All A-OK here for you and the teacher, Josh. I agree, lack of contraction is a good indicator... Nisargadatta Maharaj points directly to 'Where is the self?' So if what you are hearing is true to those teachings, there is no contradiction. The basic unit is the same: you think you are a self, inside a body. You aren't. Look, and keep on looking. Where is this you that is imagined as real?
This jumped out as I read your nice posting: "I am quietly looking what is actually there." This is very solid, a habit that will serve you. Even after the direct seeing that there is no real self, this habit can continue to deepen the realizations. Definitely keep on. In every moment it is THE question to ponder.
You are clear intellectually about thoughts, no personal self. And it is becoming, slowly, more than mere intellect. Some go from black to white in a moment... you are passing through shades of grey. Not a problem. It happens however it happens. Be heartened....
You are seeing there is experiencing, no concrete experience per se. Great. Try to find an experiencer. When anything happens, a thought or feeling or sensation... look. Where is the experiencer? Is there one? If nothing is found... focus on that, and look again, in the moment, at no experience, just experiencing.
You might, in those quiet moments, add this to what you are pondering: Is there an inside and outside? Where is the 'self'... in or out? After you answer, look again. Is it anywhere at all? Dissect the idea of the self being thoughts. Deconstruct the thought of 'I'.. What's there? How is it held together? What makes it seem so real?
Lots of love my friend.
My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
Unleash yourself. Look, and look again. No self to unleash.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
It's funny you should mention inside and outside. When I took aiahuasca (hallucinogenic drug from the Amazones) what happened was the distinction between inside and outside disappeared completely experientially, and there was resistance against it (albeit futile). It showed me that intellectually it seems like a nice idea, no inside nor outside, but to actually experience it is someting altogether different. Incidentally with my advaita teacher the pointer of not being localised is a strong one.
Pondering that question now, looking at what is actually the case based on present experience, the first thing that comes up is (although I kidn of know it's the wrong answer), the self is inside. There is a center of perception HERE, and 'here' feels in the first instance inside my body, looking out of my eyes. The fear of death is to do with losing this 'sensory center'. Speaking about contraction in the body, not wanting to let go of that localisation certainly feels contracted. There are now not many thoughts, it feels like an energetic 'holding'.
Can I just put this to you now, before I continue? Just trying to make use of both of us being awake and functioning at the same time. I'm sure I've thanked you for your time and attention before, but let me do it again: thank you Lisa!
Pondering that question now, looking at what is actually the case based on present experience, the first thing that comes up is (although I kidn of know it's the wrong answer), the self is inside. There is a center of perception HERE, and 'here' feels in the first instance inside my body, looking out of my eyes. The fear of death is to do with losing this 'sensory center'. Speaking about contraction in the body, not wanting to let go of that localisation certainly feels contracted. There are now not many thoughts, it feels like an energetic 'holding'.
Can I just put this to you now, before I continue? Just trying to make use of both of us being awake and functioning at the same time. I'm sure I've thanked you for your time and attention before, but let me do it again: thank you Lisa!
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
You are so very welcome, Josh... I enjoy our conversation very much.
You can feel 'localized' inside a body, and still have knowing/direct experiencing that you are not merely that.
So ponder further... you are doing it very well indeed.
Lisa
You can feel 'localized' inside a body, and still have knowing/direct experiencing that you are not merely that.
So ponder further... you are doing it very well indeed.
Lisa
Unleash yourself. Look, and look again. No self to unleash.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
Lisa, been busy and still a bit fluey. Will be in touch tomorrow. God willing. Josh.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
Hey Lisa,
Sorry it took a while.
Seeing my teacher was disappointing in a way. Not that it was bad, but it left me with a sense "I still haven't got there". I apparently had had high hopes that my work here with you would be the right preparation for me to 'pop'. As it turned out, I was feeling foggy in the head and did not feel very clear afterwards. Since then there have been some 'negative' thoughts, also referring to your remark above that I'm passing through shades of grey which some thoughts then interpret as I'll never get there. These thoughts and my general (foggy in the head due to cold etc) disposition then lead me to indulge in distractions and generally drifting away from my focus on this enquiry.
Not necessarily a problem, but for the sake of honesty want to tell you this is going down.
It does seem a bit hard to resume the enquiry, to get back to clarity and obviously that won't happen through thinking, the thing that feels best is just to sit and be quiet and not enquire into anything.
What comes up now is that there has been a fair bit of 'fighting' my experiences, not only now but as long as I can remember, I long to be one with my experiences and no longer have the ability to 'fight' (evaluate, judge, resist, choose, reject, try, etc etc) them any longer. In other words for this 'me-contraction' to be gone.
You will ask me: where is this contraction? What is it?
It FEELS like an energetic tendency. If I 'feel' into that, I become more quiet.
There is also the sense (and that is an old and desperate one) that I cannot undo myself. That I'm utterly powerless to let go of the I-illusion or to see that it was never there. That I cannot bring that about in any shape or form. That I can come close on a mental (clarity) or feeling (love, transparency) level, but 'I' cannot drop 'I' or see through 'I'.
That, in other words, IT has to happen.
And to walk around like IT should happen is not all that pleasant ;)
That's it (small 'it') for today.
Josh
Sorry it took a while.
Seeing my teacher was disappointing in a way. Not that it was bad, but it left me with a sense "I still haven't got there". I apparently had had high hopes that my work here with you would be the right preparation for me to 'pop'. As it turned out, I was feeling foggy in the head and did not feel very clear afterwards. Since then there have been some 'negative' thoughts, also referring to your remark above that I'm passing through shades of grey which some thoughts then interpret as I'll never get there. These thoughts and my general (foggy in the head due to cold etc) disposition then lead me to indulge in distractions and generally drifting away from my focus on this enquiry.
Not necessarily a problem, but for the sake of honesty want to tell you this is going down.
It does seem a bit hard to resume the enquiry, to get back to clarity and obviously that won't happen through thinking, the thing that feels best is just to sit and be quiet and not enquire into anything.
What comes up now is that there has been a fair bit of 'fighting' my experiences, not only now but as long as I can remember, I long to be one with my experiences and no longer have the ability to 'fight' (evaluate, judge, resist, choose, reject, try, etc etc) them any longer. In other words for this 'me-contraction' to be gone.
You will ask me: where is this contraction? What is it?
It FEELS like an energetic tendency. If I 'feel' into that, I become more quiet.
There is also the sense (and that is an old and desperate one) that I cannot undo myself. That I'm utterly powerless to let go of the I-illusion or to see that it was never there. That I cannot bring that about in any shape or form. That I can come close on a mental (clarity) or feeling (love, transparency) level, but 'I' cannot drop 'I' or see through 'I'.
That, in other words, IT has to happen.
And to walk around like IT should happen is not all that pleasant ;)
That's it (small 'it') for today.
Josh
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
Hmmm.... you say "I cannot undo myself." ???? 2? Where are they? A thought is trying to undo another thought... that's what is happening. Can thought DO that?
You are working so hard at this; and you’re dealing with this as if it's belief. Trying to get the right belief, get the 'correct' belief strong enough that it saves you. But there’s no you to save—and—belief, even if true, is just belief. Recognition, seeing— it hits at a very different level.
We are not trying to destroy belief here; we are looking where that belief says there is an actual, real, SELF.
When the belief in 'my car' comes up, it points to your automobile. When belief in 'myself' comes up, it points to nothing at all. Look.....
You are working so hard at this; and you’re dealing with this as if it's belief. Trying to get the right belief, get the 'correct' belief strong enough that it saves you. But there’s no you to save—and—belief, even if true, is just belief. Recognition, seeing— it hits at a very different level.
We are not trying to destroy belief here; we are looking where that belief says there is an actual, real, SELF.
When the belief in 'my car' comes up, it points to your automobile. When belief in 'myself' comes up, it points to nothing at all. Look.....
Unleash yourself. Look, and look again. No self to unleash.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
Lisa, I understand that. I'm not trying to acquire new beliefs, if anything trying to rid myself of the belief in a separate identity here. It is the latter I was, metaphorically, lamenting, that 'I' cannot undo 'myself'. For that is what it feels like TRYING to look. The effort itself makes it seem there is someone here that has to do something, i.e. see there is no one here!
I fully understand that looking, simply looking, without expectation, without thinking, without agenda, without even anyone looking is what is required here. And that it is not about hours, weeks, months or years of practice. That one look is enough.
Just don't seem to know how... and that how is again the 'I' trying to undo 'myself'. I definitely see the absurdity of it. But I also get rather disheartened as time progresses without any definitive progress. All that stuff, I'm well aware, is on the thinking level. From that level I cannot 'get' to the seeing level.
'Silently pondering' seems harder when I feel this disheartened and of course the first step then is to allow attention to withdraw from those thoughts and feelings.
Then I'm just feeling what I'm feeling and thinking what I'm thinking and awaring what I'm awaring.
And all of it feels like 'me'....
