumptions etc etc This is the narrator hard at work.

Now notice your peripheral vision. There will be objects that are not quite clear.
Do you notice how the mind is searching for a label for, and second guessing, what cannot immediately be recognized by the mind?




Once the mind labels "things" the default is to relate to them THROUGH the label. The mind is "content" to relate to what it believes to be true ABOUT experience rather than be open to the truth of the experience. This relating primarily to thought creates the notion of separation and thus suffering.


From time to time throughout the day take a few moments and RELAX as best you can and watch the "labeling process"
Let me know what you find



With love



Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Thu May 02, 2024 5:11 am

Close your eyes.
Are forms and shapes very apparent?
(maybe I got this wrong) I have my eyes closed, there’s no form or shape

Now open your eyes and look around you.
Do you see how as objects, shapes and forms are noticed so much more "readily"with eyes open?
no, I don’t understand this exercise! should I do it while feeling sensations?

(ok, I think I understand. but I don't get the meaning of this question, Is it written correctly?


Can you see and feel your experience being IMMEDIATELY interpreted by labels that automatically arise in your mind?
if this refers to vision... yes!
Did you notice this.... There was seeing of an object THEN the label arose?
aah I can’t manage to purely see. labels arise too fast!


The label is ALWAYS a thought that happens AFTER SEEING. Label after label after label. Opinions, judgements, assumptions etc etc This is the narrator hard at work.

Now notice your peripheral vision. There will be objects that are not quite clear.
Do you notice how the mind is searching for a label for, and second guessing, what cannot immediately be recognized by the mind?
I notice that
From time to time throughout the day take a few moments and RELAX as best you can and watch the "labeling process"
Let me know what you find
mind automatically labels, even relaxed, even without thinking, even without focusing on anything!

sometimes I get that effect of “one image”.

when focusing on letters… sometimes they transform into another thing. like, the mind labels them differently… and again. for example an “a” turns into an “e” and then into just a shape.

other than that… I don’t see anything else other than just staring like when you are lost in thought… but I’m not, but feels the same.

User avatar
Alless
Posts: 697
Joined: Tue Jan 03, 2023 6:31 pm

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Alless » Fri May 03, 2024 2:41 am

Nicholas

First of all my apologies ... I've just spotted that this did not get sent to you yesterday. You most probably could be wondering why the silence on my part. I obviously did not hit the submit button. So sorry for my inconsistency !! So here it (belatedly) is .......

And just before we go on I'm curious as to what your reaction is to the delay. Every moment in experience can show us something.
So tell me Nicholas, what is felt (if anything) or what thoughts came up as a result of not receiving this yesterday?



(maybe I got this wrong) I have my eyes closed, there’s no form or shape
Spot on. Blackness is typically what is seen.

no, I don’t understand this exercise! should I do it while feeling sensations?
(ok, I think I understand. but I don't get the meaning of this question, Is it written correctly?
Not a problem because you got the essence of the exercise as you've described next.

aah I can’t manage to purely see. labels arise too fast!
Seeing the labels as you have is great ! As was pointed to - "(and this can take some patience to catch it because it does happen so fast)" -
Seeing without labels is a challenge. The more we keep looking the more likely we are to catch it. But to managing to see purely it is not as issue - seeing the labels arise like a "fire hose" is the thing !

mind automatically labels, even relaxed, even without thinking, even without focusing on anything!
Ha ha how true ! It is wild isn't it. Not that this is any new revelation necessarily however noticing this paying attention to what is happening is the key right now.

You're doing great with this Nicholas. I am remembering the frustration that seemed to be there earlier on. Now your speaking of even being relaxed sometimes 😊

Now we'll take a closer look at the body. You've said earlier that you now realize the body is a concept, an idea seen. We'll dig into this a little more. The more we LOOK the more likely the thought stream can be "slowed" a little especially as you find your self relaxing into the experience little by little.


Experiencing the body

Sit with EYES CLOSED for about 15 minutes.
Paying attention only to the PURE SENSATIONS, without relying on thoughts or mental images:

Can it be known how tall the body is?



Does the body have a weight or volume?



In the actual experience (without ANY thought and with eyes closed) does the body have a shape or a form?



Is there a boundary between the body and the clothing?



Is there a boundary between the body and the chair?



Is there an inside or an outside?



If there is an inside - the inside of what exactly?



If there is an outside - the outside of what exactly?



With eyes closed, what does the word/label ‘body’ ACTUALLY refer to?



What is the ACTUAL experience of the body with eyes closed?




FEEL AND LOOK very carefully, especially with the last question. Take your time, don’t rush. You can look/feel several times during the day while doing other things (like washing hands, showering, having a short break from work, walking, etc) before replying.

Remember this statement at the start of our exploration?

There is no separate self, never has been and never will be. That there is, is all just a made up story, a figment of the imagination that somehow we've believed to be true.

What happens now when you sit with that statement?




Describe any differences in reaction or responses now experienced compared to when you first saw it?





With love


Alan

User avatar
Nicholas
Posts: 243
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2024 5:05 am

Re: Stream Entry

Postby Nicholas » Sat May 04, 2024 2:42 am

So tell me Nicholas, what is felt (if anything) or what thoughts came up as a result of not receiving this yesterday?
not much! "oh, he didn't write anything... that's weird. well... let's just wait and see what happens! maybe if I have no responses for 2-3 days, will bump thread, maybe he didn't receive notification"

---
Can it be known how tall the body is?
no

Does the body have a weight or volume?
no

In the actual experience (without ANY thought and with eyes closed) does the body have a shape or a form?
no

Is there a boundary between the body and the clothing?
only sensations

Is there a boundary between the body and the chair?
only sensations

Is there an inside or an outside?
nop! only sensations, no such thing as inside or outside

If there is an inside - the inside of what exactly?
nop!

If there is an outside - the outside of what exactly?
nop =D

With eyes closed, what does the word/label ‘body’ ACTUALLY refer to?
every sensation felt, all of them at the same time

What is the ACTUAL experience of the body with eyes closed?
looking at sensations, the body could be the sum of all sensations. but without a body concept... there's only sensations

on the other hand... something also tells me "there's no body, just sensations"

---
There is no separate self, never has been and never will be. That there is, is all just a made up story, a figment of the imagination that somehow we've believed to be true.
What happens now when you sit with that statement?
I still believe in a separate self. totally as a belief. when looking through some senses, some are clear, some aren't... but they show only what is sensed.

for example, the other night I was hearing some sounds in the quiet night... and I think I got the "there is only hearing" for a moment... but it is still not ripe.

Also, when reading LU QUOTES, it said something like "there's just reading happening here" and I think I got it for a moment... but right now I can't manage to... "get it".
Describe any differences in reaction or responses now experienced compared to when you first saw it?
it's just becoming more and more clear.
I can't exactly remember what I told you before! I had to read it.
so, before I said: "the self is the feeling of being alive, the self is also in control of brain and body and that's me!"

now... I know the self is only a GIGANTIC belief... it's the CORE belief where our experience runs.
regarding control... I know that's also another belief.

But I'm not looking at "senses" anymore!


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests