Hey ZOC,
We'll be posting here with Rohit's help.
Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
- jeffdilbeck
- Posts: 587
- Joined: Thu Feb 02, 2012 6:47 pm
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
the real I is there to experience life through it's host.
There is not a real I there to experience life through it's host.
There is a brain, a body, and the illusion of a 'me' who experiences life. That is all.
We can start there.
:)
There is not a real I there to experience life through it's host.
There is a brain, a body, and the illusion of a 'me' who experiences life. That is all.
We can start there.
:)
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
Hi ZOC, Answer jeff's question and LOOK When you have a thought of so called real I, trace it
back as far as it can go. What do you see? Tell me exactly what you see.
back as far as it can go. What do you see? Tell me exactly what you see.
- ZenOfchaos
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Sun Aug 12, 2012 11:45 am
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
hey Jeff and Rohit thanks for helping me out on this
I sat with the 'real I' question last night and this morning.
the feeling of a real I is an attempt to understand why there is this space that zoc occupies and is aware of its own existence and aliveness. there is this space that all of life unfolds and no-one else can see it or occupy it. this space isn't the same as Jeff's or Rohit's space.
It was also an attempt to bring together an understanding of having 'no-self' and of tolle's "I am" (prior to "I am this or that").
Upon looking i realise that this is no more than a thought: an attempt to understand things at the level of thought. I can't actually find a real I in anything else that thought or to put a label on this 'lifeness'.
I sat with the 'real I' question last night and this morning.
the feeling of a real I is an attempt to understand why there is this space that zoc occupies and is aware of its own existence and aliveness. there is this space that all of life unfolds and no-one else can see it or occupy it. this space isn't the same as Jeff's or Rohit's space.
It was also an attempt to bring together an understanding of having 'no-self' and of tolle's "I am" (prior to "I am this or that").
Upon looking i realise that this is no more than a thought: an attempt to understand things at the level of thought. I can't actually find a real I in anything else that thought or to put a label on this 'lifeness'.
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
Hi ZOC,
Sometimes people can trick themselves, dismissing the self or I, but really they have only abandoned the words or concepts, and have established an identity somewhere else. It's a trick. Keep looking for the source or base of your I and report what you find.
From your own experience alone, answer the question, what is space, anyway?the feeling of a real I is an attempt to understand why there is this space that zoc occupies and is aware of its own existence and aliveness. there is this space that all of life unfolds and no-one else can see it or occupy it. this space isn't the same as Jeff's or Rohit's space.
if you cannot find this real I, what does that imply about the Real I?I can't actually find a real I in anything else that thought or to put a label on this 'lifeness'.
Sometimes people can trick themselves, dismissing the self or I, but really they have only abandoned the words or concepts, and have established an identity somewhere else. It's a trick. Keep looking for the source or base of your I and report what you find.
- ZenOfchaos
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Sun Aug 12, 2012 11:45 am
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
the space is like a stage where everything happens. this consciousness where sight is perceived, where sounds are heard, where thoughts are thunk, where sensations are felt, and emotions are felt.Hi ZOC,
From your own experience alone, answer the question, what is space, anyway?
if you cannot find this real I, what does that imply about the Real I?I can't actually find a real I in anything else that thought or to put a label on this 'lifeness'.
Sometimes people can trick themselves, dismissing the self or I, but really they have only abandoned the words or concepts, and have established an identity somewhere else. It's a trick. Keep looking for the source or base of your I and report what you find.[/quote]
yes Rohit, I don't want this to happen. it is this knowing of being alive and sensing the world and how this feels personal to ZOC. this real I is an excuse to explain being alive and being unique in a world full of other people. mind cannot comprehend how there can be no me when it feels like there is a seer of sights and experiencer of experiences.
i was looking today during work and when i went for a walk in the park. in a meeting where we all usually talk about the problems of others i took a mental step back and things felt different. like these problems were all insignificant and there was stillness everywhere in the background. like for a few moments i was not sucked in to the drama of life. felt good :-)
Also in the park i had a moment (maybe it was this oneness who knows) where i looked at the totality of what i could see and then had an abstract realisation that it was all in me and i was all in it. probably a crap way to describe it since me or i doesn't exist ;)
don't know if these were just passing perceptions or from the result of looking. just thought i'd share.
- jeffdilbeck
- Posts: 587
- Joined: Thu Feb 02, 2012 6:47 pm
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
The space you are describing, is it just the feeling of aliveness, the ground of appearances of thoughts? Is there anything there that is always there? Again, this question needs answering, What is space?the space is like a stage where everything happens. this consciousness where sight is perceived, where sounds are heard, where thoughts are thunk, where sensations are felt, and emotions are felt.
What seems to be described here is three ideas :
This is a defensive stance that experience is personal because it is perceivable.It feels like there is a seer of sights and experiencer of experience
Find the me which sees. Use your finger and point at it.
In the next there is an I thought, which is interested in identifying with nothing, just blissing, and becoming separate from surroundings, acting as a detached I. I am a no-self.in a meeting where we all usually talk about the problems of others i took a mental step back and things felt different. like these problems were all insignificant and there was stillness everywhere in the background. like for a few moments i was not sucked in to the drama of life. felt good :-)
Look at the one which is a no self. Is this one real?