I fully understand that looking, simply looking, without expectation, without thinking, without agenda, without even anyone looking is what is required here. And that it is not about hours, weeks, months or years of practice. That one look is enough.
Just don't seem to know how... and that how is again the 'I' trying to undo 'myself'. I definitely see the absurdity of it. But I also get rather disheartened as time progresses without any definitive progress. All that stuff, I'm well aware, is on the thinking level. From that level I cannot 'get' to the seeing level.
'Silently pondering' seems harder when I feel this disheartened and of course the first step then is to allow attention to withdraw from those thoughts and feelings.
Then I'm just feeling what I'm feeling and thinking what I'm thinking and awaring what I'm awaring.
And all of it feels like 'me'....
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
We're going too far away from direct experiencing, Josh. Let's get back to really looking.
Here's how we 'know the world':
Seeing
Feeling (tactile and kinesthetic)
Hearing
Tasting
Smelling
Thinking (thoughts, images)
Intuitive (knowing without thoughts or images)
Basically, 6 senses + 1 mind, creating perceptions.
This is experience, when these happen. This is how we know that the body is here, and the world, etc. etc. It's how we know ideas, concepts, beliefs. It's how we know emotions, sound, smells, tastes... everything.
Using these as a way to investigate, where is Josh?
Can he be seen? Can he be tasted, smelled, heard?
Can Josh be touched, or felt with feelings... or intuited?
Investigate using each of these and tell me what you find. It may seem redundant or self-evident, but do it anyway. And then do it again. Keep looking with all these tools.... can they find Josh? Simple. It's yes, or it's no.
Here's how we 'know the world':
Seeing
Feeling (tactile and kinesthetic)
Hearing
Tasting
Smelling
Thinking (thoughts, images)
Intuitive (knowing without thoughts or images)
Basically, 6 senses + 1 mind, creating perceptions.
This is experience, when these happen. This is how we know that the body is here, and the world, etc. etc. It's how we know ideas, concepts, beliefs. It's how we know emotions, sound, smells, tastes... everything.
Using these as a way to investigate, where is Josh?
Can he be seen? Can he be tasted, smelled, heard?
Can Josh be touched, or felt with feelings... or intuited?
Investigate using each of these and tell me what you find. It may seem redundant or self-evident, but do it anyway. And then do it again. Keep looking with all these tools.... can they find Josh? Simple. It's yes, or it's no.
Unleash yourself. Look, and look again. No self to unleash.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
I like this. Good to get back to basics. Complexity is my middle name, I think.
To the matter at hand:
Josh cannot be seen.
Josh cannot be hard.
Josh cannot be tasted.
Josh cannot be smelled.
These sense just register what they register. What they register is not Josh. Perhaps seeing registers the hand of Josh but that is memory, labeling, thinking.
Now to feeling.
Where the previous senses are directed 'outward', i.e outside of the body, this is directed 'inward', inside the body.
It is the universe of feelings and sensations that feel intimately 'mine' and 'identify where I'm at'.
Can I find Josh there? Does the sense of touch, of feeling, feel Josh?
No. Just ever changing feelings. I don't feel Josh. I feel feelings and sensations.
Thought. The difficult one. I'm trying a few angles.
Can Josh be thought? Yes. Josh is a thought. A collection of thoughts. Of labels.
Can Josh be known through thought? No. Every thought is a separate thought. A thought cannot know a thought.
Can thought find Josh? No. Thought can say, label: 'Josh'.
Intuitive knowing.
There is just emptiness there, so no, no Josh can be intuited.
To the matter at hand:
Josh cannot be seen.
Josh cannot be hard.
Josh cannot be tasted.
Josh cannot be smelled.
These sense just register what they register. What they register is not Josh. Perhaps seeing registers the hand of Josh but that is memory, labeling, thinking.
Now to feeling.
Where the previous senses are directed 'outward', i.e outside of the body, this is directed 'inward', inside the body.
It is the universe of feelings and sensations that feel intimately 'mine' and 'identify where I'm at'.
Can I find Josh there? Does the sense of touch, of feeling, feel Josh?
No. Just ever changing feelings. I don't feel Josh. I feel feelings and sensations.
Thought. The difficult one. I'm trying a few angles.
Can Josh be thought? Yes. Josh is a thought. A collection of thoughts. Of labels.
Can Josh be known through thought? No. Every thought is a separate thought. A thought cannot know a thought.
Can thought find Josh? No. Thought can say, label: 'Josh'.
Intuitive knowing.
There is just emptiness there, so no, no Josh can be intuited.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
What is this 'Josh' that is associated with a hand??Perhaps seeing registers the hand of Josh but that is memory, labeling, thinking.
