Anatta

Welcome to the main forum. When you are ready to start a conversation, register and once your application is processed a guide will come to talk to you.
This is one-on-one style forum, one thread per green member.
User avatar
Knick
Posts: 10
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 11:32 pm
Location: East Coast, USA

Anatta

Postby Knick » Fri Sep 23, 2011 12:29 am

It seems you try to stay away from theory and discussion not directly related to liberation, but whats the harm? Still close this if you like. Elena pointed me here, and I'll start a 1on1 in another thread with whoever is willing, but take your time, I have a paper to write anyway.

1. I take it the no-self teaching around here is basically Buddhism's anatta. Why the focus on anatta, rather than anicca and dukkha? The traditional teachings on anatta seem more nuanced than simply "there is no you". Some claim that "Anatta" literally means 'not-self', and if the Buddha meant 'no-self' he would have said 'na-atta'.

2.
http://www.accesstoinsight.org/lib/auth ... tself.html
Theravada monk on self. Several points made here. One place where Buddha is asked if there is a self or not a self he refuses to answer.

3.
http://www.accesstoinsight.org/tipitaka ... .bpit.html
Sabbasava Sutta states:
That person considers improperly in regard to the present:
Do I exist? Do I not exist? Who am I? How Am I?
Considering improperly there arises 6 wrong views:
2. The view 'I have no self' arises in him really and firmly.
4. the view 'I perceive not-self though self' arises in him really and firmly'

How are these wrong views different than what is going on here? How do you figure out not-self without questioning "Do I exist"?

User avatar
Matt
Posts: 311
Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2011 2:06 am

Re: Anatta

Postby Matt » Fri Sep 23, 2011 2:57 am

1. I take it the no-self teaching around here is basically Buddhism's anatta.
No, my friend, this isn't a teaching. It's a brutally honest investigation that we encourage enthusiatically.
That person considers improperly in regard to the present:
Do I exist? Do I not exist? Who am I? How Am I?
Considering improperly there arises 6 wrong views:
2. The view 'I have no self' arises in him really and firmly.
4. the view 'I perceive not-self though self' arises in him really and firmly'
How are these wrong views different than what is going on here? How do you figure out not-self without questioning "Do I exist"?
Again, this isn't a teaching. It's not a view! It's not a belief, consideration, or even conviction. So yes, I would agree (from experience, not study) that the above would be improper. But this forum is not about discussing right view or wrong view, so you can let this intellectual tension rest, if you like. As you put your sophisticated Buddhist knowledge temporarily to the side, you can more easily prepare to look with all the penetrative clarity and honesty that you can muster. We look forward to your participation in one-on-one!

User avatar
No_One
Posts: 113
Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2011 8:42 am
Location: Romania
Contact:

Re: Anatta

Postby No_One » Fri Sep 23, 2011 5:54 am

Knick, I have no clue about theoretical schools and so on. Buddha said 'there is suffering' and that's not I suffer. That's one key point. The question 'who am I?' was used by Ramana Maharshi for some time and it's really effective. Sure ... the answer is not mental (a mental answer to this is useless and gets nowhere). The question 'is there an I?' is just the same only adapted to the 'western' mentality (full of ego usually).

Yes those views are wrong:
I (self) have no self
I (self) perceive not-self
What we say is 'there is no self'. Perception does not need a self / an I to happen. Nothing needs a self / I to happen. The I is just a thought. Just look at your experience ... is this true? What are the facts and what are the assumptions?

