Good morning,
I am moving this week.
I have been very busy.
I will finish the post later today.
With appreciation,
Lee
Direction, please.
Re: Direction, please.
Good evening,
I should have let you know what a challenging week
I am having. I just sold my house and bought another.
I have been packing and moving for two weeks.
I will finish moving this weekend, and
Hopefully things will settle down.
I haven't been sleeping well. I sleep a few hours, and wake.
I get up and pack for a couple of hours, and
Then I am usually able to get more sleep.
I have been exhausted.
I just wanted to let you know why I haven't been as
Disciplined.
As to the first question, thats the point of these exercises. Can you find what is witnessing? This is my question to you. I have my own answer, of course. My hope is, that in looking, you find your own answer and tell me.
"I haven't been able."
To further point as to what is witnessing - maybe start with deconstruction. Are the eyes seeing?
"No".
If your eyes were removed would they see anything? No. So is it the brain? How does the brain see anything? When you look at a car? how does the brain 'see' the car? Can you point to this neuron or that neuron? or some collection of things at once? It goes on and on like this. As far as can be seen in your AE, what is seeing? If noting can be found to be seeing, is a 'self' seeing like you thought it was? if not, then thats the first way you can get a sense of non self.
"I have never found a 'self' after much searching."
1) With eyes open, can you confirm that what is experienced is 'what can be seen' as I mentioned?
"Yes."
This is not so esoteric. Its simply, "when you open your eyes, what happens?" The normal answer tends to be "objects are seen." theses objects are going to change for every one and even for you over the course of the day. But objects are seen. Thats it.
3) Can what is witnessing 'what can be seen' be found?
"No."
4) Can a pair of eyes, an 'I' / 'me', a Lee be found that is witnessing 'what can be seen'? Or is there just simply 'what can be seen' to be found?
"Simply what can be seen."
This is the feeling of non self. Just to be clear. Its seeing that there is nothing that can be found to be doing the action - in this case seeing.
I was just commenting on the way most people
go thru life. It seems most totally accept their persona
as who they "really " are.
I get that. My way of pointing is simply to redirect any response back to the main objective so we don't get too distracted.
so when you say 'many people feel there is a self' that is an appeal to authority of consensus opinion. It will not help you to see what is being pointed to. this may seem like an antagonist approach, but its not intended to be. After all, we are not debating or arguing here. The nature of this dialogue can bee seen to be different in quality, i hope.
"I don't see it as antagonistic."
If you can use the quote function as I have it helps a bit to make your post easier to read. It would be much appreciated.
"Certainly."
Go through your five sense with this same exercise. What is having the feeling? What is tasting the food? What is hearing the sound? What is seeing? What is smelling?
See if you can find what it is that is having that experience? if you can't find it, thats ok. it may not be able to be found - I'm still looking myself -without much success.
"The feeling is just happening. The food is just tasted.
Hearing is happening. Seeing is happening.
Smelling happens."
Another way to look at this would be in an imaginary way. if you answer the above questions to pointing to your head - behind your eyes, i would ask 'where is that?" Is it like a little man who is at the helm of a ship? And who is at the helm of his ship? And the one his head (and on and on like russian dolls)? (but in this example the little men are neurons or cells) Keep drilling down.....is it in the electrical current in the neuron? how about the electron itself? is that where 'awareness' is? how could that be?
"You refer to 'brain' functions, and the mind will always come up with an answer. If there is 'awareness', it is not there.
It is not physical."
Does this make sense? Can you see this thought each exercise in the senses?
"Yes"
What questions do you have so far?
I will answer this later.
With appreciation,
I should have let you know what a challenging week
I am having. I just sold my house and bought another.
I have been packing and moving for two weeks.
I will finish moving this weekend, and
Hopefully things will settle down.
I haven't been sleeping well. I sleep a few hours, and wake.
I get up and pack for a couple of hours, and
Then I am usually able to get more sleep.
I have been exhausted.
I just wanted to let you know why I haven't been as
Disciplined.
As to the first question, thats the point of these exercises. Can you find what is witnessing? This is my question to you. I have my own answer, of course. My hope is, that in looking, you find your own answer and tell me.
"I haven't been able."
To further point as to what is witnessing - maybe start with deconstruction. Are the eyes seeing?
"No".
If your eyes were removed would they see anything? No. So is it the brain? How does the brain see anything? When you look at a car? how does the brain 'see' the car? Can you point to this neuron or that neuron? or some collection of things at once? It goes on and on like this. As far as can be seen in your AE, what is seeing? If noting can be found to be seeing, is a 'self' seeing like you thought it was? if not, then thats the first way you can get a sense of non self.
"I have never found a 'self' after much searching."
1) With eyes open, can you confirm that what is experienced is 'what can be seen' as I mentioned?
"Yes."
This is not so esoteric. Its simply, "when you open your eyes, what happens?" The normal answer tends to be "objects are seen." theses objects are going to change for every one and even for you over the course of the day. But objects are seen. Thats it.
3) Can what is witnessing 'what can be seen' be found?
"No."
4) Can a pair of eyes, an 'I' / 'me', a Lee be found that is witnessing 'what can be seen'? Or is there just simply 'what can be seen' to be found?
"Simply what can be seen."
This is the feeling of non self. Just to be clear. Its seeing that there is nothing that can be found to be doing the action - in this case seeing.
I was just commenting on the way most people
go thru life. It seems most totally accept their persona
as who they "really " are.
I get that. My way of pointing is simply to redirect any response back to the main objective so we don't get too distracted.
so when you say 'many people feel there is a self' that is an appeal to authority of consensus opinion. It will not help you to see what is being pointed to. this may seem like an antagonist approach, but its not intended to be. After all, we are not debating or arguing here. The nature of this dialogue can bee seen to be different in quality, i hope.
"I don't see it as antagonistic."
If you can use the quote function as I have it helps a bit to make your post easier to read. It would be much appreciated.
"Certainly."
Go through your five sense with this same exercise. What is having the feeling? What is tasting the food? What is hearing the sound? What is seeing? What is smelling?
See if you can find what it is that is having that experience? if you can't find it, thats ok. it may not be able to be found - I'm still looking myself -without much success.
"The feeling is just happening. The food is just tasted.
Hearing is happening. Seeing is happening.
Smelling happens."
Another way to look at this would be in an imaginary way. if you answer the above questions to pointing to your head - behind your eyes, i would ask 'where is that?" Is it like a little man who is at the helm of a ship? And who is at the helm of his ship? And the one his head (and on and on like russian dolls)? (but in this example the little men are neurons or cells) Keep drilling down.....is it in the electrical current in the neuron? how about the electron itself? is that where 'awareness' is? how could that be?
"You refer to 'brain' functions, and the mind will always come up with an answer. If there is 'awareness', it is not there.
It is not physical."
Does this make sense? Can you see this thought each exercise in the senses?
"Yes"
What questions do you have so far?
I will answer this later.
With appreciation,
Re: Direction, please.
First thing
on using the quote function
when you want to respond to a specific part of text I wrote use the quote function at the top of the box
when you press it two boxes with the word 'quote' come up - put the text you wish to respond to in between and it will look like this....
As the the above quote, lets keep looking at this.
Were you planning on asking more questions? or should we move on?
Where are you with self?
on using the quote function
when you want to respond to a specific part of text I wrote use the quote function at the top of the box
when you press it two boxes with the word 'quote' come up - put the text you wish to respond to in between and it will look like this....
And now I can respond to it and it will look like a conversation - its not the grand unifying theory of all things, but it helps me read your responses."The feeling is just happening. The food is just tasted.
Hearing is happening. Seeing is happening.
Smelling happens."
As the the above quote, lets keep looking at this.
Are you seeing this or are you asking about it?ou refer to 'brain' functions, and the mind will always come up with an answer. If there is 'awareness', it is not there.
It is not physical.
Were you planning on asking more questions? or should we move on?
Where are you with self?
Re: Direction, please.
I attempted to use the ". I am not sure how effective I was.First thing
on using the quote function
when you want to respond to a specific part of text I wrote use the quote function at the top of the box
when you press it two boxes with the word 'quote' come up - put the text you wish to respond to in between and it will look like this....
And now I can respond to it and it will look like a conversation - its not the grand unifying theory of all things, but it helps me read your responses."The feeling is just happening. The food is just tasted.
Hearing is happening. Seeing is happening.
Smelling happens."
As the the above quote, lets keep looking at this.Are you seeing this or are you asking about it?ou refer to 'brain' functions, and the mind will always come up with an answer. If there is 'awareness', it is not there.
It is not physical.
"I was saying that the mind is always ready to answer in any situation."
Were you planning on asking more questions? or should we move on?
"As I mentioned, I have been very overwhelmed by the recent move.
I have slept very poorly for over two weeks. It has gotten better the last couple of days.