What is it that is not feeling something labeled 'Josh'?I don't feel Josh.
Unleash yourself. Look, and look again. No self to unleash.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
A label, information in memory. If someone would ask me, to which person does that hand belong, I would obviously reply 'Josh' (or 'me').What is this 'Josh' that is associated with a hand??
I don't know. Feelings are being felt. They are being felt 'here', where ever or whatever that is. It is not 'Josh'.What is it that is not feeling something labeled 'Josh'?
PS Looks like we're going for short questions and answers. Seems like a good idea. My endless spiritual musings amount to nothing. I'll look and report as directly as possible.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
Good.
Look even more closely at the Josh that is 'a label, information in memory'. From where did that label arise? Is it constantly arising, or static? Of what is this label made?
Look even more closely at the Josh that is 'a label, information in memory'. From where did that label arise? Is it constantly arising, or static? Of what is this label made?
Where is the 'person' in there... ? Is there one? Who/what is the Josh, the 'me' that owns that hand?If someone would ask me, to which person does that hand belong, I would obviously reply 'Josh' (or 'me').
Look very closely here.. there is no Josh, yet Josh is appearing above in the above... look at both .... which is your direct experiencing?I don't know. Feelings are being felt. They are being felt 'here', where ever or whatever that is. It is not 'Josh'.
Unleash yourself. Look, and look again. No self to unleash.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
That label arises out of nowhere. It is not static or constant, it just arises sometimes.Look even more closely at the Josh that is 'a label, information in memory'. From where did that label arise? Is it constantly arising, or static? Of what is this label made?
There is no person in here. There is no owner of the hand in direct experience. There is information in the form of thought that 'knows' it is the hand that is part of the bodymind called 'Josh'.Where is the 'person' in there... ? Is there one? Who/what is the Josh, the 'me' that owns that hand?
I don't know. Feelings are being felt. They are being felt 'here', where ever or whatever that is. It is not 'Josh'.
My direct experience is, with the emphasis on DIRECT, that there is just being present, with, from time to time, thoughts that relate to a person with a life story called 'Josh'. In this direct experience nothing is known, but knowing in the form of notions (thoughts) comes up, and feelings are felt.Look very closely here.. there is no Josh, yet Josh is appearing above in the above... look at both .... which is your direct experiencing?
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
Let's get this cleared up. Thought 'knows'...? Look closely... is a thought knowing (aware of) the hand? Or is there simply awareness that there is a hand, a car, a table, a cloud?There is information in the form of thought that 'knows' it is the hand
Does the thought of hand come before, during, or after the awareness of hand?
Let's clear up this, too:
One thought relates to another thought? One imagined idea relates to another? Can this actually happen, a thought DOING something?thoughts that relate to a person with a life story called 'Josh'
One thought can look at another thought that says 'There's a person', and validate it, make it real?
Unleash yourself. Look, and look again. No self to unleash.
Re: My guide's done a runner, anybody willing to take over?
There is awareness of what we call 'hand' without knowing what it is (i.e. it is seen as a shape, a form); then there is, or can be, a notion or thought or label 'hand'. It can even be 'my hand'. There is awareness of that labeling.
Let's get this cleared up. Thought 'knows'...? Look closely... is a thought knowing (aware of) the hand? Or is there simply awareness that there is a hand, a car, a table, a cloud?
Does the thought of hand come before, during, or after the awareness of hand?
So there is seeing, and then there is labeling. They both come up independently, as it were.
The more 'I allow myself to sink into just being aware', for lack of a better expression, the more passive that seeing becomes (the less grasping there is in it), and the more labeling drifts to the background.
Well, each thought is just that, a thought, and all it is is a 'notion' of something, 'information-content'.
Let's clear up this, too:
One thought relates to another thought? One imagined idea relates to another? Can this actually happen, a thought DOING something?thoughts that relate to a person with a life story called 'Josh'
One thought can look at another thought that says 'There's a person', and validate it, make it real?
But these notions can string together into a story, so that, for example, if you were to ask me what I do in life and what I have done, I am able to tell you. This is called memory. So thoughts containing information content of past sensory impressions and events are somehow stored in the bodymind for future reference.
Without memory, there could still be thoughts but no story. There would be no experience as we commonly define it ('I am having a nice day at the beach') but only direct experience ('sun, sea, wind, smells and so on').
But maybe this is complicating things.
In answer to your question, one thought just follows another thought and they are not related.
And there is the phenomenon of believing in the thought-content of a single thought, which may produce a feeling and thus make it seem real.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot], whoknows and 25 guests