Btw, how long have you been meditating? Are you comfortable with just staying as the observer?
The truth is in here not out there

User avatar
Ilona
Site Admin
Posts: 8233
Joined: Wed Sep 14, 2011 1:57 pm
Location: Mauritius
Contact:

Re: Anatta

Postby Ilona » Fri Sep 23, 2011 7:46 am

This is not a forum about liberation. This is where liberation happens.
So tell us Knick, is it true, that there is no separate entities at all? Do you exist?
See for yourself.
8-week guided self-inquiry experience → https://ilonaciunaite.com/8-week-program/

User avatar
Knick
Posts: 10
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 11:32 pm
Location: East Coast, USA

Re: Anatta

Postby Knick » Fri Sep 23, 2011 8:08 pm

Not been meditating for long. Some basic following the breath, and noting the 4foundations of mindfulness. Though I've heard of Ramana Maharshi, and technique of asking "Who am I". But there is stuff straight out of pali
cannon like I showed above that says considering Who am I is improper. So it gets confusing which technique is right.

Traditional teaching in Buddhism is the five aggregates make up a being, and contribute to sense of self:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_aggregates
So sure, intellectually I agree there is no soul or single thing that makes up any human being, its just a bunch of processes. And I suppose certain process in the brain feedback on themselves allowing awareness to be aware of itself, thus self-awareness.

So how do I do this special looking to get to this real perspective? As the above Wikipedia entry states "ultimate freedom is realized by deeply penetrating the nature of all aggregates as intrinsically empty of independent existence.". Typically in Buddhism this penetration is done with vipasanna, which seems to take years and years, but perhaps there is a more direct method here.

User avatar
Garsius Tyla
Posts: 165
Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 9:48 pm

Re: Anatta

Postby Garsius Tyla » Fri Sep 23, 2011 8:19 pm

Those are nice ideas. Can you put them aside for a period you are here? All you need here to get truth realised is:

- engage and investigate yourself with 100 % honesty.

- answer questions/pointers not with ideas, which comes up, but with personal experience that you can get only by looking inside.

Now, if you are ready for this, after making a good look inside yourself, answer -

do you exist?

User avatar
Damon Kamda
Site Admin
Posts: 1291
Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
Location: Amsterdam

Re: Anatta

Postby Damon Kamda » Fri Sep 23, 2011 8:29 pm

Hi Knick,

Welcome to the forum.

No technique, no theory, no meditation is required for liberation to occur, so you can leave all that at the door.

And, yes, there is a more direct way to realization than Wikipedia entries and Vipassana.

Are you ready?
So how do I do this special looking to get to this real perspective?
Theres nothing special about this looking and there is no perspective to "get". It's about recognizing that, in your immediate experience, a self has always been absent.

So,before digging yourself in deeper in intellectual puzzles and theorizing, look directly at life and answer 315's question, with complete honesty.
So tell us Knick, is it true, that there is no separate entities at all? Do you exist?

User avatar
No_One
Posts: 113
Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2011 8:42 am
Location: Romania
Contact:

Re: Anatta

Postby No_One » Sat Sep 24, 2011 6:44 am

Hey Knick ... you seem to be walking too many roads. Just stick to one. And if you're here just try this ... we're not asking for 20 years and then maybe you will get somewhere. Some weeks are enough in most of the cases. You can always do a 2 years retreat as alternative :)
The truth is in here not out there

User avatar
Knick
Posts: 10
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 11:32 pm
Location: East Coast, USA

Re: Anatta

Postby Knick » Sat Sep 24, 2011 7:53 pm

1. It seems the goal here is to basically realize/say there is no self, there is no you, never was.
2. But I will quote, "Views that there is no self are ranked with views that there is a self as a "fetter of views" which a person aiming at release from suffering would do well to avoid." At liberation "Views of true, false, self, no self, etc., thus lose all their holding power, and the mind is left free to its Suchness: untouched, uninfluenced by anything of any sort."
3. So, these 2 views seem contradictory. But perhaps they are not, perhaps translation or meaning of word issues, perhaps using different words to mean same thing, perhaps 2kinds of liberation, who knows.


"Do you exist"
Not sure how to answer. Already said being is just made of of aggregates. What does some answer really matter. Its the penetration that matters. Guess I'll type up some stuff for you guys to give feedback on though.

Well there is this lump of matter, organs, body, brain. This is MY lump of matter as opposed to YOUR lump. There is MY awareness and thoughts as opposed to OTHERS inner life. Or could just as easily say universe is just a bunch of particles in relationship and not strictly correct to divide up things.

I/self is an abstraction, pretty vague. Not like a rock, or paperclip, can't point to it. Where is this I? I don't know. Its a habit to use the word "I" when referring to this body, these possessions, these thoughts. What we call I/self are only processes, but what is it to really look and see this?

There is pressure of fingers on keys. There is vision from eyes on these words. There is ache in back. There is taste on tongue. Awareness can be directed to different things, otherwise they go unnoticed. I direct attention or what does? Thinking about all this. Want to say I am thinking, but it could just be thoughts doing what they do? It seems something has some control. Take blinking, it can be voluntary or involuntary. If not focusing on it, involuntary. If focus on it, can decide to blink.

Stopped writing, and tried to wordlessly dwell in being for 30min or so...made me feel a bit detached. But what is it that is feeling detached? Someone asked me if I was alright because I looked a bit down in the dumps. Seems I was exploring around this territory: http://www.buddhistgeeks.com/2010/04/th ... -around-2/

User avatar
No_One
Posts: 113
Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2011 8:42 am
Location: Romania
Contact:

Re: Anatta

Postby No_One » Sun Sep 25, 2011 6:35 am

Knick, that are nice thoughts but that's all they are ... thoughts. Let's root this in real life. Just observe what's going on. We say 'I write a message'. What can be seen about this? What are the facts and what are the assumptions? Also, look at thoughts. Where do they come from? Where do they go? Do you think them? What are the facts and what are the assumptions? Look at feelings. Do you feel them? What are the facts and what are the assumptions? What does this I stand for? Forget about the scriptures for a while ... what's real?
The truth is in here not out there

User avatar
Knick
Posts: 10
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 11:32 pm
Location: East Coast, USA

Re: Anatta

Postby Knick » Tue Sep 27, 2011 5:26 am

We say 'I write a message'. What can be seen about this? What are the facts and what are the assumptions?
3 parts, I, write, message. writing obviously occurs. Message obviously there. Writing is action. Message is thing/object. I is what? Abstraction. I stands for this personal nature of writing the message. This something behind, or doing the writing. Writer behind the words assumed? While I don't think there is some single thing, the writer behind words, seems normal to just be lazy about it and say sure its I, its me, doing writing.

Also, look at thoughts. Where do they come from? Where do they go? Do you think them? What are the facts and what are the assumptions?
Thoughts often just come and go, fast, guess I can't see where they come from. Thoughts can be triggered by surroundings. Discursive thinking is interesting part, this inner dialogue and seems to be controlled. Assumption that thoughts can be controlled? That it seems thinking can be directed.

Look at feelings. Do you feel them? What are the facts and what are the assumptions? What does this I stand for? Forget about the scriptures for a while ... what's real?
Feelings...happy, sad, angry, bored, tired. What feels feelings...the body usually has some reaction to mental events. For example anxiety sometimes felt in gut. There is a mental mood to feelings, that feelings just seem to effect sense of being, outlook.

Don't seem too good at pinpointing this stuff. Reminded of passage that talks about this feeling "I AM" as "smell of flower:it is neither the smell of the petals , nor the colour, nor the pollen, but the smell of the flower." This I AM or sense of self is just a vague general feeling I guess.

User avatar
No_One
Posts: 113
Joined: Thu Sep 22, 2011 8:42 am
Location: Romania
Contact:

Re: Anatta

Postby No_One » Tue Sep 27, 2011 5:45 am

Cool Knick, just leave the scriptures aside for a moment and look at what's real. Yeah ... writing and message are real. And there's an assumption that 'I did that' but when we look for it we can't find it. No I can be found in that action

Same about thoughts, we see they come out of nowhere and go nowhere and we assume we think them. But when looking for an I there is none that can be found. Sure ... there is the feeling we can control thoughts, but can we. Just try to stop thinking for 2 minutes ... can you do it?

The example about feeling anxiety is really good there. There seems to be something really strong there but when we look at what's going on it's just a sensation in the gut. Can you find an I in that?

Can you find an I anywhere? What if you don't exist? How would that feel? Come on Knick ... it's really simple
The truth is in here not out there

User avatar
Damon Kamda
Site Admin
Posts: 1291
Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2011 10:09 pm
Location: Amsterdam

Re: Anatta

Postby Damon Kamda » Tue Sep 27, 2011 9:48 am

1. It seems the goal here is to basically realize/say there is no self, there is no you, never was.
2. But I will quote, "Views that there is no self are ranked with views that there is a self as a "fetter of views" which a person aiming at release from suffering would do well to avoid." At liberation "Views of true, false, self, no self, etc., thus lose all their holding power, and the mind is left free to its Suchness: untouched, uninfluenced by anything of any sort."
3. So, these 2 views seem contradictory. But perhaps they are not, perhaps translation or meaning of word issues, perhaps using different words to mean same thing, perhaps 2kinds of liberation, who knows.
This isn't about adopting "the view that there is no self" as a doctrinal statement or a theoretical standpoint. There may very well be some truth in what you're asserting and where I'm coming from there is no contradiction between these two views at all, but thats already getting too much into theoretical discussions, which is NOT THE POINT of this forum AT ALL!

The words: "There is no self" are used to point to an observable fact about experience- and this can be SEEN right now, by anyone.

As long as you keep on using textbooks as the ultimate touchstone for asserting truth, you'll never get anywhere. So drop it and actually LOOK at what's experienced.
Don't seem too good at pinpointing this stuff. Reminded of passage that talks about this feeling "I AM" as "smell of flower:it is neither the smell of the petals , nor the colour, nor the pollen, but the smell of the flower." This I AM or sense of self is just a vague general feeling I guess.
Now, can you describe how it is experienced in stead of quoting someone else. Do you exist? What do you know is true without resorting to books and theory? In the immediacy of this moment- what is known for sure?

User avatar
Ross K.
Posts: 16
Joined: Tue Sep 20, 2011 12:45 am

Re: Anatta

Postby Ross K. » Wed Sep 28, 2011 3:15 am

Hey Knick,
See if you can locate a control center, a physical feeling tone say in the head. this is where knowing manifests from, or so it seems.
1.is there anything stable there?
2.are you "in control" of the knowing?
and, please in your own words, no commentary, be genuine, drop all prior knowledge and let wisdom penetrate NOW! just simple question, look, and give an answer.

User avatar
Knick
Posts: 10
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 11:32 pm
Location: East Coast, USA

Re: Anatta

Postby Knick » Thu Sep 29, 2011 5:08 am

I see the term look and see around a lot. Look at no self, look at whats real. Looking and seeing is what the eyes do. It would not make sense to use the eyes to see an abstraction. Look and see that there is no pink elephant, pretty damn simple. Try not to think of concept pink elephant as you read those words and soon after...that's hard right. Try not to have vague feeling I AM...that's hard right. I take it you guys mean look in general sense like observe, find. Or is it about looking with eyes? Any steps or process to follow. Any exercises, or practices? Like how about the Steven Norquist reminder? Or is it mainly pointing, suggesting to observe, and bam, maybe you get it?

IT is raining. what is raining? the rain in raining. IT just points to the fact of rain happening here, now, this location.
I am seeing. What is seeing, seeing is seeing. I just points to the fact of seeing happening here, now, this location.
Right?
Seeing it raining is just a matter of looking and seeing.
But seeing the senses and their objects empty of self seems a bit different. or what?
Sure in just the seeing vision aspect there is no I, like I said above, it would make no sense.

Sure, in this moment there is experience, things happening, that is all.
But this construction of sense of being/self/I is one of those things happening eh?
Or rather not happening, but deluded to thinking it is or some shit.


Return to “THE GATE”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 23 guests