If you could give some direction, I would appreciate it."
Where are you with self?
"I continue to become absorbed by 'self'. I get lost lost in the story, and then I realize it.
It is still there."
Things are returning to normal since the move. I will be able to focus now.
With appreciation,
Lee
Re: Direction, please.
You quoted the whole text - thats less helpful than quoting the text you are responding only, like I just did. Now you can tell what it is that I am responding toI attempted to use the ". I am not sure how effective I was.
Great to hear this. Do you see how you can tell how that sentence responds to the above quote?Things are returning to normal since the move. I will be able to focus now.
Ok. Lets keep going. Do you feel that the self resides in the body after the exercises? Are you still feeling like the self is a place behind your eyes?
Where are you feeling the self? how are you defining it at this time?
Re: Direction, please.
You quoted the whole text - thats less helpful than quoting the text you are responding only, like I just did. Now you can tell what it is that I am responding toI attempted to use the ". I am not sure how effective I was.
Things are returning to normal since the move. I will be able to focus now. [/]quote
Great to hear this. Do you see how you can tell how that sentence responds to the above quote?
Ok. Lets keep going. Do you feel that the self resides in the body after the exercises? Are you still feeling like the self is a place behind your eyes?
i still feel the self resides in the body.Where are you feeling the self? how are you defining it at this time?yes, behind the eyes.
i feel it mainly in the abdomen.When I wake early, most mornings, the voice will run incessantly. It runs through everything I have been dealing with.
It will bring up every issue I am dealing with. It will be concerned, give advice, etc.
After about an hour, it slowly returns to a calm normalcy.
I usually just lie there and let it run its course.With appreciation,I usually recognize the self when it interferes. It will take one side of a situation, and then later take the other side.
It is never happy or satisfied.
Lee
Re: Direction, please.
Hi,
Sorry about the quotes. I'll keep trying.
Sorry about the quotes. I'll keep trying.
Re: Direction, please.
We can keep working on the quotes. Sorry for the late reply.
So lets keep at it with the looking
Bonus question: Who is controlling those voices in your head? Who controls the self?
So lets keep at it with the looking
Is this what you are calling 'the self' that lives behind your eyes? Is this what the self 'does'? what else does it do.When I wake early, most mornings, the voice will run incessantly. It runs through everything I have been dealing with.
It will bring up every issue I am dealing with. It will be concerned, give advice, etc.
After about an hour, it slowly returns to a calm normalcy.
I usually just lie there and let it run its course
Bonus question: Who is controlling those voices in your head? Who controls the self?
Re: Direction, please.
The voices are on "auto-pilot". They are definitely not consciously controlled.We can keep working on the quotes. Sorry for the late reply.
So lets keep at it with the looking
Is this what you are calling 'the self' that lives behind your eyes?When I wake early, most mornings, the voice will run incessantly. It runs through everything I have been dealing with.
It will bring up every issue I am dealing with. It will be concerned, give advice, etc.
After about an hour, it slowly returns to a calm normalcy.
I usually just lie there and let it run its course
Yes
Is this what the self 'does'?
Yes
what else does it do.
It's like that part "hijacks" the moment. It takes the mind off on a tangent,
jumping from topic to topic. When this is noticed, the present moment can be reconnected.
Bonus question: Who is controlling those voices in your head? Who controls the self?
I think that the running dialogue I discussed is generally beneficial.
But it is sometimes so chaotic, overwhelming, and forceful
that it is unsettling.
I look forward to continuing our discussions.
I have still been very focused on renovating the new home,
but these communications are very important.
Thank you,
Lee
Re: Direction, please.
That doesn’t answer the question
What makes the voices happen?
What are the implications of calling it these self if you don’t control it?
What makes the voices happen?
What are the implications of calling it these self if you don’t control it?
Re: Direction, please.
Put another way, How can he be something that you cannot control? Who’s controlling?
Re: Direction, please.
sorry, last message was truncated. Meant to say
How can he be something that you cannot control be 'the self?' How can a self both control what you do and you are unable to control it?
Longer more thought out answers will help me guide you better - if you need to focus on the house - do so - come back when you're ready. there is no rush - you not self will still not be there when you get back
How can he be something that you cannot control be 'the self?' How can a self both control what you do and you are unable to control it?
Longer more thought out answers will help me guide you better - if you need to focus on the house - do so - come back when you're ready. there is no rush - you not self will still not be there when you get back
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Elad, Semrush [Bot] and 17 guests