In the third situation, we have moved from I am the seer (as in view A.) and moved to I am everything.Also in the park i had a moment (maybe it was this oneness who knows) where i looked at the totality of what i could see and then had an abstract realisation that it was all in me and i was all in it. probably a crap way to describe it since me or i doesn't exist ;)
Look for the difference between looking, the looked at, and the looker.
Explain in detail like we are 5 years old what is found. Not from books, but from what is seen.
Love,
Jeff
- ZenOfchaos
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Sun Aug 12, 2012 11:45 am
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
I'll answer each question throughout the day as I look at each on its own.
Yes. The space I'm describing is the ground of aliveness, where thoughts and experiences (sight, sound, touch,emotion etc) unfold. What is always there I can't really say because its not something I know how to describe. Like trying to describe outer space without referencing planets or stars. If only I could step into a sensory deprivation chamber to explore that further!
At a thinking level I know the brain receives input so I guess its really the conscious awareness of what the brain is perceiving. ok ok ok, asked myself "who is perceiving?" And all I feel is a sense of 'me'. Will try and look at this further.
Yes. The space I'm describing is the ground of aliveness, where thoughts and experiences (sight, sound, touch,emotion etc) unfold. What is always there I can't really say because its not something I know how to describe. Like trying to describe outer space without referencing planets or stars. If only I could step into a sensory deprivation chamber to explore that further!
At a thinking level I know the brain receives input so I guess its really the conscious awareness of what the brain is perceiving. ok ok ok, asked myself "who is perceiving?" And all I feel is a sense of 'me'. Will try and look at this further.
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
You cannot meaningfully say ‘this is what I am’. It just makes no sense. What you point out as 'this' or 'that' cannot be.And all I feel is a sense of 'me'. Will try and look at this further.
You observe the heart feeling, the mind thinking, the body acting; the very act of perceiving shows that you are not what you perceive. The sense of being an experiencer, the sense of ‘I am’/ the sense of "me", is it not also an experience?
- ZenOfchaos
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Sun Aug 12, 2012 11:45 am
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
Yes the sense of me or I is an experience too.
I struggle to really get to grips with the difference between no egoic self and no self/me at all.
I struggle to really get to grips with the difference between no egoic self and no self/me at all.
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
There's an experience of knowing, there's
an experience of typing on a keyboard, and
there's an experience of trying to
understand what "no self" means. Now,
what do they have in common? One thing:
they are experiences. LOOk, can you find this "me" that thinks it is an experiencer?
an experience of typing on a keyboard, and
there's an experience of trying to
understand what "no self" means. Now,
what do they have in common? One thing:
they are experiences. LOOk, can you find this "me" that thinks it is an experiencer?
- ZenOfchaos
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Sun Aug 12, 2012 11:45 am
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
no. but mind is saying "oh but that doesn't mean there isn't one there just cuz you can't see it. its real isn't it, how do you know its real? cuz you're experiencing it". In that respect mind is experiencing it. Brain is doing its job by perceiving light and objects and sensations. Images are seen and thoughts about perceptions are thunk. Mind is equivocal. please push this more.LOOk, can you find this "me" that thinks it is an experiencer?
- jeffdilbeck
- Posts: 587
- Joined: Thu Feb 02, 2012 6:47 pm
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
Thought is happening. Seeing is happening. Hearing is happening. Is there a thinker separate from thinking? Is there a seer separate from seeing? Is there a hearer separate from hearing?mind is saying "oh but that doesn't mean there isn't one there just cuz you can't see it. its real isn't it, how do you know its real? cuz you're experiencing it". In that respect mind is experiencing it. Brain is doing its job by perceiving light and objects and sensations. Images are seen and thoughts about perceptions are thunk. Mind is equivocal. please push this more.
- ZenOfchaos
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Sun Aug 12, 2012 11:45 am
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
Thoughts arise out of the abyss. There is no choice about what thoughts arise. Therefore no thinker behind the thoughts.Thought is happening. Seeing is happening. Hearing is happening. Is there a thinker separate from thinking? Is there a seer separate from seeing? Is there a hearer separate from hearing?mind is saying "oh but that doesn't mean there isn't one there just cuz you can't see it. its real isn't it, how do you know its real? cuz you're experiencing it". In that respect mind is experiencing it. Brain is doing its job by perceiving light and objects and sensations. Images are seen and thoughts about perceptions are thunk. Mind is equivocal. please push this more.
Eyes take in wavelengths of light and different parts of the brain process colour,texture,shape,etc to make a coherent image. Seeing is automatic. Perhaps I'm confusing the brain's processing of images with a me who is seeing the seeing. Like having a photograph with noone to comprehend and appreciate it. Seeing baffles the hell out of me. It's such an amazing thing.
There are sounds and a brain that makes them into meaningful noises through labels and memories. No hearer behind hearing.
- jeffdilbeck
- Posts: 587
- Joined: Thu Feb 02, 2012 6:47 pm
Re: Zen Of Chaos-this is your thread
correct. but this confusion is not personal. it is just a thought.Perhaps I'm confusing the brain's processing of images with a me who is seeing the seeing.
Further into this inquiry:
Is there a feeler of feelings?
What is seen?
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests

