Hi Floris,
Here goes the answer to the questions; sorry for the delay.
1
) Is there a separate entity 'self', 'me' 'I', at all, anywhere, in any way, shape or form? Was there ever?
There is an idea carrying the label of ‘I’, just an idea; it doesn’t have a shape or form and it doesn’t exist as an entity; it is rather believed to exist which is the illusionary thinking.
2) Explain in detail what the illusion of separate self is, when it starts and how it works from your own experience. Describe it fully as you see it now.
The illusion could start from childhood when the mind develops and gathers information and identities from parents, environment, school, and friends. When identification with thinking and thoughts happens, the illusion of separate self is believed to exist while there is only thoughts, impressions, memories, emotions, and their interactions. Then, other stories such as ‘me’, ‘mine’, ‘doer’, ‘decider’, and ‘thinker’ are triggered. When trying to locate or find ‘I’, there is void, nothing, silence: the illusionary ‘I’ doesn’t exist. ‘I’ is sponsored by believing thoughts and identifying with them. When thoughts are not believed (not identified with), upon looking, the illusion disappears. Once seeing ‘no-self’ happens, it seems to consume gradually all aspects of this individual being including thoughts, emotions, and impressions gathered along.
3) How does it feel to see this? What is the difference from before you started this dialogue? Please report from the past few days.
Peace and silence are experienced constantly. There is lightness, softness. In the silent space, thoughts come and go. Some thoughts strongly suggest ‘I’ need this, ‘I’ should do this, but by just looking, there is no ‘I’, no doer, no needer; no person; just thoughts running in the silence. Sometimes, the body is noticed, it is seen as it is performing actions by itself amazingly. Feelings and emotions appear; they are observed too. Sometimes, they linger longer and they are watched and seen; they are allowed to be, then they open up and dissolve as energy or void. The meaning and significance that individuals and things around were carrying are fading as if there is a gap between perceiving them and the meaning they held in the past. Silence is growing pervasive gradually; that is also seen. It feels like watching a movie; just watching not getting involved.
4) What was the last bit that pushed you over, made you look?
Initially, there was strong resistance against ‘No-I’ was expressing itself as various justifications and reasoning, doubts, and questions that defended the existence of ‘I’. Your questions were acting like a sword tearing apart all beliefs and ideas wrapped around the resistance. The questions led the ‘me’ to a corner where there was looking without thinking. Then, seeing happened. And ‘Far’ as a person seemed ethereal, dream-like; the same with ‘mind’, ‘my’, ‘mine’ or ‘my mind’.
5) Describe decision, intention, free will, choice, and control. What makes things happen? How does it work? What are you responsible for? Give examples from experience.
Decisions, intention, free will, choice, control, and reaction all seem the interplay of thoughts and impressions. At the same time, there is no doer making decisions, choices, control, and having free will. They just happen. No responsibility; no person to be responsible; maybe at this stage just looking if identification happens. This morning a strong feeling (an emotional attachment from the past) raised and there was a thought associated with it insisting on taking a certain action. There was a kind of knowingness too, remembering your pointers on the releasing process of feelings and thoughts. So, I allowed the feeling to be released and just looked at it. The feeling is not felt like a pull or impulsive; it is there, it is felt, but it doesn’t hold the compelling position as in the past. The same goes for the thought; it just plays around. Perhaps, currently, the only responsibility (if it could be named as responsibility) is observing and looking.
6) Anything to add?
I am so grateful to you and do appreciate your guidance, help, the love, and persistence you expressed in this process; I am also grateful to the Gate for making this possible. Thanks, Floris.
In Love & Gratitude
Fariba